This video looks like a drop everything I'm doing situation

@ID82005

5 ай бұрын

Literally

@nobii

5 ай бұрын

fr 😭

@tiyenin

5 ай бұрын

24:30 I like Jack Johnson's "As I Was Saying" for I --> v.

@BrockBarr

5 ай бұрын

Especially if you have an instrument in hand. Maybe don't drop everything, literally at least.

@predatorx8081

5 ай бұрын

Couldn't have said it better 😂

I love the whole "and the world lives as 1" thing, that was too perfect!

@Meuhy

5 ай бұрын

Wow that joke is authentic, i've never heard it before!

@kierenmoore3236

5 ай бұрын

Any opportunity to promote that song/it’s ideals, take it …

@RavenclawNimbus

5 ай бұрын

@@kierenmoore3236 I just thought his example of Imagine worked well for explaining chord progressions, as the song ended with the word “one”

@Meuhy

5 ай бұрын

@@RavenclawNimbus I thought you made a joke about perfect cadences by saying it was pefect, so I made a joke about authentic cadences. Maybe I dug too deep on this one..

@RavenclawNimbus

5 ай бұрын

@@Meuhy Oh sorry I was talking to the other person, sorry

Note for viewers, it took me a few *years* to go from recognizing IV and V reliably to all the chromatics here. You can absolutely do it, but you've gotta learn and play songs and get those chords in your fingers and associated with the Roman numeral in your head while playing them. Great overview of the common major/minor here!

Hello David. As a musician who never really properly learned about music in the formal sense, I've been following many KZread teachers, and you're way out in front and my absolute favourite. I have to compliment you on your relaxed style of presenting music theory in a way that keeps me engaged. I've learned so much already and will continue to follow you, so please keep it going, keep it relaxed and thank you for taking the time to assist oldies like myself who never had the music education we should have had. Although I was theoretically a professional musician, I really only played at a very basic level and watching your videos has made me realise how much better I would have been had I taken the music classes at school that were available. But now through your easy-to-understand and step-by-step approach, I'm gradually catching up. Thank you and I'll see you in the next one!!!

@DavidBennettPiano

5 ай бұрын

Thank you! That means a lot 😊😊

DBP tries not to reference Radiohead challenge (impossible)

@DavidBennettPiano

5 ай бұрын

😂

@BlueManIan

5 ай бұрын

Or The Beatles

@spebtm8017

5 ай бұрын

@@BlueManIanthank god he does

@bigbirdmusic8199

5 ай бұрын

@@DavidBennettPiano love your videos!!

@shambolicentity

5 ай бұрын

It would be like giving introductions to 20th century physics without mentioning Einstein.

i love how you tailor almost every video on beginners. i admire you. it's so humble and wise. and generous, really.

@DavidBennettPiano

5 ай бұрын

Thanks ☺️

@tabor503

Ай бұрын

Yes i can watch these videos with non musicians and they enjoy it and really admire your mastery.@@DavidBennettPiano

Other songs that use the VII chord like Karma Police are: "Sexy Sadie" by The Beatles "Mr Sandman" by The Chordettes" "Dream A Little Dream Of Me" by the Mamas and the Papas And minor version of the vii is found in the Beatles' "Yesterday", the second chord right after the tonic!

@Better_Call_Raul

5 ай бұрын

Any Beatles song that help with learning the sound of the descending Minor Seventh melodic interval? For asscending Minor Seventh interval, I am using Star Trek them. That works great.

@johnreimer4122

5 ай бұрын

I'm So Tired - Beatles

@badgasaurus4211

5 ай бұрын

Tbh, Radiohead lifted the bridge section in Karma Police from Sexy Sadie

@SamBrockmann

5 ай бұрын

This is a very, very common thing in rock music in general.

@Swamp72

5 ай бұрын

@@badgasaurus4211is that confirmed or just sounds a lot like it?

I earned a music degree in college. This video reminded me of my music theory classes. I graduated 50 years ago! You are a great teacher!

Strangely did a lot better on the harder levels of the quiz haha! Stuff like the IV iv I or bVI bVII I have such distinctive sounds it's hard to confuse them for anything else. I always have issues with distinguishing IV I, because it feels like a strong resolution to me so I always think it must be V

@jaspermooren5883

5 ай бұрын

Yeah I had the same, the last question was the only one I got completely correct. Often mix up iii and vi, and IV and V. It's pretty hard to mis a bII, it's the easiest one to hear IMO, since it's just chromatic.

