I can't think of a group of people less likely to fall into anarchy than Astronauts.

@docsays

4 ай бұрын

Yup, all their training, science, & collaboration goes out the door after 1 email

@jtmplmbr4465

4 ай бұрын

Seriously. 1% chance of astronauts doing this. They typically don’t give a crap about nationality up there from the interviews I have heard

@dars5229

4 ай бұрын

Aye. For the Apollo 13 movie they pretty much had to invent drama and bickering between the astronauts that never happened because in real life the guys were stone cold professionals.

@zacharync3066

4 ай бұрын

@@dars5229it’s actually insane listening to the actual recording of the crew on Apollo 13 and how calm and collected they were throughout the entire thing

@arcosprey4811

4 ай бұрын

@@zacharync3066they were seasoned test pilots for the Air Force, every one of them. They were literally used to breathing and thinking about dangerous situations and potential death. They weren’t phased by anything that happened on the spaceflight it was quite mild tbh compared to things they’d face when aerodynamics come into play.

The studio dumped it in January and barely advertised. Told me what I needed to know before even considering to watch this one.

@chriswirt4625

3 ай бұрын

Overrated Celebs Who Actually Suck At Acting

I'm going to give it a watch I still think the movie Sunshine is underrated.

@DGidel1089

4 ай бұрын

It's a fucking masterpiece until the last 10 minutes then it has a stroke then it gets its shit together for the last couple minutes again.

@Ta2dwitetrash

4 ай бұрын

F yes its underrated.

@Zurround

4 ай бұрын

I did NOT like Sunshine, It was TOO unrealistic and got too weird near the end. ISS is not much better. Too much of the behavior of the characters made no sense to the story.

@joshuapeer9289

4 ай бұрын

DUDE RIGHT?! Thanks for bringing up that gem!

First aliens, now humans. ISS can’t catch a break.

@superhappyfuntime5466

4 ай бұрын

Don't forget the asteroid bits in Armageddon.

@HeatherHolt

4 ай бұрын

The actual iss will be intentionally crashed into the pacific in the next decade or so. Which will then make way for a Jeff bezos funded replacement. Not kidding.

@skepticalmagos_101

4 ай бұрын

Robots : We're next then?

@Theggman83

4 ай бұрын

​@@superhappyfuntime5466that was MIR. 😅

@jordantherubio

4 ай бұрын

😂😂

They weren’t nuked, the earth was attacked by a bug meteorite and the movie is trying to cover it up. “Would you like to know more?”

@Hawk7886

4 ай бұрын

Service guarantees citizenship!

@filmcomicsexplained

4 ай бұрын

I'm doing my part!

@Jcrash_31

4 ай бұрын

We have the ships! We have the weapons! We need Soldiers! Soldiers like Private Ace Levy and Lieutenant John Rico! " C'MON YOU APES DO YOU WANT TO LIVE FOREVER!! ". We need you all! THEY'LL KEEP FIGTING AND THEY'LL WIN!

@docsays

4 ай бұрын

- Ricco’s Rough Necks!!!

I want to give this movie a shot but I have a feeling it'll turn out to be extremely obnoxious just with the premise. The ISS has no tactical purpose, it's just a science platform. If superpower countries were attacked, the ISS would just be abandoned and couldn't be resupplied. I guess it's all they could do to avoid the realistic approach where a bunch of scientists get cut off and slowly starve until the platform eventually runs out of air and fuel and eventually deorbits itself, or they collectively decide to do it manually.

@emarley9

4 ай бұрын

On this we very much agree. Except that apparently they were carrying the cure for radiation poisoning (weird but alright) - something they probably should have put in the trailer so we knew there were actually real stakes.

@seanh0123

4 ай бұрын

@@emarley9that bit was so intensely stupid. Yes we’re going to take this experimental vial from the ISS down to earth and develop that into something useful overnight. We’ll first need to rebuild our supply chains and industrial capacity somehow which should take what 48 hours?

@emarley9

4 ай бұрын

@@seanh0123 haha indeed. It's very much a socialist perspective on product distribution. "You have? Give! Then *we* have! Or just me. But that's better anyway."

@cass7448

3 ай бұрын

There is a time to ham-fist politics into things. This is not one of those times. @@emarley9

@KonekoPurrrfection

2 ай бұрын

It was pretty boring

I can't imagine of a worse place to be during a nuclear war than in space even without any threat just to be there stuck watching the world burn

it makes no sense if the iss was a weapon platform, i could understand wanting control but both country's are nuked so why fight each over it makes no sense.

