I also noticed he went a bit fast, but that is mostly due to nerves I think. I mean, he was living his literal childhood dream, playing with a world class orchestra on a violin worth more than most people will earn in two lifetimes. But as he got more comfortable and gained confidence on stage, i could really feel his emotions and expressions coming through, and it was beautiful.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

It was indeed beautiful ❤️

@Timeisirrelevant

Жыл бұрын

You can tell both he and Eddy got over their nerves as they kept playing.

@Casutama

Жыл бұрын

Brett ALWAYS starts rushing at some point when he's nervous, that's his thing. But he was breathtaking on that stage, the playing was gorgeous.

@Alceste_

Жыл бұрын

Due to the incredible inflation rate "What someone will earn in two lifetime" is actually practically the same as what they'll earn in their second lifetime.

@TimFSpears

Жыл бұрын

I’d love to see him have the opportunity to do the same performance several times so he can flush out the nervousness that makes him rush a bit.

I'd like to say thx to Twoset for their work as an ambassador for classical music. The community is NOT thanking them enough for the excellent PR they do for the world of classics. 4 mil subs, mostly young people. Thank you TWOSET, thank you

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

You're absolutely right, they should be thanked more!!! Thank you, twoset 🎻❤️🎻

@kvallo2

Жыл бұрын

100%

This kind of nervousness disappears when musicians perform regularly. Brett doesn't perform on a daily not even weekly base, so it's normal not to be completely at ease on stage. All other musicians at that orchestra are seasoned and feeling at home in stage. I think after a month of performing he would be legendary.

@oxoelfoxo

Жыл бұрын

I wish they would perform regularly

@amore3791

Жыл бұрын

Completely agree with you!!!

@HLPiepgrass

Жыл бұрын

But, anxiety can still get the best of seasoned performers. I remember seeing an interview with Adele where she said she can hardly stand doing concerts because of it. I’m a fairly seasoned musician and I get it intermittently. I remember a two set video where Brett and Eddie both talked about it. I think Eddie is awesome irregardless!

@andrewroberts8139

Жыл бұрын

Yes, I get nervous even in orchestral concerts but have played in a couple more than usual in the last couple of months and I notice a definition reduction of nerves

@Yu-Fei-Hung

Жыл бұрын

I get nervous just by thinking I haven’t touched my violin in years 🤦🏽‍♂️

Brett has such a mastery over emotion, he knows exactly what to emphasis and what not to. I think most of his “mistakes” were due nervousness. If anything I’m surprised at how well he played with such a pressure😂

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Completely agree! Imagine the pressure of 50k live viewers😵‍💫😵

@yeallow910

Жыл бұрын

@@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic +500 people

@nathalietremblay686

Жыл бұрын

@@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic more 100k live viewers since lots of us had watch parties.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

@@nathalietremblay686 True that!!

@pianissimo7121

Жыл бұрын

@@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic does the number actually matter? I feel like how prestigious the event is the worse we feel.

He was absolutely amazing. It is true that he went a bit fast at the beginning but any musician knows that is what we tend to do when we are nervous. Rushing. He played so so well❤️❤️❤️

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

He played amazingly! The nervous rushing only added charm, I think😁

@rolf-reinhardganauge2008

Жыл бұрын

@@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic i think every music piece has a message. He doesn't tell anything with the exeption of perfect tone, perfekt phrase, perfect bow change etc. , but that is not what music is about. I hope you understand, what I am talking about. If not, you are the only person, which can change it. It is worth.

@19divide53

Жыл бұрын

@@rolf-reinhardganauge2008 Well that's quite probably just your personal opinion, but that's ok. I mean, I've never even felt the music played by Vengerov or Rubinstein or Argerich telling anything, if you give me a story with detailed analysis like "oh this thing they did in this phrase represents this character doing this thing" then I might be able to be like "oh, yeah, totally, makes a lot of sense" if I listen closely while reading the analysis, but I can't come up with any sort of story on my own just fromlsivtening to the music, however great the performance is. Everyone is different, and this "telling something" stuff depends as much on the listener as on the performer(s).

@Casutama

Жыл бұрын

@@rolf-reinhardganauge2008 I disagree, but that's probably in the ear of the listener. To me, it wasn't at all a perfect performance, and I think he actually played very emotively, with lots of feeling. Whether or not he was telling a story only he will ever know, but I didn't feel it was any less of a heartfelt performance of this piece than I have ever heard from "The Greats".

