Content: 0:20 Introduction to IE and Armenian language 0:56 Origin of the Armenian hypothesis 3:31 Russel Gray on ZDF documentary 6:13 David Reich on the origin of IE 8:55 Armenian-like genetics in the Steppe 10:50 Armenian DNA 13:17 Lack of Steppe ancestry in Anatolia and Asia 15:09 Armenian Plateau the missing link 16:58 The Caucassian barrier 20:57 Genetics correspond with geography 22:44 Summary and conclusion 25:23 Closing remarks

@ancientruins2856

3 жыл бұрын

PeopleofAr - I think you need to further study this topic before you make these claims as it has been debunked long time ago. Aryan migration theory is one where old colonial powers devised this theory to divide and conquer INDIA. SANSKRITH and Ancient TAMIL languages are mother of all european languages which come from INDIA. There is nothing that come from central asia or Armenia in terms of languages and people's as new DNA and linguistics study shows where it is quite the opposite.

@PeopleOfAr

3 жыл бұрын

@@ancientruins2856 Well I've presented more than enough evidence for the Armenian Hypothesis. If you disagree I suggest you do the same and present your evidence from renown scientific journals. Let's not resort to conspiratorial accusations.

@MitchBuchannon777

3 жыл бұрын

Ylli hyri/ylli hyni=ILLYRIANS REAL DORIANS/EPIRIOTES REAL HELLENES The Greek philosopher Aristotle names ancient Hellas as an area in Epirus between Dodona and the Achelous river, the location of the Great Deluge of Deucalion, a land occupied by the Selloi and the Epirotes who later came to be known as "Hellenes". In the Homeric tradition, the Selloi were the priests of Dodonian Zeus. Ptolemy calls Epirus Hellas primordial . Therefore, the probability that the Selloi were a tribe from Epirus, which later emigrated south to Thessaly and adopted the name of Hellenes as their own, may be valid. Panhellenes and Hellenes both appear only once in the Iliad; Homer refers to the "Hellenes" (/ˈhɛliːnz/) as a relatively small tribe settled in Thessalick Phthia, with its warriors under the command of Achilleus. It seems that Hellas (Eλλάς) was the land of the Hellenes, another name of the Myrmidons. Homer describes Achilles praying to Zeus Dodonian as the primeval god: "King Zeus, wept, lord of Dodona, god of the Pelasgians, who dwell far away, you who hold the agghiaciata Dodona under your influence, where your prophets the Selli dwell around to you with their unwashed feet and their clothes made of earth. " Aristotle argues that the Selli (Σελλοί), the priests of Dodona in Epirus, may have chosen their name, from Elle, another name of the Goddess. It also reports that an ancient cataclysm destroyed "ancient Hellas, between Dodona and the Acheloo River. ILLIRIANS WAS NORTH ALBANIA HELLENES TRIBES WERE ILLIRIANS EPIRIOTES AND THRACIAN Multiple artefacts from the Iron and Bronze Ages near tumulus burials have been unearthed in central and southern Albania, which has similar affinity with the sites in southwestern Macedonia and Lefkada. Archaeologists have come to the conclusion that these regions were inhabited from the middle of the third millennium BC by Indo-European people who spoke a Proto-Greek(Proto-Albanian) language. Hence, a part of this historical population later moved to Mycenae around 1600 BC and properly established the Mycenaean civilisation The Epirotes, who speak a Northwestern Greek dialect, different from the Doric of the Greek colonies on the Ionian islands, and bearers of mostly Greek names, as evidenced by the epigraphy, seem to have been looked upon with some contempt by some classical writers. The 5th century BC Athenian historian Thucydides describes them as "barbarians" in his History of the Peloponnesian War, as does Strabo in his Geography. Dorians did contribute to the culture of Greece in drama, poetry, sculpture, and especially in the huge stone buildings that marked the beginning of the Doric style of architecture. (The Columbia Electronic Encyclopedia, 6th ed.) DORIANS WERE ILLYRIANS The awareness that the four tribal groups recognized as "Hellenic" (ions, Aeolians, Achaeans and Dorians) came from a still barbaric north, also had an influence on the northern peoples, inhabitants of Epirus and Macedonia. The Dorians themselves apparently were not Hellenic, but made Doro, their ancestor, a direct son of Hellenus, in order to be called brothers of their predecessors. In other legends Doro is instead Hellenic of the second generation, son, that is, of Xuto, the second son of Hellenus or another theory says that the Dorians were the sons of Heracles. They were diverse in way of life and social organization, varying from the populous trade center of the city of Corinth, known for its ornate style in art and architecture, to the isolationist, military state of Sparta. And yet, all Hellenes knew which localities were Dorian, and which were not. Dorian states at war could more likely, but not always, count on the assistance of other Dorian states. Dorians were distinguished by the Doric Greek dialect and by characteristic social and historical traditions. Édouard Will concludes that there was no true ethnic component in fifth-century Greek culture, in spite of anti-Dorian elements in Athenian propaganda. In modern scholarship, the term has often meant the location of the population disseminating the Doric Greek dialect within a hypothetical Proto-Greek(Albanian/illyrian) A minor, and perhaps regrettably forgotten, episode in the history of scholarship was the attempt to emphasize the etymology of Doron(Dor/Dora=Hand in Albanian) with the meaning of 'hand'. This in turn was connected to an interpretation of the famous lambda on Spartan shields, which was to rather stand for a hand with outstanding thumb than the initial letter of Lacedaimon. Dorian social structure was characterized by a communal social structure and separation of the sexes. The lives of "free men" centered around military campaigns. When not abroad, men stayed in all-male residences focusing on military training until the age of 30, regardless of marital status. Dorian women had greater freedom and economic power than women of other Greek ethnicities. Unlike other Hellenic women, Dorian women were able to own property, manage their husbands' estate, and delegate many domestic tasks to slaves. Women in ancient Sparta possessed the greatest agency and economic power, likely due to the prolonged absences of men during military campaigns. ILLYRIANS HELLENS AND THRACIANS ARE INDOEUROPEAN(ARIANS)WARIORS RULED BY THE THUNDER GOD THOR/ZEUS/INDRA/TESHUB(PERKUN in the Albanian language it means to shake and here the Indo-European peoples had a god of lightning who was called in Lithuanian Perkūnas; in Latvian: Pērkons; in Prussian: Perkūns or Perkunos; in Jatvitic: Parkuns and the Slavs adopted phonetics and called it Perun.) ECC EVEN THE ACHEANS BUT ABSOLUTELY NOT THE DENYEN THAT WERE FROM LIBIA... PELASGIANS WERE PEOPLE OF SUMER THAT COME IN BALKAN CARRYNG THE DOUBLE-HEADED EAGLE SYMBOL THAT APPEARS IN THE REPRESENTATIONS OF THE GOD ENKI... THE MINOANS WERE PEOPLE OF THE SEA AND THEIRS GOD WAS POSEIDON AND WHEN THE PEOPLE OF ZEUS COMES FROM NORTH HIS DOUGTHER ATHENA CHALLENGING UNCLE FOR CONTROL OF ATHENS AND WON SOVEREIGNTY OVER THE CITY THAT TAKEN HIS NAME...

