The panel didn't strike the right tone for such a topic. The chuckles and smiles and off-hand remarks somehow managed to inject an air of frivolity into the proceedings. There are many security related forums and discussions that effectively handle similar topics in a more appropriate manner, so this panelists and producers of this segment might want to recalibrate.

It’s astonishing to see how india has managed to be the only major power in the region which enjoys full strategic autonomy. -Not joined any military alliance but managed to get critical military technologies from US, france, germany, europe to upgrade defence capabilities. - INDIA-ASEAN collaboration on security without any involvement of the west. - have an independent policy with all its neighbors. - exports ‘made in india’ supersonic missiles and military hardware to neighbouring countries (like Philippines) as part of ‘strengthen east’ policy. - managed to get critical military hardware and energy supplies from Russia, but US couldnt sanction india thru CATSA. -Countering china on its own with its own strategies. -Doing massive anti piracy, anti extremist and rescue operations in indian ocean, red sea and gulf region to protect human lives and global trade of Asia and emerging as the sole ‘net security provider’ of the Indian Ocean. India is crazy smart!

@AmitSunar3092

Ай бұрын

But Western Media will only show Poverty of India . 😂😂😂😂

@mengelmoesNL

Ай бұрын

Not really astonishing when you have nukes and 1,3 billion people. Indonesia comes closest population wise and is also mostly going at it alone.

@robertlouisebaker-hyde1267

Ай бұрын

@@AmitSunar3092admit it, 90% of your population is living under poverty line. 1% of the richest owns more than 40% of wealth and getting worse. Burying your head in the sand doesn’t change anything.

@janmil5630

Ай бұрын

@@AmitSunar3092 Ive recently been watching a Filipina girl married to an Indian guy and she's been showing so much of the rich and beautiful parts of India. it's very refreshing cause I'm so used to seeing only the poverty. It's the same with western Media only showing the poverty and sex industry of the Philippines

@Truthalonewins7

Ай бұрын

India wants to emerge as a global power in a multipolar world. The military is capable to defending itself against China or even a China+ coalition. This is partly due to geography. India does not need to sacrifice autonomy and enter into a military alliance with anyone

From India’s point, Europeans being compromised by China is the weakest link in the alliance against China

@LouiseChong-xk5xp

Ай бұрын

Is that the reason india stay in bricks with china?

@sambassil7825

Ай бұрын

Europe is not required to be at the core of this alliance, regional pacific countries are.

@SwCC2749

Ай бұрын

@@sambassil7825 They are ought to be but they can't. Most of them are economically reliant on China, it seems impossible for them to stand up against China at the cost of their survival. Europe is capable enough economically, though.

@anon.6678

Ай бұрын

"Alliance against China" - some light shed regarding the titular question.

@cowubl

Ай бұрын

Germany sold their Hamburg Port to China 😂. Chinese Cars are better than any cars

just remember these are all the countries in which China claims territory with ongoing territorial disputes Japan, India, Vietnam, Philippines, Indonesia, Nepal, Bhutan, Tibet and a few more. Imagine living in a suburbs and all your neighbors has disputes against you then it's safe to assume you the one creating the problem.

@dxelson

Ай бұрын

yeah, look at Israel, lmao

@tekinfomedi

Ай бұрын

Since 1945, Japan continues to have maritime disputes with Russia, China and Korea. Your point is noted. 😊😊

@pikachus5m166

Ай бұрын

No, just Japan, Philippines and India, and all their claims are false, most notably India.

@user-lb2wi2bj9r

Ай бұрын

Asia will have the same fate as Taiwan this evil is getting to reckless

@patrick_lee

Ай бұрын

Tibet is part of China. where do you learn Tibet has territorial issues with China? ...LoL

So Taiwan is allied with China against the other nations according to DW thumbnail

@therminust4

Ай бұрын

Funfact: ROC (Taiwan) claim 11-dash line 1947 before PRC rules Mainland China still today

@AC-he8ln

Ай бұрын

@@therminust4 Not Taiwan. You mean the KMT, which was based in Nanjing in 1947. Later took their Constitution with them to Taiwan in 1949 (and had to add Taiwan to it).

@AC-he8ln

Ай бұрын

@@therminust4 Also, the lines that include Taiwan were added by the CCP much later. The Qing Dynasty didn’t consider the eastern half of Taiwan a part of China. It’s Japan that unified the island, committing a huge genocide of aborigines.

@mackbedunduk1305

Ай бұрын

😆

@Ah-Yuan

Ай бұрын

Hahahaha 🤣

12 minutes. That is how much time you wasted at the beginning of this video 👍

@NorthernReaper

Ай бұрын

Not just 12. Till 25 mins they just rumble about BS.

@anypercentdeathless

Ай бұрын

A huge disservice to the public, making them think that geopolitics is simple enough for everyone's opinion to be valued.

@nosyneighbor4408

Ай бұрын

I too was getting annoyed with the 20 min introduction. Go straight to the topic!