I'd say that the years he spent playing in the orchestra as an accompanist,gave him the edge as a soloist.... having notes on what and what not to compensate for as an accompanist... he made him stand out as a soloist... Master Brett Welldone🤯🤯🤯

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Good observation! Completely agree that him being a former professional orchestra musician gives him an edge! 🎻

@MrScrofulous

Жыл бұрын

Actually I'm inclined to think those years have given him a diffidence that makes him less dominant in the solo space, reducing his intensity. I'm pretty sure that Hillary, Ray, Benny or Max never considered any other place in the orchestra except soloist. Every time they play, they attack with a ferocity that Brett does not really display. I do like Brett's style, as it fits his personality, but I think it's one things that would have held him back from a career as a soloist. Luckily we have them here.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

@@MrScrofulous That is true, he may be more rounded!

@violabso

Жыл бұрын

Well said! Brett made life easy for the enthusiastic young conductor. The orchrstra remained professional. I wonder if the high winds'mikes were not placed too close to the players. Just a thought, since if the balance in the hall was not right the conductor would have made them a sign to play quieter. He had good hands.

As a non-musician but avid classical music listener, I absolutely love the nerdiness in this comment section. Thank you all so much! 💕

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Thank you!❤️🎻

Great breakdown. Brett put on a fantastic performance. TwoSet is so funny and humble it is incredibly easy to think they are just novice / mediocre violinists. Yes there were a few moments where you could tell that he isn’t at the same level as they typical virtuosic professional soloists who spend 100% of their time doing this, but HOLY SHIT did he step up and give an incredible performance.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

He did really well, and considering he's not on stage with a professional orchestra every other week, I think he was fantastic!❤️

Brett’s version is lovely. I love this piece a lot and I had searched for and listened to most of the popular versions floating around on KZread. I dare say that Brett’s is more touching than at least 5 other soloists out there. It is crazy. It is obvious that he comes from a point of gratitude and pure love for the piece rather than just for a performance. Like what you said, “there is no bad part”. I was trying to nitpick (I am a fan trying to be objective) but I simply could not find any. He practised!

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

There's always stuff to nitpick, but he's done really well so I don’t see the point!!

@PositivelyNice

Жыл бұрын

@@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic Thanks for the reply.😂 No wonder this is opinion channel.

@jytte47

Жыл бұрын

I agree

Great analysis. They like to downplay their ability but they are seriously talented. Chloe, Hilary and Ray must be insane.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

They are very good! No reason for them to downplay their abilities in my opinion ❤️

@bradleyscarffpiano2921

Жыл бұрын

Hilary, ray and Chloe are literally some of the best violinists alive at the moment, the fact that Brett and Eddy have spent considerable time with them, learning and improving and the fact they pulled this off is fantastic. here's hoping they do more concerts

@ly2867

5 ай бұрын

That's the result of practice! They're definetly role model!

As someone who sits in front of the saluting boy (if you know you know), I am happy to see a person with proper knowledge and vocabularies articulate pretty much the opinions I had after I walked out of the hall (especially the too loud woodwind part haha). I walked in expected the soloist part to be a bit louder in general (based on my past experience with this concerto), but after watching the stream (later on) and this video I can see why it was that way. A bit of digression, but the microphone array set above the stage looks awesome and so non-intrusive to the eyes (both in the hall and on stream). No wonder the sound quality of the stream is that good.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

We was wondering before if the woodwinds were too loud inthe hall as well, so it's interesting to hear that they were!

For me Brett’s interpretation is one of the best I have heard. Whether this is because I feel person pride that he was able to it or because he played really well, idk

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Completely agree, definitely amomg my top 3 too

@dmwalker24

Жыл бұрын

Yeah totally. There's nothing in Brett's performance that hit me the wrong way. Something I can't say about a lot of very accomplished players. Not saying they play it bad. Just that a lot seem to focus less on maintaining nice rhythmic pulse. Personal preference I guess.

@PositivelyNice

Жыл бұрын

@@dmwalker24 many other soloists sound like they have practised the piece to death until there is no genuine emotion; just the practised emotion, though through no fault of theirs since it is their job to ensure perfection. Brett did not have to be perfect as fans would have forgiven him. He was playing for people he “knows” and in that way sounded more sincere.

