What do you think about karma? Remember to learn more straight from Neale Donald Walsch in his FREE masterclass👉go.mindvalley.com/AwakenTheSpecies

@e-karttolle786

3 жыл бұрын

Tell that to a 3 year old who is going to be crushed under a truck for no fault of his, or the truck drivers... a soul takes a body depending on its karmic memory. Highly spiritual souls have a choice of which parents they can choose to express their life on this planet. They enter for a specific purpose, maybe to liberate another souls or to positively impact the society. Once a soul is selfrealised, it has a choice whether to form a separate stream of consciousness and enter on this planet or others or remain as one with the divine. But no soul is freed of its karmic memory until there exists an “I”. In other words if you have very bad karmic memory, say if you had killed a lot of people in previous lifetimes, you will have no option but to be born in a very bad family with bad parents where ultimately you are given a choice to grow and consider what you value the most. If again, pain is what you value and you cause others pain, that is what will come to you. These new age “Gurus” are very misleading. What choice can a child who is born in the worst condition possible, say in a country like Somalia or Liberia and exploited by drug lords have in expressing divinity? Cmon now don’t fool yourselves with this new age Law or Attraction BS. You will only be frustrated to the core. Instead accept that your Life is your karma and look at tools to work it out and ask for divine guidance and grace. Ask any enlightened master on karma and he will tell you everything. I’m glad now I know not to read “Conversations with god” because I’m sure Neal isn’t a realised person yet (not saying he is a bad person). Seriously you guys need to stop misleading people. You have not seen immense suffering some people go through and they are trying to make sense of it. That Why did it happen to them? there are things that aren’t in the egos control and the divine intelligence takes care of things as per its own laws.

@e-karttolle786

3 жыл бұрын

@@Lianzu So god gave you a body and mind and made sure you suffer because it was his “Will” ? Doesn’t make sense. If the I has so much divine intelligence to create the wonder around, and also create a natural response in many living creates to avoid pain, it also makes sure some creatures are subject to immense pain ? Seems like I you call god is a maniac

@e-karttolle786

3 жыл бұрын

@@Lianzu i know what meditation is and i know what being dumb is that you are referring to. It took me 8 years to understand meditation for what it is. But I’m not convinced with what he says about karma. In my experience it’s a divine law of cause and effect and it’s perfect. Spiritual practices accelerate karmic dissolution is what I’ve found in my experience. The intelligence that created this wonder around is also the source of the mind so the mind cannot understand it which is what you are trying to say and I know it. I have realised what you are trying to say. But I want answer about karma. If it’s gods play, then god himself does things (through us) and then subjects himself to pain and suffering so that he can wake up to himself ? It might be a play to him but it’s death and suffering to individuals. It’s really sad

@e-karttolle786

3 жыл бұрын

@@Lianzu how can I get in touch with you?

This is a matter of perspective, depending on how one defines the meaning of karma. It may not be that we actually "pay back" past transgressions in another life, but I think it's important to realize we at all times live in a Reflective Universe that reflects back to us all that we think, believe, express, and the frequency of our actions in life. So it doesn't punish you for anything, but it confronts you with where your own frequency is by reflecting back to you the kind of energy you project in life. In essence, it's telling you "this is where your frequency is" based upon how you project your consciousness. I believe the Tina Louise Spalding channelings and videos are right on track with this concept.

@Bajarangbal

3 жыл бұрын

Is past life there ?

Hello every body. I think there is a big misunderstanding on Karma. In fact Karma as your understanding is well explained by Neal. In many times he said in his conversation with God: what goes around comes around. If you want more love give love. You will experience that you bring someone else to experience. So this is Karma as your understanding. But I think Neale is explaining that we are not paying now for our mistakes in previous life !!! The purpose of our life Is not to pay or to be rewarded for our past life. Living in such belief may be dangerous because you will think that whatever you do, your destiny is already sealed in paying for your past life. Pay attention to the question of Simona and you will understand the difference between the 2 vision of Karma :) So in her meaning there is no Karma.

@macbeavers6938

6 жыл бұрын

Agreed Abdel. Over many lifetimes our souls will choose to look at different situations and emotions from different angles. Many confuse this with Karma, but as you said, Karma does not exist. There is no "Karmic Debt". Funny, but I never hear the term "Karmic Credit"??

@sophietherobot6343

5 жыл бұрын

And how would one retain life experiences or lessons anyway?

@macbeavers6938

5 жыл бұрын

One's soul through the super conscious retains all experiences of all of our incarnations. The "human" mind is deleted in the second stage of what we call death. My truth is that what many call Karma is merely the soul looking at a particular subject or occurrence through different perspectives. These can look like karmic events but they are not. As you know, there is no such thing as "karmic debt".

