the explanation was so clear...i learned a lot from this interview

@mcamoranto

9 жыл бұрын

Jariel Jariel true!! :)

The explanation was clear. Grace Poe is qualified to be a Senator and qualified to run for higher office. No doubt about it. I wish you all the best Senator and I am proud to say that I am a supporter. Lead us to a better nation. God bless you and God bless our country.

@kincabachete8414

2 жыл бұрын

Study first

the best Karen Davila & Atty.Legarda now i know thanks!!! for the info.

I and my family we will support Grace Poe all the way and no matter what.

I DONT REALLY UNDERSTAND WHY THEY MADE IT A BIG ISSUE FOR CITIZENSHIP OF GRACE POE SHE IS A REAL FILIPINO AND IT WAS PROVEN SHE WAS FOUND IN THE CHURCH OF JARO ILOILO WHEN SHE WAS NEW BORN. Is not supposed to be give her a hard time. . Most of Filipinos like GRACE POE LIKE HER FATHER.why don't you let people to vote for her.

@pedropitoyko6465

8 жыл бұрын

Hindi mo talaga maiintidihan kung Hindi mo alam ang batas ng pilipinas. Any foundling who's parents are unknown is not considered natural born citizens. Being a natural born Filipino citizen is a requirement to run for president. Grace Poe is a Filipino citizen but not a natural born citizen.

Mariam Santiago commented about the constitution law about foundling. Grace Poe is not Filipino citizen.

@rebornonfire9873

8 жыл бұрын

+mslouie browny Miriam almost failed the BAR exam wayback.

@jaypeecorum3054

8 жыл бұрын

+Reborn Onfire your statement is totally irrelevant to the topic. MDS almost flunked the BAR, yes, but was elected as a judge of the International Criminal Court. i don't think most BAR topnotchers would have achieved as much.

@dropsht

8 жыл бұрын

+Reborn Onfire ah so sa almost failure tayo dapat mag focus. wow!

@potusumanbibingka

5 жыл бұрын

She has dual citizenship, Filipino american BUT the issue is whether or not she's a natural born or just a naturalise born. Poe's not a natural born Filipino, she's just a naturalise born. Hindi siya pwede tumakbo dahil hindi siya natural born. She might be a Filipino citizen because she's born in the Philippines but she's not a natural born Filipino thereby disqualifying her from running for president.

She made it so clear to me...

The Philippines adopts the principle of jus sanguinis not jus soli. Thus, natural-born citizenship is not acquired from the fact of being born in the Philippines alone, unlike in the US. Grace Poe must be able to show that either biological parent is a Filipino for her to be a natural-born Filipino. Being natural-born is a constitutional requirement for one to be eligible to run for the presidency. The Constitution --the fundamental law of the land to which all other laws must conform. The law is harsh indeed, but it is the law.

@crewcutter2030

8 жыл бұрын

edi pinay sya, dahil nga dun sa case ni poe senior na gnamit na base case for filipino citizenship. Kc dun sa case naun deniclare lahat ng nkatira sa pinas pilipino at that time.

@Geraldrich

8 жыл бұрын

+crewcutter2030 I assume you are referring to the case of Fornier v. COMELEC where the natural-born citizenship of FPJ was upheld by the Court. The facts of this case are far different from the facts attending the case of Grace Poe. In Fornier v. COMELEC, the Filipino citizenship of Lorenzo Pou, grandfather of FPJ, extended to his son Allan F. Poe, the father of FPJ. Thus, making FPJ, under the 1935 Constitution, a natural-born Filipino. In the case of Grace Poe, herself being a foundling, her biological parents are unknown. That is why it is unclear whether her mother or father or both her parents are Filipino or not. Until such fact is clear, she is a Filipino but not a natural-born Filipino. That disqualifies her from running for the Presidency and continuing to hold her position as a Senator.