@jakebarnes28

Ай бұрын

Chinese trolling is vastly more sophisticated than Russian.

As a man from Europe , I think small European countries are satellite state of USA.

@erlinghaaland5050

Ай бұрын

That is something a Chinese bot would say 😂

@luislourenco6720

Ай бұрын

But, the bot has got 6 likes and you have only one

@gror7849

Ай бұрын

@@luislourenco6720 Likes from other bots...

@lianghao7128

Ай бұрын

@@erlinghaaland5050 That is something a Isr-el bot would say😂. I can't even spell it correctly, otherwise my comments would disappear, thanks to the freed speech of the Western regimes🤣

@Jay-pt9yg

Ай бұрын

As an American, I agree but I'm for isolation and leaving sovereign nations alone, I'm sick of this country being the world police/ Emperor.

4th world countries such as Germany can't afford proper map of india .

@ssdhusg6042

Ай бұрын

Because India is still using the British colonial map and using it to claim territory. It seems that India is keen on being colonized.

@vikaskasaudhan900

Ай бұрын

​@@ssdhusg6042 katue Laura ho akbar

@bigboss.800

Ай бұрын

​@@ssdhusg6042illiter@te colonial map includes Pakistan and Bangladesh and some parts of Afghanistan

@bigboss.800

Ай бұрын

​@@ssdhusg6042you should be thank full to Japanese they have civilized Chinese citizens

@ssdhusg6042

Ай бұрын

@@bigboss.800 You have to keep your voice down. You introduced India's abacus. Don't forget that there is also an Indian Ocean plan.

Hey @DW News, the thumbnail map mistakenly includes Taiwan as part of China. Please correct this.

@raymondcyq

Ай бұрын

Could you tell me what the name of “taiwan”? Republic of China?😂

@electron6825

Ай бұрын

The map mistakenly references West Taiwan as "China"

@aslampervez2294

Ай бұрын

UN US UK EU and 180 countries recognise Taiwan as part of China

@felizzie251

Ай бұрын

@@aslampervez2294 And the earth was believed to be flat for centuries once. Read up on history will you?

@micsp1

Ай бұрын

where are you from, if you come from a UN member country, then you as well as DW's country all recognize Taiwan as part of China. go check China's civil war, Taiwan has not won the civil war yet, therefore it's just a regional regime, not a country

its not against china, its a reaction of chinas agresive behavior towards other asian country like the philippines

@halbschattenmorker9487

Ай бұрын

We need deterrence, CCP doesn't hear any words, only actions

@yunfenglu6619

Ай бұрын

Looks like only Philippine are in the frontline and get beaten hard, no other southeastern countries are aligning with Philippine. I wonder why.

@zw1697

Ай бұрын

@@yunfenglu6619 Good question.

@KuahChoonHian

Ай бұрын

@@yunfenglu6619cause everyone is scared of China’s economic coercion like what it did to Vietnam, Japan and Korea barely 5 yrs ago?

@cha8791

Ай бұрын

​@@yunfenglu6619economic coercion. The difference is, Philippines doesn't have that much economic investment from China, aside from trading. Japan is our top investor. Unlike the rest of ASEAN many are part of the Belt and Road Initiative of China. China could easily control them economically and it would be devastating to the economy of these countries.

I really like this show format. Having a designated chat monitor to put the public’s questions to your guests really helps broaden the conversation.

Germany should worry about itself being liberated by Russia for the second time , rather than worry about China!

@justinwolf7490

Ай бұрын

How about worry about both at the same time.

@RSProduxx

Ай бұрын

News break: There are more than one or two things to worry about/ take care of globally...

@khel9505

Ай бұрын

I think germany should worry about china's secret agendas all over the worlds lol😂

@LaVictoireEstLaVie

Ай бұрын

Germany is a US vassal state.

@vlhc4642

Ай бұрын

Germany really have a knack for picking the wrong side in every world war

Home come DW put Taiwan into part of China in the thumbnail map?! Could you stop making such a ridicous mistake?! So terrible and horrifying! As a Taiwanese, this is quite humiliating to see this.

@ideastshoa6383

Ай бұрын

Taiwan is not part of China. For a program discussing how China is having tensions with its neighbors, it's unacceptable mistake to put Taiwan into Chinese side. Anyone with a little bit geological knowledge knows the tension between China and Taiwan is the highest in East Asia. I start to doubt a channel with such a poor knowledge level is a good source for news.

@SwCC2749

Ай бұрын

@@ideastshoa6383 Well I doubt the tension between North and East Korea is as serious. Afterall China didn't threaten to deploy their Nuclear weapons but Kim did.

@anon.6678

Ай бұрын

That's because Germany has an official One China policy, as does 99.9% of the world.

@clairehanna9662

Ай бұрын

🐸🐸

@IdeoControl

Ай бұрын

Hi Taiwanese, Would you please tell us what's the name of your country ?🐸🐸🐸

Good

Your DW commentators are really confused. AUKUS is not a military or an intelligence alliance. It is an agreement to share technologies for development of military capabilities.