@starlightstarbrightlove1457

5 жыл бұрын

What about when someone cheats on you and treats you terribly?

@seqkatwinn2766

4 жыл бұрын

@@starlightstarbrightlove1457 I appreciate your question here, Lilya, as I'm trying to understand for myself if Karma is merely a taught belief. Your question makes me think of the question, "Which came first, the chicken or the egg?" With your question if someone cheated on you and treated you terribly - if it's Karma based then that would mean you have done the same thing. Some would argue, if you didn't do that in this life, you must have done it another. But why would you do that in another? Someone would have had to do it to you first again, but why would they do it? Because you had done it to them first? How can you both be first? Karma suggests there is no initial "creation" - but it had to start somewhere, if Karma was true. In this light the belief in Karma undoes itself. So, I land that Karma is not true. It proves itself to not be. But you have my compassion through the hardships you have undergone. Going back to CWG Book 1 - we choose on a soul level to have experiences for our experience and expression. You are strong to have chosen them. And I speak, coming from very brutal hardships throughout my life with much understanding and empathy for your pains. Give your ego the tender love it needs, seeing it as a child, and validating its pains, hugging it in your arms, assuring it you understand how it feels, and you always be there for it. Much Love and Light to you.

This mind-blowing alternate view of karma might actually make sense. It contradicts what we've been taught in Hinduism and many religions. The whole purpose of reincarnation is to learn and experience ourselves in this one lifetime...like how in childhood, our purpose was to be a child and not experience being an adult yet. Like our childhood memories, we may have memories of past life experiences and all the mistakes we made. But we move forward and learn from them. That is also why we all have Life Reviews after each lifetime, so we can learn from our lives and further move on. By being able to view all our lifetimes as souls, we can then decide what to do next. How could any soul try and break free from reincarnation if most of us cannot remember our past lives and how to fix them in the first place? I think it would be like saying, "I wish I could go back to grade school and not bully my classmate like I did. So I'll repay my debt and let myself be bullied." It doesn't work like that. I think karma is simply the results of cause and effect and the natural consequences we face while being alive, and viewing the results in our Life Review...not punishment, but a learning experience. Plus the common New Age theory of all of us having to evolve to different levels and eventually reach God/Source at the end never sat well with me. Since evolution is eternal and none of us are separate, and since according to Walsch, the ever-changing God/Source can't be surpassed, there is no real hierarchy...everything evolves together forever. God/Source never dies, our souls never die, and so why would our evolution have a beginning and an ending if all time exists at once on the other side? As long as God/Source expands, we expand.

I think alot of people misunderstood the question. The question asked is are we paying in this life time something bad we did in our past life? Which the answer is No! We are not paying for something we did in our past life. Because we don't bring the past life experience into this life time! So Neale is right! Listen to conversation with God and you will understand that everything we do and experience wether good or bad it all in this life time. Karma is the natural law of the universe course and effects!!! Do onto one as you wish it would be done onto you simple 🤔

Although there are people in life who appear to get away with doing wrong, there are a lot who face the results of their actions. The truth is that everything is the result of something, and it is good to speak to and treat people the way we want to be spoken and treated ourselves.

Teal Swan will back up what Neale is referring to. we operate in a law of attraction universe which can be misconstrued as karma. and this universe is non judgment universe. you are here to expand awareness through experience but there is no judgment. good bad indifferent - it is all equal. it only appears unequal through 3D perception which gives the illusion of duality.

@oceanbabbiie7791

5 жыл бұрын

Well said!

Karma is or usually is construed in a negative fashion. It’s our cosmic experience to be positive and to express our true identity to keep moving forward from day to day and from life to life. Not “Karma”. Love is the answer

@DougHanson2769

6 жыл бұрын

What?

@DougHanson2769

6 жыл бұрын

What?

@macbeavers6938

6 жыл бұрын

Right Doug! I "never" hear or the verbiage "Karmic Credit".

@raymartsantiago8078

5 жыл бұрын

EDGAR CAYCE VS CONVERSATION WITH GOD

That's exactly what I've always believed "karma" to be, what you put out comes back to you tenfold. If by chance you feel you are putting out love but receiving the opposite in return, then you need to check your true intentions behind why you're loving another. Is it that you're loving with the condition that they must love you back in the same way, that they have to show you love in the same exact way you show it to them? Remember, people show love differently, so check your own intentions behind how and why you are showing love to another. If you give love with no conditions, then you will attract more love like a magnet. The same goes for those who are of a lower vibrational energy, negative begets negative.💜💜💜

@kyanmuradali1415

5 жыл бұрын

Phoenix Rainwalker 👏 👏 👏 👏

IF "Karma" is so real, what of all the organizations that exploit labor? What will happen to the lead bosses? And what happens to the bosses of the bosses who never let anyone make decisions. Finally, if "Karma" is something to be judged. What body makes this judgement? What credentials does this body have to earn the position to judge merit and karma?

