This is crazy. To think I've lived 32 years without ever realizing that dogs constantly hear a piano playing in their heads.

@Sushbearious

Жыл бұрын

😆

@wildchildliving

Жыл бұрын

😂😂

@budakbaongsiah

Жыл бұрын

THEY GOT BGMs PLAYING FOR THEM AUTOMATICALLY!? HOW CAN WE EVOLVE TO SUCH A GRAND BEING!?

@antugino136

Жыл бұрын

LOL right a piano and a xylophone.

@Noah-ig2qc

Жыл бұрын

lmao

I had a Dachshund who went blind. He could find his way from across the street, through the yard, right to the back yard gate. He'd take a few steps, tilt his head, reorient himself, take more steps, repeating the process. One day the two water fountains in the front and side yards were not running. Instead of finding his way, he walked in circles, completely lost and confused. I realized then, *he used the sound of the fountains to triangulate his path to the gate.* My mind is still blown by watching this little dog do more complicated math, in his head, than I can without a calculator.

@Aaron628318

2 жыл бұрын

In a sense this is the audio equivalent of vision - using reflections of ambient noise. I understand that submarines use this 'passive sonar' to remain incognito.

@foxboy64

2 жыл бұрын

your dog isnt really doing math, thats not how the instinctual perception of space and proprioception works. there's technically math going into you being able to catch a ball without looking at your hand the whole way, but you're not doing calculations like you would do with trigonometry. you just kind of instinctually know where your hand is and how far you have to move it to catch the ball. as someone whos vision impaired (not blind but i certainly dont see as well as everyone else, even corrected), i do the same sort of thing all the time. mostly in online gaming, the spatial perception of sound really helps fill in the gaps my sight leaves out. say for instance in a shooter, with a few turns of the "characters head" (looking left and right, kinda the equivalent of a dog head tilt.) i can work out almost exactly where in space a set of footsteps is coming from. i do this in real life as well when trying to pinpoint a sound i cant see. so i found Benn's mention that humans dont do the head tilt kind of funny, because i certainly do it. anyway the point is, im not calculating any numbers in my head to work that out. its just a passive skill you pick up when your other senses have to compensate for bad sight. its like how your eyes have to coordinate to both look at the same object in order to perceive its 3d space, but with your ears instead.

@CatwithFancyHat

2 жыл бұрын

​@@foxboy64 Well Benn was probably talking about humans without vision impairment, he only said we aren't born with this ability. But as you said, we can certainly develop it to compensate for something damaged in our perception, but evolution never felt the need to give us an instinct from birth that makes our head tilt to compensate for a lack of "3D hearing" (can't come up with a better word).

@D-C1

2 жыл бұрын

@@foxboy64 I also find it amazing that your hearing is the first sense to develope in the womb and the last sense to stop working at time of death. I've always considered my hearing more important than my sight. I'm a musician, so that probably has a lot to do with it.

@Raelven

2 жыл бұрын

@@foxboy64 Awesome explanation, thank you! I know he wasn't really calculating, but he was so smart, it wouldn't shock me. I am sure he outsmarted me, many times. Again, thanks for the clarification, I appreciate your time and have a better understanding. 👍

I always thought “I wonder how this thing sees the world” but never “I wonder how this thing hears things” I just assumed every animal just heard sounds the same speed but louder or quieter than other animals

@ShwappaJ

22 күн бұрын

I just wanna know how skeletons can hear tbh

@user-pq4il4xo9s

17 күн бұрын

​@@ShwappaJthey can't

@NickHaus683

13 күн бұрын

@@ShwappaJExplain the joke

@eliasniwert3680

8 күн бұрын

Its propably because we usually only talk about vision. It is by far the most used sense that we have. Without vision we lose about 80% of our perception. For this dog it might not have been nearly as mindblowing as for you

@ShwappaJ

7 күн бұрын

@@user-pq4il4xo9s r/whoosh

A note about flies: they also sense changes in air pressure extremely well which is why a lattice-like object that allows air to flow through it, such as a swatter, can reliably hit flies when swung fast but a solid, flat object like an open palm is telegraphed from a fly-mile away. coincidentally an object moving slower creates less of a disturbance in air pressure.

Crazy to think they’re still our best friends when we are so slow to them lol.

@lenonel3286

Жыл бұрын

If you had a giant friend who fed you, scratched you and gave you a home, wouldn't you put up with him eventhough he's a bit slower than you?

@tavonfenwick-yb5xv

Жыл бұрын

What does one thing have to do with the other?

@ivyme5783

Жыл бұрын

They are born with this perception, they don't care Humans still love dogs even though dogs tend to do things that are disgusting to us Like sniffing butts

@stiepanholkien605

11 ай бұрын

Crazy he didn't think to record this vid in 60fps.

@originaluseername

11 ай бұрын

“Crazy” ok OK we get it you don’t understand that that’s a word rooted in ableism no need to do what everyone else is doing

I'm not convinced that the frequency of sound would be different to dogs or other animals. Unlike computers, we actually have different parts of our cochleas that are sensitive to different frequencies. So I think the pitch of our voices would remain the same for dogs, but it would just seem that we're talking more slowly.

@JohnZ-

2 жыл бұрын

It’s more that his editing program deepens the pitch when the video clip is slowed down

@yosefmacgruber1920

2 жыл бұрын

@@JohnZ- Strangely, due to digital sound processing, playback speed can be changed independently of frequency. Even some digital answering machines can do this. It seemed like he reduced the pitch of his voice, more so than any slowdown of playback speed could have accounted for? Like maybe sound-editing on a computer.

@Stinckyfatmama

2 жыл бұрын

And since they don’t understand English, you could use some ai software to giberize the audio so the tone and cadence are the same but it’s just essentially unintelligible.

@ChristopherWoods

2 жыл бұрын

I believe the reality is that dogs (and other animals) will actually hear a wider sound spectrum with a different frequency bias (see the Fletcher Munson Curve); the perceived loudness of human speech for example may not be as prominent, though they have become attuned to human speech through evolution and breeding. Dogs interpret pitch and intonation and have been demonstrated to read human faces for cues. No doubt that their temporal resolution and reaction times are vastly superior though, much like cats. My understanding of human temporal resolution is that it's actually more nuanced than just saying it rolls off at 60 Hz; I can clearly see the difference between 60 and 90/100 Hz for example. Above that, at least on my high refresh monitor, I can't reliably test due to the inherent limitations of IPS panels. But I can absolutely see at a faster refresh than 60 Hz. Whether my brain is able to react as fast is another matter, largely dependent on attentiveness and whatever is occupying active thought processes (e.g. how talking on a phone while driving or focusing on a satnav reduces spatial awareness).

@yosefmacgruber1920

2 жыл бұрын

​@@ChristopherWoods Wouldn't dogs become attuned to human speech because they like us and due to familiarity? We humans probably smell funny and talk funny, but they do not much care about that, because they like us. I have long wanted to write a modern GUI OS for my first computer, my Apple //e, that I bought in 1985. I have estimated that in its highest resolution, double-high-resolution graphics, if I could straight copy from memory, at just 1 MHz CPU, I could only get about 5 frames per second, faster if I only have to redraw a smaller portion of the screen. That is because the loop cycle time uses about 12 clock cycles, and an entire 16K block of RAM data has to be copied to the video RAM buffer again and again. Back in the day, that would have been almost enough to do a 3-D game, if I could somehow approach that in my game. It wouldn't be too terribly bad for scrolling a stylized text screen. Not quite the "instant" response of modern computers, but a mere fifth of a second. And repeat arrow keys hold-down or presses could be combined into greater-distance scrolls so as to keep up. Certainly a calm game like _Myst_ could work with such a low frame rate. But if I only wanted to make the screen flash, I could maybe boost it to 6 or 7 frames a second, since I wouldn't have to load new data into the CPU's registers. Or it could be much faster by switching to a lower-resolution screen. It wasn't that long ago that 24 frames a second for film in the movie theater, was plenty fast. Maybe the flicker is noticeable, but still motion appears to be motion.

I have a degree in neuroscience & physiology and have studied animal physiology, and have never heard an insects' lungless respiratory system referred to as a consequence of their flicker fusion frequency. This feels like when I accidentally wound up in computational neurobiology as a sophomore with senior engineers who were being given an intro to neuro in the hopes of working on the computing side of medical research, and me chiming in with my accurate but slightly different physiological perspective of only two years into neuro. I love and live for interdisciplinary work and am jiving with this content.

@danpowell3953

3 ай бұрын

I don’t think their respiratory system is necessarily a consequence of their flicker fusion frequency. They may have evolved independently or are both the consequence of a high metabolism and avoidance of danger. I do appreciate your love of multi-disciplinary investigations though.

@v4riab1lity77

Ай бұрын

All work should be interdisciplinary I think… I fucking hate specialization as I view it as a critical failure point for any civilization, and a cause for a huge load of our modern day issues. Because people in one field know jack shit about anything in ANY others. Fundamental education should be rounded and generalized, only slightly ellipsing the further into your education you get. Right now? Just nothing but strings. All getting tangled and wrestling eachother barbarically

@Marzimus

29 күн бұрын

I picked up half of what you put down.. 😂

@kepspark3362

27 күн бұрын

​@@v4riab1lity77 I agree.

