Ive been watching haeun since she was a kid, i really hope sm doesn't lose a star. haeun is so talented and deserves to debut!

@edoardorivera4119

2 ай бұрын

I wish she will debut as soloist like boa vibes

@imthecoolest50

2 ай бұрын

There’s no way any company would refuse to debut her. If she doesn’t debut, it has to be because she has other choices.

@Ellavie20

Ай бұрын

maybe cause she couldn't sing well ? Idk her, but that could the reason, or it's a personal choice

@shutyoasssup

Ай бұрын

It's giving hansol, 😭😭😭

@explicityy

Ай бұрын

@@Ellavie20​​⁠rapping is another alternative bad villians for example. but.l you can always learn how to sing its depends on your effort

When SM have all 12 members for debut lineup then why they are helding auditions

@shalu2044

2 ай бұрын

True.

@cattosakamotto

2 ай бұрын

Opening a new audition means a lot of trainees got eliminated from monthly evaluations but that doesn't mean they'll reopen auditions every month. They have a time period where they estimate everything from having planned evaluations to the possible trainees on the verge of getting eliminated. Also, the new audition they opened are solely for younger ones. They will train them for god knows how long until they're marketable enough for debut.

@xuoqq7930

2 ай бұрын

it’s for sixth gen, sm takes a while to debut another girl group

@aerabyeol

2 ай бұрын

L it’s for new trainees

@spicybiryani2617

2 ай бұрын

Obviously because they'll need new trainees for next girl group common sense

*All SMRookies did not make their debut excepet Aespa Ningning...That is really sad!*

@friedrice0922

2 ай бұрын

and yeri.. only yeri and ningning made it.. 😢

@friedrice0922

Ай бұрын

@honeylue yea kinda but yeri and ningning were the only smrookies that ended up debuting after their reveal

@friedrice0922

Ай бұрын

@honeylue yea that was what i meant hahah.. the rookies that got revealed early like goeun lami hina all left sm 🥲

@annanowak9620

Ай бұрын

I was rooting for Lami

12 member... if you got talents and need to shared it with 12 ppl. It might be better choice to look for other opportunities especially with her high profile. She could even go solo and started from bottom like iu. But it would be a great lift if debut with a group and built a fb for solo later just like yedam trsr. But sm wouldnt give her leave only after 2 years without drama unless its a scandal.

@bunnihanni

Ай бұрын

I agree she will barely get any lines in such a huge group. Better to go to a smaller group or solo

@eluneee00

Ай бұрын

SM should really reconsider debuting 12 like it’s too many.

@cherrybear8288

Ай бұрын

@@eluneee00 true but it’s sort of SM’s thing, they love debuting large groups.

@marklawrenceanzale1110

Ай бұрын

​@@eluneee00 imagine the line distribution if the song is only 2 mins long

@blkpopnovellover

Ай бұрын

Right, there are also groups that have many members barely managing to pull off a group consisting 11 or above. So I guess it's better for her to be solo or have a small quality of members

This could be the SM’s way of creating news and gaining attention.. I fee sorry that these trainees devoting their entire lives just to be played by the companies..

@user-je3fn5eo1d

Ай бұрын

I feel like it’s rather from minor changes to the concept over the years as well as what’s considered “trendy” in beauty standards around the time of debut. It’s really unfortunate but you can def see the changes between each generation

@habeebahshittu4753

Ай бұрын

Isn't she the one who unfollowed SM?

omg i was just thinking about her the other day. i hope she debuts😮

@hipeople9018

23 күн бұрын

Same!!

@Levi__Ackermann

19 күн бұрын

How old is she gonna be this year?

hopefully she will debut

Oh my god i completely forgot how she use to be at the peak. Hope she'll get her dream soon❤

JYPE focuses on dance hopefully she joins them probably not but I still hope she gets what she wants in the end🤍

@Mochie00

Ай бұрын

I think she doesn't fit for sm she gives me vibes of hybe

@ferdinando723

Ай бұрын

​@@Mochie00 agree! She already got SM vocals 😂 and she's an amazing dancer!

@Levi__Ackermann

19 күн бұрын

​@@Mochie00 Better not associate with Hybe at the moment, it's a bit of a mess there. People throw around lawsuits, sudden resignations like it's minor things to do monthly

@Mochie00

19 күн бұрын

@@Levi__Ackermann yeah but I m worried for her when she will debut she also removed sm from her bio and her dance line nd give cool vibe that's why I said that I m new in kpop I don't know much ...

