Man, I wish the Indus Valley hieroglyphs are deciphered in our lifetime.

@karthickb1973

3 жыл бұрын

they would have deciphered and used it for their own benefit or neglected it because it did not benefit them.

@smitas65

3 жыл бұрын

I think they have been deciphered. Read it somewhere

@b.m.5068

3 жыл бұрын

Look up for Sue Sullivan and her deciphering system She says that it is Sanskrit

@smitas65

3 жыл бұрын

@@b.m.5068 I think it would be closer to Tamil, which is older than Sanskrit. Cos it has now been proved that the Indus Valley civilization moved southwards in India towards Tamil Nadu.

@farhanrivin934

3 жыл бұрын

That would unfold a world of ancient knowledge. We need another like Rakhal Das Banerjee.

My mum is an Indonesian, and she taught me that almost every (if not all) inscription in sanskrit that were ever found in Indonesia was written in palavan script. That was an info that has been sleeping for many many years, but when I read the title of this video I was like, "aren't sanskrit written in pallava?"

@ghosthunter8664

2 жыл бұрын

It's hindu gods communication language 🙂

@galaxray8700

2 жыл бұрын

@@ghosthunter8664 and also the language of most ancient sages.

@DGHC121

2 жыл бұрын

Kindly. Post photo of PALLAV alphabets

@CeeesS

2 жыл бұрын

Pallav Script associated with Pallav Dynasty of South India is very similarly arranged like the Devanagari...

@droneacharya6057

2 жыл бұрын

sanskrit has no written script. Pallava is Tamil script

Glad you mentioned the the difference between Composed and Written. Many people still believe we have a 5000 year old copy of Rig veda in a museum.

@shahidachoudhury6925

Жыл бұрын

Yes , the reason they used to heard that , as me used to believe that crap too.

@rishavkumar1250

Жыл бұрын

@@shahidachoudhury6925 then there are idiots who think Rigveda didn't exist before 400 CE

@jayakumarmurugaiyan5587

Жыл бұрын

Nasty bruh 🤣😂🤣

@Kakashihatake-uo6ou

Жыл бұрын

@@rishavkumar1250 😁 I know them

@bombayiit

Жыл бұрын

@@rishavkumar1250 Pali prakit predates sanskrit. Sanskrit is fake news 😂 kuch bhi aake gapod do paper pe. Sabke proof mil Gaye bas ye brahman dharam ke proof nahi milte na ramayan na mahabharat sab bas fek rakha hain paper pe. Abe andhbhakto jake R.s Sharma ki ncert hi padh lo ek proof nahi de rakha hain kahi pe. Indus Valley civilisation mil gayi Buddha mil Gaye written form me ashoka mil Gaye Pali prakit mil gayi brahmi script or dhamm script me Gupta ke inscriptions mil Gaye sabke mil Gaye lekin brahman ki comics ka ek proof nahi mila na kisi ashokan pillar pe na megasthanese na dusre traveller me. Brahmano ka sab kuch Mughal ke time likha gaya aur 1000 saal se purana hain hi nahi kuch . Aaya samaj wale bolte hain lakhs of years old haan shayad dinosaur ke saath daudte honge brahman. Sarasvati river ka mention hain Abe gadho koi bhi kudhai me proof nahi mila tumhara jaha sarasvati river Bol ke khoda vaha bhi buddhism hi mila. Koi kaam me apne kuch bhi bolta rahe to wo Indian culture ho jayega kya. Indian culture wo hota hain jo logo ka culture ho sari dynasty sab log Pali prakit ka use kar rahe hain. Brothers ne aake khoja Indus valley civilisation ko Ashoka ko aur brahman claim karta hain hun 5000 saal purana hain abe 5000 saal se tum log ek dusre ke jaan ne bolke aarahe ho Sanskrit to tum logo to pata hi nahi tha Indus valley cilvilisation ka na ashoka na. Ashokan pillar ko shivling bol ke paisa kamane lage kahi par hanuman ki gada bol Diya pillar ko. Brothers ne aake decipher kiya Pali prakit ko. Tum logo ki Sanskrit Pali prakit se hi evolve hui hain 7 th se 8th century ad me aur classical to aur baad me aayi hain mughals ke time. Ye fake news mar failao ab sab pakad me aagaya hain.

When I hear the word,”Sanskrit” I said to myself,this is something sounds familiar to me, I got to watch the whole video. There are so much inscriptions written on the walls of the famous Angkor Wat temples in Cambodia. We called it,” the language of the Khmer during Angkor Wat era”. I don’t have a lot of knowledge in regards to the Khmer histories

@Chanakya2

Ай бұрын

Yes khmer were Hindus so they used sanskrit is thier religious prayers etc. u are from Cambodia??

@snailcheeseyt

Ай бұрын

Didn’t expect to see Cambodia mentioned! I get really excited when I learn more about my parent’s country

@user-mj5yv2xy9j

Күн бұрын

Khemer were Buddhists. Hindu is Persian word meaning Black, Dacoit, Thief, etc. Hinduism didn't exist when Buddhist monks or Buddhism arrived in Cambodia.

@snailcheeseyt

Күн бұрын

@@user-mj5yv2xy9j my family is half buddhist

Just imagine how many historical questions and mysteries time travel could solve.

@caseyclover1647

2 жыл бұрын

It's physically impossible to travel back in time, although there are theories on how it can be achieved but that would require unimaginable levels of energy and technology which would require millions of years for humans to achieve. Although I remember reading that New York Times said in an article in 1903 that it would take 1-10 million years for man to achieve technology to fly and 2 months later Wright Brothers invented airplane, we are just one breakthrough away from becoming intergalactic civilization, who knows maybe the next Einstein is sitting somewhere in the world looking at the sky and wondering why we see stars in the past.

@yohanbs9654

2 жыл бұрын

@@caseyclover1647 most likely we need an alien material to achieve it.

@karthikpaniyoor5348

2 жыл бұрын

Here is the thing we lack in India. We are willing to build a god damn time machine and use it to go 'back' in time, just to prove a point. The day we start thinking, to use that same time machine to go ahead of time, may be we can contribute to make this world better..

@Lomionz

2 жыл бұрын

Just imagine how many historical questions and mysteries time travel already created! =P

@caseyclover1647

2 жыл бұрын

@@karthikpaniyoor5348 that is an incredibly stupid way to think! People thought going to the moon was wasteful and stupid but the resulting technologies helped our civilization tremendously. Going forward is physically possible and quite simple in theory anyways, you just have to travel as close to the speed of light as possible and time and distance will slow down considerably for you, meaning you could theoretically travel to the nearest star and back in a matter of months or even days but due to time dilation 4.5 years would have passed on earth, that is according to theory of relativity, this would however require unimaginable amounts of energy to reach close to light speed. Traveling back in time is currently considered impossible since you theoretically have to travel faster than light speed but that is impossible due to laws of physics as we currently understand them and if anyone could come up with a valid way to do that then I would say they would be the most important person in the history of mankind. Greatness isn't achieved by discarding impossible challenges. As for India I've seen quite a few Indians boast about their scientific achievements but those same people don't even understand basic scientific concepts and are not proud of the achievement itself but rather of the fact that "we did it" Which is incredibly unhealthy way to think about science.

We're learning Sanskrit in school and I love languages. Especially I love to see people outside India discussing Sanskrit and what they have observed.

@NoName-ny1bt

3 жыл бұрын

It’s a dead language. No one speaks it and no one understands it either. It’s comparable to Latin which is also dead.

@teddyawesome5197

3 жыл бұрын

@@NoName-ny1bt learning Sanskrit is super beneficial to intellect and if one can learn Sanskrit, they can easily learn most languages in South Asia.

@neoananda

3 жыл бұрын

We some are learning & interactive with language Pali & also well versed with bramhi script. That doesn’t mean these languages are alive. Off course they are dead language. It’s our personal interest for which we are taking part.