@jeremiahjavier4326

8 жыл бұрын

+gerald mendiola but if found in philippine soil a foundling is considered to be a natural born.

@Geraldrich

8 жыл бұрын

Jeremiah Javier No law regarding that sir. If there is, cite them here.

This brought back years ago,, a Filipina who give birth to aBRITISH AIRWAYS ENROUTE TO HONGKONG but it didnt say if the birthing was already at the Hongkong territory, upon touchdown she and her baby were brought to Queen Elizabeth Hospital here in HongKong

GO GO GO GRACE POE

YES, ATTORNY KATRINA IS RIGHT. Grace POE IS A FILIPINO CITIZIN

@chefgerry7633

8 жыл бұрын

+Nilda Berano Wala namang nagsasabi na hindi siya Filipino. Inaalam lang po kung natural born Filipino ba siya, or naturalized Filipino.

we really need to change the constitution. Those Filipinos who does not have a Filipino blood were deprived for their rights.

Very simple, she cant prove that her biological parents are Filipino.

@ferdinandmillendez5875

8 жыл бұрын

+Jace Red WHAT R YOU TALKING ABOUT, NO NEED FOR BIOLOGICAL PARENTS, B COZ SHE WAS ADOPTED FORMALLY BY FILIPINO CITIZENS ,AS SIMPLE AS THAT !

the only thing i could say about Grace Poe is she was an opportunist she was an american citizen and denounce it. Because she has a political ambition in the Philippines.

Ang mga anak at asawa ba ni Grace Poe ay citizens na rin ng Pilipinas? Well, Grace and her family can love 2 nations!!!

To reacquire Philippine citizenship, one has to take an oath of allegiance to the Philippines and the text of oath does not include renunciation of foreign citizenship. One does not take an oath and say I am a filipino citizen and then automatically reacquired Philippine citizenship and renounced foreign citizenship!

When did she file Income Taxes? Residency that is when she is truly a resident!

Correct GRACE POE is a Filipino 100% sure winner for Presidential election 2016

just let Grace Poe be come a filippino case she love being fililippina

Unless the definition of natural-born is changed, Grace as president is unconstitutional. I am not anti-Grace since I like how she speaks, but this issue really shed some light about her character. I am sorry to say that she is going to be like Cory who will use Malacanang as OJT. Her advisers will rule and not her. I regretted voting for Cory before so I won't make the same mistake again. I will vote MDS. She knows the constitution. Grace's supporters keep saying natatakot daw ang mga tao kasi baka manalo. Yes, I do fear it because look at what happened during Cory's reign. Look at what happened during Noynoy's term. Noynoy also has no track record. Well, there will be a constitutional crisis if Grace wins the presidency. And if she does win, I am not to blame. HIndi totoo na dapat maiba naman ang iboto para may pagbabago kasi kung walang alam lalo na at emergency situation na, walang mangyayari. Look at the Luneta hostage crisis and Yolanda.

She had her position as MTRCB Chairman as appointed by former Pres. Benigno Aquino in 2010? When did she go to the US to study political science? please be specific in residence we are confuse need to have clarification on the time of the study in the US and coming back here.

@marlongrau246

2 жыл бұрын

Foundling cannot be used anymore because she had renounced already. Is she is under of foundling law and there are natural-born citizen's issues with works like Atty. Legarda said that cannot be accepted if not natural-born citizen, so what more if renounced? Then regain again?

@marlongrau246

2 жыл бұрын

Plus the 1987 Constitution states in the Citizenship that natural-born citizens deemed if the mother of the child is born before 1973 and has Philippine elect of Philippine citizenship. There is no other rule to say, because if we apply the international law here of citizenship, the foundling citizenship, it really breaks the rule in our current constitution. So we cannot accept the foundling as a prime rule or supremacy rule over our fundamental rule of our land especially it is about government officials.

