That’s such a cool way to disguise the design flaw

@josephjackson1956

4 ай бұрын

The design flaw being the length of her arm? Lol

@fallenmango8420

4 ай бұрын

It’s not a design flaw. Just movie magic.

@DarkAttack14

4 ай бұрын

Yeah like someone else said, no design flaw, just short arms lol

@3katsime

4 ай бұрын

@@DarkAttack14design flaw as in someone in the process not realizing it won’t be possible for her to play that

@boredboi6279

4 ай бұрын

​@@josephjackson1956design flaw by Pixar

"intentional for a reason" is like "9 am in the morning"

@LegacyOfGi

3 ай бұрын

Or "RPG game"

@grandre3464

3 ай бұрын

“intentional and for good reason” would have been better

@waffler-yz3gw

3 ай бұрын

atleast that lets you know it's just a youtube shorts creator (and not an ai software

@Ocarina654

3 ай бұрын

Not to mention that every cut is intentional, even in a poorly made movie you can't really edit by accident. Even saying the cut had a good reason or something is a little obvious, especially for a studio like Pixar, especially in a masterpiece like Soul. It is an interesting editing choice, but they should have said something like it's interesting for a reason you probably wouldn't expect.

@giantclaw138

3 ай бұрын

*Chai tea* *Naan bread*

For a second I thought you were talking about a B flat there, and was confused as to why it was unreachable but it was actually a B natural.

@TheTromboneChannel

Жыл бұрын

I probably could have clarified that

@aikifab

8 ай бұрын

Anyhow, C is in 6, which is already far away. But I had to listen twice to realize the B was natural

@AdamFarinelli

7 ай бұрын

Same

@Daddy_donaldanddouglas

4 ай бұрын

B flat is in first position and is reachable for anyone who can hold a trombone

@theduckconstructs7686

4 ай бұрын

Unless she has a f attachment trigger

I once knew a very short girl who played trombone and got the low notes by dropping the moving thingy (sry idk the right terms) down and catching it with her foot. She would kick it back up and keep playing. It was seriously cool.

@kuratse205

3 ай бұрын

Okay that sounds super hot.

@TheBeastlySort02

3 ай бұрын

​@@kuratse205dude what the fuck

@beeburn0

3 ай бұрын

​@@kuratse205 ...Dude

@completerandomness4342

3 ай бұрын

​@@kuratse205😟

@Man-lt9hc

3 ай бұрын

@@kuratse205what the FUCK DUDE!!!

It can be hard for us trombones, especially when we are a cartoon with too short of arms

@wlwgwlwgnomesarereal

4 ай бұрын

this is so relatable. i am a cartoon myself and i have the same problem.

@TTmoose

4 ай бұрын

Slide 7 ☹️

@Coastal._1228

4 ай бұрын

7th position bro Was once recording a song for a state level competition (my whole band) and MY SLIDE FELL OFF

@gpettus9508

4 ай бұрын

I assumed it was due to the student trombone player being not fully grown yet

@potatoguy5428

4 ай бұрын

​@@wlwgwlwgnomesarereal NECO ARC⁉️⁉️⁉️

My young son just started trombone this week and he's confronted with the same challenge. He's trying real hard to persevere. But inside I have to admit I laughed when his slide fell off. 😅 I guess that's what us dads do.

@TheTromboneChannel

7 ай бұрын

Google “Extendabone” - that should do the trick

@wolfang5518

3 ай бұрын

Depending on his arm's length (I'm short, so my arm-span isn't great), to reach 7th position, he'll have to rotate his chest toward the Trombone to get that extra length. This could work if he's having issues reaching 6th too, though he would need a trigger for 7th if that's the case.

@karlrovey

3 ай бұрын

It sounds like he discovered the 8th slide position.

@willkinney5051

3 ай бұрын

Don't feel bad- I was the same way when I started!

@louisleduc4220

3 ай бұрын

Just knowing that a slide fell, I feel bad. It can be damaging and make the trombone unplayable. The slide must be perfectly parallel.