@tanmaygusain1316

3 жыл бұрын

@@palashvijay4814 but most of the mantras they chant is in sanskrit.. so.. obviously they'll have to use the language.. but yeah they can misuse it and do scam people...

@atom6089

3 жыл бұрын

@@NoName-ny1bt it's not dead language bro..😂😂😂.. I can read sanskrit..

The earliest form of Sanskrit is that used in the Rig Veda (called Old Indic or Rigvedic Sanskrit). Amazingly, Rigvedic Sanskrit was first recorded in inscriptions found not on the plains of India but in in what is now northern Syria.

@asura2600

8 ай бұрын

it was not rigvedic Sanskrit instead vedic gods name in syria & some Egyptian contracts. it means before Sanskrit we spoke something else.

@NishantKumar-ry9rp

7 ай бұрын

​@@asura2600ji woh sanskrit ke words hi uss hue hai uss inscription me . Uss inscription ki language hurrian hai par uss inscription me bahut se words aise hai jo ki sanskrit ke hai naa ki hurrian language ke 😊

@asura2600

7 ай бұрын

@@NishantKumar-ry9rp words Sanskrit k h per script or language alag h ye muje pata h.

@asura2600

7 ай бұрын

@@NishantKumar-ry9rp these gods & deities are of pie origin

@NishantKumar-ry9rp

7 ай бұрын

@@asura2600 ji iss video me hi bataya gya hai ki lipi aur bhasa me difference hai aur Sanskrit ko kayi lipio me likha jata tha pahle aur aap ek baar acche se mittani kingdom ke baare me padhiye unke naam bhi sanskrit me the aur unke inscription par sanskrit ka bahut jyada prabhav dikhta hai saaf saaf.

What a great video ✅. I’ve really been looking for the ages of the vedas and found so much conflicting info, this is was by far the best I’ve seen, thank you 🙏

Also, Vedic Sanskrit (the language of Rigveda) is different from Classical Sanskrit we study today. Languages evolve over time.

@Saikalyan19

3 жыл бұрын

Nope Sanskrit never evolve

@patrickohooliganpl

3 жыл бұрын

@@Saikalyan19 Classical Sanskrit has the subset of the same grammar rules but new vocabulary (borrowings) albeit smartly adjusted to the Vedic phonetic rules. And the vocabulary set of BHS (Buddhist Hybrid Sanskrit) is one more else with grammatical rules still more reduced to the basic aspects. I can read and understand Mantras, Dharanis and short Sutras in BHS but I can't virtually understand Vedic Sanskrit. The same with Latin - I can read and understand medieval historical chronicles, legal documents and magical incantations but from the Classical Latin I barely understand Julius Caesar. A simplified subset of the same grammar but new and smaller vocabulary similar to the modern languages.

@theodiscusgaming3909

2 жыл бұрын

@@Saikalyan19 It did evolve. You might have heard of a product of its evolution, it's called Hindi.

@JohnDoe19991

Жыл бұрын

@@theodiscusgaming3909 Sanskrit never evolved . It was created to be rigid and not changed . Hindi is not evolved Sanskrit it is mix of Prakrit and Indo -Iranian languages .

@ij1316

Жыл бұрын

@@JohnDoe19991 Vedic Sanskrit is a little different from Classical Sanskrit. The Sanskrit which we study today has many new or changed words and grammar.

Yes... Sanskrit is the language not had a script (लिपि).. In northern regions in India we learnt Sanskrit by devnagari script in schools, some years later I got to learn that in southern, East and West regions they have their own versions of scripts on Sanskrit, even in ancient time Sanskrit written in many different scripts. Because of the technology I got to learn many valuable information, that I didn't even knew in my highschool times.

@bijoydasudiya

2 жыл бұрын

I personally prefer the Devanagari script though all Bengali Hindu religious scriptures use the Bengali script and Odiyas the Odiya script for Sanskrit. I am a Bengali.

@mumu6655

2 жыл бұрын

Bullshit technology

@kailashnathbansal7116

2 жыл бұрын

Okay ... Please tell me then how 👉 OM 👈 👉ॐ👈 the divine sanskrit/hindu word is written in any other language other than sanskrit .. let me clear you on this 👉ॐ👈 is written like this in any other language of the world because om is not just a word but a symbol 👉ॐ👈 Until we don't write om like this it's not considered to be divine .. in india many people keep there name om but they have write their name like this 👉ओम👈 & they are not allowed to write their name like this 👉ॐ👈 because om is not just a word but a symbol & this symbol is in sanskrit ... Sanskrit is 1960831121 years old & next year on the auspicious first day of chaitra navratri it will be 1960831122 year old

@dylandylanmorgan2642

2 жыл бұрын

Show wat u learned, simply it helps whoever in power just lick their boots for filthy survival 😀😂😂😃

@dharmajmithra

2 жыл бұрын

Sorry dear, Rig Veda is not first text, but Adharva Veda. It originated before 10000 BC . So all assumptions about the origin of languages are in different ways, and not just as said in this Video. Rig Vedic period was above 700 AD. So this is the last one. Adharva Veda's root subject was Black Magic. It originated for the safety existence in that time. So we must rethink about the origin of languages.

I am a linguistic enthusiast. Your presentation is quite studied. You made aspects simple. It indicates your laborious background work to prepare this. Great sir.

Your channel is the unique on KZread that I watch the same video several times! Thank you to share your amazing work.

The content we need these days

@iakinose

4 жыл бұрын

True

@mol-lyn

4 жыл бұрын

Why

@mikeoxsmal8022

4 жыл бұрын

@@mol-lyn why not

@mikloscsuvar6097

4 жыл бұрын

@@mol-lyn Because too many people, culture, country think these days, they are very special, they inventrped the wheel, when they are probably very likely,even if partially, influenced by something earlier, something not so purely "they as they think". And this shows a web of connection between us.

@kaedanf

3 жыл бұрын

@@kuldeepgaurav1419 Farming was around long before the Egyptians. Medicine is not culture nor an invention. Neither are math or astronomy. Printing would turn out to be a necessity and it would have been developed whether the chinese had technology for it first or not. You cannot patent nor invent a natural phenomenon or an evolutionary trait, so I don't know where you're getting the lucid dream and meditation parts.

New video about the Marathas (and a free PDF to go with it): kzread.info/dash/bejne/Zn5oxq-fdNaYnKQ.html

@saadansari2241

3 жыл бұрын

Nice Video, very well explained Don't worry about the comments here, they just want to listen Sanskrit is mother of All Languages for 100000000000000 B.C.

@ankitlakum1

3 жыл бұрын

Islamic Invader disrupted .. actually Sanskrit written in South India modern ... Old Sanskrit u can find on leaf Orr copper leaf ..

@05stanlykumar

3 жыл бұрын

@@saadansari2241 🤭😂🤣

@sethuvignesh3681

3 жыл бұрын

👍👍👍👍 great Sanskrit not oldest language It's just 100 bce

@ankitlakum1

3 жыл бұрын

@@sethuvignesh3681 100 bce that mean older

Very well made and researched video!

7:14 Sir Tamil inscriptions have been found in India dating to 500BCE you worked in Sri Lanka as well you should know this.

@gituparnasarma

Жыл бұрын

Bother don't forget Tamil and Sanskrit both have Brahmi which many politically motivated person called Tamil Brahmi which is the same thing

@knottytoob

Ай бұрын

@@gituparnasarma _/

As a Greek, I learned a lot from you about these other languages, and cultures, your presentation was very good. Thank you

@biomind

3 жыл бұрын

I am indoGreek

@meenaketanpattnaik7372

3 жыл бұрын

@Games Account that is Indica

@meenaketanpattnaik7372

3 жыл бұрын

The travel diary Indika of Megasthenes the Greek ambassador (of Hellenistic period) to India during the period of Emperor Chandragupta Maurya

@sumukhhegde7161

3 жыл бұрын

Very nicely packaged heap of crap. An honest history of language is the need of the hour. When these unbathed unkempt murderous villains showed up on our shores in the 1500s they didn't know how to spell grammar studies. Now they're telling us their ancestors taught us! What a ludicrous egotistical statement. Luckily Indians are questioning the basis for their assumptions and all will be revealed in time.

