Daune Vermeulen should be everyone's top 10 favorites.

1-read 2-vermeulen 3-lobbe 4-o´brien 5-parisse 6-chaval 7-leguizamon 8-headslip 9-faletau 10-vunipola

@BgAltair

8 жыл бұрын

+Joaquin Sabater Can't believe you just said faletau and vunipola without even mentioning Gorgodza.. Other than that the list is pretty good

@prac2

8 жыл бұрын

+Joaquin Sabater pocock, zinzan brooke, chaval was a monster

1: Read 2: Picamoles 3: Vermelen 4: Parisse 5: Foletao 6: Masoe 7: Harinordoquy 8: ME OF COURSE (I'm french!)

i love the fact you said your favourite. most people say top 10 as if thats everyones top 10 but its always what THEY think everyone else would choose which is still influenced by their own opinion as well as others

1- Read 2- Heaslip 3- Armitage 4- Vermeulen 5- Faletau 6- Picamoles 7- Vunipola

@windgatpompies3837

10 жыл бұрын

you dont know what your talking about

@rastabonsai87

9 жыл бұрын

Yea this is a better list

@pablolopez8118

9 жыл бұрын

se parece mas a los que yo elegiría, pero Vermeulen segundo

@ginge2991

7 жыл бұрын

F-X J Nick Easter?

@tollyt7465

5 жыл бұрын

No parisse? He would be just behind Read as the best ever.. And Armitage is predominantly a 7 not an 8.. Do you watch rugby at all? I'm English and love Billy V, but he needs to really prove himself over a longer period..

Personally read is the best, he's the most consistent player out of all of them. Great vid though

good list.. but I kept on watching because I was hoping to se Duane Vermeulen.. :(

@skyelark155

4 жыл бұрын

What a crap list without Duane in

My top ten number 8 list 10.Jamie Heaslip(Ire) 9.Piere Spies(RSA) 8.Jerry Collins(Nz) 7.Cj Stander(Ire) 6.Schalk Burger(RSA) 5.David Pocock(Aus) 4.Mamuka Gorgodze (Geo) 3.Kieren Read(Nz) 2.Sergio Parisse(Ita) 1.Sebastien Chabal(Fra) I'm 16 ,i grew up watching them n these guys defined what a number eight is for me, Especially the Top 5 on my list :)

For me it's a toss-up between Kieran Read and Duane Vermeulen for the number 1 spot. Based on 2014 performances. Wow Pierre Spies had some pace back when he was at his best!!

As a South African I am SHOCKED to see Kieran Read not top that list... That guy is in a class of his own. Putting Pierre Spies ahead of Kieran Read is a sin, Having Spies on this list even is dubious...

Sergio Parisse is the GOAT 8 🐐 🇮🇹!

How can Sergio parisse not be on this list

Sergio Parisse n.1 and Duane Vermeulen n.2

very nice selection of course some are missing (Sergio Parisse), but very nice anyway

Great list mate

Outstanding video. I don't agree with all of your choices and the order, but they are all top top players.

My favourite is definitely Parisse, would walk onto any team in my opinion

@johnritchie4801

6 жыл бұрын

Seriously irritating music ruined the video Not everyone shares your taste in music Did not bother to watch the whole video because of the music

enjoyed this - cheers! happen to think faletau is right up there also..

Running through Sean O'Brien at 6:51 was quite impressive!

Alex Tulou may traditionally be from American Samoa but he was born and rugby bred in Wellington NZ, gotta make that clear..

@sabathekilla

10 жыл бұрын

thanks for clearing that up man, i just couldn't find where he was actually from.

good list!!

you have to add Facundo Isa, it is the number 8 of Jaguares and Pumas, he is awsome!!

Zinzan Brooke? Best of ever! Morné du Plessis? Lawrence Dallaglio? Wayne "Buck" Shelford? Mervyn Davies? Ben Clarke? Hennie Muller? Derek Quinnell? Abdelatif Benazzi? Danie Rossouw? Sergio Parisse? Kieran Read? David Pocock? Duane Vermeulen? Billy Vunipola?

I totally agree that Duane should be there and prob one or 2 others but seriously can't argue with your number 1 choice man if he played for a team like New Zealand, South Africa or Australia he would probably be better than my choice of best #8 ever Gary Tiechmen

no Duane Vermeulen?

@jingleballix

9 жыл бұрын

Sergio Parisse is pretty good too…….and Ben Morgan, and Toby Faletau……...

@npnpnp477

9 жыл бұрын

Who?

@Theunislb

7 жыл бұрын

like ... yeah ... but this his list hahaha. and pocock is a better flanker in my opinion great player born in africa

it would be pretty interesting to see these people playing with NFL players much respect to both rugby and football players

@R4eWclan

7 жыл бұрын

Enzo Caballero there is only 12 mins of American football playtime. However, there is 80 minuets of rugby play time. personally, I think that American football players wouldn't be able to play rugby because they arnt fit enough.

