It’s impossible for me to reply to all your comments, but I read them all, and I am eternally grateful for your love and support. Become a patron and sponsor free English education here: bit.ly/CanguroPatreon Buy official Canguro English merchandise here: bit.ly/CanguroMerchandise

@user-rj6kn4vi6b

4 жыл бұрын

What is it like to be the best teacher in the world? Thanks for what you do, Cris.

@frankpitt2257

4 жыл бұрын

You are still alive? 😲

@user-rj6kn4vi6b

4 жыл бұрын

@@frankpitt2257 what are you talking about?

@edgarleona7820

3 жыл бұрын

1111q111y 11

@edgarleona7820

3 жыл бұрын

1

I am Brazilian, I am happy to learn English with you Professor Cristian. I am retired, my life project was to learn English. My life has another meaning now. English is part of my life

@RhenanMartinsRepoem

4 ай бұрын

Por aqui também.

Sometimes we don't see that the easiest way to say something is just being clear and no complex at all. In all language and culture is the same. Gracias maestro!

I'm a very beginner of English.I don't know how but, the way you talk is like you talking to my "brain". so, that is very easy to understand. Thank you.

Thank you!

Amazing class, thank you!

Thank you for this explanation: of and ing, THANK YOU!

Very interesting this class, thank you! I spent one hour analyzing the structures, and Iearned a lot.

Thank you for your amazing English tips!

Great tips!

Thank you Christian!your work is inspiring!!!

Thank you Christian! I want more similar examples! It feels easier to understand this sentences with you than all alone

Very precise explanation ever. Thanks for it.

Necesitamos más profesores como él

As always extremely good!

Fantastic approach! Your videos always make me a reflection.

Todos somos extraños. Todos estamos luchando por aprender unos de otros. Si conoces a tantas personas a las que les resulta extraño tu acento, debes demostrarles cuánto te esfuerzas e intentas aprender a comunicarte con ellos. Entonces, no eres tú quien es extraño. Pero su actitud muestra una falta de aprecio y comprensión. Usted no es el que necesita cambiar, está trabajando duro y merece muchos elogios. Yo mismo estudio "Español" e "Inglés", y sé muy poco todavía, pero no me importan ni me preocupan comentarios como ese. Mi idioma es portugués-brasileño y sigo estudiando portugués, porque nadie lo sabe todo. Estudio cuatro idiomas. Y si un dia alguien viene a burlarse de mí, no hablo su idioma correctamente, le preguntaré si sabe todo tu idioma, cuántos idiomas hablas y si sabes algo del mío. Vaya, estoy luchando por aprender su idioma. Felicitaciones a ti por intentarlo. Soy Dorgival Dantas Brito, 49 años, Músico, Cantante y Compositor, Brasileño. Vivo en São Paulo. ========================== We are all strangers. We are all struggling to learn from each other. If you know so many people who find your accent strange, you need to show them how hard you are trying and trying to learn to communicate with them. So, it is not you who is strange. But their attitude shows a lack of appreciation and understanding. You are not the one who needs to change - you are working hard and deserve much praise. I study "Español" and "Inglés" myself, and I know very little yet, but I don't care or worry about comments like that. My Languages ​​is Portuguese-Brazil, and I continue to study Portuguese, because, nobody knows everything. I study four languages. And if, one day, someone comes to make fun of me, I don't speak their language correctly, I will ask if he or she knows all of your language, how many languages ​​do you speak and if you know anything about mine? Why, I'm struggling to learn her language. Congratulations to you that you are trying. I am Dorgival Dantas Brito, 49 years old, Musician, Singer and Composer, Brazilian. I live in Sao Paulo.

thanks sir.

Thank you, Christian! You make a complex sentences is simple! Thank you for your creative approach to classes!

Thanks again Christian! As always, nice lesson "nocturnal and elliptical".

I love your videos. Thank you!

Brilliant explanation 👍Thank you!

Good video. Thank you.

That was amazing! Thx a lot

Thanks!!!

Great! I really enjoyed this

It was the best video that a have saw recently... or not recently. Amazing!

Thanks Christian!

I had never heard about the preposition + verb rule. And it's so simple... Now I get it! Thanks for teaching that in such an easy way to us!

As a teacher and student I may say: bravo! 👏🏻 Inspirational lesson, thanks

very useful lessen, thank you

I understood at 9:00 ,. You can explain complicated things to everyone and no matter which level of English people have got. Thank you Christian 😊

I appreciate it

What a incredible video

Thanks for sharing this was an interesting video.

Thank You! )

Today is the best day of the week!!

Really nice!

you are the best teacher!

Hi Christian It's really a great topic. Thanks for it.

Such a good lesson👍👍👍🌷

Great teacher, greetings from Argentina.

That's great

Great video, really! Kudos. Structure is the real *core* of grammar and, as a consequence, of languages. Understanding it, is understanding language.

