This is what journalism was supposed to look like. Great job!

Can't believe how natural you are at journalism stuff (kind of). More power to Muzamil, keep the talks going.

Can you please include Jamat-e-Islami manifesto in your series as well. I am really interested to see how their manifesto looks like. Thank you

@iq2823

4 ай бұрын

کیا ان کا بھی کوئی منشور ہوتا ہے۔۔۔۔؟ ان کا ایک ہی منشور ہے "اسلامی نظام" جس کا آج تک دٗنیا میں کوئی وجود ہی نہیں اور نہ ہی کبھی تھا۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔ کیا ایسا کوئی نظام اس دٗنیا میں کبھی آیا تھا؟ حضورپاکؐ نے اسلام کی تبلیغ کی تھی۔۔۔۔ اسلام ایک روحانی تعلیمات کا مجموعہ تھا نہ کہ وہ کسی ایک مخصوص نظام کی تشکیل وترویج کرتا ہے۔۔۔۔۔۔

@ilmenaafey9027

4 ай бұрын

+1. But, I don't think we need to remind Muzammil for that. I'm more than just hopeful that he might already have started working it out and will air it asap.

@servantofallah9425

4 ай бұрын

​@@iq2823astagfirullah. u can not be more wrong. apne class 1 se 4 tak islami book jo school ma parhate ha, wo bi sahe se ni parhe Islam ma har saza ha, har politics ha, har economical structure system ha , islam ma har har chez ha aur wo qayamat tak ke lie ha. Koi naya nabi aur nae kitab ni aege, even if we go to mars. Ye kitab aur eske asool FINAL ha

@iq2823

4 ай бұрын

@@servantofallah9425 یہی انتہاپسندانہ اور دھشتگردانہ سوچ ہے جو مسلمانوں کو صدیوں سے پستیوں کے گہرے عمیق گڑھوں میں پھینک کر کہیں بہت دور چلی گئی ہے جہاں سے ہم اپنی شناخت اور وجود بھی شائد تلاش نہیں کرپائے اور شائد کر بھی نہیں پائیں گے۔۔۔۔۔ اس کی ایک اور مثال 1258 میں جب ھلاکو خان کے ہاتھوں سقوط بغداد ہوا تھا تب بھی بغداد کی گلیوں میں اس وقت کے نام نہاد مسلمان (میں اس لفظ نام نہاد مسلمان استعمال کرنے پہ بالکل بھی معذرت نہیں کرونگا) بغداد کی گلیوں میں تب بھی یہی بحث کرتے پائے جاتے تھے کہ لفظ "ضآلین" کو ادا کرتے ہوئے زبان حلق کیساتھ چھونی چاھیئے یا نہیں یا پھر زبان کو حلق کے اندر کس زاویے سے گھمانا چاھیئے یا پھر یہ حرف "ضواد ہے یا ضآد" اور اس طرح کی بہت ہی فروعی، فضول، بے معنی بحث کی جاتیں تھیں جن کے نتائج آنے یا نہ آنے سے بغداد مسلمانوں کے دوبارہ قبضے میں نہیں آجانا تھا۔ بلکہ اس دور میں انگریزی حکومت آکسفورڈ اور کیمبرج جیسی یونیورسٹیاں بنا چُکی تھی اور ہم ایسے فضول اوربیکار موضوعات پہ بحث میں اپنے آپ کو الجھا کر عقلیت، جدیدیت اور معاشرتی ترقی سے ہی دورکرتے جارھے تھے۔ اور دور جاتے جاتے آج ہم فکری، شعوری سطح سے نہ صرف کوسوں دور چلے گئے ہیں بلکہ دوسری قوموں کے غلام بن گئے اور آج دُنیا میں سب سے زیادہ کوئی قابلِ ترس، قابل رحم اور قابلِ نفرت اگر کوئی قوم اور طبقہ ہے تو وہ ہم "مسلمان" ہیں۔۔۔ دُنیا آرٹیفیشل انٹیلی جنس (مصنوعی زہانت) کی ایجادات کررہی ہیں، دُنیا چاند سے آگے مریخ تک چلی گئی ہے اور ہم آج بھی یہ بات اپنی بیکار، بے تُکی، بے ڈھنگی اور واھیات، غیرمنطقی دلائل سے ثآبت کرنے پہ تُلے ہوئے ہیں کہ انسان تو چاند پہ بھی گیا ہی نہیں تھا کیونکہ جوتصویر چاند پہ جانے والوں نے دکھائی اس میں تو تارے ہی آسمان پہ نظر نہیں آرھے، جھنڈا لہرا رہا ہے جبکہ چاند پہ تو ہوا بھی موجود نہیں ہے اور بہت سے فضول اور کھوکھلے، بے عقل قسم کے دلائل ۔۔۔۔۔۔ سے اپنے آپ کو جھوٹی تسلیاں دیتے رھتے ہیں اور مطمؑن کرنے کی بے ڈھنگی اور لاحاصل کوشش میں ناقابلِ تردید حقائق کو جُھٹلاتے رھتے ہیں۔ بقول علامہ اقبال اَسی گَلاں اِی کردے رہ گئے تے تَرکھاناں دَا مُنڈا بازی لے گیا ۔۔۔۔