I agree Gorgodze first ! The best

Hard to do a top 10 number 8 here.. i can say that Parise, Dallaglio and Henrry Tuilagi should be there also 💪💪💪

Dimitri Basilaia and mamuka gorgodze is strong georgia.🔥⚡💥❤💪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪

wow Saba....great

No… 1.Duane Vermeulen, he once played a game with cracked ribs, got man of the match and helped the Boks beat NZ 27-25... that's all you need to know.

Since professional era for me: Zinzan undoubtedly the best. Nothing to separate Vermeulen and Reid at No.2 . (Reid may be the all round more skillful player and Duane definitely the more intimidating physical specimen.) Harinordoquy at 4 and Rocky Elsom at 5, Parisse at 6 and Heaslip at 7. I would maybe put Dallaglio in there at 8, purely because he was such a hard man, but none of the others are close, certainly not Chabal and Spies.

I would have had Billy Vunipola and Parisse but apart from that I love the list

I’m surprise to see Richie is not on the list

Forget about Duane. I think Spies was a much better no 8. But no Bobby Skinstad. The list is more robust type of players. Bobby was a class act. In the apartheid era non racial rugby had a few great no 8s like Yaghya Sakier. Grantham Jansen. Clive Thomas. Saait Magiet. It's a pity the world didn't see them

👏👏👏👏good good goo

i know the title said favourite and thats clearly your opinion but how could you leave out parisse

@sabathekilla

10 жыл бұрын

I am sorry for that, but I guess he is not really one of my favorites, but he is a great player there's no doubt about it.

@NT-fb6ow

10 жыл бұрын

still a great list of the best players in the best position on the pitch

@sabathekilla

10 жыл бұрын

thanks a lot!!!!

@gillies7775

8 жыл бұрын

and Dwayne Vermeulen?

u should also look at it from the quality of the opposition! Spies for example only excelled in super rugby and against lesser oposition. looks good on a highlight reel but doesnt reflect the players conistency. Vermeulen on the other hand had a man of the match performance against the All blacks with rib cartilage damage! i appreciate this is your opinion but that cant be ignored IRB player of the year nominee 2014 booya!

@davidayre8996

9 жыл бұрын

This video was made Jan 2014 before Vermeulen's form this season

Henry Tuilagi didn’t even make the list? Ask James Haskell. He’ll tell you!

Anyone who doesn't have Sergio Parisse on a list of the best 8s is either narrow minded, or doesn't understand rugby.. The guy has been unbelievable for years in an at best average Italian team.. He would be 1st choice 8 in any international side apart from the ABs because of Read.. I'm English and we have Billy Vunipola, who I love, but I'd select Parisse over Billy in a heartbeat..

I agree.

The thing is all these people in the comments are like where’s this player but it clearly says my top 10 favourite 8s in the title

no david pocock in the list?

keeren read is yster

This season is so sad for Biarritz =((

@sabathekilla

10 жыл бұрын

same for Montpellier

Vunipola and parisse should of been on here

But are you serious? Momuka gorgoze as the best number 8

How you forget Duane Vermeulen

billy vunipola?

Your fav is a great player. However, there's a big difference between your favourite, and who is actually the best. What you have to ask yourself is this: would he be picked ahead of Reid for the all blacks? Of course not. Would he be picked ahead of vermuelen or spies for the springboks? Of course not. They are better than him.

@kamakazilee6066

6 жыл бұрын

Dafydd Lloyd Nah sorry he would get picked over Reid. I would move Reid to flanker if necessary. Parissé is the best 8

chabali boloze gadaobb :D

Music used in tis vid?

@sabathekilla

10 жыл бұрын

1st song is 300 violin orchestra by Jorge Quintero, 2nd song- Omen by Mt Eden (Prodigy remix) and the third one is Love And Loss by Two Steps From Hell.

Sergio Parisse?!

@rscoops3986

5 жыл бұрын

'MY/ being the operative word. Wouldn't life be boring if everyone had the same opinion. You absolute shite for brains

@achimaster5498

4 жыл бұрын

Sergio parise is gay.

1. Facundo Isa.

billy vunapola

im only here to see who was number 8 at number 8.

I wish pierre spies gets better again

No Toby???

kieran Reid is number 1 in my opinion

+saba manjgaladze - as soon as I saw the username I thought he's going to have Gorgodze at #1. Don't disagree, the guy is amazing, but surely he plays openside flanker in >90% of his games? An awesome 7 who can also play 8. On that basis you could have Richie McCaw in here too.