Karma is based on the universal law of action and reaction, every time the minds performs an action, it creates a psychic "deformity" that nature tends to balance,when the time and circumstances are congenial for that potential reaction to be expressed. Basically our minds are all the collection of all potential reactions.

@endlessjoychannel71

4 жыл бұрын

Best explaination

@24muneca3

3 жыл бұрын

How does that apply to the ones born blind death handicap or disable. What purpose does their mind serve this reality

Wow... Superb description.

I like NDW a lot. But, on this question..I'll have to disagree. How can you have one person, who in NDW terminology, "has forgotten who they truly are" so badly, that they give you a great chance to show your mastery...(again in his lingo). No one can put so much pain on another and not expect to have that negativity return against them. Perhaps I feel this way because I have not reached the level of master...but, sometimes the trainer goes overboard and kills the trainee.

Karma I feel has been created by those who feel wronged and need to seek revenge. Understanding is a key to enlightenment. I hear the word karma thrown around so loosley without any true understanding thus pouring more anger and hatred and negativity onto the world. This is not of God. Nor is it healthy to our souls.

Every thoughts,words and action has an equal and opposite reaction to be experienced by the actor,for me this is Karma.I don’t know whether the previous life karma exist or not because it is not not in my experience,but for sure this life your thoughts,words and actions create karma.Sooner you realize it good for you.

Tell that to a 3 year old who is going to be crushed under a truck for no fault of his, or the truck drivers... a soul takes a body depending on its karmic memory. Highly spiritual souls have a choice of which parents they can choose to express their life on this planet. They enter for a specific purpose, maybe to liberate another souls or to positively impact the society. Once a soul is selfrealised, it has a choice whether to form a separate stream of consciousness and enter on this planet or others or remain as one with the divine. But no soul is freed of its karmic memory until there exists an “I”. In other words if you have very bad karmic memory, say if you had killed a lot of people in previous lifetimes, you will have no option but to be born in a very bad family with bad parents where ultimately you are given a choice to grow and consider what you value the most. If again, pain is what you value and you cause others pain, that is what will come to you. These new age “Gurus” are very misleading. What choice can a child who is born in the worst condition possible, say in a country like Somalia or Liberia and exploited by drug lords have in expressing divinity? Cmon now don’t fool yourselves with this new age Law or Attraction BS. You will only be frustrated to the core. Instead accept that your Life is your karma and look at tools to work it out and ask for divine guidance and grace. Ask any enlightened master on karma and he will tell you everything. I’m glad now I know not to read “Conversations with god” because I’m sure Neal isn’t a realised person yet (not saying he is a bad person). Seriously you guys need to stop misleading people. You have not seen immense suffering some people go through and they are trying to make sense of it. That Why did it happen to them? there are things that aren’t in the egos control and the divine intelligence takes care of things as per its own laws.

I really really really really wish that my next door neighbour, an extremely dogged and spiritually unenlightened man, would just wake the fuck up and stop making so much god damn noise...8 years of noise, daughters parties, incessant dog barking, loud tv, coughing at night, slamming his doors constantly, ''oh but did you tell them?'', yes, many times. They have been our neighbours for 30 years, but for whatever reason, they just decided in 2013, lets not consider anyone, lets become even more self contained, they have more money than anyone else on the street, fancy cars, always getting work done on their house, massive holidays...when they go away, its like heaven on earth, the god damn leaves grow back on the trees, then they come home and its like going back to hell. I feel like a missionary trying to save them from damnation. When you tell someone you don't like when they do something, but they continue to do it, this just tells me that this guy is a total jerkoff, and that maybe he has such an ego that he doesn't want to seem defeated...and so the barking continues, the slamming, the snoring, the coughing, the tv. I don't want bad things to happen to them, but i would love to see them getting a good slap on the wrist for being so arrogant and inconsiderate. Nobody else on our street behaves so badly.

Why Karma is being confused with Reincarnation? I have experienced it myself what we do is going to come back to us may be in the same amount, lesser or greater! I have no memory of my previous birth, so until and unless I experience it I would not confirm it. But Karma is very real! Even law of physics proves it that every action has an equal and opposite reaction, not opposite in many instances. But we are nothing in this world but our actions/ Karma! People love us or despise us for our Karma and Karma definitely pays back. I would only advise please experience it yourself for proof and not on others who can charm you into their thinking process. Just because you have not experienced it does not mean it does not exist. Peace, love, happiness!