@doggoadexx2680

26 күн бұрын

Jfc I don’t understand anything ur saying

12:34 with the amount of times I’ve rewinded just to be able to process everything he’s saying, seemingly so quickly, has helped me to understand one thing: I am slow.

@robinmeader5585

21 күн бұрын

Ha! Me too.

You mean to tell me, my cat is making these insane ninja moves in a faster timeline than I see them? That just made me respect cats even more!

@kittyticklehips

Жыл бұрын

Maybe that’s whyyy they are so fast?

@bugfisch7012

Жыл бұрын

Let's disrespect some birds, though - since they got catched by cats, even though they can see em coming for human 5 minutes =D But in their world, they sound like dinosaurs, wich is cool again...

@itheuserfirst3186

Жыл бұрын

Flies are the same way. It's why they are hard to hit. They're in the matrix. We look slower to them.

@Sharpened_Spoon

11 ай бұрын

I have the suspicion cats process faster than that. Humans process quicker in extreme situations, we perceive time slower in moments of excitement, especially adrenaline fuelled events. I see my cats pupils go huge even in the day when she’s hunting. I think cats switch on a mode where they overclock their brain for a while to hunt; while I barely passed biology I think like a camera they need more light in their eyes to run that frame rate, there’s no way she could react as fast as she does while operating slower than me at rest.. I often barely process what shes doing. When you slow-mo your cat on your phone while chasing a toy its still fairly calculated, accurate movements/reactions, not blind flailing and hope.

@jaynevalencia8743

11 ай бұрын

@@kittyticklehips Etérea😊😊😮 es 15:59 😮😮

I won't lie, the slowed down bird calls really makes me wonder how advanced their languages actually are. What sounds like to us almost identical sounds all had a slightly different pitch like they were their own words. Wonder what we'll find out about orca in the coming years.

@nasapeepo721

Жыл бұрын

Yeah, that was scary.

@mirandapanda5439

Жыл бұрын

This is all speculation... not definitive

@n9315

Жыл бұрын

@@mirandapanda5439 all theories start out as speculation so what is your point?

@newp0rt

Жыл бұрын

@@mirandapanda5439 "its all speculation" 🤓 stfu

@lizardtenticlez4000

Жыл бұрын

I listened to birds on mushrooms and can confirm they communicate the same way we interpret music

I can tell you as someone who has experienced many dangerous and life threatening situations. Humans have the ability to slow time. I have perceived time many times slower than normal allowing me to make decisions and take actions I should not have had time for. Very much like the Matrix. Your video has helped understand something I have known, for a long time. I finally can explain to all the people who told me I was imagining it, or I was lieing.

@drecool85

3 ай бұрын

Yep! One example is when we have surges of adrenaline, we are able to make decisions much sharper and quicker especially when they could mean life or death. Animals likely have chemicals within them that are impacted to slow and speed up their processes based on their external stimuli and needs.

@JezebelIsHongry

2 ай бұрын

i suspect that one day we will learn that what we call intelligence boils down to “clock speed” and “fidelity of mental simulations.” if someone’s clock speed was dialed up the pace of the world might feel slowed down…they would notice all the little things someone is doing when they speak, it would be as if they were out of synch. they may get bored easily since a day could feel like years under certain conditions perhaps they would seek flow just to break out of this time perception trap (one year feeling like a decade sometimes) and if they had a rich imagination they could take daydreaming to another level for all we know einstein and mozart lived for hundreds of subjective years with their mind movies being as engrossing as some advanced VR simulation

@mnxs

Ай бұрын

​@@JezebelIsHongryI have no idea how true that is, but it _does_ sound like a good story plot/plot device! Like in the movie Limitless.

@satsumamoon

27 күн бұрын

What.is time but the movement of attention?

@persephone342

5 күн бұрын

Roger that, hellcat!

12:19 the baby elephant using his trunk to rub his eye is frickin' adorable!

9:00 him giving his duck little scratches while it laid on it's back and kicked it's little webbed feet was the cutest thing I've seen all week! Adorable!!! 🦆🦆🦆💛💛💛

@Kylo27

Жыл бұрын

Ducks are incredibly loving pets. We had lap ducks as kids and they would come up to you for scratches/hugs whenever we went outside.

@heavnxbound

Жыл бұрын

@@Kylo27 A duck at the beach bit my dad’s toe when he was trying to give it bread 😂

@jaimelovemac88

Жыл бұрын

@@heavnxbound I too was chased after by a bunch of ducks. Scared the Hell outta me!!!

@lizamay722

Жыл бұрын

I love it so much. They make complete bonds and sometimes imprint, and they're great domesticated pets imo

@Hubson55

11 ай бұрын

Great! Now I want to have a duck.... 😤

When I was a kid I remember telling my mom I thought squirres experienced time differently She thought I was crazy

@doodlehq7722

Жыл бұрын

you mean squirrels?

@kaiden7910

Жыл бұрын

@@doodlehq7722 minor spelling mistake😮😮😮😮😮

@kells8015

Жыл бұрын

Kids know stuff we don't I swear

@cheyenneamc

Жыл бұрын

It’s cause the movie Over the Hedge 😂

@RBUKFAN

Жыл бұрын

You are

people like you make the world feel magically. Thank you for uploading this. How amazing!

@cara.leo_

2 күн бұрын

Agreed!

This is a great video. Anyone interested in going further should read "An Immense World: How Animal Senses Reveal the Hidden Realms Around Us" by Ed Yong!

@chrisphillips2025

4 ай бұрын

Thank you very much

@prettypuffprincess

3 ай бұрын

Thank you❤

@TheEnchantedDuat

Ай бұрын

OOOh thankyou, looking now :)

@saragates2255

25 күн бұрын

Love it... Thank you for the suggestion 👍

What I found interesting is that the bird sounds sounded like what movies use for dinosaur sounds.

@MayimHastings

Жыл бұрын

Totally! They are, after all, little raptors!

@jukesngambits

Жыл бұрын

They literally do use a blend of real animal calls (including birds) and just slow it down. That's how they made those sounds

@amyblueskyirl16

Жыл бұрын

Why do birds sound so much more melodic to us?

@pondboy3682

Жыл бұрын

@@amyblueskyirl16 really, most don't. They chirp or caw and it's not that melodic at all. I was wishing he'd give us a better song bird example, though! That would have been neat!

@makayladorvil1542

Жыл бұрын

I thought that too

This just means that our dog friends get to enjoy more time with us in their own eyes.

@virtual_vanitas

Жыл бұрын

It's also why it seems like we are gone for so long when we step out or go to work.

@SSukram_

Жыл бұрын

@@virtual_vanitas but they've been used to that time for their entire life, wouldn't they just think it's normal?

@cerberusdidit

Жыл бұрын

@@SSukram_ yes

@Deezsirrer

Жыл бұрын

Do people enjoy sitting on hospital for 6 hours? No! Why would the dog do.

@zero.Identity

Жыл бұрын

i now know why dog years exist

When discussing the "fps of your eyes/brain" I feel its inaccurate to describe it as the definitive fps you can see when 60 is much more a baseline, its the minimum required flashes per second to see a light as always on. The max without diminishing returns is around the thousands.

@YourIQDoesntMeanShitToMe

2 ай бұрын

Could you write that better and elaborate a bit?

You might have mistaken the resolution with speed. Cats might see blur easier than humans, but it doesn't mean that everything is sped up for them. Things still are perceived real time. Dogs don't hear us speaking slower than we are. Let's say that they have higher ISO in camera sense

The bird songs are what I believe is the closest we will ever get to potentially hearing dinosaur calls. The slowed and deepened frequency, along with the fact these animals evolved from dinosaurs, really makes me think a bunch of slowed bird calls would be like taking a step back over a hundred million years ago!

@catoftruth1044

8 ай бұрын

Imagine a Dinosaur that can talk like a parrot that can copy human talking

@naturegreene9579

8 ай бұрын

Lol kinda funny, but imagine is a trex 😮 now it's kinda creepy lol

@AzillaKiami

7 ай бұрын

@@catoftruth1044 Now thats an interesting thing to think about. If dinosaurs had the ability to mimic, it would be an extremely helpful hunting trait, since they could bait prey to them, and trick them.

@Knapweed

7 ай бұрын

The last words you hear before you're eaten are, "WHO's A PRETTY BOY?"

@SavagelyBadAtLosing

7 ай бұрын

Scientists have already released what they think dinosaurs sounded like. They made a combination of bird and alligator noises slowed way down. Sounds really bad ass!

Wow. I always thought that, just due to size difference and movement speeds, that dogs would perceive us as slow lumbering giants. But I had no idea how true that was. :D

@NotTodaySatan557

Жыл бұрын

Lumbering giants 🤣🤣🤣🤣

@-S.F.K.

11 ай бұрын

I always found this very annoying. Other animals have different speeds of processing information. This means that someone that is more exiting to us, may seem more slow and dull to say a dog. This doesn’t mean that other animals quite literally see the world in a slow motion kind of way. If it did, no matter what weird science thing you did will always have a delayed reaction. And you can see with other animals that they do not. To a dog, time feel like it’s going slower, but doesn’t actually look and sound like it’s going slower. It like when you’re bored.