@YgorReboucas

5 ай бұрын

I have the same trouble, I can more easily recognize alterations than diatonic chords. They just pop to me, while diatonics all sound somewhat the same.

@ChannelMath

5 ай бұрын

me too! after hearing some dissonance, IV just sounds so "right", I think it must be V. I've gotten a little better by thinking that while V is total confidence in the journey, IV is a little calmer, wiser, less strident or something

@Dave-nm8uk

5 ай бұрын

A great deal depends on the chord voicing. It is possible to balance different chords to get different effects in chord progressions. It also makes a lot of difference if one moves away from "simply" piano plus a few other instruments. If there's a separate bass, then that can give a different effect too. Voice leading effects make a difference also.

@gnorung7769

5 ай бұрын

Same here, I feel everything's that's been said in this thread. One thing that might help with identifying VI is that it shares one note with the I chord, namely the tonic, while V shares the dominant of the scale. It's a bit of a stretch but can be useful every so often if you can hear and identify the common note. Another thing that might work is imagining the chord one step up, since IV-V-I is a very common progression and every so often I can 'hear' the V that might follow, whereas imagining the chord one tone above V feels more difficult and has much less pull towards I. They only work sometimes, as they failed me just now during the quiz, but they do work when the conditions are right. Also in our defense, ii-V-I is way more common than ii-IV-I so after identifying ii, V is already expected.

Playing the chords on the piano as they came up in the songs was such a nice touch! As a piano player, identifying the chords where there is no piano or keyboard accompaniment is always an added challenge, so it was nice not having to worry about them in this instance. It gets even more difficult when the song does not start on tonic (it usually doesn't I think) and chords are never explicitly played but implied or just played in an unusual or complex way. One thing I'd add is that for most genres, identifying the bass helps immensely, as it's almost always the root if there is a bass player. Even for inversions and slash chords it helps to figure out the rest, I'd say. Otherwise I guess it mostly comes down to familiarity or if that doesn't work, fiddling on your main instrument. Either way, this video is a very good play to start.👍

I've been waiting for this video since I was 13, now I'm 27. So thanks a lot. Best teacher ever.

David there is something incredibly soothing about the way your videos make so many abstract concepts concrete enough to where I feel I can finally make good use of them in my songwriting!! Many thanks!

This is awesome! Working out chords by ear is a skill I've been trying to develop lately and this will help a lot. Think you could do a similar video focused on minor keys?

@DavidBennettPiano

5 ай бұрын

That’s the plan! It will be coming out soon 😊

@ProductiveMindfulness

2 ай бұрын

Just realized it's actually out: kzread.info/dash/bejne/l4ynurKzh9y8pc4.html (FYI)

Man so grateful to stumble upon your channel. How clear your explanations are, the way you play while you talking about the chord and how you play the chord over the example song really helps to a novice like me. Thank you sir!

Your channel has been a game-changer for me! Thanks to your effective teaching. Because of your videos, I've gotten really good at identifying intervals with ease. My ears, once struggling, now confidently pick up on musical nuances. Excited to delve into this video and implement it into my practice routine - your guidance has made learning relative pitch a step by step process that even I can follow and making playing songs by ear a reality for me! Please keep doing what you're doing! Your videos are extremely invaluable!

I'm currently teaching on of my students how to recognize chord progressions by ear so this video couldn't have come out at a better time! Very well put together. I will have to send this to them as another thing to learn from!

Before I even finished watching this video I already learned a ton from it and already used one of the ideas on a piece of music I'm writing that I was stuck on. This video really got me thinking differently about chord progressions and I thank you immensely.

Loved tha! Thank you sooo much David for sharing all your insight.and knowledge. I always look forward to your amazing videos. 👍

You keep outdoing yourself! This is one of the best easily-accessable music theory resources out in the world now. Very excited for your overview of minor progressions.

Excellent tutorials David, thank you. I remember having a light bulb moment with music theory when I went to a particular tutor in my 30’s when suddenly everything just made sense. He taught in a similar way to you and I’d imagine many people out there are now having this light bulb moment too. Good work!

Oh, man... the "and the world would live as the I chord" was amazingly genius. The world would live as complete, at rest, in peace... as the I chord. That captures the whole ethics of "Imagine". Brilliant.

This is my favourite youtube channel by far. Thanks for all the hard work!

