The last guy is the realest. A one state solution is not a solution as a democracy, like one guy said in the video the demography will be a problem for Israel as a jewish state. The Israeli political system gives way too much power to alliances, with 4 millions arabs they could overrun a majority of jews. The one state solution could only work if the arabs don't have the same rights, and Israel Supreme Court will never allow such a thing.

@millevenon5853

3 жыл бұрын

@Xftbllplyr Nation State Law

@ProudRegressive

3 жыл бұрын

Israel has Parliamentary supremacy and Basic Law is alot easier than an American constitutional amendment to change.

@reubenmcmurray4377

3 жыл бұрын

Federalism would address this for the most part. Let’s say eventually we have a Palestinian state and an Israeli state in one country with a federal system. Palestinians would need Israeli votes to pass anything through the upper house. Israelis would need Palestinian votes. Not to mention each state would have its own constitution.

@chayimjakob5499

3 жыл бұрын

Then maybe it's time to reform the Supreme Court.

@yko_7313

2 жыл бұрын

@@reubenmcmurray4377 ye because that just worked so well in China and HK right! Ye no.

Corey: "סִיפּוּחַ" is pronounced "Si-pu-aH" not "sippukh" . It's not "סיפוך"

@guywhousesapseudonymonyout4272

7 жыл бұрын

Oh, finally, after the interview with the young couple Corey pronounces סִיפּוּחַ right. And why was it necessary to add in the subs that they are a couple? Just because he's Ethiopian?

@jaredknows7090

7 жыл бұрын

Of course, why wouldn't he mention that?

@guywhousesapseudonymonyout4272

7 жыл бұрын

@Jared Knows Seems kind of obvious that they were a teenage couple. Mentioning it makes more of a big deal of it than it is.

@jaredknows7090

7 жыл бұрын

I was being sarcastic

@guywhousesapseudonymonyout4272

7 жыл бұрын

ok

Those Girls in the beginning are hot damn

Amos Oz explains this in "A tale of Love and Darkness" really well. Please read the book and watch the movie!

1:47 Holy moly. Israeli camouflage technology really is off the charts

@orful8166

5 жыл бұрын

Two years later! Just want you to know I laughed at this :)

@Shaw4123

2 жыл бұрын

@@orful8166 Two more years later! Just want you to know that I liked your comment.

@orful8166

2 жыл бұрын

@@Shaw4123 Crazy how fast time goes by! I remember writing this comment hahaha

@oscarabraham7834

7 ай бұрын

And two years later! That israeli is very square minded

Actually they only talk about the Bennett proposal which is not Annexiion of the whole West Bank but only of the Palestianin-ethincally-cleansed Area C (60% of the West Bank )

question: did that October survey count both Jews and Arabs who actually live in Judea & Samaria?

I like the pre-schools teachers response

love your videos

I respect the lady you interviewed at the last of the video who said yes! She understand that peace is worth it!

@ryansilver5497

2 жыл бұрын

The Arabs in West Bank want to be Israelis??? This is news to me . His poll that he shows at the beginning says they don’t I thought ?

@gili41

2 жыл бұрын

She is a little bit naive, she doesnt think what will happen if the jews will loose the demographic adventage everyone knows what are the aspirations of the palestinians. Thx god most of the israelis are not naive

@gili41

2 жыл бұрын

@@HITBnn learn some history my friend and yoo will find that the palestinians are the ones not willing to compromise, they had many chances to have a country and they rejected all the offers they were given. Why? Because they want all the land of israel, they dont recognise the legitimacy of the jews to have a country on this land. They are living in dreams but unfortunately they do not wake up from the dream

@kobi2024

Жыл бұрын

@@HITBnn I want to think this is sarcasm.

Glad you got yourself a dedicated translator who is also fluent in English. The quality of many of the older videos was marred by poor translation on the interpreters' part, as several Arabophone watchers her have testified to. It would also be nice if you could let her subtitle what the Arabs are saying rather than what the interpreters are relaying, as a lot of information seems to get lost in those translations.

Three state solution. Israel , Egypt and Jordan !!!!

Corey, no wonder they dont understand wht you're talking about. Annexation in Hebrew is not "Sipuch" but "Sipuach"

When you then consider how long the so-called occupation has lasted and consider the illegal settlements, an annexation is much more fitting by definition. Occupation - The control of a country or region by a hostile army. Annexation - A legal merging of a territory into another body.

@DND20

Жыл бұрын

annexation means giving citizenship to the annexed, that's why israel did not annexed the west bank.

@ofrikalif4938

Жыл бұрын

Israel should annex parts of the west bank including some palestinian villages and small towns, but the big cities like ramallah or jenin will be part of an autonomy

I knew there is some debate about Eilat being considered part of Eres Yisrael according to halakhic criteria and whether someone who lives there must ovserve "misvot ha teluyot be'ares", I wasn't aware that there was a question about Akko.

Many Israelis who want to annex the West Bank seem to want apartheid. That's very discouraging. As an outsider it seems like a two state solution would be best.

@ofrikalif4938

Жыл бұрын

I think the 2 state solution will make everything worse.

@RoccosVideos

Жыл бұрын

@@ofrikalif4938 Maybe. I'm not really sure which it best any more.

