mere dil ki baath aap bola aaj rahul bai.....since 40 years iam a big big fan of kishorda sir...thanks lot aap sachai bola...jeethe rahoo bai hamesha👌👌👌❤❤❤👍👍👍

@70mmwithRahoul

Жыл бұрын

Thank you Abdul Kader sahab for watching the video and sharing your comments.

@kousiksarker104

Жыл бұрын

People who don't understand music compare Rafiq Sahib and Kishoredar both are great

Mohd Rafi speaks for himself. No comparison. They respected each other.

Both versions are good. Both are legends. Comparing is futile. There is no point comparing great artists. They both would have laughed when people compare them. Its like comparing apples to oranges. Human nature is such that people are always looking for rivalry to get a kick. Leave them alone in their heavenly abode.

@pradeepkumarupadhyaysonu9132

Жыл бұрын

Great किशोर कुमार

Both Rafi sahab and Kishore da were fantastic in their own ways.

I like Kishore very much. But I disagree with you on this. Listen to Rafi version 4-5 to 8 times. He has also sung the best way It's the TUNE that's doesn't SUIT the LYRICS. Take this factor in account. In Kishore's version, TUNE and LYRICS both complement each other. Think again 😊 👍

In Rafi Saab version wording were different and tune was bit slow but in Kishore Kumar version lyrics was totally different and rhythm was fast so it was totally two contrast version hence you can't compare them but you are very big fan of Kishore sir so what could be said!

@sureshsreedharan5579

Жыл бұрын

you re right.

@fawadkashif

Жыл бұрын

yes

@vilasshriram9851

Жыл бұрын

Ur actually narrow minded and brainwashed by islam. U cannot see n r not supposed to see d good of other religion people.

Kishor Kumar was no doubt a great ... Rafisaab is Rafisaab . versatility ..Emotions .expressions and blending his voice with an actor simply outstanding ..

भाई साहब आप तो अंध भक्ति की हद तक किशोर भक्त हैं, इतना कि किशोर कुमार को रफी साहब से बेहतर सिद्ध करने के लिए अगर आपको पांच जन्म और लेने पड़ें तो आप जरूर लेकर रहेंगे !! और आपकी किशोर VS रफी साहब की हर वीडियो में आपकी ये मंशा directly Or indirectly साफ नजर आती है !! किशोर साहब का मुरीद तो मैं भी हूँ और बेहिचक ये दिल से मानता हूँ कि किशोर साहब जैसा हरफनमौला और all rounder फन्कार कोई और हो ही नहीं सकता !! लेकिन रफी साहब एक सरल हृदय और निहायत सूफी तबियत के शख्श थे जो अपनी कला के बल पर टिके और उन्होंने एक अलग ही मुकाम हासिल किया !! आपने अपनी निजि पसंद की ओट में अपनी चिर परिचित मानसिकता को व्यक्त कर ही दिया !! आपका बस नहीं चल रहा वरना आप तो कभी के रफी साहब को शून्य साबित कर चुके होते !! आप किशोर साहब के गुणों का बखान करें, जिसके वे वाकई हक़दार थे लेकिन रफी साहब को कमतर सिद्ध करने की रुग्ण मानसिकता के साथ नहीं !!

@sputnik3066

Жыл бұрын

आपने मेरे मुंह की बात कहदी

@Ahmad-ik6vz

Жыл бұрын

What an honest opinion !!!

@truthseeker9482

Жыл бұрын

किशोर ने बेहतर गाया।

@Ahmad-ik6vz

Жыл бұрын

An unbiased opinion. You are absolutely right.

@rekhabhatt8988

Жыл бұрын

विक्रम राठौर जी सबकी अपनी अपनी पसंद है, यहां मंशा किसी को कमतर आंकने की नही दिखती, मगर आप को पता नही कितने जन्म लेने पड़ेंगे बात समझने के😂😂

Both the legendary singers were uniquely versatile in their own style..

Both have their own different styles and both of them give a different feel and a different high! E.g. "Tum bin jaun kahan" from "Pyaar Ka Mausam."