Wow, this exactly my style of expressing in Spanish

Hello, Christian! Thank you so much! Ok. I know how much a teacher can be busy. Take care of yourself and, as soon as possible, I will buy something here to support you. A hug.

Brilliant

Great great and again great🔥🔥🔥

Hi Christian, could you please make more videos on creating meaningful sentences without repetition and complex sentence structure? Your teaching is fun and inspiring, Thank you! 😊

We love your articulative pronunciation!

One the most interesting class I ever had with you, Cris!!! Congratulations!!!

@Canguroenglish

4 жыл бұрын

Glad you liked it!

Your lessons isn't borring. The lessons are very interesting. It's worth noting, the lessons are also extrimely useful. It seems to me , you aren't a native speaker. But it only better for me. I understand you very well. You speak English very clearly. Thank you for lessons😁

Thanks Christian! It solved many sentences I never understood 😊. Can you do more of this video analysing "complex" sentences? Just missing the meaning of "being" as a noun 🤔

Through you my life has changed.I was wondering why anyone doesn't make a video on this. Some tried to make this kind of video but there is something about your video that allows us to peek through the great Wall of language which we beginners face.Thank you.I am really grateful to you today And most importantly KEEP IT UP we want more videos on complex structures and how to understand high professional books in English Thank you. Supporting you from Bangladesh

I don't knew that technique in English grammar, but I loved it, because help us to understand complex sentences of a funny way. Thanks for you help teacher, you are the best! :D

It helps me a lot =) thanks

Amazing content, thanks Christian :)

You are amazing

Dear, hope you, kindly, make an elaborate video concerning prepositions, particularly regarding for, of, about and the interchangeable use of some of them plus how to differentiate between various usages?

Amazing English tips.... 👍 your neighbors 🇫🇷

I love canguru so much

I love this type of videos because i am trying to prepar my B2 exam. Any advice for writing part? many thanks....

I love your videos! Can you tell me what grammar point is the one you takled about in this video :"of + noun + verb -ing? Its a very interesting strcuture

Hi I am from syria. I love your videos because you are smart.

Gucci video sir I am fan of your learning style.

Tal vez el mejor canal de ingles que he visto

@Tony32

4 жыл бұрын

Definitivamente.

Great lesson! How is your health Christian after COVID19?

'BEING' is not a noun here. It's a Present Participle (adjective) modifying the noun 'mind'. 'Be of something' here means 'comes from something' or 'belongs to something'... so I would rephrase it as: a useful analogy comes from the mind which (that) is like the sky.

@BlissAndGoodness

3 жыл бұрын

Yep, it makes more sense now. Thanks

@jankovarik9116

3 жыл бұрын

This solves the riddle :). It wasn't clear from the video to me. The problem was this “be of sth“. Cheers

@irynaodulo3543

3 жыл бұрын

I think 'mind' is an adj.(it's impossible in Russan), and 'being' is a noun.

Good morning Christian. I love when you laugh at the beginning of the video, it makes me laugh too

The moral of today's video is that "complex sentences are to facilitate our comprehension", at first sounds crazy but your wise explanation clarifies all, now we can only practice in order to absorb these concepts.

Hi there Christian, May I request a video on "Being" usage in Full. Thank you

A useful analogy is being like the sky!! :D Thoughts of a ballerina!! Simple and fun!

Hello Christian, can we eliminate the first " and " at 11:50 and put a coma instead?

It is a reduced relative clause. 'A useful analogy is the mind which is like the sky' can be reduced to ' a useful analogy is the mind being like the sky'. For example, 'another example is a man who is like a superhero' can be reduced to 'another example is a man being like a superhero'.

i like always your mood on online class

Hey, Christian, would love to hear your thoughts about Arrival, the movie. Could you make a video about it, maybe?? That would be amazing. Anyway, thanks for what you are doing, love you =)

@Canguroenglish

4 жыл бұрын

Best movie ever!

@jakemaltz1780

4 жыл бұрын

@@Canguroenglish ohmygod!! So glad you liked it!!

I had a slightly different way to take it before your explanation. I see the phrase "an useful analogy is of [the mind being like the sky]" as a sort of metonymy by reduction (I just googled, it's called synecdoche, the use of a part for the whole): what would make this a metonymy is the fact that the only way to produce an analogy is by means of thinking, so the act of thinking can be implied and become redundant. Hence the whole sentence would be "an useful analogy is THINKING of [the mind being like the sky]", and in turn, since we now have the verb, it's clear that the object is the name of an action (or the non copulative verb "to be") to be compared among alike things. Following the same line, I believe a step further should be valid, once already known we're talking of the mind: "an useful analogy is of the sky", since this is another valid metonymy: the only way to make an analogy is to compare two objects that must be alike, so by mentioning just one object the second must be the one being discussed (the mind), and since there's no action, it'd imply we're talking of either an already discussed action (not the case) or the fact of just being alike.

