In your video about the best age to neuter a doberman you recommended 18-24 months. But you actually neuter yours at 13-14 months. Can you please explain why? I have a 4 month European Doberman, that is why I am so interested in the topic. Love your vids 😀

@marinodejesus8024

2 жыл бұрын

I think Arlo was already neutered by then. But my Doberman breeder also suggests 18-24 months as he should be fully grown by then.

@DobermanPlanet

2 жыл бұрын

Thanks for bringing this up, Francisco! I also really appreciate the kind words! Means so much! Here's the reasoning for you and others that are curious about this: First, just to clarify: My previous video was on WHEN to neuter your Doberman from a health standpoint (kzread.info/dash/bejne/mpxm2sGMdanSdco.html), whereas this video was strictly about behavior changes after neutering and didn't touch on anything about health. Neither video discusses outside reasons to get a dog neutered (preventing unwanted pregnancies, dog daycare regulations, dog park rules, etc). However, all three of these things, including your vet's opinions, should be considered when deciding on when and if to neuter your dog. So remember that each of these videos is only 1-piece of the puzzle! But here are my personal reasons for doing it soon after 1 year of age with Arlo: - The dog kennel where Arlo stays at on occasion (when we go on a short vacation where dogs aren't allowed and no family is available to take him, for example) will only socialize Arlo with other dogs during "playtime" if he is neutered. Otherwise, he's kept separate. Socialization is huge for Arlo and something he always needs more of. - The dog park we take Arlo to requires male dogs to be neutered (we've been sort of skirting that rule up until now but it's getting harder to do). Again, I feel socialization is so incredibly important and his trips to the dog park are vital for his socialization and development. - Our vet recommended it (like most vets do -- I've noticed they're very "neuter happy" where I live in California). - The health studies I reviewed for that previous video showed many risks drop significantly if neutered after 12 months of age, but yes they drop a bit more after 18 months it seemed. But that second drop doesn't seem to me as significant as that first 12-month one. So we definitely wanted to make it at least 12 months. - And yes, full disclosure, the wife is in charge of Arlo when I'm at work with our 3 young boys. Her hands are very full. She was certainly on me to get him neutered soon so hopefully, it would improve his focus on the guidance and direction she gives him. I wish I could be there all the time to guide Arlo appropriately, but the realities of having a full-time job make that not possible. So yes, the wife's pressure on this topic definitely had an impact too (sorry honey)! Those are my main reasons. Everyone needs to decide what's right for them and their dog, in their specific situation. Arlo's socialization is so incredibly important for him right now. I got him at the start of quarantine for COVID and that is one area he's always needed more of. I certainly felt that once we got over the worst of the health risks (at the 12-month mark), instead of squeaking out every last percentile of lower health risk, it was crucial to get him the maximum socialization as soon as possible. So those first two points in this list were pretty huge for me. Hopefully, this clears up some of the reasons why this was the right decision for us anyway! Just do right by YOUR family and your dog whatever your decision!

@americanisshh

2 жыл бұрын

@@DobermanPlanet Wow thanks alot for the detailed and informative explanation. I can totally see your line of reasoning and it helps me make the right decision for my doberman named Canelo :D ...by the way I always wanted a Doberman and your amazing videos convinced me to finally get one. It´s been 5 weeks since Canelo is at home and I am very very happy with him!

@DobermanPlanet

2 жыл бұрын

@@americanisshh I'm so happy for you and Canelo! Great name by the way... thanks so much. Those are my reasons anyway. Everyone is different of course. Really appreciate you asking to clarify that!

@alanbatch5532

Жыл бұрын

@@americanisshhThis is old but I hope you wait until atleast 18 months. Let the dog mature to prevent development and health risks. Only neuter early if you can’t handle the behavior for one reason or another.

Of course he'll be more obedient, he's afraid you'll cut something else off. lol

@ursulaprinz1775

2 жыл бұрын

Lol

@danijelalise34

2 жыл бұрын

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

@DobermanPlanet

2 жыл бұрын

Hahaha! That's one way to look at it, Joe!

@dobermanguy9437

2 жыл бұрын

Ooooo boy 😛

@FreezoneLou

2 жыл бұрын

🤣🤣💯💯

My Bushido was right around 24 months old when he had to be neutered do to an abscessed prostate. Had to take him to an emergency vet then transferred him to another vet. $3500 later my boy was alive and back home with his brother, an American Staffordshire Terrier (Chance). I have never seen two dogs get along so well. His demeanor remained the same was never aggressive. I walked him 3-4 times a day and tried to introduce him as many as people as possible. Sadly I lost him at around 8 do to unknown reason. I will tell you this, I know he lived and respected me enough that he crawled in bed and died at my side. Greatest dog ever and I miss him dearly.

@ronnielove8781

24 күн бұрын

God bless. Gotta get my boy neutered today for the same reason hes 24 months also ☹️

@MSNsMOSTWANTED

24 күн бұрын

@@ronnielove8781 hope he has a speedy recovery❤️

I thought this was a very informative video ! So much that I took some pictures of the benefits you mentioned. Thank you John !!

My Doberman just turned 12 months, glad I seen this video.

I feel like your video topics always match my current thoughts! Such a coincidence lol. Thanks for the info!

Great Video,Thank's john!👍❤🐾

Thanks for the great video!

