Line distributions used: kzread.info/head/PLNMWM8EHufDyT91CtsoWQQyK06vk7zbSv&si=w8FDYsKkdCRwCkwx FIXED Distributions - ELEVEN - Next Page - All Night

@zachyzxchzach

Ай бұрын

Line distribution without all night?

@illegaluser69

Ай бұрын

You mixed Liz and Yujin in Payback

Liz v/s Yujin Wonyoung v./s Leeseo Rei and Gaeul chilling on 5th and 6th place

@riloy3811

Ай бұрын

main vocals get many vocal lines gets decent rapper has less it's fair

@Verowinday777

Ай бұрын

Rei is a great rapper lol, she is so underrated frfr, even her live rap is impressive.

@Sandrinarhonda

Ай бұрын

Exactly and when we say this about Gaeul , we’re gaslighted.

WONYOUNG and LESSEO Everytime ⬆️⬇️⬆️⬇️⬆️⬇️

@sunmoon_k

Ай бұрын

YES, they changed places like 8 times lol

liz staying in first for 0.3 sec

"Finally liz treated as main vocal" just stfu and say u never listen to ive other than their title tracks lmao

@Sandrinarhonda

Ай бұрын

EXACTLY LiZ is always top 3 in lines

Honestly ive Switch IS such a fair album everyone got to shine

@fofinhado_kpopzoficial

Ай бұрын

Fair? Only liz and leeseo haves first places?

@rosieposie2047

Ай бұрын

Yes it is fair ? Maybe yujin didnt get any First places yet she Had more lines in the Album than leeseo. placements arent everything cuz Sometimes the difference between First and Last is 8 Seconds and that is fair

@winnikvinni

Ай бұрын

@@fofinhado_kpopzoficialYujin gets alot of lines though? 💀💀 Liz was always in second place in the distribution and they did her horrible in the last album.

@Sandrinarhonda

Ай бұрын

Fair but Gaeul is 5th or last as always pleasee .

@rosieposie2047

Ай бұрын

​@@Sandrinarhondayk i am talking Abt the new Album right? She got 2 THIRD places and two 4th places which isnt unfair at all also compared to their earlier days where gaeul got Like 8 Secs and liz AS the Main vocalist 12 THIS IS FAIR

Liz finally takes the first place, I'm so happy with it

@yujinbestgirl

Ай бұрын

She always have many lines and frist place, it's just kitsch that they messed up

@user-bf3os2um8q

Ай бұрын

​@@yujinbestgirlshe is main vocalist wdym to say that she got many lines???

@dinonara211

Ай бұрын

​@@user-bf3os2um8qdid we watch the same video? as you can see, aside from kitsch where we collectively agree that sse done her dirty, she got pretty good amount of lines in most songs

@mariqilieva6650

Ай бұрын

​@yujinbestgirl Kitsch and Holy Moly actually

@antoncutie

Ай бұрын

​@@dinonara211 pretty sure the op meant the overall 1st place, not 1st place in a song

Finally liz is being treated as main vocalist, hope so Rora of baby monster and jeogyeon from twice will soon get this treatment

@christianscott4955

Ай бұрын

Idk about Rora, but y’all desperately need to let go of this fantasy of Jeongyeon getting better treatment as a vocalist. It’s been 9 years already

@btsismyoxyjin6577

Ай бұрын

​@@christianscott4955sad but true😅

@Avi.yo.

Ай бұрын

@@christianscott4955 true!

@laissa9372

Ай бұрын

She was always treated as main vocalist but yall never listen to their other tracks 🫠

@angelizespino6776

Ай бұрын

shes always been treated as a main vocalist, out of 9 title tracks she has 4 in where shes first in the line distribution, yujin has 2 and wony has 3, yall gotta stop with this narrative of liz being done dirty with lines all the time

Liz and Gaeul❤💌💘💝💖💗💓💞💕💟❣️❤️‍🔥❤️‍🩹❤️🤎💜🩵💙💚💛🧡🤍🩶🖤🩷

Liz, you wanna be on top? oh yes main vocalist, you deserve 🎉

Liz has many lines. It's just that the token stans are always there to pitying her to drag other members. They really messed up with kitsch, tho.

