A Greek professor (of both ancient and modern Greek) explained the sound change very simply: sheep said Beh-Beh, not Vi-vi. (βη-βη).

@jay.rhoden

2 жыл бұрын

Yes, but the more interesting question is, _when_ did sheep start saying vi-vi 😀

@trackanalysis6369

2 жыл бұрын

@@jay.rhoden that's usually determined by the exact way words were borrowed into other languages. We don't call basilisk a vasilisc, but the russian name sounds Vasil, not Basil.

@teoteog3984

Жыл бұрын

kzread.info/dash/bejne/fquOsKlwhdjbZ8o.html βηη-βηηηηη

@kalliaspapaioannou7045

Жыл бұрын

@G. V. True, still Kratinos, who wrote that, was a comedy writer, and it refers to an idiot who starts walking as "προβατον" (προβαίνω: walk in front) which did not meant always sheep back then, the word was (οίς), but could be many different animals and he either meant that the idiot person was acted in not the correct sound or he maybe means another animal. Also the animal sounds are not copied by people the same in every language, in Greek we say "Γαβ" when English can be "woof" for example and we don't know if the ancient Greeks were actually using "beh-beh " Also Plato in Kratylus (418c) says: " 'Εγώ σοι ερώ. Οϊσθα δτι οι παλαιοί οι ημέτεροι τω Ιώτα και τω δέλτα εϋ μάλα εχρώντο, και ούχ ήκιστα αι γυναίκες, αΐπερ μάλιστα τήν άρχαίαν φωνήν σώζουσι. νυν δε αντί μεν του ιώτα ή ει ή ητα μεταστρέφουσιν, αντί δε του δέλτα ζήτα, ως δη μεγαλοπρεπέστερα οντά."

@MrVladko0

Жыл бұрын

@@trackanalysis6369 True, also in Russian basilisk sounds ‘vasilisc’ (‘василиск’) too.

Great job! Thank you! Your reading is really cool at the end too, and I could understand even without looking at the text! As a modern Greek, I really think Lucian is a good system in all regards!

@diglossos5202

2 жыл бұрын

Thank you so much!

Nice summary and great reading at the end. As a long time Latin student I am just now learning Ancient Greek and this is the pronunciation I have adopted.

Lovely video! Thanks for the shoutout.

@PC_Simo

Ай бұрын

I *_KNEW_* there *_HAD TO_* be a shoutout to you. One does not simply talk about Lucian pronunciation, without mentioning you 👌🏻. 😅

Lucian sounds like a slower version of modern Greek. If you speed it up a bit they sound exactly the same

Enhorabuena por el vídeo.

The monophthongization of the i-diphthongs was very early (and was the cause of the itazism), so it would be much more consistent to pronounce αι as [ ɛː] and οι as [ øː].

@Philoglossos

Жыл бұрын

As with most sound changes it was one that may have began fairly early, but certainly wasn't complete for all speakers by this period.

Μπράβο σου! That was a lovely reading at the end! 😍 What's your native language? Are you bilingual? 🤔

@diglossos5202

2 жыл бұрын

Thank you so much! I'm bilingual English/German, but I've done a lot of Latin and Greek (ancient and modern).

You mentioned that it preserves vowel lenghts, but at the end of the video I couldn't really distinguish between long and short vowels. Did I miss(hear) anything, or was it intentional?

@diglossos5202

2 жыл бұрын

I am, admittedly, not very good at consistently maintaining vowel length. But a lot of people greatly overextend long vowels; in which case, a "normal" long vowel might sound short. In English: 'bet' is βετ, 'bed' is βηδ. But most of us don't notice the length distinction.

@HighWideandHandsome

2 жыл бұрын

@@diglossos5202 I never noticed that before. That's a great illustration! Pronouncing one as long as the other sounds unnatural.

For my part I prefer a pronunciation leaning towards the archaic period, which means distinguishing genuine from spurious diphthongs. To draw on Luke Ranieri, ειπειν has a genuine in first and spurious after, and for that purpose the old Attic alphabet is actually more etymological.

Very interesting theory of linguistic change. Why go with Lucian if modern Greeks can train their ears to the differences. Can't we?

