HDR vs a Single Raw File | Which is cleaner?

In this video I'll process one of my Tipsoo Lake photos two different ways - First as a single RAW file and then I'll show you how to merge and process 5 bracketed photos in Lightroom. Which way produces the better quality?
Don't forget to visit my website at www.jamesparkerphoto.com to sign up for my newsletter and check out my upcoming workshops and 1 on 1 tutoring. I teach classes on using your camera, landscape photography, lighting, post processing, and more.
Links:
www.jamesparkerphoto.com
/ jamesparkerphoto
#LandscapePhotography, #PacificNorthwest, #educational, #howto, #composition, #RAW, #HDR

Пікірлер: 27

  • @areks.6101
    @areks.610119 күн бұрын

    Best experiment and explanation ever!. With many thanks.

  • @JamesParkerPhotography

    @JamesParkerPhotography

    19 күн бұрын

    You are welcome!!

  • @wlacalle
    @wlacalle Жыл бұрын

    Great job explaining HDR !

  • @MrMartin246
    @MrMartin2467 ай бұрын

    Excellent video and explanations. Thanks.

  • @johndavies9585
    @johndavies95852 жыл бұрын

    great explanation cleared up so much for me at last I can understand it , and put across ,straight forward easy to understand thank you

  • @misuarimuhammad4303
    @misuarimuhammad43037 ай бұрын

    Very informative content, love it❤

  • @kangrossi
    @kangrossi2 жыл бұрын

    I like bracketing, even with 1 inch sensor camera you can get better dynamic range

  • @thomastuorto9929
    @thomastuorto9929 Жыл бұрын

    Nice photo.

  • @guyyowell8547
    @guyyowell85472 жыл бұрын

    Another really great instructive video James! It’s hard to believe you have only 423 followers (including myself). Unfortunately, I guess most people fall victim to all the click-bait videos by these other fools on KZread. When I’m out shooting landscapes, I always bracket because it doesn’t cost anything and you always have the option to create an HDR from multiple photos if needed.

  • @JamesParkerPhotography

    @JamesParkerPhotography

    2 жыл бұрын

    Thanks Guy! I'm a complete novice when it comes to promoting my channel other than by KZread's algorithms. That's why it's so important to like and subscribe - I actually have a play list that will just play all (or most) of my videos in sequence so you could just click it and head to bed with the volume down. 🙂 I'd love to know the secret to building a base of subscribers faster!

  • @guyyowell8547

    @guyyowell8547

    2 жыл бұрын

    @@JamesParkerPhotography I’ve been a photographer for nearly 50 years (my first professional camera was the Nikon F2), so I have a pretty good understanding of technique and the capabilities/limitations of even the top digital cameras. I’m currently shooting with the Nikon Z9. Whenever I’m out shooting landscapes with friends, I always emphasize the importance of bracketing, even if you’ve not going to use all of the exposures. It’s just so refreshing to see someone on KZread making really quality videos.

  • @alecubudulecu
    @alecubudulecu2 жыл бұрын

    Yeah I see a difference. But same time I feel depending on use case. If just sightseeing and general purpose …. The space savings on the single Raw file with modern cameras that can do 12-15 stops dynamic range … vs having 3-5 shots …. But yes. For a client printed like you said. Better to bracket.

  • @JamesParkerPhotography

    @JamesParkerPhotography

    2 жыл бұрын

    Yes - it totally depends on usage. Posting to facebook? Doesn't matter. Printing a large print or if you want the very best quality? Then definitely bracket as needed.

  • @amberrexford1004
    @amberrexford1004 Жыл бұрын

    Would you ever suggest shooting in the HDR setting in camera or no since you can only shoot JPEGs with the in-camera HDR?

  • @JamesParkerPhotography

    @JamesParkerPhotography

    Жыл бұрын

    Amber - No. I wouldn't recommend shooting with the camera's built in HDR mode. You can control the result exactly the way you want in post VS taking what the camera comes up with.

  • @echoauxgen
    @echoauxgen Жыл бұрын

    I shoot RAW BUT for sunsets/rises and blue hour I always bracket 5 @ +/- 2 ev. If the sun is above the horizon you get a smaller sun instead of a large blown out sun. Also say on a beach with driftwood you get the darkside of foreground driftwood bright as well as the sky is full of detail. If you do moon shots you will get a focused moon and a bright foreground without having to blend a moon in in Ps. just use SS/ISO = 125 and center shot at .5 seconds and f at 8 to 11 for moon focus. HDR was used years ago to get indoor shots with clear and in focus outdoor detail. also good for wildlife to get detail of feathers or animal hair on bright days. bottom line you have the five shots and you can use all or one for you can not go back a minute or two to retake the shot. Sony cameras let you do 5 @ +/- 3EV only a few programs can manage that 3EV separation, Photomatix is great if also movement (like the moon), Dxo that has Nik collection HDR Efex. just have fun.

  • @wordsshackles441
    @wordsshackles441 Жыл бұрын

    Great video. Question : Are the HDRI files used in CG for image based lighting based on RAW files ?

  • @JamesParkerPhotography

    @JamesParkerPhotography

    Жыл бұрын

    I'm not sure I follow your question. In my instance, I did use RAW files to generate the single HDR file, which was a DNG (A Digital Negative - Adobe's version of a RAW file).

  • @wordsshackles441

    @wordsshackles441

    Жыл бұрын

    ​@@JamesParkerPhotography Thanks for the prompt answer. I am a CG Artist, I make photo-realistic renders of 3D scenes. I am trying to figure out what color profile to associate with the HDRi file I am using to light my scene in my 3D rendering package. I understand that HDRi are linear file - not gamma encoded - but I am trying to figure out what color space HDRi files are actually referencing. There is an option to associate such file to a 'RAW' file, or say 'Linear sRGB', and I am at a loss as to whether HDRi images of real-world scenes would be considered RAW. I hope that makes sense.

  • @JamesParkerPhotography

    @JamesParkerPhotography

    Жыл бұрын

    @@wordsshackles441 - Color profiles in photography for RAW files are based on the camera settings. For my Sony, I can shoot in sRGB or Abobe RGB. I always select Adone RGB to give me the largest color space. I hope this helps.

  • @wordsshackles441

    @wordsshackles441

    Жыл бұрын

    @@JamesParkerPhotography Makes sense. Thanks a bunch

  • @alaashaban3209
    @alaashaban3209 Жыл бұрын

    Question plz Which is better Direct HDR by one click from camera or Bracketing multiple images?

  • @JamesParkerPhotography

    @JamesParkerPhotography

    Жыл бұрын

    If your camera combines the images for you, then don’t use that. I do have the camera take three or five images in a row and automatically adjust the exposure. I then combine those in Lightroom or Photoshop.

  • @johnbecich9540
    @johnbecich95408 ай бұрын

    @11'41" did you source your 5-file HDR exercise from JPG or RAW files? I presume RAW. But I'd like to know which you used.

  • @JamesParkerPhotography

    @JamesParkerPhotography

    8 ай бұрын

    I always use RAW files when editing. No jpgs. 👍🏻

  • @Mrlarryphelps
    @Mrlarryphelps2 жыл бұрын

    Enjoy your videos. Are the 5 bracketed photos raw of jpeg files?

  • @JamesParkerPhotography

    @JamesParkerPhotography

    2 жыл бұрын

    Thanks! They are 5 RAW files that were merged to a single DNG file in Lightroom.