@colorfulchameleon9891

10 ай бұрын

@@-S.F.K. Thanks for this. It is indeed a really annoying misunderstanding.

@-S.F.K.

10 ай бұрын

@@colorfulchameleon9891 glad you agree

@paulbedichek5177

10 ай бұрын

Yeah,but my Chiwawa Terrier mix,Eddie,can't reliably catch hamburger when I throw it to him, if time is slowed down for him, he should.

What a thorough piece of work! I really appreciate your dedication put in every detail! Very enlivening and educative.❤

Bird calls: majestic sounding Hummingbird: YEEEEEEEE

I had once hypothesized that this is the reason it's so hard to smack a fly when it lands on you, it's living so fast you're moving in slow motion. I sort of tested it when I discovered that if you move slow enough they can't see it until you get in strike range. So slow it appears to them that you aren't moving at all. I wrote this comment before he talked about flys.

@levistrudel9319

Жыл бұрын

A better trick, flies focus on anything moving, so wave your fingers in one hand and stile with the other. Works every time.

@ummerfarooq5383

Жыл бұрын

That's a very well known point about flies. Until you hit them upwards.

@rezynrogue1309

Жыл бұрын

I'm a master at flicking flies into oblivion. Get the flicking ready, slowly get hand into range, smack that fly faster than it can react. Mr miyagi would be proud.

@NicoBirknicnoc

Жыл бұрын

yall killing flies on a stealth mission meanwhile I put out the rocket launcher aka catching it while it flies

@Edward.Rippett.

Жыл бұрын

That's pretty crazy

Great video, very interesting and entertaining. Thanks for the heads up about possible epilepsy triggers!!!

Thank you for this video - I imagine you lurking on your porch for hours perhaps even days in order to capture just the right footage lasting only for a few seconds in the video - let alone all the equipment necessary to pull this off. Your videos are too valuable for the majority of people, both in time and resource consumption. I'm flabbergasted. A big thank you!

Hearing you say "you want some chicken?' In a slowed down drunken voice is unexpectedly hilarious.

Humans can change time perception too. For instance under extremely stressful and/or life threatening conditions. I have experienced this personally. I have been in a car accident years ago, skidded on a side of the curved road and crashed into a tree with the drivers side door (I was driving). I can remember to this day how my time perception had extremely slowed down to the point where I could see the tree approaching, then slowly making contact with the car door, the door slowly bending around the three, the glass shattering into hundreds of tiny pieces and flying towards me, all that as if I was watching video footage that was slowed down tens of times and at the same time the resolution and detail was extremely enhanced. The crash took a second or two but it felt like time almost stopped at that particular moment. Will never forget it.

@j.vdubois5074

Жыл бұрын

Actually there was a research for this involving blindfolded people doing backwards bungee jump. The result was that they did not experience time dilatation. But they formed a lot more memories, being able to recall details that would have been normally discarded. The reverse happens in prison solitude - while it is extremely bad at the time, prisoners later recollected as if months passed as days. Of course if there are no interesting things happening around you, all days blend into each other.

@newp0rt

Жыл бұрын

same reason why people think your life flashes before you when you die.

@captainzeroskill2289

Жыл бұрын

Dude. I've been hit by a red light running car when i was in food delivery on a scooter. I clearly remember i saw my precious yamaha spinning and flipping slowly on the road while i was sliding on my head (in a helmet) and i had time to think about what i'll need to repair. The whole accident felt much slower after the inpact. Luckily i only hurt one of my legs and not too badly. Allways wear your protective gear on two wheels guys.. a slow ride on a small bike doesn't mean safety!

@praudery6249

Жыл бұрын

Sadly intersting

@Ima-si4kd

Жыл бұрын

Omg the same has happend to me! Its so intresting

Amazing video! Thabks for finding, doing, and sharing this vast amount kf research and info!

Genuinely fascinating Benn. Thank you for sharing!

This totally makes sense of why dogs react when we speak to them in that high pitched sing-songy voice we all do. To them it sounds like a normal excited voice with our usual voice dipping so low in octave. Also why hearing very high pitch is easier for them as it's brought to a significantly lower frequency in their ears. Very intriguing.

@hugdablok6162

Жыл бұрын

I never used that voice with my dog.

@The..Dark..Knight

Жыл бұрын

@@hugdablok6162 Poor dog. Lol

@spookyblush-speedruns

Жыл бұрын

@@hugdablok6162 D O U B T

@anatorres-ym8ke

Жыл бұрын

that explains why women are better with animals...the voice of a woman is sweet to their ears

@munkeyinspace5331

Жыл бұрын

Somehow I feel like this isn’t entirely accurate 🤷‍♂️

Wow... I seriously didn't think that other species lived TIME differently that me. This was quite and "eye-opening" experience! Thank you :)

@-S.F.K.

11 ай бұрын

I always found this very annoying. Other animals have different speeds of processing information. This means that someone that is more exiting to us, may seem more slow and dull to say a dog. This doesn’t mean that other animals quite literally see the world in a slow motion kind of way. If it did, no matter what weird science thing you did will always have a delayed reaction. And you can see with other animals that they do not. To a dog, time feel like it’s going slower, but doesn’t actually look and sound like it’s going slower. It like when you’re bored.

@KibyNykraft

11 ай бұрын

@@-S.F.K. The whole claim you guys mention here from the video is a highly repeated myth among the public, especially those who still don't understand or even read good old Albert E' and his relativity clarifications. And one of the most frequent things to see is people also mentioning AE without having checked or managed to understand his work (of course it has a few quirks but no major things). The perception organisms have is of *motion* ,not of time, as we have relative motions. E= MC squared. Time is the way we register the reduction of distances between what is in always present motion. Each moving locality is only in a speed relative to what you compare to. The only exception here is a semi-particle moving at C, called a photon, and that is why it is a semi-particle and not a regular mass particle. (Luminosity = high energy particles reaching your eyes) So time in real physics = the reduction of distance. That's it. It is how to define that you proved motion to occur. Or like some will say a measuring concept. There is no time "on top of" motion in an existential fashion.

@SeptemberMeadows

11 ай бұрын

What was the CFF of the Predator in the first Predator movie 🤔

@CaleanWsh

11 ай бұрын

@@SeptemberMeadows I don't even know what you're saying...??

@SeptemberMeadows

11 ай бұрын

@@CaleanWsh If you know, you know 😉🤭

That was soooo interesting and nerdy and awesome!! haha, Nice work Benn you made my day better :)

I'm so glad I saw this video, as this time experience differential between different types of life forms is something that has been a theory of mine for several years!

The biggest surprise is that a simple question, “What does the world sound like to a dog?” Involves covering such a wide range of topics to fully answer. Amazing.

@maidenminnesota1

2 жыл бұрын

And it took so damned long to get there that I lost interest. Moving on...

@averywatts2391

2 жыл бұрын

Even the simplest of questions can lead to the deepest of rabbit holes.

@ProfessorShnacktime

2 жыл бұрын

@@maidenminnesota1 dude seems to love to listen to himself speak.

@RetroCube

2 жыл бұрын

@@maidenminnesota1 Your attention span is so low that you didn’t even notice the time stamps on the video to skip past the science of it to the actual stuff. This has gotta be a new level of laziness christ

@LMJr88

2 жыл бұрын

@@averywatts2391 indeed!

I'm a vet tech I'm fascinated by this..... Always doing my best to understand animals and do better at communicating with them .

@ThattechniciangirlB

Жыл бұрын

I am also one! Thank you for all you do! I’m really wondering how 100% this is, although super interesting and sounds like it’s spot on, but I wonder how can we REALLY know what they hear unless we were actually them?

@Peacefrogg

Жыл бұрын

@@ThattechniciangirlB nope. But i also can never know how you percieve the world. Do you see colours or hear sounds the same way i do? I have no idea. It’s all just guesswork. I also wonder if and how animals can ‘see’ smells.

@sullyschwartz2365

Жыл бұрын

@@Peacefrogg You'd see if sense of smell is tied to visual in the brain; That's how we know taste is affected by smell for us.

@sullyschwartz2365

Жыл бұрын

@@ThattechniciangirlB That question is more philosophical as it can apply to anyone or thing; One of the most important and renowned historical questions in philosophy is 'what's it like to be a crow?' Which brings into mind the concept of consciousness itself-what if certain colors *seen* weren't *recognized* by the brain of an animal? Would it think on such colors? Or only the colors of prey it's evolved to hunt? Also, to answer your honestly simple question: You can tell by the structure of their fucking eyes and the neurological structure of their brain. Same with ears. And nose. That's how we KNOW dogs truly feel and have developed parts of the brain necessary to feel a bond of love with humans. What I want to know is: Why do people ask such questions without putting any much effort into it? Most of these I've learned simply through feeds of published studies; I'm guessing yours consist of Facebook posts and tiktok trends? Treat yourself as good, if not better than your animals-you're a species of your own and should be just as strong; physically and mentally. Peace n love

@Peacefrogg

Жыл бұрын

@@sullyschwartz2365 i get that. So if animals could really see smells the visual section in their brain would light up. But i don’t think it’s that simple. If smells could construct a kind of map in the brain in a similar way that sight can, i don’t think it’s necessary for the same section of the brain to be active. At the same time you and i can both see the colour blue, identify it as blue, have the same parts of our brain be active as we see it, but still not be certain whether we see it the same way.

