Hidden Symbolism in Shadow of the Colossus

Ойындар

14 years later... there are still secrets being uncovered from this game. I think I might have discovered something that nobody else has ever noticed, and it was staring us in the face all this time. Special thanks to Nomad Colossus and Wisi for making this video possible.
Patreon: / maxderrat
SubscribeStar: www.subscribestar.com/max-derrat
PayPal: paypal.me/maxderrat
Twitter: maxderrat
Discord Link: / discord
Twitch: twitch.tv/maxderrat
Max's Videos on SOTC:
Shadow of the Colossus - Story Explanation and Analysis: • Shadow of the Colossus...
Team Ico - Shared Universe Theory: • Team Ico - Shared Univ...
-----------
Sources:
Nomad Colossus: / nomad0168
PSU Preview New Cut Scene: • Shadow of the Colossus...
Dante Diotallevi's Graduate Thesis: qspace.library.queensu.ca/han...

Пікірлер: 308

  • @DynoSkrimisher
    @DynoSkrimisher4 жыл бұрын

    Nomad: *Scans the data and keeps on finding stuff* Emon: STOP. Dormin: DON'T STOP.

  • @tomatogenesis

    @tomatogenesis

    9 ай бұрын

    I'm with Dormin on this one

  • @pedronied
    @pedronied5 жыл бұрын

    Just when you think there's nothing else to know about Shadow of the Colossus...

  • @hericbss

    @hericbss

    5 жыл бұрын

    Nied7 Indeed

  • @afellowhuman8944

    @afellowhuman8944

    4 жыл бұрын

    That's one of the reasons that make this game mysterious and amazing

  • @sanduba57

    @sanduba57

    4 жыл бұрын

    But actually there's nothing else to know about the game.

  • @greenvelvet
    @greenvelvet5 жыл бұрын

    It's amazing Shadow of the Colossus has these wide-open landscapes that you can transverse and explore. And there's no random encounters no busy grind quests...and IT WORKS. It completely immerses you in this mysterious land and you're just in this state of wonder.

  • @xfirexrainx6668

    @xfirexrainx6668

    Жыл бұрын

    State of wander even.

  • @brunofranco4416
    @brunofranco44165 жыл бұрын

    Horns are symbols of both wisdom and strength in various cultures around the world. They have also been linked to virility and masculine reproductive power thanks to males of various species having larger horns than females, like the bull, wich was worshipped by all indo-european peoples due to beign an essential part of their diet, it's strength wich allowed it to pull plows through the fields and it's reproductive potency.

  • @blipboigilgamesh7865

    @blipboigilgamesh7865

    5 жыл бұрын

    Ironically enough, were I live, horns are a common symbol of betrayal and masculine unpromiscuity. It comes from the fact that when some animals lose their horns, they don't grow back and how that relates to how people don't tend to get over being cheated on a relationship, but the analogy got lost in translation.

  • @MagicDragonesk

    @MagicDragonesk

    5 жыл бұрын

    Horns are of the devil 😈

  • @TexasHollowEarth

    @TexasHollowEarth

    5 жыл бұрын

    @@MagicDragonesk - Evidence of animal genetics in human dna.

  • @pracitus

    @pracitus

    4 жыл бұрын

    Dormin was probably a peaceful god but the new religion hated horns and his power, truly a tragic ending for his culture and land...

  • @juanausensi499

    @juanausensi499

    3 жыл бұрын

    @@MagicDragonesk Michelangelo sculpted his Moses with horns

  • @argonbolt
    @argonbolt5 жыл бұрын

    This is why i love SOTC, its a game that leaves so much to interpretation. When i made my video on this i read a metaphorical reading about technology and human kind grappling with balance. While i never saw your videos when i made it, i think it shows how strong the themes of this game are(even if the specific story told to us is quite simple) that you can inevitably see similar ideas even if the specific interpretations are very different.

