If I knew where this brother stationed himself I would consider moving closer to just learn from him personally. May Allah grant him goodness and protect him from evil. Ameen

@TheSaleem57

Жыл бұрын

Looks for Zaytuna College

@novado.5493

Жыл бұрын

The bay area of US. San Francisco area.

@fizzycrush4021

Жыл бұрын

Ameen

@tydiab8838

Жыл бұрын

He's in San Francisco Zaytoona College

@fadeelah5

10 ай бұрын

​@@TheGreenfrog140he's born shia as an iranian himself, but through his enormous knowledge he became sunni alhamdullilah 😉❤

These talks by Dr Ataie are just amazing . He’s so generous with his time and knowledge . Although a Christian I cannot but have enormous respect for him and his knowledge and generosity. I never knew as much about the history of Judaism nor even Christianity the way Dr Ataie has taught. I look everywhere for his teachings and lectures now .

Now I can understand( a little bit ) : why Moses pbuh is mentioned 85 times in the Holy Quran. I am so amazed thank you Dr Ali Ataie.

@nasserfirelordarts6574

Жыл бұрын

I think it's 136 times akhi

These are much needed and long overdue lectures from a Muslim scholar Nonpareil. Dr. Ali, you are proving yourself a very humble seeker and diffuser of good knowledge. I pray for your every success.

What a jewel! I love this very much! Muslim who give insights into jewish believe. Always curious and interested to learn about jewish believes. From muslim points of view. ❤️ Thank u ustadh dr Ali Ataie.

Masha Allah may Allah keep you on the straight path and continue to allow you to benefit the entire world. Keep sharing your knowledge.

Amazing understanding and knowledge. Love it....❤

very in depth, love his lectures! JazakAllah

Brilliant my bro..very interesting topic.

بارك الله فيكم و وفقكم الله لما يحبه ويرضاه آمين يارب العالمين

the matrilineal descent to be jewish applies only to the non-kohanim (israelites and levites). the kohanim still follow the original patrilineal descent. only males can be kohanim and the father must be a kohan, irrespective of the jewish status of the mother. this is the opposite of the non-kohanim. the matrilineal descent was started and promoted after 70ce by the perushim (israelites), who were from the tribe of judah, to increase their population after the destruction of jerusalem by the romans. they also allowed conversions to the rabbinic/talmudic judaism. this led to the gradual disappearance of the tribes of Israel except for the kohanim. the latest genetic studies have shown that about 50% of the kohanim have a common ancestor who lived 3300 years ago unlike the non-kohanim. the non-kohanim do have genetic connection to Middle East but they do not have a common ancestor who lived 3300 years ago or even earlier. the kohanim are about 5% of the jewish population. the jewish people who are not kohanim do not know their tribe. even the people whose last name is levy do not have a common genetic ancestor who should be the same as the kohanim. the kohanim were part of the b'nai tzadok, who started to follow the rabbinic/talmudic judaism after 70ce. the majority of the b'nai tzadok moved to arabia, first in 185bce and again in 70ce. the bani Israel and jews of arabia during the time of the prophet were tzaddukhim/sadducees/sadduqiyya and jews from the tribe of judah who followed a variant of sadducean beliefs and additionally believed in the divinity of Ezra respectively. there were no rabbinic/talmudic jews in arabia and the quran is not addressing them when it talks about bani Israel or jews. the early muslim historians such as al-jahiz (8th century) and ibn-hazm (11th century) made this differentiation and clearly stated that the quranic jews and bani Israel were not the rabbinic/talmudic jews who lived with them outside of arabia. in india there is, to this day, a jewish community which went there 2000 years ago and who has their own torah, different than the one followed by the european and middle eastern jews, and who believe in the divinity of Ezra and are awaiting his second coming.

@talhaahsanlondon

2 ай бұрын

This is so fascinating. Are there sources we could consult? What are the chances of a reply after 10 months?

Is there a second part to this lecture? Dr Ali only covered 3 of the 13 principles?

Great insights as always

Very well articulated 👏

You explained Judaism better than jews.

@EngineersQuest

5 ай бұрын

That's ridiculous.

1:21:26. Perfect aspect, not perfect tense.

Jazakallah khair, for so much knowledge. May Allah reward you more and more for giving this information to us sheikh

Masha Allah Jazakum Allah khayran. May Allah guide us to the straight path and keep us strong and united.

@ARmirzaful

10 ай бұрын

Aameen!

This is wonderful. I've always wondered what the Jewish perception of Allah is.

@EngineersQuest

5 ай бұрын

When you wonder what someone of a different religion thinks of you or your beliefs, always ask a teacher of that religion.

Listening 14 timezone away...

JazakaAllahu khayr

Alhamdulillah tq Dr.

Mashalla I have learnt so much about the Jewish faith from Dr. Ataie. You are enlightening us all Shaykh. Thank you. May Allah swt increase you Ameen

Alhamdulillah. So interesting!

may God bless you

Asalaamu alaikum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh!!!

@microcosm1957

Жыл бұрын

Walaikum assalam wa Rahmatullahi wa barakatu

Amazing.!! 👍

A lot of the sounds he's saying do sound like Ojibwe and Cree

wish you talked how maimonide was influenced by islamic scholars and philosophers

Thank you and barak Allah!

