Government 'continues to fail’ on immigration detention following alleged Perth attack
Shadow Immigration Minister Dan Tehan says the Albanese government “continues to fail” on the issue of immigration detention.
A former immigration detainee released under the controversial NZYQ ruling has been arrested in Perth alongside two others for an alleged violent home robbery of an elderly couple which left one of the senior citizens with severe facial bruising.
“They have failed from day one to have their number on priority: keeping the Australian community safe,” Mr Tehan told Sky News host Andrew Bolt.
“This alleged incident now is sadly what we predicted because Andrew Giles and Clare O’Neil have fumbled their way through this issue like we’ve never seen two ministers fumble an issue ... in our history.
“The failures just mount and mount when it comes to this issue.”
Пікірлер: 274
This is 100% the governments fault , everyone I talk to said they would never vote for this government again .
@sallycent6598
Ай бұрын
This government should be losing on many issues.
@rods6405
Ай бұрын
the problem is they made this mistake once and they will make again
@PaulSmith-ss6zm
Ай бұрын
Not just this government all Labor governments
@xovain4574
Ай бұрын
The issue is not Labor, they were released due to a Court ruling, we don't live in a dictatorship so stop crying over that. The Liberal Party is by far the worst party of them all, Labor much like any part has ups and downs, the liberals only have downs. Wake up
@franktully3065
Ай бұрын
@@sallycent6598it should be, unfortunately the opposition isn't a whole lot better.
These 2 incompetent ministers should not only be sacked but charged with the assault on the couple and sued as well
@olddog-fv2ox
Ай бұрын
Accessories
@xovain4574
Ай бұрын
This makes no sense, let's think about it logically instead of using our emotions. Assuming a Liberal government was in-charge at the time, the detainees would STILL have been released as it was a court order to release them and NOT some government decision. These people who commit crime would have STILL committed the crime, regardless of which government sit in power, saying this issue is purely because of Labor is ridiculous as best and kinda stupid at worst.
@johngunning2123
Ай бұрын
@@xovain4574 That's not quite right at all. The decision by the court order was as a direct result of information given to them by the Albanese government. Labor are to blame and have always been far too lenient on offenders. Andrew Giles and Clare O’Neil should be sacked.
@apizone1
Ай бұрын
ONE incompetent PETER DUTTON >. .. We now have the Doc of his Department warning him for 10 years To get them out of the country .. no EXCUSES ... as no democratic country allows detention of people who have not been convicted forever .. Dutton MUST Resign !!
This attack was absolutely disgusting
These 2 ministers have blood on there hands & should be sued by this grandmother ,
Labor Government has failed us all Australians.
@apizone1
Ай бұрын
So why did Duttons own Dept wrtie those DOC for 10 years telling him to ge them out of the country ??
These 2 ministers should be jailed for this, it is completely 100% their fault.
@apizone1
Ай бұрын
Dutton would be the first in ... his dept BEGGED Him to get them out of the country We have the doc .. read the newspapers
@bobKringe
Ай бұрын
How is this Duttons fault are you high 😂
@apizone1
Ай бұрын
@@bobKringe You are SOFT .. Stop tying to DODGE the fact that Duttons Department told him for 10 Years .. to get them out of the county - That it was DUTTOS legislation that was struck down by the highest court in the land
Giles & O'Neil, both win the biggest clown and most incompetent awards.
@roz7441
Ай бұрын
Hard to believe these two are worse than Albonese
@cristinah7547
Ай бұрын
@@roz7441take a look at the whole labor cabinet… they aren’t up to the job of governing … they are too focused on agendas that are handed down to them and do not do their due diligence… they are intellectually and ethically inept.
The obscene accelerated influx of immigrants by the Albanese government that includes refugees, unskilled, unaccompanied young men, and the flotsam and jetsum of the Arab world is the biggest mistake this government could make. The social problems in the coming years coupled with the cost to the tax-payer will be enormous.
@patking754
Ай бұрын
Just look at England ! You’d think this would be a warning to our government they would move heaven and earth that we wouldn’t go down the same path.
@lennardkahn6379
Ай бұрын
Individual Moslems may show splendid qualities. Thousands become the brave and loyal soldiers of the Islam: all know how to die: but the influence of the religion paralyses the social development of those who follow it. No stronger retrograde force exists in the world. Far from being moribund, Mohammedanism is a militant and proselytizing faith. It has already spread throughout Central Africa, raising fearless warriors at every step; and were it not that Christianity is sheltered in the strong arms of science, the science against which it had vainly struggled, the civilisation of modern Europe might fall, as fell the civilisation of ancient Rome.
@frankyyaggabot6222
Ай бұрын
@@lennardkahn6379 ... Churchill (1899 I think he wrote that).
@MickReeves-qr3px
Ай бұрын
Coming years,it's here NOW
@KIA-MIA-POW
Ай бұрын
@MickReeves-qr3px You think so! You just ain't seen nothing yet! Australians have not yet witnessed austerity and a country in chaos. Even those living on the street can get a meal...
Remove judicial and political immunity from lawsuits and watch attitudes of the 'ruling class' change overnight.
Is there anything Albo & Co haven't completely rooted in this country ??
@ohasis8331
Ай бұрын
Me. Well not there anyways.
@fruckya
Ай бұрын
The LGBTQ community 😂
@knight2425
Ай бұрын
Albo and Co haven’t screwed the rorts they are abusing
Incompetent Labor government doesn't give a stuff about Aussies
@TomasFunes-rt8rd
Ай бұрын
Their allegiance is to Red China's money.