HI RAHOUL BHAI 🙋‍♂️As a music lover I think Muhammad Rafi sb and Mr . kishor kumar both sung well both R legends .......🎤🎸🥁📻🎷

It is a boon for Kishore kumar and any song we hear now from him after 30,40, 50 or even 100 years it still has its mark and will be immemorable.

Version of Rafi sahib we heard first time. But Kishore Kumar Version we have listened many times, naturally what we listen more we like more. If kishore Kumar had not sing song we would have liked M. Rafi.

Fact ! But I absolutely love Both Rafi Sahab and Kishoreda . May Their Souls Rest In Eternal Peace 🙏🙏❤️❤️

@yusufshaikh3149

Жыл бұрын

Awnayzauanay

Well, I found Rafisahab a bit sweeter than Kishore sahab in this particular song , it's my personal opinion, coz the lyrics writing is different and both the legends sang the song as per the requirement! Both are my favorite! 😊

I have heard both of the songs "YE DIL NA HOTA BECHARA" and "KOI NA TERA". And both singers were fantastic in their own styles. Personally my favorite version is "YE DIL NA HOTA BECHARA".

The power in the voice of Kishore Kumar make the song live. Rafi saheb style was different, but not bad..

Rafi sahab aur kishore da ka toolna karna, chand aur suraj ko dharti ke liye kitna zaroori hai waise hi film industry ke liye ouss zamane mein ye do super gayak ki zaroorat thi.

Kishore kumar song more versatile than any other singers

I like the 'Jewel Thief' version sung by Kishore Kumar a bit too much to put any other version ahead of it! You can call me a "blind fan" for that!

Yes of course kishoreda he sang so well woh Jo bhi gana gaatay thay mere leye super hit similarly tum bin jau kaha both sang. Rafi sahab and Kishoreda but wah Kishore da was best unka Jo utaar chadau ganay ko kheechna no one was better then him thanks Rahoul for this video stay blessed

This song actually is adapted by Sachin Dev Burman from the theme music ( Colonel Boogie ) of the film, Bridge on the river Kwai. Sachin Dev Burman adapted the tune very nicely and added a lovely Antara of his own. Both Mohd.Rafi and Kishore Kumar ( even Mukesh, Manna Dey, Hemant Kumar, Talat Mehmood) were stellar singers and should not be compared because each rendered their songs exactly the way the music director conceived and matching the scenario of the film. While Mohd Rafi had a silken voice and was a highly trained singer like Manna Dey etc , Kishore Kumar was a God gifted singer who could render with perfection whatever was composed for him. Another point is important. R.D.Burman has mentioned this period of 1963 in an interview and told that he saw how cruel the film world was to his father barring Dev Anand. Panchamda however on some occasions had done apart from assisting him, the recording for his father including Sachin Dev Burman's last fabulous composition , Badi Suni Suni hai of Mili when his father was in critical condition at the Hospital and Kishore Kumar poured his heart and soul in that song

@bitanchaudhuri2502

Жыл бұрын

Exactly ❤❤

@ALIIMRAN-py5dt

Жыл бұрын

A very good analysis 👍

Wah sir bahot mast vdo h. Aapke vdo dekh k mere dil me Kishore kumar k liye utsukta badti jati h.

Definitely kishore Kumar version as usual😊

Even though the tunes are same style is totally different. Rafi Saab 's version sounds sophisticated, but Kishore da's version sounds exuberant, as the situation demands.

Yeh dil Kishore Kumar ji ne jyada Acha gaya hai

Sequence Ke Hisab Se Gaane Ki Mood Change Hote Rehte Hain. Ye Sach Hai Kishore Daa Ki Yeh Gaanaa Jyadaa Achhaa Sunaayi Detaa Hai. Recording Bhi Sahi Nehin Hai Rafi Saahab Ki Gaane Ki.. Naye Lyrics Ke Saath Kuchh Fer Badal Kiyaa Gayaa, Aur Kishore Daa Ki Yudleying Ke Saath ish Gaane Ko Record Kiyaa Gayaa. Recording Ki Sound Quality Bhi Bahat Hi Khubsurat Hai. Par Rafi Saahab Ki Version Mein Rafi Saahab Bahat Achha Gaayaa Hai. Par Recording Ki Sound Quality Achhi Nehi Hai... 👍👍🤗🤗 Dono Hi Mahan Gaayak The, Aur Hamesha Mahaan Rahenge Bhi....👌👌🎻🎻🌹🌹💟💟