Thank you. All your information is very informative and greatly appreciated. Thank you

John another informative vlog

Good video John! I got my female Doberman spayed (a laparoscopic spay) at 17 months. I haven't notice much difference, if any, in her behavior. She still has loads of energy and loves to go to the dog park and run around with other dogs. She also goes jogging with me, and I have to hold her back because she wants to run full steam ahead. I've cut back slightly on the amount of food I give her because I know her metabolism will slow down a bit without the hormones. But, all in all, I'm happy with when and how my dog was spayed. 17 months was a good age because she was fully grown and her joints were well-established. The lap spay worked well because the incision sites were very small, minimally invasive, healed quickly, and only her ovaries were removed (not her uterus). Previously, she had gone through one heat cycle, and it was a real doozie. There was blood everywhere for 3 weeks, plus vomiting, and refusing to eat. Six weeks after her heat cycle ended, she went through a "false pregnancy" (like some female dogs do), and her breasts were swollen and hanging to the ground (leaking milk). Again, there was more vomiting, and more refusing to eat. Through research, I discovered that female dogs who experience drastic false pregnancies after heat cycles (like my dog did) will likely continue having them most of their lives (after every heat cycle). I didn't want my dog to go through that kind of hell with another heat cycle, so spaying at 17 months (prior to a 2d heat cycle) was best in my opinion. I'm very happy with my decision. At this point, I have a Doberman that is healthy, energetic, and not burdened by the hormonal extremes she had experienced. I can take her to dog parks and not worry about unneutered male dogs approaching her. And, she's as protective of the house as she always was (has an intimidating bark for all strangers who approach). All in all, I couldn't be happier.

@simpslayer6299

Жыл бұрын

Well sure....she had less testosterone to lose in the first place....this would effect a male dog way more.

@James-Lifts

11 ай бұрын

Hello, how old is the dog now? Is she still the same energetic loving dog? Thanks for the info.

@geeeemn5010

11 ай бұрын

@@James-Lifts Hello! My dog, Katie, is now 3 years and 3 months old. She continues to be as energetic as ever! At the dog park she runs circles around puppies and intact dogs half her age. It's funny, because sometimes I get home from the dog park and Katie starts playing with some of the neighborhood dogs. My neighbors ask me, "Oh, are you getting ready to take Katie out for some exercise?" I say, "No, we're just getting back from that." The neighbors respond, "Oh wow, that's amazing! Where does she get all that energy?" Katie's weight has been steady at 85 lbs for quite some time now. That's something I watch pretty carefully. She gets fed twice a day, with a few treats during the day as well. All in all, she's a very healthy and playful dog. Thanks for asking!

@FobbyBobby123456

4 ай бұрын

I think she may have had dog endometriosis. I have it and experience excruciating pain and vomiting during menstrual cycles. I am on the pill which helps ease those symptoms but I’m glad you got her spayed

Great video. My dobe Jona definitely is an exception Bc he got aggressive after neutered. All other behaviors you mentioned were spot on for my dobe.

@DobermanPlanet

2 жыл бұрын

That's great to hear that you are able to relate to this video, J! Thanks for sharing your experience with us!

@befree2894

7 ай бұрын

Maybe fear aggressive ?drop in testosterone can affect there confidence make them fearful. I have a fearful dog and I was told if his testicle was removed it could make his fear worse.

Very good information

I cant do it...My boy gets to keep his boys.

@sithiaung6096

26 күн бұрын

w

@XAE_A_Xii

13 күн бұрын

So you should let them do their boys thing too. The problem only arise when the owner of a female dog starts to get annoyed lol

The Increase in fear of others leads to them being more likely to bite someone I know this because we had a dog that would never bite but after she got her surgery she gave me a awesome bite on my hand randomly.

Great video!👍👍👏👏 Love your channel so much, John,you are the best!!👌👌 Warm regards from❤ bavaria,germany!👋🇩🇪

@DobermanPlanet

2 жыл бұрын

Thanks so much, Silvia! We really appreciate the positive feedback!

Mine is 8mnths and he will getting neutered. I have never had a male. All my femals were fixed when I got them. I am glad to hear that they settle down a little. ❤️ you have a beautiful dog

@Antonio-di4cr

Жыл бұрын

Before neutering please look at the pros and cons

Hi John, my last Male was neutered due to having an undescended testicle at 18mths,(I was his second and final owner,I used to take him to a socialising class most weeks and as the types and ages or breedswould change week to week. This class was a real world type class never indoors and while we would all take turns at doing training or obedience excersises there were multiple times off lead mixing. Tyson was docked and his tail was always at 90 deg to his back ( upwards) not saying he was a true alpha as most people have never seen one most see a high middle ranked which was what Tyson was,some times he was surrounded by unneutered males and would constantly put them in their place if he deemed their behaviour to people/dogs unacceptable, he also used to split up any scuffles etc between other dogs ( as I said before this was not an established pack as dogs changed week on week)we called him the puppy police lol🙂so I would say (as my current Male is also neutered due to him getting distressed and not eating etc when my bitches came into season)that his behaviour has not changed , still as energetic, protective etc,but I would say to leave doing it until they are at least 18mth old .great job John keep it up👍🙂🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

I love these videos it really helped me out with my Black and Tan coonhound mix Doberman.

I never neutered my Doberman. 13 yrs old when he passed. My next dog won't be either.

@99Venom

2 жыл бұрын

Why do they neuter dogs anyways? Will there be health issues if they don't get neutered?