Excellent as always. In addition to your explanation there are also chord inversions (major, minor, 7ths), diminished/augmented chords and other mixes (like IV on V). When I analyze a new song I listen to the chord progression like you explained but I also listen to the bass line at the same time. Once I nail down the correct bass note, I usually have only a couple of options for building the right chord on top of the bass. This is usually a 1-3-5 (basic chord) but it could be a chord inversion like 1-3-6 or 1-4-6. For example, when starting with C major, you'll notice the bass jumps to E and then to F. The 2nd chord may sound like a iii (Em) but in this case it's actually the same C chord, played using the 2nd inversion (E-G-C or 1-3-6). The only difference from the iii chord is the C note instead of B. These are subtle differences that require some practice in order to identify correctly.

Thank you for this video! Enjoyable watch and it really helped me to study non-tonic chords. The examples of songs really help and the descriptions of the different sounds and functions of the chorsds. Enjoyed the small exercise at the end aswell.

David, THANK YOU for doing exactly this! Ear training is so important, but so also is understanding how these chord progression choices affect us W/R/T mood and emotion. It's something that probably doesn't get taught enough in formal music studies. And using examples from popular songs that (most) everybody recognizes really firmly takes the ideas from theoretical to real-world.

This is the best interval training video I've found. Thank you mate.

Great video! Love the idea of linking songs that we already know to the chord progressions we're learning.

I loved a little quiz at the end. it definitely encouraged me to be a more active participant. Often times I find myself just listening, but never applying.

Absolutely superb David. Thank you. I look forward to your exploration of minor key chords. Alan ❤

David, every video I watch of yours makes me a better musician. Thank you

Thanks for the Great lesson David, it was inspiring to see/hear all of those chord substitutions!

really great stuff man. Thank you for putting names to these sounds and including so many clear examples and explanations! So helpful for ear training and so fun to jam along to ^^

Been waiting for this for awhile - thank you David!

@DavidBennettPiano

5 ай бұрын

Thanks!

Love it as always. If you ever get a chance, and its totally cool if not, but I'd love to see a video of songs that dont "resolve" in a traditional sense. One of my favorites its Flowers Never Bend by Simon & Garfunkel and even when I've heard it a billion times, that last chord is always so unsettling and I love it. I dont know of any more songs that do that. Further more I'd love to hear your take on why a song would end like that. I'm sure at that point its more artistic stylistic choice than anything. But yeah, I dont believe ive ever seen a video that covers something like that.

@DavidBennettPiano

5 ай бұрын

Nice idea! I’ll keep it in mind 😊

@JanTangring

5 ай бұрын

0:18 to

@zzzaphod8507

5 ай бұрын

@@DavidBennettPiano "For No One" as well

@eltieum

5 ай бұрын

@evenglare : most iconic one I got in mind : "We are the champions" by queen, studio version : Remains on a suspended chord like a v7add11 or something.

@esmenard

5 ай бұрын

Opening by Philip Glass, it just keeps going forever at that point even tonic chords don't feel like resolutions

These videos are so helpful. I learnt metal guitar from tabs as a youth so never connected any of the theory. This is filling in all the gaps for me. I proclaim thee Mister Chords and salute you , sir!

you should just only give us radiohead and beatles examples at this point lmao, great video david btw: i want u to make videos on exotic scales and modes (like pentatonic or melodic minor modes)

Wowow half hour video???? Incredible. You’re amazing David!!!

@DavidBennettPiano

5 ай бұрын

Thank you! 😊

Amazing video!! Thank you so much for this!! Keep on doing the great work! Give us more! Cheers from Brazil!

This video is phenomenal & perfectly produced in every way. I am over here ripping up these progs on my Jazzmaster, through my dreamy-sounding pedalboard, then to my HRD IV + HRD Ext Cab, and into the world. . . OMGGG DUDEEE! 🙌🏻 Your approach is straightforward & results-driven, and you possess expert-level knowledge while being humble & cool AF - ALL THRILLER, NO FILLER! You are a superstar, David Bennett. I have never told anyone that but myself, so believe the hype. The other KZreadrs should take lessons from YOU, good sir. Then, they might learn how to become a legend. Thank you for sharing - Have a new subscriber, won't you? Finally, somebody on KZread gets it. Keep crushin' it, David Bennett. YOLT. 😎🤜🏼💥🤛🏼🔮

thankyou for this excellent lesson. while listening and absorbimg your tutorial one thought came to my mind, actually a quote by Giorgio Moroder: "Once you free your mind about the concept of harmony and of music being correct, you can do whatever you want" and i think he was right about that. you are doing an awesome job here!