@biffii5568

Жыл бұрын

definetely plays a big part. I mean if ur Dad, was maxim vengerov, i'd assume u'd be biased towards his interp aswell. PS, not saying we view Brett, as a father figure LOL

@dmwalker24

Жыл бұрын

@@PositivelyNice Yeah, I'm sure a lot of us were happy to look the other way on the odd couple of notes that didn't ring out as clearly as maybe they should have. I know this isn't what you were suggesting, but I have to say I got a laugh from the thought of soloists, so sick of non-stop Mendelssohn, that they're intentionally trying to sabotage it with bizarre, disjointed phrasing.

12:54 _"I'm not sure if it's a fingering issue"_ -- the score says to play that passage on the A string, which requires a jump from first position to fourth, so he may have felt that a harmonic was the easiest way to do a clean jump without an obvious shift, break or intonation problem. Note that he ignores the "A string" direction for the subsequent long B and A (he plays them on the E string), allowing him to play everything between the two harmonics in third position. So I think he generally wanted to minimise technical disruptions here, so that he could focus on bringing out the sweetness of the passage.

@MelodiousThunk

Жыл бұрын

Compare this passage to the opening theme of the second movement, where he plays the same leap from B to A on the A string and the shift is very audible, even though it can be hidden to an extent in the bow change. The leap in the first movement passage is played in a single bow, which makes it even harder to hide.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Thank you for your insight! That would explain the harmonics, for sure! I still thought they stuck out weirdly, though

@dominoplay3712

Жыл бұрын

did Mendelsohn wrote the A string direction?

@MelodiousThunk

Жыл бұрын

@@dominoplay3712 Judging by the autograph manuscript on IMSLP (page 29 of the PDF) he didn't. But Hilary Hahn plays the whole passage on the A string in a KZread video, so it might be a common approach.

@dominoplay3712

Жыл бұрын

@@MelodiousThunk maybe, but not a rule. it largely depends on the instrument and the color of the strings, and it’s a personal decision at the end of the day to do what sounds the best. It’s not so common, I’ve played it both ways and listen other players play it also, both ways.

You can definitely hear that by the 3rd movement he's a lot more comfortable and playful. The first bit of this concerto is so iconic though so that's what most will pick up but still overall it's really a massive job.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

He does relax quite a lot throughout!

@Ashgrom

Жыл бұрын

@@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic btw, very nice analisys. Super with some insight from someone who can't read music at all but the way you describe it I can almost kinda see where he is looking at the sheet.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

@@Ashgrom Thank you, I'm happy it was understandable ❤️

I have always loved Brett’s playing but how good his performance here is really surprised me! It has really great parts and it’s overall very enjoyable to listen to. ☺️

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

100% agree❤️😍

Wow! You put a lot of effort in this "criticism". Thank you for that. I am sure that Brett will be very pleased with it. I was really worried that it was going to be negative, because I too listened to the live performance, and couldn't believe my ears. Having watched 2set now for a few years, I also was unaware of their mastery of the instrument. Having just watched your video, I am now going to listen to it entirely again. I had listened with baited breath in case he goofed up, thankfully I could breathe again at the very end.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

It's always nerve wrecking when you're watching someone you don't know whether will mess up or not, but Brett did great! Absolutely go back and listen to it again with relaxed shoulders😁

@isha9300

Жыл бұрын

We really underestimated their playing. They’ve been playing for a while too.

I loved the performance. Music is an extension of storytelling. When words no longer do, music takes over the heavy lifting. When music no longer does, dancing continues. Brett's dedication to the music was proven by the Ling Ling Hickey he sports on his neck. Amazing performance. -Frank

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

He did amazingly! Definitely some Ling Ling dedication in there❤️

Both Brett and Eddy's performances (and the orchestra) were awesome! ❤❤👍👍 As much as musicians strive to give flawless performances (and that is a good thing), live concerts aren't about absolute technical perfection, they are about the experience as a whole and how enjoyable it is within the context of the situation, and TwoSetViolin putting their unique flavor into this concert made it memorable and wonderful!

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Completely agree❤️❤️❤️

What I noticed watching this video is that he does super well in the slower parts, I feel like he displays the emotions very delicately and softly, but in the faster parts especially in the beginning when he was most nervous, his tempo was a bit off. I listened to a recording of Hilary Hahn for comparison and in general she’s just much sharper, which works well for the fast parts but I definitely prefer Brett’s more emotional interpretation of those slow descends that you pointed out for example. It makes me really want to listen to it, which I don’t really get a lot with classical music.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Completely agree, his slow parts were definitely better than the fast ones! Loved his phrasing on those😍

@Ashgrom

Жыл бұрын

I agree too. It's also a little...ahem...unfair to compare anyone to Hilary when it comes to this concerto. I'm no classical music expert at all but just by layman listening, her recording is really just above everything else I've listened to. She has nuances that other's don't even try and she's playing so fast that you don't realize how fast she is until you listen to someone else.