This is wonderful! I showed it my 7 and 9 year old granddaughters and they loved it too! Thank you!!

I'm constantly trying to shift my ears to try and hear different things outside, it usually ends up looking like a slight lean towards the direction but sometimes it can look like I'm walking in a tiny circle when I can't exactly tell what direction it's coming from, that usually happens when it's something in a tree and projecting the sound in different directions. 😅👍

10:34 not the bird saying “ yeet” 😂😂😂 i knew they can speak English in fast pitch

@pingucraft95

8 ай бұрын

Nah dude it's saying yee like its dino ancestors😅

@CalledJeremy

21 күн бұрын

MAIN EVENT BIRD USO IS NOW IN YOUR FORESSTT!!!! 🗣️🗣️🗣️🔥🔥

It’s so cool how much the birds sound like “dinosaurs” or what we think of as dinosaur noises, considering how closely related they are

@noitnettaattention

Жыл бұрын

Aaandd there goes the Darwinian INSANITY!

@uddie2416

Жыл бұрын

@@noitnettaattention what

@noitnettaattention

Жыл бұрын

@@uddie2416 ...ehhm, nothing much, just make some bird noises to estabilish dinosaur "relations"...Ohh and dont forget to call it a "science" in the end...

@uddie2416

Жыл бұрын

@@noitnettaattention mate what r u on abt

@Red-jl1qr

Жыл бұрын

@@noitnettaattention what are you a creationist lmao

First video I see of yours and, oh boy, am I a fan! Awesome topic, thanks for this collection of curious facts!

Just came across your channel, 3 mins in i’ve already subscribed. Can already tell you’re a good content creator

The problem with this video is that is too short, and we don't have enough time to appreciate how good he is.

@BennJordan

2 жыл бұрын

The real time perception is in how long it took me to get some of those 1000fps shots lol

@DontFeedTheDrummer

2 жыл бұрын

You can always play the video at 0.5x speed

@JanetStarChild

2 жыл бұрын

I don't understand why so many viewers on KZread want very long videos; like as if many of us don't have things to do throughout the day and a finite amount of time. 15 minutes is enough time to cover a topic like the one we just watched. I'd rather watch a short, concise video than a bloated, longwinded video that has been artificially lengthened. Frankly, it's the reason I prefer John Michael Godier over Isaac Arthur.

@mathmanmrt

2 жыл бұрын

@@BennJordan i enjoyed this greatly but it still left me hungry for more, especially as regards the perceptions of reptiles. in all honesty i have a selfish reason in that i'd love to know more about how my friendly ball python, bob, perceives the world around him. i know that he probably exists in a chemosensory world through his incredibly engineered olfactory system but what of his sight and hearing? ah, well. some day i'll find out, or not. in the meantime, thanks for your excellent videos.

@kfl611

2 жыл бұрын

I agree I was just getting into it and it was over. What did the sea algae 'see'?

I would think that we'd still be unaware how different animals actually integrate that visual data into their own reality. None of us actually see unfiltered input. Our brains create the world we view to some extent, so how can we know what else is modified by the animal's brain. Very interesting, impressive video. I'd love to hear your plant results as well.

@Sans_The_Skeleton

7 ай бұрын

Yeah apparently we actually see things upside down but the brain flips the image

@JasonKlein97

7 ай бұрын

You can tell because some animals have significantly higher reaction times than us, like flies. This also goes hand in hand with the example he gave in the video, that if you move slowly towards it, they don't register it as movement. That's pretty hard proof that their temporal reality is sped up!

@mavisedwards

6 ай бұрын

​ @JasonKlein97 Yes, I didn't mean the very obvious examples like flies. And I didn't only mean to refer to the ability to react. I still think there are other factors that influence how reality looks and feels. It's nice that this video addresses some of them. I like videos like this and hope it brings people closer to all living things.

@gammaboost

6 ай бұрын

@@Sans_The_SkeletonWell since our brain really doesn't have any reference of what the "right" way up is, it's not really flipping anything at all. The flipped view is just how we perceive things, I guess

@jamisonr

6 ай бұрын

I know exactly what you're saying, and it is the same intuition I had. We can only approximate based on our human level of filtering.

This video is awesome!! Thank you for creating !

I felt full on STONED by 6.26 😅😅😅 Great work. What a simple, yet clever question to answer 👏👏

I think the reason that we don't hear noises so well above and below us is because of our size in our environment. Our threats don't come from above or below but from right in front of us or behind of us. If our main appendages were wings or we were smaller relative to our environment, things might be different.

@Yes_Anastasia

11 ай бұрын

Eh, I might argue that threats to us can most certainly come from above us.

@adye88

11 ай бұрын

@@Yes_Anastasia give us another 1000 years and we'll have the means to detect and deter threats from above too. Even today an example includes missle/air defense systems. We've kinda adapted already if you think about it.

@funkyfranx

11 ай бұрын

@@adye88 I don't see why we would evolve to have that when humans no longer live in a world of predatory threats. The only thing we have to fear are other humans, and they don't often attack from above. A thousand years is far too little time as well, we're not more evolved than people living in the medieval era

@OrangeTtop

10 ай бұрын

So is it rare to be able to tell? I never have issues

@Torpax_

10 ай бұрын

Our eyes are for front and vertical threats. Ears specialize in protecting our flanks. Brains specialize in making sure we don't get snuck up on from behind through systematic exploration methods. We aren't gonna physically evolve any further since civilization developed, bc we live on the equivalent of peaceful mode in Minecraft and only really have to worry about griefers lmao

The whole "time is relative" thing is so hard to wrap my head around, but I'm always seeing new bewildering evidence that the speed at which time flows isn't always the same.

@LilyUnicorn

2 жыл бұрын

Time flows the same no matter what. Too many people confuse spacetime as some magical sci fi concept. Spacetime is actually just space at a certain event. Time always moves forward. Time is an event and does not change that event point. How you see something (known as your perception of time) is what they mean. Think of a bird who can see the spectrums (rgb and uv). Us who can see rgb. And cats/dogs who can see green and blue spectrum but not red. Now think of an orange ball with uv markings on it. Bird can see orange and uv. Humans can see only orange. Dogs/spectrum cant see red spectrum and orange is about 45% or more red spectrum with 20 to 40% green spectrum and 0 to 10 ish% spectrum. To them it will appear like a desaturated bluish green/yellow. But has the ball changed? NO. It has not. It is still the same. We simply just dont see it the same way. Time is the same. Time does not miraculousy pull magic. This is not a hard concept. Just normal people who misinterpreted what einsteins spacetime means. While time may feel slower or faster from your viewpoint, time itself does not change. Event A has always happened at Event A. Think of an obese and a fit person running at the same pace... tied together with the same leash. Footsteps in sync. Obese person may feel like everything is taking forever as it is basically dragged around by fit person. Fit person may feel relaxed, slow paced but as if time runs quickly. Perception is mental. It is not reality. The reality of a time event should not be conflated with imaginary perception. Its created this massive misunderstanding of time and spacetime as some sort of gidly hocus pocus that is far simpler than you think.

@Lithane97

2 жыл бұрын

@@LilyUnicorn no, there's plenty of scientific theories devoted to the idea that time flows forward and backwards. Or others that suggest time is not directional and is occurring simultaneously.

@LetsPlayGamesRandom

2 жыл бұрын

@@Lithane97 time isnt anything but a human made concept. All there is is particles that move and that we perceive . You cant go back in time because those events have happend. Even if you travel faster than light, the world will seem slow around you but you cant reverse events that have already taken place.

@zeitxgeist

2 жыл бұрын

Your experience of time relative to others is what changes, not time itself or your own experience of time; if you were travelling 100ly at C, you would experience 100 years, but for people on Earth whose experience of time is influenced by the Earth's conditions and gravity and all that hoohaa have a different perspective: if you were to return, you'd return a number of years I'm too lazy to whip out a calculator for, but a lot, but you would have only experienced 200 years to have passed on this hypothetical trip.

@sexgod57able

2 жыл бұрын

The Quickening you fools. Bwuhahahaha!!!!

super fun! thanks for making this Benn

I'd always assumed a cat's perception of time was slow-motion (compared to ours) and that's why they were so good at doing dexterous stuff... and why they needed to sleep so much (lots of information to process). Interesting that I was completely wrong.

@TheAsylumCat

9 ай бұрын

We must seem terrifying to watch moving around

@o00nemesis00o

9 ай бұрын

@@TheAsylumCat Eh, watch a Harold Lloyd movie. After a while you get used to it.

@petrkinkal1509

9 ай бұрын

It's a bit tricky for example cat reaction time is faster than ours.

@GiRR007

9 ай бұрын

Their perception of time may be slower but their reaction time is still faster.

