As a potter who has done historical reproductions of Greek pottery, this is ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT!

thank you so much for this video. is really so good travelling my mind in the past. piece of art. Also the music fix so good. You are a artist. I don't believe someone is not Greek can touch Greek so much. You are welcome at Athens. To show you all the old places in and out of the city.

@PanoplyVaseAnimationProject

8 жыл бұрын

+Dimosthenis Markopoulos thank you very much for your kind words. I'm honoured.

@leifvulfila8837

6 жыл бұрын

Pretty certain since these people as others had written records. And what is wrong with this person to travel in a fanciful way via these animation threads to a past in a poetic and spiritual sort of way. Perhaps you suffer from a limited imagination. Dont ruin it for others by being the Minotaur in a china shop of fanciful memories.

Masterpiece. Fascinating!!!

That was brilliant!

AWESOME in every aspect!!!!

Incredible!! An excellent piece of work & very evocative.

This was an incredibly enthralling video! Thank you!

the defenders of europe....2500 years now

Dude, this is fucking amazing

I love this! I have always thought how great it would be if someone would animate what we see on the pottery! Thank you so much for this wonderful little tale!

Bravo! The ancient Greek vase painters would definitely have approved!

Wonderful! Amazing job!!! It was so faithfull to the actual battles

Brilliant, absolutely brilliant!

Not half bad!

THIS WAS AWESOME MOAR!

As a Athenian I loved it ,very moving. Pointless waist of life for all.but that what makes Hellenic. allways at war with. Every one.its in the blood,pity.

@OkurkaBinLadin

3 жыл бұрын

Why pointless? Entire Greek culture, civilization emerged around this kind of ritualized inter polis warfare. Without battle, you have no culture.

incredible work Well done to all !!!

Original and artistic!!! Well done.

what a great Video...THANK YOU

Excelent! Great job! Thanks!

very spooky but very cool love it

Truly amazing, thank you.

Τέλειο great work. BRAVO

Very good. Congratulations.

Gorgeous what you did here.

Awesome! No words!

That was fantastic. Incredible

Amazing! Really Very good job! Olders Spartans Kings say Praiers for this Brilliant piece of Art!

ΕΥΓΕ!! ΑΞΙΟΙ !

Fantastic ! I just found this vid Loved it every bit

Beautiful

Amazing!

Fantastic work!

i think left side is Sparta and right side Athens or Corinthian? or idk XD

@PanoplyVaseAnimationProject

7 жыл бұрын

Hi, thanks for your interest in Hoplites! Greeks at War. We can tell from the gymnasium setting of most of the vase decoration that this is intended to be a depiction of contemporary life - which makes it a scene of sixth-century BCE life. The similarity of the fighters suggests that they are all intended to be regarded as Greeks. The decorator may not have intended to be specific about which Greeks they are, but if you prefer to narrow it down, it makes sense to factor in where the vase comes from. The vase was made on the Greek island of Euboea, an island which was wracked by fighting between its two biggest cities, Eretria and Chalkis. So if you prefer to consider this scene as one of specific Greeks, it is most likely Eretrians vs Chalkians. If you'd like to see more about ancient Greek warfare and about this vase in particular, take a look at the animation's webpage: www.panoply.org.uk/everysoldier.html

Ok...that was awesome...🏛🏺🗡⚔🛡

Masterpiece!

great job

I've performed several lectures on ancient Greek hoplite warfare which can be seen on my own KZread channel and I think this is amazing and brilliant! I would love to see this style expand into other Greek historical or mythological events like portraying Thermopylae, the Battle of Champions, the war of fetters, parts of Plataea, the Iliad, or just about anything you could think of! What an imaginative and immersive method of illustrating everything I try to get across to my audiences.

@PanoplyVaseAnimationProject

2 жыл бұрын

Thanks very much. We’re glad you like it. You’ll find a load more of our vase animations and other materials on our website www.panoply.org.uk. Had a look at your channel, looks like you have a fantastic collection of equipment - very nice :). Feel free to use this or any of the other animations in your lectures.

Thanks so much! :)

admireable!

That was so special to watch!

Emocionante.

Increíble, excelente trabajo, felicidades

@PanoplyVaseAnimationProject

7 жыл бұрын

Gracias

Impressive work! I love it. Congrats!

It is excellent

Very cool/ kinda creepy- awesome!

HYpnotic!

It would definitely be a bloody mess! Carnage galore!!!

This is really amazingly done 👍

I can say that thes is the Peloponisian war!

perfect other than one thing. the hoplites held their spears underarm historically, not overarm as shown here. other than that its perfect, especially the historic depiction of a phalanx fight.

@PanoplyVaseAnimationProject

3 жыл бұрын

Thanks, glad you like it. We show them using both under and overarm spear thrusts as you'll find both depicted on contemporary pottery.