@MitchBuchannon777

3 жыл бұрын

@@ancientruins2856 INDIANS WERE AFRO BEFORE THE COMING OF THUNDER GOD INDRA/THOR/ZEUS/MARDUK/YAHWEH/THE LORD ADONAI SABAOTH(GOD OF THE HOSTS/ARMY)HE IS THE GOD OF THE WHITE PEOPLE...

@ancientruins2856

3 жыл бұрын

@@MitchBuchannon777 - Well, it is an interesting thought but not true my friend. Learn

Love Georgian, Armenian and Persian history. Cheers from Sweden

@VerbalWarrior162

7 ай бұрын

Maykop origins were on the Iranian Plateau. "Iranic" as a general geographic-linguistic term for peoples who inhabited the Iranian plateau. They are the pre-Europeans, The influx of people from Iran on to the Steppe from around 7000ya led to the formation of the Yamnaya culture.

@VickyLouise-uj7wt

13 күн бұрын

@@VerbalWarrior162inan Armenian Swedish

As a romanian I am happy to know about this video. Our ancestors the Dacians had connection with Armenia.

Thank you for the video. I am an American of mostly Anglo origin and roots. The Indo-European homeland has been a topic that has consumed my time for many, many years. Several years ago I began to put the pieces together that it HAD to have originated in Armenia. It is good to see that others have drawn the same conclusion.

@ArchYeomans

3 жыл бұрын

I believe there is a history of the Britons document that mentions Armenia as the ancient homeland. Some say it was Armorica (Brittany) but I think the authors of the time knew the difference between Armorica and Armenia.

@BOSS-qr8hl

3 жыл бұрын

@@ArchYeomans research the Anglo Saxon manuscript, second sentence. "the first inhabitants of england were the armenians" i think its in a museum in england.