@Zurround

4 ай бұрын

Its a bullcrap plot device. This movie was NOT well thought out plot wise.

@yaldabaoth2

4 ай бұрын

I suppose the governments knew about the radiation sickness cure. What I'm more confused about is why would these governments even still exist and have the means to communicate. Communication infrastructure is the first thing to be targeted.

@Zurround

4 ай бұрын

@@yaldabaoth2 My guess is the most powerful and important people in government had a contingency like underground fortress to hide in or something. Something similar happened in the 1983 movie called THE DAY AFTER.

@rellett1

4 ай бұрын

@@yaldabaoth2 also the magnetic pulse would of destroyed most of our technology, or the ability to make it and if the radiation cure did work how would we make with everything destroyed

@Halomaniac50

4 ай бұрын

@@rellett1I don’t think you quite understand just how advanced those underground bunkers are. They’re all emp shielded, and any government controlled ones meant for a situation like this would have science and medical labs within it

I would LOVE LOVE LOVE to see you do some explorations of the Expanse!!!!

@MerryMutant

4 ай бұрын

Seconded! Such an amazing series!

Wouldnt it been funny if between the Russians and Americans there was just a single guy from like new Zealand and the whole time each side is trying to convince him to betray the others or he just stays in the background chilling cuz he dosnt have a dog in the game

@daveyjones8969

4 ай бұрын

Nah, they need a Canadian lol. There's almost always one on board anyway, and Chris Hadfield commanded it like a boss. His book is really amazing too. Plus, they could have used the real Canada Arm instead of a fake arm... It gets overshadowed, but it's possibly the single most important tool for the astronauts. It has saved them thousands of dangerous space walks, which also need to be planned for like a week; not good for urgent repairs.

@IW3527

4 ай бұрын

​@@daveyjones8969 I think a Canadian character wouldn't have as much of a 3rd party vibe in this narrative because of their proximity to the USA. You're 100% right about Chris Haddonfield that man is badass and I really need to get his book as its been on my reading list since it was published!

@duitk

3 ай бұрын

​@@IW3527 Canada is in NATO and is part of NORAD so you are right they would have a dog in the game, since Canada is also eating nukes, in fact Europe and Asia would eat nukea too, Europe is mostly NATO and has nukes, China, North Korea,South Korea and Japan all have alliances with the US or Russia. Hell I would not be surprised if Australia and New Zealand ate nukes too since they are allies to the US.

I know it's going to have a different theme but I can't help but get Cloverfield Paradox vibes.

@daveyjones8969

4 ай бұрын

That was a horrendous film...

@tirefish

4 ай бұрын

Now that you mention it, Both movies have WW3 on Earth and WW3 on the Space Station their on. There might be more that I didn't think of.

@lucre113

4 ай бұрын

@@daveyjones8969yes chef thank you chef

@daveyjones8969

4 ай бұрын

@@lucre113 If you're going to insult me, at least have it make sense so it has a chance of stinging lol.

@AnnieAreU0kay

4 ай бұрын

​@@daveyjones8969 I'm pretty sure dude wasn't being sarcastic 🤣 but the movie wasn't trash

Nothing beats seeing another notification for your channel. Always great content with such in depth analysis. Cheers legend

@FilmComicsExplained Wow I missed this, got to give it a watch. Kind of reminds me of the astro/cosmonauts in the WWZ book that had to somehow survive and make it back down to Earth. They were very lucky to have not been completely forgotten about in that book; I wonder how this movie will end. (Also been watching your channel for years, started with the 28 Days Later graphic novel series you did (would also be really cool to see more stuff like that again :o ) Cheers bro!

Bugger, been busy all day and am late for your upload. Excellent review Niyat 👌

Call me an idealist but couldn’t someone aboard the ISS just call a meeting & say, “hey we were given crazy orders, but we aint doing that. Lets make decision how we want to handle this up here”

This movie is an amazing concept, but it wasn't handled by the best of writers/directors.

@AncestorEmpireGaming

4 ай бұрын

Seems like a common theme in Hollywood

@tmmnago2722

4 ай бұрын

Felt like this movie had no message.