@pong9000

Ай бұрын

Cats do seem to observe the general behaviour of something before making a move. Why they never strike a toy on the first pass.

Vsauce Michael actually said that's his process for making videos too. He said he might take a question like "which way is up?" and make that an excuse for making a video about how gravity works. I'm loving your recent output, Benn, keep it up.

@aiyhavnouneim

2 жыл бұрын

vsussy

@pong9000

Ай бұрын

A more disarming question is: "How do we know left from right?"

Brilliant! Thank you for making and sharing this.

5:46 its so precious to see those dogs smiling, happy, and running free.

I'm probably just tired but this is so ethereal I'm almost on the verge of tears. My dog passed away in October and its so emotional to see how he would've perceived the world and us

@NotTodaySatan557

Жыл бұрын

Honestly I feel you. I’m also really tired and my doggy died a few weeks ago and it kinda of is punching me in the gut thinking how she saw the world for all of her years ❤️

@CBRN-115

10 ай бұрын

I bet your dog lived a happy life under your care. May your dog rest in peace

@magicmoonart

9 ай бұрын

Very sorry to hear that I hope they rest in peace too

@animeloveer97

9 ай бұрын

Just know that it means that your dog experienced a long happy life in their eyes ❤

@astro-blaster4190

9 ай бұрын

I just lost mine me after 16 years. I’d give anything to see him for 30 seconds. I’m lost

This makes me wonder about long lived ambush hunters like tarantulas, who generally have pretty poor vision as far as resolution go, and tend to sit around doing almost nothing until they need to hunt, which is rarely. The longest lived spider was a trapdoor known as Number 16 who lived into her 40s. I wonder what 40 years feels like for a trapdoor Especially since mygalomorphs like trapdoors and tarantulas can have AMAZING reaction times. If you look up a trapdoor grabbing prey, the time it takes for them to grab prey is near instant to us.

@thromboid

2 жыл бұрын

I've wondered that too. I could never sit perfectly still for as long as spiders and cats do - even if my lunch depended on it!

@Scootfairy

2 жыл бұрын

Maybe they have a rich internal world.

@Vysair

2 жыл бұрын

A rock can sit longer than a river because one does not move while the other flow. Basically, if the world seems bland and empty to a spider, won't it just be nothing to them? They won't just feel anything at all unlike a cat or dog which a world seems colorful to them.

@thromboid

2 жыл бұрын

@@Vysair I think it would be unlikely that spiders would evolve such an excellent survival strategy without being able to tolerate or even enjoy the wait. But maybe they have really good podcasts.

@user-sn6yb8kr1m

2 жыл бұрын

Even if they have any memories their time may feel like just nothing, lol! Benefit of living in the moment. But regarding their visual perception, the time from their visual sensory experience may be different from their internal time perception. In some of these replies there were questions about cats' supposed slow perception, but it may just be about its visual sensory experience. Their internal time may be different. Our senses may receive more information than we can process, so each sense may have its own time independent of our internal time that ties the story we tell ourselves...

Thank you so much for the warning! I don't have epilepsy but I do have photosensitivity especially with flashing lights due to a prior brain injury. There are lots of folks who can't look at flashing or strobing for various reasons, so I think it's awesome that you put that warning put there ahead of time!

I'd imagine that humans have various time perceptions from individual to individual, and maybe from population to population. These variations would be small for sure - but consider how our time perception changes as we grow up and get older.

@seanhenry8243

5 ай бұрын

Bingo! Time isn't even a constant for human beings, and I'd be willing to bet that even an individual's time sense changes as they age.

@ellielou52

5 ай бұрын

Is that something that we know to be true? That ppls time perception does actually change as you age? I know it's something ppl say, that every year seems to go by faster and faster, but I've always thought, and heard others say (not experts just ppl in my life) that its because a certain amount of time, say 1 day, when you're 1 year old would feel long because it's 1/365 if their entire life and perceived time. But 1 day to 50 year old 1/18250 (i think, did it in my head) of their life and perceived time. I've also thought that maybe it has something to do with everyday traumas we experience, and for some big traumas that would make it even worse, causing us dissociate from our lives. Like once we got to school and were extremely bored and stressed and that boredom and stress increase through our school years, and we start to dissociate from time a little to get through that boredom and stress. By the time we retire at 63ish and have worked full time and experienced loss like death and pain from relationships and friends and had near death experiences and ask the other little and big traumas for 63 years we've become so used to dissociating from reality to get through the day to day that that's our new normal, and when you dissociate things go by faster for you. Which is why it's so inorganic to learn mindfulness and learning to sit in your feelings and all that. But maybe I am only seeing the world through my own lense and that's what makes sense to me based on my own life and problem with dissociating. But I'd be sorry interested to hear your take on that and any theories you or the scientific community have on our time perception!

@ellielou52

5 ай бұрын

Sry for my errors i accidentally hit send before proofreading and swype was not my friend here 😆 KZread won't let me edit, don't know why. Most of them are little errors, but "inorganic" was meant to be "important".

@seanhenry8243

5 ай бұрын

@@ellielou52 time perception changes day to day and minute to minute, based on many factors. Does it change as we get older, too? I don't know of any scientific study, but anecdotally, I know it has for me, it did for my parents, and for every living person as old or older than me that I speak with about it. So *shrug* let's say that we don't know for sure, but that we DO know that time perception can swing wildly based on many factors.

@rhayat10

5 ай бұрын

I don't think this is something that can be empirically proven or disproven - but my statement is based on personal experience, and experiences of other people. It would be nice if somebody from the scientific community joined the conversation.@@ellielou52

The thing about dogs we also have to realize is their sense of smell is so good they can perceive reality much more clearly than even their eyes and ears making up for the lack of color etc.

This video is fascinating, I was riveted to this. This is really great content 👌🏻

I think this type of research could unlock us to better understand the unknown especially maybe one day being able to talk to animals and for use to understand their language like it was our own.

10:30 - those audio adjusted bird sounds ..I'm betting, this is what large dinosaurs would sound like to our human ears today :)

We do in fact hear whether a sound comes from behind or in front of us, and I would assume also up or down. It’s the reason why our ears are ear shaped. It reflects and channels the sound just slightly differently depending on the direction it comes from, so as we grow up our brain will fine tune its guess to where the sound is from. Steve Mould has a great demonstration on how messing with the ear shape will totally mess with your ability to track sounds.

@DannyGruesome

10 ай бұрын

Yes. Things directly in front of you are heard better than sounds coming from the left or right even.

@Dayanto

9 ай бұрын

​@@DannyGruesome Sure, but you could do that even with just earholes based on the difference in timing and volume since one ear is closer than the other. That doesn't work when the sound is coming from above, below, in front of, or behind you since they have the same distance to both ears. It's literally impossible to tell the difference without some kind of special ear shape that can _create_ a difference in the reflected sound.

@Bob-of-Zoid

8 ай бұрын

Binaural recording mimics the human head! It's near full 3D with only regular headphones, sans physical shaking of floors and other objects. It's not just the ears, but the whole head and even mechanical waves transferred through materials we are in contact with, and how the brain extrapolates distance and direction from all of it in processing. From what I heard the reason some of us can't tell direction well and what not, is because with all of the modern amenities, we don't have to be all that alert all the time, and many of us just don't use our senses to the best of our abilities. People can learn how to hone their senses though. I also wouldn't be surprised if many pets are also operating on diminished capacity.

@SaebriSelect

7 ай бұрын

but the only difference between a sound in front or behind is the decibels. the same sound would be only louder in front of you. i could play the same sound, but you would want to say its in front if its louder. so its kind of a stretch to say we can actually hear a sound from infront of you versus behind you. its really just a guess. so calling a 'guess' or a 'feeling' as 'fact' is kinda hardcore lol. u also cant tell if a sound is above or below you, is why a lot of people get confused in video games about vertical audio, thats because there is no such thing as vertical audio lol. its all a guess or a feeling, and you have to move your head and hear the noise again to actually know

@Bob-of-Zoid

7 ай бұрын

@@SaebriSelect Not true: Your head and ear lobes, hair... change the sound that's behind you, in a way the same sound sounds different from different directions. It isn't the volume that counts as that can be distance related. The brain can tell distance of some sounds for their familiarity and what volume they are expected to be at. Now add movement, the Doppler effect and what not and you actually do hear in full 3D!

Great video. Thank you! Would love to see a further deep dive into whatever is going on in birdsong. It's far more complex than I'd realized. It hearkens back to research that demonstrates what many various types of bird plumage actually look like if you, like birds, could also see ultraviolet.

Outstanding work! This blows my mind and makes me re-think reality. Plants respond positively to stringed instruments.

When I was little I learned that owls have offset ears to pinpoint location and since then I do tilt my head to better locate sounds. It’s amazingly helpful!! With practice it has become second nature and I can listen in on conversations and sounds people around me cant.

@goldielocks3354

2 жыл бұрын

I have 5 children and 7 grandchildren this works well for hearing everything lol

@wedho_lifeInquisitor

Жыл бұрын

For real?