@karlmarx1730

3 жыл бұрын

Dude anglos and armenians are not related 😂 the first one is just another germanic tribe

@karlmarx1730

3 жыл бұрын

@@BOSS-qr8hl so how can one be armenian and anglo together? Unless you are a mixed person

@BOSS-qr8hl

3 жыл бұрын

@@karlmarx1730 I don't know what ur talking about what I'm saying is the celts where there before the anglo saxons and the celts are originally from Anatolia if u do ur research, hence the anglo saxon manuscript go read it. Trust me no Celt wants to be mixed with German

VERY interesting! Makes me an even prouder Armenian! (Also, as a sideline, I'm fascinated regarding the bizarre correlation between the Basque language and the Armenian language, since there is around 600 words that are identical in both languages. Super interesting!! You can find an outstanding presentation of this on KZread, as well.) Thank you for a delightful presentation!! I'll forward it to all my friends and family.

@dad9979

2 жыл бұрын

Armenians might also have a connection to the Anatolian farmers who migrated into Europe and gave rise to Pre Indo European groups such as the Basque so that's something

@Judge_Magister

2 жыл бұрын

The Basques are not Indo Europeans though, probably Atlantians.

@dropanukeonusaagain6606

Жыл бұрын

"Makes me an even prouder Armenian!" it is very typical for blacks to pride themselves on fictions and lies

@roland1901

Жыл бұрын

Why are you proud you didn't do anything you just can claim lineage to Great people, but are you realy one of them? Most of us live in foreign lands because we are no able to maintain our borders or have stable government:signs of Civilized society, can you be proud of 1.5 million people matching to death and refuing to unite under one rule and fight back? Can you be proud of submitting to likes of stalin and ussr? Can you be proud of today's Armenia? I admire the Armenians but I highly doubt I carry anything more the just some of thier genetic makeup and I can attest to 400year of only Armenians in my family tree

@150gal

5 ай бұрын

@@Judge_Magister The Basques have 600 Armenian words in their language via the ancient indigenous Hurrians of Asia Minor who originally were not Indo European. The Armenians are an amalgamation of 7 tribes of which two of them were not Indo European. This happened many thousands of years ago. The beginning of these people started 10,000 years ago. At least that's what I learnt in the ancient history books where the West have no clue of their early settlers. For example the early settlers of Devon England were Armenians who arrived in search of ore on the Dartmoor area and they settled in Armenton (today's Ermington) on Arme river which today people call it the Erme. This was recorded by the Saxon monks in 1100 - The Anglo-Saxon Chronicles says that the Britons who inhabited the Land before the Anglo-Saxon Invasion came from Armenia.

Thank you for this. The Armenian hypothesis has been lurking in the shadows for far too long. Needs to be taken more seriously. Please continue this great work and keep making videos like this to spread this critical information!

@badgerfaninnj

7 ай бұрын

Armenians have powerful enemies who do all they can with their billions and influence to deny Armenian history.

This actually makes so much more sense to me from all of the genetic studies I’ve read. Everything historical seems to line up with the genetic story.

Beautiful and interesting video, all Indo-Europeans owe respect and support to Armenia, where our ancestors came from! Sorry for letting you down in your war for Artsakh, hopefully you will get it back soon! Greetings from Russia dear friends and stay strong! 🇷🇺❤️🇦🇲

@JRNarian

2 жыл бұрын

you are so kind, we thank you :)

@iSyriux

Жыл бұрын

Artsakh is Armenian land

@ministr2302

Жыл бұрын

@@JRNarian Armenia deserves all the love and compassion. I am delighted to have you as neighbours and friends, considering what you’ve all been through the years. Being the very first Christian country in the world is a great honour but with a great price too, paid with losses and hardships. Stay strong and stick with the Christian virtues dear friends! 🇷🇺☦️🇦🇲

@roenin

Жыл бұрын

@@ministr2302 it's thanks to Tsarist Russia that they were expelled from Anatolia. Don't forget about the invasion of Russia into Ottoman lands including Crimea. We Turks certainly won't forget it. And Karabakh was and will always be Azerbaijan. You lost in Ukraine and soon you will lose in Crimea, Caucasus, Tataristan and many many more.

@armenkazaryan7181

11 ай бұрын

☀️🦅🏛☦️🇦🇲❤️🇷🇺☦️🏛🦅☀️

Love from Iran to Armenia❤🇮🇷🇦🇲

@smbatharutyunyan5915

10 ай бұрын

Thank you. Greetings from Armenia.

@jackwhitestripe7342

10 ай бұрын

@@smbatharutyunyan5915 and greeting back from iran to armenia

@Tamara-nn1wr

4 ай бұрын

Iranians and Armenians have been neighbours for thousands of years

Nice job! Thank you! As you are no doubt aware, Robert Drews in his excellent 1988 book, "The Coming of the Greeks," makes a strong argument in favor of your hypothesis. I look forward to seeing more of your productions.