@antoncutie

Ай бұрын

yujin is the one with 'many lines'... Liz just got what she deserves here 😘

@opinionisopinion

Ай бұрын

Liz 👑

@bypaknox3629

Ай бұрын

@@antoncutie omg shut up please

@yuqilover628

Ай бұрын

@@antoncutie 🤡🤡🤡

@antoncutie

Ай бұрын

@@yuqilover628 a sole vocalist who is constantly the whole group's vocal will never have "many lines" she just get what she supposed to have. AND SHE DESERVE EVEN MORE

Liz and Yujin : The Main Vocals Wonyoung and Leeseo: The Lead Vocals And i love how everyone in the vocal line has their moments to shine. Rei has a lot of number 1s too, let's wait and see how Gaeul's lines develop in the future.

@pinklamborghini6446

Ай бұрын

Wrong! Wonyoung and Leeseo are not lead vocalists / in the vocal line The only vocalists are Liz and Yujin, even Rei Is a better vocalist than Wonyoung and Leeseo especially

@Twasklarim

Ай бұрын

Gaeul too​@@pinklamborghini6446

@heekibunny9815

Ай бұрын

@@pinklamborghini6446 are u drunk??🤣🤣 Wonyoung has a huge range than Rei 😎

@heekibunny9815

Ай бұрын

@@pinklamborghini6446 You always underestimate Wonyoung. Remember that not all Lead Vocalists in KPop are in charge of taking high notes. In fact, Wonyoung has been the official Lead Vocalist since they debuted 😏 honestly she can do a high note more often as she like if STARSHIP not give her a "deadly" schedule or stupid fashion brand who always "steal" her time.

@heekibunny9815

Ай бұрын

@@pinklamborghini6446 even Suho EXO, Kevin The Boyz, Yunho ATEEZ, Jungmo Cravity & Jeongyeon Twice are great Lead Vocalist (Wonyoung are included). But, Have you ever seen or heard of them taking Highnotes as often as the members of their own group?? No right??!!! In EXO they give all Highnote more often to CBD, in The Boyz they give to New & Sangyeon, in ATEEZ they give to Jongho, in Cravity they give to Woobin and in Twice they only give to Jihyo & Nayeon. This means that not all Lead Vocalists get the same opportunities 😏

Liz without kitsch is number one too

Gaeul and Liz ❤🩷🧡💛💚💙🩵💜🤎🖤🩶🤍❤️❤️‍🩹❤️‍🔥❣️💟💕💞💓💗💖💝💘💖

Poor Gaeul :(

@Chuu27692

Ай бұрын

Stop it

@Chuu27692

Ай бұрын

She's the only member not credited as a Vocalist, she's their weakest vocalist

@opinionisopinion

Ай бұрын

​@@Chuu27692Bro it's Leeseo F- vs Gauel F+

@Sandrinarhonda

Ай бұрын

Righttt , smh . Gaeul deserves better !

@PedroPony833

22 күн бұрын

@@opinionisopinion My guy, vocal tiers mean nothing.

Wow, rei really deserves more lines especially when she is the only one who can sing and rap

@YatoKpop

Ай бұрын

Geaul and Leeseo can do that too

@pinklamborghini6446

Ай бұрын

​@@YatoKpopabsolutely not Leeseo can't do both and gaeul can "barely" rap

@Yuri-il4xm

Ай бұрын

@@pinklamborghini6446nah gaeul can barely sing but her rap is okay

@pinklamborghini6446

Ай бұрын

@@Yuri-il4xm well she hadnt that strong of a rap part to believe that Her one is hypnosis was good tho

@Yuri-il4xm

Ай бұрын

@@pinklamborghini6446 Yeah but compared to her vocal 💀 but she's mostly a dancer

liz & yujin : fighting together for 1st place wonyoung & leeseo : fighting together but chilling sometimes rei & gaeul : accepted their fate

Ive mine comeback Lesseo:Reverse! Wonyoung:Ah Ive switch Wonyoung:Reverse Lesseo:Nah

@danieltp35011

Ай бұрын

Wonyoung is getting fewer seconds compared to 2022...

