Is Instagram revealing my stalkers?
Ғылым және технология
Instagram has us coming up with wild ideas on how the platform algorithm actually works. It’s mostly because we’re confused about why the app’s arranged in certain ways. Like, why do I see one person in my feed before someone else? Ashley Carman talks to Instagram Home product lead Julian Gutman to learn more about the Instagram algorithm.
Subscribe: goo.gl/G5RXGs
Like The Verge on Facebook: goo.gl/2P1aGc
Follow on Twitter: goo.gl/XTWX61
Follow on Instagram: goo.gl/7ZeLvX
Read More: www.theverge.com
Community guidelines: bit.ly/2D0hlAv
Subscribe to Verge Science on KZread, a new home base for our explorations into the future of science: bit.ly/2FqJZMl
Пікірлер: 329
What changes would you like to see on Instagram?
@tomxcr7820
6 жыл бұрын
Nothing
@toddlee-millstein9550
6 жыл бұрын
Stop people from screenshotting stories...
@david_r_morgan
6 жыл бұрын
The Verge For me a perfect instagram would be, strip out all the Facebook-based algorithms, make stories optional, and give us choice over what new features we want to use. Also chronological feed. Never going to happen though.
@patrickbugay6133
6 жыл бұрын
The Verge The ability to link URLs in Stories is a feature that's still missing to the android version of the app
@ThePhenomenalV
6 жыл бұрын
No Auto refresh. Twitter is good in this case.
His answer didn't make any sense without answering yes or no, sounds just like a politician's a answer.
@NovaZayn
5 жыл бұрын
Merrin it made 100% sense lol
This isn't true, some people keep coming up at the top of mine I've barely interacted with or even looked on their profile over people I've interacted with and looked on their profile regularly, so this isn't true.
He's lying. There are people I never look at that rank higher at my stories. And it turns out it is people that look at my stuff.
@rugvedpawar7114
4 жыл бұрын
I agree
@SonOfAPreacherMan
4 жыл бұрын
True
@TheNickz
4 жыл бұрын
Agree, I don’t really interact with ma friend but she always end up in top 3, and I don’t really visit her profile.
@staywoke9299
4 жыл бұрын
Cecily Jamelia TV Omfg Thankyou I relate to this so much haha
@park-bw9hn
4 жыл бұрын
There's literally no reason for him to lie about anything but whatever floats y'all's boats.
The people I interacted the most wasn’t on the top its in the middle.
@irenecatarina5613
5 жыл бұрын
ikrrr people on the top were the ones i barely ever interact with
@78mui
5 жыл бұрын
Kim Taehyungiee exactly
@ktyy777
3 жыл бұрын
i never view certain people’s posts and somehow they show up at the top lol
If your worried about stalkers then get off social media.
@Scratchci
6 жыл бұрын
So true. It is so strange that people share things and don't want other people to save it or see it multiple times.
@capturedbyken2936
6 жыл бұрын
True that! Once it's online for the public to see , it's a wrap
@dtvfan24
6 жыл бұрын
agree
@acido44
6 жыл бұрын
And if you don't wanna get killed don't leave your house 😞
@vz3_
6 жыл бұрын
Watch the video before leaving a comment like this. It’s not about avoiding stalkers but about whether or not Instagram reveals whose activity you look at most closely, or “stalk.”
Some people on the top of my views are ppl I never stalk or interact with though...
Tell him to bring back the chronological feed
@minus1456
4 жыл бұрын
Naaahh thats more interesting
"Instagram has over one billion Instagram users... including myself." What? What is this sentence?
@shashwatsingh1626
4 жыл бұрын
Wtf😂😂😂
@onikirissr5326
3 жыл бұрын
What's the prob🤡
@seilaclymer
3 жыл бұрын
I’m not seeing the issue with that sentence
I always thought the people who looked at my story more recently were at the top, and the first viewers were at the bottom. Simple & chronological order.
How does one stalk you by visiting your public profile? No one wants to be followed in the street, if someone just follows you around that's stalking. But a public profile is something you create with the purpose of showing selected pictures to other people. That's the whole purpose of a public profile. If that creeps you out, just make the profile private or shut the whole thing down. This whole idea of instagram stalking without any interaction at all is just so stupid and immature.