@lucybuck8373

Жыл бұрын

Very cool

@reducedtoatoms1656

Жыл бұрын

Really? What song am I singing right now? Nah, better question. How many finger am I holding up? jk

@animalroom3264

Жыл бұрын

I'll try that to listen in on people when their whispering

My parrot can talk. ALSO I know exactly how he “hears” humans when we talk, because he mocks us when we are having a conversation, laughing, or even when we are having a heated conversation. He hates those. He goes “Murr murr murr murr murr murr” to mimic humans talking. It’s kind of similar to the “Peanuts” characters teachers and adults murmur. Which makes me convinced that Charles Schultz had a talking bird at one point in his life, before he made those cartoons, or at least someone on his staff did. I’ve even heard my bird mocking some neighbors outside who are speaking in Chinese, and his mimicking of them sounds exactly like his mimicking of my husband and I speaking English. So it’s not specific to one language. It’s just “human speak.” But he also has some things he says to us that are very specific to what he’s just heard (like saying “achoo” right after we sneeze.) So it makes me believe he does have some awareness of what he’s saying, that it’s not just mimicry. Not sure what that means for the rate and speed at which he can hear us. Those are some cute ducks, btw!

@lsmmoore1

Жыл бұрын

I figure I know what you mean. Technically the parrot hears the same sounds, but the general way they perceive and filter it is different. When humans tune out and only half hear the conversation, it doesn't (always) sound like that to us. But it always does to a parrot. I would describe that as "worldview" for lack of a better word, and I also want to add that this is something that differs within species as well. The "flow" of the world (that I would define as the way one's brain naturally turns its attention between things whether deliberately or otherwise) is perceived differently through autistic eyes than non-autistic eyes even when all concerned are human. Outside of my own perception, I have only really seen this "flow" represented in the movie Billy Elliot, featuring a boy in a toxically masculine family and who wants to be a ballet dancer - and is definitely autistic. And Billy's autistic issues manifest similarly to those of Zuko from the Avatar the Last Airbender series because, like Zuko, he too is raised by a toxically masculine jerk of a father (so both have meltdowns characterized by very pugilistic anger). Except Billy isn't manipulated the way Zuko is so can still clearly see he wants to do ballet. And it is clear that autistic people were involved in the art direction of that film, because a non-autistic person has neither the words nor frame of reference to know what that even looks like.

@lsmmoore1

Жыл бұрын

@UCnu8XvnIdT38APWzGqlHmng I'm not. The phenomenon I am referring to (due to lack of a word for it and difficulty of portrayal) is very difficult to describe, unless you happen to be one of those people whose perceptual filters differ from the norm (which I am). Though there is one hint I can give. If they perceive and filter something differently than we do, they will perceive their own imitation of something we do differently than we do, that imitation will line up with their own perception of the thing - but that imitation will end up sounding like something we do to us, because even though their filter is different from ours, it's still capable of registering the same sounds we hear, with consistent rhythms. And as a result of still being able to hear enough of the sounds line up, they can make an imitation that sounds accurate to our ears even if they hear the imitation and the original sound differently than we do. Because difference in filter is less like being colorblind, if you will, and more like seeing every color, except every color has a different setting. Like if someone saw a rainbow but their rainbow looked like purple, blue, green, indigo, red, orange, yellow, in that order (resulting in seeing red skies, indigo grass, and blue sunsets), so if they transmitted their view of a landscape to us telepathically, the picture would look downright weird to our eyes. But since the color alignment perceived by this hypothetical person is consistent right down to them perceiving the colors of paints in alignment with how they see the rainbow, they could still produce a painting with the correct colors, even to our eyes. And they could still name colors correctly, provided you didn't test them with telepathic imagery, because the colors they learned would be according to their perception and not ours. And the only way you'd see anything is different is through their opinions on which colors clash and which don't. That is how someone can have a very different perception of an aspect of the world, and yet produce accurate representations from the perspective of someone who does not perceive the world the same way. And that is more or less the same level of evidence this person gets from the parrot. Mostly accurate imitation, and a slightly odd form of mockery. And you might not even notice the mockery when it isn't childishly blatant - autistic people have found that they sometimes mock some of the tones of non-autistic folk, only to have the mockery not seen for what it is and taken for a sincere attempt at being polite.

@jackman5840

Жыл бұрын

​@@lsmmoore1 you have to be careful with the use of toxic masculinity as a term. it is being used in schools to tell kids they shouldn't want to be active or confident in any way, while it may be a real thing people will always take it as you saying masculinity is by default toxic. Because some people are trying to say that. I guess what I am trying to say is its a fine term but its been used for bad too often to be taken seriously. Plus I don't necessarily agree that it is a fair representation of Zuko's full family dynamic. I don't even think he is autistic to be honest, there are many symptoms of autism that can be caused by an abusive family, and it can be hard for anyone to disagree with their family and nation all at once. especially growing up in schools telling you they are the best. Top that with being exiled by his father in head to head combat, just for speaking up about killing their own men. That is something a child would do autistic or not, when he was told in those schools how wrong that would be. His reactions make sense for anyone including if he was autistic, and he obviously develops anger issues either way. Something that was directly taught to him by his father. He then becomes hyper focused on the only thing that can undo all of that trauma, he just hasn't realized it's all a lie yet. Especially because anyone else would be practically racist toward him for being able to bend fire. Even his uncle keeps up the idea that he should continue his quest, until he sees the right moment to change his mind. Plus you have to realize his uncle had to change his own mind at some point, so he knows how it can be done. I'm not saying it would be bad or wrong for him to be autistic, I honestly think it's an interesting way to look at the character. Either way he is maybe the most compelling character in the series. Someone with mild schizophrenia could tell you there are similarities with him as well. and someone with bad schizophrenia might say some things about how Azula acts. I'm not the latter, so i'm not sure.

@lsmmoore1

Жыл бұрын

@@jackman5840 I think you're getting your information on what is being taught in schools from biased sources, because I don't get the impression kids are actually being taught most of the claims about aspects of themselves being inherently bad that parents are being told they are (unless the teaching is that they are filthy sinners who need Jesus or that their neurodivergencies - i.e. autism - make them inherently bad). As for Zuko, a big reason why he is widely seen as autistic among autistic people is because of the fact that he seems to cling to Azula for social expertise all the time, even within his family. This stands out especially in a family where the overall level of social expertise (of the normal variety) is generally high, such that even its wisest man, Iroh, is a skilled manipulator when he needs to be (though Iroh is honest enough not to use those abilities all the time).

@jackman5840

Жыл бұрын

@@lsmmoore1 i was told in school that I was being toxically masculine for crossing my arms in a weird way to comfort myself as it was my first year in Public school. Its a toxic term. I'll get back to you on zuko later. I have also never met a Christian who hated autistic people. That is something from your biased source. I was told I was evil in a Christian school for wanting long hair though. You have to see that its not everyone everywhere. But that term can be hurtful to people either way.

Well I gotta say, thank you for a very interesting and mindblowing video. This has to be one of the best food for thought videos I have seen for a very very long time. I really hope you have a great day man, keep up the good work!

what an amazing channel to stumble across! thank you Benn

10:15 its so surreal hearing them at this frequency, they almost sound like id imagined dinosaurs sounded. incredible

@pixilshadows

Жыл бұрын

Exactly what i thought!

@abardet-arc5009

Жыл бұрын

that part immediately made me think about the movie Predator, both for some of the sounds of the creature but also and maybe more amazingly the soundtrack they used in parts of the movie... felt completely inspired by this, what the hell

@9000ck

Жыл бұрын

i think they are just small feathery dinosaurs.

@XMysticHerox

Жыл бұрын

@@9000ck They literally are taxonomically.

@andresreal8261

Жыл бұрын

I mean, birds belong to the "Sauropsida" clade, so... Yeah. They're literally the only know "subset" of dinosaurs still living to this day. They belong to the same clade (which roughly means "a group composed of organisms with common ancestor and all its lineal descendants").

For the first part about dogs tilting their heads, I remember watching a very interesting video about the exact opposite thing to what you said; human's ears have evolved to be able to diagnose the direction, or plane on which a sound lies, by the loops and curls that defines our ears. Many animals don't have this setup (dogs, birds, etc...) so we are technically more advanced in the regard of honing, not so much with audible frequency. The conclusion was made by the guy sticking silly putty in his son's ears, blindfolding him and then having him pinpoint his mom and dad (the creator of the video) clapping in different points around the kid. Needless to say, it was to no avail. Therefore, take those beautiful traits your weird ears have and be grateful they look the way they do!

@Cody_Ramer

2 жыл бұрын

Not only that but our ears are slightly lower/ higher than the other making it easy to pinpoint where sounds are coming from without tilting our heads.

@brodriguez11000

2 жыл бұрын

@@Cody_Ramer Don't owls have the ear height difference?

@edmonterey5138

2 жыл бұрын

@@brodriguez11000 yes, but I think Cody was saying that we have this AND that.

@Cody_Ramer

2 жыл бұрын

@@brodriguez11000 yup although they have slightly more difference than we do however we also have the specially shaped ears to go with it.

@StaK_1980

2 жыл бұрын

That was probably Destin from Smarter everyday.

