Their voices are so similar that it’s almost like hearing the same person. Ryan is how JD sounds in his own head (calm, clear, and direct) while Jamie is how he appears to everyone else (emotional and unhinged).

@dustymax56

2 жыл бұрын

Listening to them separately, it’s like two different songs but they're closer than you would think

@bellab16

2 жыл бұрын

this is genius

@MistressHyde

4 ай бұрын

Oh my god what an AMAZING interpretation-

It’s impossible to say one is better honestly cause in the end it comes down to preference. They both sound SOOO similar throughout most of it and have little moments where they add their own flair. For example, when Jamie says “fuck it” he sounds real angry but when Ryan says “fuck it” he sounds desperate. It’s just up to preference and how you like certain parts sounding. Overall I find it pretty cool that Jamie matches our OG JD pretty well while adding some grit to make it different. And obviously Ryan’s version is the staple and sounds so clean all the way through.

@jessicafelix265

2 жыл бұрын

I’m just discovering all this today lol where can I see the “OG JD”? Lol in the movie? And does the movie have singing too or only the musical?

@Demi_P

2 жыл бұрын

@@jessicafelix265 the movie is from the 80s and it’s not a musical so I’d watch it to understand they references or watch the original plot if you want. The original musical came out several years ago and stars Ryan McCartan as JD who you can hear on Broadway album but there isn’t a clip of that song on KZread as of right now (there have been in the past but they get taken down pretty quick) but I’d just keep checking for it every now and then because you never know! Hope this helps! :)

@spiders0dap0p

2 жыл бұрын

I like how the way Ryan says it, sounds like he’s talking to himself, which adds to the feeling of desperation

Jamie has like the angry growl in some words like the first “Veronica” and “fuck it” and it’s so great

I love the way that Ryan is almost arrogant when he explain the letter of why " the students died" but Jamie lives the character more, he is more dramatic and is really made for the theater I don't know I love both 🤍🤍

I feel like jamie’s is more satisfying to listen to but it’s a lot more like he really doesnt care anymore and he’s just blinded by anger while ryan’s is more like he really believes this is a great idea and he’s desperate for veronica to be with him again and he’s really worried and anxious about her since she hasn’t answered in a while. I like ryan’s acting a lot more since jamie’s is mostly just a lot of anger and like why isnt veronica listening to my demands, but jamie’s is definitely a much more satisfying listen for me

@mysteryperson2797

2 жыл бұрын

I think that's why Jamie's is better, it a bit more realistic instead of making JD this lil softie boi, it shows how scary the situation actually is

you can HEAR Jamie's acting, every emotion, every move throughout the song. he's def my fav, but both of them are incredible as JD!!

if i could combine my favorite parts of each of their songs and compile it into one, i’d be in heaven

@dragcnheart

2 жыл бұрын

i had the same thought

@bigdawgchai

Жыл бұрын

thissss

@raichutheraven

Жыл бұрын

Man this comment really makes me wish I could edit

IF YOU PUT HEADPHONES ON, AND YOU CAN HEAR ONE OF THEM ON EACH SIDE

@samsonquies7922

2 жыл бұрын

It's so nice

Are we not gonna talk about how the scream at the end it literally the same 💀✋🏼

I'm wearing bone conducting earphones which vibrate your head for the sound instead of being in the ear and this video felt strange, but interesting. Each side was vibrating a little differently and it was a cool experience. I personally like Jamie as J.D. a little more because he seems to put more emotion into the singing and acts more crazy.

@ariana1042

2 жыл бұрын

This sounds amazing

@TheGrimReaper11119

2 жыл бұрын

Where would one get these headphones?

I personally prefer Jamie over Ryan because of how scary he made JD seem. Ryan's version is nice to listen to because it's very clean, and obviously OG's are always amazing, (Ryan screaming "Veronica" is the best I've ever heard it being done tho so I'm in love) but the emotion Jamie puts into the song really completes it for me. When I first watched his performance of this song (through a screen unfortunately 😭) I was honestly shocked at how terrified it made me, and no JD had ever scared me like his did. The acting choices he made allowed the scene to feel a lot more realistic to me. Some people say that he played it with too much anger for their liking, when I think that anger was perfect for the moment. At this point JD has really lost it, everyone he's ever loved has abandoned him, so he's feeling angry, upset and impulsive. The song itself is frantic, with the upbeat 1st verse which leads into a soft chorus before jumping back into the same upbeat 2nd verse before it builds up into the 2nd chorus where he can no longer remain calm like in the 1st chorus. It's like the emotions are boiling over and he doesn't care enough to control them in this moment in time. I also just love how satisfying his growls/yells are in the 2nd chorus, and the growls he makes on certain words like "don't make me come in there" has a kind of subtle growl I've never seen anyone talk about but I love listening to. Also his "no thanks" is perfect. So yeah, Jamie for the win😤

i first started watching without earphones, it was so chaotic- sounded much better once i put them in

They both are great in different ways. Jamie acts with his voice and Ryan with his body/facial expressions

I like Ryan the most up until "You were meant to be mine" through "Fuck it!"