@kittycatdays8719

2 жыл бұрын

V99 it was explained in the video but: Higher risk for aggression Sexual frustration if not used as a breeder Marking around the house Higher risk of them trying to escape the house/leash when they sense a female in heat Some become calmer after neutering, which helps if their level of activity is somehow higher than a husky’s XD Also that way they dont get testicular cancer and theres less risk for prostate cancer.

@99Venom

2 жыл бұрын

@@kittycatdays8719 Okay thanks a lot man

@lateknight9270

2 жыл бұрын

@@kittycatdays8719 That is what they naturally do you can control them by teaching things earlier, neutering them is just an excuse

@kittycatdays8719

2 жыл бұрын

Mitesh not everything. You can try teaching them, but even in humans hormones play a huge part, they can cause to lash out, feel depressed, etc. When dealing with hormones you cant control everything, especially in animals other than humans.

Loved the video. I liked how when he's with your little ones he seems to try to not bump into him/them. Nice job John.😀

@DobermanPlanet

2 жыл бұрын

Thanks so much, Rudy! Arlo does great with the kids!

I had my last doberman, Zeiss, neutered at around 9 months old on the advice of my vet. I never had a male Dobie before and all of my females except the first were spayed, which didn't affect their behavior at all. I also had Neuticles inserted during the neutering process, which made him look like an intact male. I think that they also made him feel like an intact male, but without any of the downsides of having an intact male. 😄 Neutering didn't slow him down any as far as I could see, since his temperament was high-energy, but it made him less dog-friendly and more oriented to people. I was very careful to not overfeed him...which could be a problem for a neutered dog...or any dog...so he stayed healthy and active for his 14 1/2 year lifespan.

@zeropointenergy1574

2 жыл бұрын

Useful information - thanks for sharing. Kudos for providing dignity for your Doberman with prosthetic implants.

@hokeypokeypots

2 жыл бұрын

@@zeropointenergy1574 I think that Zeiss still FELT like a male with his Neuticles, but without the urge to chase after females and frustration when he couldn't. He still liked the ladies and had several 'girlfriends' that we'd meet when I took him for his 'walksies'. But he was always a gentleman. 🤣🤣 My vet was very strict with me about his weight, which was the most important thing in keeping him healthy. If I could feel his ribs, but not see them, I knew that his weight was ideal. The Dobie mix that I have now came to me already neutered...and overweight. Can't do much about his dignity at this stage, but I put him on a diet, so I'm beginning to see more energy in him.

None of my Doberman ( 4 dogs, 2 female both fixed mother daughter, 2 male one fixed over 17years) wanted to fetch. I would at most get 2 or 3 throws with retrieve. The other thing was none of them cared about someone at the door unless it was someone they liked. They also didn't do much barking indoors unless there was food being prepared, I think this was pure instinctual to alert " hey there's food here so go away"...lol. Arlo looks like a awesome dog!

Thanks!

@DobermanPlanet

Жыл бұрын

Thanks Elbin! Your support really means a lot!!

Our 3 year old Doberman is the same he's definitely a lot calmer and sleeps more

Previously, you suggested 18-24 months for neutering. What changed your decision?

This is a very tough question - castrate or not, and at what age??? In my country the vets tells you to wait until after one year of age. Why castration? If you castrate your Dobermann because he/she is too much of a dog to handle, then you're doing it for the wrong reason and you should have chosen another breed. This is a working breed with oceans of energy. If you can't handle that - well, then you got the wrong breed. Also - castration makes your dog having problems with incontinence. Females have bigger issues with this, but it's also a problem with males. You may need medication for this. My Dobermann is castrated, but I did it only because he had another surgery and while he's under anastethic, well - take those nutz. If you want to castrate your dog because you want to solve behavioral issues - forget about it! Your dog isn't turning in to a saint just because his ballz was removed. Then you have failed as a leader and you should get an easier breed. Maybe a Golden retriever or something... Just my two cents... I'm a former military K9 handler. When in service we had german shepherds at the time, but after leaving the service i chose Dobermann and had them for 25+ years. There's no other breed in comparison, but they are tough cookies to handle and get right. It

@deborahhill3547

2 жыл бұрын

All of my female (3) Doberman's got "spay incontinence" about a year or so after spay. My mother's female Doberman also got it. Sad to put them on the medication then for the rest of their lives.

@XAE_A_Xii

Жыл бұрын

so i still didn't get why you castrated if you are against it. you said because he was already under anastethic, so that doesn't sound like a good reason.

@guycalabrese4040

Жыл бұрын

@@XAE_A_Xii Because I got me a second dog, a female, and didn't want them to mate or my male dog feeling "bad" and getting crazy during "heat". Castrating a male is an easier option than performing a huge surgery on a female.

thank you Señor!!

@DobermanPlanet

2 жыл бұрын

You're very welcome, Guillermo! So glad you found some useful nuggets of information in this video!

My Moses is not neutered and he never will be. He is never not around us and he is not a problem in any of the areas mentioned. He is tons of fun and I wouldn’t change a thing about him. I work in the medical field and hormones are huge!! Any imbalance and it causes problems.

@suzannethepatriot8049

2 жыл бұрын

Oh!!! plus, the evidence is on when it comes to “experts”. When I hear someone say they are an expert, I run the other way!!