@ofrikalif4938

Жыл бұрын

@@RoccosVideos the two states solution died in 2000 camp david summit and the 2nd intifada in 2002. I believe that the solution is one state and autonomy such as the palestinian emirates solution. Israel simply can't allow a palestinian state to be due to strategic concerns. Look for "geopolitics of Israel" by caspian reporter. it's sums up the situation very well

@RoccosVideos

Жыл бұрын

@@ofrikalif4938 Yes, that all makes sense.

The last man speaks a lot of sense...it's a shame so few do

@HTYBeker

2 жыл бұрын

because its not true 😂😂

@louischamoun7072

2 жыл бұрын

@@HTYBeker Explain? If you have a reason, then feel free to enlighten.

why didn't you ask the Jews who live in Judea & Samaria what they think?

@greglauren8876

7 жыл бұрын

you have mental problems. what do you know about these people? have you met them? have you been there? besides what you've read in newspapers, 95% of which is lies, what do you KNOW about these people?

@greglauren8876

7 жыл бұрын

i love how people who have never seen, been or met...talk about something with such confidence. it's fascinating to me.

@g.iskandar90

7 жыл бұрын

They would say yes of course, but previously transferring Palestinians to an Arab country. Settlers are not open-minded people...

Reading comments was shocking and eye opening to me. Thanks to this channel I concluded there is no conflict at all.

YES absolutely

Israel should have annexed the West Bank in 1967. It wouldn't have been a perfect solution, but I think things wouldn't be as tense today

@beckyr.e1212

4 жыл бұрын

Vitaliy Markov like half/half?

Yes!!

It was always the goal and clearly always will be.

Yes.

Yes ... 'nuf said

I'm Palestinian and say annex everything, the West Bank and Gaza. You can even still call it Israel. Give everyone equal rights and responsibilities and go from there. It's the only thing that might work now. The two state solution is dead.

@TheBelovedDisciple144

7 жыл бұрын

Co exsist equally as Human beings under one soveriegn nation of Israel!?!?!?! A REVOLUTIONARY IDEA. Not really, but fuck trying to get people to agree with you. But im an American and I see blacks whites jews palastinians co exsisting as americans all day, everyday. But in Israel its like fuckkkk that!!!! I had this girlfriend, a palastinian, from Israel, I asked her once "Why cant jews and palastinians get along like different races of Americans do" Her answer was FUUUUCK THAT, THAT WILL NEVER WORK!!!!

@utopistmsoc

7 жыл бұрын

Well Michael, the problem is demography. Since Israel is an ethno-nationalist state and a democracy at the same time, it would be impossible to make one nation. I am Argentinean-Israeli and for me the One State Solution is the dream (a federation?) but it will not happen. A country for all its citizens, the dream.

@africangamer8287

6 жыл бұрын

Michael Alexander Idiot, even if Israel absorbed Palestine Palestinians wouldn't have equal right's. Isreal would open up multiple policies to making Palestinians a minority in what would have been known as Palestine. The Israeli government can't even provide care for the refugees assign to their country that they agreed to take care of so what makes you think that they would look at a Palestinian as if they were a Isreali citizen or specifically a Jewish citizen?

@africangamer8287

6 жыл бұрын

Meek Jahye nope, that's not a Palestinian that's a Palestinian-baiter.

@user-yk8pw5ci3t

6 жыл бұрын

Michael Alexander are you crazy even as a Palestinian you need to understand that Gaza rules now by a crazy shitty terrorist organization We don’t want them

Dude at 5:58 gets a lot face time in different videos.

Mordechai at 4:04 is mistaken...the borders of israel explicitly according to the 5 books of moses (Torah) in several places extend from the nile to the euphrates, from the red sea to the mediterrean sea and extending from the desert in the south (northwestern arabia) north to the Eyphrates.

@talmoskowitz5221

3 жыл бұрын

No. According to the Radbaz, an Egyptian Rabbi Nachal Mitrayim is Wadi El-Arish, about 30 km west of Gaza. The idea in the Tanach is to never return to Egypt. The only commentary mentioning the Nile were medieval European commentary from too far away to be familiar with the details.

@d86records9

3 жыл бұрын

It doesn't matter what any commentator says, according to the Torah, in the Genisis, Numbers & Deuteronomy there is a reference to the border to the south at a wadi or brook of Egypt. This is either the nile river or a tributary of the nile that empties in the Mediterranean. This is a border, it does not not in extend into Egypt.

@mortef

2 жыл бұрын

What matters is that Israel refuses to define its borders.

I thought they already owned it. they control it their army!

i am from brazil , and i support 2 countries one to the jews and another to palestinians , the only solution , i dont support '' annex'' or settlements

@ibelongtotheworld1578

5 жыл бұрын

eu como brasileiro-palestino, concordo totalmente com isso. Essa história de mocinho e bandido já deu no saco. Só espero paz porque ninguém vai sair de lá mesmo.. O foda é que nesse momento nem tão "anexando", mas sim criando mais e mais assentamentos ilegais.

@avigailbc1

5 жыл бұрын

Jeferson easier to say when you don’t live here

@ibelongtotheworld1578

5 жыл бұрын

@@avigailbc1 i Know lots of people that lives "there"(i'm in west bank on vacations) israelis, by the way, that thinks in the same way as Jeferson.

