Oceaniz: “This music slow f-ks me against the wall.” Me: (Driving, looking for a cliff to veer off) My Dad: (Silently Judging me from the passenger seat.)

@youareloved1455

3 жыл бұрын

WAIT YOUR DAD HEARD THAT

@richardsmith2719

3 жыл бұрын

@@youareloved1455 I watched half the video, had to go get groceries with him, and my car’s bluetooth started playing the video.

@adoniscreed4031

3 жыл бұрын

That's on you bro 😂

@cereskerrigan

3 жыл бұрын

Your Mom: (Nods along with acute nostalgia.)

@cereskerrigan

3 жыл бұрын

@Wild Dog Productions Oh yeeesss.

Correction: Overhaul's theme was played in ep65 during his meeting with the league of villains. Other than that, I 100% agree with how bad the music placements are. Yuki Hayashi made tracks with names that corresponds directly to a scene or characters, yet they think "yeah, that Katsuki and Izuku track should be played when the Big 3 walks into a room" or "We love US of Smash theme, let's overuse it"

@wetdragon6938

3 жыл бұрын

yeah united states of smash are those types of themes that are better if only used every once in a while you say run is the type nobody minds if you keep playing it every episode lol

@leeleelee7878

3 жыл бұрын

They played overhaul's theme during rappa fight ad eell

@bigsmall2842

3 жыл бұрын

It’s having the same problem as one piece. Some banger soundtracks are available but they keep on spamming the same ones.

@mohammedsakayl3016

3 жыл бұрын

@@bigsmall2842 someone had to say it.

@danieleanzaldi

3 жыл бұрын

yes i absolutely hated that they never used "katsuki and izuku" for their fight it was perfection for it you could hear bakugo's frustration and hanger contrasted by deku's sounds with "you say run"

I'm just salty about how we were robbed of a My Villain Academia opening >:|

@holybanana8182

3 жыл бұрын

same

@AmDF-et6ro

3 жыл бұрын

@@Spaceperson-xx8de also I don’t know how to describe it but if you see the second the mha logo appears in the op it’s zoomed on the word “hero” 👀

@mandreotti8320

3 жыл бұрын

@@Spaceperson-xx8de Link please?

@adriannngp2012

3 жыл бұрын

next season tho

@fullmetalpotato1258

3 жыл бұрын

@@Spaceperson-xx8de I hope for that but I'm worried we might not. It feels like they took away some funding from this season to go into their movie. I mean they even skipped MVA and ruined all tension if the arc in episode 15 just so they could add a filler episode to shill for the movie as episode 16

Not sure how to feel. Its true things like Deku's face has been a little off from the manga art alongside some other details. But all things considered prioritizing the movie over the anime feels the most potentially damaging.

@bigsmall2842

3 жыл бұрын

It is damaging. The only time we really get stellar animation is at the end of arcs, the final attacks or so go crazy, while everything else is sub par. There’s only two times that isn’t the case since OFA vs AFO: the lida and todoroki fight and the endeavor vs high end battle.

@laforestadeimillepugnali3865

3 жыл бұрын

The movies don' t take away from the series. It doesn' t work like that in Studio Bones. They are different teams working on different things.

@jayney11

3 жыл бұрын

@@laforestadeimillepugnali3865 they are talking about the re arranging

@auzinsss1665

3 жыл бұрын

@@bigsmall2842 the Bakugou fight in joint training was animated well too tho also Deku vs Bakugou at the end od season 3 was an amazing fight🤔 and one moment with Kaminari in the first fight of joint training had strangely great animation. At the end of the day I agree with you that it's inconsistent.

@mikemorro140

3 жыл бұрын

@@auzinsss1665 I'd also point out the Iida scenes in JT being really well animated

I like when people say, "I hate the flashbacks" It's funny Because the whole show is a flashback

@jaru3097

3 жыл бұрын

flashbacks in a flashback flashception

@petergriffinicemold3093

3 жыл бұрын

@@jaru3097 Flashback the sequel

@kristol569

3 жыл бұрын

Actually no, the story is told in racconto. Which is a very long "view" into the past to told a story

@expomkr7506

3 жыл бұрын

@@kristol569 which is a flashback

@kristol569

3 жыл бұрын

@@expomkr7506 No, a flashback is short. It's in the name

Before people start shitting on Bones for the less than stellar adaptation of S5 of MHA, let me preface this by saying this, its not their fault. The ones people should be angry at, are the production committee and their incessant need for an MHA movie every year. Due to this very reason the actual adaption suffers as animators and resources are moved away from the TV show towards the movies. And to top that off, Bones may have gotten tired of adapting MHA. What many fans don't realize, that MHA is an oddity in Bones' line up of shows. They as a studio are attracted towards projects that give their animators a reason to flex, and now you have a long running show with dwindling recourses and that paints a very clear picture, the production committee is taking almost all creative control from a studio made with the very foundation of creative control.

@murderman8578

3 жыл бұрын

Interesting

@OneAndOnlyWanted

3 жыл бұрын

Your points are... Kind of right but also wrong at the same time.

@SakugaObscurious

3 жыл бұрын

@@OneAndOnlyWanted Please elaborate

@OneAndOnlyWanted

3 жыл бұрын

@@SakugaObscurious first I'd like to apologize for my bad English, it's not my native language. I agree with you that the production committee is at fault for quality dips in certain seasons of MHA like s3-4 and also taking away certain animators that would otherwise be on the show but the resources and staff for the movie and series are almost completely separate. MHA was also taken up by bones because it was rather popular so it would allow the studio to get quite a bit of funds. Bones is one of those studios where if their president finds a show interesting he'll provide most of the funds for it. Like mob psycho, josee the tiger and the fish and even the upcoming supercrooks.

@SakugaObscurious

3 жыл бұрын

@@OneAndOnlyWanted Very true, but Bones was founded by the pure principle of making shows that will let its animators run wild. In a interview Nakamura once mentioned that Bones president Masahiro Minami, heavily encourages the staff to always try something new. The only reason why I can think MHA was taken by Bones was to get more funding for shows they want to make, aka originals or passion projects like Mob Psycho. Now that the the production committee is getting more handsy when it comes to schedule and resources, I cant help but think that the priority has shifted. Heck, we might have the AOT situation where, Bones might not come back for another season.