@wellesradio
5 жыл бұрын
Bruno Yeah, imagine that. Words taking on new, additional definitions. Spam is meat, not e-mail! Computer "viruses"?? Uh, sure thing, buddy! A computer can't catch my STD'S!
@jeffreeepstein1175
3 жыл бұрын
@@wellesradio wait electronics can get STDS oh geez
Is it stalking when you are posting your pics on your own will?
I stopped using Instagram when the feed stopped being chronological.
@readcastor2977
6 жыл бұрын
WisMicYal11 Facts. Worst mistake ever
@readcastor2977
6 жыл бұрын
WisMicYal11 They could have at least given us the option to choose like KZread did.
@XDario91
6 жыл бұрын
I agreed but if you start narrowing down the things you really want to see and the people you care about, let's say less than 500 following, it's actually great. Now I follow around 200 people and I always see the content that I want without spending hours on it.
@OclooBattles
6 жыл бұрын
but still means you're not gonna see everyone's content, they want you to see more, but if you only see what you want to see that gonna make sure you're not going to see everyone's content, you will always miss something
@puixel
6 жыл бұрын
We as users, should be able to setup our feed as we want.
It shows who watches your stories and from there you can see you who purposely isn’t liking your IG pics but watching your stories to be nosey
Why am i watching this video? I don’t even have Instagram account
@Plututo
3 жыл бұрын
lol same
@falaknazneen4593
3 жыл бұрын
🤣🤣
I want the chronological feed back, I miss most of the posts because of the algorithm and it usually shows content what I’m not interested.
I’m a little surprised you didn’t create a small number of IG accounts and test this. It seems like I’d be a relatively easy thing to do.
@madurai-kaaran
Жыл бұрын
IG is smarter than that
So...you're the actual stalker ? 😦
never clicked on a video so fast in my life
@guitarguy3378
6 жыл бұрын
Jared You ready for astroworld?
Conclusion is you have no control over the app and it's your fault?
What if you stalking your stalker
I swear the Instagram algorithm is too sensitive. I click on one random post about, say, boxing and suddenly my explore page is full of people punching things.
@tina-lw9rr
4 жыл бұрын
WickedRibbon LOL
They would never divulge their algorithms because it could lead to lawsuits from ppl crying foul over being stalked etc
@ashleysaprincessxo
Жыл бұрын
Exactly!
Woah, her glasses 👓 look futuristic, very cool! 😎
@3bZq0z
6 жыл бұрын
Blake Kuwahara - "Chambers"
@saimanideepb
5 жыл бұрын
@@3bZq0z couldn't thank you enough dude !
Cool video. I really liked the stabilized tracking in the beginning. For the wide interview shots that show the soft boxes, is that some overcaptured 360 footage or just an ultra wide?
I don’t really want many changes. Lately Instagram is walking on the same path as Facebook did few years ago. Adding way too many features that just populated everything and driving people crazy. I don’t want Instagram to do that. I love this app but lately it’s really adding features like a storm. What comes out of it time will only tell.
I was talking to my friend that I haven’t talked to in awhile and haven’t been on her profile too and after we were done talking I made a story and guess who was on the top of my viewer list :|
I think some people (not all) care a little too much about who sees what they post. Social media/networking is cool...just don't obsess over it (unless it's part of your job ...something like branding or advertisement)
@Dksksmsusbd
Жыл бұрын
It’s true, but it’s creepy. If those boys keep watching ur instagram. And made u hate it
I dont even interact that much with the people on the top of my story....
Could it be that they're so secretive about the algorithm because they use your personal data from sources other than Instagram and Facebook? :0
You guys are making some really freaking cool videos lately! Keep 'em coming!
*Auto refresh* on launch is my only problem
Idk what to feel whether happy or sad that my crush always on the top of my list
Instagram won't tell you their algorithm because they don't know their algorithm. It's constantly evolving by itself via machine learning. They set parameters to focus on to adjust it, but they don't know the actual algorithm and they can't directly influence it.