@jonathanallen9596

5 жыл бұрын

Until you learn about each time Palestinians could form a country they didn't. That Palestine isn't an Arabic word and they can't even pronounce it correctly as it's a Greek name for Philistine which is not what the area was called during Ottoman rule. Another thing nkat od the people who started to call themselves 'palestininas' are Arab and identify as such before being 'palestinian' ....before WW1 there was nothing between Cairo and Damascus except Jerusalem. About 3/4 of the Arabs are decendents from WW1 refugees They already have a country called Jordan and fought a short war or whatever you want to call it against the Jordanians as refugees from 67. The Jordanians killed of 20,000 of them which is more than Israel killed throughout it's entire existence. These people understand the language of violence better than any other people. They are violent people naturally, their environment has long been extremely demanding and dangerous. Until you actually live with Arabs in the middle East keep you mouth shut.

Eventually it shall become one state. Israel shall unite and every citizen of Israel shall have equal rights. Sooner both sides understand this is better. Tensions will be over, even despite foreign involvement stimulating extremism. United Israel is the best and most optimal solution for all including Arabs living in the West Bank.

Once the Nazis talked about the "Jewisch Solution" and not the Victims are talking about the "Palästinaian Solution". God are looking on you.

@georgeevangel4292

5 жыл бұрын

Are you kidding? Not a fair comparison

A strong Constitution and By-Laws to be followed by the Israelis and Palestinians in one-state solution is the answer. A State of Israel for Israelis and Palestinians. Let there be peace in Israel and the world.

@emilianosintarias7337

2 жыл бұрын

the problem with that idea is that Palestinians are majority Muslim. Religious supremacy, imperialism, and antisemitism is in their religion, and there will be 50 countries of anti-semites supporting them who Palestinians can invite in and set loose on the Jews. A bi-national federation is a better idea.

Israel won't "annex" the West Bank for the same reason Armenia never "recognized" Artsakh.

@alonelymockbird3899

2 жыл бұрын

Why didnt armenia recognise artsakh? I always wondered it,can u explain in very simple way?

@ProudRegressive

2 жыл бұрын

@@alonelymockbird3899 It bring unnecessary heat on Armenia's security situation and torpedoes negotiations and pretend negotiations while Armenia had all but guaranteed Artsakh's security and maintained troops there. It was the same reason Russia didn't recognize the separatist LPR and DPR until right before its invasion despite sending unlabelled troops to the Donbass and granting LPR/DPR residents Russian citizenship. Annexations and independence recognitions inflame tensions and nations that cause annexations and rebellions might not want the increased tension versus how much tension already exists despite being responsible or partly responsible for the situation.

@alonelymockbird3899

2 жыл бұрын

@@ProudRegressive then why did turkey recognise north cyprus?

@ProudRegressive

2 жыл бұрын

@@alonelymockbird3899 Every guarantor for a separatist entity will have its own opinion as to whether the increase in tension is worth it. Turkey felt no such issue and recognized Northern Cyprus immediately. India recognizing Bangladesh after its war of independence is another example, which involved India intervening to secure Bangladesh's independence. Russia chose to recognize South Ossetia and Abkhazia in 2008 after a war with Georgia, but like in Ukraine, that was despite a presence in the two regions, which in this case was since the 1990's. Kosovo declared independence, but only did so in 2008, despite being de facto independent since 2000 after which it was immediately recognized by its guarantors, the US and an array of European countries.

Jews and Arabs do live together in Israel. As for the West Bank, We shouldn't annex it. More Palestinian citizens, , more poverty, more violence, less democratic values and basically the end of the Jewish state. moreover, we have totally different cultures. Muslim culture being much less tolerant to other religions.

Annexing the WB doesn't leave much hope for the Palestinians in Gaza. They'll be left with nothing better to hope for than a city state like, say, Singapore.

@87HotNcold

7 жыл бұрын

Mark, that is already a hopeless case and its not Israel's fault. Its the independent country of Hamastan, elected by the people of Gaza. There are three regions in that area: Israel, Gaza, and the WB. Maybe WB will be Palestine someday, but Hamas will never give up power in Gaza. They only agree with accepting power in the WB too, ie expanding Hamastan.

When the huge cultural disparity will diminish.

7:21 “we Jews need to be there” what does she mean ? So she supports settlements but not one state solution ?

Israelis *asks question*, the proceeds to use an African as an Israeli representative to address a question concerning the ethnic natives of that land of which he doesn't historically belong to

@Lildizzle420

7 жыл бұрын

like many people in Israel who were not born on the land and having never been to the middle east.

@MrJovon321

7 жыл бұрын

The Jewish identity is not historically racial in the way people from the US would casually see it. It is more tribal/ethno-cultural/genealogical. Much more focus on descent and cultural cohesion versus racial crayola-war nonsense.

@Lildizzle420

7 жыл бұрын

MrJovon321 funny considering the extreme prejudice Jews face in israel, particular black jews

@magdalene3431

7 жыл бұрын

I could use that same logic towards european jews, who are also not historically natives of the land. Or jews from Suriname in S. America. This type of view almost justifies the discrimination black jews face. Be consistent.