@chehenry7409

Жыл бұрын

I agree. Looking at his personality, He completely matches those sections as well. He definitely perfects that kind of emotion because that's just him. Calm and sweet

@MicukoFelton

Жыл бұрын

@@Ashgrom It comes down to preference sometimes though, I personally don't like her harshness. Sometimes her playing just feels too sharp.

@BenjaminAnderson21

Жыл бұрын

@@MicukoFelton I don't think the crispness of her playing really sounds harsh in the slightest. She still maintains the sweet classical tone mendelssohn was going for when he wrote the concerto. There's just a bit more energy and character to it than in some other performances.

Agree! A studio recording of this would be awesome! Maybe a surprise for the real 4Mil? 👀 And thanks for the gold star! ⭐😁

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Right??? And you're welcome, here have another: 🌟

You have a wonderful way of interspersing your analysis while showing both the concert and the score-I also loved the comments written on the screen-bravo!!!-I'll be watching more!

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Thank you!! I'm super happy to hear you enjoyed it😊❤️

I loved Brett's playing. It was nice to see two set in a different capacity other than on the show and up playing the orchestra. It's nice to see a break down critique of this because as a novice musician myself it is so helpful!

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

I'm happy you found the video helpful!❤️

Yeah brett usually struggles with tempo 😂 he goes faster than he ought to

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

I can't say I've thought about it before, but now that you mention it I see what you mean! I guess it doesn't help with the nerves either, though😅

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

@@ChiefHerzensCoach Haha it was a mean prank! I think it actually helped him in the first mvt, as the orchestra should've followed him! But for the second movement it could've been sliiiiightly slower in my opinion 😅

Thank you for this detailed review and emphasis on Brett's beautiful phrasing. I'm remembering how nervous he was when he started the 2Mil stream. He's really come into his own and what a joy to hear him in this performance.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

It was wonderful! His phrasing is amazing ❤️

This is exactly the type of channel I was looking for!! 😍 your videos are fantastic! PLEASE keep up the good work 🙏

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Ahh thank you, I will!!❤️

Love your breakdowns, it allows the listener to hear it fresh again

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

I'm happy you enjoy it❤️

Thank you for the analysis. I'm a huge fan of Twoset and I also watch quite a lot of reactions to music... This was such a little treat for having both of my favorite things in one video. :) Have a wonderful week!

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

You have a wonderful week too!❤️

@JustFiddler

Жыл бұрын

😇🎻🌹

I have no musical literacy whatsoever, so I really appreciate your simple explanation for a meathead like me. Very grateful. I’m sure Brett will appreciate your constructive feedback as well.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

I'm super happy it was understandable for non musicians as well❤️

Thank you so much for this review! I think you did a brilliant job in giving a general overview of Brett's concert, breaking down and highligting the passages that were worth commenting on. I really enjoy your format. I didn't know your channel until... now!. I am very happy to have found it and will continue watching your reviews. May Ling Ling be with you!

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

I'm happy you enjoyed the video! May Ling Ling be with you too❤️🎶

I know the Mendelsohn concerto, and this was a brilliant performance, I was enthralling, and it worked.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Completely agree ❤️

Thanks 🙏🏼 I watched the live stream too, and I was honestly moved. Doesn’t happen often nowadays.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

It was beautiful 😍

Thanks for this video! Feel like I learned a lot of details about this concerto from you!! Really appreciate your effort and time!!

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Thank you for watching! I'm happy to hear you learned something from it❤️

8:10 I think this highlights the more intimate characteristics of Brett's playing style. The one thing that really pops at me when I was watching the livestream is his sweet lyrical approach to the piece.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Completely agree! His lyrical style suits it well❤️ Suits it well!

@19divide53

Жыл бұрын

@@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic I feel like his playing might shine even more if he plays with a small scale or chamber orchestra, it would probably bring out the intimacy more.