Thank you i am Armenian and i have always known about it . but i would like the world to know as well good job . ❤❤ ❤Menk kich enk sakayan ,mez Hay en asum

Welll done, man, keep on shooting videos. Your English is rather good.

Informative, concise and extremely fascinating. I look forward to many more videos from you. Keep up the great work.

@anlergun6918

3 жыл бұрын

Very complicated but very good. Have to watch again.

great stuff brother! yes please make more, like you said it's about time!! this topic, that topic, all the topics they are taking from us!

Now 2023, the evidence keeps piling on for the South Caucasus (Armenia/NW Iran/ Eastern Turkey) hypothesis. Max Plank and Harvard, independently support it through linguistics and ancient DNA sampling. Kudos to Gamkrelidze & Ivanov.. 1990!!!

Incredible work, expertly put together, as the usual with your content. Many thanks brother.

Very interesting indeed , I have always tried to correct researchers when they refer to Anatolia as " Turkey " ,considering the fact that Turks began to enter Anatolia 800 years ago , and ethnic Turks originally from Altai region in Mongolia ( not the same as Turkic speaking ) have no roots in Anatolia .

@Tamara-nn1wr

4 ай бұрын

Turkiye's history began from 1453 AD by Ottomans. Turkiye celebrated its 569th Anniversary in May 2022. I had the same discussion with someone who had a clip on Turkiye and he kept talking of Anatolia. I asked him to look at an old real map of the world, not one with falsified/changed names. Seljuke Turks and Mongols started moving West in 11-12 centuries AD.

A video like this was needed. Waiting for more.

Thank you! Well done. I’m going to share this:) all the best to you 😎

Great work! very informative and compelling! Thanks you PeopleOfAr…your work is indispensable! Շնորհակալություն!

Amazing videos keep up the great work thank you so much I loved it

Very well done, I enjoyed the work you did. This is a hotly debated topic, and has been for 200 years. I am glad we finally have new evidence, genetic dna to shed more light on the problem. Though I would add, the problem is still not solved and there is not overwhelming evidence yet.

this kind of videos need subtitle translation in as many languages as possibly. Great Job!

This was excellent thank you for creating it! Your English is very good. Please make more on these ancient topics.

Nice presentation, well done! Armenia forever!

Very well done video! Your English is spot on.

Thank you for sharing this.

Very interesting. You're doing fine! Keep up the good work!)

@ancientruins2856

3 жыл бұрын

This video maker need to know the actual history. as most is false. Shame

@cinsifrit9860

3 жыл бұрын

@@ancientruins2856 what's wrong ?

@ancientruins2856

3 жыл бұрын

@@cinsifrit9860 - Well this video forgets to state properly the actual origins of languages or indo-??? whatever the colonists called it as it is false on many levels. Armenian in ancient times were mentioned in Ancient scriptures of INDIA and AFRICA which gets dismissed due to white supermisist ideology of late. The direction shown in this video is very wrong as it doesn't take in account of the more ancient languages that travelled to Central Asia and towards so called europe as it was different in ancient times. Ancient Indian & African civilizations gave birth to most of the languages we speak today. African Bantu scripts, etc and Indian Sanskrit, Tamil, etc are the ones we should research more on. Latin and Greek are from acient India and i could go on and on but this is a fact. Learn MAHABHARATA, RAMAYANA and Vedas, Puranns, Ithihaasa, from Ancient India where it shall open many eyes.

@cinsifrit9860

3 жыл бұрын

@@ancientruins2856 that's false.

Great info. And the video is done well too. Thanks.

Great work - this Armenian history is wonderful.

Great job and very interesting video.

Apres Axpers. Great video, our people need this specific type of information in order for regeneration to take place

An excellent, well-presented and well-explained video. Thanks.

Your English is perfect! Keep up the work!!!

A great video of information and history ,thank you.

Thankyou for sharing this information ❤

thank you fascinating unravelling 😍

Wonderful interesting video thank you! I love Armenia and all the Indoeuropeans. ✌️✌️

this is all very interesting and mystical made more so by the great use of the music clips in the background - but it only makes me want to be living in such a time that is being discussed will there ever be a time when I will be able to actually go back in time to such and period of time that is discussed and actually experience that which you are talking about this present an even greater need for a time machine -

Great Great work!!!! I salute you!

hi, thanks for the video. could you please tell me what's the music in the background?

I love Armenia and this was very informing, I am half Yamnaya and half First farmer, maybe I have some Armenian related blood ;)

Appreciate it , thanks for this interesting video 🇦🇲

Excellent and valuable information! God bless you !