Man, thank you. I've been wondering about this for my entire life.

mindblowing stuff. I just discovered your channel somehow. amazing stuff dude big thanks!

8:02 - wow...then this explains why and how they can jump so freaking quickly from branch to branch so easily without failing even once and in such precise way..they see everything much slower and it gives them extra time in their perception to be able to perform that properly with such coordination of their legs.

That duck belly petting at 9:07 just landed on my bucket list

What a great channel mate. Good work 👍🏼

slowed down videos of ducks are something i truly didn't know i needed

Being someone with a neurological condition I just wanna say a massive THANK YOU for putting the disclaimer up about the flashing lights!!! Seriously, my nervous system is in full gratitude! I've been interested in time perception for a long time and this was a wonderful exploration of the subject! Thank you again and keep up the great work!

@BrennanHammons

9 ай бұрын

Hello there! Just curious and trying to learn more about people with your condition. I’ve always had a minor neurological condition where I have ticks. What affects you most in day to day life? Are you able to drive?

@igitha..._

9 ай бұрын

@@BrennanHammons Howdy! Thank you for your message; I have Complex Regional Pain Syndrome (also known as Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy and about 200 other names worldwide!); it's similar to MS and Parkinsons', Lupus (SLE) and POTS, as well as Autism, ADD and C-PTSD.. I have struggled with tics, tremors and spasms for a number of years now but the last few years in particular my hypersensitivities seem to be through the roof! I have lip pops, "whee!'s", head tilt tics, facial grimaces... it's a great big mix bag! I'm affected much more these days with sensory overload, including from lights and sound (flashing lights, bright lights, loud abrasive noises), which can get pretty bad when in public.. Abrasive sounds usually translate to physical pain! I have unfortunately suffered from a (public!) pseudoseizure and many collapses in the past and have noticed that my nervous system seems to be triggered (albeit low-grade most of the time) when it comes to some videos on KZread, but there have been certain videos where I've had to point out that the flashing is totally inappropriate for me and others with similar conditions! I am able to operate an automobile safely, thank god, however a lot of my physical disabilities are a result of being in a head on hit and run that wasn't my fault and the guy who hit me in a mismatched vehicle was never found. After the accident the neurological symptoms got much worse. I had my doctor confirm I can still travel safely, which is so important for independence and a sense of autonomy.. There are vitamins and nutrients out there that can help..and plenty of different therapies. I'm always on the lookout for healing! And grateful for any that comes my way.. I hope that wasn't too much of a rant! , Best of luck with your condition, I hope that you get the relief you deserve! Kind blessings !

@NikolaiWowe

9 ай бұрын

My POTS was also quite happy. Flashing lights kill my nervous system 😂

@user-fz8pw3ym7y

9 ай бұрын

He was just kidding. Go watch again

@cadosian078

9 ай бұрын

@@igitha..._I’m so sorry you have to deal with all that, and no thanks to a mismatched vehicle crash. Honestly the SUVs everyone’s buying are sort of ridiculous they’re not even classified as regular cars they’re under a different classification called “light trucks” which basically just means they can get away with bigger tires, higher bumper and ride heights and a whole bunch of other very unsafe things for everyday automobiles. It’s a shame. Gotta love all those people who drive their perfectly clean FordF150 to pick up groceries and take up 2 lanes and 2 parking spaces. I really hope your condition improves. I have ADHD and have had minor annoying occasional tics that bug the crap out of me and used to cause me a lot of stress so I can only imagine what it’s like to have a real condition. Best of luck and I wish you a healthy life.

Something that would have been interesting to touch on is if there are differences in time perception between human individuals. And also if there are any measurable effects of things like stimulants like caffeine, etc. Like, the first time I took an Adderall, it felt like time was going extremely fast. Of course I don't think it changed my hearing or the capabilities of my eyes, but I always wondered how that relates to time perception. Edit: I found this from an article online for anyone else curious: "studies on mice have shown that time perception can be speeded up by stimulating dopamine-producing neurons in the brain. These findings have profound implications for people with dopamine-related disorders, such as attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). Here, there is a reduction in dopamine, so sufferers could perhaps be impulsive because they perceive time more slowly."

@_jms430

Жыл бұрын

Same here I noticed that with adderall too. Also Nootropics medications like Nuvigil

@jeremiahfyan

Жыл бұрын

There is. Its actually a form of hallucination that can make a drug or substance classified as a psyechedelic. Its called Time Dilation. The feeling of time being slowed down or sped up. Strange concept

@helenafranzen9828

Жыл бұрын

I believe you are on to something. Remember as a kid how long the summer vacation was compared to how quickly it seems to pass as a grown up. Perhaps it is not only difference in age. Could be gender, culture and genetics as well as medical.

@jeremiahfyan

Жыл бұрын

@@helenafranzen9828 i had that theory as a kid. I honestly still believe it. Time dilation. "Normal" passing of time could be different per individual perception. I mean, hormones and other chemicals are constantly influencing our brain, and we know many drugs cause time dilation. Maybe these normal hormones can affect time perception for an individual differently depending on neural pathways in the brain or something. Ive always had the same theory with color. Red to me may be blue to you, and maybe thats why I would like Red and you would like blue. We percieve it the same but we could never know, because what we know of as "blue" or "red" are different but always consistent

@helenafranzen9828

Жыл бұрын

@@jeremiahfyan I agree. A typical case are those who are colourblind. If all of us seems to see or percieve a colour as blue we all call it blue. To those who cant see it, it can be whatever they percieve it to be. There are people in theory that takes it a lot further by suggesting that what we call reality is just an illusion created by our brain. I´m not a scientist and can not vouch for that but our brains is still to an extent an unknown territory.

This is the most incredible and astonishing video I've seen in a long time. It deserves a freaking Nobel price for cracking some secret code of nature and giving clarity on so many things in the world. Eureka moment the whole time. Love from Europe ❤

This is exactly why it's so easy to catch a dragonfly if you move slowly. It's weird, but as a kid a realisation occurred to me, after reading Darwin's shortened version of "Origin" when I was watching dragonflies hunt. I thought that they must have evolved a vision to perceive fast motion much more slowly than we do in order to achieve such flight precision. Naturally, thought I, there was no reason for the dragonflies to perceive slow motion at all, this couldn't possibly aid a dragonfly in a more successful reproduction. And, of course, I immediately tested my theory, and was amazed at just how easy it was to catch one by moving slowly. It was mind boggling how those huge, thousand-faceted eyes that probably see almost the entire 3-D space around them are at the same time, - completely blind to slow movements. It was bizarre, I even learned how to make dragonflies land on my outstretched hand by mimicking the way a branch swings in gentle breeze, which totally freaked out my friends. I haven't lost touch as an adult either. Here imgur.com/a/Kn4Rlw3

@elderender8362

2 жыл бұрын

you sound like a genius from a cartoon series wth

@mk1st

2 жыл бұрын

Wow, I'm going to have to try that.

@cheesecrew

2 жыл бұрын

And then everybody clapped...

@Scootfairy

2 жыл бұрын

Weirdly I discovered when I was young that grass hoppers and dragon flies were easy to catch when moving slowly, but weirdly I never knew why. Because I was so young I never questioned it, and when I was older, and ppl saw me catch an insect to show them, they were always more amazed by the capture than the bug itself, and I couldn’t explain how I did it, “I just pick them up how they let you pick them up” this video helps understand!

@Vysair

2 жыл бұрын

@@elderender8362 then you remembered, those who grew up with scientific access (like books) would eventually pull this kind of thing. Mine was just building a kingdom with ants (they are very fascinating! You can see many similarities of human society at macro scale)

Thank you for this video, I've always wondered about this!

8:07 this reminds me of the movie "Over the hedge" and hammy the squirrel. He already moved super fast, and near the end of the movie drank an energy drink which meant everything around him slowed down extremely while he moved at what seemed a regular pace, although he himself was lightning fast.

@vvelvettearss

Жыл бұрын

That scene is legendary! Why does this not have any upvotes Glad you referenced it :)

lol The duck kicking back in slow motion at 9:06 is honestly one of the most wholesome things I've seen on the internet in a while. Amazing. I wish there was just more footage of ducks at this speed. They're surprisingly jolly beings at their own speed.

@bobblowhard8823

7 ай бұрын

I like ducks.

@chrisclinton5424

7 ай бұрын

I didn't know you could cuddle a duck! 😝⁉️

@EyeSeeThruYou

7 ай бұрын

I had two pet ducks, and ducks are loyal, affectionate, and cuddly. And you can also swim with them, which is seriously the best experience, ever!! ❤❤❤

@TREBLEandGANGSTA

7 ай бұрын

@@EyeSeeThruYouthis comment made me want a duck now

@EyeSeeThruYou

7 ай бұрын

@TREBLEandGANGSTA There will be a lot of work and time spent with them ahead if you do adopt a duck. Above all, any avian you adopt should be treated like a member of your family and not excluded, treated differently, or segregated from family space and activities, since you are part of their flock. Birds are surprisingly aware of differences in treatment they might receive relative to another animal, like a dog, for instance. If birds receive very unequal treatment relative to other animals in the home in terms of attention, or cannot join in on family (flock) life, they perceive this, and it breaks their very social hearts. If you can give them a stable, loving home in which they can be a full member, their companionship and loyalty will be returned with interest and exceed all else ❤️

Thanks for flashing light warning! Much gratitude

Fascinating video. That being said, the head tilt is very much a human thing. I remember reading something about it one day and noticing it in humans (including myself) since. It has to do with creating a phase differential between the two ears for enhanced spatial depth or something.. Maybe it's more of a head twist (around the vertical axis) in humans, rather than a sideways tilt as dogs do, but I would imagine the two are related..