@persianprince815

2 жыл бұрын

Ok Karen

We had a GSD and had him fixed because he was aggressive to the point of being dangerous, our Vet thought this was going to be a huge help. Unfortunately it didn’t help at all and I think it made him worse, he was truly a handful, but I can say I keep him from biting people and took great care when people were around 💙

@larissa1770

Жыл бұрын

Hi may I ask what aggression signs did he show? Just wondering 😅

OMG Jhon, Finn is Arlo his brother 🤣🤣same karakter! Still good boys!! Love the funny crazy doby's. Thanks voor the good video, like always. Your BIGGEST fans from ,Belgium...Finn the doberman and Maja 😉😍❤

@DobermanPlanet

2 жыл бұрын

Hi, Finn and Maja! It's great to hear from you each week! Arlo and him sound so much alike!

@majajaspaert8661

2 жыл бұрын

@@DobermanPlanet yes the are John, so funny and so nice!! Greets Finn 🐾🐾🐾🐾🐾and Maja 😉

I never neutered my Doberman and never had a problem, but a couple of friends did neutered their Dobermans but not for the age of 2.5 / 3 years

I neutered my big boy at 15 months, my vet recommended 18+ months unless he reached what appeared to be full weight/size. I chose to do it earlier because I wanted to do doggy daycare, and my vet was onboard with doing it at that time after a “pre op” visit. I noticed that he has slightly less energy endurance, like after a dog park visit he’s pooped. Maybe a touch calmer. But that’s about it. He’s the same derpy bag of marshmallows I brought home all those months ago.

@maxwellmark986

2 жыл бұрын

Hello Lisa.......

@tabbymoonshine5986

2 жыл бұрын

Oh maxwell….

@bcv7266

Жыл бұрын

@@tabbymoonshine5986 Oh Tabby……

@tabbymoonshine5986

Жыл бұрын

@@bcv7266 😳

@goberianchloex3646

Жыл бұрын

Probably will have health problems in future. Research vet “ karen Becker” I seen first hand damage to many dogs for early spaying and neutering :0/

My first and favorite doberman and his three offspring I kept showed no changes after neutering. Camis obviously was neutered late in life, his kids about one year in age; Ember, the mom, showed changes more likely from a thyroid problem requiring medication starting shortly before her surgery. I had cats, so my dogs were never alone, never problem barkers, and thoroughly drilled in the property lines. Only Ember showed any slowing. Camis was never dominant unless he was protecting; he considered himself our primary defense. Ember was sometimes bossy and ignored. Phaedra and Gaius traded out passive/aggressive. Tidbit was the clown.

Great Dog!!!!

Neutered my boy in August (3 months ago almost) at 26 months old and he's still the aggressive, loving boy he always was. 26 months because we adopted him at 24 months.

I've had 3 dogs in my life so far two of them were dominant irish wolfhounds my 100kg dog was destructive for 18 months even with plenty of exercise people said about castration I refused after 18 months he was an amazing dog I'm so glad I stuck to my conviction I've spoke to people over the years who have had their dogs done and it changed their personality some people buy dominant high energy breeds then castration is what they choose to calm them down maybe they should buy low energy breeds I'm not saying everyone does this but I have spoke to so many people that say things like I had my springer spaniel castrated to calm him down when this is meant to be an incredibly high energy breed if people buy the breed that fits there lifestyle castration should very very rarely be needed

@flii87

8 ай бұрын

No such thing as a low energy breed. Some breeds might tolerate house life easier,.but all dogs were bred to work.

@negaalex3186

3 ай бұрын

@@flii87that’s simply not true. There’s a lot of dogs that where bred for the sole purpose of being a house dog

I understand the importance of neutering, but when I neutered my cats I’ve never felt more guilty in my life watching them trying to figure out what happened to their little balls. I couldn’t sleep for days. I’ve been really doing research on dog vasectomies as an alternative but no Vet near my area preforms that surgery.

@S5S5066

2 жыл бұрын

You shouldn’t feel guilty you may just be anthropomorphizing them. I think vasectomies are a great alternative and I wish the where more common for pets

@rawmark

2 жыл бұрын

There are groups on Facebook that can lead you to a doctor who supports your beliefs. I see that you and I are like minded.

@MarsKvaratskhelia

2 жыл бұрын

Same here when I crop my dobies ears I felt I betrayed him can’t do that anymore We’ll find him nice lady 😎 and keep his ⚽️ s

@DobermanPlanet

2 жыл бұрын

Getting a vasectomy is a great alternative to neutering! We hope you find a vet that can carry through this procedure for you and your pet's peace of mind.

@lateknight9270

2 жыл бұрын

@@S5S5066 Isn't it inhumane though

After such a good experience with our Doberman-Lab cross several years ago, we’re thinking about a Doberman now but have concerns about the tendency towards the dangerous bloat problem. Can you help us understand this better?

Oops - we just saw you already have a good video on bloat. Thanks!

I heard that tying their tube instead of completely removing a dog’s reproductive organ is available but you have to ask your vet if they specifically perform this. This would be less invasive & better option for dogs. Dogs need their natural hormone to thrive. Especially in males, most will lose their confidence w/o it.

Has anyone experienced von willebrand disease with their dobe? My almost 11yr old male was diagnosed with it around the age of 2-3yrs. We only found out because we left him alone to go to dinner immediately after moving into a new home. He had a nose bleed that lasted over 24hrs! The local vet didn't even know enough about it to really help us. Luckily it stopped but now we make sure to keep a close eye on him if he ever has an injury.

Very good video John thanks

@DobermanPlanet

2 жыл бұрын

Thanks for the feedback, Ronnie! So glad you found this video beneficial!

