5:05 Well said. Very safe answer, Prof. 🙌

Very well said. We should consider a language is a language if the two persons talking cannot understand each other though they have the same accent, and intonation. Bikol have the same accent and grammar construction with Cebuano, but they cannot understand in other words used therefore they are different languages. Bol-anon and Siquijodnon have different accent and intonation compared to Sugbuhanon or Central Cebuano but similar words and sentence construction in used, likewise can understand each other, therefore it's dialect a variation of Cebuano. Waray is different because they have similar words used but different in meaning, though they have the same accent and intonation. Same with Hiligaynons, there are words that similar to Cebuano in used but different in meaning. Therefore they cannot understand each other or else war exists if you insist that they are both the same because I myself can speak these languages and sometimes I think first before I speak due to some reasons that I used words that both cannot understand but they are using on it.

- There are 100 languages. - Languages are broader, and dialect are smaller and more specific, and often regional. - Dialect is a variation of language as long as the two people understand each other.

-Languages are broader, and dialects are smaller and more specific Language allows us to share our ideas, thoughts, and feelings with others. Dialects Retain Identity Many cultures use different words or pronunciations for the same thing. Unique pronunciations help give a culture its identity.

Dialect is a variation of language...

Three things: 1) dialect is variation of a language. Ex. Iba tagalog sa quezon province kumpara valenzuela, or bisaya sa bohol kumpara surigao. Same language pero may variation (dialect) 2) bisaya, binisaya and cebuano are one and the same. Parang tagalog/'filipino' language. Waray-waray (eastern visayas) and hilagaynon/ilonggo (western) are separate LANGUAGES. Di sila 'dialect' ng cebuano/bisaya 3) colloquially, bisaya is a language (cebuano/binisaya), while visayan refers to lugar/geography Kaya an ilonggo is visayan (lugar) but not bisaya (language), while a dabawenyo is mindanaoan (lugar) but also bisaya (language)

The prof's answer to the origin of language maybe true ONLY for spoken languages. Languages can be purely (1) oral/verbal, (2) visual or (3) written ..or a combination of any of the 3. Early humans/humanoids may have used a language even before, or way after, they had the ability to "speak" or make sounds with their voice. Where or how did language start? It started with the need for beings (humans/animasl) to communicate (to express and to be understood). Language is cultural.... so the origin of language cannot, or can never really be established (unless you can definitively establish the start of culture), because sounds/gestures/signs/writings do not have meaning unless these matching of signs/words+meaning is mutually agreed upon/shared/used by a group or community.

My three takeaways *Language involves both the ability to comprehend spoken and written words and to speak and write. * Dialect is a viration of language *Dialect is a important specially when you are talking with someone

Armila C. Cantuba -Dialect is a variation of language as long as two people understand each other. -If a two people speak in different variation and cannot understand each other it means language. -The origin of the Language is still not unknown.

My 3 takeaways: *Dialect is a variation of language. *Hyoid bone enable us to say,speak and do things. *until now the origin of language is untraceable.

My native tongue is Bikol Legazpi -Tabaco-Sorsogon and it is a dialect of Bikol Central language.

Jennifer V Flores - We should learn about the differences between language and dialect -Dialect is important specially when you are talking with someone -until now the origin of language is still cannot trace.

Can we have more videos like this! This is amazing!

I am VISAYAN but I speak Chabacano fluently, also spelled CHAVACANO. These languages such as VISAYAN (Bisaya) HILIGAYNON (Illongo) FILIPINO (Tagalog) are mostly infiltrate this foreign language so-called CHABACANO (Creole Spanish).

@Sweet-bx2ec

2 жыл бұрын

Filipino ≠ Tagalog

Very informative ..👍

Salamat sa pagupload.

I can speak Javanese, Indonesian, Tagalog and a little bit of English.

Such a good explanation 💓💓💓

Marunong ako mag Chavacano at Bisaya. Ang masasabi ko lang, sinusunod ng Chavacano ang grammar ng Filipino. Ang placement ng verbs ay nasa 1st position ng sentence. Halimbawa, Kumain ka na? (bisaya) Hingkaon na ka? (chavacano) Yacome ya tu?

Kawawa ang mga Pilipino tagal na nilito ng DepEd. Delikado ang maling pagtuturo naipapasa ang pagiging ignorante.

@macoswatkpop686

2 жыл бұрын

Manlilinlang ang DepED, kung alin ang mali yon ang tinuturo ng DepEd nililinlang nila mga walang muwang na Pilipino

@thereseclaire9806

2 жыл бұрын

Oo nga especially the Tagalogs no hate. Ung school ko mismo nagsabi sa amin that Bisaya, Ilokano, and the rest are dialects and Tagalog is THE LANGUAGE. It hurts deep inside kasi pagnaririnig nila ung Bisaya, parang nadidiri sila or they classify it as "native" while taking pride that Taglog is a high class Filipino language. This doesn't apply to all Tagalogs but to those ignorant Tagalogs I know. It really hurts char

@krukrok5218

2 жыл бұрын

@@thereseclaire9806 Yeah it's terrible to realise this as a language enthusiast. We should embrace diversity.