@rezafahimreza

Ай бұрын

No sir. AUKUS really is a military and strategic alliance, and they are signed to share intelligence.

@jdotsalter910

Ай бұрын

I mean, we're just splitting hairs at this point.

@chillxxx241

Ай бұрын

@@rezafahimreza No they are not. These countries already have military alliances. The intelligence sharing is done via “5 eyes”. Please stop talking about things you don’t understand.

@tekinfomedi

Ай бұрын

@@rezafahimreza AUKUS doesn't look too good if the purpose is to win over SEA nations. These nations aren't going to be too excited about an alliance of white Anglo-Saxon descendants of former colonial overlords. 🙄🙄

@levitabacug3377

Ай бұрын

AUKUS is a war submarines. Japan 🇯🇵 joining soon to revise the name to JAUKUS.

America has only ever had one reliable ally in the Indo-Pacific and that’s Australia, it’s also the only country to front both oceans.

@dhruvlalwani7007

Ай бұрын

Well if Australia was so reliable then why did go and mend their relationship with china after all these years

@Nikkska

Ай бұрын

G’day mate 🇦🇺

@defintity_9951

Ай бұрын

Japan, South Korea?

@seanlander9321

Ай бұрын

@@defintity_9951 Japan has been an enemy and South Korea has been a liability, Australia is the only American ally that has always paid its way in war.

@joeleonard9965

Ай бұрын

​@@seanlander9321Look up who produces the most NATO equipment. Guess who is the second biggest producer? South Korea.

Never trust XI

@zw1697

Ай бұрын

Whether you trust or not, you have nothing can do about it. All Chinese like our leader that should be enough.

@Elliott_Wave

Ай бұрын

​@@zw1697 Not all Chinese like Xi, now that's a fact. And look what Xi is doing the Philippines fishermen, Shame of Xi. But I suppose Xi bans any news like that. Right?

@KuahChoonHian

Ай бұрын

@@zw1697Chinese can and should like your leader. Just don’t use your power to suppress the smaller countries

@executor2056

Ай бұрын

@@zw1697 June 4th 1989 Tiananmen Square massacre 1989年6月4日天安门广场大屠杀

@patrick_lee

Ай бұрын

@@executor2056 2021国会山骚乱？

as a Vietnamese , the French were here fighting brutal wars , we dont have any grudges against the French , they are great people , the Japanese were here too , it were bad, but Japanese in quite a few Vietnamese opinions are the best asian , the Americans were here too , and now Vietnam have the highest positive view towards Americans than anybody else in the world. The Chinese however for 2000 years have never stop trying to pick a fight with Vietnam, their aggression have never stopped , so we have to always sleep with one eye opened to look at them.

@iScoopyPal

Ай бұрын

China may be a lousy neighbor, but it never wants to impose its will on Vietnam. The ones you mentioned pretended to be nice because they wanted to own Vietnam's soul. Don't make another mistake.

@daphuc502

Ай бұрын

@@iScoopyPal they are not pretending , they are nice because they know they were wrong and are forgiven for their mistakes . China however never learn from their mistakes or wrong doing , but always want to try harder at it.

@migspeculates

Ай бұрын

China wants to restore their Qing Dynasty status quo well into the 21st century

@jojokong3128

24 күн бұрын

努力占领越南?

1. Taiwan is not only separate from China, but on the same side as China neighbours. 2. DW makes it sound like everyone's ganging up on China just for the sake of it, when in fact they're reacting to China's aggressive behaviour against its neighbours. No one made China attack fishing boats or other coast guards in foreign waters.

@kirkhoo7456

Ай бұрын

Philippines provocation is the only reason.

@ColoniaMurder20

Ай бұрын

@@kirkhoo7456 you mean China provocation? by chinese build their artificial islands and militarize within Philippines waters?

@kirkhoo7456

Ай бұрын

@@ColoniaMurder20 Of coz Philippines provocation! Because conflicts with China means free money from the United States! But, you will see that US is not investing much. The Philippines are very clever - they keep the conflict at a level where US will give them money, and China will not expell them from the occupied Chinese islands in the South China sea!

@user-vy4cu8ui2x

Ай бұрын

3. They started claiming India territory, renaming an entire state in India.

@German_Patriot1

Ай бұрын

They make Marine patrols surrounding Indonesian gas field.

These alliances is a result of China's imperialistic actions. The order of events is important here. China's outrageous and unfounded claims in the South China Sea as well as the recent aggressive actions has placed the Philippines in a corner and the only way out would be some help with alliances.

@patrickstar686

Ай бұрын

How many countries has China invaded so far and how many has the US?

@1410superboy

Ай бұрын

@@patrickstar686 China invaded others and deny it so...