@desilonda9857

3 жыл бұрын

Hey did u know that Bhaarat was called INDIA by Greeks. Thank you.. But now this name is used for political conspiracies by Fools 😂😂

Now this is called a well researched and very well articulated video....people who commented on your previous video most probably don't know how complex the study of languages and scripts is. And they probably got that shallow knowledge from internet. Kudos to you

@theinevitable8000

2 жыл бұрын

I was taught or told like Sanskrit is the oldest language of earth and every language on earth evolved from it. Now after watching this video i'm speechless

@doityourselfpakistan6535

Жыл бұрын

@@theinevitable8000 so what have u lernt now that sansikirt is it self drived from other older script and its not the oldest one .

@theinevitable8000

Жыл бұрын

@@doityourselfpakistan6535 yes it is derived from other languages

@dominicj7977

Жыл бұрын

@@theinevitable8000 marathi, bengali, punjabi and hindi all North Indian languages evolved from sanskrit

@sachinpotdar7798

Жыл бұрын

@@theinevitable8000 no it is not derived from any languages other languages has been derived by it

U missed tamil ❤ !!! , that is older than sanskrit, but I respect sanskrit.

Thanks for the upload

this person is the clearest speaking person I have ever listened to, he should be a teacher, maybe he is.

@wennick4859

3 жыл бұрын

I don’t know his job but I know in a video he says he studied religion in university but he is basically a teacher with this channel

@desilonda9857

3 жыл бұрын

@Tian Wang he himself needs to learn more..

@desilonda9857

3 жыл бұрын

@@wennick4859 gud point.. He learned it coz they need to learn or else he can't Fool others.. Even he doesn't know much what he was talking abt..

@edwardspencer9397

2 жыл бұрын

@@desilonda9857 He has a PhD is languages and religion. Read his about us page. Stop doubting him. What are your qualifications?

@desilonda9857

2 жыл бұрын

@@edwardspencer9397 he may be PhD Holder in his place.. Coz of that still he is in doubt. Edward.. Brother.. English is newly Born.. I mean to say when ur/his ancestors were living in caves, my ancestors explored abt universe.. Wrote Vedas , Purans n etc.. So don't try to be judge here.. He has done PhD in missionary.. Edward what u understand by "Vedic science" ?

This was excellent. Thank you for making this

Thank you for a very detailed and scholarly video.

Thank you for the information sooooooooooooooooo much !🎉

I'm impressed by the depth and understandability of your videos. They're so clear, and well explained, I love them. I'm definitely subscribing, maybe getting some posters in the future. I'm a bit history buff, and language / writing systems are the part that interests me the most, the un-cracked languages and systems are like the enigma codes of our day, and I love learning about them and the attempts made to decypher and understand them. The ones we have cracked, it's like if I wrote something today, and 5,000 years later they were able to find it out (poor people, getting their hopes up and it'd probably be some really awkward letter constantly apologising that I couldn't think of anything to write down and telling them I'm sorry I wasted their time).

Oh gosh, the research in this video...Stellar work!

The earliest Tamil writing is attested in inscriptions and potsherds from the 5th century bce. Three periods have been distinguished through analyses of grammatical and lexical changes: Old Tamil (from about 450 bce to 700 ce), Middle Tamil (700-1600), and Modern Tamil (from 1600).

Excellent explanation. Removing all confusion. Thanks

Thank you so much for putting all these together for us.

We are actually taught in school that in Hindi and Odia, the languages that I learnt, the letters are arranged based on where we voice those sounds and I always found it pretty neat.

@MrPoornakumar

2 жыл бұрын

Bo Bo Black Sheep You're right. Our languages aren't random (finite)collection of symbols, each witrh a sound, that might change too.

@federicoparente3310

2 жыл бұрын

Does any other language contain the scientific structure and vibratory efficacy of Sanskrit? perhaps not? Sanskrit is very unique and original to India just like the concept of zero!

@AllhaSuarwala

2 жыл бұрын

Hindi and Odia are not much similar But Odia pronunciations are really tough for Non odias.Odia is a Classical language, odia has such sounds that doesn't exist in hindi

@rohanroy7872

Жыл бұрын

We used mug up sanskrit dhatu (odia lipi) otherwise get beaten and thrashed by our sanskrit guruji in school.

@rohanroy7872

Жыл бұрын

@@alexparakan i don't know its just Indian education system , completely outdated.

Thank you. Well explained.

Why is there no mention of the ancient grammarian Pāṇini? (circa 400 BCE, a philologist, grammarian, and scholar in ancient India, but who has also been variously dated between 520 BCE and 350 BCE, The dates given for Pāṇini are pure guesses by scholars)

@Mani-my8ob

5 күн бұрын

Panini is carved in stupas built by Ashoka in Jataka stories,so yeah he must be dated before ashoka

Thank you for this video and the research. Love information about old and ancient language and writing systems.❤️📖

1)Keezhadi excavation already shown link between INDUS SCRIPT and TAMIL BRAHMI. Tamil people have tradition writing name on pots. Lower layer in keezhadi dated to 1000BC found similar with indus script along some Graffiti marks. Middle layer date 600 BC found with Graffiti mixed with tamil Brahmi. Above layer have fully developed tamil brahmi. 2) pulimankombai inscription assumped date to be 490BC . Azhagankulam, Kodumanal,porunthalur, adichanallur,etc excavations shown tamil brahmi dated to 600-500BC.

@francisrajanlobo2698

3 жыл бұрын

Tamli not tamil brahmi, Prahmi kirutham 2200/2300 old Greek mythology king names time. Already tamili languages before 2490 times

@manikandan-ml9gd

3 жыл бұрын

@@francisrajanlobo2698 brahmi is term coined and agreed by scientific community. Brahmi is borrowed from Phoenician alphabet around 1200-800BC.. English/german Latin alphabet also evolved from Phoenician alphabet. Tamili is referred in pali literature to denote tamil scripts. Tamili is not scientific term, it's regional term.

@francisrajanlobo2698

3 жыл бұрын

@@manikandan-ml9gd 1200 - 800 bc not any proof have. Pali not related with tamili. Even paali word of school. Change in pali language like. So proof have in scientific. Science proof only world accept too not in religion way. UNESCO told 1430 ad times record make it. Approved.

@francisrajanlobo2698

3 жыл бұрын

@@manikandan-ml9gd phoenician alphabet around both side coin. Greek king name antides have. Antides have 1,2,3,4 . Greek antides long year only give too. 2200 or 2300 times not in 1500 - 800 not like? Greek carbon dating 2200 / 2300 times only. Pali or tamli you can not read or speak directly but later bali word loan get it. Seven PODAGOAS times relationship with east asia time. Indonesia, sumuthara, java settle people.

@manikandan-ml9gd

3 жыл бұрын

@@francisrajanlobo2698 please don't blabber and waste my time.. 🤦

the real problem is that these vedas mention stars and constellation at such points and degrees that it's deduced that Sanskrit was like 5000 years back. likewise river saraswati dried beds were discovered using satellites to be at least 4-4500 years and rigveda clearly shows river as fully alive and flowing. while learning etymology from PIE the vedic sanskrit seems more closer to PIE than any other language.

Beautifully explained Sir

As a nepali, i love our language... It reflects our culture and history

@elborrador333

3 жыл бұрын

What is the Nepali origin? I'm guessing you derive ancestry from Indo-Europeans because your language and customs are Sanskritic but also more Chinese-looking features than someone from Bihar or UP.