I love the fact that each one has its own identity: Ryan is arrogant and heartless, while Jamie is emotional and a little more phyco. I can't choose who is better because not only Ryan but also Jamie did a great job and both deserve to be JD... bUT BUT BUT, I personally prefer Ryan's version, just a little more than Jamie's

I prefer ryan's overrall because I like the calm manner of Ryan's JD while explaining really dark and disturbing images up until he finally snaps but certain parts of Jamie's like the whole "veronica open the door part" or whenever he sings "meant to be yours" it sounds really angelic. I wish there was a mixup of both that I could put on my Spotify playlist bc now it bothers me that the one that ultimately sounds better is missing the really popular, emotional part at the end that I've heard in trends before I even knew what Heathers was.

I love how Ryan really contrasts calm and madness. The first parte he's screaming and then suddenly softs on the "I was meant to be yours". In the "students' note" he's deep and menacing and gets frantic at "smoke pour out the doors". And chef's kiss at the "Veronica open the door". Jamie is ok, but Ryan's brilliant!

I couldn’t choose between the two because I love them both so much so I normally listen to both consecutively but this- this is my favorite version now

I personally like Ryan's version better because he hits the high notes better and jamie sounds like hes about to sneeze

How was the scream at the end so synced- that’s so funny to me

Both are really good, but Jamie has my whole heart, I love his acting, he makes JD so much more scary

1) Jamie will forever be my favourite

@ferrets_arecool

2 жыл бұрын

Elmo meme?

@chloelouise7743

2 жыл бұрын

@@ferrets_arecool 1:49

@psychoticriot123

2 жыл бұрын

Omg yes I burst out laughing at that bit 😂

at 1:48 when their high notes mix it’s SO satisfying

This confirms that Jamie is my favorite JD

I'm wearing ear buds so I hear one on each side lol I can really hear the difference but it's so good!!

It's almost like the song versions are saying that they were meant to play together all along when Ryan and Jamie sing "WE WERE MEANT TO BE ONE" Honestly this whole thing was a treat for my brain

I’ve always loved Jamie but idk Ryan is growing on me both are so good ugh

the emotion from jamie 😭

Hearing it some by side, Jamie's voice seems like it has more personality? He's more emotional and human, but Ryan seems stiff, like he's tapping into the psychotic part of JD. He's more calm and collected compared to how Jamie sounds angry

i'm so in love with jamie oh my g o d like sorry ryan but j e s u s

Please I need them both separately

@is._noah2024

2 жыл бұрын

Both of their versions are on Spotify

@ferrets_arecool

2 жыл бұрын

And youtube check the description of this video and it has links

pov: only one side of your earbuds are working

Turning your phone sideways listening to this makes it sound like they’re singing a duet together 😂

lmao i was listening to this with only one headphone and was wondering why i could only hear ryan

This edit made me smile so much! Thanks for making it :)

BYE I LOVE RYAN'S VERSION 😭

If you could put this on Spotify I would definitely listen to this over and over

I- the sound I let out when the Elmo in flames appeared on the screen

Jamie may have more character in his singing but I just like Ryan better idk is it just me

@danicalarsen9449

2 жыл бұрын

THANK UU ILLL RYAN AS JD

@sarushiro

2 жыл бұрын

ogs just sound amazing

Alternative title : The JD multiverse sing this Iconic song and also i was The Thrird JD * Caugh Caugh* and also The first female JD singing while i was Watching The video

personally ryan is my favorite jd but i love seeing other peoples opinions on it!

it’s a little trippy but i’m low key enjoying it 👀

lemme go grab my airpods so i can listen to it

When they match each other though...

all we need is dan now

Pew pew pew

OK BUT BOTH OF THEM ARE GREAT BUT THE PICTURE OF ELMO 1:49 😭😭 WAHHAHA

Omggggggggg Jamie Muscato!!!!!

