I'm whelmed.

@ImperatorSomnium

Ай бұрын

Same

@zeemilios9327

Ай бұрын

Okay Robin

@Gildorify

Ай бұрын

Perfectly, and utterly whelmed.

I feed needback.

@PyroFrozt

Ай бұрын

I know you don't read this, but sorry to keep you waiting

@evilbob840

Ай бұрын

Do you think you could take care of my needback while I'm out for a few days?

Problem is filtering good feedback vs opinions and I wants.

I can relate so much to the dislike of people not telling each other their critiques or concerns regarding each others work. I work in atomic research and one of our new workers was so bad at electronics building my coworker in charge of her decided to tell her in a professional manner everything she did wrong bc the circuit literally didnt work. She turned around and complained to HR leading to him getting fucking reprimanded bc he explained to her that her circuits literally dont work. I often feel like I struggle to get any better at my job bc literally everyone pretends we are all performing perfectly... Also coworker quit shortly afterward he couldn't take the bs.

Almost sounds like you need a "Bug Report" form for feedback, to cut through the pleasantries! Subject: 'I need feedback' video Bug: Despite being subscribed on my main account, the Karos video didn't show up in my feed Replication Steps: Live overseas so you're asleep during the upload. Suggested Resolution: Periodically ring a bell at us and stare at us menacingly in a video, so we remember to click the stupid bell icon in youtube to *actually* get notifications; saying 'click the bell icon' is so mainstream (too uncool for you) that we'd definitely tune-it-out, out of habit. Additional notes: Hello, hope you're well, love your videos and I appreciate the quality and consideration you (and your team) put in.

someone needs to make a single player game called "I'm Sorry but the MMO" and all the npcs dialog is fully voiced and its just people saying "you will never read this" and lots of pop up boxs saying sorry this content requires you to purchas it but there is no where to buy it from

@asmosisyup2557

Ай бұрын

That could be the sequel to "Pay 2 Win: The game"

@susannebrorby5992

Ай бұрын

They can add a "waiting in queue" feature as well!

@finalfantasu7615

Ай бұрын

would buy

Idk why they're messaging you like that considering your personality until I remember people on Twitter and Reddit. I had a guy sperg out on Twitter because I told a popular game creator, "I wish you luck on your game" and the fan of the guy went FERAL. Like Holy S dude all I did was wish him luck with his project! Or the other guy where I said, "yeah this anime isn't my thing; I don't like this anime and I'm not even 10 minutes in. You do you king." And the guy proceeds to freak out because I wasn't being soft with him. As someone with the tism it's a breath of fresh air to see people like Josh who say, "please be blunt and direct not soft and mushy"

@aimeeinkling

Ай бұрын

What you are describing is the difference between professionals and amateurs. Amateurs will ask for honest feedback and freak out/cry if you give it to them. Professionals know how to take criticism and eagerly seek it out.

@Nikelaos_Khristianos

Ай бұрын

The “tism” 😂😂😂

@soundrogue4472

Ай бұрын

@@Nikelaos_Khristianos Damn straight; my favorite thing to call it. I can never remember how to spell the full thing.

I feel this and I love hearing someone else talk about it too. I do theater and I'd like to improve my acting, but I never get told anything that could help me improve. Not only that, people also don't ever explain what was good about my act, so I start to feel like they're just saying things to be nice. A friend of mine, also an actor, was really thankful to me for actually giving them detailed feedback on a play they were in, since they hadn't got anything else from people other than "yeah it was good".

@AlastairGames

Ай бұрын

yeah it's very challenging to give feedback well, it can be uncomfortable to speak how you really feel about something, though it is good to hear people like Josh encourage people to try. It's a real skill that takes practice I think. And also, sometimes articulating the precise and accurate feedback is hard.

@janeenschultz8502

Ай бұрын

Actually being able to give feedback is also frustrating because people receiving the feedback are usually split between "Wow, that was helpful. Thanks," and, "Wow, why are you so mean to me?" when there is no mean intention at all and they just immediately take offence.