I see 'karma' as universal manifestation. In other words, if you are most of the time in a low frequency state like anger, hate, jealously, hurting people you name it, 'karma' (the universe) will present you the same. The same goes for high frequency behaviour. But I do agree, that it would be unlikely to assume that you get 'punished' for things you did wrong in a previous life.

Thanks for this ! beautiful

@Mindvalley

13 күн бұрын

Thank you! ❤️

Karma is something which keeps changing as you evolve into a better person...It is a journey of self realization...Ppl can name it differently...But actually what is happening is we try to grow and mature through learning...Anything done knowingly or unknowingly will change from Compulsiveness to consciousness 👍

I’ve just watched a video where he contradicts himself. He said put out what you want back. If you want love give love... If you want money, give money....Karma

@tanner3285

6 жыл бұрын

Author D. Landell I'm very interested in the vid you're talking about. What is the name of it? I would love to hear that info when he talks about how to make life work.

@true1evanique

5 жыл бұрын

Karma is action, and not a judgement tool of a third party. We are in control of the actions we send out through thoughts and intentions. We create our outcome in a world of duality which is really a dream reality.

@myriamdavid8755

5 жыл бұрын

Author D. Landell I give love and I get leaches back I give money I am still poor

I agree 100% Much Light, namaste ❤️💓💛💚💙💜❤️💓💛💚💙💜❤️💓💛💚💙💜❤️💓💛💚💙💜❤️💓💛💚💙💜👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

Karma is real i punch somebody in face and now i have a fight with one of the strongest in the town

Karma - Reward or Punishment ❌ Karma - Starting Point(Model of The World and Level of Consciousness)✔️

Thank you.

Karma has to do with forgiving ourselves for our wrongdoings and forgive the ones who hurt us. And yes it is possible that we eventually can carry karma that does not belong to us and from other life times. Listen to Dolores Canon. She explains it in a very simple understandable way! It definitely has to do with being forgiving and loving. UNCONDITIONELLY. We must forgive forgive forgive........... even the worst criminals. That does not mean that you have to agree with them. We often know so little about stories and the people concerned! We judge too easely and we should never judge. Don't we all live trying to do our best ? No, it is not always easy but I felt better after having cleaned up a couple of "unforgivable stories". I do know it is very important to get rid of our karma. As much as possible! Listen to Ashtar Sheran, the Archangels , the Ascended Masters . Look it up. The internet gives often the answers to your questions! We have the answers inside us and we always can ask for help. Good luck. We are all free to believe what we want. Be careful when you make choices. (Heard this many times) I am still learning too!

@johnnymcmanus2446

4 жыл бұрын

I agreed with Alisabeth Lissone. Doloras Cannon answered all the questions I wanted to know, and it worked for me, personally.

I agree with him...there is nothing like adward or punishment from previous life...how you want solve them when you dont remember them...you are part of God..you are not here for teaching but for recognize who you really are.so when when you are in bad circumstances it is because help you find way to recognizing..it is not punishment...

Conversation with god told me lol

Is it the Law of the Harvest, sometimes expressed as "we reap what we sow", different from Karma? Neal says we are not punished for mistkes in a past life. I think there is a distinction. Karma, as applied to this life, could be equivalent to the Law of the Harvest. In other words, the learning takes place here and now.

@jenniferwells9032

Жыл бұрын

I read that karma isn’t punishing, it’s cleansing and teaching. I don’t know?

It is very clear that what you call karma is just reaction to your actions, if you give love you will receive loved, if you hate don’t expect something different, that’s karma or what people call karma, but again is not, it is just a reaction to your actions, you don’t plant a orange tree and expect mangos. I know that maybe you think’ then why is so many people suffering? I will say that maybe suffer is the only way this people will grow, but is not a punishment, you don’t tell a teacher in school when he or she gives you a hard test the he or she is punishing you, in fact you decide to take that class, before you start a career in life you pick it, we are here to remember,

I agree ❤️

The eastern concept of karma is not about punishment - karma means action and consequences - we all create karma because we all create consequences and we can create our own suffering or joy. This isn't a moralistic interpretation of karma but simply acknowledging our choices can support us in experiencing joy or suffering

Very true.!

I have known other people in past lives. These people have shown up in this lifetime. Our relationships were different, however I knew them.What is that if it’s not Karma,is it completion of something?

Dam right it is

But how does he know for sure ?

