What did you think of the image of Sagittarius A*?

@dziczku

2 жыл бұрын

I'm waiting for the Webb's photo shoot ;)

@fizzy1922

2 жыл бұрын

Interesting. It looks like there are 3 bright spots around the black hole

@MaryAnnNytowl

2 жыл бұрын

It was astoundingly beautiful, and it's so cool how the image was produced, too!

@MaryAnnNytowl

2 жыл бұрын

@@dziczku the three videos I watched on it, from Veritasium, Dr. Becky, and Anton, explained pretty well why that won't help much. There's basically too much noise between here and there, since we'll be looking through the thickness of the Galactic disc. _~shrug~_

@danrazART

2 жыл бұрын

We need the time-lapse animated version.

It is such an honor that Lord Charles Nice read my name on StarTalk and that Neil and Brian discussed my question. Thank you so much for entertaining my inquiry! 🙏 I love Startalk, Lord Nice, Neil and Brian. These three men are among my favorite in "entertainment." Much love for all of you! Keep doing what you're doing!

@classyswag0503

2 жыл бұрын

@@RyanThomas. Of course we can't forget Gary!!

@dunderwood4444

2 жыл бұрын

@@classyswag0503 Gary O makes the perfect trio Dr. Tyson, Lord Nice and Gary O

@StarTalk

2 жыл бұрын

This comment made us smile :) it was our honor to feature your question. Keep Looking Up!

@sensualgoat3718

2 жыл бұрын

@@StarTalk if the earth was a sphere with a radius of 3959 then every distance to the horizon can be no more than 1.22 x square root of the observers height in feet as claimed by Earth curve calculators online (pick any). The black swan argument is described as any view of the horizon beyond the geometric limitations of a sphere r3959. there are many examples of the horizon FAR beyond the limitations of a sphere r3959 - evidence to back my claim search YT - taboo conspiracy Canadian black swan. The horizon isn't Earth curve and you know it.

@sensualgoat3718

2 жыл бұрын

pal, if the earth was a sphere with a radius of 3959 then every distance to the horizon can be no more than 1.22 x square root of the observers height in feet as claimed by Earth curve calculators online (pick any). The black swan argument is described as any view of the horizon beyond the geometric limitations of a sphere r3959. there are many examples of the horizon FAR beyond the limitations of a sphere r3959 - evidence to back my claim search YT - Taboo conspiracy - Black swan Canada. peace.

These two men have given me so much. We're lucky to have people like this.

@StarTalk

2 жыл бұрын

And we’re lucky to have fans like you!

@walterfristoe4643

10 ай бұрын

If they didn't exist we'd have to invent them! 🥸

@mikehoncho2640

8 ай бұрын

​@@walterfristoe4643Well if you look at it that way... We would've never guessed or questioned their existance if they never existed (In this universe right now).

@lildeanc

3 ай бұрын

Omg there is a ridiculous amount of adverts on this, and the guy in the middle aswel I don’t know how much longer I can listen …

After all them talks with Neil and his guests, Chuck should have got an honorary PhD in physics.

@TrickOrRetreat

2 жыл бұрын

Valid point 🤗

@turntablesrockmyworld9315

Жыл бұрын

@@HopDavid haha yes!Math is overrated when you can describe in a few simple sentences.

@thomascattington1660

Жыл бұрын

@@HopDavid troll says what?

@Asshole88

Ай бұрын

​@@HopDavidhe said honorary PhD, not a recognised one. While trying to sound smart, you actually appeared silly here.

Honestly one of the best episodes in recent memory

@reasonerenlightened2456

Жыл бұрын

But still , i did not hear the answer to the question. is quarks microscope possible?

@MartsEntertainment

Жыл бұрын

Recent memory is entirely subjective. At any moment your memory can shift, change allow or disallow for new inquiry and content.

@LordFindecano

3 ай бұрын

@@MartsEntertainmentyah… that’s how memory works. Are you typically prone to contrived comments?