It's difficult to think these two (2) scenarios which could make Grace Poe, a foundling, as not a natural-born citizen: 1st Scenario: Two foreigners, male and female, having an unwanted child and left this child to the church of Iloilo; 2nd Scenario: The child traveled from a foreign country to the Phl and ended at the church of Iloilo. Quite impossible. It's unfair for Mrs. Poe to be labeled as NOT natural-born citizen.

@jaechavia1

8 жыл бұрын

+Diego Ledda : Grace Poe is a Filipino Citizen but she is not a Natural Born Filipino Citizen, because she is a foundling and we can not even trace her parents.

@prudenciadumaranlazarte-ca2571

8 жыл бұрын

+Diego Ledda read the constitution so that you will know

@prestihiyoso

8 жыл бұрын

It is possible and she has the burden of proof

mas humanga ako sa sagot ni senator miriam ng tanungin sya regarding sa citizenship ni grace poe at ang sagot nya grace poe is not nutural born in the Philippines.

Seemed like the Obama case here in the US..Other candidates are running scared of him being elected. And the rest is history.. Atty Legarda tell it like it is. If you guys are fair bring it on and MANO A MANO...GO MISS GRACE POE.

Money was greater than our constitution smh

You deserved to be my future President , sen. Grace Poe...!

just go back to Grace history, how she end up with the POEs, napakaraming case na ganito sa pinas, at karamihan eh, nate-trace naman talaga ang pinagmulan, and with the wealth of the POEs plus the help of their many supporters, madali lang para sa kanila ito, or may be??? they really don't want the public to know her real story.

@arthurbonds7200

8 жыл бұрын

+norms “theBigDifference” saviour Since she's a foundling circa 1968, her biological parents could be long dead. Considering (and assuming) these parents abandoned the baby in front of a church, the child was either unwanted because of personal reasons, or financial reasons. This makes it extremely difficult to trace lineage. Her 'supporters' are frantically combing her birth region for anyone who could be related to her (aunts, uncles, cousins, etc). They've tried a few DNA tests - they came up negative, thus no cigar. And since the Philippine Constitution states birth nationality is "jus sanguinis", you cannot assume that she was born of Filipino parents, as for all anyone knows, she could've been left by passing Hispanic tourists. TL;DR They've done what you're suggesting. No dice so far, and it's not that easy.

These are immaterial topics to discuss, we want to know how Poe qualifies to hold the highest position of the land and what she had done so far as a politician to deserve this.

She is not natural-born Filipino, because Poe don´t eat Lechon

Atty Legarda, please run for any office in the Philippine governent like Senator,a vice president or a President of the land, you are highly qualified, jail all sinungaling na abogado

Si Karen, pag kausap Ay English magsalita, nag tatabalog. Kasi, baka maubusan sya. Pa English pa, pano maiintindihan ng mga matatanda na hindi maka English, kung parating English ang banat nya. Dapat kung talalog ang ini interview nya dapat tagalog din ang salita nya.

This TV host is rude. She always interrupts the guest in midsentence instead of letting her finish her thought. What's up with that?

@guilmotabasa3571

8 жыл бұрын

mga putang inang nagmamarunong, ng ipinanganak si Grace Poe sa Simbahan ng pilipinas Automatic pilipino siya kYa nga bawal sa areplano sumakay ang buntis na malapit manganak kc kung sa america pinanganak american citizen ka kaagad. ganon din sa pilipinas kahit intsik tataY mo at hapon nanay mo paG dito ka pinanganak pilipino citizen ka. dba simpleng katotohanan lang iyan . at ano ba itsura ni Grace Poe .? dba pinoy na pinoy , eh bakit masyadong issue ngayon ang pagkA pilipino niya.? dahil kc takot itong mga kalaban siya lang ang matino tinong kandidato . sobrang bobo at ungas ang boboto kay Binay na hindi kayang ipaliwanag ang mga akusasyon ng pagnanakaw. c Mar Roxasnaman somobra pag idolozed ky Pinoy Abnoy kaya lumalabas na walang diskarte . si Dutertea somobra ang dada at lumalabas na utang na loob pa ng sambayanan kung ma presidente siya dahil hindiz nya talaga gistong tumakbo dahil sa wala daw siyang pera at hindi niya daw kaya ang problema ng Pilipinas. so sa nakikita ng ng mga tao c Grace Poe ang matinong kayang magpatakbo ng Pilipinas.