@mandisaw

Ай бұрын

Generally you only get good/bad feedback from people unfamiliar with the actual skillset. Only other skilled people in that field can dig-in and give you more detailed & actionable feedback. Ideally they'd be more experienced than you, but it can be useful to talk to peers as well. It's why most artists have circles, so you can have other artists familiar with the specific challenges articulate what you got right or wrong. If possible, maybe reach out to other actors, both in your same theater troupe and outside of it, to run some scenes & monologues together. Everyone should go into it open to comment & [fair] critique, with the intention of coming out of the exercises stronger in their performance. If there's specific areas you/others want to focus on (e.g. timing), bring that up at the start. Good luck!

The BIG problem with the Karos videos is that you were not pedantic enough. I think there isnt a better example then "Life is Feudal" episode. That is my favorite of the series, and that video has just the perfect ammount of pedantery and humor.

All your video's do still whelm me. So you are doing good. I'm not a big MMO fan, but I love your "Was it any good" series. I love that you also there come in view sometimes, but you let mostly do the game do the talking. Nice balance. Only thing I would do different, is also using the "Contractual Obligation Fullfilled" graphic after ads in those video's

@MrMatsudi

Ай бұрын

I second the thing about the ad graphic lol

@Mickey_Valentine

Ай бұрын

Yes ... I too always am whelmed by Josh's content and i don't even play mmos anymore

I noticed that it was different. The pacing and editing. I really like the "Behold, combat!" phrase, and it was underwhelming in the last one. Everything else was more subtle

@Cryten0

Ай бұрын

Keep in mind that this channel isnt handled or read by Josh.

@aimeeinkling

Ай бұрын

@@Cryten0 Yeah. I have a background in video/television and I have lots of feedback I want to give, but he's not reading this and I can't take time out of my life to attend the streams, in the hopes that he asks for feedback. 😂

wrt the Karos video editing, I think the style is overall clear and acceptable, but I felt like the humor was much less frequent than it typically is, your jocund asides not punctuating the video as much. Having said that, the intro bit about the goblin problem is an A+ framing device, I'm a major fan of deconstructionist stuff like that (though i guess deconstruction is probably not the right term, more like basic media literacy + peeling back ludonarrative dissonance?).

The best characteristic of your stream is that you manage to be both primary monitor content WHILE fulfilling the purpose of the second monitor content eg : Interesting gameplay that captivates my attention & a never ending TED talk alongside it. Its brillant i can't get enough of it. Love from New-Caledonia

in summary, people should be more like "HOT SINGLES IN YOUR AREA" and less like "sorry to bother you mate, hope you're doing great. can i ask you a question?"

Is this a ploy to get me to rewatch the video, Josh? Because it just might work.

Feedback on the Karos vid--the pacing of your script delivery felt a LOT faster than usual, and as a result it felt a lot more like a script read than direct response. I understand that it's always a script read and not an immediate response but there's something about the quality of a slower delivery that both lets the jokes have space to breathe and just feels more "homey", if that makes sense. Also I appreciate your more natural vocal fry and either the mic or the production smoothed a lot of that out and I missed it! The editing overall felt slick apart from the general pacing.

Feedback is why I'm having a surprisingly good time helping my sister resuscitate our family company. I make things for the website or whatever, sometimes I try some new stuff, she tells me exactly which things she likes, which were found likeable in a quick and dirty UX study, which are known to not be good for SEO etc. Sometimes we have a little talk and negotiate a solution. But most of the time it takes literally like 5 words about each thing and we're clear for life on what to do, and what to not do. I will never again work with anyone who can't provide clear feedback. Life's too short.

I am surprised and pleased on your correct use of wherefrom!

1. Be polite. 2. Be efficient. 3. Have a plan

And don't forget guys, always begin e-mails to Josh with a 10 line essay about why you think he looks like Henry Cavill (any e-mails about Robb Stark will be blocked and ignored).

Am I expected to watch the videos instead of just listening to them now? The audacity!

@Biouke

Ай бұрын

Don't you guys have second monitors ?