@fofinhado_kpopzoficial

Ай бұрын

Wheres the next comeback ive leeseo in 1st place album distribution?

@danieltp35011

Ай бұрын

@@fofinhado_kpopzoficial não sabemos...

@fofinhado_kpopzoficial

Ай бұрын

@@danieltp35011 I love leeseo so much

@danieltp35011

Ай бұрын

@@fofinhado_kpopzoficialyou're not portuguese/brazilian?

Me encanta cuando dicen que Liz nunca tiene líneas en las canciones 😂 este vídeo: la persona con más líneas es Liz 😅

blue blood is their best line distribution, 5s is crazy

the difference between gaeul and the rest in being in last place 😭😭

@hollyglimmer3486

Ай бұрын

This is progress to Starship comparing with their first girl group💀

@sweetpim

Ай бұрын

@@hollyglimmer3486 well yes yeoreum is arguably the worst treated idol ever considering her talent 💀💀💀

@Sandrinarhonda

Ай бұрын

Exactly a mess .

@Sandrinarhonda

Ай бұрын

@@sweetpimGaeul and her are treated the exact same way , idk what it is with Starship but they always treat 1 member so horribly.

@Sandrinarhonda

Ай бұрын

@@hollyglimmer3486it’s not progress 😂

Out of 34 songs Gaeul was last in 20 of them. That means she has the least amount of lines in 58% of their songs in a 6 person group.

Can someone explain me why Liz gets special treatments when she is first?.....

finally liz takes the 1st place she deserves, main vocalist indeed ❤

i just realized how i love ive discography

One album can change everything. Finally Liz is treated well. Hopefully Jeongyeon will be treated like this too 😭

@sunmoon_k

Ай бұрын

let's hope for good lines for her in the new jp album! one song she already has a lot lines, hare hare.

@opinionisopinion

Ай бұрын

Jeongyeon need jesus to have lines 😭 omg maybe in their new Japanese album this July she might be rank 7 again

@omarbirkdar5536

Ай бұрын

this album didnt change everything, shes been treated well since the beginning, just got the short end of the stick in kitsch and kitsch alone

@fawkiouuugg

Ай бұрын

jeongyeon cannot be saved anymore

@fawkiouuugg

Ай бұрын

@@omarbirkdar5536i think after like too where they did her dirty but generally liz gets good lines in title tracks and bsides

Liz token pity stans now can stop crying😂

Liz vs Yujin or Wonyoung vs Leeseo 🔥🔥🔥🔥

My leeseo Please starship, give lines for my leeseo. I love you so much leeseo. I love your vídeos sunmoonk

Liz is Main Vocalist 🎉 Finally my dreams are coming true 😢 I'm emotional right now I'm happy for I've and Liz

I finally see Liz first place in all album line distribution. That's what a main vocalist should get!

@Free_Palestine_75

Ай бұрын

Itsealways been like this, you people are so annoying 😂

@exosnisso8909

Ай бұрын

@@Free_Palestine_75 no it wasn't, Yujin had more lines than her before this comeback in all songs line distribution, and I didn't even complain. I just pointed out the fact that Liz deserves it

@yuqilover628

Ай бұрын

not really, in most of the group the lead vocal have the most lines for eg, blackpink, itzy, twice, aespa

@exosnisso8909

Ай бұрын

@@yuqilover628 why does that happen?

@kongsuniiii

Ай бұрын

​@@exosnisso8909because of the song type, i guess, everything depends on the producer's choice which part suits certain members the most.

biasing gaeul in this economy is so hard 😔

@yuuuuuuki98

Ай бұрын

it's always been. but we need to hope that she'll get the opportunity, some time soon. a lot of Dive didn't understand the frustration of being a Gaeul fan. they'll deemed that we're ungrateful when actually we want to see more of her. they keep switching on to the lead rapper, main dancer argument and she almost didn't get no part on both categories. saddening but at least the music's good. we could only hope for another time 🙏

@fofinhado_kpopzoficial

Ай бұрын

Is realy but out now the Main rappers no have many lines

@Sandrinarhonda

Ай бұрын

@@yuuuuuuki98righttt . Gaeul deserves much better .