So, I work with animals professionally, and I have ALWAYS wondered how dogs & cats perceive reality/time compared to us humans. This is absolutely FASCINATING!!!

@Alan-kz6fc

7 ай бұрын

They see and perceive everything just like we do.. just not as smart as us and not interested in the same things .except food ..:)

Watching your dogs running through the grass is the most wholesome thing I've ever seen and I never knew I needed it until now 🥺

@WhileMyGuineaPigGentlyWheeks

2 жыл бұрын

Ikr

@tweedpenguin712

2 жыл бұрын

Why do people like you comment this? “I’ve ever seen.” And comment the same thing over and over lol. Dumb.

@androidemulator6952

2 жыл бұрын

Strangely relaxing..was it the dogs or music ??

@SatanenPerkele

2 жыл бұрын

Dogs are poop eating vacuums. There's nothing cute about them.

@adhd_with_pennies4867

2 жыл бұрын

Ik never knew dogs hear like that crazy lol no wonder my dog can't watch TV POOR animals I wish they where like us so we could watch TV together like us it be more enjoyable if the black lines in the screen where not there I feel bad for them lol

Lucy's view made me so happy. Actually had tears in my eyes. This is so lovely.

This video made me smile many times. Especially Lucy in the grass and the duck getting a belly rub. Btw, my dog really perked up with the bird sounds slowed down. He never pays attention to what I’m watching but he did for that.

I've noticed the same thing about my pets, they used to ignore any screens in the house, but nowadays most of them watch TV or look at videos on my computer screen. Thanks for the excellent video, I'm subscribing.

I think humans can alter their perception frame rate. Using stimulants or anxiety or anger, they can speed up so the world slows down, or they can use relaxation and meditation to slow down so time lasts longer perceptively.

@nosferatadentata965

2 ай бұрын

It's true. In a life-threatening situation when you are about to crash into something, time definatellly slows down...

@pong9000

Ай бұрын

The trade-off is our "bullet-time" consciousness must omit a lot of superfluous details, to run faster. Famously nobody recalls the colour of their mugger's pants. A pet theory of mine is the metallic taste people report from an adrenaline kick is really the absence of signals from all other taste buds, that normally rounds it out to neutral.

@ViniSocramSaint

Ай бұрын

Interestingly enough, I felt it playing competitive videogames. After a session ends, I go talk to other people and they seem slowed and all of a sudden I can "perceive everything" goes a way in a few minutes

Thank you for posting this informative video. I found this absolutely fascinating.

Excellent video Benn. I have 2 Huskies and a malamute. You have certainly opened my eyes, brilliant!!!

What a wonderful idea and execution for a video

@RedMeansRecording

2 жыл бұрын

Also: Me: here's my 10,000 modular system for making wild crazy synth sounds Bird: wow that sounds like shit

@StpSqncr

2 жыл бұрын

@@RedMeansRecording lol

I've developed the head swivel to locate sounds while working at an airport. You hear planes all the time taking off, idling, taxiing and I know what each sounds like. Crossing a taxiway in dense fog ,this came in handy as a large plane was crossing as well. I heard a light sound of the engines getting louder and chose to wait. About 10 seconds later a wing tip appeared in front of me. I also had a large plane sneak up on me out of nowhere, somehow, even after a 360 degree sight check. Heard the engines and slammed on the brakes. I also use this while driving. I can hear engines or tires on the interstate. I rotate my head slightly to locate where it is coming from and find a car in my blind spot. I find it safer to do that then rotate my whole head to see the car unless I am immediately changing lanes. What is more amazing is I can hear such things clearly while still having hearing damage from racing engines, gunshots, machinery and previously mentioned airplane engines.

@jasonperez7811

Жыл бұрын

You're not the only one. I can hear stuff like that too. I often hear a motorcycle or truck in the distance and can tell how far away it is based on the sound. While others hear nothing, only to hear it as it gets closer. I can also hear infrasound and have proven this with frequency spectrometers. But this drives me nuts, especially sounds from anytype of airconditioner, fan, etc. I can hear rf sometimes too. But I'm sensitive to things like thunder and am a musician. So IDK, it's nice to know I'm not the only one out there like this.

@elibell19

Жыл бұрын

I do this too! My eyesight was very poor growing up (I only found out how bad it was when I went to an opticians in my thirties), so I learned to pay attention to sounds and even click my tongue. 🤷🏻‍♀️

@marinamartin2567

Жыл бұрын

& No doubt it probably put lots of questions(that u didn't know u should be asking). { lol } ...into different perspectives for u, too.. am I right? & I totally agree with u on that too, (btw).. bc I have definitely learned (or is it "learnt") a lot more amazing stuff,from dudes like this guy, than I ever did in school.. I'm not kidding..I'm being honest.

@marinamartin2567

Жыл бұрын

Oh & everything u said about the way u taught yourself how to hear sounds is so cool,btw & I,myself, think u'r highly intelligent,..which is hard to find in most people..(imo). ...I'm just sayin'

@jasonperez7811

Жыл бұрын

@@marinamartin2567 everyone's always just saying these suits are after me but I'm sure it's just zine.

Absolutely amazing! Thank you for sharing this great work with us.

This is honestly an amazing amazing video that shows we will always know a drop in an ocean about the world. Applause 👏

Listening so some of these sounds at different levels etc, I can’t help but acknowledge how supernatural they sound. Nature is doing things we aren’t even aware of.

@anandsharma7430

8 ай бұрын

Wait till you realise that the night is never dark, but actually as bright as dusk. And out in the countryside the night sky is an intricate puzzle of lights embedded up there moving slowly across the big dome. Or that the air around you is an ocean jam packed with floating scents moving slowly like leaves in a river. There is never a scentless moment. In a modern city, there is never a quiet moment.

@seanhenry8243

5 ай бұрын

It's actually the literal opposite of supernatural, but I see what you're saying.

@runnergo1398

5 ай бұрын

@@anandsharma7430 You made me realize the Universe is actually pitch black. Without our senses, there is nothing.

@detheet

5 ай бұрын

I tried eating magic mushrooms twice this year (nevver did any drug) and im blown away. I could see colors that ive never seen and have no nome or description with open and closed eyes, time was so slow but forever passing to such a mind boggling degree that for me, i thought about a million and a half things in real time but when i pull my phone only 1 or 2 minutes have passed, and it went for over 9 HOURS. Ive did some research and time have a ''gland'' in our brain and such psychedelics alter it. So, since everyone have different brains, and sometimes someone talk about ''wow today passed really quick, didnt it?'' and it can be true or false depending on how your gland were doing in the present time. Crazy.

@runnergo1398

5 ай бұрын

@@detheet Yep. All humans experience time a little different (sometimes a LOT different) from each other. It really depends on our brain and how it comprehends reality at the speed it runs. Not to mention some humans experience reality way more different than the majority of people. If you did research on all the different ways, it would blow your mind. Compare all that to animals and what they experience is even more mind blowing.

I literally tweeted the other day "the thing people forget the most about the potential for alien life is the possibility that they exist on a different time scale than us, either moving so fast or so slow we may not be able to perceive them."

@liamrmorgans921

Жыл бұрын

Very interesting point. That might explain the alleged ufo sightings where they describe them moving incredibly fast

@Ostritchbones

Жыл бұрын

Experiencing time faster won't make you move faster

@liamrmorgans921

Жыл бұрын

@@Ostritchbones experiencing time slower can lend itself to moving faster though. Like the house fly compared to us humans. Like the example he gave in the video, if you move slowly toward the fly it arguably can’t even see you move because its too slow for them to pick up. Thats just two species on the same planet in the same galaxy. Maybe the difference gets even more heightened on different planets in different galaxies.

@kevincastro8768

Жыл бұрын

@@liamrmorgans921 But the fly is still bound to physical laws which both animals and machine need to follow. Animals adapt to their environment, so like the guy said, time perception doesn’t make you move faster.

@liamrmorgans921

Жыл бұрын

@@kevincastro8768 well it can make you move faster, but the question is by how much. Like the flies not being able to detect our slow movement, yet being able to move very fast. Im just thinking maybe there’s aspects of physics that we don’t understand that change in different galaxies, Maybe being in closer proximity to black holes has an impact etc. or maybe even material existence itself changes based on what frequency/timescale the life form is attuned to. Sort of like other dimensions. Rupert Sheldrake has an interesting ted talk that was banned (you can find on KZread) where he talks about the “laws” of nature and his suggestion that they arguably aren’t actually laws. He uses the speed of light as an example and says they “fixed it” as a constant to the speed it’s recognised at today, but the data actually showed that it was not a consistent speed.