Not bad for a 50 year old.

@PyroMonster94

8 жыл бұрын

+kingv911 he was like 45 there

@kingv911

8 жыл бұрын

Close enough.

@ianmarkd.gestuveo4172

5 жыл бұрын

@@PyroMonster94 He's 46 there...

@ahmedhosni6932

Жыл бұрын

Not bad? Excellent super fucking cool

*Jason Newsted detected* (5:21)

@chimpkongdesign

10 жыл бұрын

Uhh yeaah jason detected

@SigTheSauceMan

10 жыл бұрын

How? Jason wasn't with Metallia for the original recording and he sure wasn't with them at Nimes 2009.

@fredy2396

10 жыл бұрын

Andrew Salazar Sorry dude, I did not know that this was from 2009. But in that case, "Kirk Hammett Detected!" Hahaha :D

@SigTheSauceMan

10 жыл бұрын

Fredy Hernandez It's fine. There's probably a lot of Cliff there too. The background vocals are from the original recording, only James' vocals are from Nimes.

@fredy2396

10 жыл бұрын

Andrew Salazar Maybe. But I can hear an almost gutural voice in the chorus. I don't know if was Newsted (cool) or Hammett (some cool) Haha :)

In the soundtrack disc of the metallica's movie "Through the Never", you can hear a powerful master of puppets, with a fixed and ripped voice, it looks like James had been worked on his voice.

For his age and what he has probably put his voice through its not terrible. At least it's on key. We can't all be Bruce Dickinson guys.

@gasmaskboi19371945

8 жыл бұрын

+lucas salazar Ummm, have you heard Bruce now?

@lucassalazar5458

8 жыл бұрын

Yes I have. And for him have having cancer on the back of his tongue near his throat. I think he still sounds pretty damn good

@jumanism5681

8 жыл бұрын

+gasmaskboi19371945 He still sounds absolutely amazing. Not sure who you've been listening to.

His voice is much more melodic and clean here. It was much more aggressive and shouty when he was younger. I liked his younger voice to an extent, but sometimes it was too shouty for my liking. I like his voice on S&M a lot. It was in between.

@Opticillusion160

8 жыл бұрын

+Mike G Beatbox Metallica is just about the least shouty thrash band out there. Other than like Anthrax and Overkill. If his younger vocals are too shouty then you must not really like metal

Hearing 24 year old James in the background with his middle aged voice is so cool you can tell its the same guy but so different.

2:41 was actually pretty metal

Anyone else find it really like, creepy in an amazing way to hear Jaymz live voice, and then the 86 voice come in faintly?

Mixing of MOP studio version (1986) and concert vocals...

From which consert did you took James voice from?

@outlawthorn1982

10 жыл бұрын

S&m?

@damageincforo

10 жыл бұрын

The voice tracks is from Nimes 2009. There are more songs with that voice in the channel

@enriqueestrada6674

10 жыл бұрын

ja cuando estas escuchandolos en vivo no c nota..

@MetallicaLiveHD

10 жыл бұрын

damageincforo I know, have listened to all of them. I like it

@lniner1

9 жыл бұрын

Why not use his movie?

Absolutely love this. Only issue is how distant the chorus sounds.

Do you guys think castor hetfield will have a voice like his dad?

@dcone53

9 жыл бұрын

dcone53 its been a year

@Inspire_Orbit

9 жыл бұрын

dcone53 everyone have scream voice , you only need practice :)

@obundoben82

8 жыл бұрын

He's a baby. He can already scream.

@crazygamer6601

6 жыл бұрын

Vocals are usually genetic so I think it's safe to say

This is a great video. Thank you for making it.

always loved the voice of James hetfield

Esta mal hacer esto, en estudio y joven podia forzar la voz de un modo que si lo haces cada 3 dias en una gira quedarias mudo, el modo de cantar es simplemente el modo de cuidar su voz, cuando era joven podia gritar de un modo desgarrador y recuperarse, ahora cantando de este modo suave lo podremos tener cantando hasta cuando el decida.

@abelhernandezmanzano5927

4 жыл бұрын

chuck billy se rie de esto

@nico.ch029

3 жыл бұрын

@@abelhernandezmanzano5927 el no tiene el mismo estilo vocal ni tampoco frecuencia de uso en la voz

@locuraporgunsnroses1915

2 жыл бұрын

igual sigue sonando perfecto aunque no tenga la voz rasposa de los 80,90 suena mas que bien a su edad y mas en el 2021 que anda mejor que nunca.

That's half of bringing Metallica back is bringing back the real sound of the songs from the recording when playing live. This sounds so much better even with the new vocals. I'd love to hear this at a concert!

James is almost like a fine wine with his voice.

If they would just get their instrumentals to sound like this their new albums would be as kick ass as they used to be.

In terms of technical ability, James is voice has actually improved. He seems to be able to hit more cleanly, high end notes and shows a bit more versatility. In terms of being gnarly, his older voice is way better, much more throaty & rough, but you can't do that forever. Much better suited to thrash metal, they hardly sound like a thrash band anymore. I have no idea how Joey Belladonna sounds so good and close to his original voice...that guy looks as old as Iggy Pop and as strange as Phil Spector.

@fireinthesky3379

6 жыл бұрын

say hi to tom araya! james can sing like before he just dont wanna risk a throat injury. Tom araya doesnt give a shit about his voice

Muy buen laburo!

I don't get it how people say he can't sing nowadays or say he's like shitty pop singer. Maybe it's not metal but god damn those vibratos and his melodic singing are gold.