Great presentation

One of the reasons I belive Indo-European are from Armenia is the name Van which most people have this name. The only place out side of Europe you can find this name is Armenia (lake Van), so I thing people from Asia Miner from area of Van lake migrated to Europe and North and South also East of Asia.

@hayots_lernashkharh

3 жыл бұрын

Even a lot of Western Europeans who have the r1b haplogroup mustve gotten that haplogroup from the Armenians. I believe they at some point moved out of Armenia into Europe.

@robertolang9684

9 ай бұрын

@@hayots_lernashkharh iberians are the today people that , match the armenians and the georgions , it is no bulshit and the geneticist knows it but , the nationalistic aryan narratives do not suits them so ya armenians georgians are the aryan that iran is part of THE CAUCASOID PEOPLE THE ARYAN PEOPLE FROM CAUCASUS ZAGROS MOUNTAINS

well done brother

@ArchYeomans

3 жыл бұрын

I like how there are references to scientific papers. That is vastly important.

Thank you for great work please keep making more God bless you Շնորհակալեմ

Thank you for this information

Armenos is mentioned by Strabo in ( C 503, 10.15 ) as part of the Argonauts and companion of Jason . He writes that Armenos comes from a city called Armenio between Feres and Larissa.

FANTASTIC video. this should be a model for how to do these types of videos on KZread! Possibly college

Good stuff yekhpayr.

I havent found this video UNTIL it came on my feed. SPREAD armenian history n truths

Good job, thank you 🎉

Definitely more videos!

Fantastic program 👏 👏👏👏👍👍👍

Very interesting video, I haven't read much into the Armenian hypothesis before.

beautifully made video. It makes sense. But i am missing the India/Sanskrit connection in this video. Is the migration passing throught the Pontic steppe? Or directly via Iran?

@qoujz8113

Ай бұрын

R1A is the indo aryan haplogroup, same as Balto-Slavic. make of that what you will

Not too unlike Armenian, I've heard that the Albanian language is also very distinct and has roots that are close to the original PIE origins.

Great video my friend. Like!

The author, please, can make this video with a Russian translation, so that the Russian-speaking world knows more about this.👍

@PeopleOfAr

3 жыл бұрын

Unfortunately I can't. Someone else should copy this video and add subtitles or send me the translated subtitles to add in this video.

I'm an Iranian :) Sending love to all of my cousins & brothers & sisters all around the world who are my kin ;)) Interestingly enough some evidences & proofs including a cave were recently found in Iran where there are pictures & paintings of Animals, Humans, & human soldiers in armors with weapons who were being led by a commander/king on chariot ! ( *the paintings & pictures are estimated to be 9000 years old !!! & indicate to the existence of a major civilization in Iran, possibly an empire, which even predates the Median empire of Iran which was thought by most to be the first empire in Iran !!! Ofcourse neither the Median empire nor this older possible empire were worldwide superpowers like the Achaemenid empire of Iran in 600 B.C.E but still even the existence of an advanced civilization 9000 years ago is mindblowing* ) Also the zagros mountains of Iran & the highlands of Armenia have always been a perfect barrier to stop the invading forces from affecting the people who were settling in the south of the caucuses, & south of the Caspian sea in north of Iran ! ( *so that's probably why the gene pool of the Iranians & the Armenians are mostly intact* ) Although it's still a mystery to me where are we as Indo-Europeans ourselves are originated from ? ( *I mean, we did not just pop up in North of Iran & Armenia out of nowhere ! Right* ? ) Is it possible that the proto-Indo-Europeans themselves migrated to the north of Iran & Armenia through the Iranian plateau & Mesopotamia & Egypt from Ethiopia where it is considered to be the original place where the human population as a whole race (branching into Indo-Europeans, Altaics & Semetics & etc.) began to travel & migrate ??? *because the proto-Indo-European hypothesis itself must be somehow connected to the whole human race evolution & migration hypothesis which states that the human race originally started to evolve & migrate in Africa* These are extremely interesting aren't they ? Knowing your roots is always fascinating !

@06:00 Noah's Ark is said to have to come to rest on the Mountains of Ararat. Although technically located within modern Turkey, I think the Ararat Mountain Range is closer to what is now the Caucasus and modern Armenia and it is said that Noah's son, Japheth and his descendants, the Japhethites, settled and eventually spread out from the Caucasus Region while his brothers Shem and Ham went on to populate the regions that correspond to what is now the Middle East and north & east Africa respectfully.

@redneckdruid7185

3 жыл бұрын

Mount Ararat is a part of ancient Armenia. The Turkman tribes are a southern branch of Mongol/Hunnic people who overran Armenian and Byzantine territory in the middle ages. Their most recent encroachment took place about two months ago.