@marcus.the.younger

3 жыл бұрын

@@elborrador333 Our history is diverse... Some of our ancestors migrated from indus valley whlist some of us have mongolian/ tibetian origin... Just like hindi, nepali language is derived from sanskrit too... Some people believe that nepali language was actually derived from Khas language which in turn was derived from sanskrit...

@marcus.the.younger

3 жыл бұрын

@alan hembrom no not all of us... i think we know our history better than you, thank you...

@tupac7892

3 жыл бұрын

Nepali is Mix up of Sanskrit Pali and Brahmi..... Khas language is Similar to Eastern European language

@marcus.the.younger

3 жыл бұрын

@alan hembrom you said "nepali are indo aryan" so i thought you were referring to the nepali people... but yes sanskrit language is an indo aryan language

This was such a well-made video, thank you so much! Your precise way of expressing yourself makes your concepts not only easy to understand, but also avoid ambiguity and some common points of misunderstanding. Obviously, people with an agenda and a personal identification with specific languages may not agree with you, but the objectivity with which you present what is historically known is admirable and provides a useful tool for the layperson interested in linguistics. Thank you!

@theidleguy9041

Жыл бұрын

Just tell me one thing, did he gave any solid reference anywhere in this video supporting his claims?

@su-mu

Жыл бұрын

@@theidleguy9041 So, his statements are baseless?

@theidleguy9041

Жыл бұрын

@@su-mu Ofcourse. He gave little or no references for his claims

@su-mu

Жыл бұрын

​@@theidleguy9041Agree. I wish he gave some references somewhere: Did not find any in the description either.

Learned about Prakrit & Brahmi Lipi. Aural tradition is still prevalent in religious institutions that teach samskrit hymns.

I liked to see that many of yours viewers are very enthusiastic to know about ancient languages like Sanskrit.. and thier comments in your comment box is not a single rubbish thay said in their comments..👏👏 very knowledgeable information you have shared with us

Another great video! Suggestion for future video: what is the history of written numbering systems? What does it mean that modern numbers are Arabic numerals? How did those evolve and how does it relate to language?

@jared_bowden

4 жыл бұрын

Arabic numerals originate in India - It's interesting, many of the Indian writing systems shown in this video have their own corresponding number systems, including the old Brahma script ("Hindu-Arabic numeral system " on Wikipedia has a table of them). Eventually a set of numbers was modified for use by the Arabs, and this system was popularized in Europe in the early 1200s by Fibonacci. I would assume that the number systems evolved in a similar way with the other Indic scripts.

@ShubhamMishrabro

3 жыл бұрын

Originated in India translated in Arabic and reached europe

@happyfreeky

3 жыл бұрын

No, they’re Hindu-Arabic - a combination, not derivation

@Emcee_Squared

3 жыл бұрын

Jared Bowden Correct

@kuldeepgaurav1419

3 жыл бұрын

@J D Dear friend, I understand your emotions, However one must be vigilant of the times he is in and hence act accordingly, not forgoing the truth but with the times. Therefore I do not confirm with you as per. It is true that, out of all the existing civilizations, India is the oldest and hence it's not far fetched to assume all other civilisations must have borrowed from India on the simple basis of logic and reason which is also supported with evidences, however civilizations develop in tandem and borrow from one another. In the case of India, the earlier and contemporary civilizations from which India had much give and take are extinct and there remanants have formed the newer civilizations who also have cooperatively developed with India albeit borrowing much and giving less, which would be a normal course of events for Senior-junior. The Indian development has categorised these phenomenon of holding the truth but respecting the times, as 'Shruti' and 'Smriti', The Indian civilization of today is not outside of time or of natural course of events and hence is subject to all the natural developments that occur for a civilization. This cycle of time has all the ingredients as described through unravelling of Historical development of this world and India is a part of it. Nonetheless I agree with you on the Spiritual level, not forgoing the truth. The Shruti are timeless and so is the Sanatan Dharma, once cycle leads to another and the repitition goes on but for one who has attained 'Moksha'. The smritis however are bound to this timeline and true only for this 'Manvanter'. Shree Rama, Shree Krishna are the 'Avatars' within this Manvanter, that is with the times.

Rigveda mentions Sarasvati river multiple times. The river according to geological findings vanished around 1900 BCE

@Tamilhistoryguy

3 жыл бұрын

there is no geological findings.

@kunalrao2134

3 жыл бұрын

@@Tamilhistoryguy there is.

@Kolgai

3 жыл бұрын

@@kunalrao2134 No, there is no evidence that has been peer reviewed. I understand that post-colonial states feel a sense of shame and consequently hype up their native histories, but at some point you’ve got to be mature and objective about things.

@eldhosepeter6894

3 жыл бұрын

🤣🤣😂

@kunalrao2134

3 жыл бұрын

@@Kolgai again, there is.

Your voice is nice, clear and easily listening ❤

Very informative video. Well balanced and scientifically put analysis

Thank you for the knowledge, well done video !! 💖🙏

I can't believe that I found that so interesting, but I did indeed. thank you for so kindly sharing. Be well. Bye now

Bravo! Another, entertaining and enlightened video.

Very interesting. I'm wondering if you know anything about the numbers that we use today. I don't mean their mathematical values, but rather their shapes as symbols. Who designed them and when?

@ravindraachlawat

Жыл бұрын

The number system we use today is called Hindu-Arabic numerals originated in India at around 5th century by vedic scholars and mathematicians such as Aryabhatta and Brahmagupta, later on through trade the knowledge was shared with Middle Eastern traders, and mathematicians especially al-Khwarizmi and al-Kindi, who further introduced it to Europe at about 12th century.

Really appreciate the research that goes into creating these videos. Always so much to learn and think about! Thank you for being such a thorough educator :)

@akhilesht142

2 жыл бұрын

Hi

@deepika2440

2 жыл бұрын

The modern writing of Sanskrit like devanagari and bramhi might be younger. But linear A, b and IVC script itself was writing Sanskrit only and that makes it the oldest written language. The transformation from surviving IVC script (which are just seals with name of the person) to brahmi to other Indian written languages is quite apparent and impossible to unsee once you see it and the only reason 'experts' are not making the connection is dishonesty and agenda

@dizzyhitman_007

2 жыл бұрын

@@deepika2440 but most scholars argued that the Brahmi script had originated earlier than the 3rd century BCE. This claim is based on the composition of a set of texts, the Brahmanas, which were attached to the Vedic literature during the 6th century BCE. The Brahmanas are the only section of the Vedic corpus written mostly in prose, unlike the earlier sections of the Vedas which are hymns for recitation, specially designed for oral transmission.

@dizzyhitman_007

2 жыл бұрын

@@deepika2440 Sanskrit was the language spoken by the elite as early as at least 2000 BCE and Prakrit was the dialect of the masses. Both Sanskrit and Prakrit were written in the Brahmi script.

@dizzyhitman_007

2 жыл бұрын

@@deepika2440 Sanskrit (or Prakrit) belongs to Tamils and has been predominantly used by Tamil kings (Chera/Chola/Pandias - Devars - Lords) to promote unity, culture, religion, economy, literature, knowledge, and science (Linguafranca). This can be gauged from the fact that these kings not only ruled the entire India but also the world. They have been the once dominant world power and are the true natives of Indus Valley Civilization. Later Sanskrit has been adopted by various other kings and dynasties of Indian sub-continent.

I like the description of the vid so neat and simple,, feel not stressed

There are a total of 121 languages and 270 mother tongues. The 22 languages specified in the Eighth Schedule to the Constitution of India are given in Part A and languages other than those specified in the Eighth Schedule (numbering 99) are given in Part B.

you are my new favorite youtube channel

दूसरी से हैलो, मैं हूँ कार्यकर्ता नई दिल्ली में। इस भाषा के बारे में आपकी जानकारी के लिए आप शुक्रिया अदा किया गया था।यह इतना जानकारीपूर्ण है!