the reason why they want to disqualified GRACE POE is bcause she's very strong candidate for Presidency but the strongest among the candidates is RODRIGO DUTERTE, thou they still want DUTERTE not to run 'coz of jelousy, politics in the Philippines is very dishonourable.

Atty. Legarda has to slow down on her legal mantra, saying only natural born citizens are qualified to become lawyer or any profession for that matter. In 4:05 of the video, Atty. Legarda said that to become an attorney, or doctor or any profession here in the Philippines, one has to be natural born citizen. That is a total lie! Or a display of ignorance of the law, at the very least! Section 2, Rule 138 of the Rules of Court provides "Every applicant for admission as a member of the bar must be a citizen of the Philippines." It means both natural born and naturalized citizen may become a lawyer, and not exclusive only to those who are natural born. Atty. Legarda should be really careful in her legal statements because her superstar status makes her listeners or fans take her legal claims as gospel truth.

@whatevergoesforme5129

8 жыл бұрын

+CHEF GERRY She is not good as Miriam Santiago. Even MDS said Grace has a problem with this issue of jus sanguinis. We can be Filipino citizens as natural born or naturalized. So as long as you are a Filipino citizen you will have the rights of the being a citizen of the PI, natural born or naturalized. They twist this fact to support Grace's claim so this is the reason, I lost a little respect for Grace, although she does speak well and calmly.

@chefgerry7633

8 жыл бұрын

+WHATEVER GOES FOR ME - Would you please read my comment a hundred times. I was not talking about Grace Poe. I never mentioned anything about Poe, save to point out the legal grandstanding of Atty. Legarda and her clear mistake in saying that only natural-born citizens are allowed to be a lawyer or a doctor, or journalist. What Atty. Legarda claimed was a blatant lie. She lied. As a lawyer she knows the law, and the law says that to become a lawyer, one must be a natural born citizen, or a naturalized citizen. Nowhere in there have I mentioned anything about Grace Poe. And, oh, do not be misled by my passion in culinary arts, beacuse inside that chef's toque is another graduation cap in the college of law, from which I also graduated, and supplemented at U.P. College of Law. So, when I talk about the law, I know whereof I stand.

@whatevergoesforme5129

8 жыл бұрын

CHEF GERRY Huh, what are you talking about? I am not even attacking you nor insulting you nor assuming anything about you. I am not even debating that much with you so I think you should reread my comment that is just a comment and not meant to be a legal basis since I am not a lawyer. I did not even think much of the word CHEF since it can be just a label you want to use here.. I was just stating that Grace's lawyers will twist the interpretation of the law to suit their needs. A lawyer aims to win a case. I wonder where your defensive stance came from?

@chefgerry7633

8 жыл бұрын

Defensive?

so where the hell did Poe come from?!? was she raised by wolves in the jungle?

Wow, marami takot kay Grace Poe???

@chefgerry7633

8 жыл бұрын

+Marina Constantino You may see it your way. Or, plainly, marami lang may gusto maliwanagan kung talaga bang qualified siya according to the Constitution.

@jaechavia1

8 жыл бұрын

+Marina Constantino Grace Poe is a Filipino Citizen but she is not a Natural Born Filipino Citizen, because she is a foundling and we can not even trace her parents.

@boboka7878

8 жыл бұрын

AYAW KO TALAGA ANG MGA ARTISTA NASA PULITIKA....... MAS MALALA PA ANG GRACE POE NA ITO DAHIL ANAK SYA NI FPJ PWEDE NA MAGING PRESIDENTE..... AT KAILAN NAGING POSITIVE ANG WALANG KARANASAN SA GOBYERNO SA PAGTAKBO SA PAGKA PANGULO.... O.J.T.