I got them all ! NOT to brag, but I did surprise myself, as it would ordinarily take me a few minutes with an instrument. They must have just all been fresh enough in my head. I'd agree that such ear training practices are quite beneficial . BTW, there is this REAL nifty little tune in "G" by the Solo Acoustic Guitar Instrumental Virtuoso Tommy Emmanuel called "Only Elliot". That I'd like to hear your(or anyone's) take on. Here are the Chords: G - C - F#m7 - "G#m7" - Em7 - C - D/F# - G. & In your prefered notation ?: I - IV - iiv7(#5) - "bii7" - vi - IV - V/7 - I. I'm not sure how this particular notation ought to deal with everything. Like for instance, is the #5 necessary in the 3rd chord(of the progression) F#m7, where the 7th chord of a key is normally half diminished ? & for the slash chords(my preference bc they just contain more info) should the bass note after the / be what degree of the key or the chord itself ? For the D/F#, which is 7th chord(in the progression), I put V/7 bc F# is the 7th note of the key of G. But should it be V/#4 where the F# is relative to the V/C Chord in question ? IMO ALL such notations face some issues so I just prefer to write them out & transpose when necessary. Anyway, here is my MAIN question. The 3rd chord, F#m7 is pretty common, I suppose it would just temporarily suggest Dorion or Lydian. & I can think of many songs in C that use Bm or Bm7 for instance. BUT the 4th Chord(of the song) G#m7 the bii is what I'd call the "money chord" here. Off hand, I can't say I've EVER seen it used before, even after giving it some thought. & it sounds ENTIRELY natural here ! Any thoughts ? ANY & ALL analyzations would be greatly appreciated. Thanks ! Great chan BTW.

Wow thank you so much, as a sec taught piano player trying to dip into songwriting I have watched DOZENS of videos to try and piece together this information. Supremely helpful

This video is my turning point of playing music and composing, simply change my life. Thank you !

This was fantastic!! Coming up with chord progressions, it’s so easy to get stuck in ruts. This gives me some great ideas on ways to mix things up

@DavidBennettPiano

5 ай бұрын

Great to hear!

More of these quizzes please! I’m improving a lot but it’s hard to find good practice

@fiscaldisco5234

Ай бұрын

I came back to this after loads of hook theory and tone gym and got 100%. First time I tried I think I got 0%. Thanks for the great recommendations!!

Your videos are fantastic David. Thank you

14:23 - The flat-II chord is also known, in Common-Practice Theory, as “Neapolitan.” Usually it’s in first inversion, thus it’s called “Neapolitan 6” (“6” being the figured bass for first-inversion).

I am kinda surprised that I got them all right. The last example was the easiest, but only because I recognized it immediately as the same exact progression in an instrumental song that I wrote. As a singer-songwriter-guitarist, I am always thinking about ways to write unique chord progressions that are catchy, compelling, interesting, and most importantly, they not only match the mood and feeling, but also add a new dimension that takes the listener on a journey, but ultimately, if it's not authentically original, then it's never going to be a song that I will be happy with, and that is what is most important to me!!! Thank you for your fascinating and informative videos!!!

Only progressions that seemed to get me were the final two but I still really liked how they sounded, I’m definitely going to use those in my own music because they sounded really cool

This was great! Love the illustrations

This was fantastic David! I'd love to see a followup on chords from the perspective of a minor key.

@jackwimbish

5 ай бұрын

Just saw at the end you're already on it, excellent!

Exactly this type of videos are the very Best. About chord progressions and kind of from the practical and theorytical point of view at the same time,many thanks😊😊😊

@DavidBennettPiano

5 ай бұрын

Thanks 😊

Wow! Very informative, concise, and impactful.. I failed the test miserably, only got the first two correct. But extremely helpful and am looking forward to your minor key lesson. Kudos mate!

@derek_williams

3 ай бұрын

Similar result for me. Although the explanation was excellent, it doesn't result in immediate capability!

Looking forward the next part, thanks a lot.

Really useful post David. Looking forward to the minor one, thanks

@DavidBennettPiano

5 ай бұрын

Glad you enjoyed it 😃😃

Thank you for this! I've been struggling to learn this

@DavidBennettPiano

5 ай бұрын

Happy to help!

This is a real treat! Thanks David!

@DavidBennettPiano

5 ай бұрын

Thanks!

I am happy to See that someone finally made a Video that gives the Knowledge that is really relevant.