Beautiful presentation (your's and also Brett's). I'll be your fan. Thanks a lot. I can hear this amazing concerto with new "ears". 😀

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Thank you so much, and welcome❤️

Thank you so much for the amazing video! You give an awesome insight to the performance and since I have lots of music related knowledge yet to collect it makes me understand the whole concerto quite a bit better :) thank you (again)

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

I'm happy you enjoyed the video!! Excited to hear I could be of help❤️

This was really helpful, thank you for taking the time to put the score up with the performance

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

I'm happy to be of help❤️

I really liked this video!❤As a non-musician, it’s so cool to see the detailed analysis of this concerto, based on the scores even! Have to say that the score looks rllly challenging and I sometimes struggle to keep up😅, but knowing where did Brett do well based on a rather professional perspective is actually giving me a lot of new insights, so thank you!

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

It's completely understandable that it's a struggle to keep up with the scores - I struggle sometimes on the fast runs too🥴 My goal is to make it understandable even if you don't read music, so I hope I achieved that❤️

@doradostern4851

Жыл бұрын

@@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic You absolutely did! Thank you

The boy can really play the damn thing. And he's so adorable doing it, too!

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Truth!!

This was his deep dream. He is very serious. Loved this concert.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

So did I🥰

Thank you! You have done a most amazing justice to Music and this concerto as well as Brett.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

I'm happy you liked it! Brett certainly played really well😊🎻

thank you for putting so much effort into this video, I enjoyed it a lot!

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

I'm happy you enjoyed it, thank you for watching ❤️

love your analysis! as i watched the concert live, my friend and I did notice him going faster than expected at the start, and we attributed it to the nerves. normally, high notes tend to sound slightly pitchy when played, but in bretts case it was definitely not so! his attention to detail, even noting during his orchestral days about such pieces, definitely contributed to this spectacular performance ❤

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Lucky you got to see the concert live! Can't wait for the world tour to get to see them ❤️

A fine musician, who is destined to be a history maker.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

100% agree

Wonderful analysis and video. As fans of TwoSet we are very invested in their success, but even I didn’t necessarily expect such a level of excellence! ❤ I was at the rehearsal though and it was clear in that run through that Brett’s preparation was on point. The only question was whether his performance nerves were going to trip him up. They didn’t - no memory slips, just a tiny bit of rushing in the first movement. I would love to see your analysis of the Bach double as well! There is so much going on on there!

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

I'm happy you enjoyed the video! I have a poll up on the community tab on whether to do La Campanella or Bach Double next, so make sure to leave your opinion there❤️

Thank you so much for your review! As a layman of classical music, I was actually looking for someone who knows about classical music to review Brett's playing because I truly enjoyed it but don't know how he fares to people who knows classical music. Really appreciate it

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Thank you for watching, I'm happy you enjoyed it ❤️

This is so neat to be able to see the music as he's playing!

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Always great with the score!

Thank you so much for this!

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

You're very welcome!!❤️

It was an excellent performance, ive watched close on a dozen times n glad its on utube so i can watch more times yet. Good on brett really great

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Agreed, it was awesome!❤️

Thank you! I was hoping someone would do an in depth analysis of Brett's performance and you explained everything so clearly that I could understand. I have some music training, but on the clarinet and my knowledge is quite rusty now! It was great to be able to understand more about Brett's interpretation and performance. Like everyone I could hear he was rushing slightly in the beginning, but soon got that under control, and he didn't compromise his sound or intonation etc. I was blown away by his performance. Like you, I knew he could play to a high standard, but having not performed professionally for many years like that & having more of a background now in comedic playing, I was apprehensive. Obviously I needn't have worried, he smashed it!

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Clarinet gang❤️ His performance was amazing!

@sarasate89

Жыл бұрын

@@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic yay clarinet gang! I've seen you have made a video on Mozart's clarinet concerto, I'll definitely go and watch that one

@susanbryant6516

Жыл бұрын

Hey sarasate, clarinet player- did you feel that the woodwinds came in too loudly at 7.51 like the author of this channel and other commentators have mentioned? I didn’t notice it really, so wondering if you as member of Wood-wind gang thought this too? Or maybe think it should have louder through the whole thing, 😆?

Very nice analysis! You show the full orchestra show and not only "criticize" the solo part (Brett) but also the other part on the score , this is the best analysis ive seen , e v e r

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Ahhh thank you!! Very kind comment❤️ I'm happy you enjoyed it!