@eljsusvillatv7438

2 жыл бұрын

@@thereseclaire9806 sa totoo lang po Mas nagandahan Ako sa bisaya Kasi matapang Sila mag salita kisa sa tagalog

@thereseclaire9806

2 жыл бұрын

@@eljsusvillatv7438 thank so much po!❤️ all languages are beautiful ❤️

Still useful til now

Good

Bakit wala man lang nag bigay ng tubig????

Maraming mga tao lalo na karamihan sa mga Taga LUZON na alam nila ang LAHAT sa bu-ong pilipinas Ngunit binabasa Lamang ang mga libro sa pagkat Hindi naka punta sa lahat ng mga Lugar sa bu-ong Visayas at sa bu-ong Mindanao dahil ang nangungunang ginagamit na salita sa bu-ong Visayas at Mindanao ay Cebuano or benisaya language.

Kahit ano pa sabihin nila kaya wikang Tagalog ang isa sa napili at ginawang National Laungauge hindi dahil para alisin sa Pilipinas ang ibang Language or Dialect ng mga locals sa ibatibang lugar ng buong bansa kaya ginawa ang Tagalog at English maging National Language dahil sa pinaka 2 Rason Unang Rason Ang mga wikang ito ay mag identity na tayo ay Filipino Pangalaw para magkaintindihan ang Lahat Kaya dalawa ginawang Major Language sa Pinas Tagalog for internal communication dahil kung lahat ng salita pagaaralant ng pinoy at gawing major language lahat Tingin nyo sa Filipino subject palang mahihirapan na ang Estudyante magaral dahil sa daming language pagaaralan At kaya ang English naman ang ginawang 2nd major language naman for international communication Un lang dahilan dyan logic lang yan kaya wag kaya magtalo kung ano ang tunay na salita nating mga filipino lahat ng wika dito sa Pilipinas lahat yan ay wika ng ating bansa kailangan lang talaga mag karoon ng national Language for a good Communication eh kung magkanya kanya tayo salita dito sa pilipinas eh baka mag kadigmaan lang sabihin ng bisaya ihiwilay nya ang Bisayas gawin nya sarili nation ganon din tagalog ihiway nya katagalogan region dahil sa di magkaintindihan eh di lalu lang lumiit ang ating bansa natin dahil magaya pa tayo sa north and south korea sila di sa salita nahati bansa nila dahil lang sa ideolohiya😂😂😂

My three takeaways in this video; * that we have 100 laguages. * learned about the difference between laguage and dialect. * that chavacano is a combination of Spanish and a little bit of Cebuano.

Water. Tubig. Where's the intern?

Si prof felipe jocano to eh

Bigyan nyo naman ng tubig nasamid na nga eh

@ralpharzagon290

3 жыл бұрын

haha hayp nasamid ako

Nainis ako sa interviewer

Inuobo pa talaga si prof

well on my own opinion. language is national speakers on one country. dialect form of many city, province, dialect speakers..

@jasonquinones4901

2 жыл бұрын

un/fortunately, opinions doesn't count. The differences of a language vs dialect have already been established by Linguistics experts, not by opinion, but by objective facts.

@jasonquinones4901

2 жыл бұрын

While majority of the Canadian provinces speak English, a substantial population/provinces speak French. So what then is Canada's language? Is French then, only a dialect?

@dore3faso6sido

2 жыл бұрын

Language for daily conversation needs 5k words Language for communication /education/trade/technology needs 15k words Language must have 15k vocabulary /words Otherwise its call dialect. Filipino / tagalog have 25k words Illocano visaya and others didnt have 25k words

