also people love to say how 'louis is a flop' but he is literally on his world tour right now, breaking guinness world records and his fanbase is so dedicated and loyal. it was also not his fault that he released his solo album much later than harry and niall and he has had so many set backs due to losses in his family yet was still able to produce an album that fans love, that was not for the radio therefore many call it a flop.

@kai-gq1xy

2 жыл бұрын

@C ·i agree!! its like some people only care about charts when some of the worst songs to exist were number 1 hits!! and some of the best music just doesnt get high on the charts but that doesnt make them a flop just because they arent #1 also i love louies so much they literally made me feel so safe and valid

@CakeAnyoneAnyone28

2 жыл бұрын

EXACTLY LOUIS IS DOING AMAZING RIGHT NOW SO FUCK PEOPLE WHO SAY HES THE WORST MEMBER OF 1D AND FLOPPED!

@nocturnenix

2 жыл бұрын

@C · I think Louis and Niall's fanbase are the chillest fandom. Rarely see them get into fights as well.

@menage9136

2 жыл бұрын

@loveutill theendoftimes Liam's songs has outsold Louis globally. That's just facts. Look up "LIAM PAYNE’S DEBUT ALBUM 'LP1' IS OUT NOW" press party....as of fall 2019 Liam was streamed 3.7B times globally...I don't think Louis is anywhere near that today. KZread views is only 1 metric.

@menage9136

2 жыл бұрын

Louis is a great songwriter, but he is still considered the least popular and least commercially successful member out of 1D. It doesn't change the fact he has a dedicated fanbase though and his career is performing "well" in the grand scheme of things.

louis is not a flop AT ALL, we know he is not at the top of the charts, the singles rollout of walls is not good and didnt had a lot of promo, BUT he has a strong and loyal fanbase, not everyone can do that, so im pretty sure that with his second album he will get the recognition he deserves.

@Kaile.28

2 жыл бұрын

Yes! Louis is not chasing radio and that is why he is a “smaller” artist. He has the most dedicated audience and that is how Louis is successful because he needs his fans and his fans need him. In my opinion Louis is the best because he knows without his fans he would be nothing, he has such a strong relationship with his fans and that’s what makes him successful

@gabeash007

2 жыл бұрын

hes not a flop but you just described that hes a flop😭 he has a loyal fanbase but theres like what 20? girl move that album aint going nowhere

@Kaile.28

2 жыл бұрын

@@gabeash007 he has successfully sold out his world tour, smashed world records and done so many amazing things including running a successful festival, please touch some grass

@Kaile.28

2 жыл бұрын

@@gabeash007 you clearly don’t know anything go outside, he had one of the most successful albums of 2020. Louis is quite happy with his smaller fan base but he still has millions supporting him

@loulicious5882

2 жыл бұрын

​@@gabeash007 20? he sold put big venues pk 16k capcity webleys areana. bug venues of asian and latam countries. they arnt 20 to me? stop embarassing yourself gabe ash

I think the difference between Liam and the other guys, and the reason why he never really got as much success despite his potential, is that Liam has no clue who he is. He's constantly changing his style and the music he makes because he has no identity outside of 1D. What he said about Simon promising him to be famous and lead the band makes sense in that everything was planned. He had all these things planned for him on who he was supposed to be that he never had to take the time to figure out what he actually wanted to do. The other guys seemed to have figure that out, and took time before releasing their music and other projects to decide which genre of music they want to make and how they want to present themselves. Liam rushed to bring out music thinking that that was what people wanted. He's done songs for different movies but they never even seem to reach more that 5 million views on KZread. He just isn't consistent. Their was no passion or love in anything he's done so far. Louis' on tour right now and from the videos I've seen from him he seems to be 100% enjoying every second of his time on stage because hes creating something he's in love with. It's the same thing Niall and Harry. They seem to wholeheartedly love what they do. Liam is struggling to even pretend he wants to be there. All the dancing and him being shirtless is just so much with no real reason or happiness behind it. I think instead of focusing solely on music, he should maybe going into voice acting or something since he frequently changes his accent. He needs to take a break from music and find himself because the road he's going down is leaving him with no legacy in the next few years.

@menage9136

2 жыл бұрын

@loveutill theendoftimes That makes 0 sense when TikTok is the future. Look at Charlie Puth w/Light Switch, Halsey w/her recent single, Jason Derulo....labels are paying TikTok for music campaigns.