@varduhibaloyan3989

Жыл бұрын

5th century historian Moses of Chorene describes Hayk as a descendant of Noah through the latter's son Japheth: "Yapheth begat Gamer [Gomer]; Gamer begat T‘iras; T‘iras begat T‘orgom [Togarmah]; T‘orgom begat Hayk."[9] Hayk's descendants through his son Aramaneak (Aramanyak) are listed as follows: "Aramaneak begat Aramayis; Aramayis begat Amasya; Amasya begat Gełam [Gegham]; Gełam begat Harmay [Harma]; Harmay begat Aram; Aram begat Ara the Handsome."[9] Hayk's other sons, according to Moses, were Khoṛ and Manavaz....

@huaweip8178

6 ай бұрын

myth mythology this is not real

Бесконечно рада ,что нашла Вас!

Very interesting, so what would you say is the next step in furthering this hypothesis?

@ArthaxtaDaVince777

2 жыл бұрын

Proving that Urartian is in fact Indo-European. Urartologists are already at it, the current progress is very convincing. But we need to make in mainstream. Our haters are still trying to discredit Armenia's connection to Urartu.

Extremely thorough and knowledgeable!

Save Armenia. Save Atsakh (Nagorno Karabakh) the armenian people are substantially threatened in their ancestral origins.

@VickyLouise-uj7wt

13 күн бұрын

I have this on my Facebook

Much love bro

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! MERCI BEAUCOUP !!!!!!!!!!!!!!! c'est génial !

Love this

Very well done. But now I am wondering. Was it not also proven that there was a first neolithic wave to europe. And for example the sardinians are genetic proof for it. Maybe the Armenien Hypothese needs to be merged with first wave anatolien hypotheses?

@HorukAI

2 жыл бұрын

You have at least 2 to 3 thousand years of difference. Also it is known that pre-IE population of old Europe were not speakers of IE.

@robertolang9684

9 ай бұрын

@@HorukAI WERE PROTO INDO EUROPEAN DO kzread.info/dash/bejne/jHiVprSPisisf6g.html

@robertolang9684

9 ай бұрын

@@HorukAI THERE IS PLENTY OF TRUE THAT GLOBALISTS WANNA HIDE

I found this video very interesting. My DNA has been tested years ago and the Caucasus region was part of my genetic past. Now I have a little more insight concerning my heritage. Thank you.

The Vendidad. in Avestan Persian reads that the leader Yama and the people were in a region where the sun rose and set once a year. That can be only in the Polar region. Further evidence is found in the Rig Veda. All of this was used by B G Tilak in The Arctic Home of the Vedas. The Kalasha population in Chitral Valley show DNA of Siberian paleolithic 20K yrs and speak an Indo Aryan language. How can we reconcile all this with the info in your clip? Many Thanks for your work and the work of others in the clip!

The Genetics of the Kalasha was found on Google. The study was done by specialists.

Perhaps... I have a question though: many Iranic languages were and are spoken North of the Caucasus mountains. Did they migrate south into Iran and then north again? Or north and then south again? What’s the archeology say?

@bondex392

Ай бұрын

They came to iran through central asia

❗️Ruseren el petq e anel ays videon ev haeren. 👍

R1b was at home everywhere on the Eurasian steppe. Eastern Hunter Gatherer lived in Asia from way back - haplogroup R0 is even ancestral to the American Indians. The genetic element from "Caucasus hunterer gatherers" was relativesly small. Also, proto-Indo-European had a substantial element of URALIC loan words.

@Chiefofpretania

2 жыл бұрын

I don’t think it was the fact PIE had elements of Uralic in it, but I think Uralic and Indo Europeans came from the same source. Research the Indo Uralic and the eurasiatic language theory, it really sheds light on the language continuity hypothesis as I believe that Ancient North eurasians fathered the proto Indo European, Uralic and Altaic languages. Proto Indo European and Uralic are the closest related as they both can be traced back to the steppe and western Siberia areas and they also derive from genetic peoples who directly descended from the ancient north eurasians.

@borisgodunov6

Жыл бұрын

The genetic element of Caucasus hunter gatherers were even more than the genetic element of Eastern european hunter gatherers. I can send you many facts and sources with the latest researches )))

Love it, thanks for the video, we need more like this 🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲

Makes perfect sense!

Around 22:02 is a great overlay / animatic

Yes more videos

It's refreshing to hear something that is not steppe, that accounts for a broader range of haplo groups

Are you saying the hitties are not related to the yamnaya? Also what are the pre-Christian religions in Armenia?

