How special and unique that Yuval says straight up that due to his closeness to this tragedy, he cannot be unbiased and on the side of Israel. He suggests to hear others with a more Palestinian bent. That is being Intellectually honest and a true professional...and very rare. Good on you Sir.

@pascalpoussin1209

6 ай бұрын

Search for Norman Filkenstein, Miko Peled, Noam Chomsky or Aaron or Gabor Maté. They give an excellent analysis.

@davideatwell6577

6 ай бұрын

When talking about AI Yuval says that it threatens our ability to realise our potential, part of realising our fuller potential would be a broader perspective presumably, I guess that's what's required everywhere

@neyctferreira915

6 ай бұрын

Agreed 100%

@peterkratoska4524

6 ай бұрын

@@pascalpoussin1209 Except Chomsky says the Palestinians should not fight because Israel is so much more powerful, oh hang on he said that about the Ukrainians.

@pascalpoussin1209

6 ай бұрын

@@peterkratoska4524 if your interested in listening to analysis of the Ukraine war you may enjoy the interviews on KZread of Jacques Baud, a colonel in the information section of the Swiss army who published 3 books on the subject. Most of his interviews are in French but there are one or two in English. His line of thought follows that of people like Jeffrey Sachs.

I respect that Yuval invited the audience to look for the Palestinian point of view after watching this interview. Very few do this.

@1001Balance

6 ай бұрын

At start he was unable to do this. Respect that he could get back to ratio over emotion.

@BrunonBarros

4 ай бұрын

Luciano Huck Defends Communism and Socialism in Brazil

You don’t hear often a speaker acknowledging his partiality and urging the audience to go hear the other side of the story. 👏

@JimiHL

6 ай бұрын

Which means he's biased and wrong.

@roberthewat8921

5 ай бұрын

It means he is aware he is biased, but he is still totally wrong. We're talking about his country doing genocide in the eyes of the whole World. His position is totally indefensible regardless of his eloquence and scholarly pretensions.

@erelfink8822

5 ай бұрын

​@@roberthewat8921obviously he's a little biased but both of you clearly didn't understand what he was trying to say and definitely don't understand what genocide means

@rinkohorowitz

5 ай бұрын

@@roberthewat8921What Israel is doing isn’t genocide. There’s no empirical evidence to prove that that is the case. Once again, it is the ramblings of the western liberal moralists, who decry all war as genocide, and all attempts at accountability of the protected groups as oppression based on racism.

@blaaaaaaaaahify

5 ай бұрын

@@roberthewat8921 You struggle to understand even simple human language. He is directly involved, meaning that he is on the side of the Israelis who are suffering as a citizen. What he meant was "I cannot speak on behalf of Palestine because I'm part of this, if you want to gain a broader perspective you should also listen someone from Palestine's side and make up your own mind" . He's absolutely not wrong at all.

1:15 Although I would not agree with Yual on many things right now, but my eyes were full of tears when I heard him, being so honest that he could not be objective and we also have to listen to a passionate Palestinian for that reason. I so wish we had people like him all over the world! My full respect to you Yual!

@rhetleonard2968

6 ай бұрын

I do believe there are many, many people worldwide that think in similar ways as Yuval. His clear thinking and impeccable language to communicate the message is extraordinary, but many, many of the global population understand and agree when he unpacks the issue.

@MrLevwoolf

6 ай бұрын

There are some major misleading talking points, regarding the facts here, despite my agreement with his meta perspective...the normalization process was about to erase Palestinians last hope of achieving statehood. That's why...He makes it out as something very different. Now, people are actually discussing a Palestinian state again. I am a jew. "Never again " means never again, for anyone, even haters. The inhumanity, born of generations of past trauma, has been unpacked on Palestinians. My issue with him, on a philosophical level, is his devaluation, lact of appreciation or understanding of the importance of Emotional wellbeing and inteligence. He extols the mind, abstract inteligence... at great cost. When we as a species, need integration of mind and body, logic and emotion. He is future oriented, living in ideas, and there is too much of a good thing.

Thank you, Yuval! I appreciate your hope for humanity.

@evertbakker5307

6 ай бұрын

Sorry but this man is absolutely pro transhumanism, and a wef popet

as a german i found the end very beautiful. It's true how insanely wonderful the friendship between jews and germans today is. (obviusly it's far from perfect) but it can be a great example.