@icedbunn89

9 жыл бұрын

vonteflon He wears 7, but 7 in france is blindside like in South Africa. Dusautoir is an openside, but wears 6

@vonteflon

9 жыл бұрын

icedbunn89 That's not my point. It's about flankers in a "Number 8s" list. No big deal anyway, just thought it was an overly patriotic way of shoe-horning his Georgian hero in!

How could you possibly leave out Duane Vermeulen ???? With all due respect>

the song Please

Buck Shelford?...Zinzan Brooke?...Mario Carreras, Pablo Camerlinckx?

@DionFerreira

9 жыл бұрын

I think this top 10 was chosen from guys still playing the game, but I know for sure that Zinzan was one of the best..if not the best. Can remember him from watching rugby as a youngster. My dad was/is a big Buck Shelford fan as well!

How is Sebastian Chabal #10??

Lawrence dallaglio??

Not sure if u renember but theirs some one called keiren reed who should me in number 1

@joshmultiboss

9 жыл бұрын

well this vid was uploaded when read was not at his peak performance. He was still good but not as good as he is now

@Fredacinii

9 жыл бұрын

Josh dingley Well this vid was made Jan last year. Kieran Read was IRB player of the year 2013. I'm pretty sure he was at his peak when this vid was made lol

and dwayne vermeulen is also yster go south africa!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

No Sergio Parisse, no Billy Vunipola, No Ben Morgan and no Duane Vermeulen? Okay...

@freddiei123

8 жыл бұрын

+Joshua M Yeh but this guy is obviously bias, he's Georgian haha

@Theunislb

8 жыл бұрын

+Joshua M morgan parisse and vermeulen not a fan of vunipola he is to inconsistent these days morgan over him any day

@mrmoley64

8 жыл бұрын

+Theunis Louis Botha yeah I agree about his inconsistent performances but they've both come back from injuries

@ginge2991

7 жыл бұрын

Joshua M add Nick Easter to this list

Steffon Armitage ?

Fernandez lobbe is better as flanker

Louis Picamoles?

Totai Kefu was the best 8 ever

What about falataw

Morgan

Laurent Rodriguez?

Zinzan brooke the best

Reid picamoles heaslip vunipola armatige

No sergio parisse?

Reid is number 1 by a mile

no English, Welsh or Scottish 8's??? And no Antony Foley !(Axel)!!!!

@skyelark155

4 жыл бұрын

Scottish 😂😂😂 No Duane Vermeulen thr best is a joke ... Scotland are shit

david pocok, read and chaval

Billy nianopola?????

batman freak

Il migliore è Sergio Parisse

Parisse ?

What about Alesana Tuilagi??...oh wait...

@daviddbell1987

5 жыл бұрын

He was a winger. It's his brother Henry tuilagi

@skiavo94

5 жыл бұрын

@@daviddbell1987 Of course, I was joking

vermeulen by a mile no1

Dwayne Vermeulen?

No Parisie ????????????????

No Sergio Parisea ( or however u spell it, no Jerry Collins...

Upro koreqtuli iqneboda rugby forwards ro dagecera

@sabathekilla

10 жыл бұрын

martalia magram am videoshi marto 8 nomrebi arian

dimas sawinaaRmdego araferi maqvs mSvenieri forwardia magram mgoni cota ukanimsaxurebs :)

@sabathekilla

10 жыл бұрын

Sheidzleba, magram martali rom gitkhrat mirchevnia bevrs romlebits mis ukan arian.

@doncrawford7173

7 жыл бұрын

K

#1 Sergio

@achimaster5498

4 жыл бұрын

You is stupid. You son of bitch italy.

et Vermeulen ??

TAULUPE FALATAU better than the rest

parisse?????

Alex tulou no no no

Theres no Danny Barrett. And I believe Sebastian is better than your first.

@owyn4799

8 жыл бұрын

+PsyQo Fortune Chabal was often in Harinordoquy's (think it's spelt right) shadow when he was playing for France though.

@diogeneslantern18

7 жыл бұрын

The Caveman had an awesone presence - no doubt because of his looks. Technically he could never be the complete 8th man. That title in my humble opinion goes to Kieran Read. (And in saying this I adore Marmuke). Read is simply the complete player (and as a Saffa I am somewhat loathe to say it)

@owyn4799

7 жыл бұрын

PartiZAn18 I dunno, I like Read but with a squad and culture like the All Blacks anyone can shine. I love Picamoles tbh, he's a tank and has been tearing it up for Northampton (From an Irishman).

I am disgusted to see that Sergio hasn't made the list... Has played in every 6 nations match since Italy joined the 6 nations...

Gorgodze is a great flanker not a great number 8... Billy Vunipola ?? Duane Vermeulen ?? My favorite #8 is kieran read