  • @alextheconfuddled8983

    @alextheconfuddled8983

    4 жыл бұрын

    Undertale: *Hold my beer*

  • @outrospector
    @outrospector5 жыл бұрын

    I am a Tibetan Lama monk, and I grew up sorrounded by mandalas, there is a tradition regarding them as ephemeral in which we (Lama monks) draw mandalas with dyed sands of different colors, we take hours, even days drawing them, so they look percfectly balanced, and after we finished drawing them we just clean all the sands and begin again, this tradition shows how ephemeral is everything in life, even cycles, the point of putting all our effort from hours and loosing it in minutes is to be concious of the way life works, and how nothing is eternal, even the things which took more effort to build eventually decay over time, is a lesson, to live with no fear of losing everything, since nothing belongs to anyone, and a proof that time can erase everthing, just to be deattached from matterial stuff and even from life, not in a apathetic way, but in a way in which we live, and love and do our best everyday in our lives, being mindful that they could end anyday I drew mandalas since a kid with my father, he makes Yantras, which are simbols engraved on leather representing wiches and fears, it's believed that we have better control over things when we give them a body, since we sometimes are more conected to our bodies than to our souls, Yantras are also a representation of how a though, something ethereal, fits a body and gives meaning to that body, just a piece of paper is what it is, paper, but every book composed of the same paper is unique, because of it's content, that's how we are, all living beings have bodies, but the content is what matters the most, and by giving the soul a material container, you can give it the will to act,musicians for example use their will on their bodies to make music, music has no body, any casette or cd or bit means nothing, but what matters is the content it has, but that content can't exit in a material plane without a body. in conclusion, what this means is that we need either body and soul to exist and to understand ourselves better we need to pay attention to both and nurture them, I'm curently studying medicine and a common thought in my workplace is that, souls are not real, well there are many arguments related to this topic, I disagree with science denying souls and also I am not a religious person at all, but maybe if humanity stopped being separated either by science or religion, humanity will become more balanced, them who deny they have a soul are as wrong as them who deny molecules make their bodies, as I said before we are both material and ethereal, we are all dyed sand mandalas being slowly removed by time and wind.

  • @rhandyrhoads12

    @rhandyrhoads12

    5 жыл бұрын

    Wow. I thank the Internet for allowing each of us to communicate with (relative) freedom

  • @Heidealtere

    @Heidealtere

    5 жыл бұрын

    Wonderful insight, sir. Your thoughts and reflections about such a peculiar subject as the soul and body ambiguous yet connected nature, is imbued of significant meaning through your comment presented here.

  • @GemGames3

    @GemGames3

    4 жыл бұрын

    Thank you for sharing this, very fascinating and thoughtful.

  • @sleepycowboy18

    @sleepycowboy18

    4 жыл бұрын

    ooohh somehow I feel cleansed just by reading this, thank you this is very insightful and beautiful

  • @thomasbouche8004

    @thomasbouche8004

    4 жыл бұрын

    Thank you for your comment

  • @imperiallray7933
    @imperiallray79335 жыл бұрын

    you are the best incarnation of game theory we ever could have dreamed of

  • @lostpockets2227

    @lostpockets2227

    3 жыл бұрын

    i hate game theory because "HI AND WELCOME, THIS IS GAME THEORY! DONT FORGET TO SUBSCRIBE, WE ARE GAMETHEORY! WANNA BUY MERCH!? USE CODE GAMETHEORY!

  • @sporeham1674

    @sporeham1674

    2 жыл бұрын

    @@lostpockets2227 First time I've seen a valid complaint about GameTheory honestly.

  • @furyberserk

    @furyberserk

    2 жыл бұрын

    @@lostpockets2227 When you grow up, you tend to hate how stupid adults assume you were. Gt has that children appeal everyone hates, but I respect his grind.

  • @hollywoodwillburn
    @hollywoodwillburn5 жыл бұрын

    Nimrod is also connected to human sacrifices in the occult and just like the story of jesus and nimrod it seems like dormin required sacrifice of the flesh to bring about the rebirth of a God or Demon depending on which theology we look at great work love these break downs

  • @codymavick9068
    @codymavick90685 жыл бұрын

    To add to Wanders sacrifice. He didn't even do it in the intentions of becoming divine or pure he just did it because he wanted to bring his girl back to life. Even as Dormin warned him he could have unforeseen consequences, he didn't care. He did it for completely selfless and pure intentions which could potentially be why he succeeded in becoming reborn or divine. (I'd imagine if someone slayed all the colossi seeking immortality or divinity for pure selfish reasons would probably be turned into a shadow demon instead of being reborn into a pure innocent horned baby.) Maybe that's why Emon followed him to the forbidden lands and stayed at the end "if your alive your cursed". He thought wander wouldn't succeed in becoming divine or if it was even possible to become divine. He thought Wander was a shadow demon and that Mono was dead.

  • @frostycane5134

    @frostycane5134

    3 жыл бұрын

    Interesting

  • @CodeeXD

    @CodeeXD

    2 жыл бұрын

    One could argue wanders sacrifice was selfish. Not caring for the consequences of his actions he potentially risked the world for his love

  • @williampan29

    @williampan29

    5 ай бұрын

    ​@CodeeXD who cares what the world thinks. We don't own the world anything.