LAWYERS the money is BAG,LET THESE DAVID AND THE BINAYS DISPUTE THE RULES OF LAW

PANO UNG PAGGAMIT NIYA NG US PASSPORT NUNG 2010? DONT BULLSHIT ME LEGARDA

tama si Gerald mendiola magbasa-basa nama kayo.

This is what you call a legal prostitution. 😂

This is American mentality.... Nationality which created by American... Now Philippines is western mentality combined with eastern

ipakita ni poe yung DNA nya para malaman ng taong bayan na filipino sya talaga . tapos ang usapan . ganun lang kasimple.

@jeremiahjavier4326

8 жыл бұрын

+Mark Francis Barriatos nakalagay ba sa DNA kung ano nationality? hahahaha wala nga yung birth parents panong DNA hahaha wow diba

Iboto natin si grace trapoe JOKE

No matter what your parents are if you are born in the philippines then you are a "'NATURAL BORN" filipino. Same goes to the states. I have 2 NATURAL BORN American Citizen sisters born and raised by Natural Born filipino citizens but legal RESIDENTS of the city of Los Angeles. You can NEVER run for presidency ACCORDING TO THE CONSTITUTION if you are not A NATURAL BORN FILIPINO CITIZEN. If you have doubts please look into it before you jump in the bandwagon of fools.

@adrianashley903

8 жыл бұрын

bec U.S. apply jus solis. but not in the philippines. and really bec. US law is based from the fact that people lived there are migrants from other countries. but to many countries they favored jus sanguinis. or by blood relationship

Marcos money works on her case

Duterte

about the issue for grace poe i don't care solid duterte me they just make publicity just follow d constitution hwag ng ipilit maging president hwag kang mag ambition

I am not a Poe supporter nor any other candidates but there was a gross misinformation on how Legarda state some of the facts. Around 3:50, she mentioned that foundling has no citizen, yes that is true because we could not trace or verify the foundlings parents if one of them is a Filipino. Furthermore on her statement, "cannot be a lawyer, etc. because we have to be natural born citizen" which is a sugar coated opinion. I look into the Integrated Bar of the Philippines and PRC, the requirements of being a lawyer nor registering to become a professional requires the applicants as Filipino citizen which is different from Natural Born Citizen. You are stating a sugarcoated lie that only natural born Filipinos are allowed. Foundling will become citizens as naturalized citizens but not natural born citizen and can still become professionals because the requirements only states "Filipino citizen" without restriction. Meaning natural born or naturalized citizen could become professional. Please lang don't interpret the law that would suit your camp's need.

@whatevergoesforme5129

8 жыл бұрын

+Sanie Joel Cagoco Agree. I am not anti-Grace but her supporters are deluded that Grace is not a trapo just because she is new. She is following the advice of trapos. She uses Poe which is a trapo tactic since she rides on the popularity of her father. I used to like her but this issue really shed a light about her character. Good thing I am for MDS who knows the law well.

YOU ALSO HAVE TO COMPLY WITH THE US RULES WITH REGARDS TO RENUNCIATION OF US CITIZENSHIP... THAT THERE SHOULD BE A FORMAL RENUNCIATION IS IMPORTANT AND CAN ONLY BE DONE IN THE PRESENCE OF AN AUTHORIZED PERSON... HAAHHAHAH UGOK KA ATTY LEGARDA

@marco121774

8 жыл бұрын

+Deanna Tanierla abugado ka ba? can you go to debate atty legarda?

@deannatanierla6770

8 жыл бұрын

ahahah halata halata kang ignorante ka sa batas... kuya kahit ex-convict may karapatan under the law LOL sus wag kang satsat ng satsat kung wla namang laman