I think people mix up Karma with reflection. The universe we live in is very reflective. That's why if you give love, you receive love. And I think some have come to call this Karma. But I also believe in the Oneness. We are all One. So what you do to another, you never do to another ... you do to yourself, and that's why you'll see the reflection come back to you. From a soul perspective as well, (not the egoic perspective), our souls very well may wish to expand and understand both sides of the coin. And it may sign up for a receiving of what it gave in another life time in this one to understand the other side of it. The soul is of God, Source ... and as so, being All That Is, it has really nothing to lose and everything to gain to experience both sides. We come here for experience and expression. The ego has fear of pain. The ego has desire of vengeance. Never the soul. So, it's not surprising to see humans come up with this definition for what they've witnessed as reflection. Such as, "Ha, he got what he had coming to him ..." type of thing.

karma is real. it's even stated in cwg book 1 chapter 14. but he's right. it isn't a dept that must be paid back. it's not about guilt and vengeance. it's about growth and making expierences with other souls. every soul has a free choice to solve their karma or not. old souls these days can even drop their karma entirely so that they don't have to make already made expierences again. (good book here is the human soul revealed by monika muranyi/lee carroll/ kryon.

What is LOVE ? It is this for you It is that for me Very hard to pinpoint

So what happens when someone murders someone out of anger. Nothing happens???

Sehr gutes Argument. Möchtest du jemals aufhören jemanden zu lieben, den du liebst? Dass Liebe und Gott Synonym sind, das ist auf einer sehr hohen Ebene und auch ganz profan - immer war.

I disagree as well, I've seen Karma in action with others and I have experienced it as well.. The universe whether we want to believe it or not holds us responsible for many things... Karma is happening every min of everyday... Cause and effect is a NATURAL law so how do you escape natural law... you can't

@ajdecristo

7 жыл бұрын

I believe in that we reap what we sow on a daily basis which could be called Karma (You get what you give) but I'm skeptical of paying debts from previous lifetimes, because I doubt God hates me that much to make me incarnate again to pay off a debt from another life.

@jills911

7 жыл бұрын

Dia Nunez The question was about karma being carried from one lifetime to another. We are not here to pay any debts from previous lives. I don't think that takes anything away from the law of sowing and reaping.

@303studio4

6 жыл бұрын

Dia Nunez i agreed.

@susanpeters3341

6 жыл бұрын

Dia Nunez You define it as Karma, but there is no such a thing.

@dorothyjohnson4755

6 жыл бұрын

What's your term or opinion of it then?

"We are not here to somehow pay back some mistakes, so therefore karma does not exist." This is a potientally diabolic half-truth. The first part of the sentences is right, but the second is obviously not. Because the law of karma has nothing to do with pay back mistakes. Either he does not know what karma exactly is or he spreads deliberately half-truths, which potentially are even more dangerous than lies.

I understand your not repaying a karmic dept,but continuing to grow and learn,evolution.

EDGAR CAYCE VS CONVERSATION WITH GOD

If karma, as most people understand it, is not a part of Life, having to move from one incarnation to the next to 'pay back' what we did in our previous life cycles, then tell us this. God says in CWG that there are consequences to our actions, how then would those consequences manifest itself, if not in a present incarnation?

Karma does exist...You reap what you sow!!!😲

Karma isn’t real. Bad things happen, good things happen. It’s a stupid Belief.

@jerryg7391

4 жыл бұрын

It's just a man made idea just like finding a penny on its head for good luck. Karma is not real, things are going to happen to you no matter if do good or bad stuff in your life.

I agree. Thank you. Man made up the word along with its definition. xo No Karma. End of conversation. Abraham Hicks also backs this up.

@raymartsantiago8078

5 жыл бұрын

BUT YOU ARE COLLIDING HEAVILY WITH EDGAR CAYCE

@raymartsantiago8078

5 жыл бұрын

EDGAR CAYCE TALKED A LOT ABOUT PAYING OF "DEBT" FROM THE PAST..

@chrissonofpear3657

5 жыл бұрын

Cayce was not necessarily perfect in his claims. Nor are many astral plane 'guides'.

@bethlovett7612

5 жыл бұрын

I agree too.buy I think it's a word that people Think keeps other people in check!

I am agree with you sir if anyone does not believe that karma is real I suggest him to learn the book Buddha and his dhamm by dr be Ambedkar that book tell you karma is not real it is real if you believe that it is real law of karma is a great misunderstanding

Dolores cannon in her tapes says there is karma and we have to pay it, so what are your views

Everything that happens to us we made the choice to bring it in our space. You do things with a particular energy that's at a certain frequency and it attracts things of the same energy and frequency. It's not Karma. You chose it by what you think say and do.

If karma is real justice will be served huh I saw bad things happen to good people and good luck happen to bad people!

I would love this to be true, but in my paradigm, I have to believe that there is some reason that pedophiles, rapists and murderers exist. The only way I can get my head around a 5 year old being abused, tortured and raped is because they had to play the part of a victim, because in a previous life, that child was a sexual predator. It is wonderful to believe all of these higher thoughts, but there has to be a reason for both this apparent innocent victim and this monstrous predator. With Love, Ann

@ant13d

6 жыл бұрын

Ann Nymous you cannot blame a 5 year old for being raped "because of his previous life".There are a lot of things we cannot understand.I can only hope that the victims will get some justice.