I play trombone and I missed this lol I just don’t really pay attention to the slide movements

@isaacjaramillo7333

9 ай бұрын

Me too ur good gang

@thatsmyboy_1

6 ай бұрын

Same here

@ambroseeck746

4 ай бұрын

Same

@Shrexy_Shrek

4 ай бұрын

Same

@trombonetribute6433

4 ай бұрын

Yes same

I missed that and I play trombone, that was very well hidden Hear me out, use a trigger instead… Edit: You can also lip the notes down if you don’t have a trigger, I use a straight horn in jazz and I have to play a low Eb for a section, so I just lip it flat, you can do the same thing on that partial right above if you need to.

@Beef_jerky_official

4 ай бұрын

Only some trombones have a trigger

@xXCodeyXx

4 ай бұрын

Those are so expensive tho

@Franmd

4 ай бұрын

Most middle schools have the trigger less one and some high schools have them

@jonathandemiguel1458

4 ай бұрын

​@@Franmdthat's why those starter trombones are so trash, they gotta cut corners somewhere

@Franmd

4 ай бұрын

​@@jonathandemiguel1458they do, even on the trigger ones when my friend got a brand new one the water valve fell off mid playing

“Hey do you play Trombone?” “Only 4/7 of it while people are looking”

It’s also a pretty good transition to how as she continues her music, he starts getting more and more interested.

"...Actually intentional for a reason."

@oscah_whisky

3 күн бұрын

When you gotta teach that word count...😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣

I love trombone because the limit to how high or low you can play is determined mostly on your skill. This means you can go as high or as low as you can and it still can sound great. (Technical there is a lower range limit depending on how slowly your lips can vibrate/make a discernible tone)

@AliOssol

3 ай бұрын

Brass instrument In a nutshell ❤

I play the trombone and missed this.

Omg it's like me lmao I have an F attachment cause I can't reach 7th in concert set and I can just barely reach 6th in parade set 😭 I've dropped my slide once trying so I normally just stick to using the attachment for 6th and 7th

@aikifab

8 ай бұрын

Dropping the slide is a bad experience...

@tidus08

3 ай бұрын

This person gets it. F Trigger for the win.

@blamboy27

2 ай бұрын

Is the F attachment a trigger or no? I understand the pain of dropping your slide.

@oliverdiamond6594

2 ай бұрын

lol one time my concert band was a bit sloppy on this one piece, so our conductor organised a outside of school rehearsal on the weekend so we could catch up. during sectionals, the bass trombone player accidentally dropped his slide while putting a mute in, the conductor was annoyed but he have him a second chance. then he dropped it again, and the conductor was clearly not happy and said he needs to work on this. then during a whole band rehearsal he did it again, and you could see his face fill with terror. the conductor berated him. then a little later my mute fell out. then i tried another mute and it fell out. then he berated both of us.

@blamboy27

2 ай бұрын

@@oliverdiamond6594 I'd be lying if I said that isn't funny.

I love my tenor lol

I feel like a lot of people who play the trombone still wouldn’t have noticed that

I'd like to see this movie.

@hammy_and_britney

4 ай бұрын

Watch it! It's really good

@petarus

4 ай бұрын

5 months have passed. Have you seen it yet?

@lucys2401

2 күн бұрын

9 months have passed. Have you seen it yet?

@ernestcassler2505

2 күн бұрын

@@lucys2401 no I still need to watch it.

Dude I play the trombone and I missed this, I just was happy to see a trombone

@blamboy27

2 ай бұрын

Same.

As someone who plays bass trombone with my middle school jazz band, I can confirm I didn’t notice this

As a trombone player, I can confirm that this is true.

@OfficialTruzoFN

4 ай бұрын

Same.

@shrimpickles9910

3 ай бұрын

As a trombone, i also confirm

They should have made it a trigger trombone. Then that problem is eliminated. I saw that and was confused but this is explanation makes sense. Trombone superiority!!

@retrospy

2 ай бұрын

i heard they wanted to make the animations/slide movements accurate,having a trigger prob makes it more difficult since they need to animate the thumb moving aswell as the rotor mechanism

Soul was one of my favorite animated movies as it had a very deep underlying story

as a flute player, i can confirm that i’ve missed this and was paying attention to the flutes the whole time. 😂😂

always glad when you enjoy an ep of buffy, but was surprised you enjoyed this one. thought it was gonna be another ‘ted’ situation where you just sighed and rolled your eyes through the last bit when things really ramped up haha. great reaction, and great post-editing interlude. have really loved seeing your cordelia opinions evolve in particular

Trombone players who use a F attachment and don’t have this problem 👇

@_.Peanut._.