They really can't screw up MVA or the War arc. These are easily the highlight of the series and need all the attention they can get. Honestly these stupid movies need to go

@SonGoku-qn1nc

3 жыл бұрын

How are the movies stupid? They are good from both an animation and writing standpoint

@theone_shogun

3 жыл бұрын

@@SonGoku-qn1nc Sure they are sakuga candy and fun but if they are going to impact the main series then I'd rather not have them. You can see how Heroes Rising messed up the adaptation of season 4 and now the same thing is happening with season 5 and the 3rd movie with a random filler to tie in the villain.

@mr.preston1632

3 жыл бұрын

@@theone_shogun ??? They just moved the Endeavor Agency Arc to the current arc?

@theone_shogun

3 жыл бұрын

@@mr.preston1632 it's the most recent episode I'm talking about. It's a filler with a short tease of the 3rd movie villain but it's just reducing the amount of time for the main plot

@mr.preston1632

3 жыл бұрын

@@theone_shogun I agree

Sometimes the anime really fucks up Bakugou's character, they love to use his anger as a gag, which I know Horikoshi did himself, but they really exaggerate those scenes and others, making him look a wild animal or something. Just like his scene with Jeanist, when they met he tied Katsuki up, but that never happened in the manga.. it really leaves a bad impression.

@jimjam8246

3 жыл бұрын

Maybe that's why I absolutely detest Bakugo and dread every time he's on screen. Would I enjoy him more as a character if I began to read the manga?

@najadamu2724

3 жыл бұрын

@@jimjam8246 Probably. You'd at least see the nuances of his character a bit better in the manga, since he's not near-constantly screaming in there.

@d3anims97

3 жыл бұрын

​@@jimjam8246 Yeah the manga, now that he's focused on change, uses his outburst as more of a gag and it even seems like the anime doesn't want his character to change. He's still explosive in the manga since quirks might as well be personalities but some examples would be: - In S3 after he and Deku fight, HEs the one that initiated the conversation about shoot style and how Deku can improve it, in the anime Deku asks and Bakugo is silent but then relents and gives advice - In the Joint Training when he tells Deku not to compliment him, its an endearing gag in the manga because he's literally chewing at Dekus speech bubble, in the anime he comes off as the same prick - After his team beats Class B and Deku congratulates him, he tells him to move out of reflex (it says so), in the anime he just comes off as a prick that still hates the guy -I also think after his Class B match he told Deku not to fall behind before Dekus match but the anime was just ramblings about being stronger and stronger. Of course, maybe it was a translation ting when I read the manga Bakugo is a treat for me in the manga because even though he's over the top you know he's out to do some good in his own weird outbursty way...in the anime he's kinda cringe except for when they get to those defining character moments and then he's cringe again for a gag, its weird lol.

@yallaintit

3 жыл бұрын

I didn't realize this. Maybe Bakugo is popular mainly for his exaggerated personality so the anime adaption keeps changing him to make him fit these desires. It can make him very unlikable though.

@auzinsss1665

3 жыл бұрын

Idk, I think Bakugou's voice actor really makes Bakugou even better. Not to mention that usually the animation is on point when he is on the screen. Bruh I can't wait for the war arc to get animated, imagine the moment in chapter 285 animated TIERS WILL BE SHEDD Even tho Bakugou has his gag moments and is portrayed as you said a wild animal he still has his serious moments that make him a three dimensional character that isn't just going by one characteristic

I honestly think that other than the extended flashbacks, which are annoying, Joint Training was handled very well, I really enjoyed it in the anime. While the rearranging of the arcs worries me, I am still very excited and hopefully for MVA.

@danitabori

3 жыл бұрын

yeah I enjoyed class A vs B in the anime much more. I didn't really know what was exactly going on in the manga and I guess we get more done in one episode than in one chapter. Appearantly there will only be like 7 episodes or so for MVA. That's what worries me. I don't want them to make it too short, that's one of the most interesting parts of the series.

@tommydude447

3 жыл бұрын

I totally agree except for the flashbacks part

@icyhot8167

3 жыл бұрын

I 100% agree nothing against hori sensei but the jt arc was kinda boring in thr manga even tho i binged it but the anime made it so much better with the amazing animation, soundtracks and voice acting, especially the last three fight's and the blackwhip introduction....the flashbacks were a small problem thi but honestly apart from 1-2 episodes it didn't bother me that much

@thecrow4461

3 жыл бұрын

I honestly think the arc switch is Genius what makes a better season finale. Another endeavor focused finale or shigi going ham but I do think it’s weird being a manga reader my anime only friends still find it enjoyable they kinda like that they have no idea what’s happening in the background.

@SuperNinjaBoy43

3 жыл бұрын

The problem for me was that there was no need for JT to be more than 6 or 7 seven episodes. For an arc that is almost exclusively action, the anime should have vastly improved the pacing, but it did the complete opposite. Fights 3 and 4 had great pacing, 5 was ok, but 1 and 2 were abysmal. I think I'm probably in the minority of people who thoroughly enjoyed JT in the manga, despite it's pacing problems, but it did not need or frankly deserve 11 or 12 episodes. And then we have MVA. I have no idea what they're doing or why they thought it was a good idea. Switching MVA and EA is perfectly fine, maybe even better for the anime, but it is baffling to me that they would pre-emptively spoil so many parts of MVA and seemingly attempt to ruin what made the arc so amazing.

I completely agree with you on the color pallet. If I hadn’t been told how good this show was initially, it wouldn’t even taken me a long time to actually start watching this show because of the at reason. Also, I totally agree about the background thing.

I do not blame the animators. I blame the executive producers. S5 would have looked great if it wasn't for that stupid third film. More importantly, we could have gotten MVA academia sooner, but because they had to change the order of the story arcs to tie into the film, fans will have to wait longer to see Tomura kick ass. From a narrative point of view this is very annoying, because by adapting Endeavor agency first, it spoils certain moments in MVA. A member of the league almost died during the fight with the MLA, but because The current arc was adapted first, their fate will be less impactful because we know they survived. All this because the executives got greedy and wanted a third film. Now they have pissed off manga fans and will probably confuse a few anime only fans as well.