Thanks! Thank you neil. You got me into science and space and really opened my eyes about the world we live in. I love the education you provide to us all. Thank you so much.

@souptikb7

Жыл бұрын

This is pretty cool new features in comments!

@mandyronald8187

Жыл бұрын

Absolute feature on KZread

@TheXxxwolfman

Жыл бұрын

And they didn't even give a thumbs up to his comment. Come on StarTalk! 💀

@oldsoul1349

Жыл бұрын

He saved you from school 🤣

@Onestringpuppet

Жыл бұрын

You didn't get a thankyou for 50! Wow

I think we all agree with the lady who said ,*never stop this podcast* so please never stop Thank you for making me fall in love with the universe

@StarTalk

2 жыл бұрын

It was our pleasure!

@reasonerenlightened2456

Жыл бұрын

​@@StarTalk But still , I did not hear the answer to the question, is quarks microscope possible?

@letitsnow8518

Жыл бұрын

@@reasonerenlightened2456 yes, Neil and Chuck digress too much, and time is too short

Brian should do his show at the sphere in Las Vegas. I can only imagine how epic it would be.

@tylercarrell

3 ай бұрын

If he did i’d book a flight for sure

Does anyone else enjoy watching Chuck learn on the show as much as I do? Thank you, Lord Nice, for being a part of this show.

I wish that Neil & Brian were tasked to provide a full curriculum on Science for the UK & US until from ages 5-16. Great communicators, engaging, inspirational. That's in addition to teaming up with Chuck on a monthly basis to do more of this.

@jammyd7927

Жыл бұрын

Chucks input would add extra fun to experiments

🌟 We just saw the FIRST EVER image of Sagittarius A* - the supermassive black hole at the center of our galaxy - a few hours ago! How EXCITING is that?! 🥳 . . . for everyone else obviously . . . I mean, for me the best thing that happened today is this video. Thank you guys for taking from your time to share with us. It is greatly appreciated. 🙂 Lots of love.❤️

@StarTalk

2 жыл бұрын

Thank you for taking the time to share the love ❤️ means a lot!

@TrickOrRetreat

2 жыл бұрын

Still processing 🤔 this is big deal. Did we just get some more information on gravity Wave's 🌊 we probably need to investigate further. More startalks coming up 🥰

It is finally happening!! Brian and Neil...full episode...it's 1:40 AM in India and my night just got a little longer. Please don't let this episode stop. Just keep talking you two...please.

@Shivam.evolved

2 жыл бұрын

Agreed.

@michaelegan6037

7 ай бұрын

@@RyanThomas. Do you believe all this crap I saw a big fly you would belive

Big fan of Brian here, got to a learn a lot from two of his old shows - The wonders of the solar system and wonders of universe. The way he explained things such as entropy, formation of different metals in a dying star and how we are all made up of star is simply outstanding. he is a gem just like Attenborough.

Two of my favorite physicists alive today, and on one show, how cool is that! love this one!

@johnliljeborg5363

2 жыл бұрын

I was about to say the same 😃

@masonkeener4778

2 жыл бұрын

They’ve been together a few times we need a lot more of Brian fox over here in America

@KC.801

2 жыл бұрын

Also add brain Greene

@rolando2395

2 жыл бұрын

Paul mecurio and send chuck kick some rocks, maybe we can find a place at a retirement home... you know, because of his lame dad jokes

@KC.801

2 жыл бұрын

@@rolando2395 bruh what chuck is funny your just hatin

I would have watch the whole thing if it was even 3 hours. The best episode with most updated theories and answers. Loved it.

My father was a fan of yours, Brian. I would have loved to have taken him to one of your talks when you come to Western Australia, but he passed a few years ago. I'm sure he's enjoying riding the cosmic waves now

@darrengreenacre1142

Жыл бұрын

Your dad was born as a star, which will never change.

I'm going to go see Brian's show next week; I'm looking forward to it! It seems like a lot of fun.

@AlexYoull

2 жыл бұрын

Enjoy, he's absolutely brilliant.