I listened to it about 3 times in my car, never actually watched it, but listened. I'll have to watch it and give some feedback sometime

I know you never read these, Josh, Hope you're well! Despite the slim chance of this message ever catching your eye amidst the deluge of comments and messages flooding your channel, I couldn't resist taking a moment to express my heartfelt gratitude for the incredible impact you've had on my life through your videos. Your channel has become a sanctuary for me, a haven of positivity and creativity that never fails to brighten even the gloomiest of days. Your unwavering dedication to your craft and your infectious enthusiasm are truly inspiring, and I find myself constantly in awe of your ability to spread joy through your content. Before I delve into the main purpose of this letter, I want to take a moment to commend you for the incredible work you do. Your passion for what you do is palpable, and it's evident that you pour your heart and soul into every video you create. Now, onto the reason I've taken the liberty of reaching out to you today! Have you ever considered exploring the world of classic video games in your content? Specifically, I've been curious to hear your thoughts on one of the most iconic games of all time: Pong. I believe your unique perspective and insightful commentary would add a fascinating new dimension to the discussion surrounding this timeless classic. But I digress! Returning to the matter at hand, I want to express my sincere gratitude for the positive impact you've had on my life and the lives of countless others. Your channel serves as a beacon of light in an often chaotic world, reminding us all of the power of kindness, positivity, and creativity. So, as I bring this letter to a close, please know that your work is deeply appreciated and valued by so many, myself included. Thank you for being such an incredible source of inspiration and joy. Warm regards.

Okay uhh, timestamps for talking points? I feel having a standard link for the BEHOLD, COMBAT of each video would help a lot for actually comparing between games.

Would you prefer the question sectioned off? I have been more of a says viewer and wanted to participate so this half of the message is just me writing effectively the pleasentrys you said youd rather not read and thanking you for content

About apologising for disturbing someone, i don't think it's pertinent to entirely reject it. Sure, if you know you're going to waste someone's time, don't. And if you know you're not, apologising is nonsense. But there are situations where you *might* be disturbing someone for nothing, or not, you're not sure. Or you may be contacting someone whose job isn't to deal with your situation, but there's a problem elsewhere and there's noone else to turn to; in which case, using that formula as a preamble is just caution and politeness, wouldn't you say ?

Hey, Josh. Please consider doing a "Was it Good" for Darksiders 1.

The Discord invite in the description is invalid.

I sneed and feedback

I didn't know you didn't edit it. Very well done.

Now I need to watch this episode

Feeding you back

Love the self fulfilling prophecy and great thinking on how to approach people on feedback. Funny title nonetheless, are you giving feedback or sharing a good advice? P.S. I am not sorry to disturb you.

I agree, skip the preamble and get to the action.

You’re looking for a type of feedback nuanced to: “constructive criticism” 🍻 cheers. And agreed while compliments are nice they are rather ineffective at helping one specifically improve upon a project or video or whichever when seeking feedback on improvement

What about the amble up front, then the preamble politeness at the back end?

I enjoyed the zooming in and out of important bits or the parts that you are mentioning at the moment. Makes it easier to figure out the mass of menus and such, and better underlines your points. I saw the video, youtube even showed me when it will premier, so that all worked well on my end at least (always am looking forward to new videos, but also am not doing that... "Premier viewing" as chat then annoys me rather and youtube struggles to maintain quality. What I did not like... mmmhm, memes are fine when they pop up, but fully red screens are bad (liiike late night watching does not like that!) or loud noises over the usually calmer videos you do (I like your voice, very smoothing, and hearing people slap their forehead loudly fits not at all) So, good video, good editor, smaller flaws.

When are you gonna start a gaming podcast?

On the opposite hand of some other people, I think the visual gags could be longer ... As a second monitor content there should be time to switch focus when they appear 😂

Just had this discussion, I hate when people can't be honest when asking for feedback

Justice for Wakfu!

@sleepalaska

Ай бұрын

justice for wakfu!

@Biouke

Ай бұрын

Justice for Wakfu !

@evilstermegaman

Ай бұрын

Für Fortnite!

in the first 30 seconds of the Karos video, there are 5 different key-framed camera zooms of varying speeds (4 out of 5 i believe were zoom outs). That averages to about 1 zoom every 6 seconds. That makes the video feel somewhat "cheapened" with arguably the worst/most used attention grabbing effect possible.