ELEVEN TAKE IT LOVE DIVE ROYAL After LIKE My Satisfaction Queen Of Hearts KITSCH Blue Blood I AM Lips Heroine Mine Hypnosis NOT YOUR GIRL Next Page Cherish Shine With Me WAVE Classic I WANT Either Way Off The Record Baddie Holy Moly OTT Payback All Night Will HEYA Accendio Blue Heart Ice Queen WOW RESET

10 seconds ago ❤😊

Slayyyyyy 😊❤

OMG LIZ

Finally Liz is at the top! hope she never has to come down again lol

@Free_Palestine_75

Ай бұрын

She was last once, stop being so annoying 😂

when will people start using mine for royal? random_k's is wrong

@bypaknox3629

Ай бұрын

bruh because people wanna leeseo last? because of the intro royal?

@miam_k

Ай бұрын

@@bypaknox3629 what

@bypaknox3629

Ай бұрын

@@miam_k idk sorry haha

@Sandrinarhonda

Ай бұрын

@@miam_ksupporting your channel btw l, you’re amazing

SLAY LIZ

can u give me what app u used to edit ? ❤

@sunmoon_k

4 күн бұрын

Flourish studio for the bar chart race Alight Motion and CapCut for the edit (mainly CapCut)

Rooting for Liz and Leeseo 🩵💛

a sole member who is constantly carrying the whole group's vocal will never have "many lines" she just got what she supposed to have. AND SHE DESERVE EVEN MORE

this comeback is so Liz era

@yuqilover628

Ай бұрын

Not really 🤣

@antoncutie

Ай бұрын

@@yuqilover628 you are just a hateful person. g idle stans will always be the worst thing ever ewww

Liz main vocalis become really true

@Allure.Entertainment

Ай бұрын

Their are no positions😀

Why no one count Liz adlibs in Payback....she does that adlibs its not bg vocalist.....she herself lip-sync in the MV.....just like Next Page we thought The adlibs were Bg vocalist.....but Liz herself do that on Live performance......it can be Her...

@sunmoon_k

Ай бұрын

some adlibs are her, however, there are some that are bv, the background vocalist of this song has a voice similar to Liz, so it may sound like her, but it's bv:)

@i_for_ivyz6306

Ай бұрын

@@sunmoon_k random K didnt count the last chorus adlibs....which is done by Liz....thats the problem.....that is not Bv.....most of the adlibs is her...but RandomK dont count.....

@Kat-y_L

Ай бұрын

@@i_for_ivyz6306 Lis only had adlibs during the 2nd chorus , the last adlibs are not her , it's another singer .

@i_for_ivyz6306

Ай бұрын

@@Kat-y_L its her she lip sync in the Payback mv go check

@Kat-y_L

Ай бұрын

@@i_for_ivyz6306 I'm not sure.... everyone who did vocal analysis for payback said it wasn't her ....also just cause she was lipsyncing doesn't mean it's her lines . She didn't lipsync her adlibs during 2nd chorus so does that mean it's not hers ? No offense...but either way she's first .

all night line distribution is incorrect In the pinned link you said that you used the random k one ( line distribution) but in the video you used a different one that it.s incorrect

@Kpop_lover165

Ай бұрын

So in total Wonyoung is 4th And lesseo is 3rd

@weejinnie22

Ай бұрын

yeah they said they fixed the distribution, random_k didnt double the timer for wony and yujin's adlibs

Line distribution without All Night?

Liz was saved at the last second

Can you fix Payback Liz has 58

@bypaknox3629

Ай бұрын

no are you crazy hahaha

@JY_Hann0

Ай бұрын

@@bypaknox3629 she even lipsyncs them in the mv + THEY SOUND LIKE HER😭😭

@bypaknox3629

Ай бұрын

@@JY_Hann0 no

bestie love dive is kinda wrong because de lalala isn't the girls

For 6 member this line are pretty fair 😎

I notice that the new album track's line distribution are really gair, like look at the pie chart, it's literally the same amount.