@gavo7911

3 жыл бұрын

Actually, I’m pretty sure they reshuffled the arcs to give the animators coming back from the movie MORE time to work on MVA. At least, that’s what I hope.

@fullmetalpotato1258

3 жыл бұрын

@@gavo7911 they wanted the filler beach episode to be timed closer to the movie premiere. And since it fit better with the Endeavor agency arc, they shuffled it. And ruined the MVA story in the process... for a filler episode...

@gavo7911

3 жыл бұрын

@@fullmetalpotato1258 Did you ignore what I just said? The later development of MVA means they’re gonna have more people working on it, which means it’ll probably look amazing.

@fullmetalpotato1258

3 жыл бұрын

@@gavo7911 they seem to have less episodes than they should unless they are extending the season. And episode 15 screwed up all tension in the arc by showing us who would be alive by the end of it. Even if it gets GOD TIER animation, they fumbled the story of the arc HARD before the arc even started.

@gavo7911

3 жыл бұрын

@@fullmetalpotato1258 How do you know how long it will be? It’ll probably be the last 6-7 episodes.

Sometimes, people complain because they care, they give judgments and critics with suggestions because they want what they like to do great, and sir you’ve clearly show your love for the series

About the Japanese dub, I think the best performance occurs in Season 5, when Ochaco screams at Shinso asking him to stop a rampaging Deku. Ochaco's VA let out an actual scream of anguish, one that you would actually hear in real life during a street brawl or a particularly brutal event

"it slowfucks me against the wall and offers me champagne afterwards" is a god tier sentence. SSS+

I have noticed over the last two seasons that some of the characters (deku in particular) have had several prolonged scenes of the characters being incredibly off model. The animation quality has also been a bit stiff, save for the sakuga scenes. Overall though it’s been… fine. Also I must give the proper praise to the sound effects, Bones absolutely nailed them in nearly every case.

@laforestadeimillepugnali3865

3 жыл бұрын

It' s because from S3-4, there were some changes in the animation directors! So the art was more incosistent. Lot of those shots were corrected in the BDs, thankfuly.

@ObaREX

3 жыл бұрын

@@laforestadeimillepugnali3865 Really?

@MyCatEatsPlastic

3 жыл бұрын

@@laforestadeimillepugnali3865 What does BD stand for?

@cantthinkofaname5046

3 жыл бұрын

@@MyCatEatsPlastic I think blue-ray release

I just hope for no more movies after this one. God knows how much help they'll need to animate and give a good direction to season 6. The less distractions the better.

As someone who got good grades in music class, I can confirm that Yuki Hayashi’s compositions fuck. They always fuck, deeply and passionately, basically in every anime I’ve ever seen. He’s the GOAT right now as far as musical compositions for anime go, no question. The musical scoresin My Hero and Haikyuu are both especially high tier.

I liked this video because it’s not just up straight fan speaking only bad about the anime I’m tired of hearing the negative comments to complain by dissing everything good makes me feel like I’m listening to a silly person complain I’m only praying for MHA’s success that’s it People say it’s overrated but I can hardly find fans who are true TRUE fan who appear very rarely and I hate it the most when they get overshadowed by negative comments😢

@motor4X4kombat

3 жыл бұрын

fandom: is this human thinking they call ... rationality?

I just hope someday someone makes a faithful Berserk adaptation...

@sesereddead465

3 жыл бұрын

Although considering the fact that the manga may not be continued because of miura’s untimely passing, that’s a secondary concern atm.

@Midorikonokami

3 жыл бұрын

I don't want it, man. It still hurts that berserk will never be finished... Hurts so much.

@justajobro1266

3 жыл бұрын

Yes by madhouse or David productions

@rudrakumar5441

3 жыл бұрын

Kingdom and tokyo ghoul too

15:18 I couldn't agree more

I thought this was going to be 20 minutes complaining about how bad the Direction has been. I have very few issues with the art, few issues with the sound, and 101 issues with the pacing and storyboarding. Once you see examples of anime hitting the pacing and storyboarding out of the park (like jujutsu kaisen), Bones' mediocre direction sticks out like a sore thumb.

@mikemorro140

3 жыл бұрын

See the comparison point is why I haven't actually had too big of a problem because like while yeah if you compare to Mappa it's not great right now but then if you compare to how Toei and Pierrot treated the big three and Black Clover at times and god forbid about how Deen and Cloverworks have done the latest seasons of Promised Neverland and Seven Deadly Sins, I can't help but think is it really that bad or is just not as amazing as we're used to by now.

@Dell-ol6hb

3 жыл бұрын

@@mikemorro140 it’s just not as amazing as it used to be and people are losing their minds over it, like I think people need to just chill tf out tbh

@dynamixstorm1436

3 жыл бұрын

@@Dell-ol6hb I agree, it's not like their complaining will change anything and if people can't enjoy the anime as it is and keep being negative about it they have a option of not watching it. I have seen a lot of people saying they are quitting the anime because of a arc they haven't EVEN SEEN animated and I am really glad that they are gone tired of these toxic assholes.

@Chobin29

3 жыл бұрын

@@dynamixstorm1436 I’m glad to see some people being reasonable. Everyone needs to at least wait for the season to end before losing their minds over it. The biggest issue with the switch in arcs is the spoilers, and even those are pretty minor in my opinion, especially without any context

@dynamixstorm1436

3 жыл бұрын

@@Chobin29 yeah if you want to complain or criticise at least wait for the season to get finished but nooo all I see is them saying the arc is ruined when they haven't even seen it. You know I have been in this fandom for three years now I have seen the worst of it but this has been the absolute worst it's ever been for me. I always thought why does the anime fandom keep saying that MHA has the worst fanbase but now I am starting to think that they are right.

14:20 i knew people loved the music of the anime but i didn't think you loved it that much 🤣

I think the animation complaints are usually stupid. But the way they batched the over haul arc is unexceptable. The mirio vs overhaul fight was terrible. The pacing was to fast and i felt it was way harder to enjoy in the anime vs the manga. Season four is when i truely felt the adaption failed and no the deku vs overhaul and endeavour sakuga dont fix it

@RM-56

3 жыл бұрын

To be fair Mirio vs Overhaul didn’t even have a fight to be adapted. It was a narraration

@mikemorro140

3 жыл бұрын

@@RM-56 yeah that's why I still don't get why people were complaining about that(at least manga readers anyway) like there was nothing to adapt fight wise in the manga anyway at least they added some scenes.