@orale_

7 ай бұрын

How you learn something

Imagine a podcast with Neil, Brian, Mitchio kaku and Carl Sagan.

We love Brian and Neil, they're both rock stars to us ❤️

@tunjilegba

11 ай бұрын

Rock Star has a different meaning in my mind now 💫

@retired5218

9 ай бұрын

​@@tunjilegba And Brian was a real rock star earlier in life. Now he's a rock star in another field.

I love how casually Brian talks about Black Holes blocking the view of a powerful enough microscope. It seems like there is some kind of limit to what we can see and Black Holes appear whenever we pass that limit

@ubercoo

2 жыл бұрын

It was the x-rays and electrons are the same that got me.

@fixxa6455

Жыл бұрын

The explanation about quantum physics and things in space are more connected/ entangled then we might expect

@BAbhijeet

Жыл бұрын

Micro scope ??did u mean to say telescope??

@WilliamReginaldLucas

Жыл бұрын

@@BAbhijeet no he says it happens if you try and see the smallest of the small in a microscope (put simply)

@stoneysdead689

6 ай бұрын

@@WilliamReginaldLucas I think both of you are missing the point- doesn't matter if it's a microscope or telescope or if there's no scope of any kind- he's saying that if you dump enough energy into a small enough space- because we know mass and energy are the same thing in different forms- you create a black hole- period. The fact that you did so trying to use a microscope- really doesn't matter.

There is a wonderful section of the book, "The 3 body problem" that imagines unfolding a subatomic particle. It starts with 1 dimension, then 2, then 3, and continues up to the 8th dimension. At the 8th dimension the particle is as large as our entire universe, but beyond that the imagination of even the wisest could not comprehend. My mind exploded. It was wonderful.

Your cosmic queries videos are so fun to listen too! The way that you guys make science so interesting, and the ways that Neil simplifies things in ways that we can understand is amazing.

@StarTalk

2 жыл бұрын

We’re so happy to hear that!

My two favorite big thinkers, and an entertainment professional that I can respect and admire for their dedication made for a great episode. Thanks guys!

Neil, i think you're brilliant. I discovered you on here a few years ago. You're right about Brian dominating this side of the pond! But thats because his knowledge is unparalleled... the way he plucks these complex theories out of his head to perfectly answer questions that initially sounded so complicated 🤯 Explaining these complex theories and then way he can he simplify them for us commoners to understand, is why we love him so much in the UK. We need to see you on our screens more though. Loved listening to this, and will definitely listen to more episodes. Keep educating! 👊🏻

Brian and Neil have given me so much and change my life thank you both never stop educating us

Two of the greatest scientist coming together, it’s so great to me to see these two coming together

Love it when these two are together!

@paul4280

2 жыл бұрын

I know!! Neil and Chuck are the best!!!!

@homosapien5684

2 жыл бұрын

@@paul4280 yeah they are great... but i kinda meant brian and neil

@njones420

2 жыл бұрын

If you haven’t listened to “infinite monkey cage” you should… Neil has joined on a few episodes of that too

My most favourite two science communicators ❤❤

@OiOiSillyBoi

8 ай бұрын

Brian isn’t just a science communicator, he’s actually made significant contributions to science on the international stage - such as through CERN and the ATLAS experiment. Certainly adds to Neil’s inferiority complex in some aspects of this talk. Don’t get me wrong, Neil is intelligent and both focus on different areas of science as a speciality; but Brian is leaps and bounds ahead of Neil overall.

@hasithaudalagama3837

8 ай бұрын

@@OiOiSillyBoi yeah I agree.

They are always fun to watch and listening, and this one was extremely interesting

@StarTalk

2 жыл бұрын

So glad this one piqued your interest!

I love this duo! and of course Chuck is the cherry on top putting that witty humor I love it

@timhyatt9185

2 жыл бұрын

chuck is "everyman" that keeps all us none phd physicists engaged and entertained... :) thanks for being there Chuck!! do not EVER think you are not appreciated!

