This video was SO much fun to make! Would you eat any of these cookies? What other ingredients should I try replacing next???

@BelleOfTheBrawl1

Жыл бұрын

awesome video! maybe try tiktok cookies!!

@_leovaldez

Жыл бұрын

This isn't a a request for ingredients to replace but can you do more vids with Justine ❤❤ love ur vids

@digitaldiary2176

Жыл бұрын

🙂Amazing & Scrumptious Sharing!👍Excellent job!🙂carry on!🙂🔔your friend subscriber & regular visitor of your channel with big like!👍👍Stay happy, healthy, safe & blessed ever! 🙂Good work!🙂Stay connected! ✅🎁🔔👍🙂🙂With best wishes🙂📌HAPPY 2023!🙂💐🕛🌜🎉🎈🎂⛄

@killerllamayt6342

Жыл бұрын

Try replacing sugar

@liberty2380

Жыл бұрын

You should do extracts because that can completely change the taste

It would be really interesting to see a part 2 to this video with some recipe adjustments (wet/dry ratio, temperature, etc) for each flour to maximize their full potential

@Liz-bt2sk

Жыл бұрын

Yes!!! I’d really love to see an adjusted coconut flour recipe! I think I’ll try the oat flour in the meantime! 😊

@maironamakesstuff

Жыл бұрын

I would love to see this too - my mom has celiac and loves to bake, so it's been a struggle for her to find the right replacement flours for some of her favorite recipes since she was diagnosed. Also, for the banana, I'm curious if replacing some of the moisture with an overripe banana would help the flavor? I'm not sure how much tweaking it would take to get the right texture, though.

@Cora_44

Жыл бұрын

@@Liz-bt2skyea it sounds delicious 🤤 😋

@TiannNChong

Жыл бұрын

I was thinking this too - since we already know what goes wrong, part 2 should compliment this by doing each flour justice! (except maybe the cauliflower LOL)

@maironamakesstuff

Жыл бұрын

@@TiannNChong agreed - I'm really curious to see what would be needed to save each cookie because then I could apply those lessons when baking for my mom who has celiac. Though I agree, there's no saving the cauliflower!

As a gluten free person I found this video interesting but almost all gluten free flours on the markets are a mix of GF flours with rice flour as a base so I knew how this was going to go. Love to see a trial comparison of gluten free flours available commercially. Only certain flours work for certain baking applications like cookies vs. breads. I also noticed that arrowroot, sorghum and tiger nut flours were missing, but thank you!

@reepicheepsfriend

Жыл бұрын

yeah I have a feeling sorghum would've done pretty well

@StancyInTheCity

Жыл бұрын

The grittiness of especially the rice flour cookie was because the flour needed to be hydrated. So make the dough and put it in the fridge overnight. That helps with the grittiness

@berlincitylights1972

Жыл бұрын

Very interesting experiment👍🏻 The problem with the gf flours is that you need the characteristics of different flours and starches to emulate gluten. „Baked to perfection“ explains that very well 😊

@katharinaspeelman1623

Жыл бұрын

We used to experiment with all of these same flours until a good gluten free flour came out

@carinakamangoesmael7669

Жыл бұрын

@@victorianokes9043 she made half a batch

I want to see Ro try sugar replacements in her chocolate chip cookies! As for which I'd try, definitely the oat flour like she did as it was the best one.

@eg5395

Жыл бұрын

Yes!!! My husband is sugar free, so this would be a life saver

@MyRamooon

Жыл бұрын

Yes I would love to see replacements for sugar too so I can bake for my diabetic inlaws 🥰

@Jgonc024

Жыл бұрын

yes! same!!

@rosalie.e.morgan

Жыл бұрын

You would need a sugar free chocolate chip as well

@Jgonc024

Жыл бұрын

they have sugar free chocolate chips at trader joe’s

I giggle at the beginning of her trying the cookies and gasping them out she always make me laugh

Great idea for a crossover/collaboration; the franken-cookie (with respect to Safiya Nygaard), where you mix all the flours together to equal the 1:1 ratio, and make a chocolate chip cookie with that.

@eselcool3720

Жыл бұрын

or mix every storebought cookie dough into the frankencookie!

@BookwormBelle1191

Жыл бұрын

Or do both and make a two part collab with Ro and Safiya.