@taosamundo

3 жыл бұрын

For clarification for those who don't know, the Mirio vs Overhaul fight after he got hit by the bullet, was just narration in the manga. It said something like "Mirio faught overhaul quirkless for 4 minutes after the bullet". In the anime, they decided to animate it to an extent. But, the animation was that of a slideshow, so many anime-onlies complained about how "lazy" the animation team was, assuming that they didn't adopt (non-existent) manga panels correctly.

@keelograms911

3 жыл бұрын

@@RM-56 no it wasnt. After his quirk was lost it was narrated and the fight was poorly addapted before that before they did the power point slideshow. They really cut corners and saved the budget of all the fights we got i wanted to what i thought would be Mirios final fight done with some flair. That fight is a D- when i was expecting at least a B.

@keelograms911

3 жыл бұрын

@@mikemorro140 i disagree they adapted everything but did a poor job. The fact that its a pretty short sequence makes it worse that they couldnt show the source material some respect for one of the main fights in the arc

My biggest gripe with the animation is in how fights are handled. Compare the sakuga from Naruto to that of MHA for example. MHA focuses heavily on big epic colorful one punch attacks, but has very little focus on any fast paced hand to hand combat. It's all kamehameha with no martial combat. When given an opportunity to have any faste paced action, the anime slows down time and has characters give entire monologues between or during attacks. Such as when Deku tries to stomp Overhall's head. Even the few exceptions such as All Might vs Nomu is marred by using the animation short-cut of just adding blurred punches instead of animating the body movements. I'm talking about the infamous gomu-gomu-no gatling-gun punches. The only fight of the series I think there is actually good sakuga is the second Deku vs Bakugo. Ida vs Mudman is pretty and colorful, yes, but look back at it again. There is very little movement of their bodies or interactions. It's another kamehameha moment. Pretty, but not a dance of anatomy. Seriously, check out some Naruto fights to see what I'm talking about.

I'm sad to say that thus far they've fucked the endeavor agency arc, I think that MVA will go really well, but the order change was just a little bit too much story change for bones to handle, since they literally just changed the arc orders and nothing about the actual arcs themselves, and it just feels... off?

@ObaREX

3 жыл бұрын

They've also cut out little scenes that added the world building in both arcs.

my baby brain can't keep up, you need to put more flashbacks in this video

Love this breakdown. Love the content. 🙏🏼🙌🏼

You're right, I really can't unsee that background thing now. Also thanks for mentioning how awesome the ost/score is.

The manga's fight scenes were sometimes hard to follow until the Overhaul arc, in my opinion. And Kohei Horikoshi loves doing big pictures that take up 2/3 of space across two pages. These look good when you are reading them on an app, but when I buy the volumes, they don't translate very well thanks to the binding in the middle.

Thank you for making a serious review of the anime adaptation of the story and not just complaining that it isn't the manga

“Everything lit like it’s a sunny midday” oh yeah that would probably be my biggest complaint Backgrounds suck “Tell me from the future” ah yes the infamous mva adaptation.. For some reason, i just hate the openings. I think this is first anime where I consistently skip openings and endings. They just don’t work for me for some reason…

One of my biggest gripes with the art direction in season 5 is the depiction of winter. Winter skies are pale and pretty when clear, and dreary and gray when cloudy. In MHA S5, the sky looks exactly the same as if it were Summer, and when we see Todoroki's breath during the lecture scene in episode... 103? Idk, I've lost track. Anyways, when we see his breath, it feels a bit jarring. The atmosphere doesn't make the scene feel cold.

6:54 ngl i thought this was a google image background and when i was confused about what u were talking about i watched heros rising and thats an actual thing in the movie and i was blown away how bad the episodes are compared to the movie

14:00 well i don't know what everyone else is saying, but i think it went pretty well lol

Glad someone acknowledged the anime doesn't seem to know how Shigaraki looks.

@TheRawyan

3 жыл бұрын

True

@averageanimefan519

3 жыл бұрын

If even Horikoshi has trouble sometimes when it comes to just drawing Shigaraki, I'm not surprised the anime can't do it either.

The over haul arc was not handled well in the anime it’s too fast paced and lacks tension because of that not a fan of that adaption every since then I been strictly mang

@auzinsss1665

3 жыл бұрын

I mean for the overhaul arc I was an anime only and after reading the manga it could have been handled better but for an anime only it still was very entertaining.

@suzeray87

3 жыл бұрын

I said the same thing and the gentle arc… the manga made Gentle look like the protagonist

@nada17anaum

3 жыл бұрын

I really think the problem is because we shifted to the manga we wish for more perfect animation to come to light That’s why there are almost no complaints in season 1-3 because at that point many were anime only

@auzinsss1665

3 жыл бұрын

@@nada17anaum that's actually so true

@reakefit7304

3 жыл бұрын

@@nada17anaum I cannot talk about others expectations or experience with the anime, but for me, once I made the change to manga during the license arc, I can say that I prefer the anime for the first three seasons. After all might's fight with afo I lost interest in it for a while, so I moved to the manga, and honestly to me, after all might's retirement the anime just stopped being interesting. It still has it's moments but personally I'm not gonna spend a whole season just to get to a good scene.

After being there for the studio change of the seven deadly sins anime- yeah no complaints, they're doing a good job thankfully. A bit nervous about arcs getting switched but we'll see how it goes in the end

TY! Mha is one of those rare shows I couldn't watch the anime for because the art for the manga is great and the anime is a step down which is ashame.

I’m just finding it hard to be optimistic about the MVA switch. It seems to me it was just done because of the movie, and that does not inspire confidence. How I see it, Bones needs to pull of a miracle to have this stunt be worth it.