@adisyoye

4 жыл бұрын

So basically you are saying that every kid that got raped kinda deserved it? Kinda fucked up thinking.

We see karma in action daily..but maybe not paying for past life discrepancies..

It also has creation by consciousness

Karma is not a debt We aee joyously coming back to the realm of the relative

it seems to me that concept of Karma has different explanation and some of them are just mentalization, some are tendency to fit a certain definition widely used therm or principle to a certain philosophy, some just imaginations and some has profound understanding of universal principles. So it seems to me that karma as a predestined future is just a fiction as missinterpretation based on missunderstanding based on limited context. On the other hand what I understand as karma is simple principle - so there are certain programs that produce a exact reaction and consequences to a certain influence for example if somebody calls me a liar and my reaction is based on the program of hate the result will be insultation, agresion or just bad language, but if my reaction is based on program of compation than the result could be understanding the meaning and compation with that person and acceptance that everyone see everything subjectively and if the observing and analyze of the experience is precise and consistent we can see that the reaction is my own product based on my identification. So then we can define that Program is a certain pattern that prelimitates a certain reaction. Then Ego will be a identifying with the program as Me or mine. Than based on this Karma would be a complex context of interactions and status based on a certain identity that interacts with everything intrinsicly. So then Karma is living and interacting with world nonstop based on essential identity. If the identity changes qvalitatively and quantitatively the context and experience as whole changes so we can say Karma will change. To integrate past lives identifications in the formula will result in understanding that we ARE identified with certain programs and 1. we are aware of that and we live like that and experience that and simultaneously 2. we are not aware of that so that identity (esspecialy for past lives) is in the unconsciousness or subconsciousness and it influences the life we live without our awareness of that. So the identity is the key. There is identity we are aware of and also that we are not aware of but the major principle is that there is limited identity (linear, dual, within time-space, form as body-emotion-mind, content, specifics.....) that can be described directly and there is unlimited identity (non-linear, non-dual, outside of time-space, no-form that is difusive as field like character, context, universality....) that can not be described but can be experienced. The evolution then is disidentification with limited identity called as felse I or false identity or Ego and identifying with unlimited identity called as true identity or true Self or Consciousness.

He does not know what karma is. Most people do not. They craft idea only. Through karma , life and rebirth we are going to oneness. However it possible to move forward , backward, side direction.

Finally!!! Someone who Knows that there is No such thing as Karma! Glad I'm not alone in this knowledge :)

If there is no such thing as karma, then what is God talking about a 'life review' after our death where we will be subjected to every life interactions we have had with all others and being made aware of how we may have hurt them and what they felt and experienced at our hands? Furthermore, He says there are no punishments in His kingdom but there are consequences to our actions. Aren't we going through these 'consequences' in our reincarnated lifetimes? Why is God mincing Her words? Isn't He toying with words as a means to deceive us? How does anyone know with absolute certainty that we are hearing these words in your Conversations with God dialogues from the Infinite Source and not some demi God?

Even Jesus spoke in the bible about sowing and reaping. Isn't that KARMA? Either God is fooling us and toying with our minds, so we keep these conversations going without end, or, what we understand as karma is for real. One master puts it this way. Our bodies are loaded with memories from the past, a cocoon of the past holds us and when we incarnate into a lifetime, we bring forth the data (memory) of the past and it is through these data(past actions in the form of memory) that we have certain tendencies to be, do and have in the way Life unfolds.

i am hindu , i dont believe in karma. if something is wrong then just move out of it to happier pastures of life. life is too short to think of karma stuff

"Karma" is not a punishment , it is simply a balancing of energy . Every action had a RE - action this is universal law. Please be careful with some of these videos. We will inevitably reap what we sow but (like I stated)not because we are being punished, ALL ENERGY MUST BE BALANCED. I left the new age movement a few years ago and while I'm still not a very religious person I DO follow the teachings of Jesus Christ our Lord and savior. Blessings ♡

bullhockey! i totally disagree with this man! Karma is very much real and we dont have to die and be reborn to experience it. Its a part of our daily lives.

@guilhermemarques4963

6 жыл бұрын

Brianna V.B. Well, there are a few problems concerning the idea of Karma. For example, who is to say what is wrong and what is right? Would this differentiation be instantly accepted by everyone without arguments? How so? One would have to be pretty sure of his criteria and standards for such an affirmation. I don't believe in God to hold him responsible for this task, but even if I did, his logic should be simple enough for me to understand in order to accept it. Having said that, is it really possible for me to understand an idea, but somehow be unable to come up with the ideia myself? I don't think so, and that's precisely the reason why Karma doesn't really make sense if you think it through. Mankind surely have had its geniuses, we still do, but we can't actually tell good and evil apart.