@laus9953

4 ай бұрын

it's utterly shameful how today's German government is supporting most barbaric, fully deliberate atrocities by nethanyahus government against innocent Palestinians. shame on all germans who fail to clearly condemn this fascist bloodshed. you have learned NOTHING from history. many international Jews stand with Palestine today - and AGAINST the state of israhell.

I always align with Yuval! I am a Jewish American woman. I care for all human beings. I do not take sides . The humanitarian thing to do is always the correct thing to do. Thank you Yuval! Thank you to the host for giving him a platform of common sense and morality.

It is very good to listen and learn from this conversation. It offers much hope, not only for the Middle East but the world. Thank you.

Thank you, Yuval! For being one of the few sensitive voices in the mainstream who has the knowledge and uses reason to make sense of what's happening. I've been saying a lot of this things since last month and you're one of the very few who think like to me. It's complex, but not that complex. It's achievable once we know who is who in the conflict. Let's all accept that if it's wrong to say that hamas and Palestines are the same, by the same token, it's wrong to say that Israel's government is the same as Israelis. Not that Israel's government has zero good intentions, as you explained in the beginning. And based on this, we have a lesson for so many things in life. How to move on after a defeat? How to accept a defeat so we can have the chance to win in the future? To hear "we can't save the past, we have to compromise, we can't have perfect justice" is hard. But necessary. Sometimes in life we have to accept the less worse, because trying to reach what we dream as "the ideal" will hurt us and other people. And btw, sometimes the "less worse" is better than we thought and "the ideal" not as good as we thought.

@gaiamelita

6 ай бұрын

Totally agree.

@ricktran3038

5 ай бұрын

Agree 100%

@samirlazrak3304

5 ай бұрын

Sensitive? You call this thing Sensitive? I'd much rather sleep in a room full of scorpions than trust this nutter whilst wide awake

Yuval has the perfect perspective. We need more world leaders that appreciate his views.

@socrat6617

6 ай бұрын

But Mr. Harary did not tell about the origin of his family and what does he do in Hayfa, a Palestinian Town. You might know, that indeed there was other families in this town, wo had been either killed or deparured may be by Harary`s family. It does not matter, the main thing that we had a historical, who should be appreciated by the world leaders!!

Thank you so much for your thoughtful and balanced perspective. So deeply needed. 🙌🏼

I love Mr. Harari! He’s a human being that we should all try to emulate.

@The_Practical_Daydreamer

6 ай бұрын

Didn't he refer to some people as useless eaters?

@kenwoodburn7438

6 ай бұрын

He's a psychopath who wants to transhumanize us all.

@kenwoodburn7438

6 ай бұрын

​@@The_Practical_Daydreamer Otherwise he's just great .... if you're part of the club.

I agree with Yuval’s massage And as Israeli, I must admit that this is the first time I don’t even think about the Palestinian pain. I used to give some space for thinking and caring about the children of Gaza but I’m too anxious about my own people and children pain

@jacobjorgenson9285

6 ай бұрын

Norman Finklestein Avi Shlaim Ilan Pappé

@TerryMcMaster-jw8zr

6 ай бұрын

Well you should be ashamed of yourself

@marinagordon5243

6 ай бұрын

Just check what happened yesterday in Tulkarem. And then answer yourself if you still believe in peace with these people. And, bytheway, before jews and German became friends, fascist regime was destroyed☝.

@eliranlevi6168

6 ай бұрын

​@@TerryMcMaster-jw8zrI love how some western folks who have no stake in the game and reside in their safe country, are pretentious enough to tell us how to feel after hamas terrorists killed 1400 people , abducted 240, beheaded, raped and what not, all in one day.

@guyeshel9316

6 ай бұрын

@@jacobjorgenson9285 What about them?

Wonderful Yuval. Consice and fair minded. Thanks for this sane perspective.

That's a great talk Yuval. Thank you for talking and injecting sense into us during this troubling time. I hope more people get to see naunces and the details in our complex reality than only paint each side as black or white.

I'm a big enthusiast of your words. Your writing is inspiring and impactful. Thank you for sharing your words with the world!. 🇧🇷 @lucianohuck

Yuval, I appreciate that you made a disclaimer at the start and you said that you couldn't be objective, but that doesn't justify you being a propaganda mouthpiece for the apartheid Zi.on.ist state. I though you were a liberal intellectual/academic!