@Editsdevil

Ай бұрын

​@@patrickstar686 china invaded Tibet ( today country has no existence because of one china policy) Taiwan is also not recognised by the world

@kzm-cb5mr

Ай бұрын

@@patrickstar686 It's not about how many countries were invaded. But Chinese vessels are intruding to Japanese and Philippine waters and Indian territory. Then China acts like a victim once these countries veer closer to the US. Common sense.

@washuneluvhada7616

Ай бұрын

​@@EditsdevilTaiwanese are actually Chinese who immigrated to the Chinese island when they lost the civil war so why would a province b recognized 🤡

China's "Wolf Warrior Diplomacy" certainly didnt help their image.

Stop showing incorrect map of India. DISLIKED 😡

INDO-PACIFIC TREATY ORGANIZATION (IPTO) should be created to deter and stop Chinese Aggressions and illegal claims in all its neighbors.

@user-ho7me9dd5y

Ай бұрын

Louder NATO bot😂

@johannagarda

Ай бұрын

It's only the question of time Jeremie! (from my asian friends' and relatives' point of view, it is very likely to happen)

@hazlinabdulhamid7461

Ай бұрын

FPDA alert...✌️😊✌️🇬🇧🇲🇾🇸🇬🇳🇿🇭🇲

@ligerdave

Ай бұрын

For real, you don’t understand much about the history. Unfortunately, the claims, very much, are lawful. Check on the historical events, you would find how much cia has fabricated the facts and encouraged other Asians countries to make opposing claims. Some, are debatable however. It really depends on if you wanna be a state of the us or an independent country with independent foreign affairs

@tekinfomedi

Ай бұрын

@@hazlinabdulhamid7461 FPDA not really related to China.

Even US tries to always include India on its side. However, in the end we cannot be sure which side India would stand. India remains uncommitted. Good for them to take advantage of each side at its convenience.

@Arun_Kumar_UK

Ай бұрын

The west has this deep seated view that, the world is split between good and bad. The west is good, and the rest are bad. It's impossible for the west to imagine multiple poles due to this good vs bad view. In reality geo politics is like having multiple political parties, so you don't have to choose the lesser of the evil. So it's natural to have multiple poles. If you think about it, west is one pole, India is another, Africa is another, Iran, Russia and China are it's own poles each. Just because Russia, Iran and China are cooperating currently doesn't mean they are together as a single pole. All these countries have independent foreign policies. The west on the other hand doesn't have full sovereignty and have to follow the US foreign policy. I wonder if this stunted thinking about power centers is due to the bi-party system in the US.

@justinwolf7490

Ай бұрын

China is currently building dams in Tibet to control 40% of India’s fresh water. We might not agree with the US on everything but The CCP is pure evil. 🇮🇳 🇺🇸

@Nehas949

Ай бұрын

Usa want slave and vessel. Usa always supported paxistan. I really don't get which face American ask us for help when they always supported paxistan

@avk1943

Ай бұрын

Usa tried to attack India and they still fund pakistan even though osama was found there just as a deterrent to India

@urbanmangyan3095

Ай бұрын

Of late, India is resonating an obviously calculated move towards cooperation with the Philippines.. so u r bit off tangent with ur idea

Great discussion! Awesome!👍🏼❤️

Thanks you U.S., AUSTRALIA, UK and JAPAN 🙏🙏🙏❤

Aries we are very proud of you. Your Brilliant. Watching from London.

Why does your map show Taiwan in RED as part of China. Taiwan is an independent nation that has never been a part of China. Tibet should not be shown in red. China's neighbors need to unify their response to Chinese aggression with a military treaty similar to NATO. The South Sea Treaty Organisation that includes Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, Philippines, Indonesia, Vietnam and Malaysia. The USA, UK, and Australia would should not be members of the SSTO but should be create a separate South Pacific Treaty Organisation that works closely with the SSTO. India needs to form it's o.wn treaty organisation that includes Nepal, Bhutan, Thailand, Bangladesh, Cambodia. The massed arms of these treaty organisation would crush China if the started a war,

Why is Taiwan in red on the map shown in the video thumbnail?

@anon.6678

Ай бұрын

That's because Germany has an official One China policy, as does 99.9% of the world.

@jameschen5686

27 күн бұрын

cause the official name is ROC, republic of China

Philippines concern started when China do not want to maintain the status quo by snatching atolls and reefs and developing them into military installations and asking our fishermen not to fish in the sea that they have been fishing for ages.. who would not freak out? It is not containing china because of america but because they are invading space and access in the south china sea which are too close to the philippines because of their ridiculous and outrageous nine dash line.. so yes, china needs confrontation and should be contained for causing problem in the south china sea

@KittyCat-qg4vd

Ай бұрын

The Philippines started stealing Chinese inlands in the 60s during the Vietnam war. Fact.

@wayangpok

Ай бұрын

I think China may consider removing their claims if the US moved all its military bases in countries surrounding China in the South China Sea. Wishful thinking I know because the US can't give up on pinning down China.

@aldrinmilespartosa1578

Ай бұрын

​@wayangpok philippines DID remove the American basis, that's now a free port and economic center. Its WHEN China seize control of said island.