Any advice for soliciting constructive critique from people?

..... Straight into the Amble !!

the reason why someone starts with the question with "this has probably been asked before but..." is because sometimes streamers react to a frequently asked question by insulting the person or just be annoyed by the question

@bevvvy1374

Ай бұрын

So then make an FAQ banner and put the question in there. Not hard.

I can confirm Josh actually does read comments because once I very jokingly pointed out what could be perceived as contradictory complaints between two different videos that were both years old. (This game would've done better if it didn't do X while other video said this game would've done better if it DID do X) As in if you just took what he said literally it would seem like they were contradictory but they obviously weren't because it's two very different games. But even though these videos were both years old he responded to my comment in less than a day. I feel bad though because he felt the need to defend his point because my teasing sarcasm was taken seriously but I was impressed that such a popular content creator with a LOT on his plate still found time to engage with comments on extremely old videos. Josh is the man.

I love your videos. Your videos are solid. That being said. Have not seen the newest video.

Thoroughly whelmed right now.

I don't use Twitter, so I'll say it here - I think you should've tried to do a bit of russian translation (even through a simple Google translate). Like, I'm russian and I understood what the negative Steam review of Karos, you showed in the video was talking about. But I think when a viewer sees a potentially serious foreign message (like that exact review was) stretched over the monitor, I'd like to know what it's talking about. Especially, if the game has non-english publishers/developers or a prevalence of nonenglish-speaking community. (Offtop, but I'd like to mention that it was very nice of you to tell what kind of feedback you'd like to hear - some content-creators aren't as vocal about it)

@Biouke

Ай бұрын

Nice point, I didn't think about that because most of my interactions with russian players were in DotA and I have a hard time processing that anyone could write anything serious with that language ;p

6:16 “Science-based dragon MMO” _Wow,_ that’s a coincidence (minus the MMO part) 🤯

I didn't have enough real estate on my second monitor to actually watch it, though KZread fed it to me. (I haven't found them very interesting lately because I have this perception that it's all the same old song and dance.) This video was nice though.

Asks for feedback on his video and in turn he provides feedback on how best to message him. Lovely guy. The advice works, too! Did for me, anyways.

The joke at 32:10 'I couldn't have said it better myself' could really have used a zoom in or something, because what you were commenting on was impossible to see with my setup of normal resolution on a phone screen. And by the time I could change things so I could see and get it it wasn't funny anymore.

OMFG I HAVE WANTED JOSH TO PLAY DOFUS OR WAKFU, for so long 😍

I got recommended this video before being recommended the video on the main channel. I hope this info is helpful. I don't have any feedback for the video quality. You'll have to make due with my like.

Damn, streaming sounds like the hardest job in the world!

I think its funny that you think I WATCHED the video. Side glances to the second monitor are the best I can do.

Josh is like what if I stayed in school and pushed my acting and theater skills. Word; I dunno why; but that British touch just adds some grace to his stature

I didn't plan on watching the latest WMMOE (World Wrestling Mysterious Occult Entertainment), mostly because the title covered was an absolute unknown number to me and the thumbnail didn't seem entertaining? After watching it, yeah, the script was good (funny as always) and I've learned something new. I would prefer if you would talk more about what to improve as well, or how you would do it. I don't mean this as a complaint about you complaining, more as a thing of interest in game design. I wouldn't do more clickbaity thumbnails, but I would have used a thumbnail that is more fun? God I am the bad client I always fear to have. Have you tried more thumbnail? Increasing the thumbnail ratio of fun and information? /s What I would have done, is putting the missing translation into the thumbnail, for example. As the thumbnail is now, it us just another female character in a long line of female characters in the front and gameplay in the back. The thumbnail also repeats the information of the title. I would either change the title or the thumbnail to add some more flavour about the episode or let the screenshot speak more of that itself. A character running around with bad graphics is not different from most thumbnails I've seen. It isn't inviting to me, as I did not expect to see or hear anything that is much different from the other bad mmos covered. And it would be more interesting to me, if there is a hint of what this one does differently bad or especially bad and hearing constructive things about these. So, either a hint of the entertaining/funny/joke value of the video (love your humour, but this one could have used more of it), or/and more information...al? value. But being from the less tea drinking and polite version of our shared Germanic root I can't complain about the complaining. I just need a hint it is more than that. Which I know you usually do, but.. YT is full and my list of videos already long. I hope that helps. You can keep that last missing main verb.