@underscore2736

3 жыл бұрын

I hope they're delaying MVA so they have more time to make it look good

@LunarJaguar

3 жыл бұрын

@Alexander Jackson 7 that's what we said for the Promised Neverland season 2 and look what we got :(

1:30 TOKAGEEEEEEEEEEEEE

great vid. if adaptation comparison becomes a thing u on ur channel, id love to see you do Black Clover next

Season 1-3: Incredible Season 4: Uhhhhhhh Season 5 so far: 😐 Basically the issue is bones are prioritizing non canon movies rather than it's main story which is what's ruining season 5 rn. Let's pray to god they nail season 6 cause if not the anime is doomed (especially if they make a 4th movie alone side it).

@laforestadeimillepugnali3865

3 жыл бұрын

No they aren' t. Two different teams work on both things. If the movie didn' t exist, those animators wouldn' t have worked on MHA in the first place. Besides, S5, animation wise, looks better than S3-4. The movies actually are helping, because like it happened in S4, many animators of the movies, being free, helped the struggling production of S4. S5 looks the best from as far as S2.

@SonGoku-qn1nc

3 жыл бұрын

Season 4 is good in my opinion I honestly don't understand why people don't like it

@mr.preston1632

3 жыл бұрын

S5 isn’t even that bad yet the Animation is really good and the fith user got that bling

@dynamixstorm1436

3 жыл бұрын

@@laforestadeimillepugnali3865 yeah I hate how this misinformation is still going on look at all the comments movie this movie that. The only thing that is valid is because of the movie they rearranged the arcs and I am pretty sure there were multiple reasons for that.

@laforestadeimillepugnali3865

3 жыл бұрын

@@dynamixstorm1436 Yeah, it' s never cut and dry like many people thinks.

There are few perfect adaptations

Never noticed the background because the series is paced so fast. Now I literally can't unsee it.

This season had the potential to be even better than Season 3, instead it’s the worst because studio heads valued a non-canon movie over the actual story.

@IgorJCorrea

3 жыл бұрын

we already know all the movies are canon. they don't affect the main story but horikoshi considers them canon.

@johnpaulcross424

3 жыл бұрын

The movies do be a waste of talent and production imo, why flex the hardest on non canon material if the actual show is gonna suffer.

@deadshot1995

3 жыл бұрын

@@IgorJCorrea if it doesn’t affect the main story it’s irrelevant, whether you call it canon or not.

@IgorJCorrea

3 жыл бұрын

@@deadshot1995 that's.... exactly what I said

@mithril5155

3 жыл бұрын

@@IgorJCorrea If it doesn't affect the main story, then it isn't canon, it's 1+1.

Gotta love good faith criticism.

As someone's who's always been more drawn to how sound design/audio enhances a medium, it's really interesting to see someone talk extensively about visuals - both the good and the bad - in ways I was able to see but not quite understand. Nice work 👍

Sometimes i feel MHA fans don't deserve Studio Bones.

This was a very nice and thorough review! I love how you actually put thought into how the lighting of each scene or the placement of OST affected the adaptation rather than just worshipping it or flaming it like a lot of videos.

IMO - I'm still gonna watch MHA regardless of the way it was organized. I'm still a little pissed that they rearranged the arcs for a movie they should've just put it on hold at the end of Season 5 and keep the arcs arranged the same before the movie (Joint Training, MVA, Endeavor Agency Arc, then the Movie) but I still got a feeling that the movie's gonna be good. Anyway, I'm still looking forward for the My Villain Academia Arc, but after that arc ends I'm gonna watch most of the Endeavor Agency Arc again just to feel like I watched it in it's original continuity. That's my plan anyway. Edit: I just looked up that season 5 will apparently have 25 episodes and we're already on 17, I'm hoping it'd not gonna be rushed. But I'm still sticking to the plan

Well, about the climax moments I can easily say that MHA just has the MOST FUCKING AWESOME ones among the animes I watched. The way I felt when I saw All Might vs AFO made me few like I was in that nervous crowd watching him and when the fight ended I noticed I was holding my breath. Shit, that feeling was awesome. Same as for scenes like Endeavor vs High End. I just hope I feel this way again in the MVA and war arcs.

Personally the only thing I dislike about the Anime is the Joint Training Arc, because as you mentioned it was painfully slow. Also compared to the season prior with the Shie Hasaikai Arc, it made it look like childs play.

If they do mva imma be mad if they censor out all the dark shigaraki backstory stuff because it's really important and impactful. I don't care how gory that dog got. I want it to be in the anime. If they want it to be towards a younger demographic then maybe make it to where theres less fan service because that's more of an issue because nobody cares if its violent or not.

Ayyy 😄 Another oceaniz upload. Let's go

Normally i would say "whogaf" but after stone ocean i realize points were made

Overhaul’s meeting with the League of Villains was also very well done I think, but yeah I’ve seen so many ppl drop the anime then read the manga after some time and they always say the manga is better

No but seriously, why is an underground lair THAT bright? It makes absolutely no sense, everything should’ve looked like Kirishima and Fatgum vs Rappa to fit the tone of the arc.

@tcincali9642

3 жыл бұрын

Idk but at the same time Overhaul is a germaphobe so I think looking grimey and dirty goes against his character. I work in a hospital and the most sanitized areas are bright as hell

I think the my villain academia arc was postponed for the fact that it is a dark turning point but the endeavor agency is fairly bright

As a hardcore fan of MHA i hate how bones is treating the anime just to do more movies, i thought that they learned their lesson with season 4 but they are doing things worse. These things are not suppose to happen in a seasonal anime, like they made animes seasonal to avoid these situations exactly.

Cool Video

It scared me so much when they put the endeavor internships were put before the liberation arc. Not because of the act of making it, nooo, they kept the torture shit scene there. Like, I know it isn’t a huge problem, to me at least, I watched the anime first so it didn’t mind me much, just confusing. Now that I read the manga tho? Kinda pisses me off 😅 No hate on bones tho :)

One thing I'm really annoyed by in the anime is how they constantly feel the need to show the names and the quirks of the characters. I mean do they have to do this every episode? Don't they think that we know by now? Also the eye catches look really ugly with all the random text plus the translations that are too fast to even read. I think the pictures of the characters would be enough or they should've kept the eye catches from S1, where it was just the title changing colour or whaterver.