I have a 3 year old intact male. He has none of the "issues" you listed. He doesn't mark any more than my spayed female, and It's either a tree or the grass. He has very little sexual behavior, mostly just sniffing and he's easily redirected. In comparison, my last male was neutered at 6 months and he was hypersexual. He's not an excessive attention seeker, but he does jump up every time I move like "LETS GO!" I don't think that would change with neutering though. He's also walked on harness or a flat collar and is not hard to handle. I don't get the generalized "if your dog is intact he'll be a raging hormonal humping machine." that's just not true.

@pumpgod940

Жыл бұрын

Same reason they say "neuter your dog if you want it to calm down" without mentioning all the health issues it could bring. Money.

@saribeepo.o5111

Жыл бұрын

The sad part is, it's the responsible owners that could probably manage an intact animal that are the only ones that listen to the propaganda. The ones that have dogs that actually need to be neutered because they left out to form packs and roam the streets/country side causing problems aren't getting taken in to get fixed.

@StoneCoolds

8 ай бұрын

Greengos have so little knowledge about dogs that they believe such things, like americans literally nutter their dogs so they dont mark territory or cut their vocal cords so they dont bark, when bot behaviors are easily avoided with training 🤦🏻‍♂️ Aaah but someone cuts a dogs ears and he is a monster, a mutilator of animals, a selfish biggot... the hypocrisy

Hey John any recommendations on reputable Euro Dobe breeders where to get a puppy from ?

just watched the dobies with kids compelation...wish i could have commented on it. all it did was make me want to get another one RIGHT NOW! did not agree with the parent letting the baby crawl across the dog, because they (either one) could get hurt & react, but all the rest...loved it. i'm on 5 diff waiting lists for my next dobie...estimate 2-3 years! ahhhhhh.....!!!!!!!

Hey John hope you got the email of me saying yes to you posting the drawing because it would be a honor and glad you liked it

VERY INFORMATIVE!! Please include more Proven Scientific studies on Dobermans! I’m planning to own one in the future. Thanks!

I could never do this. It’s the bro code

I take care of dogs for almost 20 years and I never do that for my dogs and will never do it

My first dog was a German boxer, he was super crazy muscles and then some, he strayed to follow a bitch in season...when I got him back I made a decision to have him neutered, to prevent him going AWOL again...He never changed one bit....I have a male doberman now who's 7minths. Who I hope to keep intact.....From other articles Ive read they stay leaner in old age and are generally healthier animals..... Great video always filled with valuable information and always happy to see your beautiful Arlo....,😁

@TedH71

Жыл бұрын

Believe it or not, I've seen neutered males breed with females in heat and the males had never mated prior so yeah it can happen.

Don't take their hormones away too early, they need them for growth, especially the bones - around 2 years old is good.

@dneesetherunner

Жыл бұрын

I agree!

My Doberman puppy seems to attack the little dog in my house any tips to how to get him to be less aggressive or not bite her ?

Kind of off topic, but how would you get the thick athletic build in some dobermans I see

I feel terrible, having to neuter my corgi, he is almost 12 months but he was taken from his mom and the rest of his pack early. All of the pups were at six weeks so they missed out on teaching from each other etc. six weeks this way to relieve but I didn’t know it at the time. This is something this breeder does but hasn’t had to answer for. Anyway, he bit me a few times maybe five or six times and all I did was go to pet him each time. He bit my husband one time we train him and he will sit but he’s so hyper, and if you’re getting bit that many times and still trying to train him does seem like the only thing we could do. We pick him up pretty soon. I hope the recovery part as well. Thank you for your videos.

what size pen do you have for him?

Lol I think is so funny when folks see my happy dog & tell me I’m cruel for cropping his ears & tail, while they’re walking their confused neutered shy dog

@briannahernandez6627

2 жыл бұрын

All the dogs I know that are neutered are happy and healthy there are no problems with them

@kabir1557

2 жыл бұрын

Cropping and docking is bad but neutering is the worst!

@kabir1557

2 жыл бұрын

@@briannahernandez6627 that's what you feel. Neutering is not natural and shouldn't be done unless for a health problem.

Cruel is what it is , never could understand why someone would neuter a male dog other than health issues only , if you can't train or handle the natural behavior of a male dog intact then you shouldn't get a male dog . it's kinda crazy how some people rant and rave about docking or cropping ears and tales but yet they neuter and think that's no problem at all

@raymonddeflaviis2306

2 жыл бұрын

Exactly! And if you mention it to them, they look bewildered! As though they can't make the connection!

@lezliestaley4763

2 жыл бұрын

Population control!

@lezliestaley4763

2 жыл бұрын

Many breeders will not release the dog's papers until you provide proof of spay/neuter. This us responsible dog ownership, in my opinion and most rescues.

@FISTSLIKEBULLETS2

2 жыл бұрын

@@lezliestaley4763 maybe breeders shouldnt over breed females for money or have so many litters , how many times you see a so called reputable breeder selling the female because all she was used for was breeding and now she has had so many litters they have no use for her and these are not just so called backyard breeders or a family who's dog has one litter in it's entire life , I respect your point and comment as far as population so fix the females , my point is male nuetering is cruel don't have a male dog if you think his drive is to high for you or your family

I had Sasha spayed before her first heat. At about the age of four, she started to have a weak bladder. (Leaking) I was told that I should have waited until after her heat. Ideally, I was also told that she should have a litter first. It would have made her more protective of the family/home.