1 minute ago

Isn't After Like wrong?

@sunmoon_k

Ай бұрын

No, I think

LIZ FIRST?!?!!??!?

leeseo wony : were best friend till the end yujin liz : sometimes, we switch our rank *WHILE* rei : *far away gaeul : ok👁️👄👁️

the adlib in after likfe prechorus is yujin not liz

@sunmoon_k

Ай бұрын

it's clearly liz

@bypaknox3629

Ай бұрын

@@sunmoon_k nope?

YUJIN and LIZ everytime ⬆️⬇️⬆️⬇️⬆️⬇️

the best vocalist is on top 😘

When you look at it Ive’s line distribution is actually really fair

I don't understand why Leeseo has so many lines, has high notes (which could be made by strong vocalists like Liz, Yujin even Rei or Wonyoung) and is receiving raps, more than Gaeul than if she is a rapper (I don't hate it or anything about it, but I really think that the lines of strong vocal should be given to the strong vocalists and the raps to those who are rappers, in this case Rei and Gaeul)

@blueorangeade712

Ай бұрын

Honestly in the group leeseo is one of the louder ones when singing live so I get it

@opinionisopinion

Ай бұрын

True, starshitt promoting her so much

@ayjheyday

Ай бұрын

I saw it too... idk maybe the producer think leeseo voice suit the song more than any strong performance?

@55Michelle

Ай бұрын

Probably because her voice perfectly fits IVE's sound. Ive has this siren and alluring sound and leeseos unique vocal tone perfectly fits the song along with liz.

@ppkrn2854

Ай бұрын

So Leeseo would be no line right because Vocal part You think She doesn't deserve Only Strong vocalist can made it, and Rap You think She doesn't deserve those line Only Rapper, What's line she can have it

Where's Dear cupid

@sunmoon_k

Ай бұрын

not a song

liz should have 1 fifth place for love dive

This is pretty fair

ELEVEN Take It LOVE DIVE Royal After LIKE My Satisfaction Queen Of Hearts Kitsch Blue Blood I AM Lips Heroine Mine Hypnosis NOT YOUR GIRLS Next Page Cherish Shine With Me WAVE Classic I WANT Either Way Off The Record Baddie Holy Moly OTT Payback All Night Will HEYA (해야) Accendio Blue Heart Ice Queen WOW RESET 리즈 Liz: 1119.5s 유진 Yujin: 1119.2s 원영 Wonyoung: 929.8s 이서 Leeseo: 925.1s 레이 Rei: 813.7s 가을 Gaeul: 717.8s ELEVEN ~ HEYA (해야) IVE (아이브)

Liz finally takes the first place, I'm so happy with it...SHINE LIZ

Kitsch is still one of my top IVE songs, but I still dont understand how Starship wrote the song giving Liz just 1 solo part. I know she has most seconds in total discography, but Kitsch is one of their top songs. They could've easily given her at least 2 parts. I wish we could ask Starship personally what was going through their minds. Make it make sense. Still love Kitsch and Liz and IVE.

@weejinnie22

Ай бұрын

It might have been a marketing tactic to get people talking about it before I Am was released

@KaMiCoNg

Ай бұрын

@@weejinnie22 that actually makes sense. Bc it can't be an oversight, no one would make that mistake on purpose. Let's just believe Liz is an integral part of the ambiguous chorus. But I tell ya Kitsch and Love Dive live at the concert was sensational.

Rei and Gaeul, You Are Rapper but you Have better vocal than Leesoo and Wonyoung

@roshankamat1216

Ай бұрын

wongyoung and leeseo dont have the best vocal skills...but they both have a beautiful tone while singing...❤

@Noble482

Ай бұрын

That’s a lie. You’re either not updated on their skills or you know nothing about vocals. The correct ranking based on techniques and skills is: Liz Yujin WonYoung Rei Leeseo Gaeul. Attend their concert or listen to their live performances. Wonyoung’s falsetto is much better than Rei and Gaeul. Leeseo is quite nasal but she’s more consistent and can project more while dancing.