What do you say when you to be on the tips that most of the coptics spoke the hellenic language about 25oo years ago and the second greatest library situated in alexandria which contained thousands of manuscripts sciences in hellenic language and the alexadrian university lectures were in hellenic language so it has become a native language for it used as well in liturgies, but misfortunately in the reason of various drastic mishaps factors that have gone through by the onalphbet invatiion tribes was totally lost. As to come to the conclusion we have missed away a lovely toning language, but we could manage to regain our native coptic language before it's utterly lost. We stii have a tiny village that speaks this language as well. Moreover, we were able to keep the philology and its correct sounds. As for myself, the good chance has given me the opportunity to learn greek language, for I found out a wide range of similarity between the both languages,and that has given me an impetus to read the septuagint so that I'm still diving lookin for pearls and diamonds. It's really a pretty and lovely great job, for everybody has deep consideration for such subjects.

At last an acceptable ancient Greek pronunciation for modern Greek speakers

Does Attic Greek poetry rhyme in Lucian pronunciation?

@diglossos5202

3 ай бұрын

Welll technically Attic Greek poetry doesn't rhyme in any pronunciation except by accident, because ancient Greek poetry doesn't use rhyme. But the Lucian pronunciation preserves long and short vowels and so maintains the meter.

@cool.ebiaka

9 күн бұрын

@@diglossos5202 and this is the point. i suppose it is exclusively for this reason why he keeps the vowel lengths at all. the lengths are acceptable or tolerable in his method rather than necessary and historically based.

Is it called "Lucian" because of Luke Ranieri?

@MarcoMangia78

Жыл бұрын

By Lucian of Samosata, a famous writer that lived in 2nd century AD, the period this reconstructed pronunciation system refers to

@13tuyuti

10 ай бұрын

@@MarcoMangia78 but probably not entirely a coincidence.

I've read that Lucian was a Syrian from birth ,do you think his way of writing/speaking was based on the Greek spoken in Syria or more on the one spoken in Athens? He was part of the second sophistic if I remember correctly?? Do you know how this movement shaped the Koinè Greek??

@diglossos5202

2 жыл бұрын

A big question! As far as we can tell, this pronunciation reflects the way Greek was probably pronounced by most educated speakers during the Roman period. There were however regional variations: Athens in particular was a bit more conservative than other areas. Lucian himself may have had an accent, yes, but he was still a fluent Greek-speaker.

@richardyannick8935

2 жыл бұрын

@@diglossos5202 Maybe we could answer it by comparing Lucian prononciation of words compared to Capadoccian greek ,the closest geographical dialect of the Greek spoken in Samosata ?? Just guessing I'm a total beginner in greek , well I know the alphabet now 💪 An other question about Lucian prononciation, it is possible to communicate with a person speaking modern Greek ?

@dariusmot8440

Жыл бұрын

@@richardyannick8935 Lucian pronunciation is quite close to Modern Greek pronunciation but of course we do have a few differences. I think if we mimic the modern greek phonology they can understand us.

The reading and pronunciation of modern greek is easy and it's logical, but writing it is a little more difficult because you have to either memorize or know the root. English is 1000x worse

@jay.rhoden

2 жыл бұрын

Exactly. People who argue "We should pronounce koine greek as it was written, letter by letter, because it makes learning easier" should check how quickly a normal 5 year old is able to pick up the English pronunciation system.

I believe that if you want to pronounce ancient greek as it might have been pronounced in 5th century AD then this so-called Lucian pronunciation is appropriate. It could be easily called late Roman empire pronunciation of koine or simply early BYZANTINE pronunciation and both would be correct. In other words a greek speaker in 500 AD would have read Plato, Aristotle and the New Testament in this way;however a Greek in 400 BC or 350 BC would have read with the reconstructed and updated Erasmian pronunciation. The Lucian or early Byzantine pronunciation is akin to pronouncing Shakespeare and 16th and 17th century English in modern British or American pronunciation as we indeed do today. If one wants to pronounce Plato, and the other 5TH AND 4TH CENTURY GREEK AUTHORS, then the scholarly modernized Erasmian pronunciation would be more accurate. Either way this is a choice one must make that suits one's linguistic abilities and personal ease of pronunciation or sense of reproducing authentically the Greek language in its targeted chronological period. That is all. Either way each choice is appropriate to the person who chooses it and it works for him or her.

It was too fast though.. He wasn't reading for learners😢

hmm, thanks a lot! melikes this new pronunciation far less than the erasmian one. well, this new method is a priceless breakthrough for biblical studies though. is it really hopeless to reconstruct the athenian pronunciation of about 5th century b.c.? classical reading, i mean, not hellenistic one

Một bài hát rất hoài niệm , nhớ những ngày bồng bột của tuổi trẻ, chút kỷ niệm của tình yêu, lời chia tay vội vàng đúng như cái bồng bột ấy. Đức Phúc cover lại bài hát này tâm trạng quá !