Our Doberman was fantastic - until it had it's jewels cut off at 13-months. Shortly thereafter it became very aggressive towards everyone including me. Never abused, always loved. Yet bit mu face when i slowly leaned in to kiss it on the forehead. We had to give him up, very sad situation, but it went to another home with no kids. Was still aggressive there. Never a hint of this before he was 'fixed.' Look it up, this is actually common in dogs, it just is not the political thing to spread.

Had 5 male Dobermans never neutered (stretched out over 30 years) Only bred one once with the female I had. Never an issue. Never had aggression. Just energetic. They never lived over 8 years of age. Even the expensive ones. Thinking of getting another. I miss having a Doberman. They are so awesome!

@bjstallworth2978

Жыл бұрын

I met a 13yr old rusty

@thomasford4235

Жыл бұрын

@@bjstallworth2978 Wow, Thats like ancient for a Doberman! I wish mine would live to at least 10.

@Antonio-di4cr

Жыл бұрын

Nice bro

@OPWasatchReptiles

Жыл бұрын

My gsd un cut, lived to be 17

@lyndseybailey776

Жыл бұрын

I have a neutered black and tan male who is about to turn 11! He's been the best dog for us and our 3 kids! We got him when he was 5 weeks old!

What is the orange circular bone Arlo is chewing on at 2:48?

Thank you for all this info! Our Dobie just turned 1 and we plan to nueter at 18 months based on our vet's recommendation. Our local daycare and kennel won't take him until he's neutered. Right now he marks SO MUCH and we're really hoping that stops after his surgery! And despite out efforts, he howls when we leave him alone so it would be amazing if that also improves

@dirge44

2 жыл бұрын

In that situation that's not going to fix it At ALL. Obidience is the problem

@XAE_A_Xii

Жыл бұрын

why in hell did you get the dog in the first place if you can't handle it? daycare and kennels are prisons for dogs, and let him out so he won't mark indoor, and if he does outside, what is the issue?

@TedH71

Жыл бұрын

IF your dog is marking INDOORS, he is NOT housebroken. Go back to square one and get on his case EVERY TIME he marks in the house and hustle his butt outside pronto and give him a food reward and verbal praise if he marks outside. I've only had one male mark ONCE in the house, he got yelled at and hustled outside and hasn't since. His great grandson has never marked in the house. I tend to keep my dogs intact for 3 years and I raise catahoulas.

Great video. Your videos are always very professional, with quality content. 👍

@DobermanPlanet

2 жыл бұрын

Thank you very much! Seriously means so much!

I love your videos! I live in Arizona and I'm looking to purchase a Doberman "European" Do you by any chance know the best way to go about purchasing one?

Hey I don't know if you'll ever see this but I do have a question, I'm about to get my first doberman puppy thanks to you and I was wondering if a pedigree is necessary.

My boy Zeus is 6 years old, he had to be done at 18 months old, due to only one ball dropping. Vet said to wait till then in case the other ball dropped. It didn’t, they opened him up and the other ball was round by he’s back. My female is 21 weeks old, still debating when to have her done?

@maxwellmark986

2 жыл бұрын

Hello Denise.....

in the words of abigail adam’s- “remember the ladies” John - hoping the spaying video is coming up soon.

@DobermanPlanet

2 жыл бұрын

It's on the list! It will definitely happen! Haha. Love this comment though!

Thank you for the video. Fauci is about the same age Arlo and your videos line up perfectly with what we have going on.

@DobermanPlanet

2 жыл бұрын

That's great to hear, Evan! So glad the timing of these videos is working out well for what Fauci needs!

@chrisnelson3691

Жыл бұрын

You named your dog Fauci?

@evanmcswain6183

Жыл бұрын

@@chrisnelson3691 Yea and he is a bad ass very well trained dog.

@aes_ka

Жыл бұрын

@@chrisnelson3691 🤣

I just recently started putting my doberman puppy in day care for more socialization (4 months with all shots), and all the dog daycare around my area require all dogs to be neutered after 6months old. Isnt it too early to get my doberman neutered once he hits 6 months old?

Please help me John my Doberman has been so reactive and aggressive. When he is on a leash I use a mini educator collar, and he bites me if something scares him or if something is concerning or if another dog on a leash comes around then he attacks whoever is holding the leash I’ve gotten stitches. I’ve got bit by him multiple times. I really don’t want him to get put to sleep I don’t know what to do.

Your dog Arlo is awesome I wish him and chief could get together and play. I've come across complete strangers who were walking their Doberman and I'm walking my dog chief they get along like they are best friends it totally blows my mind but I cannot say that for other breeds that he comes across like German Shepherds or pitbulls it seems to me that my dog gets along fine with other Dobermans and even when he meets them for the first time must be a doberman thing

@maxwellmark986

2 жыл бұрын

Hello Stan Z.......

@dobermanguy9437

2 жыл бұрын

@@maxwellmark986 howdy howdy

@maxwellmark986

2 жыл бұрын

@@dobermanguy9437 I'm fine thanks and you, and I hope family and friends are all safe and sound over there?

Anyone have any reputable doby breeders in the scranton pa area? I'll even drive 3-4 hrs away ! Thanks !

Arlo is nice

I tend to wait until age 3 but I had one pup that was the absolute terror and he got neutered at 9 months of age. They still hate each other and I have to rotate 2 packs. I run catahoulas and they tend to become dog selective after a certain age even if they're fixed. Neutering them at later ages helps prevent them from having joint issues later on in life. Literally the only 2 differences I've noticed is their urine is much less smelly and they do gain weight no matter what your vet tells you. Oh, I do not take my dogs to any dog park...they're cesspools of parasite ridden dogs who also may carry diseases and frequently aren't fixed and want to fight. If your dog is high energy, I see nothing wrong with getting an opposite sex puppy after your original dog turns 1 to 2 years old and is fully trained. The original dog will help train the 2nd dog and the puppy will pick up on the behavior much faster. They keep each other occupied but be sure to train separately.