@athenaw670

Жыл бұрын

Or mix the remaining dough together and bake

@AnnaReed42

Жыл бұрын

I think we could allow her to omit the cauliflower one, though, to give it a fighting chance 😂

@ITSNYLAJ

Жыл бұрын

Yess love this

"We made bark cookies everyone, maybe deers will like them!" - Ro 2023 She is starting the year out right. Love you Ro.

Can you do sugar substitutes next?! I'm allergic to cane sugar so I would love to see how cookies change from honey, maple syrup, etc.

@rosalie.e.morgan

Жыл бұрын

Sugar beet sugar is common and extremely close to cane sugar

@maydavalle

Жыл бұрын

Such a good idea👍🏽

@jenniferwellman5311

Жыл бұрын

I’m actually doing keto, and I would love to see recipes that she does, with something I can eat.

@belgianchik

Жыл бұрын

Monk fruit does really well in baking

@ravenclaw2898

Жыл бұрын

@@belgianchik I've heard that but most monkfruit has corn added to it and I'm allergic to corn :(

i absolutely adored this! as someone who has been gluten free for 7 years due to a severe intolerance i’ve tried just about every flour substitute in the book, and some are definitely far better than others. it was so cool to see the side by sides and how to possibly fix the ratios!!! i personally enjoy mixed flours like bob’s red mill that contain several flours, like rice and tapioca, and xantham gum always helps with the texture too!! i would absolutely love to see substitution experiments for other common allergies. there’s so many of us out there dodging food hurdles every day and just trying to make our food taste the best we can. loved this video!!!

I've been gluten free for many years, and there aren't really many single flours that work well as a 1/1 sub for wheat flour. So I'd love to see a video comparing various brands of gluten free flour blends.

I'd love to see a part 2 with some adjustments in the recipes to see if it helps some of the flours work better! Some of them probably can't be saved, but the ones near the top that weren't quite there maybe.

I’m so glad you did this! My dad has celiac’s and is a Cookie Monster! Thank you for showing what each one is like with the different flours

@debprivate7840

Жыл бұрын

Don't use oat flour unless it says that it was made from gluten free oats.

@melhenline8438

Жыл бұрын

Try King Arthur's Gluten Free flour or Namaste Perfect Blend. You will make excellent GF cookies that no one will guess are gluten free. 🙂

@halfofayellowmango2661

Жыл бұрын

King Arthur’s GF baking flour is a perfect substitute!! 1:1 ratio

@kellyerinhannon8288

Жыл бұрын

The love for King Arthur’s here is amazing- I have used that brand a ton and it’s great

@kellyerinhannon8288

Жыл бұрын

@@debprivate7840100% that is so important

I would love to see a video where Ro tries different ratios/ingredients to make the coconut flour work in the cookie. She had so much hope for it that I would like it succeed in some fashion. :)

@faeriesandrainbows

Жыл бұрын

I second this! 😜

@kellyerinhannon8288

Жыл бұрын

Totally I was very interested in that one and I bet it would be amazing with more liquid and xanthan gum but definitely more liquid

This was fascinating! I have a coworker who is gluten free and this gives me ideas for how to include her in baking tries.

@CrownedLily

Жыл бұрын

I've been gluten free for going on 8 years in April. And honestly I use store brand (Shaw's) all-purpose flour and it works just like regular all-purpose flour.

@krysb25

Жыл бұрын

I have a coworker that is gluten free and a different coworker that is vegan. I've had to really experiment with recipes. I've hit on some good ones but I've also had a lot of failures. 😀

@Theanimalfarm077

Жыл бұрын

@@krysb25 As a vegan, we appreciate you just giving it your all! It doesn’t need to be perfect. I have some really great cookie recipes so let me know if you want them (vegan ones, if you wanted them for your co-worker) Also, for eggs, i recommend to use bobs red mill, just make sure you mix it good with the water (measurements on back) to remove any lumps, be sure not to over mix. It will look and taste disgusting but i promise its what many of us use and you cannot tell the difference!

@Theanimalfarm077

Жыл бұрын

And to be clear, i mean it will taste disgusting and look bad before you add the mixture to the cookie. When added its identical!

@hagbau

Жыл бұрын

Pro tip: don’t use just one flour. Ro’s not a gluten-free baker, this is just entertainment not a practical guide.