Hello Yuval; I really admire and respect your up-front humbleness of declaring that you are not objective and to check opposite sources to get a better picture🙏. In the same time, a part of me is disappointed that, a person like you, historian, open minded, meditator and who works on compassion, cannot see the disproportion of what is happening on the ground, a d ehat happened in the oast decades, and not asking for a ceasefire. I understand that rhe first week or 2 you would be one sided, but after 6 weeks, 15,000 death, and tens of thousands of injured...entire areas levelled, hospitals, achools.....name it..all brought to the ground; the Istaeli army had already bombed more than what Russian has unleashed on Ukrain in their year plus war, and similar for thr number of death; and yet, no mention of the inequality and the brutal response, and saying only: Israel has the right to protect itself..... is deeply hurting. If you don't see this inside Israel, who will? How can we restore peace or order with all this brutality? aren't we creating multiple Hamas (or future terrorist group's name fighters) for every Hamas death? A child who is living all this pain, and lost his mother and father etc or a father who just lost his kids..... isn't this also a creation of mote and more future suffering? The conflict has always been disproportionate, and all what is happening is a result of cause and effect if you trwat peole like the Israeli gvt treats the majority, what do you expect to get really? I hope that somewhere in your untold thoughts, you have a doubt of thr possibility that your own government had directly or indirectly contributed to the events culminating in this awful and deeply painful and unjustifiable attack by hamas. nite that the hwad of rhe Al Aqsa flood was a 5 year prisoner in Israel...just saying. and he qas killed directly after the attack.... they knew exactly where he was... Time will tell, but I won't be surprised to see Gaza annexed to Israel, or at least putting hand on the oil abd gaz wralrh beneath the ground and sea there. Anyways all my comments are juat a trial to ioen your eyes to what might be painful to see, but I am positive that you have the inner strength to embrace it🙏

@gaiamelita

6 ай бұрын

Interesting comment. I do think Yuval said that the Israeli govt had responsibility to bare for the Oct 7 attack.

I have utmost compassion for both sides. We have two eyes to see, "An eye for an eye makes us blind." We must find the third option when we're blind... Thank you.

Ótima perspectiva trazida por Harari! Adorei a entrevista!

Yuval is brilliant intellectually and emotionally. Great interview

@kenwoodburn7438

6 ай бұрын

He's a psychopath who wants to transhumanize us all!

It is always a learning experience listening to the insightful thoughts of Yuval Noah Harari.

As always with great respect and understanding to the truth. Thank you

As a Euro-Arab I agree and respect Mr. Harari's opinion on this. May we all live in peace.

Thank you Mr. Harari and the editors for your kindness to the world. Every phenomenon in human society comes from one point: the content of our brains. If we have peace in us, the outside world would reflect it. We can have peace by - for example - meditation or using time of our lives only in order to make others happy and to get rid of unhappiness from others. If we use time for others first before we would do for ourselves, the concept of time over the world will change entirely. Human suffers by thinking about oneself. Unsoundness will heal by forgetting. If we forget “time” by using it for others, the world will be cured. Time is the key for the world peace. i want Everyone over the globe to become happy. ❤ G-d bless you.

Muito obrigado pela aula! Concordo com teu argumento e sugestões, teus livros são ótimos e mostro aos meus alunos. Abraços da Amazônia brasileira!

Great work as always Yuval 👍🏼👍🏼✅

Even this incredibly balanced, non-polarizing interview, if you read the comments here many of them are totally polarized. For one “side” and against the other “side”. When will we understand that we are truly all interconnected on this planet earth? Peace has to prevail, there is no other way forward.

@ginette84

6 ай бұрын

You put in words what I feel... "we are truly all interconnected on this planet earth, peace has to prevail..." Terrorists attacks shock me to the core. It reminds me that we are all human and capable of awful acts. I live in a family where hatred reach high level with no justification. For a long time, I have been praying for Middle-East residents, so they could to live in peace together. I live in Canada, a land which still belongs to First Nations people. They were parked in reserves; their kids taken away from age 5 to 15 for assimilation to French and English; prohibitedto talk their language or practice their religion (cultural genocide). They don't send rockets nor come in our houses to torture us. One of their Wise man told me that they had more LOVE for their children than HATRED for us the invador.

Thank you Yuval Harari. Ppl and nations are both victims and perpetrators. With this awareness I am perplexed that there is not simply anti-war protests (like before Iraq) instead of pro this group or pro that group, from the nations outside the conflict 🌿

Noah is honest and such honesty is rare nowadays! This is truly outstanding.

Wonderful insights. If Germans and Jews can become friends and mutual supporters within a lifetime of the holocaust, then there is hope for all animosities and hatreds in this world. That is a profoundly hopeful perspective. Thank you.