@MrJovon321

7 жыл бұрын

You are probably talking about *Ethiopian Jews. Some people face prejudice, some people don't, some for different reasons that are not stuck on 'race'. I've haven't ever personally collected a rich consensus from Ethiopian Jews on their modern experiences in Israel, but I do always hear non-Israelis proclaiming how poorly the "blacks" are treated. I believe some of this could be hopeful projection. Of course there was/is a period of cultural adjustment when so many disparate groups of people are living next to each other for the first time in their lives. Seems natural, I'm sure general people are feeling more and more collectively "Israeli" every day. But I don't live there.

Maybe some day there will be a single state but for now they need distance and time.

Just a thought... Whay do all people assume theat Arabs in Israel should have equal rights? Do they have it automatically in any other Arab/Muslim country!?

@Lildizzle420

7 жыл бұрын

if you want israel to be compared to any other arab/muslim country, Im still amazed at peoples willingness to compare Israel to saudi arabia, russia, china, even north korea. I think thats telling in itself...

@amitaimedan

7 жыл бұрын

Lildizzle420 What about Japan?

@Lildizzle420

7 жыл бұрын

you have to be more specific? what about japan?

@docorwhatever2168

3 ай бұрын

Because they are human beings maybe?

@amitaimedan

3 ай бұрын

@docorwhatever2168 Do all human beings have equal rights in Arabic countries??? Are women's human beings?

No. There will always be extremists on both sides and these two won't co-exist. Unless Israelis can tolerate explosions every now and then.

HEY PEOPLE? SAYING WE WERE THE FIRST PEOPLE LIKE FOR EXAMPLE 2000 years ago but then we left and now we want back our land that's not possible if you're open minded and see the world as a temporary thing as we all will die one day and leave it all. i'am of albanian origin from serbia not far away where roman emperor constandine the great was born, we was of illyrian origin. now illyrians lived in all the western balkans and were one of the first people to migrate there from near east but then the slavs pushed them south forced to hide in the albanian mountains, of assimilated them. now do you think that after 1500 years the land of central serbia, of slovenia, croatia etc belongs to illyrian albanians , no because time changes and people move and even if they lived there at one point they have no right to claim something that belongs to other people since 1500 years. So isral must liberate judea i mean the real jewish people must liberate themselves from zionism and arabs must find a way to live together in a federation. independent countries fully aoutonomous from each other but part of a same federation like israel and palestine thi could bring peace to this crazy world

@lajibolalatonymontana2302

5 жыл бұрын

Luan - Lion of Europe PREACH

אני בעד סיפוח. זה הרעיון הכי טוב ותפסיקו להפחיד אותנו שאנחנו לא נהיה יותר מדינה יהודית אנחנו נהיה מדינה יהודית גם אם יהיה כאן רוב ערבי. וזה לא יקרה כי לעולם לא יהיה כאן רוב ערבי. אין להם ולא תהיה להם זכות שיבה ורק אחרי שהם יוכיחו נאמנות תהיה להם זכות בחירה בכנסת

8:25 - dude reminds me of a young Robert De Niro.

Regarding one state or any binational/(con)federal state 🇮🇱🇵🇸, if Palestinians could prove that civilian murder of Israelis from another potential civil war following unification would be drastically small compared to sum deaths of the entire conflict, there’d be a case for 1SS. They can’t unfortunately, until they root out anti-Jewish hatred, in culture and radical theology. Obviously, Israel should help build trust with meaningful and legitimate concessions, but the systemic antisemitism of the PA, Hamas, and their citizens is an issue bigger and much older than the conflict. That’s where the onus foremostly is.

@ef2718

2 жыл бұрын

A lot of it is due to transferring the education system to the hands of the PA.

It's supposed to be pronounced si-pu-ax, not si-fux

Basically the only justified solution. Create one nation and give everyone equal rights. All the counter arguments in this video are the same ones that were given at the end of Apartheid. Look how immoral those seem in hind-sight. Furthermore, the Jewish population in Israel is quite significant, so these fears of being overrun are unjustified. The Israeli's can also create a federation where each state has large autonomy. This way the majority Jewish regions can maintain there cultural and legal heritage.

7 january 2023. My second post is depicting a view of mine. Of late changed my stance to Israel evacuating all settlements and splitting in two states to the one state solution - because the hundreds of thousands of thieving settlers in the West Bank make removing them impossible or so I thought. Rewatching this, the fact Jews evidently refuse annexing in majority - then occupation cannot breathe a moment more.

If everyone was like the lady in 9:25 there would be peace.

@Tibbs142

5 жыл бұрын

that's true but a lot of people on both sides aren't which is why it isn't a logical answer. The palestinians want Israel gone and the Israelis believe it is their homeland so it will never work. The palestinians would never accept Israel as a state let alone become a part of it.

@tarekj5951

3 жыл бұрын

@@Tibbs142 I’m Palestinian and I don’t want Israel gone. I’d rather be a citizen in a one state solution with equal rights. It’s as simple as that.

@kobi2024

Жыл бұрын

@@tarekj5951 Unfortunately Palestinians who are of the same opinion as you are the minority

Israeli women are the sexiest on the planet, Romania is a close second... Oh my GOODNESS....

@ablond1701

5 жыл бұрын

When you go to the supermarket on an empty stomach, everything looks yummy. Ogling women on KZread ain't too classy.. Having said that, I agree that Israeli women are beautiful. :-)

SIPU ACH not SIPUCH

You shouldn't ask a soldier. He works for the Government and can't give a political view.