  • @itswonkavision9946
    @itswonkavision99465 жыл бұрын

    Video begins: My brain: You're finally awake

  • @lilvampire7439
    @lilvampire74395 жыл бұрын

    Hey look at this circle SotC theorizers: *M A N D A L A*

  • @khakisohn9710
    @khakisohn97103 жыл бұрын

    "Power corrupts, and absolute power corrupts, absolutely," for some reason that last line gave me chills god damn I'm too pea brained for this

  • @JudgeMagistR
    @JudgeMagistR5 жыл бұрын

    That really brings me back to the old times where SotC and religion theories were Always a thing, Me personally never really saw it that way. But when it comes to elements such as balance, light and dark always seemed to me to be the main theme of Shadow of the colossus, Or even the whole Fumito Ueda universe really. I always wanted those mandalas to be analysed so much. So I really appreciate thIs vídeo and it's amazing work. It all began with Dormin sword having half the mandala design of #6 and 13# on the dormin sword hilt. Also the mandala at #13 arena was a new addition to the remake version of the game, it wasn't really there in the OG, Unless it was fully covered in sand. I haven't really met your channel before and i'll definitely check it out your other SotC Related vídeos!

  • @sebastianbancroft7184

    @sebastianbancroft7184

    4 жыл бұрын

    Darkness is the absence of light. In reality you can’t have a mix of the two as the game suggests. It’s just teaching dualism.

  • @TENRAN432
    @TENRAN4325 жыл бұрын

    I'm glad that people are still making Shadow videos. Continue to make great content man! One question: Do you think that Dormin (or the collosus) are perfect beings in that universe? What about baby Wander?

  • @maxderrat

    @maxderrat

    5 жыл бұрын

    In regards to Baby Wander, I don't think he's a perfect being... I just think he's a little higher on the scale towards divinity for his efforts as an adult. As for Dormin… I think he's the perfect representation of darkness and all that darkness implies (evil, misery, loss of self, etc. ). The colossi are neither perfect or imperfect in my estimation. They just ARE... kind of like animals.

  • @ShintogaDeathAngel

    @ShintogaDeathAngel

    4 жыл бұрын

    In some (mostly pagan) religions and cultures, darkness and the underworld are more places and times for contemplation rather than representing evil and punishment. The way I see Dormin is as a literal deity (they perform literal miracles, most notably resurrecting Wander, Mono and possibly Agro. I’m pretty sure Agro would not have survived that fall, but that’s just another thing the game deliberately leaves vague) and their god status directly threatens Emon’s “new” religion. In sealing Dormin away and Emon casting them as evil, the story also provides an analogy for Christianity trying to bury/discredit paganism, which is Christianity’s own roots. Dormin is neutral, not evil - while they did use him, they give Wander the chance to turn back, when he is the first human they’ve seen in who knows how long. If he had left, would anyone else ever set foot in the forbidden lands and free them?

  • @codemancz798

    @codemancz798

    3 жыл бұрын

    Dormin is probably death.

  • @greenvelvet
    @greenvelvet5 жыл бұрын

    Those illustrations look closer to the illustrations you would find in books, regarding alchemy and mysticism

  • @passerByL
    @passerByL5 жыл бұрын

    "power corrupts, and absolute power corrupts absolutely" i like this, i like this very much

  • @aceragnarok9451
    @aceragnarok94515 жыл бұрын

    Absoloutley fantastic. Loved every moment and you better keep making these high quality videos

  • @FarronMoon
    @FarronMoon4 жыл бұрын

    These concepts sound a lot like Kingdom Hearts. Hermeticism may very well sit comfortably with Namuras love of Numerology and Daoist symbolism. The realms of Light & Darkness, the Sleeping realm, data worlds, the enevor of Xehanort to study the balance between these forces, remaking a great war for his cause. This video feels perfectly suited to this topic as well.

  • @blumiu2426

    @blumiu2426

    3 жыл бұрын

    Asian culture is based around those esoteric concepts, and part of their culture. You will always see it and why many of their stories are always based on balancing good and evil, not one overcoming the other. If you did deep into the occult, dualism is far more insidious, as it's believed one should embody both (yet in reality we know human nature tends to go one way over the other).

  • @starofwonder1810
    @starofwonder18105 жыл бұрын

    This was extremely interesting. This was a childhood game of mine... It meant so much to me back then.... Thank you for posting this.

  • @pineoandloeb
    @pineoandloeb5 жыл бұрын

    This is brilliant. My love of Shadow Of The Colossus meeting my love of the occult. I always felt the game had some deeper esoteric element to it and this illustrates it well. Nice work!

