An important part of an important subject. Thanks very much sir !

thank u for doing this Dr. Taimur

U r great sir i listen all your lecture God bless u

ماشاءاللہ بہت زبردست معلومات فراہم کی ہیں آپ نے۔ براہِ مہربانی مزید تاریخ کے ان حقائق سے ہمیں آگاہ کرتے رہیں۔ شکریہ ۔

Love from Bangladesh 🇧🇩❤

Learning so much from you sir.

بے شک میں نے آج بہت کھچ سیکھا ۔

Thank you so much Sir for providing us with the valueable content 🎉

Allah Pak aap k kaam mein barkat day... murshad

💯 Proud Mu'tazili Al-Hamd-u-Lillah ❤

awsome comrade keep it up ....

بڑا مزہ آیا محبوب امید قوی ھے کہ معلومات سے سیر کرتے رھین گے میری کچھی پھیکی ادرو کو درگذر کرین دوست

Is topic ko itni detail main kisi ne nai cover kara. Jazakallah khair

عائشہ عنھا

Thank you so much

অসাধারণ তথ্য সমৃদ্ধ বর্ণনা স্যার। আপনার কথা শোনার জন্য অপেক্ষায় থাকি। ❤🇧🇩

This content is actually very good.

Mza agya sir g

We are blessed to have a person like you in Pakistan. I don't agree with all of your point of views but the good thing is that you explain all the things in a very eloquent and easy manner. This series was much needed as regarding these things, we get the biased knowledge and opinion about it if you ask it from any respective sect...

@onedirectionlover08

Ай бұрын

By the way, he is not giving his views, he is putting forward political history, views are by the people watching and learning through this discourse.

Earnestly wait for your video

❤❤❤ can wait ... for next blog taimur bahi

love the series sir...

Beautiful

Great work: waiting for next sir❤

Laal Sb Zindabaad Keep nurturing us..never let it go, thanks again

I appreciate how easily you dispense the knowledge. Also im surprised of your ability to explain complex concepts ans historical events so easily that a Jahil like me can also benefit from it. Gratefulness and appreciation 🎉

Was eagerly waiting for this.

Boht shukriya for great information

Good work

wow sir finally long awaited episode uploaded.

MASHA ALLAH great work dr. sb.

Sallam sir aj apki video sb se pehly mene dekhy😊 ha bohot a6a conclusion sir great respect ❤❤❤

Sir bhrreen best and very informative video waiting for next time

Waiting for more such videos. This will make easy for us to understand Muslim philosophy.

Fascinating

Sir please pronounce Hazrat Ayesha R.A Anha instaed anho coz anho is used with males and anha with females. BTW sensational approach towards history ❤ I learned a lot from your lectures on philosophy and history. Stay blessed❤

Thank God Dr Timur is fast coming out of this sensitive phase of great Arabian History

Taimur sb apki videos se hum ne bohot kuch seekha hy aur apko follow karte han, female sahabia ya ummahat ul mominin yani hazrat ayesha ke name ke saath anhaa lagaya karen with alif and male sahabas ke saath anho yani vow lagaya karen. Thanks a lot for your videos and lectures . We're grateful sir

You might have done too much hard work on this topic of mu'tazilah.. it is a big academic and researched work,,,,, no doubt. May Allah bless upon you.

i agree with khwarij point of view of Khilafah. That any upright Muslim can be Khilafah of Muslims.(pious, knowledge of fiqah, knowledge of military)

@user-xe1lx1pg9q

Ай бұрын

It seems History is proving khawariji point of view to be the actual correct one

@user-xe1lx1pg9q

Ай бұрын

It seems history is proving khawariji point of view to be actually correct

Dear Taimur, I give you 💯 not for what is said but to create an amazing interest in Islamic political history. 😊 if topic would have been simply, Islamic school of thoughts this may not have attracted many

Sir females ko jung ki permission nii hy to phir Hazrat Ayesha r.a ny ya jung ki... Kindly iss prr roshni daalyn

Sir we wait for your episodes like a episode of our favorite drama. ❤❤❤

Sir g sunay begirat he like ker diya😁

Love your efforts and Muhammad Mirza Ali engineer ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

I call upon you directly to respond to this.in "after the prophet" book written by Lesley Hazelton It says about in the battle of siffin it was not HAZRAT ALI RA who came to an agreement with himself rather the Kwarijites who told Ali Ra to to come to agreement with Muyaawiya It would be great if you give some sort of reference or proof about the different narration you told in your video. Also some proof or reference about Kwarijites later development to become ibadi

Good approach. I hope you'll explain other philosophies with the same approach.

Thanks a lot❤

Very impressive

Sir you are the diamond 💎

Super

Vedio duration should be minimum one hour.