@aldrinmilespartosa1578

Ай бұрын

​@wayangpok philippines DID remove the American basis, that's now a free port and economic center. Its WHEN China seize control of said island.

@aldrinmilespartosa1578

Ай бұрын

​@wayangpok philippines DID remove the American basis, that's now a free port and economic center. Its WHEN China seize control of said island.

Please you need to also interview Carpio

Indo pacific should banding together if they want peace in the region and against the expansionism

Respect to the brave and enlightened country's defending the world from Chinese communist bullying.

@alereon

Ай бұрын

Zoinist

@LouiseChong-xk5xp

Ай бұрын

​@@alereondon't u dare question US sugar daddy. Those weapons sent are for peaceful purposes😏😏😏

Our Chinese people are intelligent, hardworking, kind, and brave. The political elites in the Western world who aspire to make China a banana republic will not realize their dreams. The Middle East, Persia, Iran, and Far East China are both extremely proud and stubborn civilizations. Even if they may be in an unfavorable position for a while, or even conquered by foreign races and religions, their inherent pride prevents them from being transformed into other ethnic groups. On the contrary, as long as they seize the opportunity, they will decisively establish their own national flag again and throw themselves into the long river of history with their unique posture. Jack Sullivan, the National Security Assistant to the President of the United States, personally stated that spending too much money over decades to turn China into a banana republic has completely failed.

@peterhanssens7260

Ай бұрын

The conflict is with the party, the CPC and not with the people of China. Chinese Canadian are hard working no argument there. The CPC is not China and must be reminded as such.

@leomarreyes6011

Ай бұрын

CCP is greedy and liar!

I get that “soon” is relative… but to me, soon means 30 seconds or less🤣🤣

Map is outrageous

What a rhetorical question. China is already encircled by neighbours.

@WSOJ3

Ай бұрын

By whom? Russia? NK? Kazakstan? Afghanistan? Myanmar? Malaysia? Or is it Pakistan? Oh I see, it’s only the US and it’s crony Japan.

@marudesugaming5686

Ай бұрын

Could be allies or friends or partners. But china wants to be the boss.

@kingxyz906

Ай бұрын

​@Ladusingh-me3xihe is saying that china is surrounded by its neighbours

@wayangpok

Ай бұрын

@Ladusingh-me3xi China's only sea front is posited by a slew of American military outposts from the Philippines right up to Japan.

@SwCC2749

Ай бұрын

​@@wayangpok apparently they weren't able to stop even detect Chinese warships and submarines when they enter the Pacific. btw which country isn't encircled by its neighbours lol

Was this the view. I came for geopolitical and financial news but failed to find any.

We have the ASEAN where member countries are coordinating and managing issues and concerns in the region.

@SwCC2749

Ай бұрын

Yeah and ASEAN's largest trade partner is China lol

❤❤❤

CCP has been harassing her neighbors , when these neighbors come together to form alliances that is their right and a common sense….

❤❤❤❤

Your thumbnail image showing the wrong map tells a lot about Germany and how it acts on Beijing's will.

Respect for Indians for refusing to become a vassalage of USA.

@Celda-dg3ux

Ай бұрын

Remind us once China controls all your rivers emanating from Tibet.

@maxpayne4118

Ай бұрын

​@@Celda-dg3uxI'll like to remind you that you failed you geography class

@blackhawk5903

Ай бұрын

​@@maxpayne4118 no he is right Einstein

@peter-xw1mu

Ай бұрын

China bot detected

@syncmonism

Ай бұрын

The US was never trying to make India a vassal state. Obviously that would be impossible for them to do, so to suggest that they would try to do such a thing is absurd and misleading.

As a man from Europe , I want to thank india for sending oil and gas to European countries.

@user-bd7oq3yx2k

Ай бұрын

But India buys its oil from Russia

@ssdhusg6042

Ай бұрын

Yes, that is oil resold from Russia by India at a higher price. Europeans are a big grievance.😂

@andrehunter1295

Ай бұрын

That's why they are so desperate now, they have blocked themselves from enough cheap recourses from Russia, only for us interest 😢

@user-vy4cu8ui2x

Ай бұрын

@@ssdhusg6042 And who blew up the direct connection from Russia to EU ?

@ssdhusg6042

Ай бұрын

@@user-vy4cu8ui2x no Russia and EU .

showing military muscle with alliances is actually good😅

All this is largely overstated your talking up the situation which i guess is normal for western media

Thumbnail map is wrong and disrespectful to India, arunachal is not a disputed region simply because China wants it, dont spread misinformation

@SDM496

Ай бұрын

DW is always anti India. I always recommend to ban dw from India just like Rt is banned in EU.

@gigimathew4031

Ай бұрын

I am sure it got something to do with the big boss.​@@SDM496

@angusp5178

Ай бұрын

China's foreign ministry in 2023: "The Chinese government has never recognised the so-called Arunachal Pradesh. The south Tibetan region is part of China's territory."