6:59 can’t belive potato-flour isn’t a thing everywhere 🫣🫣🤭 it’s used for SOOOOO much overhere in Sweden. Not for bakning tho 😂 but for thiccening sauces, jams, marmelades And can even be used as babypowder for raw baby-diaper-butts 🤭🤭 It’s pretty much like corn starch (wich really isn’t that big of a thing here) 🥰

@jeannine1739

Жыл бұрын

We have it here in the US, but predictably, we usually call it potato starch, not flour. It's not as common as corn starch, here. We grow and eat a LOT of corn in various parts of the US! We have corn starch, corn meal, corn grits, corn flour (a very fine grind of the whole corn, not just the starch), and masa harena which is basically ground up dried hominy (lye activated corn), and is used for making tamales, corn tortillas, etc.

@marcilk7534

Жыл бұрын

I have some Scandinavian cookbooks, and I did notice potato flour was used quite a bit. I haven’t tried any of the recipes using it yet.

@maureenfortner5627

Жыл бұрын

Potato starch great to thicken gravy, mix with a little butter or oil before adding liquid.

@kriisi2889

Жыл бұрын

I love to use only potato flour for Swiss roll batter, and it comes out fluffy perfect. Made it once for my friend who has gluten free diet, and now I always use it for Swiss rolls. So it also works for baking, but probably suitable more airy than as dense goods as cookie.

@zannadunstrand6289

Жыл бұрын

@@jeannine1739 get it 🥰 thank you for knowledge! My guess was that you used corn-starch instead of potato-flour (wich is potato-starch) thanks for confirming 🥰

I kinda want to see a coconut cookie! Replacing butter for coconut oil, adding coconut milk, or doing a better ratio of the coconut flour. I feel like it’s the stuff Rosina would also enjoy doing and eating!

Ro: "I'm overdressed as always and ready to bake!" Me on the couch in my pyjamas waiting for her video to come out...

@teresamorgado4558

Жыл бұрын

Me: Underdressed as always and ready to watch!

@maydavalle

Жыл бұрын

🤣🤣🤣

Would love one on egg raplacements!!

@thelifeauthentic

Жыл бұрын

That would be cool! I like to use banana or applesauce for egg replacements. :)

@teresaspurgeon1013

Жыл бұрын

Ground flax seeds or flax seed meal is a great egg replacement. You just add water. Bob's Red Mill has the measurements on the bag.

Loved this video!! Dairy replacements would be cool. They did a whole GBBS episode on that a couple of times ❤️

I love Mike's reaction when Ro throws a cookie at him "I don't want it!" 😂

@eileengalindo4949

Жыл бұрын

Same

@alissatanner2955

Жыл бұрын

I like that reaction too

You look like the embodiment of Christmas. I loved the concept of this video SO MUCH Ro. Perfect content as always. Thanks!

Time Stamps for flours; To start; Regular wheat flour 3:07 Tapioca flour 4:52 Rice flour 6:20 Potato flour 7:50 Buckwheat flour 9:47 Almond flour 11:30 Cauliflower flour 13:40 Coconut flour 15:31 Quinoa flour 16:58 Banana flour 18:07 Chickpea flour 19:10 Oat flour

Loved this video, Ro! I was really hoping cassava flour was going to make an appearance!!! I love its texture when making cupcakes, and I've tried it with cookies, too. Cassava claims to be a 1 to 1 swap, I find it depends on the brand and what you're making.

This needs to be a series ❤ love ya ro

Hi Ro! Love this video! I just wanted to tell you that you inspire me so much and you have helped me through many difficult things. You light up everyone's day and you are an incredible person with a great personality. I love you

Wow I love this idea! I’ve always wondered what different flours would be like, excited to see the results!

Yes! I would love to see more of these baking experiment videos! I love getting to experiment with substitutes when I have the chance!

I would love to see a part 2 where you tweeked each recipe then taste tested them again!!

Yes! More of this! Baking science I wouldn’t have known!

I can't wait to watch this, I love your baking videos! Love you Ro!!

Ever time I see a new upload it makes me so excited thank you ro! ❤

Thanks for the recipes, Ro, cookie baking season is definitely nigh! 🍪😍

I'm thinking that Ro could adjust the coconut and almond flour variations to be right up there with the oat flour 1:1 version, maybe even better (?). I have an almond allergy, so oat and rice would be the 1:1 recipes I would be most interested in trying.

This inspires me to try baking cookies with almond flour or coconut flour (with corresponding recipie tweaks), as your description of the flavour of those sounded really yummy

Ro: Here Mike, I got you something! Mike: I don't want it! Ro: It doesn't even get to be in the line-up I was anticipating Ro getting to talk about this cookie again at the end since she started making it and said it smelled like fish food. Love you Ro! Try dairy next!