  • @chugg159
    @chugg1594 жыл бұрын

    Wherever there is a shadow of the colossus video, there is always a special thanks to Nomad. Absolute legend.

  • @Trickle_Official
    @Trickle_Official5 жыл бұрын

    Okay, so I am new to this community and HO LY COW these are impeccable!!! I wonder if that light harnessed, presumably, from people is also what is found in the blue tailed lizard and the blue butterfly, as well as the fire Dormir breathes! I was planning on playing Ico this week but I keep discovering that I've SO MUCH MORE to discover in the world of the Colossi! Thank you SO much for these heaftfelt videos, I can't wait to play Ico so that I may watch the rest of your content!!!

  • @Zelchacha
    @Zelchacha5 жыл бұрын

    Awesome insights man, I love your content, your Asperger’s syndrome gives you such detail and you dive deeper than most. It’s a gift and a curse so it seems.

  • @timmadone8930
    @timmadone89302 жыл бұрын

    There is a Mandala on the floor where colossus 6 comes out from but getting to it is not easy. You basically have to get on the arm of the colossus & let go just as he try's to throw you off & with a little luck you'll be tossed up onto the platform. There is also a Mandala high up in a dark area on a wall just before the cut scene starts for colossus 8. There is also a Mandala on top of each castle tower near colossus 15. You need to use photo mode to see them.

  • @bennyindawall
    @bennyindawall2 жыл бұрын

    This is why I fell in love with this game, not only is it amazing gameplay and an absolutely beautiful world and story but just there was a certain mystery to it, and it’s just amazing when people like you and nomad spend so much time deciphering it, truly amazing work you guys have done🙏

  • @dgodiex
    @dgodiex2 жыл бұрын

    What a great video, it's not easy to articulate these ideas, specially for the non iniciated, but you did a perfect job. It's absoluteley wonderful that this engraves are occult inside the game's code, and it says a lot about the author's esoteric influences and the spirit of the game at large.

  • @killroy4653
    @killroy46534 жыл бұрын

    Some of the death screens are legit scary

  • @Kortlandt
    @Kortlandt2 ай бұрын

    I do like how that there's more to this game. I really do love it and its predecessors.

  • @annedidiet5416
    @annedidiet54165 жыл бұрын

    Very interesting vidéo. Really love Fumito Ueda and Silent hill. Thanks.

  • @kevinaudrey4731
    @kevinaudrey47314 жыл бұрын

    i thought he's called Dormin because he lays DORMANt in there for years

  • @Storm1Trooper5

    @Storm1Trooper5

    3 жыл бұрын

    Yeah me too 😅

  • @czinsation
    @czinsation4 жыл бұрын

    Following that idea of ascension, is it possible Dormin is a king or lord of the forbidden land who used that power to ascend but became too powerful.

  • @venomsnakessidepiece
    @venomsnakessidepiece6 ай бұрын

    What’s interesting is that the sword wayfinding mimics the mandala visual of the “let there be light” illustration. The light even unifies into a singular beam when pointed towards a single being, but points everywhere else when not focused on anything.

  • @dianamations9371
    @dianamations93715 жыл бұрын

    This is an excellent analysis! thank you!

  • @nalbarracin
    @nalbarracin8 ай бұрын

    I just want to add some reference: The phrase "power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely" is usually attributed to Lord Acton (See Hist. Essays, page 504)

  • @jerm5466
    @jerm5466 Жыл бұрын

    This is one of the best videos on this game there is. I’ve watched it many times, just felt like letting you know.

  • @clinto32
    @clinto324 жыл бұрын

    Brilliant work! Great eye opening vid

  • @kronometron1034
    @kronometron10344 жыл бұрын

    Fun fact: Nimrod built the Babel Tower trying to reach God.

  • @sinisterbotanist
    @sinisterbotanist5 жыл бұрын

    One thing Ueda does extremely well (and is a sort of staple of his aesthetic style) is generating an aura of significance. You're placed in some majorly empty, ancient world that seems to harbor the meanings of a long-lost form of life. E.g., symbols in stone, mysterious markings, shrines, etc. I doubt Ueda or anyone "assigned" these symbols discrete meanings; all that matters is that they are suggestive of meaning (suggestiveness, rather than full-blown illumination is one of the essentials of Japanese aesthetics). It generates that "mythic" character. Like the "tomb" where you get the shield in The Last Guardian: I sort of don't want to know anything about whose grave it is! Just knowing it's obviously a grave (and all the associations that entails) is enough to generate an atmosphere of significance or depth that's way more interesting than if I had all the "facts" about the matter. It leaves speculations way open, but open enough to where I don't find it too exciting to imagine we're ever going to piece together a "right" interpretation or theory. I sorta want to bask in the indeterminacy of it all. also, I used to be way into Jung but I found his ideas tend to occlude genuine social/historical/cultural differences. If we think each and every circle denotes a "mandala" as Jung conceives them, we're going to be ignoring genuine differences in how those symbols are conceived by different traditions (and this is a fictional tradition so it doesn't really apply). But depth psychological interpretation can still yield some interesting views! Maybe Wander's journey is really all about seeking a return to the oceanic oneness of the primordial womb or whatnot. That's not my gig anymore.