@abadyr_

Ай бұрын

@@SDM496 If two countries want the same region, it's disputed.

@avijitbasak8837

Ай бұрын

​@@angusp5178China occupied Tibet!

Yes, we need to push back.

Why does your map show the Republic of China in red?

In the thumbnail the island of Taiwan is red, or a shade of red. Is DW News saying the island of Taiwan is a part of the PRC, or maybe a part of the PRC? Does DW have evidence of when the Republic of China ("Taiwan") ceased to exist?

@HectorSantos-fi9xm

Ай бұрын

When did it begin to exist?

@aslampervez2294

Ай бұрын

Taiwan is recognised as part of China recognised by US EU UK and 180 countries

@vietnguyen4312

Ай бұрын

@@aslampervez2294 There are no internationally recognized treaties, policies, agreements or UN resolutions that declare that Taiwan is part of China. 180 countries support the One China Policy. The One China Policy does NOT state that Taiwan is part of China. Read it carefully and educate yourself.

@binbi8177

Ай бұрын

@@vietnguyen4312 Taiwan is just a separatist regime in China, it is not a country

@marlion6183

Ай бұрын

你认为dw比你傻吗？你的话比联合国决议重要吗？😂😂😂

China's wolf warrior diplomacy backfired. Aggression makes your neighbors scared and want to band together. Putin learned that when he invaded Ukraine and caused Finland and Sweden to join NATO.

@growtocycle6992

Ай бұрын

It's America who has been the aggressor

@wayangpok

Ай бұрын

Which neighbor banded together against China ? Only the philippines and India.

@wayangpok

Ай бұрын

I mean not including Japan who has been at some odds with China after WW2.

@SwCC2749

Ай бұрын

Does 'Band Together' mean that China remained ASEAN's largest trade partner for more than 10 years?

It's pathetic that you can only get Clifford as the voice for China's view.

Philippines need to speak with Beijing without the US interfering in this issue

@leomarreyes6011

Ай бұрын

We did but CCP is a liar and all talks

Some members of Asean depend on Chinas economiy that's why they don't want to anger china

@hbr968

Ай бұрын

Except Philippines we don't relay on China, we can live without the help of China we have lot of allied we don't want Enemy in our own backyard

@hbr968

Ай бұрын

Only Philippines have the ball to fight the Paper Dragon 😂😂😂

@WingkKong

Ай бұрын

​@@hbr968Philippine cannot Stop the Rise of Asia

Honestly, DW, this presentation is somewhat lacking in professionalism. Think about changing or better prepping the presenters.

I agree with the red color for Taiwan. It’s been quite hot recently here so it is totally possible that it just naturally turned red on the map.

QUAD is NOt an alliance! 😂 it’s a strategic cooperation!

But the strategic, trade and economic pacts that China has built with its friendly states are forging ahead with greater unity and urgency these days. These includes BRICS, Belt and Road Initiative, CEPA, Shanghai Cooperative Organization.....Taking BRICS for example, the pact commands 36% of global GDP and over 47% of global population, putting the comparison with G7's numbers in shade. The problem for the West is these pacts are getting stronger by the days, thanks to the West's own bipolar actions.

India is importing crude oil from Russia transform it to petroleum products and the Europe's are very silently sneakingly importing them from India.

@rajput2736

Ай бұрын

But India also fighting against China...India arch enemy country is China not Russia ..

incomprehensible how theyve been talking about a potential ww3 for over an hour in such a relaxed manner

How long will USA hold allies. When china show lollipop all allies run to take it😂😂😂

Where is Taiwan on the map? Why does it have the same color with China?

@anon.6678

Ай бұрын

That's because Germany has an official One China policy, as does 99.9% of the world.

actually, they are inviting Japan and India in the AUKUS. so it will be called JAUKUSI...

@nick00176

Ай бұрын

😂😂😅

Why is the map of India being depicted incorrectly?

Is it just me or PRC's territories on the map used by western media keep getting smaller and smaller.🤔

@muck6345

Ай бұрын

They are gaining spiritual victory

Busy forming alliances against a country that doesn't care.

Iam indian. Europeans must understand friendship with Americans more dangerous than enemy 😅😅😅😅

@Wombat7777777

Ай бұрын

elaborate pls

@nmew6926

Ай бұрын

​@@Wombat7777777Imagine the unlikely scenario both China and Russia defeated. What will happen next. Dont you think US will identify a new big enemy. Months before WW2 ended, US already thought of post WW2 and they already identified USSR its war ally as it's next big enemy

@Wombat7777777

Ай бұрын

@@nmew6926 In post WW2 Europe USSR the war ally did what Germany did before in their occupied territories, besides deathcamps.

Marking Taiwan as part of China, particularly when talking about strategic alliances against China, is a smooth-brain move.

The map on the thumbnail is just wrong

Both hostress and commentators failed to mentioned about USA has military base along the China Sea. Wouldn't China feel the threatens?