You could have talked about the spooky action at a distance + wormholes theory for MUCH longer. I loved everything you guys talked about but most of it, like time travel, has been talked about before, that was genuinely new to me and deeply fascinating.

@mathiaspierce9204

5 ай бұрын

Quarks be quarks yo

@mathiaspierce9204

5 ай бұрын

Or is that their Charm ;)

On entanglement; when Chuck said you lost me at 1 over root squared, I actually for the first time was able to visualize math as form!! Thank you.

Neil and Brian, pure gold! And Chuck too..❤❤

I’m so bummed I had to miss the Philly show. I hope Brian goes on tour again. You too Neil! Tbh I wish there was a Convention with all types of science personalities like Neil, Brian, Bill, Mayim, Michio, etc. I’d break my neck for that 😂

Yet another fantastic & thought provoking discussion with Neil, Brian & Chuck! Now I would really love seeing Brian's "Horizons" show. 👍👍😉😉

@StarTalk

2 жыл бұрын

You absolutely should, you won’t regret it!

We are lucky to have the two Prof in the generation

I love this! It's refreshing to be able to experience science with this very unique feel.

Love this episode, probably my favourite so far! Looking forward to more!

We're lucky to have these people in our universe.

@shellsel

15 күн бұрын

💯

Fascinating video as always. On the topic of inflation-did that occur at speeds exceeding the speed of light in vacuum, according to the theory? Love the quantum entanglement explanation. This is also a good video to watch if you are a fan of Doctor Who, Star Wars, the MCU, Interstellar and other science fiction films and series. Real science can inspire creativity and vice versa.

Such an entertaining session! Thanks a multiverse guys.

The two that brought science to popular culture 🙌🏽

This legit made my entire day. Thank God for people like this.

Thanks for mentioning Austin as part of Brian's tour. Not gonna miss it!!⭐☄🚀

chuck is not a scientist but got the mind of a scientist with the questions he raises

@shellsel

15 күн бұрын

I know right?

Probably the best trio on this show :) love them.

Brian is awesome btw for those who don't know of him, catch the tour if you get the chance!

@abowden5079

7 ай бұрын

Is there a torrent to dl a video of the tour show?

Went to the Edmonton show/lecture and it was great. Loved the comment to "why is the black hole image blurry?" Cant wait to see what comes from black hole research

This was a fantastic interview!! Thanks Neil and Brian!

I love Brian! I wish I was able to see his show! It sounds amazing!

I was at Brians first presentation on the north side of Chicago and spoke to him briefly as he got out from his livery SUV on Tuesday. It was fantastic although I had one complaint, after the intermission the second half of the presentation was far too short cause he left us all wanting for more. Please in the future make the knowledge you shared with us at least 5 hours or more cause your feeding hungry minds and we all would like to have fat heads😁🤣😋!!!

Saw Brian twice live (one recently) and will be seeing Neil for the 6th? time in September. Please bring Chuck to Boston!

The best part is how much fun everyone has, nobody else can make such mind blowing unfathomable topics so funny and entertaining

The best question in this video was that someone asked about how do you measure these quarks or the strings?

Nothing better than science and laughs. Keep it up guys

@sensualgoat3718

2 жыл бұрын

science? what was the natural phenomena? what was the independent variable that was isolated and manipulated? hhmm..

The audio is usually very low on your podcasts here on YT. Maybe render the video with a bit hotter audio. Great episode!

I love the way that Neal and chuck can balance each other out in these discussions

Such wonderful geekiness 😍

Super excited for Brian’s Calgary show in a few weeks!

This was a great podcast, such an interesting concept that now the entangled particles are being considered as connected by a tiny worm holes, that makes a lot more sense than trying to use counter intuition to imagine a non existent connection.

I think travelling back in time is impossible, you can go back, but it won't be to your version of the past, it will split off the same way as any choice you make going forward. So you go back, but you're not really travelling back in time as you move yourself to a new dimension due to a choice and a break in the space time.