To those who do not understand the concept of Jihad : Israel is considered occupied Muslim land, and as such, should be under Muslim rule. Since Jews are considered as enemies of Islam and the worst infidels, they should either be executed, converted or pay Jisiya (tax) and live under humiliating laws. Those who are naïve enough to think they could live under Muslim law, or with Muslims as equals, should take a long hard look at history books and what's going on in Muslim countries ,especially to people of other faiths.

@TheLethalknife

10 ай бұрын

exactly!

@abdellahumer3965

6 ай бұрын

I THINK YOU ARE DESCRIBING THE JIHAD OF ISREAL

Hey Corey - I think this was a really interesting question....however, in my opinion the real ramifications of annexing the west bank weren't really discussed with the interviewees. i.e. - if we annex the west bank we'll basically be governing a sector of society that won't have real democratic rights, which in turn will result in an apartheid scenario.

@ravisingh7928

2 жыл бұрын

Better still .. Why not commit to givving the palestinians their land, ending settlement land grab, and learn to share ... No other solution

they already own it

They should just admit they believe the whole world belongs to them ffs

@Tibbs142

5 жыл бұрын

They never mentioned or even went in that direction. Jews don't believe the whole world belongs to them, they know they are a very small percentage of the human population, all they want is their tiny sliver of land where they can live in peace without worrying for their lives on a daily basis...that's it nothing more.

@eyeswideopen5582

5 жыл бұрын

Tibbs142 it’s not something they’ll all readily admit.. Why would they expose themselves to the world when what they seek is sympathy? Although there are a few who love to boast about it and this is just one video where they admit it kzread.info/dash/bejne/a2qrksqEaZy5cps.html

Yes, it should have happened in 1967. Judea and Shomron belong to Israel.

@JohnDoe-um2qk

6 жыл бұрын

There is no israel

@HITBnn

2 жыл бұрын

And what would happen to the Palestinians living there ?

@ForeverRepublic

2 жыл бұрын

@@HITBnn What do you mean? They'd be given citizenship like everyone else, voting rights, political representation, state funding for Arabic language schools, etc. Annexation by definition means full integration, and every single checkpoint and wall would come down. If I was prime minister I would also reserve 25 seats in the Knesset that must be held by non-Jews. When we took the Negev and the Galilee in the 1948 war we took in hundreds of thousands of Muslim, Christian and Druze citizens. The descendants of these people serve in our army, our government, public service, as ambassadors, they are our fellow Israelis. It would be no different for the Arabs in the West Bank. Sometimes I think this will never happen, so I'm not opposed to other ideas granted we all live in peace and Israel maintains its status as a Jewish state.

@HITBnn

2 жыл бұрын

@@ForeverRepublic and what makes you think they’d want to live under Zionist Jewish rule ? That’s the root of the entire conflict. Someone comes from halfway across the world to your home and tells you hey this place where you and ancestors have been living for generations is mine now so you either live by my rules or you leave

The guy at 5:00 is wrong. Akko is part of Israel. It is as holy as Jaffa, or any other place. Without getting into the details, Akko's past halakhic inferiority is trumped by its inclusion in the state of Israel.

''muslims did things to us?'' WTF DID WE DO TO YOU WTF WE'RE NOT THE NAZIS MORON YOU DID THINGS TO US side note: that lady in the market at the end is fucking awesome i love her

@kobi2024

Жыл бұрын

They meant stabbing and suicide bombing, mass shootings etc, things that most Palestinians will refer to as "Resistance".

what the heck Jews are experts in combining church & state,for every damn thing they start crying yehwa gave this to us messiah enters through this gate .....😑tell me something I could believe in

@mirabrown2271

3 жыл бұрын

Problem is you probably don't believe in anything but yourself and even that might be a problem.

they can't do it.

@gotarabmoney6665

7 жыл бұрын

They already are. Its called settlements and they continually grab more land using the wall. Their border is continually expanding.

@g.iskandar90

7 жыл бұрын

GotArAbMoNeY 666 So true!!!

NO NO NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

So u have avocado, try and make guacamole , seriusly, where is democracy , annexation without referundum is colonisation, stop messing over there try and ask ppl from both side what do they want

Jeremiah 14:2 [2]Judah mourneth, and the gates thereof languish; they are black unto the ground; and the cry of Jerusalem is gone up. TRUE ISRAEL WILL RISE

I mean if bad idea to give the Palestinians citizenship. As for slowing annex West Bank once the Jews birthrate highing Palestinian that might something look into when and if happens. Might good idea limit Muslin 10 seats ,Chirstain to 10 seats and none Jews 10 seats. Untrue orthodox to 20 seats and rest the Jews have can take no more then 70 seats. If Israel annex West Bank or not that should do make ISrael because religious thorcy or a none Jews state.

What about the Jews who live in Judea and Samaria? There are hundreds of thousands of them in those areas. Judea and Samaria are part of our ancestral homeland and we have a right to it. There is already a two-state solution: Israel and Jordan.

@HITBnn

2 жыл бұрын

No you don’t. All of the West Bank+Gaza+East Jerusalem for Palestinians and the rest for israel

@asr2009

2 ай бұрын

@@HITBnn correction: all of historic palestine is for palestinians, while the rootless colonizers called "israelis" get nothing.