3 ай бұрын

Lucky >:( I have to push the slide all the way down

@sharkgrove9272

Ай бұрын

I cut my finger once when I tried playing a b natural

Me who plays trombone but still didn’t know about this: 💀

They don't want the people watching the movie to see her arm split off of her body, to play those notes

Learning this on clarinet one week before the final preformance is terrifying, thanks for the video for reference

I play the trombone and totally noticed this. B flat, usually the first or second note trombonists learn is very easy since it’s 1st position (the position closest to you), while B natural is 7th position, fully extended slide position, right before it falls off but not quite yet. This only applies for normal octave because for higher octaves of B and B flat, there are way easier slide positions.

Yo that's Erik Griffin

@TheTromboneChannel

Жыл бұрын

It’s actually played by Andy Martin.

@RolandSpecialSauce

Жыл бұрын

@@TheTromboneChannel Man, That joke flew right over your head.😂

@TheTromboneChannel

Жыл бұрын

@@RolandSpecialSauce i genuinely have no idea what you're talking about.

@RolandSpecialSauce

Жыл бұрын

@@TheTromboneChannel Look up Erik Griffin and you'll know what I'm talking about

@TheTromboneChannel

Жыл бұрын

@@RolandSpecialSauce so the joke is that he’s a comedian???

Never noticed that, but yeah the B note always got me during my trombone days. Being pre-teen is not conducive to playing the slide. 😂

I love how creative Pixar and Musicians can be.

I actually remembered this happening, and I pointed it out during the movie

I still have my Trombone in my room and I always assemble it and just play some good songs I learned during elementary and middle school, it's been a while since I played my trombone at the moment but from seeing this movie has a place in my heart as a trombone player 🥹

I love design people being passionate about an Instrument or Music in General as i play Bass myself, keep going man! :D

Dude Soul literally opened my head to Disney trying to animate instruments

When I played trombone for band class I would use the very tips of my fingers when I had a hard time reaching a note. I honestly miss playing trombone.

Fun Fact, some trombones have a rotating stick detached to the handle of the slide to allow easier access to that section for shorter arm lengths.

As a band student who doesn’t play trombone, I still understood as soon as the music came up and ngl it’s hilarious how Connie is just too small to play that note lol

Reminds me of how movies who use cgi would use objects blocking our view to make it easier on the animation team, kinda like transformers where robots transform off screen

I started watching thisbyesturday after mcas in school bro and stopps at this part 😭

He looks like he got stung by a bee in the face.

HELP HER ENTIRE ARM GOES TO THE BELL💀💀💀💀

I always thought that cut was unintentional for a reason

That's some really impressive attention to detail.

Kids in my middle school had to tie a shoestring form their wrist to the trombone slide to hit those low notes

"Intentional for a reason" just over here saying the same thing twice

Relatable, I always used my middlefingers tip to reach the 7th slide

It really shows how little funding their band gets, especially since most bands nowadays, even those with little money, have trombones with the F trigger attachment to reach those position’s equivalents easier.

when you reach eighth position and your trombone enters a state of enlightenment and the band director wipes his tears with a polishing cloth

Thank you for mentioning this I thought I was the only one who noticed this I’ve been playing trombone for three years

Camera tricks like this in animation are common. They usually do this in times when it's hard/impossible to animate. For example; characters changing clothes in real time though sounds simple but it is not easy to animate, so they pan the camera to their surroundings.

I watched this when it came out and started playing this year😂

I used to play trombone. I didn't notice it at first but I did before you mentioned it

I can hardly hit those notes on my trombone either, lmao

Pans back to her who's know using her feet to reach those notes.

The way the kids played the instruments is so accurate to middle school band lmao

As a trombonist I see this as an absolute win.

What I'm getting from this is that they are actually making sure the instrument is visually played correctly, even though they could just do random movements and pretend it's the right way to play. I respect that.

Love how a bunch of trombonists have conglomerated in this comment section, really warms the heart

Yeah when I watched soul I hadn’t started playing the trombone yet so I didn’t notice and now that you pointed it out now I noticed

I genuinely though he said " to play deez nuts". Im an idiot 😂

The shame i feeling being a trombone player and missing that is immense

There was a story in my marching band back in school of a short trombonist who hit those notes by tying a string to their wrist and to the slide to extend their reach a bit. Never saw it in person, but it sounded like a good solution!