@graylady3633

2 жыл бұрын

I do believe that Liam has always tied his success to another person or entity; like, yes he and Louis were a power team in writing songs together for One Direction, but he never really branched out with the other boys or wrote with other artists even when the band was together. That is probably the reason why he is reaching out to other, younger artists, because they are looking to network and build more interpersonal industry connections like he is, since he didn't do so when he was actively writing. Cowell and other Syco officials did seem to dote on him A LOT in the beginning of his career, and objectively speaking he was the most well rounded, stably trained, powerful voice out of the group. Anyone else thinking of the Gifted and Talented Program, and how that screwed over so many kids when they hit high school? Same thing applies, just now throw in a couple thousand dollars, alcohol, and a loss of privacy. That being said: management, the label, and media painted him as a responsible, father like figure and that may be true now as well as then, but he was still just a teenager trying to figure himself out. The man is pretty much a child at heart if you watch any interview or fan interaction. Not to mention that his ambition and drive, work ethic and (dare I say) people pleaser complex was unconsciously cultivated and flourished during the 1D days. This may be a theory, or a crazy delusion of mine (because- let's be fair, this is all speculation, I don't know the guy nor his dealings in or out of this industry) but I believe that Liam's label and management still reign heavily over his career. Louis always fought back in terms of getting the entire band a voice and to enable them to make the music they wanted, to an extent of course (Zayn). Liam doesn't have a Louis in his corner in the studio anymore. The TWO multi song EPs that Liam released had zero marketing, zero coverage, and thusly gained zero traction. He later said in an interview with a magazine (one of which featured his rather risqué photoshoot something that he later stated that he really didn't want to do) that he released those EPs full intending to make an album out of them but had felt that the sound wasn't quite him anymore. I don't know about anyone else, but those songs sounded just like HIM- a sound that he may have started with Louis during 1D, but definitely something that had his melodic signature, lyrical flow, all the things that I have come to expect out of a Liam Payne song. And then LP1 comes out and it's...different. I still loved the album, and it was a fun thing to listen to, but it did seem safe and media power washed- kind of like Up All Night was for One Direction. Songs like Midnight, and All I Want (for Christmas) feel more authentic to me (quick side note: All I Want is the one song on the ENTIRE LP1 album that utilized his lower register and his ability to drastically change vocal tones, a deep gravely belt to a clear Broadway level tenor high note- something that he was been able to do since his teens, which is why I believe it was regulated to a bonus track position, because it did not fit the near constant falsetto pitch of the rest of the songs) and those were both songs in which Liam had already had a pre-established professional relationship with when he wrote them, rather than the writers and lyricists that his LABEL introduced and prompted him to work with during LP1. Which if you notice, lyrically the songs don't match him as a person (in my biased, idiot opinion) and resemble the image that the media is trying to push: a shirtless, macho man with a debut album filled with songs about untoward subjects and little narrative variety. I might be crazy, I might be too invested in all this, but I have a passion for music, and it pains me to hear something that I think the artist didn't fully get behind creatively or utilize the full powerhouse they have in their artistic arsenal. I still love his album, and I wish him the best of luck and love in creating his next one. But if he isn't enjoying it, or if the label or management or whomever is trying to influence his voice in any way, shape or form, I can only hope he finds the strength to step back and create what he wants, the opinion of the world be damned.

@menage9136

2 жыл бұрын

@@graylady3633 Ur comment is far too long for me to read, but I read the last paragraph. Basically what I gathered from Liam is he admitted in interviews he was too high/drunk to "properly write music" so he is getting clean/sober this time around to "take it more seriously" (his own words). I'm looking forward to his 2nd era, and I think it will be great. LP1 had some bright spots and is not as bad as what ppl make it. All it lacked was proper promotion and Liam dropped the ball on it ontop of COVID derailing lots of things.

@Kaile.28

2 жыл бұрын

@@menage9136 I don’t think he is gonna do a 2nd era 😂 he got dropped from his label and he needs professional help or rehab. It’s ridiculous that you would think Liam is doing a 2nd era/album 😂 my bet is that he’s gonna quit music altogether. And try to be a good parent to his son, that is if Cheryl wants him to be near bear after the things he said about her.

@menage9136

2 жыл бұрын

@@Kaile.28 Well it's not what I THINK, it's facts. Liam posted clips of him in the studio (and a snippet of a song he's working on) and pictures of him on a set recording a MV. My bet is he's going to resume his music career! Life goes on, ppl like you are just bitter. And AFAIK Cheryl never complained about Liam's role as a father, and Liam is "near" Bear bc they live on the same street lmao.

I was never a fan of One Direction, because I was not within their audience or age demographic. But Harry and Niall to me have had the most interesting and colourful solo careers. Harry has had the most experimental career, all of these risks working in his favour and Niall's down to earth soft rock sound was the most comforting to listen to.

@marlenesummerhayes5343

2 жыл бұрын

Harry had a plan& always courted the American A lister life style even when in 1D but to be fair to had the loyalty to wait till they split, unlike Zayn, Niall had the Irish behind him & they are always supportive of their own,& now he has his golf school, Like Liam needed other things in his life as wall as music

@belle1109

2 жыл бұрын

Louis killing himself to put out unforgettable tour moments.....

@sounds0fmeows

2 жыл бұрын

Niall is the only one that had his music played alot in Canada. nobody else from ID has yet to be heard.. he's got that Jason Mraz style going on with his vocals and instrumental, Naills music is heart warming like sitting around a campfire on a beautiful summer night. he did good for himself musically, and definitely has the best solo music out of them.

liam never really moved on from one direction i think. he knows that anything even regarding 1D will give him attention hence why he constantly talks about them and says about reunions etc. he hasn’t developed any sort of defining characteristics since 1D because his personality is 1D yk

If Zayn promoted his album he also could have done very well . Like his debut album mind of mine was a massive hit. He deserved grammy for that album

@danielamunozl

Жыл бұрын

I think he's not promoting on purpose. It seems like he hates fame and doesn't care about awards.

@miloseviczarko45

Жыл бұрын

@@danielamunozl Zayn doesn't know what he wants at all.

@danielamunozl

Жыл бұрын

@@miloseviczarko45 Si? ah bueno...

@dirrty9387

Жыл бұрын

@@danielamunozl from the way he was treated while in one direction, i am not surprised.