@KianOntong13

3 жыл бұрын

Yep the way the name and quirks of the character pops off as well as the english tranlation of it really crowds the screen i hate it

@endo8835

3 жыл бұрын

To be fair though considering the amount of people that surprisingly forget names and quirks it’s warranted

@OtakuNewsSource

3 жыл бұрын

It's done because of the timeslot it's on, along with the fact that there's so many characters/abilities that many tuning into this seasonal show may forget. For what it's worth though, the DVD/Bluray releases of the show do not have the character names/abilities text on the screen at all, and it's the correct/best version of the show to watch since it comes with art fixes + no dimming of the light during action scenes.

Honestly, the anime was serviceable to me up until the beginning of season 4. It was good, definitely preferred the manga but I'll still tune in to see how most of the fandom experiences it. However, a new director and art director had come in before season 4 and I had been skeptical, especially since while he is experienced, the director doesn't have any impressive directing roles to my knowledge. After seeing the directorial style of the first eps of season 4 (both the recap and the first canon episode), I immediately went, "Oh, this doesn't seem good." My Hero Academia had never had very good direction but it was good enough to get the story across; however, the direction presented here, while not easily noticeable to the average viewer, was pretty subpar and awkward and just took me out of the story a lot, especially in dialogue heavy scenes (also the new art director is incredibly inconsistent, and the style that ended up in the anime the most is the very rectangular cheek style that I personally do not like at all). And lo and behold, at least in my opinion, the quality has been decreasing ever since with the rare sudden spikes of quality in the obvious scenes (aka deku vs. overhaul and endeavor's fight with high end). The padding techniques that the director uses also really sucks, such as the long flashbacks and really really long stretches of shots drawn from really really far away that the characters are only a few pixels to save on animation. Additionally, rearranging the arcs for the sake of the movie is always gonna be a bad idea, especially these arcs cuz the manga had the arcs in a certain order so that you as the reader can feel the effects of time on each side (alternating so that the week or so deku spent getting black whip under control is felt through the villain academia arc, and the four months for shigaraki is felt through the endeavor internship arc), but the anime has irreversibly ruined that so now deku just suddenly unlocks black whip immediately after saying he won't be using it for a while and those four months will be just stated right before entering the war arc. The worst part of this, though, is what I had said before: that these are not noticeable to the average viewer; they are, however, easily felt. So, unlike something like the promised neverland season 2 where everyone and their grandmothers knew that it was the adaptation itself that was a dumpster fire, average viewers would attribute the lessening quality of the anime to My Hero Academia as a whole instead of to the clumsy adaptation.

@AintNoWaye

3 жыл бұрын

Agreed. Mukai really sucks

@ObaREX

3 жыл бұрын

Dude this is exactly what I've been trying to tell people.

@expomkr7506

3 жыл бұрын

agreed

@ratticustheemperor

2 жыл бұрын

i liked the anime until season 2 because the training camp wasn't really my jam

The visual + effects, and especially the ost of Worlds Heroes Missions is just beautiful

@yoru6042

2 жыл бұрын

Too bad that the anime is horrible

Honestly I like the music of MHA, i dont listen to the intros and outros, but those are only good in a handfull of anime either way

Maybe the show got worse, but Yuki Hayashi's music still hits hard, seriously I LOVE MHA sountrack, one of the best I've ever heard and one of the most recognizable (also the first one that I have fully listened, I know and recognize the 95% of the songs, even minor ones)

@danieleanzaldi

3 жыл бұрын

@L they are also bangers and we got to listen to 2 of them already in the anime

@danieleanzaldi

3 жыл бұрын

@L it was true they were leaked exactly one month ago in fact i have the files for all of them

@BryMakesArt

3 жыл бұрын

You should hear Attack on Titan’s music. It’s god tier

The only thing I kinda hate about the anime is all the re-introductions when a new season starts

**Manga Spoilers** I'm just really hoping they don't fuck up the whole Villains vs heroes fight, mainly the bakugou moment where he got hurt saving izuku, and when Bakugou apologized to him + uraraka's speech to the public. Idk how they could mess up the actual scene; im just worried they'll shove random filler between the episodes that'll reduce emotional impact/tempo, but we'll see.

I wasnt even aware of any of these issues and I read the manga well I just sit back and enjoy the show some of yall overanalyze it

I will never forgive that they didn't animate shigaraki walking through his memories while he is remembering his past and awakening.

The fact you can go between Super Serious Analytical mode to "This music fucks. Yuki Hayashi's music slow fucks me against a wall" is great lol I think the dialogue about Overhaul thinking rats spread quirks was also cut, which isn't a major downside but its a little frustrating

I think the excessive flashbacks, filler, weird shots for fanservice, and censoring (of the blood/"gore") brought the adaptation down

Oceaniz your criticism is perfect for the anime but my only problem with a video like this is there's so much misinformation in the comments it's hurting my brain.

@awsomedude23456

3 жыл бұрын

So it’s not a problem with the video, more so the people. Which he really can’t control

@dynamixstorm1436

3 жыл бұрын

@@awsomedude23456 I didn't really say the problem with the video it's just my own personal problem hopefully that made sense.

@daniellu1321

3 жыл бұрын

@@dynamixstorm1436 what misinformation? I just want to know so I can avoid it

@dynamixstorm1436

3 жыл бұрын

@@daniellu1321 that bones is wasting animators on the movie and movie affecting the quality of the animation. The animators working on the movie are freelancers they would have never worked on the anime to begin with. The only thing that is fair is one of the reasons for the rearrangement was the movie but there's alot of other reasons that goes in the decisions this big. I want to add one more thing a big advantage of having a movie is now the animators for it will also work at the end of this season like they did last season with the endeavor fight. The people trashing on bones and the animators don't know that this decision is not something they decided alone shueisha and the production committee have a big part in decision like this. When the villain arc was first ongoing the manga sales took a slight dip in sales and the CC2 chief iirc said that the arc is taboo so the production committee are trying to shorten MVA as much as possible which sucks but what can you do.