@chrissonofpear3657

6 жыл бұрын

As long as it is not parasite food for orbiting spirits...

@DougHanson2769

6 жыл бұрын

Brianna V.B. Karma is or usually is construed in a negative fashion. It’s our cosmic experience to be positive and to express our true identity to keep moving forward from day to day and from life to life. Not “Karma”. Love is the answer

@meshakey6661

5 жыл бұрын

No its actions and reactions karma do not exist itsawordderivedfrom hinduism whi h has racist origins in it itself.untouchable

@MarilynRedmond

5 жыл бұрын

karma is about balancing all your past energy to move into loving resolutions from past fearful, negative actions. Always respond in a loving resolution to resolve and balance your energy.

i think karma is real and it's happening with me

I like it how he is proud of his hindu background. Did not Christ say you reap what you sow?

No no no you’re dead wrong Neale. Karma is real!!!! Do unto others as they would have unto you. I’ve seen karma happen with my very own eyes. I’m disappointed and disgusted.

BECAUSE YOU MAY NOT LIKE THE CONSEQUENCES OF CERTAIN ACTION YOU MIGHT WANNA DO....

EDGAR CAYCE TALKED MANY TIMES ABOUT KARMA AND PAYING OF DEBTS...

My question is in these sayings; "What goes around, comes around" and "Every dog will have their day". It's ' circular energy'. Where you perceive karma, others see it as goodwill or paying it forward. What's the difference? I've heard of karma detoxing and water grounding to realign your energy, but the way this guy is explaining that there's no karma, makes me suspect to his wisdom of total spiritual alignment on a physical and mental level. Question everything. Why miracles happen or why supernatural intervention occurs or why financial blessings happen when giving with good intentions. The truth is never absolute because it has more truth in it to be discovered. Discover your inner being to know who you are. I just weep for lost souls still looking for answers on why crazy things happen in ppls lives. It's puzzling that ppl is always looking for answers to something obvious. Jus sayin. Think deeper, understand with openness and live your truth. Be better humans and want positive things to happen for the good of humanity's sake. 💙

@raymartsantiago8078

5 жыл бұрын

IF YOU DONT BELIEVE CONVERSATION WITH GOD THEN...IT IS NOT YOUR CHANNEL,, REMEMBER NEALE ANSWERS QUESTION BASED ON CONVERSATION WITH GOD? CLEAR NOW?

yes, completely feel as Neale does about this so called "karma" which is only a title that many think is payback. Drop the labels and move through life with an authentic heart rather its a loving choice or not. All our choices are what predicts the outcome. Another words there are consequences both that feel good and those that dont. "karma" doesn't exist.

Yeah, i agree with him. I believe karma isn’t real.

This is different from what’s said in The Law of One and many other books - that we elect to join a cycle that lasts 25,920 years which is divided into 12 ages of 2,160 years each. There’s too much evidence of karma, which is simply described as "cause & effect." Karma is physics.

I mean, you can play word games all you want, but at the end of the day, there is 0 evidence for God/Karma, or any other supernatural bullshit. Like future lives or past lives.

While I do NOT subscribe to the doctrine of "karma" I can testify that in my own personal life the people who have been the most unreasonable mean hearted dickheads to ME personally? Are dead. At least the ones I know of...not to say there are not a few living high and happy ....just the ones I have gotten updates on. But was it karma? Or did God just act on my personal behalf? I am embarrassed to even suggest THAT because I certainly don't have a record of being particularly"good" myself ... But at least I CAN testify to being personally amazed at my own good fortune considering what I actually probably more deserve....MAYBE (and of course I can't know for sure)...but MAYBE what I have going for myself "karma" wise is that I CONFESS and REPENT.....Who knows? Maybe that is key?? The Bible says "Pride goes before the fall"....DAMN do I hope I confronted my damned pride honestly and REPENT of it!! ??

Not true

EDGAR CAYCE IS GENUINE TOO

YES Karma is real .

@romant142

4 жыл бұрын

robert forsythe no it’s not

if you think karma is a figment of the imagination, then how can you explain that there is a cosmic circle and that we go from lifetime to lifetime? They are both concepts. Even God itself is a concept so how can you say one is true and another isn't. Totally disagree. I feel like a lot of people in the new age of self growth makes everything seem like it's all rainbows and roses. It's not. We are very responsible for all our actions and we absolutely have to pay for them whether in this birth or another. People see proof of karma everyday. We can't see proof of your cosmic cycle however unless we die and come back and remember everything as it was. Sorry. Totally incorrect on your part.