I watched it: was a good video, I don't remember many specifics on how it was edited , so nothing too egregious could have been done. Was a comfy video.

Dear Josh Strife Hayes, I know you won't read this, but... Where do I even begin? Your impact on my life, albeit virtual, has been nothing short of profound. From the moment I stumbled upon your corner of the internet, I was captivated. It's as if each video you create is a portal to a realm where passion meets intellect, where curiosity is nurtured, and where storytelling transcends mere narration. As a fervent follower, I've traversed the vast expanse of your content, eagerly absorbing your insights, analyses, and musings on topics ranging from science fiction to philosophy, from gaming to literature. Your ability to weave intricate narratives, coupled with your infectious enthusiasm, has cultivated a community of like-minded individuals who, like me, find solace and inspiration in your digital sanctuary. In a world often plagued by superficiality and fleeting trends, your dedication to authenticity and substance is a beacon of hope, a reminder that genuine connections can be forged through shared interests and genuine discourse. Whether it's dissecting the nuances of a beloved video game or delving into the complexities of human nature, you possess an innate talent for fostering thought-provoking conversations that linger long after the screen fades to black. It's not just your knowledge or your charisma that draws me in, but rather, it's the sincerity with which you approach each topic, the humility with which you engage with your audience, and the unwavering passion that infuses every word you speak. You've become more than just a KZreadr to me; you're a mentor, a confidant, and a source of endless inspiration. In a world overflowing with content creators vying for attention, you stand out not only for your expertise but for your authenticity, your integrity, and your unwavering commitment to your craft. So, as I embark on yet another journey through the digital realms you've meticulously crafted, I do so with a heart full of gratitude and a mind eager to be enlightened. Thank you, Josh Strife Hayes, for being a guiding light in an often murky sea of mediocrity. Your impact transcends pixels and screens; it resonates within the hearts and minds of your devoted followers, myself included. That being said, please play Hello Kitty Island.

I knew there was something different about that vid, but I couldn't put my finger on it. The only thing I could descriptively say I didn't like was the lack of YOU being on screen. I like when you do a short monologue, standing there with the mic in the coffee cup! Otherwise, the whole thing just seemed a bit more....subtle? That might not be the right word, but it was different.

@user-ff8rs7gk6r

Ай бұрын

All this to say, you are still, hands down, one of the best youtubers I follow.

Tbh I only watch the clips channel and your “Was it Good?” videos. I suppose the point of this comment is to feed the algorithm. Best regards.

The polite way to open a message is: Greetings, I know you're probably very busy so I appreciate you taking time to read my message. Body of text, keep it concise and to the point. Possibly positive items, negative items, positive items and praise. Sincerely, Name Acknowledge that you know it will take some time out of his Henry Cavil but from Wish work. Give clear and honest feedback. Be polite.

3:01 yeah yeah yeah feedback... but the MMO aim is back

About feedback: I am not sorry to disturb you -> also , I liked everything except what's to blame on KZread -> additionally which editor wouldn't find easy to work with a cowman boss honing a vest and pink fluffy hat ?? With that in mind Mr Greg 👌 Mr Streamer 👌 Mr Clipper 👌 Great episode

Is this about the uniform? ...

Was it any good: Final Fantasy Tactics. That is all. Hope you're whelmed.

Thanks for the feedback about leaving messages.

I just usually post an initial message with something like "Hey, mind me asking you a question?" or something along those lines (depending on what I want). That way, if you don't read/answer I haven't wasted my time.

My only feedback is I often listen to videos as falling asleep and it feels like the snippets of game clips where you stop talking is often 2x the volume of your narration parts and can be jarring

At first I thought this was just...feedback in general. Cause I want to watch you paint Warhammer.