This was very interesting and scientifically studied background on the Armenian highland the spread of Armenian language to other areas of Indo-European people and the languages which has its origins within Armenian languages being spread from the Armenian plateau.

There is another reason, not mentioned in the video, that the Caucasus Mountains did not pose an impassable barrier to ancient people in the area. Certainly, the people of 5,000 years ago had boats, right? I see no reason to believe that people could not have migrated up and down the coasts of the Black and Caspian Seas by boat, going around the eastern and western ends of the Caucasus range.

@omega2469

3 жыл бұрын

Actually even without boats people could of had moved through the west shores of current time Georgia, or the Western shores of the Caspien sea,,, After all mountains have never benn a barrier,,, Europeans crossed the Pirenees or the Alpes anyway,,,

@levonparian6863

10 ай бұрын

I found it interesting that the Gaelic name for boat is "navag" the same as in Armenian.

I find this theory very convincing. It has been known for a long time, that the Yamnaya are a mixture of Caucasian and Eastern European Hunter Gatherers. The big question is, what languages they all spoke. My guess is, PIE is actually some varient or perhaps a mixture of a N-Caucasian language, very distantly related to Chechen.

@Laotzu.Goldbug

2 жыл бұрын

This is objectively untrue. Souther Caucasian admixture in Yamnaya populations is extreme minority to negligible: *"In addition, the Maykop (and other contemporary Caucasus samples), along with CHG, had significant Anatolian Farmer ancestry "which had spread into the Caucasus from the west after about 5000 BC", but is little detected in the Yamnaya. Partly for these reasons, Anthony concludes that Bronze Age Caucasus groups such as the Maykop "played only a minor role, if any, in the formation of Yamnaya ancestry." According to Anthony, this, the absence of evidence of significant admixture (including of paternal genetic influence, often associated with language shift) from the south on the Yamnaya suggests that the roots of Proto-Indo-European (archaic or proto-proto-Indo-European) were mainly in the steppe rather than the south."* - _Dispersals and Diversification: Linguistic and Archaeological Perspectives on the Early Stages of Indo-European_ | ISBN 9789004416192

@ArthaxtaDaVince777

2 жыл бұрын

Hurro-Urartian, the supposed isolated language family.

@borisgodunov6

Жыл бұрын

@@Laotzu.Goldbug Caucasus hunter gatherers came in the north from today's Georgia. Georgia is the only native country in southern caucasus. Azerbaijanis are turkic people. Armenians are middle easterner migrants in Caucasus. BTW Georgians have the highest CHG admixture even today, even thou there was admixture with Anatolian neolithic farmers. Even Maykop is created by people who went in the north from Georgia(Imereti region you can literally see it in wikipedia) but they had high anatolian admixture.

@musichd8422

Жыл бұрын

@@borisgodunov6 whT,Armenian Highlands is its own penisiula older tha both Caucasus and middle east,was fully Armenian Populated in 4000BC,which ferytale are you making,or can people whith blue eyes and blonde hair be came from middle east lol

@huaweip8178

6 ай бұрын

@@musichd8422 A mixture of Armenian, Anatolian and Middle Eastern. whether you accept it or not

Shnorhagaludyun

Unfortunately, there is no archeological evidence of typically indo-european paternal lineages in transcaucasia or the armenian plateau that precede the bronze age ponto-caspian steppe expansion (which is associated with the spread of the IE languages and that a good chunk of armenians does have). Those lineages themselves come from the eastern eurasian hunter-gatherer populations. Tl;dr : the steppe is the ultimate origin

@Tamara-nn1wr

4 ай бұрын

Armenians call Armenia Hayastan and Armenians Hay. Even Hittites, before Armenian Kingdom of Erebuni, mentioned Hayasa. It is sad that Armenian history, being the 4th oldest country, was pushed aside for self serving political reasons by some countries. Iran is the oldest country, Egypt is 2nd oldest country, Vietnam is 3rd oldest country.

Many PIE origin hypothesis seem to ignore the impact of changes in climate during this period and the corresponding changes in vegetation and animals. The end of the ice age and the expansion of isolated populations from some refuges could bring a new light on the movement of groups. Remember that the oldest animal husbandry was with reindeer. The conversion to cattle, sheep and horses would have been natural with the changing ecology.

Thank you for great video. Proud to be an Armenian.

Its amazing that Armenia remain genetically distinct living in a region that is massively central to so much contested territory by so many powerful empires.

İ am a Turk and i also believe that Armenians And Kurds have a deep impact to pie .

@orhanaydemir366

2 жыл бұрын

Nope

@JRNarian

2 жыл бұрын

thank you for not being brainwashed. Ignore any hateful comments you might get from other Turks.