Great series , hope to add more information before reaching to Mutazlai. It's like saying " closing the history in a bottle "

well done

love you💌💌

02:45 Collective Property Vs Individual Property

Love 😍 you Sir ji Laal 🚩

دونوں طرف سے شہید ہونے 😂

Salaam. Sir how can I contact you. I need some guideline regarding phd in political science. I am from Karachi

Present Sir

Imam Ali and his loyal companions were against the arbitration offer by Muawyyia because they knew that it was a clever tactic by the son of Abu Sufyan to avoid the apparent defeat. But khwarijites refused to fight,as a result son of Abu sufyan survived and hence that was the when Islam started to decline…

Sirji please make a Video on IBN RUSHD and he's secularism 🤝🙏❤

*کیا ہم یہ مطلب اخذ کر سکتے کہ خاتم الأنبیاء ﷺ کی بدولت جب کُھلا مالِ غنیمت آیا تو صحابہ آپس میں ٹکر و ٹکری ہو گئے؟*

@Taimur_Laal

Ай бұрын

Sadly.

very very intelligent person

9:37 Hazrat Ali also wanted to continue the war with Damascus forces as he was winning the war but majority of his forces were from kufah, whose people tried to stop him from further confrontation. Jazak Allah 9:37

you're actually good

Bhtreen!! Sir .. Magr sir kiya Murjiyaaa kharjiyoo ki hi development nhi zara naram aqiad k sth?

Dr.Sahib May I request to record a series on All Shai sects

Mr. Rahman... Give reference to books that prove your videos authentic and also people can get a way of reading....

@Taimur_Laal

Ай бұрын

Good suggestion.

Sir❤

We also believe that politcal leadership of a community should not be restricted to a particular tribe or clan. So, have we same thoughts as Khwarij?

❤❤❤

Thanks for your wonderful contribution to education. May I suggest just one correction here: “Anhu” is for male and female”AnhA” is for female. So, Hazrat Ayesha will be Razi Allah Taala AnhA, not AnhU.

❤

Please convert your lectures in book form. It will help us to understand in more clarity than lectures.

@waqarahmad1833

Ай бұрын

He is himself quoting from Books of others. On this topic please refer to خلافت و ملوکیت

@mahalam2391

Ай бұрын

@@waqarahmad1833 It seems you have not gone through the mentioned book written by Maulana Maududi. Lecture was based on information collected from different books in speaker words.

@waqarahmad1833

Ай бұрын

@@mahalam2391 then what will be the purpose of another book from a lecture which already is a reference from some books? Even the information he is sharing is incomplete and such matter is the one نیم حکیم خطرہ جان

@mahalam2391

Ай бұрын

@@waqarahmad1833 from new book. We will get reference of different books. Also all details will be in written form . I can re read the books later on. Further any body after some times can go through the details regarding different groups of that time. I hope it is clear now.

@mahalam2391

Ай бұрын

@@waqarahmad1833 to my mind reading book is more useful than listening lectures.

Agar dakha jaey TU khawarji point of view was modern at that time,aur apni jaga Sahi BHI thaa.

Qaramatein ke bare me btaye..ye log to kafi advanced the...socialism democracy ko follow karte the .

معذرت کے ساتھ ڈاکٹر صاحب ، ثالثی کی پیشکش حضرت علی نے نہیں بلکہ حضرت معاویہ کے لوگوں نے کی تھی۔

@Taimur_Laal

Ай бұрын

Yes of course. But many in Hazrat Ali’s troops wanted him to go into arbitration.

These numbers are exaggerated and that's an understatement.

@Taimur_Laal

29 күн бұрын

Could be but these are the numbers stated by Muslim historians closest to that period.

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

Dr. Taimur, are the current royal Saudi family not related to Khwariji and Ibn e Wahhab? I thought they come from the same strain of that sect.

❤️👌

عائشہ رضی اللہ عنہا ہے اور علی رضی اللہ عنہ ہوتا ہے ڈاکٹر صاحب۔ جزاک اللہ

@Taimur_Laal

Ай бұрын

Yes. My mistake. Thanks for correction.

@shaha8783

Ай бұрын

@@Taimur_Laal No problem dr sahib.we all are students .

*We read in about 50 ancient books of Sunni sect that in last sermon; Prophet said: even if a maimed black slave is made your Ruler and he holds fast to Book of Allah Azza wa Jal; then listen him and obey him. And you have told in this video that those people who are labeled by Sect-Followers as "Khawarij", also said same what Rasool said in last sermon*

During hazrat usman khilfah ,he brought Marwan his cousin who got removed sent outside Mecca by prophet Muhammad pbuh,he along with his father ,all the important governors were given to suffiyan maviya group which created hatred towards hazrat usman so that group blocked his house and forty days no food water could get through and that group brutally murdered caliph Usman,hazrat ali became caliph civil war started by the muaviya group and the mess murders happened for the next 72yrs by the muaviya dynasty and than Abbasid continued for the next 220yrs they brutally murdered muaviya families and ahl bait as wel

Marwan bin hakam Mawiyah bin Abu safiyan

😊🌹 ❤

In spite of the three Ummayeda Shias And khawarij I fully agree with khwarjee Though

تو مطلب خارجی نقط نظر سماجی اعتبار سے بہت بہتر تھا۔ (دوسرے مسلمانوں کو غیر مسلم سمجھنا بلکل غلط تھا)

Sir these quraish families actually was bannu ummiyad

@Taimur_Laal

Ай бұрын

Abu Bakr was from the Banu Taym tribe of the Quraysh tribal confederacy. Ummayad's accepted his Khilafat.