With my earphones my right ear is Ryan and my left ear is Jamie idk it feels rlly cool taking one out and hearing one and then putting it back in and hearing both of them 😭😭

Guys Jamie is so cute!! And I absolutely LOVE his voice!! Ngl though.. if he came to my door and asked me to open it I would open it as soon as I hear his voice ❤😍

I feel like with Jamie, he’s speaking to the listeners as if we’re Veronica.

this is so cool with headphones

Can't choose which of them is better, but do I even have to?

I honestly love Ryan wayy better but then again that may be a little biased. But if you think about it Ryan was always uncomfortable playing J.D because it's a very real thing in the U.S so it was hard for him to play a character like J.D. But for Jamie it was probably easier because stuff like that never happens so he might have had an easier time playing the character where as Ryan had a hard time playing J.D they both sound great but Ryan has my heart

@wowz3rs265

2 жыл бұрын

what-

@erinhemmings95

2 жыл бұрын

Bro shit like this happens everywhere?! No one wants to play a psychopathic teenager. Don’t say about where shit like this happens when you don’t know.

@sirenyt9224

Жыл бұрын

wth

@lachlanpdenbrok

Жыл бұрын

huh

Ok but elmo hahahaha

stop comparing them theyre both good like both ryan and jamie have their own interpretations of JD and im all for it goddamn😭

WHY DOES JAMIE LOOK LIKE JAKE PAUL 😭 I mean in the musical it made him look like he had a unibrow so.

@lemxntea2

2 жыл бұрын

HELP LMFAO UR SO RIGHT

@cleo2936

2 жыл бұрын

NO 💀

*Dies in gay*

Jamie’s my favorite JD

i prefer ryan, because like jamie sounds like a country guy singing a halloween song and he has his moments where he’s perfect for the role but ryan’s calm and collective state with a hint of desperation and anger just kills me and i sit in the edge of my couch and i feel great.

I love how the creator of this video has only liked comments about Jamie being the best 😂 The creator is correct 💅

I took like left earphone out bc I LOVE RYAN DUDE

in earphones this messes with ur head

Ryan made the “original” which is my fave sooo

i love ryan but like can we replace the og mom with the jamie mom one

This was oddly satisfying.

guys put a headphone so it sync right

I'm in love with Ryan sorry....

@danicalarsen9449

2 жыл бұрын

No same...

@cborles

2 жыл бұрын

hes so handsome for no reason

This is so funny on 2x speed

У меня крутые наушники:-) Ну а та конечно похожи, ведь ну я не смогу объяснить но у них все же разные. И у того челика много эмоций особенно когда он пел про ну тип одноклассников которые должны были сгореть, а у второго чела по другому ну мало эмоций?😅

누가...제이미여...누가 라이언이야...?

Myslalam że leci tylko jedno bo na jednej MIALA słuchawkę

I think there is a difference from acting with a lot of emotion and forcing it, I loved ryan's version becuase I could actually see it and sometimes in jamie's version I can feel he fakeness and although he absolutely rocks the song I prefer hearing ryan's version more

Ryan

2x made this funny.... do it i dare u

@jsissa_

9 ай бұрын

WAHAHHA😭😭 I BURSTED LAUGHING AT "BAM BAM BAM" WHY DOES IT SOUNDS LIKE A MARIO SOUND TRACK-

앜ㅋㅋ이어폰 왼쪽만끼고잇어서 댓글뭔말이지하고잇엇넼ㅋㅋ

ryan is my favorite sorry

Who’s the guy on the left?

@Maddie-hs4yf

2 жыл бұрын

Jamie Muscato

@kaitlynrenz1841

2 жыл бұрын

Jamie Muscato, he played J.D in the West end production. Ryan Mccartan played him in the off broadway version

@lemxntea2

2 жыл бұрын

ryan mccartan (right) was jd in the original production

Where's Dan?

@Allitini

2 жыл бұрын

he doesn’t have a studio recording :(

@Evielicious

2 жыл бұрын

@@Allitini AWWWW

Jamie is better..

you guys can hear which is which? 🥲

@Allitini

2 жыл бұрын

??? their voices are vastly different??

@Asteroidarc

2 жыл бұрын

@@Allitini no i sorta have hearing problems and most of the time if 2 voices are mixed it sounds like a broken radio? idk how to describe it

this just confirms to me that Jamie is my favourite JD