@jackwhitestripe7342

2 жыл бұрын

@@JRNarian what do you think about Kurds? Because all other Armenians hate Kurds.

@JRNarian

2 жыл бұрын

@@jackwhitestripe7342 I don't know any Armenians who do. Especially after Kurds formally apologized for their involvement in the genocide. I've liked every Kurdish person I've met in person.

@tekhayat5995

2 жыл бұрын

@@JRNarian yes, but not all Kurds were included in the genocide, on the contrary, some Kurds were protecting the Armenians and hiding them in their own homes. Only 12 Kurdish tribes participated in the genocide, they participated in the Assyrian genocide. Some Armenians, on the other hand, called themselves Kurds and hid them out of fear of death. Do not include all Kurds in the genocide.

Sorry, but there are many factual errors here. The Yamnayans did not have Armenian-like genetics. They had the type of CHG admixture that was dominant among the Neolithic farmers of Central Zagros. The ancestral component sometimes known as "Gedrosia" due to it's peak in modern Baloch and Brahuis. Modern Armenians score relatively small levels of this compared to other West Asians, and also compared to the Iron Age Armenians of the Yerevan area. The DNA and geography indicate that the Transcaucasus DNA of the Steppe pastoralists came from North Iran rather than the Armenian plateau. There was large-scale Bronze Age migration from the Steppe into South Caucasus. The Bronze and Iron Age samples from Armenia and Urmia region have a very large Steppe admixture that did not exist in older samples. The dominant languages of the Van and Urmia lakes were Hurro-Urartian rather than Indo-European until the arrival of Armenian and Indo-Iranian languages.

good ost!!

Your language is very good

I heard there's some link between proto Illyrian (Albanian, Thracian) and Luwite language. I suspect they come from Anatolian branch of Indo-European. In the case of Greek I don't know but there might be some influence at least with illiyrian and Anatolian languages for sure

@dori25t

3 жыл бұрын

The real helenes are coming from semito-egyptian

@nixter888

2 жыл бұрын

@@dori25t What an ignorant person! Greeks are indigenous and the missing link is the Aegean,and not Armenia or any other place in Asia or Russia...The Greek Pelasgians spread their culture and their language to the test! Enough with the nonsense!

@dori25t

2 жыл бұрын

@@nixter888 non sense is your Dow logic the mythical DNA of greek minoan is j2 group and they come from anatolia

@dori25t

2 жыл бұрын

@Tony Camaj j2 it is not exclusivity of minoan

Kevin Macdonald wrote a book which affirms this thesis.

Can my ancestry tell which and how many languages I speak?

A very good and informative video. The question is now what Survive the Jive has to say about this. Is he going to have to change his name to Survive the Armenia (hehe).

Robert E. Howard was a prolific American fantasy fiction writer of the 1930's. He was an avid ancient history buff and incorporated much of what he read into his "pre-deluvian" sword and sorcery yarns aimed at the teenage boy pulp market of that day. He may have been aware of the Armenian Hypothesis put forth by the earlier of the two scholars you mentioned or he just figured it out on his own. Either way, his Conan the Barbarian was a Cimmerian warlord. Cimmerian is the latin pronunciation of the Greek Kimeroi. Kimer is the Greek cognate of the biblical Hebrew "Gomer and all his bands" who came down from the north and pastured their herds on the grain fields of Phrygia, one of whose kings, Croesus, had the golden touch. The Assyrians eventually pulled it together and ran the Cimmerians across the Dardanelles where Celtic chieftans in the Balkans welcomed them and their large bottle shaped stone furnaces capable of smelting iron ore. This may have initiated the LaTene phase of Celtic culture. Howard's Conan character was a pastiche of many warrior adventures such as Gilgamesh, Cuhulain, Hercules etc. The Sumerian Gilgamesh was a blue eyed foreigner from the northern mountains. Sounds Armenian to me. Well, obviously, your video has stirred up a lot of old memories. (All of which are in desperate need of vigorous fact checking.) I hope the Armenian Hypothesis prevails and consider my sword and shield at your service! I also hope the Armenian people prevail in these perilous times. Hang in there. It ain't over yet.

@ArcanumArcanorum17

2 жыл бұрын

Yes gog and magog and all those people were iranic steppe nomads

@musichd8422

Жыл бұрын

lol how are getting born blonde,blue eyed people in iranic nation🤣

@Tamara-nn1wr

4 ай бұрын

​@@musichd8422- You will be surprised as how many Iranians have green/blue eyes, light brown hair. Presently, Iran is a multi-ethnic/religious country.