@ralphwiggum1982

3 ай бұрын

Zayn could have honestly been on Harry’s level of fame or damn near close 1D fans loved him and still do his debut was huge he had that other hit song with Taylor Swift as well but I don’t think Zayn ever wanted that type of popularity he’s just now starting to do interviews and put himself out there but I don’t know if he’ll ever match the type of success he had back in 2016-17

Everything Liam does and say now (more like the last couple of years…) just gives me second-hand embarrassment 🥲😭 I’m cringing sooo bad lolol

@TheEarthRealm

2 жыл бұрын

Me too, because I love him (and everything he'd done so far) from the bottom of my heart, and now he's become a different person that I don't even recognize anymore.

harry is doing incredible things…he is probably the most successful artist in the world right now…and talking about sold out shows…lol he sold out wembley two shows in a row and he would have sold out more dates …he is doing residencies at msg and forum …he is in a league of his own… Next i think for me its a tie between Niall and Louis…they are doing pretty well too i think

@zojika9192

Ай бұрын

Well I wouldn’t say he is the most successful artist currently, not at all, but he is most successful between the members of 1D

video ideas/requests: - Zara Larsson: discussing her career or her latest album Poster Girl and why it performed badly. - Anne-Marie: why is she a UK hit maker but not in the US - Becky G: finding success in the latin market music than the english ones - Chloe X Halle / Chlöe: the on the rise duo / solo artist - Christina Aguilera: discussing her latest 3 LPs messy/nonexistent rollout/promotion - The current R&B Girls (Summer Walker, Jhené Aiko, SZA & Victoria Monét)

@reedfoster1923

2 жыл бұрын

I want to know more about Zara Larsson’s “Poster Girl.” It’s a great album but nobody seems to know any of the songs from the album. Just the singles from her first album.

@marymiranda2687

2 жыл бұрын

Oh my god. I love your video ideas!! Especially the one for Anne Marie and Becky G! I would love an analysis on both of their careers! I remember when Becky G's Shower was taking off and she was being marketed as a rapper but then suddenly she's now a latin pop artist and has found huge success in that genre. I'd love to know how it came to that. Why didn't her rapping career take off? As for Anne Marie, she's definitely a hitmaker. Her EDM collabs like Rockabye and Friends really helped boost her career. And her hit song 2002 really got people talking about her. She's also toured with heavy hitters like Ed Sheeran so I find it so interesting that she is not big in the US. I think it's the same as Little Mix. It's the UK curse I think.

@Shad106_

2 жыл бұрын

@loveutill theendoftimes The USA is the biggest music market. KPOP, Adele, Sam Smith, Iggy Azalea, hell even Rihanna all came to America to make it. How many American artist go overseas to further thier career.

@wave7097

2 жыл бұрын

@loveutill theendoftimes like it or not the US was and still the most known/biggest music market. everybody knows that.

@wave7097

2 жыл бұрын

@@marymiranda2687 right!! I don’t know why Becky’s career didn’t take off in America after Shower.. even now she released an english song “They Ain’t Ready” in 2020 I think? and it didn’t go anywhere literally. her last album “ESQUEMAS” sounds so good. same for Anne-Marie last album “Therapy” it’s good too but made no noise their.. for Little Mix, Bounce Back was supposed to be another attempt to break through the US market but didn’t succeed

I do think that Liam’s claims that Simon saying he’d build a boy band around him aren’t truly false bc if you pay attention to the rollout of 1D’s debut album the frontman are Liam, Harry, and Zayn. Eventually the GP would decide in 2012-2013 that they liked Zayn & Harry (especially) more than Liam so he was pushed to the back and Harry was made the “face” and “leader” of the group, and Zayn got all the good singing parts. Liam is clearly confused on his legacy in the music industry. He was just a somewhat talented member of one of the most popular boy bands in the world but that’s it. His solo career was not one many of us where checking for because while in 1D he wasn’t all that interesting.

@autumnschaefer6574

2 жыл бұрын

its also funny because the x factor released that video of nicole and simon putting 1D together and liam wasn't even the first to be put in the band. they picked niall first. but he definitely was the leader at first. probably because of how extremely confident he was at that time. however, part of me thinks that was just narcissism now lol

@miloseviczarko45

Жыл бұрын

Yet Liam is the sexiest of all 1D members. I think he should do more modeling than solo music career.

@deqi1125

Жыл бұрын

@@miloseviczarko45 1) No he’s not. 2) A modeling career isn’t gonna do anything for him. He should just retire from the entertainment industry and pick up an ordinary job or just live off the royalties of 1D music.

As a review said: LP1 is the proof that not everyone is fit for a solo career. Liam might be a talented singer, but a good voice can only take you so far. Releasing generic music after pushing back the album so much is a disastrous move. By pushing back the record so much you give even higher expectations on how good your record will be, but if after years of push backs all you can do is come up Justin Bieber’s rejects you won’t go very far.

@littlelou050

Жыл бұрын

that's a good one! covered it really well. and yes that is the problem with pushing back a release. making fans wait causes them to become impatient. if you don't splash it out of the park it's going to be very easily pushed aside as the outdated album it is. it's only really big artists, smart marketing teams and good music that survive this. unfortunately liam is none of the above.

louis is my favourite for sure. all the obstacles he's faced and getting next to nothing for promo, yet he's still selling out arenas on his first world tour, has made a million dollars in just one concert, has such a powerful fanbase that brought a year old non-single from his album on to the charts, brought his album to number 1 on itunes a year after releasing it out of nowhere, broke the Guinness world record for most livestream concert tickets sold by a male artist in 2020 (beating both niall and liam's livestreams), and has been putting out genuine authentic music that he's proud of that shows his artistry and relatability. he truly is beating all the odds that were stacked against him with all the forced delays of releases and shitty team and personal tragedies. nothing could stop him or his fans. he should definitely be so proud of what he's been able to accomplish, and this is only the beginning! next album with his new label will be bigger! just imagine what he could do if he actually got label support and promo

@purezamagno3135

2 жыл бұрын

He's still nothing compared to Harry's achievement period.

@user-lc3wy7ih8f

2 жыл бұрын

@@purezamagno3135 when did i ask?

@aguedafescuca

2 жыл бұрын

@@purezamagno3135 yes, but remember that Harry was put in frontman position in 1D times. They did not start from the same position.

@purezamagno3135

2 жыл бұрын

@@user-lc3wy7ih8f for you to realize the truth.