Do this again with hetfield's now voice and I bet it'll be better matched

I'd love to hear his new voice over all the original tracks of the first five albums, including the studio versions of Am I Evil and Blitzkrieg.

if u did with the voice of 1999 it would be great

@jeremeasofficial2086

8 жыл бұрын

+Yazid Messi wasn't it half tone dropped?

@alfonsomartinez2751

8 жыл бұрын

it was

now all you need is the st. anger snare lol only kidding

@ironhammer8935

8 жыл бұрын

+Grossguth Richard There's actually a video of Master of Puppets with St. Anger snare.

Hetfield's old voice is what I miss most from 80s Metallica. That and precision in playing.

@nicolasvillamil7523

7 жыл бұрын

James has always been precise on guitar, that's the one thing that hasn't change at all really.

@ozricness

7 жыл бұрын

Nicolas Villamil I agree, he's mostly spot on, and so have been their bass players. It all started with Lars replacing practice and precision with improvisation that he hasn't got the skills to back up and lately Kirk playing sloppily too. Getting mega successful and super rich despite all that tends to take away some of the hunger for excellence too.

@arsletirott

7 жыл бұрын

blame Kirk for the sloppy guitar playing

I wished if James could again re-record his voice on Master of Puppets and Fade to Black.

its cute that crowds voice is his voice in the record 😂

it does not count. the original song's key is E. since mid-90s, they've been playing this song half step down, which is Eb, so he's singing it in Eb. get your shit straight.

how did u get the new vocal tracks

May I suggest re doing this with the trough the never vocal track? That way old het isn't in the background.

Is 'New Hetfield' James' brother?

@RevoltingRudi

9 жыл бұрын

***** on a mtv live show in 1996 he sings like the old days. he never "lost" it but he risk voice problemes if he sings to much like this.

@fireinthesky3379

6 жыл бұрын

2 years ago there was no spit out the bone !

This guitar tune sounds so similar to Countdown to Extinction

vocals are from Nimes 2009 cool i must say

The voice from Nimes 2009?

It sounds great but the only issue I have with it is the vocals seem a bit off time, I'm not sure if that's just because I'm used to hearing James' original vocals, or it just *is* off time slightly

Some part are realy good, some not but it's a live performance so can't realy mean anything... Would be awesome to record in studio again with his "new" voice. could be realy efficient.

that other voice was way to low.... "Obey your master"

You should have made sure all of it was in synch. Otherwise, it was interesting to listen to. I like.

This is máster of puppets live 2010-2020

could have jus done a pitch change to his voice like they did on death magnetic

Yeah, this is what happens when you tour for decades and eventually get old

really compairison wise it isnt fair there is a big difference between live and studio

I dont really like his live singing, but in his new studio songs he sounds much better. can anyone tell me why he sings so differently in the live compared to the studio?

@Metal2Bach

9 жыл бұрын

As a fellow metal singer, I can say for me it's because you have so much more freedom in the studio to give every track 100%. At a show, you may be playing for 2 or more hours and you have to "save" your voice to an extent to get it to last that long. In a studio, you can give it everything you've got in one song - and if you mess up, who cares? Just do another take. Mess up live, and you don't get another chance. You can push yourself much more in the safety of a studio. :)

@generalshamic4777

9 жыл бұрын

Darker Instincts yeah i didnt think of that. i checked out your channal btw, and your pretty talented :)

@Epiidevvy

9 жыл бұрын

Darker Instincts I agree with your statement. As a musician that sticks to the studio (albeit a home made one) you can really blast through every song. Also as a Metclub member I can download Metallicas live shows from their website, and I've downloaded some of their old shows and some of their most recent. It turns out that in the old days, James' voice would get more and more tired the longer the show went on. Now his voice is constant through out. In fact, I really like James' studio voice as it sounds like the old James mixed in with the Death Magnetic melodic new james. If you hear their Ronnie Rising medley for Ronnie James Dio's tribute album you'll see what I mean.

@Metal2Bach

9 жыл бұрын

***** That's also true - the big vocal change came in between the Black Album and Load/ReLoad as he had to change his vocal technique after blowing it out so badly on So What.

@pakoti96

9 жыл бұрын

General Shamic Pro Tools.

Still better than me.And this is from a live performance. lol

you know what it sounds like?... a DEMO. oh well. happens to the best of us.

Thats shocking lol!!

Why would you even do this?

Damn, he's really lost his voice, this sounds awful compared with the original one, he had a really awesome voice when he was young, too bad he can't sing like the old days anymore, such a shame.

@JoshLikeCrazy

10 жыл бұрын

this is live singing, if it was in studio it would be better. plus they are downtuned when they play live so it's out of key.

@dabob878

6 жыл бұрын

yeah but it's not a matter that it's live because Seattle 1989's perfomance

@captaincumrag42069

6 жыл бұрын

Nubshooter he was also 30 FUCKING YEARS OLDER that was his prime...he can sound that good live anymore

The moment you realize that Lars and Kirk are the only problems with metallica.

Me gusta mucho Metallica, pero suena muy afeminada "Master" con esa voz tan suave :S

@DonMarcoSZ

6 жыл бұрын

Breian Barrera Le queda perfecta la voz a master cantando asi, jaja.

Music seems to be drop d or even lower here

@foley6077

4 жыл бұрын

Egor Alekseev Eb tuning

I hate the way he fucks with the vocal placement live

Master-ra lol 3:33

oh my god its awful compared to the original '

Down tuning again I see the voice just isn't there still a good band though!

plastic drum