I’m from Manchester, UK, the same city Brian is from 😊 Just wanted to let you guys know, both he and David Attenborough aren’t considered God like figures here, they’re just really nice, humble people, who make science accessible for the everyday person. We just consider them as dear family members in our country :) I watch Star Talk nearly everyday, it was really lovely seeing Brain on here too. We’re blessed to have such amazing minds like you guys Keep doing your amazing work X

Is there a place online where I could get tickets for Brian’s show in Los Angeles or Texas??!! Or Dr. Tyson? Thanking you in advance!

The best part of the video is that all the 3 guys are using "wired earphones" which are always better at capturing audio due to the low hanging mic than the wireless earpods and what not. Hopefully, more video interviews use them.

Neil tyson let me dream to be astrophysicist , thanks man I love you

My two favorite people to learn from 👍

@GreggyAck

2 жыл бұрын

Add Carl Sagan and you've got the top 3 educators ever for me.

please please please do a super extended episode with brian! 48 minutes doesn’t do him any justice. could listen to him for hours

THIS literally brought a smile to my face

The 2 geniuses together !!!! This is crazyyyyyy !!!!!

19:51 damn chuck!!! That was an absolute awesome question and point in and of itself.... ...not to discredit you for not being a degree achieved academic scientist....but i applaud you in the very specific subject you just brought up....well done sir...💯

@kushalgokhale9114

2 жыл бұрын

exactly. i thought the same. it was a brilliant question asked by chuck.

@barbaralachance5836

2 жыл бұрын

Chuck is really smart and he contributes to this show with way more than humour 😊

@ZenRyoku

2 жыл бұрын

@@kushalgokhale9114 its like....I luv Chuck...💯 he is definitely a little wacky because he is a comedian after all...but in no way did I want to demean Chuck at all...but you gotta consider you have 2 Professors of Astrophysics and true scientists to the core...thats a hard crowd to hang with intellectually no matter who you are...so my thoughts were DAMN!!! NOW THAT'S IMPRESSIVE...💯

@barbaralachance5836

2 жыл бұрын

@@ZenRyoku definitely ❤️

Love these minds and so excited to learn .

Someone needs to tell Chuck that when he joked about the speed of light being a limit programmed into a simulated universe, he was very close to realising that everything moves through space-time at the 'speed' of light (not really a speed given that it's a rate of change of both distance and time, as opposed to just distance, but 'speed' is my best attempt at a description) this arises beautifully out of rearranging the Gamma equation (for time dilation) so that (1/gamma)^2= 1 - (v/c)^2 rearranged again gives us (1/gamma)^2 + (v/c)^2 = 1 the equation of a unit circle, (the most beautiful equation in my opinion) is x^2 + y^2 = radius^2 our movement through time and space must always sum to 1 (the radius). for slow objects, we travel almost exclusively through time, and very little through space. Light on the other hand travels at the fastest speed (unit 1), and thus experiences no time, which fans of physics will know.

My two heroes together

I've used the analogy of 2d creatures living on an emensely large expanding balloon, as a wya to explain how we can see space expanding but not find a "center" of that expansion The extension of the analogy is that our universe is "expanding" in 4dimensions, but we being 3d beings, do not have the ability to percieve where that expansion center is; as it is "right angles" to everything else... Could this fit with the idea that space-time is an emergent property of "higher dimensional" expansions???

@Sammasambuddha

2 жыл бұрын

Holographic principle

Fabulous episode! Neil it would be a brilliant meeting of the minds to have as a guest, globally recognized leader in discussion on Consciousness, Tony Nader, MD, PhD. He takes the discussion on consciousness full circle and shows that everything is consciousness. Check out his conversations with Kastrup, Hoffman, Goldstein, Kuhn

Brian is actually so funny!! Amazing episode guys! I wish he came to the middle East with his tour ❤️

“With a central black hole” 😂 Best gag yet on star talk!!