@user-lc3wy7ih8f

2 жыл бұрын

​@@purezamagno3135 no idea where you got the impression that anyone cares about your "truth", but if that's what helps you sleep at night lmao

Harry and Zayn have been the only two I’ve heard about since the band went to pursue their solo endeavours. Harry just keeps striking Gold time after time and well with Zayn, I just had high hopes about how well he was doing in the beginning of his solo career.

@CoconutGirl333

2 жыл бұрын

I agree. But with Zayn, I just feel like his way of navigating his career is the complete opposite of Harry. This isn’t a bad thing though, because Zayn was always so lowkey and only cares about sharing his music with the fans without promotion and the typical artist rollout that makes a successful album. Again, it’s not a bad thing at all. They’re both amazing in their own way and i always adored them both (still do!) it just makes me a little sad lol because Zayn would be just as big as Harry if he put himself out there more. But of course, I understand why Zayn wouldn’t want to do it. I’m just glad he still makes music because his voice is just..whewww lol

@marlenesummerhayes5343

2 жыл бұрын

They were in with the American A lister life which sets you up for your music to get played & promoted ,there are great singers& performers who have great careers who would not be known in the American Hype Harry is fine, but apart from his first album & single & one he did with Sia Zayn has never done as well in UK as in America, don’t compare let them do what they want

@menage9136

2 жыл бұрын

@@CoconutGirl333 Zayn is navigating music on his own terms and does not do things in a traditional sense or want what other ppl want. He doesn't want Madison Square Garden or a Grammy. He wants to make music and live a simple life.

@Faridapows

2 жыл бұрын

@@menage9136 That's the thing with Zayn. I think he does want those thing( grammy, msg ) but he doesnt wanna play the industry games/ networking.

@userJFK

2 жыл бұрын

@@CoconutGirl333 took the words out of my mouth finally someone who understands

I was working at a record store when LP1 dropped and nobody bought it 💀

the reality is they were formed as a group because they each could not have made it as solo artists in 2010 - they all lacked in one way or another - Liam was put in the group because he had the most stable vocals but the importance of that diminishes over time as everyone got vocal coaching and improved and so when you have other members of the group who have more interesting personalities and voices, have a better understanding of themselves musically, and is still able to appeal to the 1d fanbase (1d whilst a pop band did draw a lot of rock influences) of course it makes sense that Liam hasn't succeeded as much as some other members. as for personal favourite solo careers mine is definitely Niall - I love his discography, I like his personality and whilst I do love his career the most so far I still see a lot more potential in him as well

Although Harry is obviously ahead of Niall and Louis, it's always Niall for me. He is so emotional with his songs, but can then flip it around and perform rock. He's brilliant performing duos with other artists, and so down to earth. He was my fave from when they each had their individual auditions for X factor, and will remain my fave. He was massively underrated in 1D, along with Louis, but he has proved them wrong now.

@wackywardwoman

2 жыл бұрын

Agree 100% but I worry that his golf has taken front center to his music. No word on any new music

@jvernon9094

2 жыл бұрын

@@wackywardwoman He's stated several times that he is working on NH3, and has chosen the title for it. We all know that Niall won't release a lacklustre album, as others do just for the sake of releasing music. Following COVID, many artists are releasing music in order to get back into the charts. Once Niall has his music set to his highly critical standards, venues and dates have to be set in place around the world, plus a crew has to be contracted. As backing musicians, crews and venues have all been rapidly booked up, it is more difficult to access them now. Yes, he also has his golf business, but other artists have side interests also, and why not? Pressuring him won't help and, as he says, he will release NH3 as soon as it's ready. He has also stated that he can't wait to get out touring again. I believe in him, and know that this album will be fantastic, so I'm happy to wait until that time

Harry has always been my favorite and still is. His music is like no other. He writes from the heart ❤️ My daughter saw him in concert before his new music dropped. It was a canceled concert from the covid times, she loved it. She and her BFF are seeing him in LA in Nov. He's an all around talented guy, music, acting, heartthrob and entertainer!

Harry is just another level.you know he is gonna be next superstar. Niall's solo career is definitely very good with sold out world tours but still is criminally underrated. Louis' solo career is very good too.its not mainstream pop, it's like indie- pop Rock.he has a very good album and sold out world tour. Zayn's solo career was pretty good at first because he did some promotion but i think he is just over the phase of getting popularity and media and just wants to stay private and make music.his music is dope tho. Liam is just all Payne right now.his album sounds like some random poppy songs thrown together.

I like Niall's discography because I like indie folk but Harry's House is a masterpiece.

my favorite will always be louis. i don’t understand why people call him a flop. he is literally on a world tour, and when i say world tour i mean it. he’s been everywhere. his music is not mainstream so it’s not for everyone but he has a solid fanbase and i believe when he drops his second album he will get the recognition he deserves.

@loftyradish6972

2 жыл бұрын

He even came/is coming to Perth arena in Western Australia. We are one of the most isolated cities in the world with a comparatively small population. I know an artist has truly made it when they are able to hold a concert in our arena and actually have people come.

For me I’ll always support Zayn and Harry❤️ As for Liam he needs to find himself and work with great songwriters

@lynnsmithershubbard1896

2 жыл бұрын

maybe collab with other singers instead of solo

@userJFK

2 жыл бұрын

@@lynnsmithershubbard1896 he already did but it still didn’t work out for him

I completely missed one direction - I was too old and not in their target demo. Harry caught my attention with sign of the times, converted me to “fan” with the fine line album and has totally blown me away with Harry’s house. He’s truly on another level in terms of creativity, musicality and performance. I also really appreciate how he’s pushing the envelope with his fashion and branching out into other endeavors like acting. I think he’s a star. I listened to all other 1D’s solo music because I was curious to see if it was good as Harry’s and I would say not even close. However, Niall seems like a really nice dude and I like his indie folksy take and some of his songs are very good.