@Levi__Ackermann

19 күн бұрын

@@Mochie00 Na Haeun was born in 2009, she's only 15 this year. You gotta chill, she still has around 3-4 years to spare as a trainee. If SM doesn't want her, she got time to look for better agency that suits her style. She totally can debut as self-choreograph soloist coz I know she's an excellent dancer, some examples; Chungha(former I.O.I) and Chaeyeon(former Iz*One)👈🏻These two are among the best female dancers in nowadays kpop era for me and they're soloists who choreographed their own songs.

I just want the best for my girl and she already has made a name for herself since she was a kid

Omg? I’ve been watching her for a very long time I hope her talent doesn’t get lost

I think 12 people is too much.. Wonyoung is popular even if she's not in the Big4.

@dvm007

Ай бұрын

Wongyoung who ? The girl who changed her whole face , acts like she is the leader of the group and wants to be centre of attention everytime ?

@NigerianSimsStudio

Ай бұрын

@@dvm007 have you realised that most leaders in kpop groups are not even that popular? i am not even a IVE fan but I find your comment very stupid and hateful. Like, what else do you expect from the group visual? at least, she has the skills to be an idol and keeps working on improving herself. you might argue that she gets better treatments than other members, but if you think it, she kinds deserves that, because although she and Yujin came from IZONE, Wonyoung was the one who boosted IVE's status. So, take it easy when criticising the group. it's not her fault. before groups appear in public, they always have outfit check. so, if noone found it an issue before they all came to the public, then the public should just mind their business. besides, Wonyoung is doing a good job as the face of the group, and I don't know if she's done plastic surgery, but even if she has, she is one of the very few idols who look almost same as their predebut selves. SO, TAKE A CHILL PILL. you need it ^_^

@wony_stvr

Ай бұрын

⁠@@dvm007 her role is the CENTER she’s supposed to be in the CENTER! Second wonyoung is very kind and talented. Stop making it seem like all she has to show of is plastic surgery.

@dvm007

Ай бұрын

@@wony_stvr her comes a mega simp trying to explain her role 🤡🤡

@skittychuu

Ай бұрын

@@dvm007wonyoung hater trying to throw 💩 on her whenever she’s mentioned.

Sm is very selective with who they want to be in their company so even if they are high profile they gotta have the talent. That’s the one good thing about them as a company even if I hate their guts.

I mean why would she wont to be in a 12 person girl group

@fierriefiles

2 ай бұрын

I wouldn't. I'd rather be in 4 members like Aespa. Or atleast 7 members.

@bye1546

2 ай бұрын

I always wondered why companies have to make groups that big it’s so unnecessary but then again these are trainees who sacrificed years for this opportunity.

@deltaboy2011

2 ай бұрын

@@bye1546yeah doesn’t really make sense like TripleS with 24 members. Too many.

@하나-리아

Ай бұрын

​​@@SeventeenIsMyFavoriteNumberWith only few lines? frustrating especially when you are a good singer since you really can't show your talents

@dvm007

Ай бұрын

Well it depends person to person and how confident they are about themselves and their talent . Many girls/boys who join or debut in a big group (above 9) aren’t sure of their abilities to do well in small groups . If she is confident that she can do well in small group then she should definitely go for it. For eg I would have preferred garam over sakura in lesserafim.

she doesnt need to be kpop group when she has 5mil subscribers. Mostly kpop group cant use their personal channel unless their going solo when debut its such a waste when you already earn lots from it

@Levi__Ackermann

19 күн бұрын

Yup, she can go IU route honestly. Her name is already reputable enough i think

Isn't the kid who used to dance in mma awards now i couldn't recognize her how time flew it's seem just yesterday i saw her performance in mma award on twice what is love 😅

Hear me out…I think SM is doing a survival show. 12 girls is a lot and they are also holding global auditions (probably for extra girls to add in to the show)

@j-ghostie

Ай бұрын

It’d make sense considering the fact that Jyp had a2k, hybe had dream academy and r u next, and the black label / mnet has iland 2 rn

Holycow she's grown, omg I've been watching her since she was so small doing dance intervals with the idols in the background cheering for her in shows lol

Idols don’t really have the name of their company on their personal account. Maybe their group but not the company. Idk this doesn’t scare me yet

I just hope Haeun can debut by herself without any the rest of company involved (which is hard). Im glad if she's real leaving the SM.

Omg she grew up so much I still remember her dance cover of all those groups at that award show! When Kai told her to join SM I was like NOOOOOOO DONT internally… I wish her luck elsewhere cause SM isn’t it

Stay away from SM. Heck from most entertainment companies, at least until she's older.

5 million subscribers? they need her more than she needs them

NO WAY

I forgot about her she used to be everywhere dancing with idols

@loveyloveydobby

25 күн бұрын

that's because her yt channel became inactive after signing up as a trainee in SM

@luu-ev3zc

24 күн бұрын

@@loveyloveydobby ik i just forgot about her

But why?