Aaj bhi wohi awaaz ... wohi shore ... Ek hi naam ... KISHORE ❤❤❤

Mughe bhi kishore da ka hi verson pasand hai. Great singer Kishore da 🙏🌹🌹🙏 vmb

Yeh dil na hota bechara kadam na hotey awara…. Kya baat hai Rahoul bhai

I too feel the Kishore Kumar version was more peppy and soothing to the ears. The Mohammad Rafi version sounds too ebbed and sober. As such Jewel Thief is one of my all-time favourite movies. I watched it in the theatres when I was in 11th grade at Shreyas in Ghatkopar. I hope that theatre is still there ❤❤

After hearing Legendary Rafi sahab 's version comparison to Gurudev Kishoreda 's version, no words to describe, ( KHADE HAIN HUM BHI RAAH MEIN, YEH DIL.....)👍👌✅🙏🏿❤️❤️♥️💯💯✔️🪄✨🎵🎶🎶🎼🙏💜🙏🙏🙏🙏

Of course Rahul Ji.... Kishore Daa jaisa koi nahin❤ Ye Dil na hota Bechara one of my favourite Too

I didn't saw God... But I heard him sing.. The only voice of God kishore Kumar

@nadiakashi1679

Жыл бұрын

Absolutely wrong Kishor's voice is so rough and harsh o the ears

Absolutely right Bhaiya. I truly agree with you. Kishore da is the greatest

When Composer Uttam Singh says the same during recording of Waaris songs, there is no doubt left. Hum toh yaha seekhe hai. Unko uparwale ne bana ke bheja hai. Dont remember the exact words. Please upload a video on this. Or may be I have missed.

Super,I love Kishore da, special this song when I was kid, there are so many songs of Kishore da, but this was romantic song, this is Raj from Hyderabad

तुम बिन जाऊँ कहाँ सोंग भी रफी साहब और किशोर दा दोनों ने गाया है।

If Naushad disliked Kishore then as Kishore ascended,coincidentally Naushad was on the decline. Leader, DDDL,and above all Shunghursh which slowed the flow of a classic movie.

Sir, mujhe bhi kishore daa ka gaya geet hi achcha lagta hai

Kishore's version is definitely more lively and memorable, and I believe a large part is played by the lyrics. The lyrics of Rafi's version are abstract whereas that of Kishore are immediately relatable. Kishore's version comes across like your friend telling you about his failed affairs! And talking about Jewel Thief, there's another gem of a song in that move that's equally unforgettable. Raat Akeli Hai. Asha Bhosle and SD at their phenomenal best!

@pradeepkumarupadhyaysonu9132

Жыл бұрын

Great किशोर कुमार

There is life in kishore kumar version

Superb orginal information like always and not the made up ones.... there is so many fake stories go around on social media, for long time everyone belivied kishore da sang one line" akbar tera naam nahi "in song parda hai parda after rafisaab requested but recently amit kumar clarified that's it's his voice

Rahoul sir, I shall be much grateful and indebted to you, if you could arrange the recording of the “Lata Mangeshkar Shradhanjali Concert” and provide it to us as fans of Lata Ji who will treasure that masterpiece as it a goldmine.

Kishor daa gaan is undated & svar is filtered. Almost all the males sings like typic females,dukhi tadap thakaa udaas. Kishor daa is nar praakritik adbhut apurva madhur shuddh balvant shaktishaalee tej & vishva. Vayse bhi pasand apni apni! Yeh dil naa hotaa becaaraa is ati uttam nar praakritik jeevant vishva prem prasangayukt gaan,madhur shuddh sampuran,adbhut & apurva. 🙏🏼bahumukhee sampuran svar sur & taal sangeet samraat,vishva ratna shri Kishor daa Kumaar ji 🌹😘❤️.

Thank you Rahul sir khubbhalo laglo and yes I highly agree with you Kishore Kumar did sang better but the great Rafi's version is also good as well they both are tremendous singers both are great institutions of music.I miss them always.Great content.Respect and love from Toronto🇨🇦🇧🇩.