@marielaita1

2 жыл бұрын

Agreed

Liam Payne wanted to be the next Justin Timberlake so bad and failed miserably

Zayn and Harry for me. They were my favorites in 1D and always looked forward for their parts when they would release their albums. Also just enjoy the type of music they release after the band.

Wasn't a huge fan of one directionbit then I listened to louis' album and his interviews and deep dived into their 1d days and I've been addicted since ... love all the boys solo music but louis definitely is my favorite

@user-je2jx1gd2x

2 жыл бұрын

Omg same 💙

@kaviyaaditi7565

2 жыл бұрын

@@user-je2jx1gd2x eyyyy!! My first song of his was Two of us and I cried lol made me go into the whole album because of the power those lyrics had to move emotions so much .... funnily enough that's my favorite song but I listen to it the least cuz well tears

@aksmia123

2 жыл бұрын

saameee

@luckymo_on

2 жыл бұрын

@@kaviyaaditi7565 this is exactly my experience 😂

@aguedafescuca

2 жыл бұрын

Me too. I fell in love with Louis 'Walls' and then found One Direction songs.

You know I’m a 50 + year 1 D fan, but I have been a Louie fan from day 1 of 1 Direction. . What he has been able to achieve is incredible. He just gives sooo much, he supports all his colleagues and new bands. He gives back over and over to his fans. He is sooo authentic and true. Love him to bits.... beautiful beautiful soul.❤️❤️❤️

The shade. The shade of it all 😂 edit: omg I didn’t realize his first album only reached number 111 on the billboard 200. Out here claiming he outsold everyone despite the fact that *literally all other band mates albums before him* debuted at number one 😂 Even Lois hit number 9, and his first album wasn’t released until years after the band broke up.

Harry has made an impact with the style of music and fashion, because nobody expected it. niall makes music that is very similar to one direction so he plays safe, so if you liked the group's music you will like niall's (and he is very down to earth) Zayn is not interested in being a big musician, therefore his music lately is not mainstream and there will always be a small fanbase that likes that. and i think the same thing is happening with Louis. liam is very..... what you will expect of a "basic straight guy" there is nothing that attracts, nothing interested and also his obsession with one direction is just...

@TheEarthRealm

2 жыл бұрын

What do you mean his obsession with One Direction? Do you mean an obsession with the other members?

@TheEarthRealm

2 жыл бұрын

Also, remember that One Direction fans are the only ones keeping his solo career and influence going at all. Mainstream music listeners aren't the ones checking for him.

His first album had a lot of controversy and from what I’ve heard was lackluster compared to other 1D albums.

louis and harry are actually my favourite members right now i believe liams career turned out how it did was because that in the band, yes he and louis did most of the writing for the group, however liam has said that louis was the lyrics man and liam was the melody, which is evident in their solo careers. liams music wasnt written by him and the ones that were, didnt have good lyrics and therefore made is unable for him to connect with the fans through his music like he could in 1d. and not to mention all of his homophobic comments and problematic past, especially in regards to his support of duck dynasty, both ways being biphobic and making weird comments about harry's non-traditional and feminine way of dressing

Here’s the thing…. I think we all knew who was gonna be the most popular of the boys… Harry had something that the people liked and it’s definitely showing.

Louis, Harry and Zayn are my favs. They're really diverse with their albums and it's really interesting and fun

i was a fan of one direction for a little bit but grew out of it. i remember trying so hard to like liam’s music bc i thought you had to like all of the guys’ music to be an “actual fan”. now i’m more into harry, niall, and recently started getting back into zayn’s music (i don’t hate louis, i love him loads, just his music isn’t my type, don’t attack me 😭). niall has always been my favourite though, i love how he has different sounds on most if not all songs. good video !

Louis' debut was released later in his career and didn't get much promotion, and it was a tough time in his life due to losses in his family. His album wasn't huge but it was still liked and respected by his loyal fanbase because he's an understanding and lovely person. Liam may have outsold him but LP1 was nowhere near groundbreaking or original, and he's massively egotistical about it. There's no way he said strip that down outsold the other members without knowing it was a complete lie

My fave will always be Louis Tomlinson plain and simple, no matter what he does or will do I'm in for it.

Harry was always more engaged with his audience than the other guys. And it only increased during his solo performances. He’s been that way since he was a kid, according to those from his hometown.

@memi8405

2 жыл бұрын

true, but louis has the best relationship with his fanz

@cherylreinell857

2 жыл бұрын

@@memi8405 No way!

@cherylreinell857

2 жыл бұрын

Yes way!

@marielaita1

2 жыл бұрын

Yes, since the beginning. And he was the most mature too. He always knew what he wanted

If you want to market yourself as sensual and sexy, it helps if you actually are those things… Liam talks like he’s drinking again. He has a good enough voice and he’s been on som good songs, but the album fell flat to me. Harry Styles is my favourite. I love his music, he has a very distinct style and he just shines. I really liked Zayn in the beginning, but recently I feel like he’s mumbling too much for my taste. Niall Horan and Louis Tomlinson I really like. They both have some killer songs and lyrics.