I started to seriously fear for Yuval's safety. Criticizing Israel's right wing can be catastrophic. Remember back in 1995 when Yigal Amir attacked Yitzhak Rabin. @Yuval Noah Harari, please stay safe. I beg for your safety 🙏❤

As an Egyptian, we already have a lot of Gazzans who are living in Egypt, and I haven't seen one palestinian who supports Hamas and i was told that personally, but they wouldn't tell so to their oppressors. Israeli governments MUST change their mindset about palestinian civilians. They could have made themselves at least less worse than Hamas terror group .

Thank you for this wonderful interview!

"....to keep the space of peace, this is really the job of outsiders. People and nations, they can be victims and perpertrators at the same time. Mr. Harari, peace is the responsibility of us all, insiders outsiders.yes, and them that don't care. You have inspired me to renew my study of Arabic and Islam. richard e mulcahy

taking a picture was the hit! thanks for sharing this clip

I am a Brazilian living in the US for over 40 years. I am appalled by the direction the world is going. I thought Mr Hulk was just an aloof tv entertainer. I am glad for his thoughtfulness in providing Brazilian audiences with the rational perspective of this horrible situation from the incredibly bright Mr Harari. Thank you.

Yuval, i like that you want good for humanity, you are smart and fair. Please brother yuval if you can do anything to influence anyone to stop the war. Thank you and God bless you Love and compassion in our hearts can make miracles

Speaking of world leaders, how do we elect Yuval?👍👍

I don't know whether Yuval has changed his stance, or I have become rational in the Palestiene-Israel conflict. But the thing is we want peace, peace and just peace.

Congratulations by this amazing and explanation interview about the war today in Israel 🇮🇱, yuval is an espetilist in human rights and history around the world, and Luciano a man that have many knowledge about great nations, very good.

Great work as usual 🥰

Ultimate respect for Yuval ! He is amazing to be thoughtful in the context of a very difficult situation

Mr.Yuval thank you very much!

Thank you both for your insight. Good advice, for a better understanding, listen to both sides. Wise comment : If you have to choose between justice and peace, choose PEACE... Salomon could have said the same thing...

thank you

I have a real respect for Mister Harari but he escape the historical contexte about Israël. He critisise the actual gouvernement of Israël but does not critisise a long history of Israelis gouvernement since the establishment of Israel...Dommage.

@samara6041

6 ай бұрын

Exactly! He’s being so dense. I can’t listen to him anymore.

A melhor entrevista que ouvi...de tudo o que ouvi ... visão clara e legítima! Obrigada, Yuval e ao Luciano também.

Recent investigations showed that the stories of decapitated children, torture and rape had no solid proof and American Journalist also didn't find any names of victims associated with the atrocities. Definitely Innocents were killed and some killing was even done by Israel IDF under Hannibal act. One thing we should do is to talk after getting all our facts straight

Love his point of view 👏👏👏👏👏

Thank you, Yuval Harari!

Very interesting and really balanced and clear opinions of two intelligent and thinking Jews. There is no future without two nations living side by side. There is no future in terrorism. Hatred does not lead anywhere. This video should be widely distributed because it is a summary of what the reasons for the attacks are, and where the solution must be sought.

Something bright is growing step by step in Every Human Heart ... let.s see where it lead us ... very cool expectatives for Yuval ❤

We need a one-state solution where the entire population of Israel and Palestine lives within a space of democratic principles under a country like the US or UK. In democratic and modern state where no special groups of people with certain religions are treated to have more special rights than other groups of people. This also tests the credibility of US as a champion of democracy in action.

@samara6041

6 ай бұрын

💯💯💯

Respect from Brazil.

I liked very much this interview! the issue was discussed clearly describing how the Hamas is dangerous for the world. I hope that this problem finish fast because Israeli and Palestine don"t deserve to suffer this way. While there is war who pay the bii are the civilians not who creates the war. Peace is necessary fast because is unbeliveble anciants, childrens, women, dying this way for Hamas's madness . Yuval Harari thank you very much for your explanation about the war , the world need more respect, tolerance, love and more democracy.

"I want to know with who I¨m speaking" ........ finally somebody made a perfect description !