You are appreciated Ro ❤

This is awesome to see the differences! I usually use gluten free flour specifically for baking from Walmart and I’ve found great success with it. It’s primarily composed of rice flour.

I Love the Same Cookie Recipe with 12 Different Flours and thank you, Ro 🍪💙😍💕

This was great. Would love to see more of these! Super helpful if baking for crowds with dietary restrictions.

thank you so so so much for this video!!! my mom has celiac and we've struggled a lot w/ baking. we've been hoping you'd do some videos on gluten-free recipes and we all rejoiced when i put this on and you said all of the flours were gluten-free (except for the control of course). we'll definitely have to try oat flour next time we make our chocolate chip cookies. thank you again and i can't wait for the next video 🥰

@jeanleibel7144

Жыл бұрын

Just make sure your oat flour is made from gluten free oats, as many people with coeliac can’t eat oats!

@jayysstar2657

Жыл бұрын

@@jeanleibel7144 True, my friend can't have gluten and I always forget to check so my recent favorite has been chickpea flour, but it can be hard to find. 😅

I love her videos!! They always make my day and are always so entertaining to watch!!! Love y’all so much!!! Hope you have a blessed day!! ❤️💕💞

I love that she loves science and baking and she just mixed them both together to create the best video!!!!!

I love experiments like this. It's so amazing to learn and see the differences and the effects. I hope you do more like this.

how did she scoop each one so perfectly, i love her! x

I was waiting the whoooole time for the oat flour, haha. It's always my go-to for cookies! I think a lot of GF flours have their place, just for different things. Like, cauliflower being last here makes total sense, but cauliflower crust and gnocci is sooo good!

Let's hope 2023's videos will be full of more Justine and Ro vids!🤞🤞🤞🤞❤❤❤❤

I loved this video!! I thought it was so interesting to see the different flours do their magic. I would love to see egg replacements and maybe even butter replacements as well!! (If there are any) Love you Ro! ❤

I am SO impressed, put all the time on researching all those different GF flour options! THANK YOU SO MUCH

Great video, Ro. I think it is so interesting that you experimented with 12 different flours! Must have been a cookie adventure! 🍪 😋 😊

Have you ever thought of making sourdough and incorporating it into baking? I would love to your take on it! Also having this replacement test is amazing and I thank you for doing so, many people cant have regular flour and it's great to know what alternatives can be used for at least your cookies 1v1! Much love from many years of watching ❤

Loved the video, and I believe this series has a lot of potential! I'd love to see how different types of sugar would react, cocoa powder, egg replacements, anything really! Let the science begin 😋

You inspire me rosanna❤

Lol I love the end when she said here Mike got you something and throws the gross cookie at him as he screams I don't want it! I can imagine him trying to run away and dodge it. 🤣😂

LOVE this video and "baking testing"!!!! so cool to learn

Thank you, Ro!! Just saved this video for when I try using a different flour to bake. ♡

This was super helpful, it would great if you could include the brands. Also it would be so helpful if you could do a sugar and dairy replacement videos! Love you videos!❤

I’d love to see replacements for eggs. I think that would be interesting.

This was such a great video. I've always wondered how different flours would work - would definitely try the oat flour and rice flour ones. 💕

That was a great tutorial. Thank you so much for this demonstration.

I would LOVE to see a butter or egg replacement recipe for baking

I immediately clicked on the video when I saw the notification! I love all of your videos!❤❤

omg it was so interesting to watch!! would want to see the different butter, milk and egg replacements!!! ty for such a great video ro! ILY❤

I love this! Very useful/helpful information. Would love to see more like this! Like flour in cakes and brownies and maybe different butters/margarines.

I do ALOT of substitute baking and as soon as I saw this video I said to myself "I hope she tests oat flour and loves it as much as I do." Maybe with your influence oat flour won't be so difficult to find and the prices might come down a bit. Thank you for making this video!

@macuisinesanssulfites4101

Жыл бұрын

Oat flour is nothing more than ground oats. i never buy any. I just use a coffee grinder and make my own.

I love your videos your funny and a very good cooker *edit your makeup is VERY VERY NICE I LOVE IT*

This was so interesting to watch! Thank you for doing this video

How Fun, Thank you for sharing your project with us!