@505Vermont

Ай бұрын

That’s not an excuse to take territory of countries that don’t even host US bases

@kzm-cb5mr

Ай бұрын

US has no bases in the Philippines since 1991. The US access to Philippine bases was only granted AFTER the Chinese aggressions restarted in 2012. If China feels threatened, that's their own doing, they're just reaping the results of their bullying.

@chillxxx241

Ай бұрын

The US has bases next to China, because it had to save China from Japan during World War II. Then the communist came out of their caves after the fighting stopped and attacked their homeland. The US has been stuck in the region, fighting minor wars against the communist and trying to prevent World War III from breaking out, but China and Russia are interested in starting that war now.

@belladonna1994

Ай бұрын

the hostress and commentators are CIA bots

@belladonna1994

Ай бұрын

so some European settlers come and grab the Indians land, then founded the country USA, then now their descendants are lecturing China / Russia on territorial integrity and freedom of navigation

The Communist Party of China's actions in the South China Sea are a cause for concern and demand international attention. Despite their claims of ensuring safe passage for international trade, their aggressive tactics and territorial assertions paint a different picture. The ongoing disputes and incidents involving Filipino fishermen highlight the real intentions behind China's actions - a bid to assert dominance and control over the region. China's attempts to propagate a false narrative of safety in the South China Sea contradict the realities of the situation. The international community remains vigilant and is closely monitoring developments in the region. The pattern of bullying and aggression displayed by China raises serious doubts about their commitment to ensuring free and open navigation in these vital waters. The concerns surrounding China's future intentions in the South China Sea are valid, especially considering the potential for increased restrictions and interference in maritime activities that do not align with China's interests. It is imperative for countries to uphold international laws and norms, and for diplomatic efforts by those like-minded countries to castigate China to accept the Hague Ruling (ITLOS) invalidating the 9-Dash Lines.

china china china is the problem problem problem😅😅😅

In the maps, If India's Arunachal Pradesh is being showed in dashed lines I believe "Tibet" NOT "Tibet, China" should also be shown in dashed lines like its shown in Taiwan. That would be right representation of the country's territories.

Too much nonsense 😂😂

China still lives in barbaric era where you can just claim territories by force or threats😂

Tama lang. China is more aggressive in China sea. The JAUCUS Collaboration is the key against the abusive China. The collab looks like NATO in Europe. It seems that world peace is an elusive dream?

Technically the notion that these alliances were forned to contain china can be logical because each and every nation out of these alliances have common interests. But i think the most reason that primarily countries around china are behaving of what we see today, is a response to the colonialist,terrritorial expansionism attitude of china.

Japan should defend its former colony that it ruled with brutality for 50 years? Really ? Israel is allowed to colonise the west bank, so in the extremely unlikely and irresponsible move, is America thinking about Taiwan becoming part of Japan and then japan could do a proxy war with China like ulkraine against Russia? Like sending military aids to Japan so the japanese can defend taiwan? You guys ever asked if Japanese locals, NOT the extremely unpopular politicians, want to wage a war against China over Taiwan? Must japanese military be dragged into a war with China over taiwan? Is japan truly a Democracy when most want to stay out of a war? All the talks about democracy is better than chinese communism, does it mean it s better alternative if taiwan is being colonised by democracy, just like how the west accepted the colonisation of the west bank? If you want to talk about international law, who is actively supporting israel with military aids and starving 2 million people in Gaza or doing nothing when the west bank is Illegally occupied? Taiwan being occupied by China would be MORE legitimate under international law than israel colonising west bank because almost ALL countries recognise the one China policy. If the west accepted colonisation in the west bank, is it not the height of hypocrisy if a war over Taiwan happens despite the island being part of China, with its full official name being the Republic of China?

1:15:00 most Asean will be neutral countries. especially laos, cambodia will not support phillipines on this issue

@IslamicMuhammadIsPedophile

Ай бұрын

They will give moral support to Philippines. Also, Indonesia and Malaysia will navigate their own waters which are claimed by China, and China cant do anything about it. All ASEAN countries are irked by Chinese specially Vietnam. Lastly, China has so many powerful and rich enemies like Japan, South Korea, Australia, India, Taiwan, US and EU. China will lose in this war.

Where is the Republic of Korea in these equations?

Actually there is a actual super villain group called Orchis

Like the guy who gave us the Chinese point of view on the matter 😂😂😂 it's just laughable, coz he said the most anti China stuff of all the invited guests

@aslampervez2294

Ай бұрын

He was selected for his view

Germany not learnt lession of 1945 always put wrong map of india, USA vasal Germany you are 3 rd grade power don't forget it

These alliances have been there for 70 years. When China-US relation is good they are useless; when China is seen by US as a threat, China is then seen by US allies as a threat, or US money printer (for the Philippines).

@bjornborg4849

Ай бұрын

If they do what the US says, they are not allies, they are vassals ;)

nobody's country has moved anywhere, so this idea of encirclement is silly.

Your map shows Taiwan as part of China 🤦🤬.