2:43

ANNEX!!

From responsibilities you get rights. The arabs aren't given responsibilities, so the Israelis don't seem to feel they should have rights. this is the source of some of the friction. The arabs don't want to be responsible, but the want all the rights. I personally feel rights come from responsibilities and depending on the charity of the state means you give up rights.

@stroke_of_luck

7 жыл бұрын

How so? Handicapped folks can be responsible. Lots of them work 40 hours. Israel has lots of handicapped people in the military. They even have folks with down syndrome in their own special units. They have even found a job that technically crazy folks can do better than sane folks watching the Gaza border and integrated them in.

@captain2ahab

7 жыл бұрын

"From responsibilities you get rights. " Actually you get rights from being a human being. And it is not in the business of Israel giving or denying the arabs rights. " The arabs don't want to be responsible," Well, that is bullshit, and you know it

@doesntmatter4136

7 жыл бұрын

The Arabs are given rights, just not responsibilities. The whole 'apartheid' myth crumbles as soon as you go there.

@captain2ahab

7 жыл бұрын

Are you insane ? I was talking about pregant palestinian women, who cannot leave their villages because of curfews and who cannot reach PALESTINIANS hospitals

@thebig3864

7 жыл бұрын

Steven Demonnin it's their land the Arab land the zionists have any right in the land fuck responsibility

If Netanyahu know a little love he would redraw the borders to the 1967 lines

@mosheshadi6722

5 жыл бұрын

Netanyahu not redraw to the borders of 67 because he's smart. we gave them Gush katif and look what's happening their

@houssemeddinbettaibi4706

3 жыл бұрын

@@mosheshadi6722 what do you mean you gave them? Palestenians were living all over the area and you kicked them out in 47, 48 and haven't allowed them to return to their homes dedpite UN orders and right of return.

@mosheshadi6722

3 жыл бұрын

@@houssemeddinbettaibi4706 no they are not. there never was such thing as "Palestine", not a state or other entity. please don't speak about topic you have no clue about.

@houssemeddinbettaibi4706

3 жыл бұрын

@@mosheshadi6722 i'm actually well educated on the subject. Please read these two booksby jewish israeli Historians: The ethnic cleansing of palestine by Ilan Pappé and the birth of israel by by Simha Flapan. These two history books tell what happened in 1947 and 1948 and afterwards and facts based on classified materials of the period of Ben Guiron as prime minister that were declassified in late 80's

@mosheshadi6722

3 жыл бұрын

@@houssemeddinbettaibi4706 yea well living the reality is not the same as reading some books

It's not SIPUH. it's SIPUAAH

I dont think that most of the Palestinians would dare to say in front of a camera that they want to be annexed. So Corey, could you ask them without a camera?

Gasa to Egypt, West bank to Jordan. Full citizenship granted as a humanitarian aid (Hard to expect that from Muslims to Muslims, I know). End of story.

"Solution to the Palestinian question"

@ibrahimsued4906

5 жыл бұрын

"Palestinian state"

@jakedones2099

5 жыл бұрын

@@ibrahimsued4906 no the irony is that the nazis used similar wording with respect to the jews prior to their extermination campaign. "Final solution to the jewish question"

what should happen to atheists?

@twattythirky

7 жыл бұрын

We agree, I'd like to see the response from both israelis and palestinians however

@SpearofZion613

7 жыл бұрын

twattythirky same opinion as jace

@nurimahrasidz271

2 жыл бұрын

The paradox is. Ethnic athiest Jew do not believe in God of Abraham BUT believe the Land was given to them by GOD. Also the Israel will accept anyone who is a non believer ethnic Jew (even they have less than 1% Jew DNA). Also Abraham was from Ur, Part of Iraq and Iraq is in ME. And ppl of ME are called Arabs collectively by British which makes Jew a part of Arabs. But they so distinctively want to be on their own while in reality Arab is so much of a mixture.

When I listen to Hebrew I think of Arabic, Russian and French. Sounds like a mix of these three.

@Visualsgenevas

6 жыл бұрын

Jordan Left More of a mix of Amharic, and Arabic

@alexcarter8807

4 жыл бұрын

@ZadfrackGlutz Zesozose We've got a stabbed pig fucking expert here...

Go all over and ask 8:712 Israelis not only them and find out.

הבן אדם ב5.40 לא יודע הגמרא - רבי אבא הוי מנשק כיפי דעכו....

I would like to know if Arab Israelis love Israel.

@clbeob

7 жыл бұрын

they are.

@yko_7313

2 жыл бұрын

Some do some don't majority in the middle somewhere.

The premise of this question is wrong, because it takes for granted that with annexation, everyone who lives on this land is automatically entitled to citizenship.. Sure we should annex the land - all of it. But that doesn't mean the Arabs living on it must become citizens. We build a state on a small portion of our land, while an enemy nation sits on the remainder. This enemy nation attacks us several times, and in the process, we capture more of our land. So now that we successfully defended ourselves, we are obligated to give this enemy population the keys to our country? This would mean they can attack us, and conquer us by losing the war. This is lunacy.

@JavedIqbal-mw3sd

3 жыл бұрын

Even if you win the lands what would you do with the people? usually they are given citizenship but this is not possible according to you. Then it is apartheid were you dont give one group rights. Also lands through conquest is illegal.