Wow. I need to watch this video 2 o 3 more times.🎉😅

❤️❤️❤️

Н= Your lesson is like a ray of light

Words "blitzes" and "tamp" written down on my personal vocabulary notebook (y)

That is an excellent explanation. Much better than fobbing off the student who dares to ask such questions with the stock phrase: "It's because English is like that"....... ;-)

@Canguroenglish

4 жыл бұрын

Thank you sir.

This coments are so interresting to avoid repitition

Being like the sky is a present participle(adjective) which is providing some extra info about the noun "the mind" and this is what i know about this sentence..!🤔🤔

@beyzanura6772

4 жыл бұрын

I don't understand noun+gerund Mind being It is weird. I do not the structure

@phumkiatwananuraksakul7815

4 жыл бұрын

I agreed with you completely as present participaial phrase acting as an adjective modifying noun phrase,the mind, come from reduced adjective clause:which or that is like the sky by chance ommiting which or that as relative pronoun then changing verb to be "is"to be base form and putting ing

Can I use a semicolon instead of "and that"?

It's good to see Christian again. 😁

Could you please teach us how to use punctuation marks? Because when I write complicated sentences my teacher says that I have a lot of mistakes. Sometimes I have to write essays and I don't feel comfortable writing them. Please... I really like your classes, thank you for all 👍

@ichbinhier355

4 жыл бұрын

Search for run on sentences 😉

The level of language input (listening) must be higher than the level of language production

@emolitvin

4 жыл бұрын

Absolutely agree with you

@kellybesen312

4 жыл бұрын

It depends on the objectives...

@elkyubi4281

4 жыл бұрын

Not necessary, a deaf person can acquire the ability of reading-writing.

@neigarcia5008

4 жыл бұрын

I agre with you if that sentence were " the level of language input ( understending) must be higher than the level of language production becose in all language we understend better than producing it.

@MarcoAntonio-zu2zr

4 жыл бұрын

I love it.great explanation by far.

Smell like a verb 😂😂😂😂🤭🤭🤭 made my day 🤣🤣🤣

Somehow I missed the feature of the word "and" being a conjunction?

Why not say: And a useful analogy of the mind IS being like the sky?

@elkyubi4281

4 жыл бұрын

Because is an analysis of that style of communicating, you could apply your sentence without any complication.

@fernandoalba1463

4 жыл бұрын

@@juluatanaya thanks a lot for your explanation 🤝🏽

@peterbutter2054

4 жыл бұрын

@@juluatanaya Well explained. Thank you.

@marcosdiez7263

4 жыл бұрын

Actually, IMO, since the only way to make an analogy is by means of a thinking process, the redundant way to put it would be "an useful analogy is TO THINK OF the mind being like the sky", the "of" here assume it is implied we're talking of thinking and the byproduct of the thinking process by which you make the purposed comparison between the mind and the sky.

analogy is of mind - mindable analogy? This 'is of' is quite tricky. From the context i understood that author sees mind as skylike. But 'is of' confuses me. It could mean that all he explained above is made up out of his skylike mind. Cambridge dictionary says this is English level C2 by the way.

Yeee

:-) The grifty snolls cloppered raucingly along the unchoofed trake. They were klary, so they higgled on sperately. “Ah, chiwar kervay,” they squopped rehoply, “Mi psar Quaj!” “Quaj!” snilled one, and filted even jucklier.

Would it not be consistent to say 'predicate', 'subject' and 'object' rather than 'verb' and 'noun' whilst one refers to parts of sentence and not of speech?

@Canguroenglish

4 жыл бұрын

Yes, but I try to keep the explanations as simple as possible. ❤️

Thanks Christian. Is it correct : “AND A USEFUL...” ?? It should be: “AND AN USEFUL...”. In that phrase sounds rare “IS OF”, I wouldn’t use OF.

@beyzanura6772

4 жыл бұрын

Yuseful so it has to a useful Like, a university An honest

@lilianagallo8771

4 жыл бұрын

Beyzanur ack Thank you. Yes. Google says: “Question: A useful or an useful? Answer: A useful. Although U is a vowel, the pronunciation of useful begins with a Y sound (yoos-ful) which is a consonant sound.

wouldn't it be better to keep the second "the mind" to ensure the focus is not put on "a useful analogy"?

I like a phrase that I didn't know that English has a gerund, while I didn't be a teacher.

Source of the confusion: "A useful analogy is of the mind". How about rearranging the last part of the sentence a little like-"A useful analogy of the mind is being like the sky," instead of "A useful analogy is of the mind being like the sky".

@peterbutter2054

4 жыл бұрын

Grammatically, both are correct. If I hadn't seen that original sentence, I would say a useful analogy of the mind is being like the sky. However, they carry different meanings. "A useful analogy of the mind is being like the sky" emphases the analogy. But "a useful analogy is of the mind being like the sky" emphases the mind. The analogy can't be like sky, but the mind can, right?

why do you need "of" I would write that sentence without the "of". Does analogy need the prep "of"?