@venor2612

3 жыл бұрын

^

interesting to see how so many people are disappointed by this season. i for one have personally enjoyed seeing how it’s been handled. the character designs and the character acting in general has been handled much better this season. the storyboards and directing have been way more consistent, even among conservative episodes they do a great job of making the episode as visually pleasing as possible. but my favourite part of this season that has me excited for mhas future is the creative liberties it’s taken. i agree with your point that mha has followed the source material a bit too closely in the past. but since mukai took over as director, we’re seeing a lot more changes that let the story shine in anime form as best as possible. things like adding in the onomatopoeia for certain scenes, drawing scenes from different angles than the manga did, adding in extra content, and even something as simple as having current deku narrate the action in JT was a welcome surprise. even went as far as rearranging the setup for the war so it looks like we don’t have to worry about them following the manga too closely anymore😅 seems mukai has improved a lot as a director in season 5 so i’m expecting even more growth in season 6!! also a huge fan of the 3D backgrounds this year, they made for some really fluid and dynamic movement in JT and i’m excited to see them more. overall i’ve been enjoying season 5 more than any other besides 2, even more than 2 in some aspects, and i suspect mvas adaptation will make it my favourite season. sorry for the huge rant i just had a lot of thoughts on the animes current state as well.

@fang9325

3 жыл бұрын

Yup, this is exactly how I feel about this season. The most creative and maybe even more consistent one in terms of character designs and acting (maybe on par with season 2). I didn't really feel most of the pacing problems people point out, but i can see why they would feel a bit tired of the flashbacks, which, as Oceaniz said in the video, is a hard thing to adapt because it's not just a panel or 2, it's more like 5 or 10 seconds, but in a series like MHA where there is a lot of foreshadowing and callbacks, it's kinda necessary or at least normal. I'm looking forward to see how they handle the switch because this can really be my favourite season in the end if MVA is done right!

@icyhot8167

3 жыл бұрын

Yes!! I agree 100% the animation this season has been really good and consistent and the use cgi..flawless (except for that endeavour shot tho 😋)

@vism2812

3 жыл бұрын

@@fang9325 i’m also very curious about how they’ll transition to mva now. if i remember correctly, in universe it was happening simultaneously with pro hero and JT, so a little flashback happened at the beginning before reaching the present. but now that the anime is gonna have it be an event that’s completely in the past, and we already know how the arc ends up, i’m looking forward to see what changes they make in introducing the arc

@Chobin29

3 жыл бұрын

@@vism2812 Honestly, if they do the scenes that lead into the arc chronologically, like 1-2 episodes in, I think the timeline will be so much easier to follow.

11:47 YES the lighting!!! I've never seen someone talk about this (maybe it's just the circles I'm in lol) and I thought maybe it was just my personal taste for muted, limited, or darker color palettes, or perhaps getting too used to the manga in black and white, that made me dislike the way the anime is often colored. But now that you've laid out these examples it's so obvious. And just look at Horikoshi's covers and color spreads for comparison. His use of contrast is gorgeous and I love the soft fill textures combined with bold dramatic lineart. It all has a certain dimension to it that I really wish could have been recreated.

This is a great video for explaining what to look for with adaptions in general, at least for those just starting out in analyzing these things imo

I don’t see why they couldn’t have just delayed the movie release for a few more weeks, then the series could have flowed properly and everything would have been fine :/

@crazyassassinkill

3 жыл бұрын

Someone wanted to buy a boat and some crack i guess asap

"Hard as shit". :( If your shit is hard, something is very *wrong* .

about the lighting thing where it always looks like the midday sun is out, i completely agree with how it ruins the atmosphere. for the longest time, i was stumped on how the manga manages to look overall more.. *chilling* than the anime, and then i realized that the lighting plays a large part. in the manga, shading is used masterfully to make certain scenes send shivers down one's spine, but in the anime, things just seem a little less... *intense* when there isn't the intense atmosphere, created by intense lighting. i think i found the first s4 arc way more creepy in the manga and i always felt like more was at stake, rather than in the anime. i understand that mha is generally a colourful show and on the surface, its themes would come off pretty bubbly, but the charm of the manga (that appealed to ME most, that is) is that despite the use of no colour whatsoever, it can still manage to pull off both bubbly and fun and creepy and deadly. anyways, these are just my thoughts on the matter of atmosphere and how it affects the viewing experience, nothing too big. i just feel like the atmosphere plays a large part in how i enjoy anime - i sometimes refuse to watch certain things at a certain time just to get the right atmosphere (i.e. watched the first season of demon slayer as the sun was going down and late into the night with al the lights off, which made it a memorable experience because the atmosphere made the night fight scenes seem so.. scary, i'd say?). the thing with mha is, no matter how much i try to set the right atmosphere from the outside, there's only so much i can do to give myself the thrilling feeling that *something* is at stake. i do hope this changes during the war arc, because although the battle took place in the daytime, it was absolutely gruesome.

@Knick3607

2 жыл бұрын

To me, the reason why the atmosphere is so dark in the manga is because it's completely black and white, its got nothing to do with shading (Although it's definitely a factor).

@whyulookatmeh9404

2 жыл бұрын

@@Knick3607 you've got a point there, the characters are pretty colourful so their colour palettes don't really go with a darker atmosphere, as opposed to the black and white of the manga

They tucked up S5 to promote their movie.

When they switched arcs I was fine but what got me a little sad is that they showed the LOV and in the MVA a lot of things happened to them but the weight won't be too emotional as we know they r still going to be fine

I love my hero academia but I honestly hate season 4-5 and if they do another movie then im guaranteed to hate the next one unfortunately since I love the manga.

Bro overhaul theme is so goddamn fire...I'm butthurt it was hardly ever used

In adaptation vs recreation I should note: It's possible to adapt material with plenty of room for inclusions and changes without taking the opportunity to literally write your own show with the same names.

2:20 it does when the adaptation deviates completely from the original medium.

Idk man, I think this is a little more detail obsessed than what’s appropriate for the average viewer. The arc switch we’re going through right now is interesting to see how it ends up comparing once it’s all done, but I think the average standard of this anime is higher than you suggest it is.

@KianOntong13

3 жыл бұрын

It's not about the standard of an the Anime only. It's a good anime. It's about the standard of how well it adapted the source material specifically.