I have read all Harari’s books and found them very interesting, thought provoking and also concerning in what they depict for the future. I also found this discussion helpful, it is good to see Israelis speak up about the suffering of the Palestinians and make a clear distinction between them and Hamas. I was disappointed however that Harare does not seem to have a very good opinion of the demos, he is clearly a technocrat who appears to think the educated managerial technocratic class should rule & know better than ordinary people in democracies what is good for them. Here we part ways. There would not be a rise in the populist leaders who he finds so distasteful if the governing elites took notice of the very real concerns of the ordinary people over whom they govern. The arrogance of this view is causing great tension within democracies like the U.K. & the US. If he chooses peace over chaos he will be very disappointed in the coming years as ordinary people fight back against their entitled technocratic elites who are destroying the cultures of their countries without so much as a by your leave of the people.

They dont want "Peace" , they want FREEDOM. And Hariri should know the diffrence

@rae516

3 ай бұрын

Palestinians would have freedom if they were peaceful. Arabs/future Palestinians have been committing attacks of terror against Jews in the land of Israel/Palestine since the 1920s. Terror attack after terror attack after terror attack......There's been no end to it. Time and time again, Jews have offered land and peace and they have been refused. When Palestinians put down their weapons and accept the state of Israel, there will be peace. That is the truth.

Usually I like what you say Yuval, but here I must say, I don't agree with you. As long as the Palestinian people are not free to do what they want, live where they want and are always under the hammer of the genocidal zionist far right government, this will never end. The settlers have been very busy in the West Bank in the last month, the killings the settlers are acting out is disgusting and yet it's being aided by the IDF, so, that's another huge problem. Long lasting peace and disarming both sides would be the only way forward to live in peace once and for all. Settlers usually come to Israel and steal lands and houses, so that *must* stop.

@samara6041

6 ай бұрын

💯🎯💯🎯💯

Excelente entrevista, grande entrevistador frente a um grande historiador e pensador de nossos tempos. Apenas uma observação que, na minha opinião, pode não ser clara para todos os ouvintes: é necessário diferenciar Gaza da Cisjordânia. Gaza era um território autônomo e presidido pela organização terrorista Hamas, que chegou ao poder por eleições legítimas - obviamente, sem qualquer ingerência israelense. Parabéns merecidos pela iniciativa e pela excelente abordagem, obrigada

Great interview!

Always clear and morally honest.

Mr. Harare is as always very smart and explains everything so clear.

Last idea give me hope! Thanks Yuval!

The sanctuary we seek in others has instilled a momentary lapse of reason within ourselves. A sanguine expression is now impeached by the conceptualized “essence” of particle discord. An elevated symmetry of congruent “facts” have now been discharged as specious, spurious verbatim construed as intellectual virtue. What has presented itself in “idea” has not transpired in “form.” Therein lies the pity!

@juvenalhahne7750

6 ай бұрын

Se Yuval está sendo justo ou não quanto ao lado palestino, acho menos urgente que a necessidade de cessar o conflito ao prolonga-lo tomando partido. Mas acho injusto cancela-lo como intelectual e pessoa, autor de trabalhos de repercussão mundial, baseado na lógica retroativa de que finalmente descobrimos quem realmente ele é.

@chasefancy3092

6 ай бұрын

@@juvenalhahne7750 Do you want me to start speaking in the language of Jinn. Please speak in English or give us the translation

It's quite strange that he says somebody can be both the victim and the perpetrator, when the civilians in Gaza have nothing to do with and carry no responsibility for what Hamas has done?

Yuval's most salient comment is that YOU CAN'T SAVE THE PAST, AS IT IS GONE!

The hope for all people- is in how we tolerate this open sore on Democracy

@gaiamelita

6 ай бұрын

So much this.

Muito bom.

Caldeirao do Huck. Buena entrevista.

תודה רבה יובל 🙏 תמשיך להיות הקול השפוי שלנו ❤ Luciano, Muito obrigado por ouvir a mais racional de nossas vozes Tem amor Para Barzil aqui, sempre! ❤🇮🇱🇧🇷❤

Love this man!!!!!

We need balanced perspectives like this so that reason and not rage guide actions

It's always such a pleasure to listen to Yuval. His perspective to the issue is humane. And that's THE ONLY WAY FORWARD......

Philosphizing is very easy. It is a very comfortable position to be the good guy, neutral. Taking action is much more difficult.

The question: Is humanity ready, at this moment, to live in a world without borders? Have we a good level of tolerance that allows peaceful coexistence between different religions, different cultures or different ideologies? Does it make sense to force the end of walls, opening of borders, if everything we see is more and more intolerance and rage?

I respect Dr. Harari SO much. What a lovely human being. To me he represents the beautiful Israeli people.