Love how he's claiming to be so relevant when he's only ever had one real solo hit, and at the time it came out most people thought it was an Ed Sheeran song

All are unique but Louis is my favorite. We don't know what's going on behind the scenes. Liam and Louis had a lot of stumbling blocks in their way.

never listened to one direction but Zayn and harry are by far my favorite and clearly the most popular for a reason, they make genuine good music

I think Harry Styles is the most successful member from 1 Direction BUT I did not expect that I really thought Zayn would be the most successful member. Anyway i am happy 4 Harry Styles & his success & I'm a fan of him because of how some what relatable & down to earth he seems & also his wardrobe/fashion. I do agree w/ everything said in this video about Liam

Harry’s new album is so so good, I am in love. Also some him a few weeks ago on tour and he was born to do this, incredible and for sure one of the most fun nights of my life ❤️

Sadly Liam is free falling towards a being a holiday camp/ cruise ship entertainer at best. Has a good voice but ironically doesn't have that X Factor.

I would say they all make great music but To Me Niall Is Always my Everything.. he's my inspiration as a Singer till date and I always felt relate to him..

I will alwys support Zayn Malik ..the way he choses himself to known is the thing he putting his art on his album cover to showches his talent ..he is the most kind person ever who got the cruaily of rasism and hate and is ban from the industry by that simon who had so much spare compaing aginst him so proud of him he still stood up .he desrves ao much love and support 💞🙌

Personality wise Louis is definitely my favourite. Same with his fans, the community he has created is my favourite if with the 2nd album he goes more into indie/ rock than he will definitely be top spot on my personal list. Otherwise I currently enjoy niall, Louis and Harry’s Albums but have never liked listening to liams solo stuff

harry on a league of his own rn

harry's solo career will always be the best

Love Harry and Niall's solo careers

Easily the least musically talented and interesting among the 5. He really only ever relied on his looks. And with his self-aggrandizing quips, it's clear this guy still needs the band to keep himself from resorting to controversies just to cling to whatever his warped concept of relevance is. Unfortunately for him, that ship has sailed long ago.

seems like he needs to be on a different label. a boring album that keeps getting its release date pushed farther and farther back is one of the most obvious sign the label does not care about that particular artist at all.

I love louis and niall’s music the most, only recently im into harry’s with his new album harry’s house. Im a big louis fan but i gotta say harry has the biggest fandom.

Can you please make a video comparing all the 1D members solo careers from the start to now??

Seriously Zayn will always own my heart, because of all the hate he got. Who sings like Zayn Malik? No one.. I hope he can tour and continue to make, produce and create all the music he wants on his terms, when he is ready..I adore Harry as well. The showman of the group has not disappointed. Who works harder than Harry. No one.

He should have done the Zayn strategy. Release the album a few weeks after Strip That Down. Zayn did the same with his debut album. Pillowtalk was massive and the album followed shortly after when the song was still doing well. The other singles all flopped but the timing was right. So Liam should Have released LP1 a week after the lead single

@menage9136

2 жыл бұрын

My theory is Liam was struggling with substance abuse issues and that delayed the album a lot. He even mentioned it himself he went into a downward spiral after 1D and even on his song "weekend" it's about him almost dying every weekend bc of heavy partying.

@userJFK

2 жыл бұрын

Whoa let me correct you there Zayn’s first album didn’t flop it was literally no.1 on billboard 100 let’s speak facts and not opinion thanks

@Philipp19967

2 жыл бұрын

@@userJFK dude learn how to read. I said Zayns first album did well because of the strategy to release the album RIGHT after the successful lead single and Liam should have done the same. Because his follow up singles flopped just like Zayns. Only Pillowtalk was huge but he used this and released the album at the right time

@menage9136

2 жыл бұрын

@@Philipp19967 None of Liam's singles before LP1 could be considered flops. They were considered streaming monsters (at the time) and all have over 100M streams. Liam's LP1 was a flop bc his team jumped ship with promo, marketing and Liam wasn't sober when creating the album. It was still good but nowhere near what his fandom wanted.

@Philipp19967

2 жыл бұрын

@@menage9136 none of the following singles matched strip that down in terms of sales and peaks

Can I give you some ideas? Re-imagining rollouts for the following albums: Katy Perry-Smile Taylor Swift-Reputation AND Lover Beyoncé-B’Day I’ve written out my own rollouts for these albums Can you also elaborate the legacies and impacts of pop stars like Gaga, Britney, Madonna, MJ, etc? I know you already have videos like this though.

@johnadams7145

2 жыл бұрын

For Smile, I would shelve the whole record and either go full experimental, full acoustic/rock, or full dance pop. But as a KatyKat, outside of a few songs, Smile is bland and forgettable.

@RhapsodyHC

2 жыл бұрын

@@johnadams7145 Dance Pop would’ve been so good for her especially when Gaga did similar with Chromatica. All she needed to do was work with Zedd, Tiesto, and Alesso more and release it. But then again Only Love, Cry About it Later, and Not the End of the World would’ve been sacrificed, and that would’ve hurt me.

@jasastopar

2 жыл бұрын

Also Nickis "Queen"

As a group of solo artists from a boy band One Direction have been unusually successful. Harry has been the most successful because he's crafted a striking image/brand and made music that is off-beat and distinctive. Niall I would say is the next most successful of the five because he actually writes the best songs and is quite motivated. I'm sure Niall is looking at Harry and is thinking how can I make a better album than Harry's House. I'll give the next position to Zayn as he has put out a lot of music much of which is quite interesting. Zayn just doesn't do the music business and has squandered his talent. Even a few tv appearances and concerts would have had Zayn competing up there with Harry. Louis should really be in position three for success because his album is way better than the critics want you to think. I think it's still early days for Louis as he is a strong songwriter, is doing amazing on his world tour, and is a very smart and honest artist. His authentic nature is a real plus in his musical potential. In last place despite having one of the best voices is Liam. Liam went for the hit sound and only had a few hit singles because he is not in his music. It's a plastic performance to be successful. Liam needs to realize he is the British Michael Buble and put out a perfect album of adult music and watch his success sore. A One Direction reunion only gets more interesting with the solo journey of each member.