Sir, I only want to comment that you are matchless, unique.... I have no words to describe you, simply matchless, great, very studious and very useful, and true to the point

@ajazio

2 жыл бұрын

Mr P you have mastered the art of ass kissing. You will do very well in Indian politics

@dhruvtatteetablefan7502

2 жыл бұрын

@@ajazio ok Al Haramain perfumes Hyderabad

those who wanted to know Sanskrit writing was changed - again by Gujarati as Devanagari was first evolved in the Region which is present day gujurat - and Bhrami was again evolved in Eastern UP and Northern Bihar.... so Gujarati changed from Bhrami to Devenagari in 200 AD , yes AD not BC.

A very well researched informative video. And I was kind of waiting for the mention of the way the south asian writing systems are so well organised. Firstly, the vowels and consonants are separated. The vowels are arranged in short-long pair. The first 25 consonants are arranged in 5 separate group based on their place of articulation, with each group having 5 consonants sequenced based on aspiration, voicing and nasalization.

There are two types of brami script in india. One is called asokan brami and other one is tamil brami often called as tamili (தமிழி ). Asokan brami goes to 2300 years back and tamil brami goes to 2600 years back. You can find asokan brami only in asokan inscription. But you can see tamil brami written in pottery, rock, and etc. Ongoing excavation in tamilnadu (state in india ) will go even before. Both are completely different Tamil brami belongs to tamil language and many linguistics say that this writting system is from indus script because they found many similarity.

@chintanguru7083

3 жыл бұрын

Very correct argument! It started in the Southern India and went to the world. Even DNA, migration supports this claim.

@recoilzriot6211

3 жыл бұрын

@@kuldeepgaurav1419 I hope you are all from India or Speak Tamili

@islandsunset

3 жыл бұрын

Brahmi divided into two parts. One is north Indian Brahmi and the other South Indian Brahmi. Ashoka the great used North Indian Brahmi. Think about it... Tamil Brahmi is called Tamil Brahmi because it derived from Brahmi.

@praveencad1

3 жыл бұрын

What he said is fundamental analysis were correct ! It's has no origin letter continuation derived methods ! If you see in Tamil Current letters derived from vattezhuthu Than vattezhuthu derived from his own indus sign.. This language survived because it can drive by it own without any support from other languages ( by any means) Archaeologist found so many Indus description as well southern part of India, they seen the many evidence proof these people used same letter... Few years back in arcot founded stone axe dated 5000yrs same letter ..many things are there but this govt not willing to excavate to bring this knowledge to public ! Keezhadi also the best eg... They found indus letter in that pot..

@praveencad1

3 жыл бұрын

Moreover let him explain from where the Aramaic derived !!! Korean has 1600 word similar to tamili... Eg , In Tamil for mother and father we call as Amma , appa Korean language also the same for sound

Thanks, i had a test on ancient languages, i'll make the best of this!

Excellent logical and balanced explanation.

The "unknown" Script was found in Tamilnadu in 2019 in keezhadi the script is called "Tamil brahmi" Which is a predecessor of all brahmi scripts used in 🇮🇳

This is the kind of content and research that we NEED alot more focus on! Thank you for making this video.

3:33 you're wrong. Evidence 1- River Saraswati which has flown twice in history- before 10,000 BC the first time and then between 6000-4000 BC the second time. Rigveda has hymns about the intense flow of river saraswati.. so intense that Rigveda describes it as alive river. If Rigveda was written in 1500 BC it would've never known of Saraswati. Evidence 2- There's an archaeological site in Sinauli, Western UP, India which is estimated to be older than any even the Masopotamian civilisation. Rigveda describes 3 processes of cremation after death. Remains from all 3 burial/ cremation processes have been excavated from Sinauli. This again rejects the claim that Rigveda is only from 1500 BC, but actually much older text than that.

@SV-vo4ym

2 жыл бұрын

@Moon Cahn ok.. I'll take the challenge. I challenge you to give me evidence of these so called 'Aryans' first. After that we can talk on lengths about Saraswati river. Challenge accepted

@ln1050

2 жыл бұрын

Deep Underground, Now How Deep It Is, And How Wide, How Much Distance From One Point To Anonther Point ?. And Saraswati Is A Hidden River From Everyone Eyes. It Is Not Above The Ground To Be Called Saraswati River, Then Who Name This River ?

I really like these kind of Info. I don’t know these are 100% true or not. But, 100% dedication by the video creator 👍🤟

Only if Nalanda survived, all these questions would have been answered, as Nalanda library stored manuscripts in every scholarly language of that time.

Quite knowledgeable and quite clear too. Congratulations

I just discovered your channel and I’m really enjoying it. Thank you for producing this type of content in a scholarly and unbiased way. 🙂