This might have changed as a lot of people i talk to on a daily basis on ig are scattered all over the list, not always at the top
I've been wondering this too cause I keep seeing my ex as a friend suggestion even though I click the tiny "x" to remove them but they show right back up again lol
have one specific Instagram user that shows up twice in the list of people who viewed my story, the same account info the same profile, just listed twice. What does this mean?
What about the screenshot myth??? A friend and myself tried the SCREENSHOT MYTH, but found nothing notifying me of anything
Please dig into this. My friend is going to Jamaica and we talked about it while my phone was on the table between us. I never travel outside of Europe and I never even googled Jamaica or anything that has to do with it. But only about 2 days later, I got an email from a travel agency I booked a holiday with only once before and it showed we hotels from Jamaica only. Please find out if our phones are listining to us, it would be a interesting video
Thanks for the "including myself" in 0:20, I would've been so confused
@21daystill
5 жыл бұрын
When you don't meet the word count and start adding words
Instagram, I don't care about my best friends appearing at the top. I want recency to be the deciding factor. As for the share menu, if the app is supposed to be so good at knowing who my best friends are, why does it not show my best friends at the top of that list?
Can some tell me if your list shows the same people on at the same time are they also interacting with one another
I know he's lying. For a FACT. I NEVER interact with my ex. In fact, I set my settings where I don't have to see his stories and posts. I never get on his profile. Don't even visit his Facebook, and I set my settings the same for FB as well. I don't DM him at all. Every single story I have posted for the last year, he's been number ONE.
So instagram when r u going to improve video quality on android?
I'm in hearts with those glasses! Any idea who designed them?
KZread is also stalking me... Tomorrow i downloaded insta and now this vdo is in my recommendation list
"We know your stalking habits" "You don't need to know, what we know about you"
hi friends, anyone here know what does it mean if there is a word 'following' in grey colour underneath the person name I follow..it does not mean they r following me...I found it when i check the list of people i am following ...anyone pls reply!
STALKER ALERT!!! 😂😂😂
Bruh nah he is lying. I follow 400+ people and the person on top is someone I never texted/interacted with.
that eye contact is SO intense
Finally... Finally i have an answer!!! Thank you so much Verge that rules out a lot of speculations here... 🤗
@MrAhuraMazda
5 жыл бұрын
I wrote this on my own comment but I highly doubt this man is telling the truth. The fact is Facebook/Instagram will collapse if it was confirmed that it publishes or even uses stalker info to other people. Privacy is the bedrock upon their whole business. They would never admit it if it was true. And the excuses this man gives are easily disprovable. First off, it's not about who you interact with cause the people I interact with most never show up in the top of my list, a lot of them appear towards the bottom. A few always appearing at the top of my list I never interact with. Also, the list isnt random or chronological. My list is fairly predictable, the same usual suspects keep floating around the top. It's not random and it's not who I interact with. And Instagram has every incentive to deny it, in fact the entire platform would tank if it came out that they, in some way, disclose private info to other users.
@LaurenceNaber
5 жыл бұрын
MrAhuraMazda187 NAILED IT 100% This Guy is def lying
@LaurenceNaber
5 жыл бұрын
Not random and not ppl i interact with. Even if it randomized ppl into the top it still doesn’t add up
@AnimationAndMusicTimeTunnel
5 жыл бұрын
@@MrAhuraMazda This is exactly the same for me, I just wrote the exact same thing before reading yours. There's some people I interact with a lot, view their profile regularly yet there's some people who I never do (or barely do) who always come up over the top of those I interact with. I know which profiles I visit, posts I like etc.. and some people are coming up at the top every time over all this.
great research beautiful! im sure you answered alot of peoples questions.
Yess ask Instagram to active everyone's , add post to my story , I'm unable to find that option and I'm frustrated abt that , I need that option badly
I'm combing through the shots of the phone for Arrested Development style jokes. Wish me luck.
This is confusing because im 28 and never had any type of social media at all. I just signed up up for instagram and i get a suggested friend list of people i know how is that possible if i never had any social media?
@mat7549
3 жыл бұрын
The people you know probably follow each other or interact with each other. I think it’s a smart way to get small accounts started up
tldr; no, the users YOU stalk are more likely to be at the top of the list
Luckily, I never use the Stories feature so I'm good
my story views were increase from 80 - 216 in just 1 minute i don't know why but it's 1 year ago but the viewers is not my followers even my audience is really poor and it seems the viewers don't stalk my IG it's very weird can anyone tell the truth why is this happening ?