Anyone with long arms who initially tried for the trumpet got the trombone

I noticed that immediately while watching it in a band class lol

As a bass trombone I have two triggers for a reason so that’s why it’s great for people who don’t have long arms.

when i played trombone and couldn’t reach, i would push it and use the tips of my fingers to snag the edge of the handle lol

She's literally me when I was trying to play trombone years back. My arms were too small so it was so hard to play.

I remember having this issue, I would have to put my foot up at the end and flick it back up into my hand. Every time my director saw it, he died. 😂

In 5th grade my grade had to pick either choir or band(and instrument), I chose band, because I saw videos of people making engine sounds mimicking high speeds with trombone and played it until 8th grade when it was no longer required, now I play guitar

I am a trombone player (tenor ofc) and I missed this after watching this 5 times

I play trombone, and I can feel her pain just hearing those notes. Also I should really actually watch Soul sometime.

Fun fact: Andy Martin was the player behind Connie and he said he played while being motion tracked

I play the trombone and used to be unable to reach 7th position, the way they divert he attention is so smart

I just like how the end finish of the trombone went

When he said “these notes” it sounded to me like deez nuts

This is true. In my band class I was one of the only kid that could use the trombone because of how tall i was and my arms were long enough.

Was either the only one who started to hear I’m so lonely at the end of it

They should have shown her adjusting her grip, which is typical for middle school trombonists. My friends used to switch to holding it between their middle and index fingers to get all the way out

As someone who used to play trombone and could not in fact reach that far with my arms, you can twist the left side of your body and your head back a little bit to extend the slide to position 6 and 7 It’s not comfortable and it definitely looks odd but it works if you can pull it off

I used to play trombone I think if ur using a trombone with a trigger on it u can do those notes with out having to go all the way to 7th

As a trombone player myself, I’m kind of surprised that I couldn’t figure this out on my own

It sounds like that one song: meanwhile: feel like sun on my skin

Dude I literally stopped the short at the beginning just to watch soul again since I actually play trombone

bro i play trombone and i missed this

When I had a peashooter those lower notes sucked. But with the trigger made it a lot easier. Even years after school I still have all my instruments

During my last year in animation class, i had to animate our character playing piano. We got the contact of a man from our headlaster, that knows how to play and do sound design. It was a terrible idea to listen to him, because he doesn't know anything about animation. He said that the bird (our second character) should sound like a violin, to change for the usual chirp or flute.. but pal, if that's what everybody used for so long maybe it's because it works better. I had to replicate his movement when our character played his music, and in the end the jury told us it was not good, nobody Plays like that. None of them ever played an instrument. None of them knew anything about birds. When they criticised our characters, we responded with "you want to know why those three things are terrible ? Somebody asked us to listen to our composer, that's why the sound is off. He corrected us on the hands animation and we had to litteraly duplicate his movement, that's why the hands looks off. We used references of big birds because our bird is big, thay's why it's not moving fast like tiny birds. It's the size of an hawk, not a colibri." We succeeded. All that to say, animation is hard. Animating musician is really hard. Animating them accurately is a nightmare that most people won't even see. The cuphead show intro, mugman doesn't play right. Jojo part 6 when pens fall on a piano, its played correctly. Don't put too much effort in the toughest things, nobody is gonna say you did good anyway.

As someone who has not played trombone in 2 years, i can confirm. arm no streatchy like that

As a trombone player i didn't notice that but I did notice that im pretty sure she didn't play the write notes in class

When you said something being a trombone player I was like "I'm not, this could be interesting...." Forgetting the four and a half years I put into playing the trombone back in middle school and early high school

I remember when I was first learning, and I had to use the tips of my fingers to reach those last few notes because my arms were just a little too short.

I play trombone but i did not realize that sound was 7th position till now

I was the first kid in my grade who could reach 7th position comfortably, and as a result was automatically first chair.

I remember trying to hit that in 6th grade and failing

on most trombones u can use ur valve to make those lower notes, without going all the way down

That’s such a cool way to avoid a design flaw (yes I fixed the top)

i used to hit that note by throwing my slide and catching it with my foot. when it finished it kick it back and play as if it hadn't happened. only sometimes it would fly off 😅😅

Better than having her just say *"ZOOM PUNCH"*

Fun fact. If you have an F trigger trombone, you can plan the C in 1st position