@Abeturk

2 жыл бұрын

Deriving a new verb in turkish 1.(Der-mek= ~to set layout & to provide)=ter'kib & ter'tib etmek (used after the verbs which ending with a consonant) Verb+"Der" is used as suffix for the subtle voiced words (ter-tir-tür/der-dir-dür/er-ir-ür) Verb+"Dar" is used as suffix for the thick voiced words (tar-tır-tur/dar-dır-dur/ar-ır-ur) (ak-mak>aktarmak)(bakmak>baktırmak)(almak>aldırmak)(çıkmak>çıkarmak)(kaçmak>kaçırmak) 2.(Et-mek = ~ to make) (mostly used after the verbs ending with a vowel sound and when the suffix "der" was used before) Verb+"T" is used as suffix for the subtle voiced words (t-it-üt) Verb+"T" is used as suffix for the thick voiced words (t-ıt-ut) (ak-mak>akıtmak)(bakmak>bakıtmak)(yürümek>yürütmek)(yırmak>yırtmak)(öldürmek>öldürtmek) 3.(Eş=partner) (together or with partner)-(all together or altogether)-(each other or about each one) Verb+"Eş" is used as suffix for the subtle voiced words (eş-iş-üş) Verb+"Aş" is used as suffix for the thick voiced words (aş-ış-uş) (gör-mek-görüşmek) (bulmak>buluşmak)(uğramak-uğraşmak) (çalmak-çalışmak) 4.(Al / El)= come to a state/a form through someone or something (to get being ...ed) Verb+"El" is used as suffix for the subtle voiced words (el-il-ül) Verb+"Al" is used as suffix for the thick voiced words (al-ıl-ul) (it's used as N to shorten some verbs) (gör-mek-görülmek) (satmak>-satılmak)(vermek>verilmek)(yemek>yeyilmek/yenmek) 5."En"=own diameter(self environment)=(about own self) Verb+"En" is used as suffix for the subtle voiced words (en-in-ün) Verb+"An" is used as suffix for the thick voiced words (an-ın-un) (gör-mek>görünmek) (bulmak>bulunmak) (tıkamak>tıkanmak) (kıvırmak>kıvranmak) Mak/Mek...(emek)=exertion /process Git=Go (verb root) Git-mek= to go (the process of going) (Git-der-mek>gittirmek)=1.Götürmek= to take away (2. Gidermek=~to resolve) (Git-en-der-mek>gidindirmek)= Göndermek= to send Gel-mek= to come (Gel-der-mek>geltirmek)=Getirmek= to bring 1.Gelmek...2.Getirmek...3.Getirtmek...4.Getirttirmek..5.Getirttirtmek..and it's going so on Dür-mek= to roll it up (to make it becomes a roll) Dör-mek= to rotate on its axis ( törmek=old meaning)-(to stir it , to mix it(current meaning) (döngü)törüş/törüv=tour (törüv-çi=turqui)(tör-geş=turkish)=tourist...(törük halk=mixed people in ownself) (Tör-en-mek)>dörünmek= to rotate oneself /(2. to turn by oneself) (Törn-mek)>Dönmek= to turn oneself (Dön-der-mek)>döndürmek= to turn something (Dön-eş-mek)>dönüşmek= to turn (altogether) to something (Dön-eş-der-mek)>dönüştürmek= to convert/ to transform Yürü-mek= to go on (to walk) (Yürü-et-mek)>yürütmek= to make it go on (Yürü-et-der-mek)>yürüttürmek=to be provider ensuring it's going on simple wide tense for positive sentences Var-mak= to arrive (for the thick voiced words) (positive suffixes)=(Ar-ır-ur) Er-mek= to get (at) (for the subtle voiced words) (positive suffixes)=(Er-ir-ür) for negative sentences Ma=not Bas-mak= to dwell on /tread on (bas git= ~leave and go) Maz=(negativity suffix)=(ma-bas) =(No pass)=Na pas=not to dwell on > vaz geç= give up (for the thick voiced words) Ez-mek= to crush (ez geç= ~think nothing about) Mez=(negativity suffix)=(ma-ez) =(No crush)=doesn't > es geç = skip (for the subtle voiced words) Tan= the dawn Tanımak= to recognize (~to get the differences of) (Tanı-ma-bas)= tanımaz= ~doesn't recognize (Tanı-et-ma-bas)= tanıtmaz= doesn't make it get recognized (Tanı-en-ma-bas)= tanınmaz= doesn't inform about oneself (doesn't get known by any) (Tanı-eş-ma-bas)= tanışmaz= doesn't get known each other Tanışmak= to get to know each other =(~to meet first time) Danışmak= to get information from each other Uç=~ top point (Uç-mak)= to fly (Uç-a-var)= Uçar=it flies (arrives at flying) (Uç-ma-bas)= uçmaz= doesn't fly (~gives up flying) (Uç-der-ma-bas)=(uçturmaz)=uçurmaz= doesnt fly it (doesn't make it fly) (Uç-eş-ma-bas)=uçuşmaz= doesn't (all)together fly (Uç-al-ma-bas)=uçulmaz= doesn't get being flied Su=water (Suv)=fluent-flowing (suvu)=Sıvı=fluid, liquid Suv-mak=~ to make it flow onwards/upward (>sıvamak) Suy-mak=~ to make it flow over Süv-mek=~ to make it flow inwards Sür-mek=~ to make it flow on something Suv-up =liquefied=(soup) Sür-up(shurup)=syrup Suruppah(chorba)=soup Suruppat(sherbet)=sorbet sharap=wine mashrubat=beverage (Süp-mek)=~ to make it flow outwards (süp-der-mek>süptürmek)>süpürmek=to sweep Say-mak=~ to make it flow one by one (from the mind) = ~ to count ~ to deem (sayı=number) (bilgisayar=computer) Söy-mek=~ to make it flow from the mind (Söy-le-mek= to make the sentences flowing through the mind =~to say, ~to tell ) Sev-mek=~ to make it flow from the mind (to the heart) = to love Söv-mek=~ call names (to say whatever's on own mind) Süy-mek=~ to make it flow from inside (süyüt) =Süt= milk Soy-mak=~ to make it flow over it/him/her ( to peel, ~to strip, ~to rob ) (Soy-en-mak)>soyunmak=to undress (Sıy-der-mak)>sıyırmak= skimming, ~skinning Siy-mek=~ to make it flow downwards =to pee Siyitik>Sidik= urine Süz-mek=~ to make it lightly flow from up to downwards (~to filter, strain out) Sez-mek=~ to make it lightly flow into the mind (~to perceive, to intuit) Sız-mak=~ to get flowed slightly/slowly (~to infiltrate) Sun-mak= to extend it forwards (presentation, exhibition, to serve up) Sün-mek=to expand reaching outwards (sünger=sponge) Sın-mak=to reach by extending upwards or forwards Sin-mek=to shrink (oneself) by getting down or back (to lurk, to hide onself) Sön-mek=to get decreased by getting out or in oneself (to be extinguished) Sağ-mak= ~ to make it's poured down (Sağanak=downpour) (sağ-en-mak)>sağınmak=~ to make oneself poured from thought into emotions (Sağn-mak)>San-mak= ~ to make it pour from thought to idea (to arrive at the idea) Sav-mak=~ to make it pour outwards (2.>put forward- set forth in) (sağan)=Sahan=the container to pour water (Sav-der-mak)>(savdurmak)> savurmak (Sav-der-al-mak)>(savurulmak)> savrulmak=to get scattered/driven away (Sav-en-mak)>savunmak=to defend (Sav-en-al-mak)>savunulmak=to get being defended (Sav-eş-mak)1.>savaşmak=to pour blood / to shed each other's blood (savaş= the war) 2.savuşmak=to get spilled around.(altogether-downright)=(sıvışmak=~running away in fear) (Sav-eş-der-mak)1.>savaştırmak=(~to make them fight each other)2.>savuşturmak =(ward off-fend off) Sürmek = ~ to make it flow on something (Sür-e--er)= sürer = lasts /gets go on /drives / spreads on (Sür-der-mek)> sürdürmek= to make it continue (~to sustain) (Sür-der-e--er)= sürdürür = makes it last forwards ,(makes it continue) (Sür-ma-ez)= sürmez = doesn't drive / gives up fllowing on / skips the spread of (Sür-der-ma-ez)= sürdürmez =doesn't make it go on (doesn't make it continue) (Sür-al-ma-ez)= sürülmez =doesnt get driven by any.. (2.doesnt get followed by any) Sür-en-mek> sürünmek= (~to makeup) (~rides odor) (~to paint oneself) Sürü-mek= to take it away forward / backward on the floor (Sürü-e--er)=sürür=takes it away forward (Sürü-et-mek)=(sürütmek) sürtmek=~to rub (Sürü-al-mek)=2.sürülmek=to get expelled (Sürü-en-mek)=2.sürünmek=to creep on (Sürü-en--der-mek)=süründürmek=~to make it's creeping on (Sürü-et-en-mek)=sürtünmek=to have a friction (Sürü-et--eş-mek)=sürtüşmek=to get rubbed each other (Gör-mek)=to see (Gör-e-er)=görür=(that) sees (Gör-ma-ez)=görmez= doesn't see (Gör-en-ma-ez)= görünmez= doesn't show oneself (doesn't seem) (Gör-al-ma-ez)= görülmez= doesn't get seen by any.. (Gör-eş-ma-ez)= görüşmez= doesn't get seen each other (Görs-der-ma-ez)>göstermez=(that) doesn't show (Görs)=(Khorus) Göz=Eye (Görs-et-mek)>görsetmek=to make it visible (Görs-der-mek)>göstermek=to show 1.(la/le = to make via)-~getting by means of ~to do through it -to make by this way ~getting with ) (used after the nouns and adjectives) (.le-mek-..la-mak) (.le-et-mek- .la-et-mak) (.le-et-der-mek-.la-et-der-mak) (.lemek-.lamak) (.letmek- .latmak) (.lettirmek-.lattırmak) Tıŋı= the tune (timbre) Tıŋı-la-mak= to get the sound out >(Tınlamak=~reacting /answering )(~to take heed of) Tıŋ-mak= to react vocally Tıngırdatmak=to try playing the musical instrument Tiŋi-le-mek=to get the sound in >(Dinlemek= to listen) Tiŋ-mek=to get at the silence >(Dinmek= to calm down / to get quiescent 2.(laş/leş =(ile-eş)= (to become equal with.) (to get the same) (used after the nouns and adjectives) (.leşmek-.laşmak.) (.leştirmek-.laştırmak) (.leştirtmek- .laştırtmak) 3.(lan/len =(ile-en)= (to become with)- (to get like this )(to have -this way.) (used after the nouns and adjectives) (.lenmek-.lanmak.) (.lendirmek-.landımak) (.lendirtmek- .landırtmak) by reiterations (Parıl Parıl) parıl-da-mak= to gleam (Kıpır Kıpır) kıpır-da-mak (Kımıl Kımıl) kımıl-da-mak by colors Ak= white Ağar-mak = to turn to white Kara= black Karar-mak=to become blackened Kızıl= red Kızar-mak= to turn red (to blush) (to be toasted) by a whim or a want Su-sa-mak= to thirst Kanık-sa-mak öhö-tsu-ur (öksür-mek)=to cough tüh-tsu-ur (tüksür-mek/tükürmek)=to spit out tıh-tsu-ur (tıksır-mak) hak-tsu-ur (aksır-mak) hap-tsu-ur (hapşur-mak)=to sneeze

Thank you! Very clearly explained distinguishing between written and spoken language, something many books on linguistics does not emphasize.