I've found Classics professors at my university often encourage us to just use the one that comes most easily to us. Reason being, it'll get in the way of actually learning if you get hung up on it at the beginning. Like right now, we're doing alot of Attic Greek, so I try to go for Attic pronunciation like one of my professors. But then others use Erasmian, and others just kinda feel their way through it. It really just depends on the person I find.

@manos7958

Жыл бұрын

Imagine if it was math or physics and a professor said that he doesn't care if it is correct or not, "just use the one that comes most easily to us". I will leave it at that, give it a thought.

@scintillam_dei

2 ай бұрын

@@manos7958 Exacto.

This video is old and inaccurate. The vowel pronunciations provided are almost all wrong. Check out Kantor's pronunciation for the most updated info.

@diglossos5202

15 күн бұрын

Kantor's reconstructions are accurate but rather one-sided. I'd actually recommend Teodorrson's series of studies, which demonstrates pretty conclusively that (1) changes in the direction of Modern Greek started very early, even in the classical period, but also (2) a conservative pronunciation that maintained the diphthongs and η as /e:/ lasted into the Byzantine period among some speakers. The question about pronunciation is always, whose pronunciation? Did lots of speakers have itacism in antiquity? Yes. Did lots of them preserve aspirated consonants and full diphthongs? Also yes.

KOINON MAKEDONON

@AthrihosPithekos

5 күн бұрын

A Yugoslav fart popped out...

I'm afraid this pronunciation adds lots of difficulty for students, with no real advantage. It prevents me from recommending Luke's videos to my students. I hope he'll change pronunciation someday!

@diglossos5202

2 жыл бұрын

I'm afraid I often agree.

@diglossos5202

2 жыл бұрын

Incidentally, in your opinion, what kind of video would be most useful for your students?

@DiomedesDioscuro

2 жыл бұрын

@@diglossos5202 I really really think the best thing is to combine both restitution and convention, details depending on the language of the students. For example, my Spanish speaking students pronounce χ like in modern Greek, because it matches Spanish j, but I might not demand the same thing from an English speaking student.

@kenx8176

2 жыл бұрын

Same here.

@Nikelaos_Khristianos

2 жыл бұрын

@@DiomedesDioscuro I actually found that to be the case when teaching a session of Ancient Greek to English 10 year olds (it was a programme at university). I basically offered a "hard way", like "chi", and an "easy way", like "khi". The main difficultly they found was distinguishing the aspirated consonants from their non-aspirated counterparts, like "kappa" vs "chi" for example. Overall, I found it was a decent middle-ground between making sure everyone could have a try, but also letting the more ambitious students to try and show off.

Τhe pronunciation is the same the last 3500 years and the letters pronunciate the same

Any sound change from modern Greek to any system renders that system invalid.

@mariostsam

2 жыл бұрын

As a greek my self I admire the ignorance of the neogreeks about ancient greek language, not only about the homeric or the varioys classical dialects, the hellenistic and roman times but even the "byzantine" pronounciation was different from the neogreek, eg the /y/ sound of Y. Ancient greek, hellenistic poetry in modern greek pronounciation, loses basic characteristics as length, gravity, musical intonation is no more greek than latin poetry in modern english mode. The fact that the modern language of the greek state is named "greek" means NOTHING. Italian Spanish Portuguese speaking people dont claim that they speak Latin! Η ΕΛΛΗΝΙΚΗ ΦΩΝΗ ΞΕΝΗ ΕΣΤΙΝ, ΔΙΑ ΤΟΥΣ ΝΕΟΕΛΛΑΔΙΤΑΣ

@acstamos

2 жыл бұрын

@@mariostsam You must be spending many hours in front of a mirror every day admiring yourself. Yours has to be one of the most idiotic comments out there stupid.

@mariostsam

2 жыл бұрын

@@acstamos I admire your strenuous arguments. A celebration of dialectical thinking, a theophania of Hermes Logios Himself.

@acstamos

2 жыл бұрын

@@mariostsam That was not an argument. I just called your post idiotic, and stupid. Your last post is just as idiotic.

@IIlines

2 жыл бұрын

And as I expected, the only 2 people that left a comment here were Greeks and they started fighting together immediately.