@raymartsantiago8078

5 жыл бұрын

IF YOU DONT BELIEVE CONVERSATION WITH GOD THEN...IT IS NOT YOUR CHANNEL,, REMEMBER NEALE ANSWERS QUESTION BASED ON CONVERSATION WITH GOD? CLEAR NOW?

@raymartsantiago8078

5 жыл бұрын

YOU DONT UNDERSTAND HIM... HE SAID EVERYTHING ACCORDING TO CONVERSATION WITH GOD! , NOT ACCORDING TO HINDU SCRIPTURE OK? CLEAR?

@murphymad2130

5 жыл бұрын

@Raymart...she absolutely has a point...yu can't just say based on Conversation with God and Escape...! Unless you got a point to back ..Bhagwat Gita Has answer to all these questions

I BELIEVE YOU. KARMA IS BS, BUT HOW DO YOU EXPLAIN ABOUT THOSE BORN DISABLED? OR BLIND? ISNT IT ABSURD?

@pavlekovacevic1676

4 жыл бұрын

The less you have on Earth the more you have in heaven

Xfavor en español

Karma is real and it comes fast. But If you do the escape it, get away with stuff, watch out! because when it hits, it is gonna be BAD!!

@TikMaria

3 жыл бұрын

If you had a lot of karma it doesnt come fast,, if you dont have a lot of bad karma and if you did a bad thing once ,, it'll came back fast 😊

THEREFORE CONVERSATION WITH GOD TEACHES LIMITED FREE WILL,,SINCE THERE IS CONSEQUENCES FROM OUR ACTION...YOU ARE NOW LIMITED TO WHAT YOU WOULD LIKE TO DO?

thats me Leopoldas.. karma very stronger.. Karma blocking everything... you dont know whats can happen..

@kicinas

6 жыл бұрын

well thats why you are here

I disagree too. Jesus wont help you!!

@myriamdavid8755

5 жыл бұрын

Fred Marlin Why ? Did you have a conversation with Jesus ?

@flitzgerald7984

4 жыл бұрын

Grace, my friend.

He just has a mediocre understanding for life, he is not a master but hippocrate. Lets not distort karma in complicated sense. Karma simply means series of actions you performed. You have choice to perform karma but you don't have choice and control over your consequences. Its like newton's third law of action (motion).So be wisely with your action. By knowing your own being, you can become free from your karma. Free from cycle of life and death. Karma is not just physical action but it is a behavior attached with soul, life after life in sequence. "Enlightenment simply means soul getting deattached from your karma or freedom from your karma by know it, by experiencing it, not by avoiding or ignoring it" - upanishad scripture.

Look at the world and yourself.. The bad get richer and smile and the poor poorer how can this be karma? No way. I did nothg and life punshesme everyday... This can never be karma. Karma is the hope that somebody will fix it for us... And Look at yourself.. Did karma make you wealthy? Lol...

This is a misunderstanding of karma, which in the Eastern philosophy it comes from simply means actions. The idea of it meaning we reap what we sow is a Western religious overlay onto the original meaning. There is no notion of retribution. In the Buddha’s teaching, he says this arises, that becomes. Everything is entirely interdependent. The Western religious filter should be removed when looking at Eastern concepts.

Karma is very much misunderstood but very much real, karma is simply cause

This older gentleman still needs a lot to learn, Karma is as real as the sun giving light to the moon and Trump being president of the United States. Poor old man

@macbeavers6938

6 жыл бұрын

Yes, Neale has communicated with God and written 26 books and still has a lot to learn. Ha! Ha! Karma is FEAR based. God is LOVE.

@raymartsantiago8078

5 жыл бұрын

IF YOU DONT BELIEVE CONVERSATION WITH GOD THEN...IT IS NOT YOUR CHANNEL,, REMEMBER NEALE ANSWERS QUESTION BASED ON CONVERSATION WITH GOD? CLEAR NOW?

@macbeavers6938

5 жыл бұрын

Nicely put Raymond. As you know, we create our own reality. Mine does not include KARMA! Take care.

Karma Is bullshit

Karma is real .that's why when I see a child with leukemia I punch them in the face beacase they were obviously that dispicable that deserve a terminal desease the deserve even more suffering.If they acted like better human beings they would be as content as murderous drug lords on there yatchs surrounded by bikini models

hm... how can we find out who we are if our personality gets shaped by our surroundings and life experience finding your self is also a endless process... i dont know some of this makes no sense at all its more likely words and imaginations for this mans mind to calm his self down i thtink

His explanation is wrong....

karma is totally real he didn’t have conversations w god lmao

FYI,KARMA IS REAL!!!

No karma no god no devil no superstitions deal with it.......

Neal Donald Walsh is soft