Dear Doberman Planet: Have you ever addressed the trembling of Doberman's back legs while standing? The internet says it's "Dancing Doberman Disease" with no known cause and no major issues. That doesn't sound like a "disease". I feel like it's just excitement because it usually happens after a good run, or when he's watching a squirrel climb a tree. People ask me why he's trembling, and I just say it's excitement. But I wonder what your thoughts are on it. Thanks for the great videos!

@larissa1770

Жыл бұрын

Omg yes I thought something was wrong with my pup or it was cold for him. When I gave him food in the morning his back legs would shiver. He hasn’t done it in a while though

Hey John! What are your thoughts on partial neutering, aka like a vasectomy for a dog? Love the channel btw, and the beard/shadow looks good on ya!

@DobermanPlanet

2 жыл бұрын

Hey, Allen, thanks so much for the compliment! We didn't do as much research on having a vasectomy done as this was mainly about neutering, but it definitely seems like a great way to "fix" the dog without taking the physical look of his manhood away. Fewer vets offer this option, though, so you'll have to do some digging to find a reputable vet near you that does offer this alternative.

@XAE_A_Xii

Жыл бұрын

vasectomy seems to be only good to prevent your male dog from impregnating other dogs, but will not stop from production of testosterone - a male-life hormone. so just don't neuter or so vasectomy, don't go against the nature or play god.

Hi, New to your channel. Just wanted to ask a question if you don't.. Is there any specific reason why you chose to neuter? Apologies if you have already answered that question. Thanks

How can you tell if your dobe is protective? My dog is with me ALL the time. Upstairs, downstairs. Hubby is in his office but Bullitt is with me. Once when a friendly workman was over and we were all in the backyard my dog was leaning against me. Was that protective behavior?

@maxwellmark986

2 жыл бұрын

Hello Huber......

I don’t have a Doberman I have a 5month old pitbull terrier with a dominant attitude he gets hyper jumps up people when excited we do tell him “off “ and sometimes he’ll nip at people when he’s in his hyper state of mind .the vet told me around 6 months is a good age to get the surgery done , so I’m hoping he behaves better I mean he’s good in-house doesn’t chew furniture or have accidents on floor and that sorta thing I just want him calmer

@zayworld9933

10 ай бұрын

Update?

I may be getting a 3 year old European Dobie, he is not neutered...but I plan to do so! Will this help him be a little more settled and focused?

I understand the reason for spay/neuter in some circumstances where the dog is not under observation at all times and unwanted pregnancy can occur. I have participated in this belief myself. I have however examine the result of this elective surgery and now I'm not as convinced that it is the right thing in all circumstances. The incidences of hip and bone issues is affected by this procedure. Many of the behavioral issues that you address ie aggression etc is rarely cured by alteration. Most of the issues that you described would be best served by proper training and socialization. I think the most important consideration that is all too often overlooked is to consider what was the breed created for. No amount of surgery is going to change the innate characteristics of the breed type. Maybe consider that a doberman or shepard is not what you are prepared to deal with. All too often we fall in love with the appearance of a dog without a minutes thought of its purpose in being bred. A doberman will never be a golden retriever anymore than a golden retriever can become a herding dog. A doberman was bred for guarding and has the temperment to be aggressive and forceful if warranted. A lapdog is not in his design. He is more than a gorgeous black and tan furry coat.

What are the changes that you would have not liked to change thou?? Be honest about this thou. Remember, I'm not tryna come at you for taking the decisions you took for your dog... I'm also tryna come to the best ultimatum for my best friend. If you did mention em thou, simply tag the time to them please? I might have missed them. 🙂

We waited 4 years. His behavior hasn’t really changed much, but his appetite definitely increased. He was a very picky eater, and now would eat breakfast lunch and dinner if we let him. Lol

The only reason we neutered our previous Dobie Pepper is because he developed a growth on his rear being an in tact male. The neutering literally saved his life and gave him almost an extra year and a half to 15 wonderful years.

@DobermanPlanet

2 жыл бұрын

No better reason than that in my opinion. So glad you guys had so long together, that's amazing!

@XAE_A_Xii

Жыл бұрын

neutoring to save your dog is something you can't argue, but neutering because the owner concerned with their dog's barking, or marking, or stubbornness - is ridiculous.

Neutering your pet is like having your child's balls removed for being a child and making a mess at home....how can people justify this thing, think about youself if your father has taken away your ability to have sex or children because he was annoyed of your childish behaviour.....it's just total cruelty to animals .......

We are on our 4th Dobi first one was a female and 3 males all of them didn't get neutered ad we had breeding papers the first male we had , I had him in Schutzhund so none of the dogs would like each other the next male was really good got along with any dog and the one we have now is almost 10 years old and very bossy only likes other males if they are neutered next one is going to get neutered as it get harder to deal with that for me ! But all in all we just love this Breed our son has a male that is not neutered and our Daughter has a female

@DobermanPlanet

2 жыл бұрын

It's funny how each one is different, isn't it, Ursula?! Each phase of our lives will bring different circumstances that might change our stance on this as well. You just have to do what you think is best for your pet!