@Alittleb1tter

2 жыл бұрын

This is spot on with my thoughts- especially with regards to Niall and Harry. Niall is the best songwriter and I think he's got greater creations up his sleeves. He's relentless in honing his craft. Fully anticipating for him to gain more accolades and acclaim in the future, whether that be as a solo artist or writing for other artists. Harry is the one with the alluring persona and charm, that even when the music doesn't immediately grab me, it still adds to the intrigue that is 'Harry'- if that makes sense, lol.

Liam needs some career lessons from harry lol.... Some stats of harry for the goofs out there: - three number 1 albums in the us and two in uk, the third being charting number 1 in almost every country - two number 1 singles in us and 7 in the top 10, as it was being the top single in uk since 9 weeks, only artist after Drake to chart all the songs of his album in the top 30 - multiple award nominations and wins including Grammy, aria, ama, billiboard etc - currently the 4th most streamed artist on spotify with 70+ million listners, as it was made the guiness record for most streams by an artist in a day... He has more than 10 billion streams - sells out stadiums and shows - and most importantly a humble guy who spreads kindness So you guys need to stop comparing and stop acting like a clown as liam is behaving

I didn’t even know liam was part of one direction and made strip that down until I saw that comment about outselling all the former members

For me personally Niall’s music is my favourite he is an amazing lyricist and his music is calming . But I also really enjoy Harry’s music , just like everyone else tbh . Sign of the times deserved so much more when it came out back then

Honestly, you could tell just from watching One Direction that Harry and Zayn were going to be the successful two out of the band. They are extremely more talented than the other guys.

hoping to see a sigrid album analysis here someday💙

Next: What made Harry's Harry;s House impactful?

@MohamadFirdausCheIsmail

2 жыл бұрын

Cohesiveness and lyrical authenticity

Harry Styles!

Not really related to Liam or 1D but when you mentioned other videos I’d love to see you do one about Miley Cyrus & Her Dead Petz era, I’ve yet to see any music channels cover that era in detail.

Zayn and Niall, musically and aesthetically are my favorites.

tbh, if you would've told me in 2012 that niall would have a more successful solo career than liam, i wouldn't have believed you. most of us thought he'd be one of the most successful

@autumnschaefer6574

2 жыл бұрын

i really thought it would be harry and liam as the most successful. man, was i wrong lol

Liam was always my favorite. I thought he was the most handsome and mature of all the 1D members. He was the one I would have wanted to meet, for sure. But man, did he really fall from grace with his solo albums. And then to go on Paul's podcast and say he was the best selling one of all the members when he was no where close... that's just bad form. As a Liam Stan, I'm disappointed.

He got big headed cuz he thought he was the leader of 1D which then lead him to believe he had it easy and it’s royally screwed him over…

@lynnwinter1784

2 жыл бұрын

I think his drinking was / is a problem. He was drinking a lot during his bombshell interview recently when he said all those stupid things that put him on everyone's shit list.

Liam comes across to me as "dumb sexy". The guy can sing fine, but I think he's at his best when he just stands there and look pretty 😂

Niall solo album 💿 is amazing 🥲.

Harry

WHY would you release a project at the end of the year?!?! December releases are always doomed to fail, due to Holiday music bombarding the airwaves and streaming platforms, year-end lists are already done, the grammy cut-off date was a few months prior......Even if the record was okay, it had ZERO chance of performing well.

However Liam has recently given interview which has thrown so much hate towards him. Considering everything ALL the 1 D boys have been through... Liam is doing Ok. He also just needs love and support to find his own self, he tooo is a beautiful person. Don’t throw him away with all this negativity. Just show support, because it is a dog eat dog world in the music business. Just look at how Niall has never toured his Hearbreak Weather album. Great album, every song beautiful. Just show support, it’s easy to throw anyone under bus.❤️❤️

Harry is my favorite he's doing really well louis n Niall are amazing at what they do too Zayn too of course Liam on the other hand I tried really hard to get into his solo career( since after 1d disbanded all I wanted to do was to support all their solo careers) n I was just not feeling it the only song I liked a little from him is bedroom floor tbh

For me, zayn is the most successful one

louis, harry and Niall are my faves

liam outsold taylor swift (he wishes)

He has fans?

My fav was, is and always will be Louis. I can't understand why people call him a flop when he is selling out arenas and his headlining festival of 17000 audience was sold out in 24hr. Also to those who are accusing him of larry baiting, please give him a break. Us louies love Louis for who he is and his music. From his beautifully unique voice to his amzing personality, we love him with all our heart. Yes, I am a louie and a larrie. But I will continue supporting and loving him even if Larry wasn't real. I don't care about charts or critics either. Louis and his music saved me and I'll forever be greateful for that.

@marielaita1

2 жыл бұрын

Maybe he is gonna be bigger when he releases his new album. But he has the weakest voice, thanks god his fans make all the job in his shows

@thaephyu2891

2 жыл бұрын

@@marielaita1 You call it weak. I call it unique. Agree to disgree. I found Louis at my worst and I'm not exagerrating when I say he saved me. I guess your fav may be Harry or Niall. That doesn't mean u have to throw shades at Louis. The irony is that Harry is all about TPWK and you are here sending hate to his mate unnecessarily.

@marielaita1

Жыл бұрын

@@thaephyu2891 it’s not shade. I just don’t like his voice. And his music is just fine for me. I don’t feel the need to listen twice. Don’t be dramatic.