Dear Rahul, bht hi umda narration as usual. Bht shkrguzar hon ga agr ap apny segment mn play hony wali back ground melody ki notation mjhy send krdain. Thanx. Shah Ghalib.

It’s your point of view.. I don’t agree with you… Each singer is good in his own way. No comparisons please….

Sir Rahul ur commits for me nice thanks sir we love ur to classic knowledge I am from Bhopal

@70mmwithRahoul

Жыл бұрын

Thanks and welcome

Really informative. I always enjoy your videos as a great Kishore Kumar fan.

@70mmwithRahoul

Жыл бұрын

Thanks a ton

Undoubtedly Kishores version was much better 👌

I am totally agree with you and of course this song of Kishore Kumar i love to hear again and again he is our legend

Yaar kishore kumar ki awaz boht ache hai i love his voice

Kishore Kumar was god....... who can surpass him....even today?

This comparison will always be there, and fans of both of these timeless singers will always argue. However, Kishore sang this song brilliantly. No doubt on that.

You are absolutely right.kishore Da was Parasmani of stardom.don Bradman singer of Indian film industry Aabhash Kumar ganguli was God gifted champion of his field

Kishore ka hi achcha hai, Masti bhara gaana hai.

जय हो किशोर कुमार जी की

Allh bless u all time and urs family love urs videos urs videos r very true only urs channel is not fake

@70mmwithRahoul

Жыл бұрын

Thank you Amina Jeelani

@aminajeelani1356

Жыл бұрын

@@70mmwithRahoul lots of love from occupied Kashmir

Greetings from Bahrain Thank you Rahoul...

@70mmwithRahoul

Жыл бұрын

Most welcome!

Lovely fact ! I am in agreement 😊

Absolutely right. God of song. Baki sab singer. Not god.kisore KUMAR only one baki sab saw crows dur

Rahoul that goes without saying that Kishore Kumar version is definitely the best one.Who can beat that golden voice? Tum bin jaun kahan is another masterpiece sung both by Kishore Kumar & Rafi Sahab...but we all hear mostly the Kishore Kumar version...and me being a Bengali, get to hear all the Bengali versions of these songs as well.Even the songs like Hum e aur jeene ki, O saathi re and several other such songs ...Kishore Kumar versions are definitely the best ones.Of course I love to hear them.

@70mmwithRahoul

Жыл бұрын

Kishoreda was magical.....

Absolutely ,absolutely Kishore Kumar's version was way better than Md Rafi's.

Rahul ji am a sports journalist and commentator. Just love Kishore da. You pass on some excellent information every now and then. Is there any mail id where I can contact you. I would love to share some special information on Kishore da our music God.

@70mmwithRahoul

Жыл бұрын

hello@70mmwithrahoul.com

Kishore sahib nay acha gaya hay agay pasand apni apni

Its one of the legendary song and everyone loved it. Aapne pahle ek video main kaha tha iss song main Dev sahab jo sweater pahna hain woh beautiful actress Jahida ji ne boona tha for Dev sahab. Stay blessed Sir 🎉

You are absolutely right sir. Maa Saraswati had full grace on Kishore Da. He learned music in heaven even before coming to this world. And no doubt Kishore da's version is immortal ❤ Thank you sir for sharing this amazing fact 😊

Great किशोर कुमार

Yes Rahulji. You hit the bull's eye. Kishore dada ka ye gaana bahut lively hai!❤❤❤

@70mmwithRahoul

Жыл бұрын

KK was a magical artist

You are right..... Guru Kishore is best......❤

किशोर दीड बेस्ट. Manly voice.

You are 100% correct.

Kishor kumar ji was natural actor, singer.

Valuable information,thanks a lot.

@70mmwithRahoul

Жыл бұрын

So nice of you

Aap se main 100% 👍😊Tum bin jao kahan,song Kishore kumar ka song best tha Rafi se😊👍👍

Almost the great kishorda ka hi style And version pasand hai bhai

I thought you are talking about the Tum Bin Jau kaha song …. But great story.