Mashallah 10/10

I only listened to maybe like 30 mins I'm curious to lusten in full but we do not say that The Ineffable Name is God's Essence. We can't describe His Essence or really talk much about It. We just call It Ain Sof (Without End)

@hrsbg

Жыл бұрын

He addresses this at 1:15:37

@Tzadokite

Жыл бұрын

We tzaddukhim have known this since Aahron and Zadok. we pronounce this name during our seclusions or Qbl-El or Qbl-Al. this is not the rabbinic/talmudid kabbalah. we have to do 40 days and nights of Qbl-el with HaShem or El at least once in our lifetime. however, we do meditate on this word/name as part of our midnight worship or qiyam al layl. this name/word has been passed down orally since moses, aahron and zadok. i have not across anyone besides us who knows how to say this word/name. it has to do with the Essence of HaShem but is also much more than that. it can only be experienced. shalom.

Will the bani israil ever become Muslim?

I love you Bro!

very interesting. how do we convert the orthodox jews to Islam?

@Ashleii

Жыл бұрын

We don’t do anything other than behave like the prophet pbuh, answer any questions directed at us, signpost to greater knowledgeable people, make Dua. Those who are sincere then Allah swt will guide them. But as Allah says The Jews and polytheists will be the most hostile to Muslims . So we leave it to Allah because we don’t know what is in their hearts when they approach us

@superhydra8873

Жыл бұрын

​@@Ashleii the Christians and Jews will be the most hostile You don't see Jews attacking islam, that's because islam is a universalized Judaism

@EngineersQuest

5 ай бұрын

You don't.

33:33

My brother a very well read Muslim often says that the Jews follow the other Moses ( Moshe Maimonides) , not the prophet of God As they follow the Talmud and not the Torah

@huzaifahali412

Жыл бұрын

Where are you from dear and whats your brother's name and work.

@ITubeYouK

Жыл бұрын

Similar to how Modern day Muslims follow the Hadith literatures which separate Muslims into sects (Shia and Sunni) versus just following the final revelation of Allah (The Qur'an) which was given to the final messenger of God, the Prophet Muhammad (MHMD). The creed of Islam (submission to the One and Only God) has been around since Adam. Messengers have come for remembrance and warning. Surely division in religion is not what God intended for us, indeed he wanted us to be men of action, men of good deeds, who believe in Him and uphold His remembrance in duty and prayer. Pure monotheism, the belief in God, and the followings presented to us in the Tanakh, the Gospels, and the Qur'an. Fundamentally they are all the same, the answer to our purpose and what we need to do to attain salvation is clearly outlined and detailed in the Qur'an.

@jamshedshaikh4619

Жыл бұрын

I happen to ventured into “reading and understanding”Guide To Perplexed” by Musa Bin Mammon his real name in Arabic known as (Maimonides)to Europe.I bought the English translation of the original book( written in easy Arabic as he claimed)from Barns and Nobel but turned to be a real heavy duty and sophisticated philosophical work. As I am not trained in theology or philosophy it is taking me for ever but the esteemed scholar is making it much easier and way more interesting in learning this complex religion.

@uthman2281

Жыл бұрын

@@ITubeYouK Are you Quranist?

@rajababy2009

Жыл бұрын

@@uthman2281 from his comment it is crystal clear he is

🐱👍🏿interesting

Seems quite similar to islam

@Ashleii

Жыл бұрын

Not at all. Rabbinical Judaism allows rabbis to make laws that even contradict God . Rabbis are considered greater than God while on earth . Obviously there are remnants of the true message but it has been complicated and made difficult by the Pharisees / Rabbis

@RonVoldman

Жыл бұрын

@@Ashleii making a claim like Jews consider rabbis greater than god while on earth is so disgusting - you’re not building bridges with anyone with thoughts like that.

@imprisonedmerchant691

10 ай бұрын

@@Ashleii That is simply not true. No Jew has ever said that. This type of misinformation and mockery is exactly what has made a rift between Jews and Muslims.

@EngineersQuest

5 ай бұрын

​@@AshleiiThat isn't true at all.

👍💚❤️💙

Great lecture. More was needed on their beliefs on the unseen. Jinn paradise life in the grave journey of the soul. hellfire. Eternal punishment. You get mix messages from the jews. If you are openly disobedient after clear signs are given, in my humble opinion, Allah doesnt let you on that day to show up with a clear tawhid which can get you to paradise. Along the way due to your arrogance he lets you slowly dwell into shirk. Shia are a good example. And jews have dwelled much into the unseen, the world of jinn and because of their limited information by denying prophets, have created a twisted notion of who they are and Allah manifesting Himself as them. Jewish mysticism has been the foundation of all the occult, their practices and their framework of worshipping ibliss in different forms of interpretation. The brother should explain their disbelief structure which has kept them from following many of the last prophets of Allah. Selam

After what i understood and its prove that they don't believe no one prophet nor GOD, Those jews ennemies of themselves are juste DWELLING in this religion because its benefit them. But those people who using religion liké it was and IS till today a nation country not religion.

@RonVoldman

Жыл бұрын

Then I guess you didn’t understand much.

@jado2k

2 ай бұрын

la hawla wala kuwata illa billah. Brother, you clearly did not listen to the lecture. This is an opportunity for interfaith dialogue and understanding, not for braindead hate comments. The jewish creed and their interpretation of God's attributes are the closest thing to Islam. Do not conflate Judaism with the zionist war machine, which is a largely secular-nationalist, christian (evangelical zionism and beliefs about armageddon; by no means an attack on christianity) endeavour. You are not going to spread the light of this religion with your tribal attitude. Jazakallah

Jews knowing themselves that they don't believe no Prophète, No God either si they hiding and DWELLING into this Religion. Their wrote, rewriting thé torat according to their own satisfaction. Everything that Moses, Jésus, and thé reste of thé Hébreux prophètes left for thé jewishs , well they changes everything for their on satisfaction .