I am currently obsessed with Niall. Have you listened to heartbreak weather? I like some of harry's songs but they are a miss for me a lot of the time because they're not my vibe. I have honestly never listened to louis before i would appreciate your favs of his as reccomendations

@marielaita1

2 жыл бұрын

Harry’s house >> heartbreak whether. But still like it

This video described my opinion on Liam best - career wise. His album really felt void of personality and generic. For a sophomore or junior album, I could see that happening for LP1 but for your debut solo album, this was (no pun intended) the wrong direction. The production was not special on this, sadly.

liam’s music is unremarkable as helll 😬😬

Honestly I’ve only heard 3 songs from him Strip that down For you Naughty list And two of the three are colabs

@jennifer1462

2 жыл бұрын

all three are colabs or featured somebody

i mean... i really dont like lp1, the only song i like is polaroid so yeah... and honestly at this point, i cant back up or support Liam anymore, like, he doesnt have bops, his last succes was like 5 years ago and he cant keep himself from being problemtatic and it makes me sad because his voice is AMAZING and he was part of of mine and other people's life but his music just lacks of life and im afraid now its too late to reverse the damage and get second opportunity. And my favorite carries are Niall's (probably my fav), Harry's (it was obvious he was going to be the most succesful) and Louis :)

Everybody knows who is the biggest one. Even a few people mentioned him. Love you H

I’ve been a fan of the boys since the very beginning and love each and every one of them equally for their talents and different personalities but I personally disliked the path Liam was taking in his solo career. I felt like all the other boys were either experimenting with different genres aka Niall who went down the path of almost country pop, Louis who went down the path of almost being influenced by pop rock but knew he wanted to use his experience of grief throughout his music, Harry also pop rock however experimenting with different decades and zayn who went down the path of R&B. However with Liam I personally felt he wanted to to try and keep it safe and followed the same path as 1D or Justin Bieber and as a result did not work for him. I mean it’s completely fine he wanted to follow down the path because it was his first time stepping out into the solo career and he wasn’t used to that environment but I just felt it was restrictive and he wasn’t able to demonstrate his creative side. We have all clearly seen he can be a great song writer but let’s hope his next able does him the actual justice he truly deserved.

To me Liam was a bit lazy I thought... He didn't seem interested enough to write his own lyrics and didn't take the time that was needed to get his music out in time... He has a loyal fan base for sure I know I'm one, but it seems he's just not interested as much as the rest of the former 1D... Hazza is a fireball rite now you can see smoke coming out of his heels if you look closer... He's unstoppable... Liam needs to get that spark bac that drove him to The X Factor in the first place... When he does he'll be on fire again... I have faith in him... 🌿🌹🌿

No offense to Liam Fans but he hasn’t even come close to outselling anyone. I’m saying this frankly cause the numbers speak for themselves. In terms of personal success, Harry has done the most his second album alone proved that. Plus winning a Grammy, (wether you like them or not) places him with no room for debate at the top of most successful. The rest are a toss up, Zayn is the second most successful if you ask me but with his lack of promotion for his music the numbers aren’t as good as they could be. (Also I believe if he didn’t snub then Grammys he would have one). I personally put Liam last in terms of comparable success or accomplishments. Other than strip that down which is mediocre at best he hasn’t done anything and I most certainly don’t see him. “Being the front runner or leader of the band.” But honestly this is just my opinion on the matter. You don’t have to agree but facts are facts and those are undeniable. Liam has accomplished little to nothing compared to his time in One Direction. If you ask me he never will 😕😕.

@menage9136

2 жыл бұрын

Before Fine Line, Liam was outselling him and considered the most commercially successful solo 1D member as of Fall 2019. Look up "liam payne LP1 press party" his label said it in a press release.

@HimaaBinoo

2 жыл бұрын

@@menage9136 Get from under my comment bullshit. This isn’t even worth a rebuttal.

If I had to rank them I would say (1-10) Harry Styles (9) Louis Tomlinson (8) Zayn Malik (8) Niall Horan (6) Liam Payne (5) And that’s how it’s always been for me

i think one major reason liams album flopped so badly was that as soon as it was released, he had a new major controversy that made people not want to buy or support his new album in anyway. I've listened to all their albums at least once except for liam. once i heard the few singles and heard what he was actually writing about, i knew it was gonna be a bad album. despite the album issues, I also don't think he's a very good person. he continuously finds himself dissing his former bandmates in some way or another. so much so that in his most recent controversy, he didn't even mention harry after that major backlash from the last time he insulted him. so in my opinion, that's another reason why I don't think his album did well. my favorites will forever be harry and niall. they are consistently good and are always very respectful of the fans and of the former bandmates. liam had so much potential, but he honestly ruined that for himself

He never had a proper sense of self when it came to his persona or what he liked which is why he’s coating genre’s attached to anything he can get

poor liam ahhhhhhh

He's trying too hard to be this hiphop artist, when the fans really wanted something authentic, not this macho posturing that very few people like nowadays. I think his style needs to evolve if he wants to remain relevant, while of the same time keep working on those insecurity issues.

Love 1D😘💚💙🇮🇪❤💛

remove those hands he said

The Chris Kirkpatrick of One Direction..😂

Harry & Zayn are killing it as far as careers are concerned, due to their success in the US. The American Market is difficult to penetrate. Much as I like Liam, he needed to restructure his career. He is going thru the hotshot DJ route, like David Gueta & Calvin Harris, and its not working out. He should embrace his matinee idol pedigree and come up with catchy, hook laden pop songs to drive the fans crazy.

@marielaita1

2 жыл бұрын

What are you talking about? Zayn’s last two albums are flops, nobody is listening, just zquads. Harry’s got three number one albums and filled two wembley, and the grammy and four movies. Don’t put them in the same level cause they are not

can we get a video on how Gaga's A star is born era turned out to be so successful It topped Born this way in sales, charts, streams and etc...

About Zayn please