@chayimjakob5499

3 жыл бұрын

​@@JavedIqbal-mw3sd Actually, the defeated population in generally not given citizenship. Historically, when a defending army wins a war, if the animosity between the two nations still exists, the population living in the conquered areas are expelled. But that's beside the point. Regardless of what other countries do, Israel is not required to endanger itself to accommodate a defeated enemy. So, yes, Israel made a colossal mistake not to expel the population that attacked it in 1967. Too late, what's done is done. But they certainly don't have to give citizenship to a hostile foreign population living on its land. As to your accusation of apartheid, that's simply not true. The Apartheid regime in South Africa deprived citizens of their rights base solely on their race. They were citizens. Full members of the Nation of South Africa. This is not the case in Israel, where the Arabs are an entirely different nation who happens to be living on our land. They are entitled to full human rights, but not national rights. It is not apartheid to deny citizenship to a foreign population living on your land. Is it apartheid for France to deny citizenship to non-French? Is it Apartheid for the US to withhold citizenship from non-Americans? About gaining land through conquest... How did the US acquire Puerto Rico and Guam? How did the Arabs acquire Syria and Egypt and Lebanon and Morocco? Unlike the Arab conquests, Israel took the Judea, Samaria, Binyamin and the eastern half of Jerusalem in a defensive war. If you start a war and you lose, you lose. You don't want to lose territory to a neighboring state? Don't attack them. More importantly, those lands were ours long before the first Arab ever set foot there. You don't find Arab artifacts in the archeological digs, you find Jewish artifacts. The Dead Sea Scrolls are in Hebrew, not Arabic. Jews, not Arabs, are buried in the ancient graves on Mount Olives. The ruins of Masada are Jewish, not Arab. The Arch of Titus depicts the Roman looting of Jewish treasures, not Arab. Yes, land through conquest for the sake of conquest is wrong. This is exactly why the "Palestinians" have no right to the land of Israel.

@JavedIqbal-mw3sd

3 жыл бұрын

@@chayimjakob5499 of you really are going to compare it to times if lawlessness, it all will make sense. You can even commit massacres after citing historical ones. No those nations don't have to give citizenship to foreign nationals. But accept the palestinians aren't foreign nationals. They are in their land. They don't have anywhere else to go. And using the straw man of 2 million Israeli Arabs don't really work because its all that is, a straw man to say that the oppression isn't apartheid. But this doesn't really stand as if Israel didn't mind having Arabs with them, they would give all of them citizenship. And yes expelling a population is ethnic cleansing even when the Arabs did it. 2 wrongs don't make a right.

@JavedIqbal-mw3sd

3 жыл бұрын

And calling Palestinians hostile as if Israel was just like Switzerland in middle east ain't really gonna cut it. The natives were hostile towards apartheid south Africa, American countries, Australia and such isn't a valid reason to oppress those people because they have legitimate reasons to be hostile. Without equality that won't change.

@chayimjakob5499

3 жыл бұрын

​@@JavedIqbal-mw3sd * You said "usually they are given citizenship." I simply pointed out that it's not true. I'm not using it to justify my position, as I clearly told you, it's beside the point. * You say they are in their land. And I disagree. So do the facts and historical evidence. * You say they have nowhere else to go. That's a humanitarian issue, not an argument for sovereignty. And it could have been addressed, had they not gone to war with us. * I have no idea what you're talking about with the 2 million Israeli Arabs being a straw man argument, and giving them citizenship, etc. * I did not mention the Arabs expelling anyone, and in any case, that was not my argument. But when you say ethnic cleansing, we need to add some context. The term became common during the Bosnian- Serbian war, and it referred to the purging of an ethnicity by killing them. No one is suggesting any such thing (from our side). Expelling an enemy population, though tragic, is often done, because there is no alternative. No country is required to commit suicide for the benefit of a population they are at war with. In any case I am not suggesting they be expelled or deprived of their human rights. I am simply suggesting they not be given citizenship. * Of course the "Palestinians" are a hostile population. It wasn't meant to be derogatory. The fact is our people are currently at war with each other. * I didn't say anything about oppressing them. * And just as side note, the hostilities didn't originate with the "occupation." Arabs mobs were foaming at the mouth in rallies leading up to the war, declaring, "we will push the Jews into the sea."

Typical wanting to have their cake and eat it to attitude

hello Israel =)♡ i want one day know you

You will never do that, lets be real 😂

I’m Palestinian and I believe if this happens we will have peace in Palestine and in Israel. We truly need peace we are hurting our futures with this horrible war. I support this message. 🇵🇸🇮🇱

@user-dy9bt7kj7r

5 жыл бұрын

We need two different states. We don't hate you, we just know we cannot live together.

@user-dy9bt7kj7r

5 жыл бұрын

@Ben Ostergaard Actually yes, because Arabs from the west bank are much more violent and anti-israeli than Arab Israelis. They won't accept Zionism and demand for self-governing. We don't want binational state, we want our Jewish state next to your national Palestinian state. Just stop being violent and aggressive and constantly attempt to destroy Israel.

