A ww1 hero against germans in ww1 A ww2 marshall to the germans in ww2 Wow history changed very fast

@georgethakur

5 жыл бұрын

not as fast as italy, didn't even take two wars, just one!

@georgethakur

4 жыл бұрын

@@un-coglione-nostalgico sry

@subaru-kuntheotakudude9942

4 жыл бұрын

@@un-coglione-nostalgico it is true, Italy Changed Faction in WW1 And WW2 In WW2 The "People" Changed Not The Supportist.

I totally disagree with you about Petain. He was neither a traitor or a Nazi sympathizer but a true French patriot who did not abandon his country like De Gaulle. Petain refused to have France enter WW2 on the behalf of Nazi Germany when he met with Hitler in 1940. France lost WW2 due to the decadent Third Republic with its vile liberal and Marxist policies. Petain was right in his war against secularism. His trail and imprisonment was disgraceful, France could use a man like Petain today.

@Randomeslaw-cz4yt

4 жыл бұрын

finally someone who agrees with me

@amxelcbis4464

3 жыл бұрын

Wtf

@carlosmpsenyorcapitacollon6977

3 жыл бұрын

I am not exactly anti-petain, but what about the deportations?

@villanovakid84

3 жыл бұрын

@@carlosmpsenyorcapitacollon6977 No man is perfect. The deportation of the Jews to concentration camps was abhorrent.

@guntugakgun1924

3 жыл бұрын

I defended the same thing in another video. It is what it is.

"Travail, Famille, Patrie" LONG LIVE VICHY FRANCE!!!!!

Is it even legal to play this song in France today? I can't imagine many people would want to be reminded of it.

@shako4907

7 жыл бұрын

John Cate Probably not as bad as Germany

@postmodpen1169

5 жыл бұрын

big fucking deal. We still listen songs from 1700's even though it was a period full of poverty.

@postmodpen1169

5 жыл бұрын

9homefries8 _ I dont fucking care what the avarage person does to be honest. I listen to clasical music, fascist music, commie music any music.

@erwinheinrichstromer1156

3 жыл бұрын

@@postmodpen1169 Music is music after all

Vive La Marechal!

so the french anthem will be " Empereur, nous voila "

Best president of France.

1.Although the French law of secularization was passed in 1905, it took time for the " rot " to set into France, By 1940, the decadence has set in to such degree that the French had lost the will to fight,and this malaise was not evident during WW1 as France did win, but this was due to American support, otherwise, the war would have been a stalemate. The Polish, French, and British armies were defeated by the Nazis due to superior tactics. continued......

Vive le Marechal Petain!

@altamirojunior2860

9 жыл бұрын

Get the fuck out anarchist

@frood801

8 жыл бұрын

+Icek Zimmerman If you have to be a anarchist why do you have to be the shitty one?

@agonistadenoche7806

8 жыл бұрын

+Icek Zimmerman >anarchism >communism

@frood801

8 жыл бұрын

Okapi Jirafa The end result of communism is a form of anarchism.

@agonistadenoche7806

8 жыл бұрын

Le Shiggy Donetello no, not everything is volunteer dude

That was not the National Anthem, which remained unchanged from the Third Republic. It had a high but nonetheless unofficial status.

@50shekels

5 жыл бұрын

Primus Inter Pares no La Marseillaise was the unofficial anthem of the resistance after it was banned by the Germans

@austinmontgomery117

4 жыл бұрын

No.

@news_internationale2035

3 жыл бұрын

@@50shekels Nonsense. Pétain held a public event with The Marseilles.

@50shekels

3 жыл бұрын

@@news_internationale2035look it up, or continue being wrong. I dont really mind

@news_internationale2035

3 жыл бұрын

@@50shekels kzread.info/dash/bejne/c4KWucygebuomrQ.html

Marshal; here we are.

Gloire au Marechal ! Reposez en paix

Good translation!

vichy france is something like the wang jinwei japanese inspired government or the thai government in thailand after japanese occupation or other japanese puppet states in asia and like the european collaborator governments in europe after german occupation especially quisling norway while free france is something like chaing kai shek's china and the free thai movement in asia while the european resistance movements in europe . i prefer free france in this case but i still like the tune of this

Im no student of French history but I cannot understand why some people seem to support Petain so much. I know he was a hero from WW1 at Verdun but didn't he capitulate to the Nazi's?