@laughingskull3881

3 жыл бұрын

@@PanoplyVaseAnimationProject ah , ill rematch then. Thanks

It is as cinema or board story as on kilyx some thounsand years before

Very nice animation! We would like to use a short clip (about 1 minute of the battle scene) for our new Astroconcert "Eclipse Without Borders" (the performance will go online in live streaming later this month). Is it possible? How would you like your credits to be given? Is there a email where we may contact you? Thanks and congratulations! Stefano Giovanardi and Angelina Yershova

@PanoplyVaseAnimationProject

7 жыл бұрын

Thank you for getting in touch Stefano, Angelina. I like the work you're doing as well. This animation is available to license to use, in whole or part, for exhibitions, events and shows for a small fee. I can't message you directly here but if you are able to contact me through our website form: www.panoply.org.uk/contact.html I can give you more information. Thanks again for the interest.

Excelsior

They (the ancient) tell circular story on kilyx

A W E S O M E ! ! ! !

Why the fuck ppl aren't following this insane dude, and why the fuck is he not creating more?

@PanoplyVaseAnimationProject

6 жыл бұрын

Ta. More coming in 2018 with vases from the National Museum of Poland in Warsaw.

@muricamarine9473

6 жыл бұрын

Je ne peux pas arrêter , regarder la vidéo, it's seemed, make more

@muricamarine9473

6 жыл бұрын

Steve Simons faster man faster, I'm dead here, I already watched this 25 times

@muricamarine9473

6 жыл бұрын

Steve Simons seemless, magnificent

@muricamarine9473

6 жыл бұрын

Those who disliked it, can suck my cock

Magic

!!!

Apotheon, anyone?

@mattaffenit9898

6 жыл бұрын

Hackl Schorsch Yes.

If John Keats could see this....

@scarecrow2097

8 жыл бұрын

who is that guy?

@PetrieRobert

8 жыл бұрын

+scarecrow gamer 'Ode on a Grecian Urn'. A famous poem by John Keats.

+1👍🇬🇷🇮🇹

Please don't call us ''greeks'' were HELLENES Our country is HELLAS (Ellada)!! Greetings from Makedonia!!

@BarryMichaels

8 жыл бұрын

Sorry Greek man

@WarshMeh

8 жыл бұрын

Macedonia is Greek?

@motherhacker7744

8 жыл бұрын

+WarshMeh ofc

@ashfur6719

8 жыл бұрын

+WarshMeh Since two or three thousand years there is an area here in Greece named Macedonia. The country Macedonia (or Fyrom) has been made just some decades now.

@natasagiokarini9774

8 жыл бұрын

+WarshMeh of course it is

O.M.G.

Wut?

This is really creepy.

(EDIT. I take back what I said in this comment, I misunderstood the video) I love you videos. But this one, not that much. Not only did you invent something never depicted on any black figure vase (or red figure for that matter), which is a phalanx style of warfare (of highly questionable historicity, but certainly an anachronism) and pushing tactic on top of that (that one being a completely modern invention) but you also added a 300 reference which has no place in any culture related video. Not a fan. This is not how these Greeks fought wars.

@PanoplyVaseAnimationProject

9 жыл бұрын

Vojkan Selakovic Thanks for taking the time to comment. We put a lot of thought into how ancient warfare should be depicted in this animation. Massed formation fighting is depicted on a few Greek vases. The famous Chigi vase, made in about 640BCE - a hundred years before the vase in this animation, shows massed formations, as does the MacMillan vase by the same painter. We adopted some of their motifs for the animation. I would agree that close formation phalanxes were a later phenomenon, but loose massed formations certainly were used in the sixth century, that’s why we’ve depicted quite a loose massed formation here. We also avoided including a shield wall and an initial shield wall crunch, as that doesn’t fit our idea of how things would have worked. The scene of marching feet probably suggests more unison than is strictly appropriate to archaic warfare; we took some artistic licence there and included it to convey a sense of weight and dread. I’m not sure what you mean by the 300 reference, but would be interested to know. If you’d like more information about ancient warfare and the creation of the animation, visit the animation webpage at www.panoply.org.uk/everysoldier.html. From September 2015 you will be able to read a more detailed account in our chapter, ‘Animating Ancient Warfare: The Spectacle of War in the Panoply Vase Animations’, published by Bloomsbury Academic in War as Spectacle: Ancient and Modern Perspectives on the Display of Armed Combat.

@jovanjorgovan23

9 жыл бұрын

Steve Simons Thank you for taking time to answer and patience to explain. In that case, it is I who didn't interpret well what was being depicted, and since we obviously agree on that development of Greek warfare, I apologize for my quick reaction. PS. shield bashing seemed painfully familiar from 300 movie. But anyhow, keep up the good work.