This really is a rational explanation ive seen, we indians r bit emotional hence we refuse to accept sometimes the practicals, especially the old language crying batch tamils

Didn't think you'd touch make on the language landscape, pleasant surprise! June 19th better come quick.

7:05 we don't have any surviving examples of writings in India before 250BCE. Meanwhile Tamil Brahmi in Keezhadi " Am I a joke to you?"

@sathiyangovindasamy7929

2 жыл бұрын

please don't call it Tamil Brahmi... it is actually Thamizhi

@acharya8959

2 жыл бұрын

No one cares. No one. This video is about Sanskrit, please don't spam all videos with , "Oh, what about Keezhadi, Keezhadi, Tamil is oldest....oh...." Meh. Sanskrit is in a different league altogether 🏅🏅🛕🙂

@draxmarvel

2 жыл бұрын

I think the uploadeder is a blind or deaf to see your comment

@joshua7500

2 жыл бұрын

@@acharya8959 if you don't care y comment

@yashagrawal88

2 жыл бұрын

@@sathiyangovindasamy7929 No it is not.

Written Sanskrit ( Bronze Age) 3300 BCE to 1300 BCE in Harappan Brahmi 600 BCE ( Iron Age ) Bambhi script of Lalit-Vistara and three Jain Sutras ( including Bhag-wati Sutra ) 200 BCE Ashokan Brahmi LATER DEVNAGRI 1600 AD English with modified diacritics to master diacritics of Harappan and Brahmi as well as DEVNAGRI. Note ; there are no Diacritics in PALI , ancient Hebrew, Phonecian, Egyptian, Latin and Ancient English .

I've just started watching this video - I love languages - and I have to make a point about your definition of languages. Sign languages aren't spoken, and generally aren't written, though they can be notated using Stokoe notation. Your definition explicitly refers to spoken languages, but even then some don't have writing.

Out side of India : oh great video Inside india : this is not correct ,he know nothing ,he is saying what westerns know😂

@KhukuriGod

3 жыл бұрын

*Inside India:* We invented nuclear weapons in 7000BC. We wuz kangz!! Bharat mata ki jay!!!

@M_Dinesh

3 жыл бұрын

Broooo 😂😂😂

@shoaibhaq8680

3 жыл бұрын

@@KhukuriGod what an absurd headcanon claim... Lol.. Whatever dude.. Whatever floats your boat...

@AakashKumar-gl2fk

3 жыл бұрын

@@KhukuriGod idea of nuclear weapons and aerodynamics is in the indian scriptures. Bharat mata ki jai is permanent.

@mhmridul1960

3 жыл бұрын

@@KhukuriGod savage !! 😂

Thank you. I am novice student absorbing many of your videos just recently discovering them.

Good job. Thanks.

0:46 hebrew arabic aramaic and i think also phoenician are written are shown left to right instead of right to left

Thank you for an illuminating documentary on the language ,Sanskrit.

@hydacanal

2 жыл бұрын

He's wrong about the dates.

Well the whole theory that Brahmi came from Aramaic is no longer valid, because more pre-Ashokan inscriptions have been found recently of earlier time than 250BCE. Examples include Brahmi script of Anuradhapura, Srilanka of 5th-6th century BCE, Tamil Brahmi script from Kaladi, Tamilnadu from 4th century BCE. Please include them.

@summergram

3 жыл бұрын

Yeah, it is strange that he only did partial research on this topic... Why would anyone talk about something so complicated like sanskrit and risk making mistakes - like the one you mention. There are many other mistakes in this video, so it is clear that youtubers just dnt have the respect for foreign history, systems or culture.

@sasdasbd

3 жыл бұрын

@@summergram Plus they read more from colonized British fake history of Aryan-Invasion Theory, so anything Indian has to be imported from middle-east and Central Asia. :-) The Indus valley civilization and following Vedic civilization are a nightmare to them. Because other older civilizations like Babylon, Egyptians, Roman, Mayan are destroyed easily by the European, but only Indian and Chinese civilization stood tall to those invaders and still thriving.

@bineshsukumaran1994

3 жыл бұрын

There are Jewish burial tombs around 300bc in South India. So contact with middleast and india is very old. They might have introduced early version of ibrahim script. Writing systems are adopted based of ease of writing. Just like we use english alphabets while texting in our mother tongue using phones. Becoz it is easier to type. It is very possible Indians might have dropped native scripts for foreign ones. We still haven't deciphered Indus script. Until then we can only make conclusions based on evidence we have. i.e. brahmi might have roots in Phoenician

@kuldeepgaurav1419

3 жыл бұрын

@@bineshsukumaran1994 What exactly is this evidence that you mention. I am much interested. Kindly share it.

@AditiSharma-hk3tn

3 жыл бұрын

soo true , i waa going to comment the same but don't need to now😬👏

A very interesting and nice explanation and authentic too. Sanskrit in the present form is not more than 600 years old and that is the written version. Tamil language, considered one of the oldest by many, is also laced with sanskrit but its letters differs completely from devnagri. Paper came into existence much much later as the old writings are mostly on stone slabs, papyrus and some tree barks. The oldest writings would have been on the sand or mud only and those that caked in the sun and got preserved may be available as some of the old footprints are available to the anthropologists. Also, sanskrit must have gone a seachange from the originally spoken version to the modern written version and cannot be called as the original oldest language.

Very nice explanation.

I greatly appreciate all if your video presentations. I have learned a lot from you. The Cambodian language used a combination of Khmer, Sanskrit, and Pali. The written Khmer language was derived from the Abudiga Brahmi script that appeared in ancient Cambodia around the 6th century. Since then, the script had transformed about seven times to look like the present written form that is used in Cambodia.

@lll2282

2 жыл бұрын

Pali originates from Sanskrit btw

@lll2282

2 жыл бұрын

@True Light even murayans and guptas did, u ll find beautiful hindu - Buddhist fusion in entire sea countries. And we know that ashoka spread buddism in sea countries

Such a nice video. Very clear and concise. Love such content. It's always interesting to note similarities, patterns and such things.

Well played, dude. U concluded the date of ancient written sanskrit while referring it as its composition. Hat's off to westerns

@sahilsingh6048

10 ай бұрын

You are andhbhkt , blinded by fake nationalism and doesnt want to accept

@KumarK-cn1sj

10 ай бұрын

@@sahilsingh6048 Do you want people to accept imginations of westerners ?

How does one (or a group) compose such lengthy poems and hymns without writing them down ? And then even share it in their society ? Once a society has memorized all those hymns, then I can imagine they can be shared with the next generation as they grow up. But how does it start ?

Sanskrit maybe is standardized form of prakrit because the meaning of prakrit means natural and Sanskrit means civilized or standardized

@DrAshishPradhan

3 жыл бұрын

Good point

@aishwaryadharmaastrology1688

3 жыл бұрын

Are u fool? Prakrit has descended from vedic Sanskrit

@kapilgyawali4758

3 жыл бұрын

@Nihilist Seeker well current Nepali bhasa is also standardized from khas bhasa . I am no expert on this I am sharing this from someone else view which I thought was legit .

@kapilgyawali4758

3 жыл бұрын

@Nihilist Seeker Sanskrit can't be a common man's language buddy lot of work is done to make this scientific language. It's a work of geniuses not a command man

@kapilgyawali4758

3 жыл бұрын

@Nihilist Seeker so you think Sanskrit was comman men language? It just doesn't fit with evolution does it? I believe some cult of geniuses made it from lot of hard work

can you do me a favor: solve the indus valley script? asking for mankind.