I would def watch a reconfigure episode where you iron out the flower amounts! I have always wanted to use Cricket flower as well if you wanna throw that in the mix :D

Thursday night I made the brownies from my nerdy nummies cookbook! They were soooooo good

@Rosemary_fern

Жыл бұрын

NOO WAYYYYYYYY I GOT A HEART OMGGG

Loved this! I’m gluten intolerant and my husband is lactose intolerant so I’m always loving stuff like this.

You reminded me I had a bag of oatmeal chocolate chip cookies around waiting to be opened! It’s so interesting how each cookie looked so different from one another. Your OG recipe for the win. Loving that lip color on you with your adorable dress btw!

You need to try bob mills gluten free flour! It’s 1 to 1 and it tastes so good! I’ve even made your recipe with it and with plant butter since I can’t have dairy and it’s fantastic!❤

Those cookies look tasty and chocolate chip is my favorite 😋 😍

Adore this video and your energy!! Would love to see the same idea with mini-cakes too ❤❤

Very fun video. As a person with celiac, my favorite baking flour is Bob’s Red Mill 1:1 gluten free flour which is a combination of several gf flours. Great for cookies. Works very well for quick bread recipes that call for oil and some plain Greek yogurt which helps offset the drying, grainy tendencies of gf flours. Thanks for sharing your results!

i dont know why but the "alright im overdressed as always" was really funny 🤣

Is no one going to talk about her makeup and dress IS LIKE SO CUTE ❤️

@sarahgoliszewski381

Жыл бұрын

That dress looks perfect on her! I love it.

@KUROMI56441

Жыл бұрын

@@sarahgoliszewski381 Ikr

I’m so into these baking experiment videos! I’d love to see dairy replacements tried out.

Loved this video! Recently had to start a GF diet due to a celiac’s diagnosis and this video is honestly really helpful as someone who is trying to find replacements to make things I used to love. Thanks for this ❤

I would love to see her do cupcakes but frosting replacements. Cream cheese melted cheese etc.

Ro’s videos never disappoint! I have been baking since I was 7 now I am 15 years old! I love your videos Ro!❤️

OMG this is crazy, you actually randomly popped up in my head a few days ago cause I used to watch and love ur videos when I was a kid, it's been 9 years since the last time i watched one of u're videos, and now u suddenly were in my youtube recommendations, wow this crazy, and I'm very happy to see that you still make ytb videos after all these years, this just made my night

This was a great idea. Over the years I would see people ask about the use of replacements for regular flour and never saw anyone try them all in one video. I saw someone mention sugar replacement in recipes. I've tried doing that once or twice. No matter what you are trying to replace, if you love the original it will not be the same, but if someone has to avoid the ingredient, it's nice to have the best option.

So glad you did this!!!

Ro! I'd love to see you perfect the Coconut Flour cookies. That sounds soooo good! 😋

This video was so much fun! Thank you for doing it for us. I love u.

This is honestly such a cool idea!

Love the idea behind this video Ro! You should continue doing videos like this. Also your outfit is amazing!💚❤️

This has been sooooo helpful for me. Two of my kids have coeliac disease so this is a game changer for both me, and my daughter who loves to bake and loves your channel. We decided to use rice flour today in her red velvet cookies and they've turned out fab, so she's chuffed! Thank you so much, we usually don't have luck with our gluten free cookies. A video on how these flours behave in cake recipes would be amazing.

Please do more of these videos! They’re so interesting!

I really love this❤️❤️ I have had Celiac Disease my whole life and baking is a STRUGGLE because a lot of gluten free flours just don’t work the same in regular recipes

This is sooo helpful!!

You are so funny and great to watch! You have a great personality and you seem authentic.

This video was sooooo useful! thank you!

This is brilliant! I had such high hopes for the almond flower and the cauliflower cuz I think it’s the best pizza crust replace

Thank you for testing the different flours. I didn't know banana or cauliflower flour even existed. I have a gluten free friend in my friend circle, so excited to try oat flour for my holiday cookies this year.

This was great to see. Would love more videos like these. Also will be fun to see you learn why some flours didn’t work (like some “flours” are actually just starches like tapioca) and alternatives to employ (like a pinch of xanthum gum for almond flour to bind in place of gluten).

Love the idea for this video, would love to see more!

I have a gluten sensitivity, so I bake with Gluten Free flours a lot, and I have to say my favorite recipe is Oat Flour, so I am so glad you like oat flour as well!! 💕💕

I was looking for a gluten free cookie recipe and this video delivered and then some. You are a riot! I can’t think of a time I enjoyed myself more watching a baking video! Cheers!