@Hawk7886

4 ай бұрын

​@@tmmnago2722yeah, seems like they started with the nuclear apocalypse montage and worked backwards to try to build a full plot around it

Whether it's climate change, aliens, technological malfunctions, or other humans, space stations suck to be on.😱

@WangNurMouth

4 ай бұрын

So sayeth earthman *sticks flag in own yard*

Thank the lawd for another FCE video I needed one after today.

@filmcomicsexplained

4 ай бұрын

I got you brother, hope your day gets better chief!

I don't see the point of countries fighting over the space station during a nuclear war/winter.

@r01d2

4 ай бұрын

"whoever control the sky control the world" your satellite internet are in space, the astronaut is the one fix it and "unfix" it, then ask your friend how many they want to pay before you unplug their communication device.

@dsadik666

4 ай бұрын

@@r01d2 in the after math of a nuclear war, radiation Free Shelter with clean air, food and water is the most important thing.

@Hawk7886

4 ай бұрын

​@@r01d2the ISS has nothing to do with commsats and in a nuclear war civvie networks would probably just drop out

@dranixrush3306

4 ай бұрын

​@@r01d2Yes, people think it's gonna be kumbaya up there in an event like this.

@chancethompson8752

3 ай бұрын

It’s semi implied in the ISS podcast that covers the first hour of the nuclear war but implying the that the governments of bounty countries realizes that most CC locations will be storied and with lose of there secure communications with military hardware they need a way to tensever massages to there forces to continue fighting or rebuilding there nations

I love your channel and your videos. After 7 years of watching your videos, this was the first time i lost track and found hard to grasp what the hell was going on. Mind you cloverfield paradox was explained seamlessly. Perhaps this was a shorter and quicker pace review. But i rarely find myself venturing to another channel to see a review from where i first checked yours out on. Never the less thanks for sharing, if it wasnt for you i would've never known this movie existed.

Your videos are so great and well put through, I remember your first vids. Wish these movies could’ve been better

Funniest thing is that if this happened, I'm almost certain the astronauts/cosmonauts would just be like "what? No dude"

@dranixrush3306

4 ай бұрын

You don't know that.

@oxymoron02

2 ай бұрын

@@dranixrush3306 Considering that the closest we ever came to nuclear war was when a Russian nuclear bunker received launch orders, but the operative on duty questioned it and held fire, I'm on the side of "The Americans would get orders to take the ISS by force while the Russians realised there is no bloody point".

@dranixrush3306

2 ай бұрын

@@oxymoron02 The two scenarios have slight differences, but important differences especially considering that you can clearly see a nuclear war ongoing. It would make more sense to follow the given directives.

@hectito982

2 ай бұрын

@@dranixrush3306the ISS doesn’t have or provide any tactical advantages, so no

@dranixrush3306

2 ай бұрын

@@hectito982 It had medicine to combat radiation or some shit. That would be a good tactical advantage.

Great video, I swear without you my day wouldn’t be as good

Wonder if the Soyuz still comes with a survival pistol in its kit.

@purpleranger5987

4 ай бұрын

Shotgun no? Because of bears and wolves

@Name-ot3xw

4 ай бұрын

@@purpleranger5987 I forget what type, I would assume some sort of 30-30 or near caliber. With a shotgun you'd risk just pissing it off.

still not watch it but when I told my friends about the synopsis, all reply is same "they're non-combatant people, no obligation to support their country in war" in nutshell calling the plot is not possible happening in the right mind.

@IW3527

4 ай бұрын

It makes more sense when you consider that out out of 330 NASA astronauts 201 of them are former military. Don't know about Russia but at least for the USA it would make sense that some may prioritize national allegiance in such a situation.

The premise of this film just feels exhausting and exploitative of current events but also kind of late since not only is the ISS coming down but the Russians are also abandoning the program.

@cmath6454

4 ай бұрын

It's kinda not believable because if you are on a floating life raft the size of half a football field flying hundreds of miles a hour through hostile space with no military strategic, only scientific value, you aren't going to put anyone in danger because they are up there with you.

Couldn't have chosen the best time for your video 😂

@filmcomicsexplained

4 ай бұрын

👀

@cockneycharm3970

4 ай бұрын

@@filmcomicsexplained Thank you for your reply. Scary times Sir. Great channel my friend 👏

Thanks for the video!! See you later!! Stay safe.😊

@filmcomicsexplained

4 ай бұрын

Thanks! You too buddy

I just watched this with my mom. We liked it

@Zurround

4 ай бұрын

The movie made no sense. Why did she kill ANOTHER AMERICAN near the end of the movie. How was HE a danger to her? And his motives made no sense either. He goes from making a SANDWICH to having to be killed? I did not get it.