I waited 2 years!…. And we get the news that she left , this was low key a waste of time , they should just debut the gg last year

What if she just doesn't want to debut? I feel like fans should respect the possibility that she won't.

They can't have high-profile idols in their new group cause it would be hard to control that idol. SM the control freak

SM fucked up for real…(sorry for the rude language). Haeun is such a star and she is probably the best dancer I’ve ever seen. I don’t understand why SM keep cancelling their contracts with these amazing people like haeun.😢

SM out here playing with the lives and futures of little kids from a young age Imagine going to school and reaching the final year and then cannot take the exam Future is gone man

I don’t know if It’s on purpose or not but yes the jbj on the thumbnail summon me here lol.

She signed an exclusive contract which basically guarantees debut. I don’t think she’s left

Oh I thought she had already debuted. Since she have solo mvs

Sm bad reputation for protecting their artists and still the label with the highest deathsuiciderates

What if her past isn't suitable for an idol and SM don't want to receive hate for debuting her? Maybe they don't want another Seunghan or Garam situation.

@blueshoes5145

Ай бұрын

But the girl has been with them since she was 4 and now they are looking into it ? And also, the girl was propably not going to school all that much if she was training back then. Neither would she have the time to bully people.

Honestly tho look at sm rn… it’s completely falling apart. Look at how many sm artist are leaving and trying to get out of their contracts. Who knows maybe haeun and her mom saw that contract and were like hell nah and left 😂 but I hope her success in whatever she does

NOOOOO

Maybe she doesn't want SM plastic surgery, it's possible since they do that when young there or maybe she wants a smaller group or a group focus on dance So much possibilities

She's still a kid, I hope she doesn't debut until she's an adult and even then only if she wants to. She dances as her passion, sometimes you lose your passion when it becomes your job.

is she haeun from laipillus?

@loveyloveydobby

25 күн бұрын

no, she is Na Haeun. she's a dance prodigy who first appeared on star king when she was only 3 years old and also the youngest contestant in kpop star 4

12 is a lot of members

Maybe she cant sing lol. Sm artists need to be able to sing

@stan_babymonster_and_bonedo

2 ай бұрын

who tell you she can't sing ? sm ? no then you should shut up and mind you're own business and stop being rude

@stan_babymonster_and_bonedo

2 ай бұрын

don't forget that Belle herself leave sm and debut on another company and she is still have golden voice so leaving company doesn't mean trainees are talentless bruh stop being stupid and mindset🤦🏻‍♀️

@me9981

2 ай бұрын

​@@stan_babymonster_and_bonedo why are you so offended and rude lmao. they were not rude at all...they were just saying that maybe she can't sing, that's it...

@stan_babymonster_and_bonedo

2 ай бұрын

@_aerina yes that what I'm saying if any trainee leave sm doesn't mean he or she talentless maybe they can't fit the concept that sm plans but his was disrespecting her that's why I was defend her 🤝

@stan_babymonster_and_bonedo

2 ай бұрын

@@me9981 lol me offended and rude ?!😂 wow you are blind enough to ignore his/her comment I was telling truth , so hating on just little girl who want to full fill her dreams and say that they can't accept her maybe because she can't sing is such stupid thing , cuz there is some trainees I know they traineed in sm and now they become best vocalists in thier groups so leaving sm doesn't mean they are talentless and can't sing they leave cuz maybe they can't fit sm concept

Nothing new..high profile trainee..who cares if u have more talented trainee😂😂

Hope she joins HYBE new girl group

@ilikealotofthings731

2 ай бұрын

Nah. HYBE is cursed for girl groups.

@Usery5439

2 ай бұрын

@@ilikealotofthings731 yeah but i hope she will. i don't stan HYBE but i like ggs in HYBE as well.

@wondeukiforwonderfullifeu_8137

2 ай бұрын

No,she will destroy herself if she join hybe

@aerabyeol

2 ай бұрын

@@Usery5439as a former trainee there that’s the worst decision she can make

@Usery5439

2 ай бұрын

@@aerabyeol Well we don't even know if she left or not actually. i just like the streamable music HYBE gg makes. Don't like the company but their music is really calm and easy to listen. it's just my preference. she will do whatever she likes. It's her decision. But every gg that debuts under HYBE after 2021 has been doing great and successful. There are controversies, yes but every hybe gg is so popular, has a huge fanbase, music is so good and all hitting billboard charts too. so future groups will too. So it's a great advantage as well. Now Katseye is debuting. So It will boost HYBE so much internationally. We'll just have to wait and see what happens.

i hope she debuts but only if she wants to ofc🩷

I used to watch her 🥹🥹