@macoswatkpop686

2 жыл бұрын

@@jasonquinones4901 oo nga mali , ang pakahulugan niya

@macoswatkpop686

2 жыл бұрын

Sa science tayo magbatay hindi sa opinion

According to stupid and idiot(Sariling opinion,imahinasyon) Dialect means regional,local,indigenous language According to dictionary(Katotohanan) Dialect means distinct and regional variety of a language Kaya ang dialect ay variation ng wika. English dialects is the variation of distinct version of English language. Spanish dialects is the variation of distinct version of Spanisn language. Bawat wika ay may kanya kanya dialect May mga dialects ang wikang Tagalog. Walo ang dialect ng wikang Tagalog. Anim ang dialect ng wikang Hiligaynon. Anim din ang dialect ng wikang Cebuano. Dalawa ang dialect ng wikang Itneg at ng wikang Ilokano, tatlo ang dialect ng wikang Ibanag. Nasa labing tatlo aabot ang dialect ng wikang Bikolano. Ang dialect ay variety ng wika. Kaya ang dialect ay sanga ng wika. Language vs Language Hindi nagkakaintindihan dahil pareho silang magkaiba ng katutubong wika na ginagamit. Halimbawa nag-usap ang German native speaker sa Chinese native speaker magkakaintindihan sila hindi dahil pareho silang may magkaibang ginagamit na katutubong wika. Hindi nagkakaintindihan ang Bisaya sa Bikolano at sa Ilokano. Dialect vs Dialect Nagkakaintindihan ang mga taong gumagamit. Dahil pareho ng wika kaya nagkakaintindihan. Kapag nag-usap ang mga Tagalog magkakaintindihan. Ngayon may ibang version ng pag Tatagalog ang taga Laguna sa taga Quezon. Yan ang dialect ng wikang Tagalog. Pareho sila ng wikang ginagamit ngunit may pagkakaiba sila ng paggamit o bersiyon ng paggamit. Dahil hindi nagkakaintindihan halimbawa ang Native Speaker ng German sa Native Speaker ng Chinese. Ano gagawin nila para makipagcommunicate gagamit sila ng English na pareho nilang inaral. Yan ang tinatawag na Lingua Franca. Upang magkakaintindihan ang Bisaya at Ilokano dahil hindi sila magkakaintindihan dahil pareho sila may sariling wika. Ano ang gagawin nila? Gagamitin nila ang Filipino upang mag-usap. Kaya ang Filipino ay siyang naging tulay sa kumonikasyon yan ang tinatawag na Lingua Franca. Ang Lingua Franca ng buong mundo ay Ingles. Samantala ang Lingua Franca ng Pilipinas ay ang Filipino. Logic Hindi ba sa dami ng wika sa mundo kaya hindi nagkakaintindihan ang mga tao sa balat ng lupa. Kung sa dami ng wika sa mundo kaya hindi nagkakaintindihan ang tao sa balat ng lupa. Hindi ba sa dami din ng wika, kaya hindi nagkakaintindihan ang mga Pilipino sa Pilipinas hindi dialect. Kaya nagkakaintindihan na ang tao dahil sa Lingua Franca. Gaya ng sinabi ko ang dialect ay sanga lamang ng wika. May mga dialect ang wikang Arabic, French at Aramaic. Bigyan ko kayo ng halimbawa Ano ang wikang ginamit ni Jesu Cristo? - Wikang Aramaico Anong dialect ang ginamit ni Jesu Cristo? -Galilean Aramaic kaya ang Galilean Aramaic ay matatawag nating dialekto ng wikang Aramaic. Language: Aramaic Dialects: Palestinian Aramaic, Assyrian Neo Aramaic Language: Japanese Dialects: Kansai dialect, Ibaraki dialect, Mikawa dialect, Tokyo dialect Language: Tagalog Dialects: Manila dialect, Tanay Paete, Morong dialect, Tayabasin, Batanghenyo ,Bataan, Bulakenyong Tagalog, Caviteñong Tagalog.

kkk

Cebuano is Language! Pero dialect nila mga waray, ilonggo at iba pa, kasi magkakaperaha naman pero naiba lang sa intonation o accent sa pagbigkas, may napalitan lang ng konti.

@JVPCHANnel

3 жыл бұрын

Yes and no, cebuano is a language and bisaya is a dialect because may mutual intelligibility. Which means nag kaka intindihan kahit may pinagkaiba sa tone or accent. Waray and ilocano are both distinct language kasi walang mutual intelligibility. Meaning wala kang maiintindihan. Ibang iba language nila

@dailyviewstv5323

3 жыл бұрын

@@JVPCHANnel, Bisaya refers to the whole language of VISAYA speakers. Cebuano is their main language, most of them can spoke Cebuano(Waray, Boholano, ilonggo, karay-a etc)..

@JVPCHANnel

3 жыл бұрын

@@dailyviewstv5323 i know meron din bisaya/Binisaya na dialect its like cebuano but different accent.

@MillenialsCotabato

3 жыл бұрын

Cebuano is language, their dialects are: Bol-anon, Siquijodnon, Dumagueteño, Davaweño, Bukidnon, Misamis, Pagadianon. Kidapaweño, etc. Bisaya is people living in Visayas. Binisaya is another term for Cebuano because other Cebuano-speaking decline to accept the Cebuano as their tribe because they're living outside Cebu. They consider Cebuano as the people living in Cebu as Davaweño living in Davao.

@dailyviewstv5323

3 жыл бұрын

@@MillenialsCotabato, Bisaya is at from Visayas?... Huh!.. The visayan speaker in Mindanao!?.. Most of them migrated hundred of years from visayas! What do you call them?.. Visaya is a tribes spread through out Philippines, they speak only in their own intonations and accent, but if listen properly, it is the same words but have a little changes of intonations and words.. But you can tell them, they are one.. That the reason Luzonian call them BISAYA... Think this! The British migrated in America(USA), because mixed in other languages, created a new accent but still English.. The Latin, they evolved in different language but still called them LATIN.. the Spaniards, french, italian, Portuguese etc..

Thank you for the clarifications. Now I'm finally enlightened. 🤍