All things being equal, the efforts of making classical music popular for all people far outweigh any nits and divots in the performance.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Completely agree! I hope my review most of all showcases the positive things about the performance❤️

not sure if ull see this but i just want to say the 85% speed part was so beautiful, it made that part of the piece sound so much sweeter and "savoury" even with the weirder pitch

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

I see everything ahahah But I'm happy you like it too!❤️

Thank you so much for this review. Was hoping that you'll discuss the cadenza which is my favourite part but i totally agree on Brett's beautiful phrasing althroughout especially that small bit you emphasized at the 3rd movement. For me the subtle diminuendo was chef's kiss! Subscibing! Ps: shared this link in the lingling40hrs subreddit, hope you don't mind :)

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

The candenza was beautiful, I agree!! It was just more of the same, that's why I didn't talk about it! Good phrasing and all ahaha Also, I don’t mind at all! Thank you❤️

Very interesting, enlightening dissection and explanation behind your observations, none of which take anything from this incredibly skilful performance by the awesomely humble and incredibly talented Brett Yang.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

6 ай бұрын

I'm happy you enjoyed my comments! Brett is indeed very talented!❤️

He played it so well!! 😍 thanks for your analysis!

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

He really did!! Thank you for watching ❤️

My mom is a classically trained singer who'd play classical music on Saturday's as she was baking. I grew up actually listening to metal and folk but got into classical about 10 years ago. Absolutely adore Faure and also Shostakovich and Borodin. My fav, by a country mile though is the cello sonata performed by Mstislav Rostropovich and Rudolf Serkin. BEAUTIFUL!

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Those are awesome too!🎶

Thank you for sharing this. As a non musician, this review is very helpful. Personally I love Brett's interpretation on this concerto. Days before the stream, I listened & watched some live performance to understand more of the concerto. I was so nervous when he started to play but of course nowhere as nervous as he was! All the things you point out in this video makes me love his performance even more. It makes things much more enjoyable whenever I'd relive this performance again (I'm still listening to it everyday at work ngl). Again, thank you so much for your hard work on reviewing this concerto. Also, I don't mind watching 1 hour long video if it's this fun. :3

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

I'm so happy you enjoyed the video!! It takes soooo long to make the long videos, but it's worth it if y'all love them ❤️

Thanks for slowing his 2nd movement to 85%! I thought his original version was beautiful enough but when I heard the slowed down version, it has even more "feel" to it. Absolutely love it! Great analysis overall. Bravo not just to Brett but to you as well. 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

I'm happy the effort was worth it! And that you liked the video! Thank you for watching ❤️

thank you for giving us a very good reason for listening it again

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Of course ❤️ Thank you for watching!

Thank you so much for this very detailed critique. I am a middle-aged guy who started getting into classical music (flute) just before the pandemic. I appreciate this critique because it is like it explains to me why I like this concerto. I knew I liked it, but I did not know why. Thank you.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

No worries at all! Welcome to the woodwind gang❤️

Thank you for making such an in-depth analysis whilst also respecting the musician’s efforts! Sometimes these kind of videos can be overly critical and judgmental but you were very well-intentioned. Thoroughly enjoyed! ❤

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

I'm happy you liked it! Thank you for watching ❤️

Thanks for the detailed review! It's really making me see some bits in a new light! Live performances aren't perfect, but to me that's their charm - there's something vulnerable, genuine about them that makes it so enjoyable, little imperfections and all (on that note, anyone noticed how the mikes sometimes pick up breathing? srsly impressed at the high level sound recording ability there 😂) Would love to hear your thoughts about the Bach double and La Campanella!

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Completely agree on your thoughts on live performances! I'm definitely looking into talking through the other pieces from the concert, so stay tuned for that!❤️

This is what I mean when I say I want music commentary. This is absolutely magnificent. 💯

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Thank you🥲❤️

You are really great in explaining how the music is played. Subscribed!

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Thank you! Welcome to the channel❤️

I kinda enjoyed that 1 harmonic lol but apart from that I wholeheartedly agree with everything you've said. He def rushed a little in a few places but of course that's nerves and nothing a little more performance experience wouldn't take care of. I think it's easy to forget just how good Brett and Eddy are when we're mostly watching them play games and stuff. I knew Brett had been practising a lot so I came into the performance with fairly high expectations and I was still surprised and impressed.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

The harmonic is for sure a personal preference on my end ahaha He played really well! Surpassed my expectations!😊

Brett is so amazing at emotional expression

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

He really is! It's controlled and thought-through, but still very much emotional!