Professor Harari is consistent with himself and with the situation. However, the center of the issue is not Hamas nor the Palestinians who elected them (something that Harari and the media "forget" to mention), but the mutual protection agreement between Saudi Arabia and the United States, and the Saudi Arabia peace agreement with Israel, as required for logistics. Iran does not want these agreements due to its imperial aspirations, it wants to be hegemonic in the region, plans to take over Saudi Arabia for its oil, or both. The excuse will likely be "free Mecca" or something similar. To disrupt the status quo and make any agreement with the US and Israel internally difficult for Saudi Arabia, Iran unleashed its dogs (Hamas and Hezbollah) to attack Israel. The terrorist attack is a populist distraction by Iran to gain sympathy from radical Islamic religious leaders, aiming to destroy the two agreements. Meanwhile, Palestinians and Israelis suffer - and Jews around the world are attacked - for being Jews.

@DaemonJax

5 ай бұрын

The last election was in 2006. More than half the current population wasn't of voting age then. Just something you failed to mention. And are you seriously arguing that the population is responsible for the crimes of their elected government? That would literally justify terrorism.

@sysfx

5 ай бұрын

@@DaemonJax Absence of elections is attributable to popular support (fact), to absence of opposition to heavily armed warlords (fact), or both (very likely). In any case, a people is responsible for the acts of its armed factions, especially when it attacks civilians without declaring war. It is responsible even more when it welcomes terrorists to hide behind hospitals, mosques, schools, and civilians. It is responsible when the money donated to its poor is wasted in attack tunnels and not shelters; rockets and not power stations; bombs and not water/waste treatment plants; weapons and not education; hatred and not love; death and not life. The path Palestinians choose day after day leads to disaster, their own self made disaster. It doesn't take a genius to understand why.

Precisamos de vozes como Yuval, para retomarmos um pouco da racionalidade.

Yuval, you are the best!! ❤

Great interview thanks. As Yuval mentioned, is there someone from the Palestinian side that you could interview that is partial but also somewhat empathic to the Israeli perspective? In order for there to be peace, both sides need to show some empathy and make concessions.

OTOH, you have a point when you say that outsiders can be more objective in helping resolve the conflict. OTOH, outsiders have their own interests and have less at stake, so it's not that simple.

very good.

Agree 💯!

admiration for this brilliant mind

Brasil 🇧🇷🇧🇷

RESPECT to Yuval 🙏🙏🙏

Greetings to you from Morocco. The truth is that Hamas has become the military wing, not only for the Palestinians in Gaza, but for the Muslim Brotherhood in the world. In fact, the Israeli-Saudi rapprochement, which would have paved the way for building confidence and drawing a map for the future Palestinian state, was aborted by Hamas on October 7.

Love listening to yuval 🙏🏼

@marinagordon5243

6 ай бұрын

Till hamas will knock your door. Ah, incorrect. They don't knock.

Using your logic, why is the Israeli government behaving the exact way Hamas wants them to behave?

“Peace is achievable, justice is not”. This is the only realistic way forward.

the peace process for people like yuval is surrender to Israel and forget the Palestinian identity … peace deal is not the same as surrender and cancel the cause which is what the saudi normalization deal involves

@samara6041

6 ай бұрын

Well said!!!

Does the Ben Gurion Canal have anything to do with Israel Hamas conflict?

Yuval please read Ilan Pappé. Get informed. Don’t close your heart. What is happening is indefensable

Türkçe çeviri yapmıyosunuz tam anlayamıyoruz

Extremely difficult to remain objective after the disproportionate vengeance from Israel on Gaza. I think we are passed that point. Sadly.

I understand the narrative and it's clever if you ignore the whole reality of facts. both sufferings are not the same, not in size, cause or reprecussions. to mourn the loss of israelis as the same as the losses in palestine is to put israel in a minority position that it does not belonged since its infancy.

@clarissachevalier9249

6 ай бұрын

the whole "we should condemn hamas because they are a terrorist organization!" is always the same narrative it creates a public enemy (even if its public knowledge that netanyahu financed hamas) but on netanyahu's governments you have "criticism"?? what israel has done in palestine in plain and simply spread terror.. but they are not terrorists? make it make sense

@user-wb6xo6jh3k

5 ай бұрын

We certainly live in obscure times...

To have a glimpse on the Palestinian side, read "Ethnic Cleansing" and "The Biggest Prision on Earth" by another Israeli historian Ilan Pappé.

@emetahava

6 ай бұрын

zzzzzzzzzzzz

@emetahava

6 ай бұрын

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Yuval is my idol.