In Estonian it's not throat singing, but an instrument, parmupill (Jew's harp) is melting together with the backup singer's voice.

The ”throat sound” in Estonian was a backup singer, or whatever they’re called in English, the singers in the chorus, *BESIDES* the lead singer. The style is called ”regilaul” in Estonian (”runonlaulanta” in Finnish, and ”leelo” in Setu). Throat singing is peculiar to Mongolic and some Inuit groups, as far as I know, and neither ethnicity is Finno-Ugric (or even Uralic, for that matter). Anyways, great video. A Finn approves. 🇫🇮👍🏻🇮🇹

@tovarishcheleonora8542

6 ай бұрын

Tibetians well known for their throat singing.

@PC_Simo

6 ай бұрын

@@tovarishcheleonora8542 OK. I’ve never heard of that; but, I guess, you learn something new, every day. Thanks, for educating me, here 🙂👍🏻.

@forgottenmusic1

5 ай бұрын

There was no throat singing, but a backup singer AND a Jew's harp (Estonian name: parmupill).

This is really cool but latvian or lithuanina aren’t uralic languages

@duhni4551

3 жыл бұрын

But both countries have large populations of Finno-Ugric speaking people.

@PC_Simo

2 жыл бұрын

My thoughts, exactly.

@PC_Simo

2 жыл бұрын

@@duhni4551 Yeah, but the languages (Latvian & Lithuanian) that the uploader was talking about, aren’t Uralic.

@duhni4551

2 жыл бұрын

@@PC_Simo That much is true, didn't argue against it. Just pointed out quite relevant fact, if we talk about language families in the region.

@PC_Simo

2 жыл бұрын

@@duhni4551 OK. So, you were just pointing out a related fact. Gotcha!

Ingrian is spoken in northwestern Russia(Leningrad region,Karelia and nearby territories)

@KimmoRantala-hs5cc

Жыл бұрын

Inkeri on suomea. Suomen murretta. Äänislinna on, ja tulee olemaan, Suomea.

@PC_Simo

6 ай бұрын

@@KimmoRantala-hs5cc Taitaa sekoittaa sen inkeroiseen (= Izhorian), joka ei ole suomen murretta, vaan alueella jo pidempään asuneen suomensukuisen kansan (inkerikkojen) kieli. 🤔

@KimmoRantala-hs5cc

6 ай бұрын

@@PC_Simo No tämä on totta. Tarkoituksena oli, että Inkeri ei ainakaan venäjää ole.

@mixlllllll

3 сағат бұрын

​@@KimmoRantala-hs5ccKyllä Äänislinna, tai siis Petroskoi, taitaa ihan Venäjää olla 😁

Я если честно первый раз такую удмуртскую музыку слышал :D

Livonian is a minority language in Latvia....

You can view the map from here: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Finno-Ugric_languages#/media/File:Finno-Ugric_Languages.png

I'm from Finland and this sounds mainly just like gibberish or 'elvish' to me..

@moisuomi

3 жыл бұрын

Well maybe you aren’t Finnish?

@moisuomi

3 жыл бұрын

This sounds very similar to me and I am Finnish.

@juulia8983

3 жыл бұрын

”Kuulin äänen, kuulin, kuulin äänen kullaltani Heläyksen, helä-heläyksen hertaltani Luulin luona, luulin, luulin luona olleheni” Siinä sulle lyricsit nii ymmärrät sääki😉

You had it right, what you said during Finnish song. All examples thus far had been from closely related Finnic languages. As a native Finnish speaker, they are the languages I immediately recognize as relatives, because they have similar words and so much common in all levels of language. Finnish and Estonian are the biggest Finnic languages, and for example language called Votic (vatja in Finnish) is very interesting, because it is in many features like a bridge between Finnish and Estonian. So, you were very right about mutual intelligibility. For Finnish speaker Karelian Viena dialect is probably easier than Spanish to speaker of Portuguese (the equivalent could be Swedish to Norwegian speaker). Estonian without prior learning is for Finnish speaker probably quite much harder to understand than Italian to Spanish speaker, but I know from my own experience that even a little bit learning made me possible to read in Estonian about familiar subjects. Distance between Livonian and Finnish is something like Portuguese and French. Of course these are only rough approximations, but you can see that Finnic languages form a similar network like Romance, Slavic and Germanic languages with great similarities and regular differences. Some languages are closer to each other than others, but they all are easily classified in the same group.

@yungwhippin7252

2 жыл бұрын

As a native swedish speaker i find norweigan so easy to understand that it seems not like a seperate language but more of a dialect with a few words that i don't recognize but i can still understand basically everything else their saying the only difference being that they speak a little bit differently. Would you call it the same between for example finnish and karelian?

@mikahamari5994

2 жыл бұрын

@@yungwhippin7252 Yes, it is exactly the same situation. Karelian Viena dialect is very similar to Eastern dialects of Finnish, they have same roots in earlier language form called Proto-Finnic. Most words that are not easily intelligble are loan words from Russian, but it feels much more like a dialect than separate language. Meänkieli spoken in Sweden is another example. Earlier it was classified as Finnish dialect, now it is minority language. Because I have learned Swedish at school, I understand Swedish loan words and Meänkieli is like Finnish dialect in intelligibility. I was once listening to Meänkieli activist, who (paradoxically) tried to convince us that we don't understand him. I respect his passion, but I understood everything. :)

@yungwhippin7252

2 жыл бұрын

@@mikahamari5994 That's interesting i have never heard of this meänkieli dialect before. And in regard of what you said about the finnish and karelian languages having roots from Proto-finnic, I suppose you could compare it to the scandinavian languages common root from Old Norse and maybe even the more broad Proto-germanic. I also wonder if finnish and karelian being descendants of an older language retain different words from the earlier language meaning for example that one word from this older language was kept in one language while in the other it wasn't kept. Sorry if that end part didn't make sense lol.

@mikahamari5994

2 жыл бұрын

@@yungwhippin7252 Yes, you are correct. In Uralic languages classification it is common to postulate earlier language form called Proto-Finnic, which is common root for Finnish, Karelian, Estonian and so on. This is the similar historical level as Urnordiska or whatever is called the common root for Swedish, Norwegian, Danish etc. All descendants of Proto-Finnic are easily recognizable as related languages and somewhat mutually intelligble. But this Proto-Finnic had three main dialects: Western, Eastern and Southern. Estonian is from this Southern branch, Karelian from Eastern. Finnish Western dialects are from Western branch and Eastern dialects from Eastern. So, actually Eastern dialects of Finnish are genetically closer to Karelian than to Western Finnish. Standard Finnish is combination of both and that's why it has synonyms from both dialects. So, Karelian and Finnish dialects have retained these words and have also own words that don't exist in other branches. Of course nowadays in Finland mass media makes words in every geographical area more common than at earlier stages of language.

@yungwhippin7252

2 жыл бұрын

@@mikahamari5994 Thank you for answering my questions! I think tradition should be at the core value of the community of every country since it is deeply rooted in the land itself. It is sad to see globalism destroy the individualism of each culture and intertwine them in a connected modern pop culture. I think dialects should be preserved, i think tradition and the way of life of every people should be preserved aswell. I know it is of topic a bit yet i'm quite passionate about it.

9:56 you mean Estonia? (1:34)

Quante lingue sai parlare Mauro?

Hola ya me suscríbi

Per favore puoi fare la reazione a "la gente mi guarda di ks"pls nn e famoso pero se lo merita🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