  • @Rktkid18
    @Rktkid185 жыл бұрын

    Certain things things about this game upon initial playing felt like this game owed us more

  • @JenXBeauty
    @JenXBeauty3 жыл бұрын

    Fantastic video. 🙌🏼 love this game

  • @aidenmorreyvoiceactor
    @aidenmorreyvoiceactor4 жыл бұрын

    11:22 "Have ya heard of JESUS?!!" -Jontron

  • @IsolatedFreedom_
    @IsolatedFreedom_5 ай бұрын

    Here's symbolism no one I've seen has talked about I realized when the sprits of the Colossi attack Wander, he dies. He is then reborn again by going through the white light ( Search Soul Trap Theory)

  • @BynumOfficial
    @BynumOfficial5 жыл бұрын

    There is always new symbols being discovered in Shadow or the Colossus. Such a legendary game.

  • @MrDumdumkilla
    @MrDumdumkilla4 жыл бұрын

    You and Nomad and of course everyone else made me enjoy this game as if its a new game lol. Replaying this since its free on ps plus and seeing all these mantras in the world is like wow

  • @ZeldaMasterJohn
    @ZeldaMasterJohn4 жыл бұрын

    Nice video friend 🔥

  • @TU-mf2ut
    @TU-mf2ut4 жыл бұрын

    I hope someone brings this up to Fumita Ueda in an interview. There's so much he could tell us about what Nomad and the secret searcher community has found.

  • @ShintogaDeathAngel

    @ShintogaDeathAngel

    4 жыл бұрын

    I think they paid tribute to Nomad and the searcher community in the remake, at least I saw something about it in another video. I’d love to know exactly what Ueda was thinking when building the storyline, but I know just enough was left vague and open to interpretation that he would never confirm any interpretation as canon. I love and hate that at the same time!

  • @alisweatshirt7405
    @alisweatshirt74055 жыл бұрын

    Saw the title and subbed. I love you

  • @HumanPudding
    @HumanPudding5 жыл бұрын

    Amazing video!

  • @emmanuelgonzalezcaseira9141
    @emmanuelgonzalezcaseira91415 жыл бұрын

    Amazing insights right here :) If we look at this from the narrative perspective, taking out all the fantasy stuff, the moment wanderer "turns" into Dormin might very well mean that moment in a narrative were the main character exhibits the worst part of himself as a person, and when he enters into the pool of light, he is cleansed from, you could call "Pride" and "Wrath" (In the sense that Dormin can be seen and I think if I remember well he considers himself a God) and what is left is a pure being, a baby, with the horns as a reminder of the "Sins" of Pride and Wrath that he committed before, in the same fashion a scar would be left after having been dealt a serious huge injury. Still, without the fantasy elements taking into account, you can say that this is a story of a man that deals with Pride and Wrath (mostly) and by the end he becomes a new person, maybe not willingly, but a new person in the end once he enters the light... which you could see as the inherent truth of life that not even he could escape, the truth of moving on, of acceptance and peace with himself, and no matter how much he fights back, he ends up entering the pool of light, letting go of his pain, and the reason of his Pride and Wrath. He may have scars, but he is once again a pure person. You could even say that Mono coddling baby Wanderer is, taking out the fantasy aspect of the story, Wanderer being able to, as a person, feel love again, letting himself be loved and love again. Now I can see why this game has touched so many people over the years :) Once again, thank you for your insights.

  • @KenShinta174
    @KenShinta1744 жыл бұрын

    Great video, I like the depth of the game

  • @bearbonezmusic
    @bearbonezmusic6 ай бұрын

    This is an amazing video essay. Thank you

  • @dvd11811
    @dvd118115 жыл бұрын

    I have and have read the exact copy of the ACU book you are using ... good stuff ... I am a fan of Jung!!!

  • @alextheconfuddled8983
    @alextheconfuddled89834 жыл бұрын

    12:18 this reminds me of when I walked across the giant bridge just to get an achievement and another coin, I regret it.

  • @igorcruzs
    @igorcruzs5 жыл бұрын

    Great video!