Kishore da ki koi comparision nahi. Dada was ultimate

Bilkul Sahi! KishoreDa itne gifted the aur unka voice culture itna zabardast tha ki classical training ke baghair bhi wo sab get gaa lete the aur sabhi jagah छा जाते थे. Mera favorite comparison प्यार का मौसम का गाना : तुम बिन जाऊं कहां । KishoreDa ke dono versions ( yodelling waala aur sad slow version) Rafi sahib ke dono versions se Kai behtareen rahe: aawaz ki bulandi, gahrai, kashish aur slow version mei अद्भुत दर्द ही दर्द!! बहुत मज़ा आया! Keep up the great work राहुल!

Mujhe bi ye bhut acha lgta hai .❤

Kishore kumer was hidden under shadow, but he came out as sunlight by the gift of God.

किशोर दा चरित्र के मूड को अपनी आवाज में जी देते थे ।

"Jeevan se bhari" gaana kishoreda ka.....

Kishoreda is simply God..🙏

Yes, My brother Rahoul ji, I like this version of Kishore Da. Both the Dhun are same. But the song on Dev Sahab is much better than the song of Rafi Sahab. I'm also a big fan of Kishore Da. Very nice video. Very nice information. I love to watch your videos daily. My best wishes are always with you My brother Rahoul ji. 🙏🙏🙏❤️❤️❤️

Kishore kumar....khud mein hi ek tanpura the....

किशोर कुमार एक वरदानी पुरुष थे, जय हो किशोर कुमार की, हर हर महादेव

सर, इसमें बताने की क्या बात है। किशोरकुमार ग्रेट थे, हैं, और हमेशा रहेंगे।

That's very true because Kishoreda's voice is the voice of God. Human voices are no match in front of Kishoreda's voice.

Rahoul, the fact some people from one religion prefer Rafi saab and some from other religion like Kishore Kumar. Two sides of the coin, but the valun of the finest is same. Thanks

Yehi hai woh geet jo mujhe bhi pasand hai

Always kishore da's version sound more progressive n rocking than others, all great singers r good but kishore da has something extra factor and that is called God gifted genius

@tapankumarghosh9272

Жыл бұрын

হ্যাঁ ভাই অবশ্যই জিনিয়াস ভগবানদত্ত

Un dino doordarshan par har shanivar rat ko 9.30 baje hindi cineme dikhaye jate the. Usame ek hi hero ke cineme dikhaye jate the. Mujhe Mr. Dev sahab ke Guide, Hare Rama Hare krisnha, Jwele thief, Des Pardes, Chori mera kaam,...etc. move bahut pasand. Aur sabse jyada Guide. Jisme ek insan ke sabhi rang dikhaye gaye - Son, lover, thief and Sant. The legend movie Guide (Raju guide)👌👌👌

Very true. There's more of punch and impishness in Kishoreda's vouce❤ Here I might add, it was cruel on the part of Gurudutt to remove Burmanda, who already down with an attack, and give another jolt. But life is like that. Time and Tide(read money) waits for no man😢

The movie was Jewel thief

👍👍 fully agree.. listen to any song sung by Kishorda with any singer...you will attracted more to Kishorda part... something that can't be explained or analysed.. it's unique... I've loved Kishorda all my life- simply divine !

Mujhe bhi kishore da ka hi version pasand,

A lovely podcast on this wonderful song "Yeh Dil Naa Hota Bechara" This song composed by S.D.Burman would have actually been used in the movie Baaharein Phir Bhi Aayegi that too way back in 1961 had Senior Burman not suffered ftom a heart attack. I feel that Guru Dutt, should have waited for S.D. Burman's recovery as he had given alternatives to Guru Dutt, that the recordings would be done by Rahul, but this did nit happen & Mr.Sachin Dev Burman was dropped & replaced by O.P Nayyar. The song saw daylight in 1967, when it was included in the movie Jewel Thief by the evergreen Dev Anand. I heard the clip that you shared in the video Mohd.Rafi sang the song beautifully in his style & it is so soothing to the ears. But, Kishore Kumar's version is superb !! The song in the voice of Kishore has its own chirpiness - liveliness & the song fits perfectly in the movie !! Kishore Kumar has created Magic Thank you Rahoul for this lovely trivia 👍❤

@70mmwithRahoul

Жыл бұрын

Thank you Anish for your inputs as always.

Great kishore da best