Sooo ... Basically a Call of Duty Ghost level, got it. 😂

Explore The Ancient Enemy from The Phantoms.

That reminds me of the movie from the 80's Def-con4

The only time I can think of WW3 and the international space station together was the original modern warfare 2

Just saw this movie last night. We had a very in depth discussion about it all the way home. I don't think you can take very much at face value in the movie. It looks like a science fiction movie, but everything is an analogy or allegorical. The firestorm on the planet is too big for the scale, but it doesn't need to be scientifically accurate. The constant glow and what it represents is more important. The loss of Gordon and Nika to me represents so much more than just plot contrivance. They represent the futility of love when war is determined to tear the world apart. As for the radiation sickness cure. If you think about it, there really isn't a cure, or a defense, against radiation that you inject or take. But that isn't important, it is what the cure represents. It is a decision that the characters need to make, and one we as the audience need to contemplate. It couldn't be the cure for cancer or old age, it had to be the one thing that would bring salvation for everyone on Earth. It had to be radiation sickness. Once the radiation starts circling the globe, everyone is going to need it. The idea is that the final 2 survivors have to choose whether or not to give the world a 2nd chance. If they do, which side would get it? They appear to choose the 3rd option, a hope to give it to a different country that won't use it to dominate the other, but give the whole world a chance. Completing their character arcs of not having to choose a side. I think this movie is way underrated right now. It is amazingly brilliant and I hope it gets it's a more fair assessment in the future.

Hi Niyat. Will you ever do a Q&A?

If Chris messina is in this then it’s a watch from me,He was in that film devil that was superb,

I enjoyed this video more than the movie.

have you ever done HBO The Leftovers?

Must be comforting and sad to be on a space station while the world burns below 😢.

@FilmComicsExplained I think we just need to start a petition or fundraiser for what we all know would be the best movie ever. Terminator vs predator vs aliens vs Robocop vs demolition man vs Rambo vs John McClain vs Martin Riggs and Roger Murtaugh vs last action hero vs Judge Dredd vs Snake Plissken vs Jack Burton vs Jackie chan vs Tango and Cash vs John Matrix vs Jack Ryan (Clear and present danger) . Hollywood just ain't got the chutzpah.

This makes me think of something Black Mirror would make 🤔

Wait this reminds me of among us

@filmcomicsexplained

4 ай бұрын

Sus

@sarajohnson6855

4 ай бұрын

Super sussy . You can't even trust your own comrades. 😮

I just watch the movies like 3 hours it was great

I remeber long ago there was an Episode of The Outer Limits with kind of the same plot but on Mars.

SPACE!!!

@M05tly

4 ай бұрын

😂

tbh, the movie’s plot feels like a Black Mirror episode.

Sucks bc the visuals don’t look half bad. Story is most important tho, and should always be the prime concern. I can watch a great story with bad cgi but a bad story w good cgi is a no.

@FilmComicsExplained and no i didnt forget about Freddy vs Jason vs Michael Myers vs leather face vs pinhead vs pumpkin head vs Buffalo Bill vs Ed Gein. That's the second movie which then culminates into the 3rd filmfor a horror vs action super mega hyper ultra battle royal! Where the twist at the end is they actually all have to face off against the lawnmower man..... *head explosions*

@WangNurMouth

4 ай бұрын

And for more money, in the end credits, Ed gein and Buffalo bill defect to lawnmower man. For some sort of violence pain flesh furniture arts and crafts orgy as the 4th installment. It will be a little risqué ill admit, but it's in good hands.....its alll in good hands... :3

Read Neal Stephenson’s, Seven Eve’s if you want a look at how astronauts would most likely act on the ISS during a world ending event.

I wonder if they took any ideas from the 80s VHS rental Defcon 4. Not a direct ripoff but a lot of similarities. They definitely got a budget over that campy film.

I don’t get how they expect to win with Euron Greyjoy on the team!!! Someone is going to get “a finger in the bum”!!

With the ending though, is there even a earth to back to 😢

I’m in the minority here but I liked this movie. Yeaa it had plot holes but I would rather have it then not. im interested to see how the world below is In a sequel and it didn’t end how I assumed. Love sci fi

If it went more into what was going on and happening on Earth it would have been better. It was good though

Pilou Asbæk is so underrated. He looks like Emile Hursch and Ewen McGregor had a son.