  • @RevSoma
    @RevSoma3 жыл бұрын

    That hermetic philosophy on becoming one with the universe is a pretty interesting way of putting integrity or Te. I'll have to remember that.

  • @MrGrimlocksmash
    @MrGrimlocksmash5 жыл бұрын

    So glad I picked this up around launch day (ps2). Best gift ever

  • @lotobia9482
    @lotobia94822 жыл бұрын

    Funny how Diotallevi is a phrase squeezed up into one word which is used as a family name, that in italian language means "God raise you" ("raise" meaning educating and helping in physical and mental growth). Dio= God , T' (short form for "Ti")= To You, Allevi= Raise. (Not that this is relevant at all)

  • @technologic21
    @technologic215 жыл бұрын

    The Fiat Lux brings forth (at least in my mind) the idea of Illuvatar and the genesis of Tolkien's legendarium. SOTC is also fantasy and a really deep one at that. It definitely borrows from the genre, from Tolkien to Neverending Story. Great video.

  • @raycorrea5147
    @raycorrea51475 жыл бұрын

    Just one observation on 6:39 why a circle besides the perfection if you think about it there is the number Pi, an infinite number that contains everything, all the information of this world is contained at some point in Pi, so it makes sense that the circle represents our reality. There are additional observations about what's next maybe you can find it in books like "the flower of life"

  • @SianaGearz

    @SianaGearz

    5 жыл бұрын

    Pi's property of containing all possible information if you look far enough into it comes from its property of being an irrational number. It's not unique, there's a large number of known families of such numbers, most of them not at all related to pi.

  • @zenitpro
    @zenitpro2 жыл бұрын

    Wow, wow wow... just WOW! I've always loved the game since day one, because of the sense of vastness of the Forbidden Land, the atmosphere of sheer mystery and the feeling of loneliness. And clearly having all these theories attached to the mythos of the game gives it an even greater sense of grandeur - if that's even possible. Thanks for sharing your studies. I can NEVER get enough of SOTC.

  • @queazy03
    @queazy034 жыл бұрын

    Yeah, horns were divine in some cultures that were at odds with early Hebrew/Christianity (perfect example is the old biblical story of fights with the priests of Baal Haddad) Back in Sumeria & Egypt, they viewed cattle as fertility so their gods would have horns. One of these biggest ones was essentially Baal Haddad, who superceded his father El as chief diety. Baal Haddad was a rainy storm god that would give rain to the desert regions, but would also fight evil serpents. How mighty was Baal Haddad? Zeus uses lightning and fought snake-like Typhon Perun uses lightning and fought snake-like Veles Indra uses lightning and fought the snake-like Vritra Thor uses lightning and fought the snake-like Jormungandr ...I think they were all chief deities of their pantheons (Thor was originally chief deity before Snorri Sturluson rewrote Odin as chief deity). They were all based on Baal Haddad (btw, the word "baal" just means "lord", but he was so famous people just called him baal; at some points even Yahweh was referred to as Baal Yahweh). The ancient Hebrews had falling out with the mighty Baal Haddad priests, villified them and said they won against them in some religious battle, cast them out and essentially made their own religion where Baal Haddad was a bad guy, but some combination of Yahweh/El was the good guy. Hence why "Thou shalt not have any other gods" is the first Commandment of the Ten Commandments. The ancient Hebrews were originally polytheistic, but were trying to become monotheistic. You can see fingerprints of Baal Haddad, Asherah (consort to Yahweh), and El in the old Hebrew texts, they were originally very polytheistic. Heck just check out the name, it's IsraEL not IsraYAHWEH. Hence, in western cultures that are based on Christianity/Hebrew, they paint demons with animal horns. But one of the most interesting things was this comment from KZread user "tppuao Weldezion" from 3 years ago. Nimrod was a character known for wearing bulls horns on his crown. Building a great tower in a forbidden land abhorred for polytheism (Nimrod did claim his ziggurats could reach the heavens) Most importantly, he was split into several pieces when he died! After he died, his wife allegedly had a virgin birth and claimed the child was Nimrod reborn. An obvious parallel to SotC having a baby born at the end with Dormin's appearance without any apparent mother.

  • @clubbasher32
    @clubbasher325 жыл бұрын

    You might want to research/read Jung’s Alchemy and Psychology. It explains all this stuff in greater detail. Alchemy is an allegory for the transmutation of the human soul through experiences. Such as transforming lead into gold through perfect mathematical magic. The photos of the layers of elements within the rings are references to leviathan, the earth and labyrinths. The squaring of the circle, and the serpent that eats itself. Silent hill 2 uses all of these concepts as well.