@dynamixstorm1436

3 жыл бұрын

Yeah I agree with you and I am gonna be honest when I binged the anime I didn't care about music placement or if the faces look weird I had a great time watching it and to me that's what matters.

@deadshot1995

3 жыл бұрын

I don’t share many of the problems with the anime brought up in this vid. But the MVA switch has really messed up the pacing of S5 imo. Hori’s formula is to follow a high intensity arc with a more relaxed breather arc. In this season we get two breather arcs back to back, and the intense arc gets spoiled.

@ADHDkid321

3 жыл бұрын

@@deadshot1995 is the endeavor agency arc supposed to he a breather? Lol

@wesuckatgames9549

3 жыл бұрын

@@ADHDkid321 well, yeah. there's not really anything at risk. it's basically just another training arc

Every time somebody bags on season 5s animation quality I feel like I'm living in a bizarro other world. The animation itself has been GREAT. Honestly way better than it has been for the last couple seasons. We havent gotten any crazy animation sequences yet (mostly because there hasn't been anything that calls for it just yet... but we're getting there) BUT in general it's all been consistently pretty good, even during the smaller moments which previous seasons had completely phoned it in for. As for everything else... the pacing is really different. I really dont like the fact that they swapped mva and Endeavor agency, but my roommate is watching rn and he still loves it so maybe this is just a result of being a manga reader? I will say the pacing of joint training was TERRIBLE who did that? Who tf okayed some of that shit goddamn. Momos fight was especially egregious. We could have wrapped up that arc in way less time and given more time to mva (still not sure if we need it. It's a lot of action). And the decision to put filler in at this point of the series? I mean the episode wasnt terrible but cmon. Oh and the openings have been boring lol.

@arreilaa4872

3 жыл бұрын

We have gotten crazy animation though, iida’s recipro turbo

@ADHDkid321

3 жыл бұрын

@@arreilaa4872 Oh yeah that's what I mean! Season 5 has been relatively consistently giving us pretty awesome moments like that (though that's definitely the best) and I feel like the season just isnt getting enough credit because we havent gotten a mind blower like overhaul vs deku yet (and I have literally no doubts that its coming in the final parts of the season)

@motor4X4kombat

3 жыл бұрын

they say its bad because is not as good as demon slayer, or jujutsu kaisen. Kinda when people start shitting on the MCU look because it didn't look as pretty as the DCEU. But as we all know style dosn't equal quality, demon slayer is still a mid manga that ufotable make it look like a top tier one, and jujutsu kaisen for now is good but not THAT amazing yet like most people are claiming since we din't get to the shibuya arc yet, and if one punch man and promise neverland taught me something is that you should NEVER hype a series for the first season only. And since theres a shit ton of problems with mappa right now im in fear for the future of JJK.

@underscore2736

3 жыл бұрын

The animation for season 5 is fine. Not great, not awful, just fine. It's perfectly serviceable 80% of the time, and that's it. Sure there are Sakuga moments like Denki vs Bigfoot guy, or a more notable case being Lida vs Softening guy, but outside of these specific scenes and highlights, I wouldn't call S5 the best in terms of animation quality.

@ADHDkid321

3 жыл бұрын

@@underscore2736 If you wanna call it fine, that makes sense. It's just CONSISTENTLY better than seasons 4 and 3, but those seasons have had drop-off moments

I hadn't considered how the lighting affects the overall atmosphere of the anime until this video and I'm really grateful for that new perspective. It IS a shame certain arcs or scenes weren't given more--let's say 'daring' for lack of a better word--lighting choices to best capitalize on the strength of the writing and characters in those scenes. As you've said, MHA is still a damn good series, but becoming aware of things like this, if nothing else, gives me food for thought on what it could have been. It does make me a bit sad but at the same time, it increases the love and respect I have for the manga. TLDR: Thanks for pointing stuff out. Great video as always!

Hello i have suscribe and Like

My question is can they even fully animate Shigarki's backstory without the age rating going up or are they gonna beat around the bush like ohHhHh spooky blood puddle

It’s slow and the flashbacks make the progression annoying sometimes. But I still enjoy the anime

I am almost certain that the "Blotch Nature textures" were created using the Difference Clouds filter on Photoshop as repeating that filter a few times looks almost exactly like that.

The attitude with which you went about this whole video is a real highlight ngl

I got goosebumps when Deku us All for one ost, during Deku vs overhaul

My only 2 critic is 1) the atmosphere of the anime, colors, their color palette, like the overhaul arc,,, c'mon,, I just really hope they do justice of MVA, though, I can't argue much cuz MVA took place in daylight but I'm talking about them flashbacks, especially Tomura 2) how they kinda "waste" some banger ost's like how Oceaniz mentioned, BONES somehow didn't use the Katsuki vs Izuku ost to their fight (for the pacing) but used it when the Big Three was walking. (though, they used it with Deku when he first saw Nine in Heroes Rising) But apart from that, I love it! I have high hopes, looking back at all the fights they've animated ^ ^

Ocean - Aoyama's theme, while absolutely a banger, is a remix (ish) of "Just Another Hero" which is Endeavor's theme. The music is so good, I wish they were better with it. Just Another Hero is also potentially the best song in the series (not named "You Say Run", obv.)

So this is why the music felt so weird to me. It's great music used stupidly. Why didn't I think of this? Anyhow, great observation! And on the topic of faces: I hate Dabi's face in the anime. Everyone else felt kinda ok, but Dabi looks so weird, his face is elongated too much and it lost all of its roundness, I would say. Which is weird, because almost everyone else with a round-ish face still has that quality, like Deku, Mina, Shoto etc.

Bones puts so much effort into the movies. Then you look at season 3-4 and you’re like “WHAT DID YOU DO?!”

@FlappoTheSilentScientist

3 жыл бұрын

I feel that Season 3 can be forgiven, since it was the same team doing the movie and the show at the same time. Season 4 however, was delayed to give the new team more time to work, and we all know how that turned out

I don’t exactly understand why the quality of animation goes from good to downright shit. Demon Slayer constantly has amazing animation and hardly ever has lackluster scenes where the main characters are like blurs without any detail.

@Nicu-vy3gm

2 жыл бұрын

Imagine if ufotable animeted my hero season 6

MVA Arc in the manga is so much better