@WangJinZhu

3 жыл бұрын

@Chitragupta if it were easy, then it would have already been cracked

@Ss-tt9pp

3 жыл бұрын

Far greater minds have failed to do it.. I doubt this guy can

@anybody9059

3 жыл бұрын

I think already done by Prof U R Rao

@Ss-tt9pp

3 жыл бұрын

@@WangJinZhu that was sarcasm my friend

@WangJinZhu

3 жыл бұрын

@@Ss-tt9pp OKK

The most important point about researching the ancient matters is nobody knows it for certain. It always leaves room for speculation and further study. Humility is necessary.

Northern Indian languages (Indo-Aryan languages) did not evolve directly from Proto-Iranian (that would be modern Iranic languages like Perisan, Balochi, Pashto, Kurdish, etc.), but rather Prakrits via Vedic Sanskrit from Proto-Indo-Aryan (to which Proto-Iranian and modern Iranic languages are related to), ultimately from the Proto-Indo-Iranian subfamily of Indo-European, which Proto-Iranian, along with Proto-Indo-Aryan, descend from.

Informative and well-presented. Thank you. Please note that the first half of the word "Sanskrit" is pronounced like the English word suns, not like the English sans.

@dev_peace_soul

2 жыл бұрын

This video is not fully informative 😐

@thetruthseeker5448

2 жыл бұрын

...and historically and linguistically ACCURATE too. Not based on personal emotions, cultural baggage, myths and legends

@federicoparente3310

2 жыл бұрын

@@thetruthseeker5448 the speaker begins by suggesting that original Sunskrit [which he knows not how to pronounce) is "probably" from Aramaic. By the end of his presentation even he himself doubts his own original comments. there is the suggestion that Sanskrit may have been invented by someone,, May i suggest that "Like the table of the atomic elements" Some great sage received it in his consciousness and it continued on, Too many linguistic connections show that it existed long before any middle eastern languages, In the indus valley archeological discoveries of recent years the skeleton of a Yogi in Lotus posture has been dated at about 7,000 years - how many millennia prior to that was required to develop this advanced science and what language did they speak?

@mahamahopadhyaya_._

2 жыл бұрын

@@federicoparente3310 He said Brahmi could be a new invention, not Sanskrit...

@MaryamMaqdisi

2 жыл бұрын

@@federicoparente3310 dude, he never made those claims, he said language isn't the same as script (and it isn't, otherwise German and English would be the same thing as Latin), and that the sanskrit language is ancient and rich, there's just no evidence of it being written down before it came in contact with Greeks and Persians. He never claimed Aramaic is a linguistic ancestor of sanskrit, he never said anything you claim he did.

It may be that one culture finally reached prominence and began trading with another culture and the languages mixed by accepting new products and definitions from another culture. This alleviates the burden of deciding which came first.

hindi language is also 200 years old but the writing system on devnagri is for different languages, not Hindi.

A good one. I loved it.

This is a good video. Although many emotional statements will fall out based on where we live and what language we love, this rational way of understanding and accepting will have to be done. Which is the oldest is good to know. Can you make something like which is the most influential? Also why was chinese, japnese etc left out. Or did I miss that video! Anyways thank you.

@sebastiangudino9377

2 жыл бұрын

The Chinese and Japanese script have no relationship with the other writting systems discussed. The point of the video was to show how most writting systems descend from Egyptian Hieroglyphs thanks to the spread of the Phoenician Alphabet. The Han Characters were a Completely independent development. Just like Sumerian Cuneiform, Mesoerican Glyps and many many others

@pn2763

2 жыл бұрын

Well explained! Great video! Thanks !

@JOJO-of8vl

2 жыл бұрын

Look into Dravidian scripts used in India, they must have evolved from a ancient script/ language (idk which) that existed in Southern Asia, which later evolved into Southern India as proto - Tamil and other SE Asian countries as their own scripts. Also it's strange that a lot of Korean and Tamil worlds seem to match, despite the two countries (India and Kor) being nowhere near one another. Could be due to trade which we know the Chola empire with their massive navy would thrive on trade with ancient China/ Korea and other East Asian countries.

@anilvashist6758

2 жыл бұрын

@@JOJO-of8vl Another possibility... One of the ancient Korean royal family was from Ayodhya in North India. I got to know very recently but was surprised that some Koreans are aware of this. I don't remember the details but there are a few KZread videos on the subject.

@hopeworldbaseline843

2 жыл бұрын

@@anilvashist6758 the story of queen Heo Hwang Ok and King Kim Suro.

Wonderful job. Lot of research and hard work. Brings lot of clarity .❤️ Love to see more such videos

@rvgopal

2 жыл бұрын

For the layman.

I thank you for this objective view. that's how linguistics is done. Unfortunately, linguistics often turns into a tool of politics so these kind of clear explanations are of great value .. Stay objective!

The thumbnail of this video has an image which is written the Brahmi Script

You can refer tamil language... still its alive..Archaeological findings in keezhdi(tamilnadu)will give more insights

@utubetruthteller

3 жыл бұрын

tamil may be as old as sanskrit but it doesn't have same impact as sanskrit

@badaburner

3 жыл бұрын

Although you are correct, the current version of tamil is quite different to classical tamil.

@shanmugamshan2459

3 жыл бұрын

@@utubetruthteller Dude, I don't think so. If you find clearly about the history of Tamil language, it had caused far more impact than Sanskrit language. The history that we are learning about languages of India is been biased and deceived by current ruling system.

@utubetruthteller

3 жыл бұрын

@@shanmugamshan2459 mere rhetoric wont convince people, if tamil was so great why dont tamil priest dont use tamil mantras for puja, sanskrit grammar is superior to any other indo European languages like Latin and greek, English let alone tamil language, its quite futile to argue against that.

@shanmugamshan2459

3 жыл бұрын

@@utubetruthteller Yes true but no worries, one day the truths will come out.

Rig Veda mentions things live the river Saraswati which dried up around 7-9000 years ago , and it speaks of such as if it were present at that time. This and other findings suggest the Rig Veda is even older, and considering the fact that most hindu texts were originally passed down orally , it could only mean that the vedas are even older.

@ANTSEMUT1

2 жыл бұрын

What a religious text can't possibly absorb information from other sources and must be a first hand accounts of the event it is quoting. Is what you sound like. The old testament mentions events in the distant past before it was composed, no rational person goes huh must be contemporarnoius accounts of events.

@SattickDas2001

2 жыл бұрын

@@ANTSEMUT1 bro I never said that. I only mean to say that recent evidence suggests that Hinduism is older than what western historians suggest. To be very honest tho, I personally believe there is no One religion called Hinduism in reality. It's a conglomerate and it is dynamic unlike Abrahamic Ones.

@SattickDas2001

2 жыл бұрын

@@ANTSEMUT1 bro , the bible is full of shit that absolutely sounds like fiction. Hinduism is completely different from even the western idea of a religion. We're open to questioning, debate and everything else. Just to let you know the context , I myself am an Athiest Hindu, and also a Statistician and a man of Science.

@ANTSEMUT1

2 жыл бұрын

@@SattickDas2001 you framed it like it was a primary source for those events, not a second hand account it got off something earlier and incorporated into it's mythos. Also Hinduism probably has roots in proto Indo European religion conglomerating with indus valley religion and other indigenous religious motifs.

@SattickDas2001

2 жыл бұрын

@@ANTSEMUT1 anyways , do some research before you say sometimes. The vedas aren't even religious texts , they are a set of hyms that were originally passed by word of mouth. So it is obvious that quite a lot of information there is pretty dubious. But the archaeo-astronomical data present in the texts can help in uncovering a lot of information that we are yet to know!

Great job