My male Rottweiler mix is getting neutered next month ! Mostly because I also have a female and I don’t want puppies but it would be nice if it also helped him stop marking at least indoors, was more focused and easier to handle!

@XAE_A_Xii

Жыл бұрын

sorry for rottweiler, i think you should neuter yourself as well, it will help from leaving white marks on your clothes so less washing for your mum

@KCJuster

Жыл бұрын

@@XAE_A_Xii don’t worry I wash my clothes myself and I’m infertile so it wouldn’t really do anything anyway

I’m waiting out the 18 months. My goober is leash reactive because he wants so much to play with everybody, and the leash is holding him back. I’m continuing with his trainer but I’m excited to see if the lesser testosterone helps chill him out a little.

@XAE_A_Xii

Жыл бұрын

lesser? he will have none, no balls - no testosterone. no testosterone - no desire to live. in human males, lack of testosterone leads to depression and motivation, so i would assume the same is for other animals. don't dare to damage the health of an animal

My male stopped marking after bein neutered. My female was spayed as a puppy and she marked until she passed.

@DobermanPlanet

2 жыл бұрын

Interesting about your Female!!!

Ive bought a dobermann from a well reputated breeder/trainer, picking him up now 5th April. Theyve had their kennel and training since 1981 with dobermanns, I asked them the difference between a nutered dobermann. They just said, ppl who neuter their dobermann cant handle them. So ill go with their knowledge over this.

This is sad. I’m a fan but honestly I’m sorry for Arlo. I will never neuter my dobie boy. It affects them terribly. No way!

@bmrz38

2 жыл бұрын

I agree. I have two Doberman and will never do that to them. They are 5 1/2 years old. Big, strong and full of personality. People should reconsider getting a doberman if they are going to change their personality by neutering them.

@DobermanPlanet

2 жыл бұрын

I totally get it Shawn. Thank you for being a fan regardless. I certainly always appreciate different opinions here so that others can see both sides and make up their own mind! I'll "like" and "heart" your comment so it goes further up the comment list and others can see some other opinions. Are you in the U.S.? I'm just curious because I've noticed more of those strongly against neutering seem to be from outside the U.S. I think there's a big cultural thing at play too here. Like the ear cropping or tail docking for example. Those things are so foreign and strange outside the states but inside, it's the norm. Like neutering, there are some areas that have ordinances requiring dogs to get neutered (or pay much higher dog license fees) it's so common.

@shawndady

2 жыл бұрын

@@DobermanPlanet I’m in the US. But like one of the other commenters on here, I’ve researched and found that neutering of dobies causes big issues bc hormones are so important. I do think that neutering is many times for human convenience only. But I’m a huge fan of your channel John and listen and take to heart most all of your videos. In fact I going you before I got my dobie puppy. Such a great decision. I’ll continue to be your fan, but I simply won’t alter the hormones of my guy. The potential for big health issues for him is just too great for me.

@shawndady

2 жыл бұрын

Oh and I am fine with ear and tail cropping. Just not the neutering. Ears and tails don’t cause health issues. In fact the ears stay cleaner.

@lateknight9270

2 жыл бұрын

@@shawndady Boths the things are inhumane in most of the cases

My vet just told me that there was a study across all breeds after nurturing/spay. She said they found Doberman males will get lymphoma 100% if neutered. Female goldens will also get cancer so in my city there is a vet doing tubals for them. Boxer females should always be fixed to prevent cancer. I just got our second male Doberman and this scares me she said I’ll just have to double down on training. The focus is huge our last male died at almost 9 and he was very alert all the time. His tail never was down it was always strait up. My puppy now we can just pray I can keep him intact

@Aristes

2 жыл бұрын

Nothing is 100% guaranteed. Your vet is goofy. lol

Can you do this same video but about spaying

My boy only has one descended testicle. I wouldn't snip him if not for that. I hear it must be done and surgery to remove stuck testicle. Any advice he is 9 months now. Really don't want to neuter him.. Thanks.

Do you have any tips for like rainy days with a doberman

@Hadassa1977

2 жыл бұрын

My Doberman loved puzzle toys or search games

@DobermanPlanet

2 жыл бұрын

They love to be mentally stimulated since they're such sharp dogs! Rowan's suggestion of puzzle toys and search games is very helpful. You can also throw in an extra training session or two (maybe try to teach hide and seek!). Hope this helps!

Could you do the same video for females? 🙏🙏

My European has the same mattress Arlo has. It's her second mattress cause she ate and tore the first mattress to almost shreds. Ugh!!

The reason for my visit to this channel is the following: My husband wants a Doberman. Now, why is that a problem? This is why: - My husband spends 20 hours a day sleeping. He is a retired man with very little energy, absolutely no hobbies, no friends and nothing to do, so his favorite pastime is lying in bed the entire day. - A dog with so much energy that it will demand so much attention in an environment where the person who really wants to own it will not be taking care of the pet (most of the time). - We currently have cats in the house that have been with us for around 5 years. - Sorry but I deeply hate dogs in every possible way. I can't stand their behavior, I can't stand having them around. - We have other family members who feel the same way than I do. I would really love to make my husband happy, but I don't see a way to make this work. I know I won't be able to stand an animal destroying the house, because I think that's going to be the final scenario. What should I do? How could I let my husband know that we are not the right family for this type of pet? Thank you.

Honest question, why would one want to reduce the working ability of a working dog by removing the dogs testicles, thus reducing its energy,strength ,recovery ability,and aggression.