Thank you for such a insightful video on music progressions on ear training, thank you...✔️😌🌟

Thank you, really helpful! Best regards from Argentina

Good stuff as always. I would love to see a similar video where you focus on chords in inversions. e.g. How Tonic in first inversion differs from second inversion, etc. That would be a fun ear training challenge!

The moment i heard you play the A chord from stand by me, i paused and ran through the song in my head, figured out it was I-vi-IV-V, and went "...wait... How did i know how to do that?" You, sir, are a wonderful teacher.

Thank you, love this kind of content!

Thank you, it was fun refreshing my college theory classes. You stumped me on the thord from last and the last chord progression. I'm rusty but still mostly have it. Cheers.

I got them all correct 😊 And I definetly agree with you that being able to identify chords in a progression is a very valuable skill for a musician.👌

@DavidBennettPiano

5 ай бұрын

Great job!

Bro having found your channel is one of greatest God’s Grace

You did a great job on all the chords with this tutorial

@David Bennett Piano - Your videos are so good, dude

TYSM UR VIDS R SOO VERY MOTIVATING

Fantastic as always! I’d like to watch a video about song structure some day. Love from Japan☀️

One of the best videos I’ve ever seen on KZread Dave, you’re really without an equal around here my friend

Thank you alot. You are amazing teacher👌🏻

You're such a brilliant man!

Excellent video 👍. The iii always sounds to me like it's the first step on a journey; appropriate for Space Oddity both thematically and for the chords that follow.

This was a super masterclass! Thxu u🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽

Thanks for this amazing video!

A couple cool examples of the bV are "Humming" by Portishead and "Don't Be Light" by Air.

It's a gem 💎 of video just on so many levels.

@DavidBennettPiano

8 күн бұрын

Thank you!!

That I-iii-vi-ii progression sounded familiar, and now i know why: its the chorus of now and then

I do mashups for fun on soundcloud because I discovered I have a natural tendency to recognize chord progressions. I'd be listening to music in a pub, or at work, and something clicks in my head: "Hey, that sounds like (X) song". I write them down, on paper or phone, and mix them when I get home.

great stuff David, inspiring us all :) (minor note: secondary dominants want to go a fifth _down_). loved the examples and the quiz!

I love that v sound. I think it just reflects who I am a bit personally. I love playing almost that exact same progression with the Gmin being a Gm11 and adding a Bbsus2 and Gbmaj7 to create more movement. I also like to pull it back home with a bassline to make that progression even more interesting.

4:43 - Songs that go between the relative major and minor chords are fun, particularly when you can't be quite sure whether the "home" key is major or minor. A great example of this is Talking Heads's "Road To Nowhere".

It's a great great ear training experience. I'm happy that i can hear these chord changes 30:26 Got the last 😊

Wonderful video David 👍😁

I really wish I had this skill. I've wasted so much time looking for the written sheet music just to figure out the chord progressions. My main problem is with the inversions. As the chords moved down but the top note stays the same I'm like, "Oh no, now where am I?" I get lost. Can't wait for your next video.

This was a fantastic video...I will watch over and over again..so much useful information.. this was a musically nutritious video.. it was full of lots of meat and potatoes... well done David..cheers !

Thanks man. That is super helpful.

This is brilliant ❤

thanks so much, it's so very helpful!

You really open my ears, thank you very much.

David Bemnet out with yet another banger! 🔥🔥🔥

@DavidBennettPiano

5 ай бұрын

Thanks 😃😃

impressive teaching. great content

This is a highly educational and valuable video. I followed the music theory, but my ear is not sophisticated enough to recognize the progressions. So, my score was zero. However, I still learned plenty and I will continue to watch your excellent videos.

thank you very much for doing these videos!!

@DavidBennettPiano

5 ай бұрын

Thanks for watching 😌😌

An interesting quirk of having perfect pitch is that, in my experience, it actually makes learning to listen for chord relationships harder. My brain tries to process the specific notes being played, which makes it harder to listen to the quality of the chords relative to each other. But even so, this video was really helpful!

5/5. Great job, David.

@DavidBennettPiano

5 ай бұрын

😃😃

Thank you David 🎵🎵🙏

@DavidBennettPiano

2 ай бұрын

Thank you!!

Happy to say I got 5/5 :D Playing piano for a couple years definitely helps haha. Another brilliant video! absolutely essential for those of us who wish to be able to learn songs by ear. I still learn songs with Sheet Music but there's something about being able to hear a tune and pick it out that just feels incredibly satisfying, not to mention its great practice for the ear.

Excellent That was great Thank you 😊

@DavidBennettPiano

5 ай бұрын

Thanks!