@iq2823

4 ай бұрын

@@servantofallah9425 کیا حضور پاکؐ نے کوئی اسلامی نظآم قائم کیا تھا؟ اور اگر کیا تھا تو اس کی ڈھانچہ کیسا تھا؟ اور اگر وہ کوئی اسلامی نظآم کا کوئی وجود تھا یا ہے تو پھر دٗنیا کے 57 ممالک میں ایک بھی ملک نے وہ نظآم کیوں نہیں اپنایا؟ کیا کوئی بھی مذھب انسان کی ہرہر ضرورت اور ہر پہلو کا احاطہ کرتا ہے؟ اگر ایسا ہے تو پھر عیسائیت مسلمانوں سے پہلے وجود میں آئی تھی اور ان کے پاس بائبل بھی ہے تو انہوں نے کونسا عیسائیت کا نظآم متعارف کروایا تھا یا ہے؟ یا پھر یہودیت نے کونسا ایسا نظآم متعارف کروایا ہے؟ اور اس نظام کے ماتحت کون کون سے ادارے ہیں یا ہونگے اور وہ کیسے کام کریں گے۔۔۔۔؟؟؟؟ اگر مذھب کے اندر اتنا ہی دم اور طاقت ہے تو دٗنیا کے کونسے ممالک ہیں جو مذاھب کی بنیاد پہ آج دٗنیا میں اتنے ترقی یافتہ ہیں۔۔۔؟

In terms of foreign policy, I am with PTI. We need to focus on our economic crisis.

I watched the PTI manifesto in one go, as it had the actual solutions to the problems plaguing Pakistan. But this one I had to watch in multiple sittings as after some time it seemed "narey bazi" rather than actual solution, due to which i lost interest, even though I wanted to give it a fair chance. Excellent Job TBT!!! very thorough and fair analysis. Also i'm interested in Jamat-e-Islami as well, even if it is after the elections, if at all possible.

Absolutely loving this series 😍 You are requested to review & make comparative analysis of Jamat-e-Islami's manifesto as well. They are also a very big political force which deserve the limelight as well.

Mera vote jamaat e islami ko ⚖️✅✌🏻.

Jamat e islami manifesto should be discussed also.

You are doing something that no one else is doing. Amazing content!!! Keep it up bro. More power to you!!!

Make a video on manifesto of jamat e islami as well

JI manifesto review will be nice as well, especially the difference in the manifestos of JI PK and JI KHI

@PoliticalEconomyPK

4 ай бұрын

It would be nice, I agree. But I think he's focusing mainly on parties that have in the past or may in the future form the government in federal

@nowie4007

4 ай бұрын

Yes, please also make a video on J I manifesto too❤❤

Ap ka last part ki wajah sa khali comment karta hu ma , mujhe ap jesa log bhot pasand jo humara mulk ka bara kuch soch ta ha aur wo cheez awam ko bata sir in pakistan probably you have the finest podcast , and sir only because of you i got to know many intellectual people like Usman asif Ceo of systems Mifta ismail ( real thoughts about country and how ut should be runed) And many more who i have been forgotten right now, Thankyou sir for giving sir such Valuable information for free. I would love to meet You one day in Shalla. I would really appreciate i f you comment on my post

Please include Jamat-e-islami manifesto in this series as well.