Ishmaels trips will never accept ur side accept it we are cousins yes but we will never be together

annexing whole west bank would be bad idea ... but annex area c only could turn out to be good

@joybiswas3506

7 жыл бұрын

Alex M area a and b will be under control of PA like it's now ... So there is no question of election rights

@joybiswas3506

7 жыл бұрын

Aaron Sochaczewski Aaron Sochaczewski i am not for expelling them ..but annexing settlements like maale adumin etc.will be good .. let arabs live in area a and b as they want ..

@joybiswas3506

7 жыл бұрын

I am against expulsion ... Let so called Palestinian living in area a and b and annex all the settlements in West bank ... Lets Pa govern the Palestinians ... If any new settlements needed .. then make there are plenty of empty space in W.B

@joybiswas3506

7 жыл бұрын

Bethlehem is already under PA .... But east Jerusalem ... Forget about it ... 2000 years later jews are back in control of their holiest site .. where every Jew dreams to visit one day ... From 1949 to 67 when it was part of Jordan ...jews were expelled ... Jews weren't allowed to visit W.Wall ... Do u think israel will take that risk again ... And Palestinians with a good record .. is always allowed work inside israel ... Thousands of Palestinians cross check points every day to work in israel .. Pa get enough aid to build a good economy they invest it in terror .. that's their fault ...and nothing can be done .. about gaza unless hamas steps down

@microchip470

7 жыл бұрын

@Alex M Area A and B are plenty for a viable state. There are currently ~25 countries in the world that are smaller. Some of those include Monaco, Macau, Lichtenstein, Singapore, and Bahrain, all countries with a decent economy. If those countries can do it, then the Arabs in Areas A and B can find a way to do it too. There is no way Jerusalem will be separated. Arabs can’t be trusted to take care of non-Muslim holy sites. Historically, as Joy Roy mentions, they were unable to do it. A few years back, the Jordanian Waqf, which controls the Temple Mount, had Jewish artifacts removed and destroyed from under the Dome of the Rock in order to delete the Jewish connection to the site. Look now at other areas of the Middle East where Daesh has destroyed ancient historical sites and non-Muslim holy sites. The PA is already doing this to some extent in Bethlehem where the city is losing its Christian character and becoming Muslim. If the city is to be a boon for the economy, as you say, then it would be in their self-interest to preserve the Christian character of that town. The reality is the “Palestinians” and Arabs, in general, don’t really care about creating their own country, they care about eliminating one country, Israel. That’s what this conflict has always been about. If the Arabs were interested in creating a state, they would have done so when Jordan was in control of Judea and Samaria and when Egypt was in control of Gaza from 1949-1967.

The blonde was cute

@yohanespanama6091

7 жыл бұрын

Fawad Malik and you want to have her phone number ya?

@neutronstar5544

7 жыл бұрын

Jace_From_Spaaace ! Mia khalifa😍😍😍😍

Gog and Magog(Fake Jews) in the holy land. Ezekiel 38:19. Think Earthquake.

It really angers me how some answered that it was a “Jewish State” and they wanna keep it that way, Can you imagine if it was a Muslim country who said something like that?

@yko_7313

2 жыл бұрын

They literally say it all the time in Muslim countries.

רי

Yes. Judea and Samaria is Jewish land.

@derberliner8779

7 жыл бұрын

IamDeathwatch no they are not they are palestinian land . Illegal settlements are a Crime

@IamDeathwatch

7 жыл бұрын

Der Berliner There's noth8ng illegal about settling the land of the Judeans and the Samaritans, the indigenous people's of the land. It's been Jewish for over 3000 years. It's never been Palestinian.

@Adler2935

7 жыл бұрын

Most of Israels citizen are atheist. Should they leave too since its a jewish land?

@IamDeathwatch

7 жыл бұрын

Yun Chun That's an ignorant status. Most of Israel's Jews are not atheist. Those that are, are Atheist Jews. They're still Jews. It's still their land.

@IamDeathwatch

7 жыл бұрын

Adidas XL Nonetheless I am intrigued by your claim. Which groups are you thinking of?

Israel to israelis, egypt to egyptians (copts), syria to syriacs, north africa to berbers, arabs to (saudi) arabia

@jaredknows7090

7 жыл бұрын

Syriac Christians live in a historic range which transcends the borders of modern Syria.

@othmanbettach2665

7 жыл бұрын

well maybe i agree in some points i'm an andalucian berber from Morocco but the thing is most of palestinians r the native people of palestine they just converted with time and being arabized unlike most of israelis r from europe with not jewish blood in them

@Jordan-xg4pn

7 жыл бұрын

andalucian = spanish. So you're spanish moroccan? :/

@othmanbettach2665

7 жыл бұрын

Jordan Left my family from both sides have spanish origins Basicaly after christians took iberia they kick spanish muslims too And jews

@othmanbettach2665

7 жыл бұрын

Jordan Left my family from both sides have spanish origins Basicaly after christians took iberia they kick spanish muslims too And jews

A Home invaton from 2000years ago land Lords. So I can cliam land the belonged to great ancestors . Okay ,yeman here I come for you.

Dima is hot lol

Two-state solution or one national state for all, Israel will be overwhelmed either demographically or politically.

Yes they should annex, and also offer them free WIFI!!!

LMAO (and yes they are a couple)

fake news.

😂 If they belong a country first 😂 Free plestine 👦