3:09 so its a mix of mw2 and the famous muiltyplayer game in a space station where 1 person is a spy.

Post the next planet of the apes movie analysis please 🙏🏼

Fun fact, the movie was filmed on the same Hollywood set NASA use for the ISS.

@exiledone69

4 ай бұрын

😂😂😂😂 🤦

Somebody poisoned the waterhole!

I wish I had seen this 7 hours ago.... Its pretty, and well acted, but the directorial and editorial choices are disappointing. Chekov's air system was probably the most egregious. The setup is solid, the follow through is just bland, and flavorless. Almost like they were afraid to make any kind of statement for fear of being to pro or anti American or Russian. Also, I would argue this is NOT sci-fi. It is set in space, and it postulates a potential future or alternate present, however science, actual or imagined, has little impact on the plot. This same story could have been told in an Antarctic research base, or any other isolated location with a dependency on the greater world for continued existence. Euron Greyjoy (Pilou Asbæk) is probably the only redeeming feature of this otherwise meandering meh burger.

Kinda reminds me of the movie 2010. While not the same, there's the same idea of US vs Russia while in space and a stressful situation going on.

@BritGirlJay

4 ай бұрын

2010 is a wonderful movie.

What would taking the iss really do?

How would even cure radiation? Isn't the deal with radiation that you can only block it, not remove it from the body?

Film really fizzled out after the climax. They didn’t know what else to say after that point.

So this is why NASA have Johnny Kim: astronaut, Harvard MD and Navy Seal operator …

I think it would have been more chilling had the Earth just gone complwtely dark and not on fire. No.lights, barely any communication or anything. I couldn't imagine how creepy it would be looking at essentially a dead planet.

Love the video Can you do Department of Mysteries,Azkaban,Avery family,Carrow family,Morsmordre,Theodore Nott,Antonin Dolohov and Yaxley Harry Potter

Gallager’s son was in this

i couldn't get over the idiotic haircut Kira has

@happicheshirecat

4 ай бұрын

Strong women

@Hawk7886

4 ай бұрын

honestly I think she rocks it

Well, I'm sure they have fun touching down in the middle of the pacific ocean.

More and for joel and until next Friday

The Plague 2006

ah yes, the russian as bad guy in hollywood movie is coming back...

Is this a sequall to modern warfare 2?...

this will be a cult classic soon with everything going on the planet right now. peace my friends.

Nightmare scenario

Angela Bassett did the thing...lol

more

Think NASA has agreement that geopolitics on earth has no affect on astronauts on ISS, this is to ensure that this film doesn’t take place

Please tell me in the final fight, someone says the line, "kiss my ISS!"

Among us live action was great

0:48 people are makeing call of duty stuff into movies=the zombies in space=moon map.

Components. Russian components, American components...all made in Taiwan! - Lev Andropov

IRL everyone would just want to go home.

It's not like the ISS is the equivalent of the Hammer of Dawn from Gears of War, so why fight about it?

my favourite space movie still The Martian. in that movie nobody asking what's your sexuality (seriously no romance in it) or what you represent, just Mark Watney want to survive, and everybody no matter what race or status just want him go home.

How silly is that, if WW3 does erupt they could potentially be the last humans so why fight?

No. It's suspension, but you're still in school.

I don't know the hell scape on earth kinda overwhelmed my suspension of belief.. as if nukes are that powerful

Or you could just take everyone out and be supreme ruler of space.

My girlfriend went to Palm Springs and saw this. It was the most ISS i think ive ever seen, which was certainly a movie.

Everything about this movie is so bad it's funny.

The outer limits dd a even lower budget of this story, When communication break down, and nations are on the edge. Did someone strike, should we hit first, what if its on. With no coms people start to get primal, and selfish. The ugly side of humanity shows its face.

Was pretty decent up until the ending. Ending this movie was so weak.

@Zurround

4 ай бұрын

I still do not understand that ending. Did you?

Honestly....movie was mid

Amogus

Too unrealistic, the Russians would've just locked themselves away after the first toilet backed up.

Premise doesn't make any sense at all. What's the point of loyalty to countries that no longer exist? You want to fight over whose country is the most unhabitable?

i think it was done better in the second movie to 2001 were thay were out by jupiter and had to move to other spape ship then both sides were this is stupid

Eat bones!