Listening to this podcast, especially the foreign policy section of PPP which is apparently the most deeply touched area of the entire manifesto or perhaps the only extensively covered section according to the host reminds me of Mr. Bilawal Bhutto Zardari's famous statement OPENLY ALLEGING Khan Sahab k TUM TO SIRF KATHPUTLI HO TUMHAARI DORAIN TO KOI AUR HILA RAHA HAI Now we can clearly see k kon KATHPUTLI hai or KIS ki DORAIN KON hila raha hai So that was a kind of notion I got from this Kisi ko bhi meri baat apne dil ya gurday pe lene ki zaroorat nahin hai chill kerain(endnote)

do one on JI manifesto its the only one with at least some depth like pti

@nowie4007

4 ай бұрын

I want to see JI manifesto too❤❤

what about jamaat e islami???

I guess there Jamaat e Islami's manifesto should be discussed. We already know these parties, if JI is a good be party it should also be introduced. And Muzamil Bhai u can do it. It will be a favor for the nation. Plz.

Can't wait for JI's Karachi Manifesto❤

Can you also do for JI?

Please include jamaat e islami also …

Aoa Muzammil ; Why not add manifesto of Jamaat e Islami? It would help in comparing the solutions provided by the party with the other parties

Love the series , could we have jamat islami aswell

also discuss manifesto of jamat e islami

No party give clear idea on environment, yes there is 1 point in both PPP and ML but they don't share how they will do this. In 2024 Environment is very much important topic and fight against Global warming is very much important. 2023 was the hottest year

You don't have to worry about time, you just have to deliver the message, share ur thoughts and educate people, whether it takes 10 minutes or 50 minutes. Good luck👍

@nowie4007

4 ай бұрын

I agree, we love watching your content muzammil ❤

Can you also cover jamaat e islami

I totally agree with your point of view and explanation. You're truly doing a good job! So beneficial for me as a student of politics.

Can you please include Jamat-e-Islami manifesto in your series as well. I am really interested to see how their manifesto looks like @TBTPodcast

38:05 nai ziada chota b nai aur na hi lamba hai. interesting program keep it up.

@SalmanNasir359

4 ай бұрын

😂

@farispervaiz1634

4 ай бұрын

@@SalmanNasir359 funny... is it?

I would want to watch jamat e islami manifesto review as well.

Absolutely Amazing & in-depth Analysis of different political parties ❤ The way you criticise and evaluate is amazing ❤ Being Psychologist loved to see someone who’s talking logically and awaking people with fact & figures ❤

Please Dcode Jamaat e Islami Manifesto, you will surprise of their thoughts. And if you can't it will be dishonesty

I heard Indian influencer saying that Indian govt incentivise their people for having a food known as Mid-day meal in SCHOOLS so they could encourage the people to send their kids to schools for meal and they get education as well which is an amazing outstanding IDEA. I think political parties will have more access to search and know how this scheme works deep down.

please also sum up JI manisfesto

Make a video on jamat e islami manifesto as well.

Thank you for doing this series.

Link to PPPP's manifesto pdf: pppp.org.pk/website/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/Manifesto-2024.pdf

Loving the content, it's very engaging. Thankyou for breaking down things so all people can understand. Politics always seemed intimidating and now that it's easier to grasp, I'm following along and looking forward to the upcoming episodes!

Please do one for JI too.

@servantofallah9425

4 ай бұрын

And jui too

Thanks for educating us This will helps us understand about the thinking process of these parties If possible, we would love to hear about the manifesto from other parties apart from these 3 Really appreciated your efforts

Good job brother. please do the same for Jamat e Islami's manifesto. Thanks.

Good work! Muzammil :) Really appreciate your effort. Can you work on one thing as well ? For the purpose of awareness can you also describe about the previous manifesto and what actually the party has done for country ? It will be more awareness of what historically the party has performed ?

@abidhussainanjum7213

4 ай бұрын

It's a nice suggestions 👍

Love the raw information❤❤

Loved listening to this. Learning so much from you so thanks a lot for bringing this powerhouse of information to us.

I APPERICIATE YOUR WORK MUZAMILA. KEEP IT UP.

Wonderfull series

Journalisam should be like. keep the same work up Pakistan needs you.

Thank you Muzammil. Keep doing this, more power.

Not boring totally relatable you've done a decent job and what neutral review means is this

very well researched and well put

Informative.. i haven't read any manifesto but you have summarised it..and like your style

Love this format.