Nice glasses! It seems like the lenses are floating. Can we get a review of them? They look very good.
@3bZq0z
6 жыл бұрын
Blake Kuwahara - "Chambers"
Why is a viewer's name greyed out in my Instagram story viewers list?
I miss more posts this way because if I just open Instagram to send a message without looking at my feed and then close the app and go back in later it thinks I’ve seen all the previous stuff from when I last opened the app, so now I have to find were i last left off on the feed, very annoying, why not just keep it simple? Just show posts as they come out!
I hate the algorithm because they don't show me the best content just the content of whoever has the most friends that clicked like solely because they are their friend NOT because it was a creative, cool, beautiful or useful post.
can instagram please make feed recent updated again..
Her look is so cool - she looks so futuristic
Pls can someone tell me do my friends see what i search
You could do a video on a myth which says that charging your devices after they are fully charged reduces the integrity of a battery.
@ChristianVezina
5 жыл бұрын
theyve actually done this video a year or two ago
dont know is it just me or this feels like instagram just shifted the attention to what users are doing rather than actually telling the algorithm. it's like asking ur friend about the wifi password at his place and he just dodged the qn and turn the table asking why are u even online and ure making up a narrative that u need to be online
Your glasses are old-timey-futuristic. I like em
can u ask them how to know who viewing our videos on iG ????
I don’t think this is true because there are people by the top of my list that I’ve never interacted with. 🤷🏻♀️
I blinded a lot of people from my ugliness on Instagram. So, my stalker chance is -951.1% compared to others.
Is it bad that if I were her and used Instagram (and Tinder), I would look up my date with a second account?
I knew this already. I'm an instagram stalker.
Current verge line up really killing it these days.
This video is a long time coming
The problem with this for me is that my top followers are people that I don not follow or interact with, so...
In late 2019/early 2020, I've got the idea that the viewer on the bottom is the first to have seen your story. So isn't it just based on the time people watch it instead of interests in your or their page?
@mikejazz9400
4 жыл бұрын
Bingo! usually the ones on the bottom are the ones who first saw your story or they visit your page the most last few days. Below them are new visitors that you dont interact with that are randomly clicking on your story
so she just said that she doesnt want to get exposed that shes stalking her ex's profile, while she was saying that on youtube.. interesting
but if someone sees your story fast it means that you show up first for them so THEY ARE STALKING YOU
where are her glasses from?!!
My favourite person on The Verge.
But there’s a bunch of random people who I don’t stalk at the top of my list tho? I’m so confused 🤣🤣✌🏻
@valrenvie
5 жыл бұрын
Becca :-] exactly
Wait what, I thought the story viewers where in order from the time they saw it . . . What is this
The back focus!
I lost my video views in Instagram how can I get back???
What if you don’t visit there page or like there stuff or even see there stuff but they are always at the top of my feed I like making videos for ig but I’m not ever propelled to ever look at anyone’s storytelling pages so thSts always made me wonder y they there I still don’t look in there pages even then 😂
2:30 what kind of person describes who looked at your story video as "relative interesting content" lol
LOL. I already know how the algo works when all the page i like or see a lot always shows. It's never about who stalked you the most ever.
No, I have to use the app the way I want to. They are not the ones to decide what I get to see first because I know what I want to see.
Never been so disappointed this much
Better ask Instagram why not all of the functions (gif, vote etc) are available. I have two accounts and new one with 0 subs has everything and the main has nothing. And this is on the same phone!
two words, split ends.
What's an instagram?
0:37 I see Ashley doing that catwalk strut in her stylish outfit. 5 minutes later I'm at the top of her Instagram watched-story feed.
Really cool eyeglasses, where can i buy them?
@3bZq0z
6 жыл бұрын
Blake Kuwahara - "Chambers"
Instagram algorithm sucks. Instagram turned 100% for brands, 0% for people. Don't try to clean that mess. Looks like paid content from afar
I love Ashley’s glasses!
omg i work right there on water st in the beginning of the video
He had a nice voice and so relaxing