@mattybt400

8 жыл бұрын

Taliesin If you surrender you will save lives. Thats true. If other countries loose a lot of lives trying to win it back for you. Thats kinda embarassing.

@mattybt400

8 жыл бұрын

Heinz Hampel Are suggesting Petain knew what was going to happen in sixty years time?

@Richtofenfan

8 жыл бұрын

+Matty Bt oh no he didn't capitulate, he just joined in making an armistice, meaning "we'll give you land at the north in exchange you let us make our own country in southern france"

@mattybt400

8 жыл бұрын

The Geisha Boy what were the terms of the Armistice?

@Richtofenfan

8 жыл бұрын

Matty Bt the germans made sure the terms were favorable, such as taking a lot of food supply, a very small army about 15,000 strong, and it also gave philippe petain authoritarian powers. it was something like this.

Who is the singer ?

1:08 what were the names of these dogs? De Gaulle and who?

Anyone who would betray their country the way he did should be labeled a traitor and his family

@Aragonstar

6 жыл бұрын

He tried to protect the french from slaughter, in my opinion, what he did was better than what De Gaulle did with the french army

@joshuawillis602

4 жыл бұрын

Jari who was tried in court after WW2? A man who dedicated his life to freeing France or a traitor who let France become a puppet to another country?

@joshuawillis602

4 жыл бұрын

austro- hungarian empire ball if it’s a puppet then it’s not it’s own nation not in the slightest

@opiterturpilinus2248

6 ай бұрын

If anyone is the traitor it's the men who led France into WW2

Petain was the shame of France .he'sonly the symbol of the collaboration .

2:16 wrong france and english lyrics

But "levons la tête" actually means "let us raise our heads", not "raise your heads".

Dans cette raison que j'ai ajouté cette.. :) Vous devez prendre une leçon de votre histoire..

2. However, the French has more men and material than the Nazis, and in some aspects, the had a technological advantage over the Germans in some of their equipment, whereas, the Polish were both outnumbered and had antiquated equipment as compared to the Nazis. So, the French, with such a magnificent army, lost to Hitler in 5 weeks, this was utterly shocking. Therefore, Petain's argument that the rot caused by the decadence of the 'Third Republic' accelerated this great debacle for France.

et vive L'Empereur !

@ZEtruckipu Ouais plutôt d'accord ! L'homme providentiel de Verdun, oui et non, la victoire est plus due aux soldats qui se sont battus et sont morts, plutôt qu'au commandant bien au chaud dans l'Etat Major.

I prefer this song and Petain than Chant des Partisans and De Gaulle. Petain is greatest patriot!! De Gaulle is just a traitor. Tu sauves la Patrie, une seconde fois. De Gaulle betrayed fatherland second time, first is WW2, second is Algerian War.

@overcastandhaze

8 жыл бұрын

This has a more upbeat tone, a sort of gratitude towards Petain. The partisan's song sucks, truthfully. Polish home army songs sound much better

@FormerAccountofPF

6 жыл бұрын

TheSpitfire109 "De Gaulle was just a traitor" Yea. Being part of a shitty puppet state of the third reich is totally better than fighting for the freedom of his Country. The Algerien war was and will be forever a war crime for france. I'm glad that De Gaulle gave Algeria the Independiente. Petain was a hero in WW1 but ended up as traitor in WW2.

@FormerAccountofPF

6 жыл бұрын

And yes. I know Petain needed to surrender to save more french civillians. But he still cooperated later then. So you know what I mean.

why the hell didn't you guys fight in north Africa?

@overcastandhaze

8 жыл бұрын

Because we didn't exist yet.

@adamhauskins6407

8 жыл бұрын

+Jdr Eldridge but the French "army" was there!

@overcastandhaze

8 жыл бұрын

Adam Hauskins Meh, I guess they knew it was a forgone conclusion.

@innosam123

6 жыл бұрын

adam hauskins They were still weak from the invasion.

@MrSomebodyyyy

4 жыл бұрын

They did fight, against the Allies.

Subtitles not always accurate. Les sous-titres ne sont pas toujours corrects.

@TomorrowWeLive

8 жыл бұрын

Which parts are inaccurate?

@dominiquebeaulieu

8 жыл бұрын

At 2:49 : tu nous as redonné l'espérance.