Yes you are right. Politics of Pakistan is not national, it's a geopolitics.

@Muzammil Bhai 1,000,000,000 % Agree with You. Keep doing the Great Work!

VERY INFORMATIVE AND MUCH NEEDED CONTENT!

Never heard anything like this before.. very interesting and informative.. Bravo!

Nice series. I am really enjoying this seris.

Doing a great job And thanks for everything

Great Job. we understand properly

Awesome 🙌

Please read the complete motto and manifesto where whole procedure is mention

Great podcast 👍 people like you are really appreciated ❤keep on doing this work ..hmary country ki young generation KO aus trah ki knowledge ki need ha .. jazakAllah ji ❤

you should also review the JI's manifesto

Thanks for sharing, great insight!

Loved every part of it! Excited for upcoming episodes. More power to you!!!

Sindh ko dekh kar dar lagta hai 😢😢😢😢 ki Pakistan Kahi Sindh na ban jaye

Very informative 👌

The content is great length is also fine great to see you in this form of conversation

Thank you for this series bro! Great work. JazakAllah. Much needed journalism. I really pray people learn how to analyse any political party critically before voting for them. Good luck! ❤

I literally love this series ❤ TBT comback

Absolutely brilliant series, Muzamil! Waiting for the third episode

Great talk. Great presentation

Great job Muzammil.

Hey muzammil. Try to cover Jamat e Islami too. Briefly.

yess... na lamba ha ,na short ,na boring, its nice ...please continue the efforts

Thanks

i think this format is more interesting and particularly easy to consume you should do more of these.

Thanks for saving us a lot of time

Just you and fsw can explain the things like wow

Great 👍🏽 series

Great Initiative ❤ Very Interesting and this is what we expecting from Main Stream Media. Muzammil Bhai❤

Great insights Muzammil bhai! Really appreciate yoir work. I hope you are planning to spotify these episodes as well

Great bro.Keep it up.We need more like you. Truly inspirational

Loved every part of it ! Keep it up ❤

Love this series. Keep it up!

Muzammil Bhai You just did a great Job🎉

PPP should have mentioned the Examplery Reforms they have introduced in Sindh and shud mention that they would develop Pakistan like they developed Sindh in past 20 years

Love from the bottom of the heart

Input -> Processing -> Output. Only outputs are mentioned in this manifesto.

nicely analyzed Muzamil bae, and keep continuing dill ki bat series. it's soo worth from you.

Very good series

Great but just one suggestion, if can kindly add pictures with highlighted text of the manifesto that would be great. Personally I don't like to read long stuff this way I can check specifically some points I am interested in through you episode, and secondly it will help people (personally me) to understand the some context and meaning behind some buzz words that are included for in these manifestos. You can also compare the same ideas of the different parties like how they have put it on paper at least.

Bro its really interesting knowing the manifesto's, continue❤

I personally feel that Sindh could be used as "brand of governance" for PPP but unfortunately party has not delivered in past 3 consecutive tenures as they could or should. They have neglected urban sindh , out of political or ethnic rivalry or what i am not sure. The way party has snatched the Karachi's local government from JI is totally undemocratic and is a dark stain on party's face. Thanks for imparting in inculcating the true political wisdom in our minds. Anyway, good work Boy ❤👍

Keep going !!!

Amazing content!!!

I guess elections se pehly Jamaat e Islami k bhi ek episode honi chahye. I m personally curious, it seems to be a better party but i don't have much insight about it. So plz JIka manifesto bhi pta hona chahye hume.

@fatimashahid9321

4 ай бұрын

same i am also curious

Such a good content! 👏🏻 Thank you for this. But the time doesn't matter as long as your talks are engaging. So you could go a little deeper (especially in energy and climate change portion).

It's a good series and I'd request you to continue this series and even put more focus in it than the Podcasts and guests stuff. But yeah since you started with a very difficult task so seems like you still need lot lot of improvements in this. Whenever we're to present ideas of a someone we may not agree with, we should learn the art of simluating a completely new role while presenting it, if they watch your video, they should admit that no one would be able to better present our manifesto, I'd highly recommend you to go through some of the series of Allama Javed Ahmed Ghamidi where he takes dedicated time to just present the narrative of his opponents with whom he doesn't agree, but he does it so well that they admit that it could'nt have been better.

Great job bro! most of us were always interested to here your oppinion also other than the guest's