@kirkhoo7456

Ай бұрын

As it is.

@taiwanlife6531

Ай бұрын

@@kirkhoo7456 I recommend to educate yourself! I live here and I can guarantee you that these criminals from the CCP aren't ruling Taiwan.

@taiwanlife6531

Ай бұрын

​@@kirkhoo7456 lol, you are a good comedian! Taiwan isn't ruled by Pooh!

@khaelavellano1966

Ай бұрын

​@@taiwanlife6531Winiie the Pooh of Chyna lol

@kirkhoo7456

Ай бұрын

@@taiwanlife6531 some part of China is not ruled by Pooh. So what? It is still China.

A lion vs a pack of dogs

@sockhal4595

Ай бұрын

More like a paper tiger jumping into a swimming pool 😂

@zanezhao4490

Ай бұрын

@@sockhal4595Go challenge the lion and see if war is cruel.🦮

@giacomogiacomo1194

Ай бұрын

​@@zanezhao4490Well they are doing it now. And I'd rather be on the side of the Americans than the Chinese.

@titobandito1555

Ай бұрын

Bot

@LOOOOOOOOOOL229

Ай бұрын

That why paper tiger crying rn😂😂​@@zanezhao4490

apparently the HMAS Hobart is to be handed over to the PHilippines Navy.

We've known since 1988 exactly what types of weapons Japan would develop. Akira.

A lion vs a pack of dogs 😂

@scrollop

Ай бұрын

Sure you can call the US a lion and china and russia are dogs. Countries that give their citizens very little rights - such as the right to move freely, to protest or to view the internet freely, are worse than dogs - and china and russia are prime examples.

@sockhal4595

Ай бұрын

You mean a paper tiger jumping into a swimming pool 😂

@giacomogiacomo1194

Ай бұрын

Who is Lion? China? 🤣. It's more like the other way around Family of Lion or Pride vs. a lone Hyena.🤣

@titobandito1555

Ай бұрын

Bot

@iROChakri

Ай бұрын

Many dogs need to get together to fight a paper tiger. With this logic and stupidity, for sure they need to get together to survive 😂

China is geopolitical and Asia Regional superpower, its position right to shape the region. its will wise for other Asian nation build good relationship with China for own security and economic interest not try to align with US western hismspre superpower.

@subhaysinghpooniya4662

Ай бұрын

Nope we will not allow china to be imperial power

@Celda-dg3ux

Ай бұрын

Sounds gangsta.

It’s all Cheesy Ping’s fault. He wants everyone’s honey!

Stop showing Taiwan as part of the PRC when it's literally when of those Indo-Pacific neighbors that is allied against China. Bizarre choice of graphic for this topic.

The Talk is one sided....where is the view from china side??? The islands is within 9 dash line which china claimed hundred year back (when there was no philipine country.) Taiwan(which is called Republic of China ) is still having a unfinished civial was with PRC. (and china have ligitimate claim on Taiwan Province since 200 hundred years ago). why those not explained in this vedio?? we should hear both voices from history not the simple one sided voice?

Pillar ONE is about a bit more than subs. Pillar 2 is ALSO about a bit more ( the Japanese subs are Diesel and Australia cancelled a deal with France for the best diesel subs to be supplied to Australia in order for Australia to build nuke subs.....the Virginia's by the way ARE nuke subs - Nuke subs are ten times more superior than diesel, maybe a hundred times more. China is NOT afraid of Diesel subs but they are afraid of nukes. But there is a LOT more to this than just what is said here......A LOT MORE!

😅Japanese clearly knew what is going on... 2024-4-9 Japan local media say, U$A goal is more Japanese tax $$ Sad for Japan tax payers.

China are the one entering countries territories... what king of questions here... no countries take or enter china lands and waters.... but China taking Lands, Islands, and Sea...

@kirkhoo7456

Ай бұрын

Many countries tried to enter Chinese lands and waters; unfortunate for them they were kicked out. Japan in 1945, US-UK in 1949, India in 1962 and 1972, Vietnam in 1979.. etc etc.

@justinwolf7490

Ай бұрын

@@kirkhoo7456lol wtf was that little alternate history. The US kicked Japan out of China by beating Japan. Japan was well on its way to conquering all of China with a small army of marines.

@jetli740

Ай бұрын

@@justinwolf7490 US kick japan out of china? what drug you taking?

@ronaldtan8273

Ай бұрын

@@kirkhoo7456 yes but Phil. are nothing todo in the past... but China taking Phil. waters and Resources.... by Force...

@ronaldtan8273

Ай бұрын

@@kirkhoo7456 yes but Phil. are nothing todo in the past... but China taking Phil. waters and Resources.... by Force...

It's either them or us. These country will make sure that's not them.

Philippines only in the whole of South east asia other countries could not be trusted and entrusted crucial rules all of which have their own strategies that is deterrent to the goals of the indo Pacific. This is definitely not anti China it is anti aggression and disrespect.