  • @onlyonewhyphy
    @onlyonewhyphy5 жыл бұрын

    Excellent video

  • @williamheinbuch
    @williamheinbuch3 жыл бұрын

    This game prophesied the chosen before we even knew he was a thing.

  • @codemancz798
    @codemancz7983 жыл бұрын

    There is likely double symbolism to the horns. On one hand, they are associated with grace and divinity, and likened to crowns (to the point some statues include horns instead of crowns). On the other hand, they also represent a return to animalistic behavior and darkness. This is likely the cause Ico was ostracized. Also, there's definitely some sort of connection between the Forbidden Lands and Babylon. The idea with Babylon is that they tried to build a tower to avoid the next flood, but God didn't like that and prompty put a stop to it, leading to fragmentation. Given the fact all the Colossi have idols in the shrine of worship, it's possible that they were the figurative towers. The pyramid design of the Tower of Babylon is quite bluntly reflected in the design of Malus, who seems to be a hybrid of the Tower and Buddha. Such an origin even goes back to the theological ideas of giants: They are improper unions of heaven and earth, are commonly hybrids, and guard places (particularly the margins of the world.) Lastly, there is a connection with the south, symbolizing death. You approach the lands from the north and must cross south, and Malus is located at the southern most point of the Forbidden Lands.

  • @zezuntxiduntxi
    @zezuntxiduntxi5 жыл бұрын

    amazing video. thank you.

  • @stanleyurivosich7007
    @stanleyurivosich70075 жыл бұрын

    Dear max, youre my favorite youtuber Have a nice day

  • @maxderrat

    @maxderrat

    5 жыл бұрын

    Dear Stanley, YOU DA MAN Have a great week!

  • @zer0deaths862
    @zer0deaths8623 жыл бұрын

    "A perfect circle" *Giggles in Maynard James Keenan*

  • @jesuspomales
    @jesuspomales4 ай бұрын

    I feel like all three game are a large story played in reverse.

  • @olymolly3637
    @olymolly36375 жыл бұрын

    I miss watching this game's LPs.. It's a masterpiece.

  • @thedarkmoonman
    @thedarkmoonman3 жыл бұрын

    amazing!

  • @sincerely_lofi9570
    @sincerely_lofi95704 жыл бұрын

    So can we imagine for a minute about gathering all the best game theorists on the internet and making a game company with them. I mean honestly imagine how fun it would be always finding secrets and having games that somehow always have something sweeter hidden inside the more we play and look into. Just imagine

  • @saidius
    @saidius5 жыл бұрын

    THAT IS BRILLIANT

  • @supernintendochalmers6628
    @supernintendochalmers66285 жыл бұрын

    🤯 good shit man.

  • @tomasbalseiro4148
    @tomasbalseiro414811 ай бұрын

    this video explained everything perfectly

  • @Shuffledhearts
    @Shuffledhearts5 жыл бұрын

    First off, great video, not just this one, but also the Silent Hill ones are great. For Nimrod, you don't need to just cast it aside as 'christian myth' because firstly it is Jewish, and secondly there are two good papers on him (at least) Yigal Levin's "Nimrod the might, King of Kish, King of Sumer and Akkad" where it is argued that he represents the Sargonic dynasty of Akkad, and then Douglar Petrovich's article "Identifying Nimrod of Genesis 10 with Sargon of Akkad by exegetical and archaeological means," which as its title states is arguing for Nimrod being Sargon of Akkad.

  • @marshallemmet1366
    @marshallemmet13665 жыл бұрын

    Who knew I would gain the power to reset the universe from watching a video game analysis.

  • @TheAlison1456
    @TheAlison14563 жыл бұрын

    It's poetic that Wander achieved harmony whereas the civilization didn't. He didn't even seek that.

  • @WhoTookMyMirr
    @WhoTookMyMirr5 жыл бұрын

    idk if someone has already pointed this out, but Fludd could also be using alchemy symbolism for some of these mandalas. Back when alchemy was in its heyday, it was outlawed by the Church. Therefore, those who practiced it had to use a sort of visual code to hide their recipes, ideas, and the spiritual aspect of the alchemical process itself (the "Inner Work", which used ideas from Hermeticism). With Fludd's interest in early chemistry, it could be that he was also using alchemical symbolism. In the context of Shadow of the Colossus, it's easy to see the principles of medieval/renaissance alchemy at work. The main character is going through a spiritual alchemical process in order to become...something else. It's worth looking more into the alchemy angle.