Also ... Will the chocolate pizza mukbang happen ??? ❤

Instead of apologizing, you thank them for taking the time to read your message, simple.

Almalexia be praised.

I think you've toned down a lot on your "pedantics" which I always loved, I loved it all from the older videos. I think you could be a little more again. The pacing and editing did feel different but I don't think it was bad, it was kind of refreshing... I hope this helps as good feedback, love your videos (and yes, I put the nice comments after the actual feedback)

I watched that video. It was great.

it was pretty whelming.

There are three landmarks of narrative that work for virutally any writing or communication. 1. Tell them what you're going to tell them. 2. Tell them it. 3. Tell them what you've told them. Here's an example... "Hello Person, I'm reaching out to propose a potential collaberation. I think your skill at looking like Henry Caville would pair well with my boutique line of pink cowboy hats with with feather frills, and I would love to work together on this. If you like the idea of this proposal or have any ideas of other work you would like, please drop me a line any time" You can use this for everything, and it even nests. Writing a 100 page thesis? Thats your three global landmarks. Writing the intro of that thesis? That's the structure of your intro. Writing the meat of it? That's the structure. Guess what the conclusion is? Short, long, medium. Presentations, letters, scientific papers.... It all works. And look at that... Even this comment has the three landmarks, including nesting.

I have a design document for a dragon-based science fiction MMO. Seriously, I do, but I don't have the skills to make it. So it remains my little secret.

Also, the link to your discord here on YT doesn't work. That or after my previous message here in the comments with my recommendation you have preemptively banned me from your discord in which case I commend your actionable speed however, I am disappointed and please expect a 42 page angry letter in the coming days.

1:33 Yeah, the I love everything response is so unproductive. To the video your editor made, I couldn't see a difference between it and the videos you made. Looking forward to his next works.

I know you never read these but I didn’t watch the worst mmo video so I have no feedback also I’ve never made a game before but I love your stuff so I’m making a new mmo. Any tips on making an mmo?? I’m thinking about making a good one instead of a bad one

I didn't notice a difference in editing.

"science based dragon mmo"? what do you mean by that?

But... Is josh gonna play wakfu?

I really hope that he can do the City of Heroes homecoming mmo.

You mat have to disturb someone, but still feel sorry about it.

Don't start with "you probably never read this", start with "I hope this message finds you well"

@bevvvy1374

Ай бұрын

Yeah maybe it you're sending a letter and live in the 18th century

I don't know if you're going to see this, but: I don't even watch those videos anymore. They were entertaining for a long time, but they're not anymore. Normally, when I open one of those videos now, I lie down on my couch and fall asleep about 10 minutes in. The videos I personally love are: 'What is Pay to Win?', 'What Went Wrong with Gaming?', and my personal favorite (I've watched it 6 or 7 times), 'New World - Timeline of a Failure.' It's just the same formula over and over again, and to me, it has lost its charm. To be fair, maybe I am not the audience you are looking for.

People who like direct, clear communication will laugh out loud to Jeannie Robertson's tale of sending her husband to the grocery store. The title is : "Never send a man to the grocery store". I'm leftbrained myself and found it hilarious.

I do feel there was a bit of unmotivated motion edits. Zooming in/out for no real reason than to artificially generate energy into the video but ironically, it distracts from the voiceover which is the most energetic part of the video. It’s quite jarring. But I do feel the game was the biggest problem. Can’t be artificially energetic about something that saps all that energy away.

The video seemed like it was written by someone who misses bottles at point blank range.

heads up dude I clicked the bell notification and your videos have not been showing up for me on the main channel

Here's a template for everyone : Hey Buddy, Please Play ( insert game here) Thanks love ya!

amble: I'd love to see Wakfu hit worst MMO ever, but we all know it's decent. post-able: Love your content, that hat is overstaying it's welcome, but still cute on you. Stay fabulous!

I dont even remeber anything being different. not sure what that says about me

oh Josh, asking people not do to a thing is just gonna make it a meme lol

That last video had too much Josh Strife Hayes in it to be honest.

My feedback is that I hate that stochastic CS bullet spread thing the guns in Fallout 3 and New Vegas do