@Alceste_

Жыл бұрын

He never shows any with his face so he can pour them in his playing!

thank you for this video. For someone who's not a violinist, this was very helpful and insightful.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

I'm happy to hwar you found it helpful!❤️

Thanks so much for the detailed analysis. I learned a ton.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

So happy to hear, you're very welcome❤️

I agree with the tempo in the 2nd movement as well. The fast tempo did catch me in surprise during live but since I'm not an expert, I'm not sure if it's just my personal preference or not. Overall, I already expected Brett's sweetness would paint the piece really well, but the perfection throughout the whole thing still exceeds my expectations. Maybe because I had been comparing it to the 2mil and 3mil, which though I still like to listen to, they were flawed, not like a polished concert recording, but this concert I can honestly say I can listen to it for the whole thing and not differentiating it from a top tier soloist recording.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

It's an excellent performance, for sure!!

@ranonampangom2185

Жыл бұрын

Tbh I think that's going a bit far, though it was excellent I think he still has a ways to go before he reaches his full potential here. His sound and tone were absolutely delightful and sweet, and his phrasing was amazing, but I think perhaps he could have added even more flair. Not so much that it would have overpowered the performance, but slightly more flair to truly mark his own distinct sound for the concerto. BUT that just means I look forward to hearing much more from him! And in the meantime I'll be replaying this incredible performance on repeat! 😊

@acd4457

Жыл бұрын

@@ranonampangom2185 For sure there's a lot more to improve. There always is. Just the fact that he was able to keep the standard for the whole piece from start to end amazes me.

@Casutama

Жыл бұрын

I don't think it's quite fair to compare this to the previous milestone performances. Not just because of the Stradivari violins, the orchestra, the professional sound recording, and the fact that because they practice 40 hours a day they're now both better violinists than they were at the time of their respective previous milestone performances (although these are major factors as well), but also because, especially compared to 2Mil, the amount of preparation time that went into this is almost incomparable. They announced Tchaikovsky around 4.5 months before the performance, and they've since admitted that when they announced it, they were planning just to prank everyone, before they evenutally realised the fans genuinely wanted to see that performance. So I think it's realistic to say that somewhere between 3-4 months of actual preparation went into that concerto (and, while Brett's more familiar with it, it's also the harder of the two concertos). Whereas we know that he prepared for Mendelssohn for almost an entire year. Which is why I actually went into this performance with relatively high expectations - and was completely blown away. What I mean to say is: I'll always love and enjoy Brett's 2Mil Tchaik for what it is, and this is not so much another calibre of performance as rather a different *genre* of what you might expect.

Liked and subscribed! This was amazing. Thank you!

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Thank YOU! And welcome❤️

Thank you so much for this analysis. I very much enjoyed it. Subscribed. I thought Brett did so well. I was sure he'd do great, but I didn't expect this! Technically he's not up there with the greatest of course, but from an emotional perspective this is one of the interpretations of Mendelssohn that have touched me the most. I agree he rushed a bit in the second movement, but he must have been so nervous. With more experience of playing seriously and the self confidence that comes with that he would be even better. I hope he (and Eddy) will get more chances of playing seriously in the future.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Welcome!❤️ I agree that they should get more opportunities!!

this video is actually pretty good. ı am glad ı found your channel.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

I'm glad you found my channel too❤️ Welcome!

I think they did awesome and was so happy for Brett that he was able to fulfill his dream. I think the tempi are also a matter of Interpretation. Thank you for your detailed review.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

They absolutely did amazingly! Tempo is definitely an interpretation thing! I'm happy you enjoyed it😊❤️

So, SO exquisitely beautiful!

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Absolutely!!❤️

I think it’s very personal taste too. The one recording I love most is Anne-Sophie Mutters 1980’s recording of the violin concerto. She slows it right down and imitates an opera singer. Simpler changes that are much closer to the human voice. She is a master at this.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Mutter is amazing tbh

What a wonderful analysis of this performance! 😊💚

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Thank you ❤️❤️

@srrfounder1

Жыл бұрын

@@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic Your editing deserves an A+ as well, MUCH appreciated!!

Wow!! Great job!! Thank you for your analysis.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Thank YOU for watching it!❤️

🌟🌟 Gold Stars for Brett and Eddy!!

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

🌟🌟

I loved how he played this. Completely. ❤

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

I do too😍

Thank you so much for your review of Brett's performance. I think you captured his creativity well. I agree with your comment about the second movements tempo being a bit quick. This concerto has been a favorite of mine since I started playing as a child. Thank you so much.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

I'm happy you enjoyed the video! Thank you for watching😊❤️

This is the first video of yours I've seen. Well done! I appreciate your commentary about the details of the Mendelsohn Concerto. I've heard it before, both by Brett and other violinists, but my analysis is at the overall violinistic approach: bold or sweet, swift or measured. I'd not appreciated the small details you brought out. Thank you!