@KhawarAbbas-mm2sc

Ай бұрын

@@Taimur_Laal sir actually the conflict between bannu Hashim and bannu ummiyad was too old before Islam which lead the battle between prophet and Abu sufiyan, battle between hazrat Ali and mawiyah bin sufiyan and finally the battle of Karbala. And you know it.

@KhawarAbbas-mm2sc

Ай бұрын

@@Taimur_Laal the reason behind the acceptance of hazrat Abu bakar khalifat was at that time ummayad was very weak at that time but during hazrat Osman era they got power again and they were the governor's of the most important provinces.

@Taimur_Laal

Ай бұрын

@@KhawarAbbas-mm2sc hmmm 🤔 I’m not entirely in agreement with that.

@KhawarAbbas-mm2sc

Ай бұрын

@@Taimur_Laal sir you have a right to have a different opinion.

Did in Jang e Saffin.... Mawaya put Quran on sword to force Hazart Ali's Army to stop fight..... To avoid defeat????

@Taimur_Laal

Ай бұрын

That is what historians tell us.

Bring more Muslim Rational philosophers in the light. So that every Muslim can be rational. 🤝👌

@Zebred2001

Ай бұрын

As long as anyone reveres that 7th century suicidal warlord, slaver and child rapist they are forever precluded from being "rational!"

@uzone8571

Ай бұрын

I wish the same for QAR and Sahil Alim.Well at least we have Engineer.

@SapiensHaiHum

Ай бұрын

​@@uzone8571 what do u think is special in Engineer

@uzone8571

Ай бұрын

@@SapiensHaiHum At least he has highlighted some serious stuff regarding clerics. These sick people have defended the fake Kamila of chisti their debate.

@GhulamMuhammad-vh8up

Ай бұрын

Well philosophically there's is no room for any religion's I am talking about western philosopher who devoleps today's philosophical ideas or thought or logic western philosopher did their work from Greek and Roman languages in short they read and understand the Greek and Roman philosopher very carefully

Sir one correction, it is Hazrat Ayesha Raziallaho Anha not Anho!! 🙏

Thanks you sir i learn alot from you . Our university need sir like you.

پروفیسر صاحب ۔ کیا ابن جریر و طبری کے علاوہ جمل و صفین کی کوئی اور شہادت ہے ؟

You said both sides had martyrs in jang-e-jamal! It means both sides were at the right path then why war started in the first place?

@yhz2K

Ай бұрын

Misunderstandings

@hamzashah4779

Ай бұрын

@@yhz2K misunderstandings are just face-saving notions. How can you kill above 30,000 people just because there was misunderstanding between two people. Read the history and you'll find the underpinnings of desire for power and territory in these 'Fitnas'.

@farazahmed0

Ай бұрын

@@hamzashah4779 I’ve read from many many sources and found it to be misunderstanding as long as Sahaba RA were concerned. Hazrat Ali RA was right because he was of the opinion that currently Ummah should unite and then we will take action against those who martyr Hazrat Usman RA. On the other hand Hazrat Muawiyah RA who was cousin of Hazrat Usman RA was also right and he wanted to avenge Hazrat Usman RA shahadat. Hazrat Ali RA negotiated with Hazrat Muawiyah RA giving the reason even Hazrat Muhammad SAW did peace treaty with kuffar at hudaybia why can’t we have peace treaty among muslims. Here Khwarji thought came into being and they got offended by Hazrat Ali RA’s decision of negotiation and separated. For background context Hazrat Ali RA was referred to as the highest authority to interpret law in difficult cases in the times of Hazrat Abu Bakr RA and Hazrat Umar RA. Both Sahaba referred to Hazrat Ali RA for interpretation of the most difficult cases since Hazrat Ali RA was the most intelligent one. Considering this Hazrat Ali RA was right about this unity was important. Hazrat Zubayr RA was martyr in Battle of Camel when Hazrat Ali reminded him that Hazrat Muhammad SAW used to tell that you would fight me. He backed of from fight and returned. Upon return a person killed him and brought his head to Hazrat Ali RA after he entered his camp Hazrat Ali RA reminded him that Hazrat Muhammad SAW predicted that the person who will martyr Zubayr would go into hell fire. Also Hazrat Zubayr was given a prediction from Hazrat Muhammad SAW as a martyr. Based on the above both groups Sahaba RA were on right path. Allah knows the best.

03:15

❤🌹🚩🌹💞

آپ پوری باتیں نہیں بتا رہے۔ حضرت عثمان کو کس نے اور کیو شہید کیا یہ بتایا ہی نہیں اور سیدھا پہنچ گئے خوارج اور حضرت علی کی شہادت پر

Professor I think you missed alot of nuance when retelling early islamic history especially the events that the contended between the two major sects of Islam. It is always better to mention opposing historical view points rather than implying that a specific version of history is the only credible one worthy of mention.

@Taimur_Laal

Ай бұрын

The part you are referring to is impossible to tell because of polarisation within Muslims. Someone or the other will always feel that it’s not the truth.