  • @huggarugga
    @huggarugga5 жыл бұрын

    Excellent thought provoking stuff as always Max. Thank you for being an awesome guy who makes such enthralling content.

  • @madafraskasanchez9119
    @madafraskasanchez91195 жыл бұрын

    Just to let you know Max, you are the best!!!

  • @maxderrat

    @maxderrat

    5 жыл бұрын

    No... YOU'RE THE BEST.

  • @bloodykun4443
    @bloodykun44435 жыл бұрын

    Painting the people of the forbidden land in this light puts a bit of a new spin on it for me...hate to compare it but it almost feels like both Demon's and Dark Souls' seemingly tragic insinuations. Evil as Dormin may be implied to be, I think there's still a question that remains in whether it was some false idol or king such as Nimrod, or if it is the god they may have meant to worship. Dormin seems to have association with both light and dark, something that would appear to be in harmony, and perhaps it's because of his possession of Wander that he is able to be reborn, but who can say how that actually worked. A lot of new info to think about.

  • @GlacyLav
    @GlacyLav5 жыл бұрын

    Fans of SotC have such talent in overthinking small stuff, and I love it.

  • @frankiebq5604
    @frankiebq56045 жыл бұрын

    Thank you so much.

  • @vine01
    @vine013 жыл бұрын

    I have a quote from Frank Herbert's Dune which deals with power and corruption: “All governments suffer a recurring problem: Power attracts pathological personalities. It is not that power corrupts but that it is magnetic to the corruptible.” A different PoV which easily can be true as well.. SotC is not about government, but the body that wields the power is obvious..

  • @Nonamearisto
    @Nonamearisto5 жыл бұрын

    They gave the fans a new sword behind that door in the remake, once those 79 gold sparkles are collected, with 79 steps in the tunnel leading to the sword, IIRC. There really isn't anything else to find.

  • @JM-fx2cc
    @JM-fx2cc4 жыл бұрын

    Nomad is a absolute legend

  • @coolbubba7337
    @coolbubba73373 жыл бұрын

    Its too bad the Game Theorists can't make such a good theory, but a smaller channel can connect a graduate thesis to the Shadow of the Colossus. Thanks for such a good theory and hope more channels like you become the face of the theorist community.

  • @Jimmawww
    @Jimmawww Жыл бұрын

    If mandalas are present they represent the structure of that colossus soul, an identifier. Hermetic alchemy is all about transmutation of matter or spirits, which makes sense that a soul or souls are trapped in and power each colossus. Also combining the opposite elements of light and dark akin male and female to create new superior life also fits into the hermetic mindframe. As for Nimrod I only know non Abrahamic religions were prone to child sacrifice and unnatural methods, and that Kabbalah is closely associated with Babylon.

  • @WELLbethere
    @WELLbethere3 жыл бұрын

    So you're saying he set out to slay some dragons, fell into a deep darkness, and emerged as a transformed individual. Yup, sounds very Jungian indeed.

  • @cloudbloom
    @cloudbloom5 жыл бұрын

    Nomad is a hero

  • @DoomTown92
    @DoomTown92Ай бұрын

    You've got this

  • @Bhunt9394
    @Bhunt93943 жыл бұрын

    I came for lore, but stayed for the mandalas and Fludd.

  • @Harvest133
    @Harvest1332 жыл бұрын

    Power does not corrupt. Power is merely a tool. It can only reveal corruption, not create it.

  • @romanceenthusiasm7972
    @romanceenthusiasm79724 жыл бұрын

    ICO and this game are definitely conjoined. The same sword dropped in a pool of water is the same sword ICO gets after falling. Also in the beginning of ICO the chamber were they placed him must of been a sacrafical chamber and there were many more around.

  • @dark0ssx
    @dark0ssx5 жыл бұрын

    very interesting

  • @ISCREAMSODAsmr
    @ISCREAMSODAsmr6 ай бұрын

    11:21 he freed 16 beings from imprisonment. You all and even the creators say dorman was split 16 ways BUT 16 people had to be the sacrificed to seal the spirits.... Naruto's Death sealing technique states so and I'm inclined to believe sealing something like that would require a sacrifice 😢

  • @tyrod8232
    @tyrod82323 жыл бұрын

    After you beat the the 8th colossus and before you spawn into the temple you hear a whisper in the transition. Does anyone know what it’s saying? The lines get longer the more times you resurrect

  • @narcissismincarnate9201
    @narcissismincarnate92015 жыл бұрын

    Are the colossi eyes mandalas?

  • @TheAlison1456
    @TheAlison14563 жыл бұрын

    3:21 weird. On 3/27 I drew a bunch of circles. Not a mandala, but close.

Келесі