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

I'm happy to hear you enjoyed the video❤️🥰

You made a Great analysis! You were on point with the observations.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Thank you!!

I loved this! I really loved it! I will be sticking around your channel! There were so many tiny weeny things that I wondered if anyone else spotted (spoiler alert, they/you did) and I'm stoked to see someone geek out over it the way I did! 😄❤️

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Ahhh I'm happy to hear you'll be sticking around❤️❤️❤️ And there were so many things that I could've pointed out but it would take sooo long

@jihanabelleslavin6386

Жыл бұрын

I mean.....if you ever decide to make a part two, I will be an early viewer. 😄

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

@@jihanabelleslavin6386 I have a poll for La Campanella or Bach Double up, so check that out!😁

@jihanabelleslavin6386

Жыл бұрын

I have done now! And I look forward to it! 😄❤️

rly gud analysis haha, glad yt recommended this to me :)

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

I'm happy you enjoyed it😁❤️

great job with the vid anyway, u rlly helped me better appreciate bretts performance

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

I'm super happy you found it useful ❤️

Excellent video and good opinios about the Brett´s playing, Bless from Nicaragua

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Wow, Nicaragua!!! Thank you so much❤️

OMG I was waiting for this kind of explanation from the musician's perspective since the live concerto, Thank you so much for the deep insight. One thing I disagree is the a bit slower second movement tempo, I like this fast one, but hey, music is subjective 😊😊😊 But one thing I most love is how twosetters are reacting to your explanation, Lingling community is the best. @twosetviolin please watch this:)

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

I'm super happy you enjoyed the video!! I'd probably die (from happiness) if twoset watched this, frfr)

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

@@londongael414 Ahh I'm so happy you found this useful!! Welcome to the channel❤️

@Casutama

Жыл бұрын

I agree, I really liked the tempo in the 2nd movement too! But, like you say, subjective ;)

Beatiful video and really entertaining. You definitely need more attention

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

You're too kind, thank you 😭❤️

I've been watching these guys for years, and this is the best they've ever done. I know it could have been better, but then again what performance exists that could n't be improved? Oh, and it's Eddy who has the Perfect Pitch... He's always chiding Brett on "quarter tones" and being half of a semitone flat or sharp. Brett has always been big on endings, and I'm so pleased he nailed this one.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Completely agree! There are no perfect performances!

I thought it was a good concerto, and it got better throughout, but I’m not well educated in classical music, though I do enjoy it quite a lot. It was really strange seeing Brett in the same place as Ray Chen, Hillary Hahn and other greats and pulled off quite a show that thanks to their channel - and channels like yours - I was able to appreciate its qualities a little more!

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

I'm happy to hear you enjoyed the video! They certainly did a great job!

Thank you for your commentary, very astute.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Thank you!

Interesting analysis, thanks. I enjoyed the concert a lot

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Thank YOU! I also enjoyed the concert, they did great!

I'm loving these reviews people are making of Brett's Mendelssohn 😁 and I'm starting to think I would like to see a twoset's review of the reviews to his concert! (Apart from his own review of his concert, of course) Reviewception! 😅

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Reviewception!!!

Love you🙏🏼❤️

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

5 ай бұрын

You're too kind!! The love certainly should go to Brett for his excellent performance!❤️

i was hoping for a video like this. I suggested it in the comment section of the performance video and people strongly disagreed. it is one more opportunity to learn.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

That's crazy that people disagreed! I didn't know that, actually 😅

very personal performance by Brett. just love it.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Absolutely agree!❤️

Delightful!

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

Thank you, mr Chopin!🥰

Mille mercis!! A thousand thanks, is very common in France and Belgium, so if just a few of us who watched your concert live could give you mille mercis, then the count could rise exponentially. (Brett can work out the equation)

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

A thousand thanks is common in Norway too❤️

@violabso

Жыл бұрын

@@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic a sensible country, Norway.

I think the louder woodwind section might be due to the placement of sound receivers for the live stream, say if they were placed overhead. The actual dynamics in the hall may be different for the live audience.

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

That was my theory too, but some commenters here who was in the hall say it was the same there! So idk😅

I liked the pace of the second movement! But some really interesting comments, a lot of which I agree with :)

@MyOpinionsAboutClassicalMusic

Жыл бұрын

The tempo of the second movement is definitely a subjective thing, and not at all hard facts from me! I'm happy you found some interesting stuff, though 😁