@edwardbowers5509

Жыл бұрын

Ever wonder why there is a planet called Uranus. 🤣

I think Brian discovered the fountain of youth, he does not look 54.

@geraltdelautreriv

11 күн бұрын

He looks 35 that's insane lmao

I just watched The Planets a few weeks ago, but didn’t know his name. Thank you StarTalk!

I have an infection in my lower left jaw I found out a few days ago . Today I have to get it taken care of and I have been in the worst mindset and just really lowreally low. Being a avid student of all physics asteo and particle along with quantum. This episode had made my nerves very happy and relaxedrelaxed. I cannot thank you enough

The language would actually not be gibberish, any more than English or any other tongue is gibberish. The word you’re looking for is Asemic, that which lacks context or intention. Perhaps evolution has created the astonishing randomness that lies before our eyes is so stupendous, why would spoken language even be a necessity in some of these inflationary multiverses.

Out of the million, billion, quadrillion snowflakes to ever fall, how can we really be sure there haven't been duplicates? I just doubt that every snowflake is unique, always.

@tylercarrell

3 ай бұрын

I have a hard time believing someone went out of their way to put enough snowflakes under a microscope to claim they’re all unique in the first place

Conversation between some of my favourite people. Awesome.

I use the pair of socks analogy for quantum entanglement. Take out a pair of socks from your drawer. Both of them can be either left or right sock. But when you put one sock on your left foot, the other one becomes your right sock instantaneously. So take out the same pair again, but separate them one million light years away from each other. Again, both of them can be either left and right sock until you put one sock on your left foot -> again, the other one becomes your right sock instantaneously regardless of the one million light year distance.

@JoniKukkola

2 жыл бұрын

Also the answer to 'the mystery of a missing sock' is that they're just sucked in by a black hole. That's why you never find the missing pair :).

Why do we have a 15 years old boy as a profesor of particles. Lol 😅 jokes aside I'm glad to see young people invested in real science.

Am I the only one that thinks Brian is getting really annoyed with Neil constantly interrupting and cutting him off mid sentence. I'm getting annoyed and he's not even doing it to me. Please for the love of God LET THE MAN FINISH A SENTENCE! This guy has the patience of a Saint. I would've said something after the 3rd time.

@Upthemightytigers

17 күн бұрын

I got nothing but Neil being condescending the whole time

@sorryidgaf.6043

16 күн бұрын

Can you weirdos shutup and stop crying? You both sound like little girls 😂

Love the show, love the interactions between the people on the show. Always amazed how much Charles Liu aka the Geek in Chief knows about comics

My 2 peeps Neil and Brian! Hard to find a better duo than these 2

Brian has a very soothing voice.

NEVER STOP THIS PODCAST!

Love that Brian is a Connolly fan-love that man ❤

Brian is just great. The wormholes being responsible for space-time and physical limit to our way of probing ever smaller things was a pleasant novelty thank you. So I guess we won't have a Planck microscope anytime soon :)

I'm so excited! I'm seeing Brian in 2 days in SLC for my bday!

What I absolutely love is that Neil is so genuinely open to laughing and enjoying. I had planned on calling Mr. Tyson something much more respectful.

In Canada, Neil and Brian have equal notoriety. Excellent balance!

This was great. I even understood some of it.

Always love the space talks, more of these please!!!!

@sensualgoat3718

2 жыл бұрын

If the earth was a sphere with a radius of 3959 then every distance to the horizon can be no more than 1.22 x square root of the observers height in feet as claimed by Earth curve calculators online (pick any). The black swan argument is described as any view of the horizon beyond the geometric limitations of a sphere r3959. there are many examples of the horizon FAR beyond the limitations of a sphere r3959 - evidence to back my claim search YT - Taboo conspiracy - black swan Canada. Peace.

I love Brian. He is always so interesting, and has such a lovely speaking voice.

I want to learn more about the theory on inflatory universe. I am gonna research on it. btw, I love this channel❤. Keet it going

Mind blown!! Great episode!