@roshankamat1216

Ай бұрын

@@Noble482 I agree they r both so good......no hate to Rei and Gauel

@heekibunny9815

Ай бұрын

@@Noble482 indeed bro!! Wonyoung are great Lead Vocalist in IVE and best Vocalist with Yujin & Jiwon (Liz) Even, A lot of western Vocal coach and Music Producer like Ryan S Juhn are praised her singing skill. They not even afraid to give a high grade to Jang Wonyoung's vocal abilities.🤝.

@heekibunny9815

Ай бұрын

@@Noble482 Only SM STAN always underestimates the vocal abilities of middle/Nugu agency groups and what's more cunning is that they always instill a stigma in the public that vocalists from other agencies are the worst 😎

But yes liz is mistreated 🥺🥺🥺

@antoncutie

Ай бұрын

she's the only one with proper vocal support, people are just happy that the starship did something before it became a real mistreatment. but the real mistreatment here is not giving the supposed 2nd best vocalist any vocal lessons because girlie been struggling since izone

@lia-zc4iz

Ай бұрын

​@@antoncutie yujin can support

@antoncutie

Ай бұрын

@@lia-zc4iz once in a blue moon, yes.

@izzysplanet69

Ай бұрын

@@antoncutietoken stan

@antoncutie

Ай бұрын

@@izzysplanet69 if being the best vocalist that solely being able to support and stanning her making someone a token stan, then sure if that helps you sleep at night 🤭

Finally Liz in first place

@ihatebeingright3376

Ай бұрын

Wdym finally? She was always in the top ranks for line distribution

Deserved Lizzzzz!!!!! I think wonyoung should be 2nd place I literally don’t see the appeal in Yujin’s voice no offense

@lia-zc4iz

Ай бұрын

Yujin can support and have better vocal tone than wonyoung who cannot also have nasal voice sometimes

This is my opinion, so if you don't agree and want to disagree, just disagree for yourself. I'm sorry Liz fans, but in my opinion Yujin should be the main vocalist, since she has all the necessary skills to be in that position. Liz has great vocals too, however I would say that she could be one of the vocal leaders of the group, since in Ive's classification, she would be in the top 3, with Yujin as main, Liz as second and in third place me I would leave Wony or Leeseo, although we can recognize that Wony is just the main visual and also the face of the group. What is worth highlighting here is that Ive urgently needs to create ways of putting Rei and Gaeul on the same vocal range as the sub vocalists until then.

@Kat-y_L

Ай бұрын

What load of bullshit that you wrote , yujin is technically on the sub vocalist level of 4th gen kpop idols , no support , regressed techniques , straining even the basics of notes. There's a huge huge gap between Liz and yujin , yujin is closer to rei and wonyoung's level comapred to liz . Yujin doesn't have the bare minimum skills to be in that position let alone the necessary skills , hitting high notes isn't the only skill needed to be the main vocalist , I maybe a bit biased to Rei but even rei is more relaxed than yujin when it comes to mid to low range . I don't know how much you understand vocals but if i were to compare with other idols , Liz is a better singer than main vocalists Lia of itzy , Mia of everglow or Hanni from newjeans whereas yujin is worse than chaewon of lsg , youngheun of kep1er etc , she's more on the level of , minju(newjeans) , stayc's J , or g idle's minnie .

@eupedromarcello

Ай бұрын

@@Kat-y_L Like I said, it's my opinion, so whether you like it or not, is your problem!

@eupedromarcello

Ай бұрын

@@Kat-y_L I still think you're stupid, since Yujin is the leader of the group, do you really want to talk about Everglow's Mia? Since it unfairly dominates the lines of all songs?

@nswer_co.

Ай бұрын

this makes no sense

@haobinisreal

Ай бұрын

​@@Kat-y_LFrom what I understand Yujin is E+/E which is not at the level of Minju from new jeans and even less than J from stayc Minnie is currently E- That's all, I share the same opinion as you.