@CactusHazretleri dimi ya :)

What he told me if you read his comments is that I have a right to be a secularist (thank you very much) but that secularism somehow causes "rot" which caused the French defeat in World War II. He was unable to prove this ridiculous affirmation, mind you.

@gavinlane7459

7 жыл бұрын

Secularism has caused rot. Look at modern France now.

@TheMaster4534

5 жыл бұрын

Like religious fanaticism is better. So what? Christian State good, Islamic State bad? Double hypocrisy. Same shit different holy book.

Soit dit en passant, si vous préférez communiquer en français, faites-le, je vous en prie. Votre anglais est excellent, mais si vous désirez vous exprimer dans la langue de Molière, pas de problème, quoi!

🇮🇹🇫🇷🇫🇷🇮🇹

Well, I will not condone anti-semitism because people who are prejudiced are usually not educated and ignorant.However, I can attest to the fact that some people dislike Jews and there has always been varying degrees of anti-semitism in Europe, anti-semitism is common here in my country too. So, Petain's anti-semitism was probably ingrained in him at an early age, and with Hitler ruling Europe, it was much easier to enact these type of laws directed against Jews.

I am not familiar with these anti-Semetic laws that Petain initiated in France. Yes, De Gaulle was anti-Nazi but he ran off to England while Petain remained behind and tried to correct all the maladies of the Third Republic.In this sense, he was totally right because liberalism and secularism led to the French defeat to the Nazis.Vichy France was given a high degree of autonomy by Hitler due to the great respect Petain had with the French people. Laval was an opportunist and a Fascist, yes.

There national anthem sounds like a looney tunes cartoon staring bugs bunny.

@onurmayis Haklısın unutmasınlar.

@Zuxair Certes il a merdé durant la 2nde guerre mondial mais n'oublions quand même pas qu'il fut l'homme providentiel de Verdun. Je suis convaincu qu'il a agit du mieux qui pouvait considérant Laval qui voulait une collaboration active. Néanmoins il est clair que pendant Vichy il a outrepassé les mesures que les Allemands lui imposait et son acceptation de la déportation des juifs français est impardonnable.

@jeanetienne6288

2 жыл бұрын

He did not have a choice.....it was either listen to Germany and do what they tell you or see your most prized monuments, paintings and cities destroyed by the Germans.

@jeanetienne6288

2 жыл бұрын

But I am not glorifying him....I know what he did and it's bad.....I am only saying that he didn't have a choice

Yes, Petain did lose a high degree of his power after the Allies landed in North Africa in 1942 and Pierre Laval started to player a larger role in Vichy France. I know that Dr. Goebbels kept lobbying Hitler to get rid of Petain as evidenced by diatribes against Petain in his diary. Hitler wanted Petain to declare war against the British, but he refused to commit France to such an undertaking.And both Britain and the US gave full diplomatic recognition to the Vichy government.

It is absurd to compare the French Third Republic to the USSR. Yes, the USSR was an " atheist " state, but it was under the rule of an authoritarian leader in Joseph Stalin, a great man and a great leader. Stalin was not shackled by parliamentary bickering like the Third Republic or any other democracy. He was a man who tolerated no dissent and got things done, a ruthless dictator, just like Hitler.There was no room for " rot" under Stalin, if so, you would be shipped to a Siberian gulag.

@crazyepicfortnitegamer8426

6 жыл бұрын

villanovakid84 Stalin great? *laughs hysterically*

ALLEZ MARINE NOUS VOILA

3. I sense that you are a secularist by your comments, and this is ok. Talking with people who have different views in sometimes interesting. You ask why Italy did so badly in war? The Italians had horrible leadership among their officers, this was well documented by Rommel and other German generals. I think the Italians contributed greatly to the defeat of Hitler, they surrendered in droves to the British in North Africa even with superior numbers. They sucked big time.

Both are a chame

honteuse page de l'histoire de France

All the allies were smashed by the Germans in 1940 because they were not ready for Blitzkreig. France included. Your absurd notion that secularlism "rots" a country and makes it unable to defend itself is ridiculous. In point of fact, 80% of the effort in defeating Nazi Germany was supplied by the USSR, which was an atheist state. This discussion is too stupid to continue. If you want to continue to repeat Pétain's stupid ideas go ahead. I have wasted enough time on you.