@Luvly2938
Ай бұрын
So true!!
@user-gl5kj1fm5x
Ай бұрын
true but what about Duttons failure to detain people with mental health problems that end up with innocent people in hospital or worse still dead? And his role in the Robo Debt Scheme?
@knight2425
Ай бұрын
@@user-gl5kj1fm5xthe Liberals stopped the boats though so people like this wouldn’t be here in the first place
They have to be sacked it’s a disgrace truly disgusting
Albanese has had PM next to his name for three years now and every time I see it I feel ill! He’s inept, incompetent, arrogant and dangerous!
@johngunning2123
Ай бұрын
I feel exactly the same. Even the sound of his voice makes me cringe.
Labor has always wanted high levels of immigration - legally and illegally. Consequences and your safety be damned.
@xovain4574
Ай бұрын
This isn't true, immigration on that scale goes against the values of Labor.. but if you had critical thinking you would know this!! The liberal party is MORE pro immigrant, how? why? It's cheaper to hire a bunch of immigrants off the books than it is to hire Australians, this goes directly against Labor principals which are undoubtedly to get us more jobs and wages. You're confusing Labor being okay with legal immigration and not crying about it against a party which will cry about legal immigration but still allow it in ( especially illegal ), common misconception. :)
@Blackwood-gh6jd
Ай бұрын
@@xovain4574 LNP dont have any problems in kicking them out, this Govt wont as to scared to upset their minorities....this is proven in the 35% muslim seat of tony burke , who refused to condemn Hamas....they are as a weak as.
@nigelmorgan3449
Ай бұрын
That’s right bud you keep supporting Labor they need long time suckers like you to keep the numbers up Bet your the little guy that turns up each week to collect the union subs with support you lazy good for nothings
@ljnv
Ай бұрын
I would say both parties are terrible. Labour wants high migration to look good and shove their values down others. Liberal party have had higher level of migrants after John Howard come due to their corporate friends wanting cheap labour. Their needs to be another party both of the same just care for their own pockets.
@eagle1579
Ай бұрын
bit like the Democrats in the US.
Despicable attack caused 100% by labor incompetence. Bullshit your way out of this one Albogreazy 👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻💩💩💩💩 ❤️🇦🇺
@eagle1579
Ай бұрын
Today, Albo said this is now the State's matter...next..
I hope she takes this government for every cent
@carbonite1999
Ай бұрын
she should take it from the labor cartel ,not Australians ,its always been party before the people ,bankrupt them not the AUSTRALIANS WHO DIDNT VOTE FOR THEM .
@roz7441
Ай бұрын
@carbonite1999 well said, agree 100%
@evil17
Ай бұрын
She had better hurry then before Albo & his Labor clowns blow it all.
The government needs to be educated on what the word deportation means.
MGG that poor couple, This Government has a lot to answer to, So to the Governor General to do his bloody job and sack this government
We don't want them .
Albo and his ministers are incompetent, they just blame Dutton. Making promises with Albo mantra my word is my bond.
@apizone1
Ай бұрын
NO I,,it is DUTTONS own appointees as the Minster of Immigration .. on who watch they came in on Who we now Know warned him for 10 years ... to get them out of the country no excuses Before the High Court does here .. what they do everywhere else.. let them out if they are not convicted
@cristinah7547
Ай бұрын
@@apizone1did they come in during the greens push to relocate the Nauru asylum seekers under medical emergency loophole bypassing the 3rd country medical treaty we had? I remember that well, so they basically ambushed the governments policy of keeping them off Australian soil leading to the next plethora of human rights activism that the coalition tried to contain in the interest of public safety… tell the whole story mate … we’re not as disengaged or as clueless as your voter base…
Claire… Shameful performance You should go immediately Should be hauled up in front of parliament, asked to explain their actions, and sacked on the spot with no entitlements
Enough is enough. Albo should resign.
We see the face of the woman who was bashed but not the faces of the people who carried it out .Somethings wrong here .
@eagle1579
Ай бұрын
Well, we don't want the people to know who these fine people are, agree, the cops should take away what they are holding up.
Wtf!! Im in Perth and this is the first im hearing about this ..that poor woman..her face may recover in time, but the mental scars are for life 😢
@haydencooper_
Ай бұрын
Then you don't follow the news.
Never ever vote Labor
Once you see the plan you’ll realise this is what they want to happen.
why are they being set free in the first place
@xovain4574
Ай бұрын
Because a court said to do so, not the Government... some idiots in these comments cannot understand that a COURT and the GOVERNMENT are two separate bodies and institutions, the Government and in this case parliament write the laws, the courts enforce the laws. Under our constitution, it would be illegal to detain them indefinitely and so they were ordered to be released..
@helenowen5408
Ай бұрын
@@xovain4574no dickhead the courts released ONE detainee the labor clown show released the rest and has imported record numbers of un skilled unemployable migrants try to keep up with reality dh🤣🤣🤣🤣
@eagle1579
Ай бұрын
@@xovain4574 In this case for public safety the Gov needs to step in and overrule the anti Aust high court.
@xovain4574
Ай бұрын
@@eagle1579 So the problem with what you just described is that we would turn into a dictatorship. Once you violate the constitution once, you are free to violate it as many times as you want. Please think through the ideas and thoughts you have before you comment them... if we disregard what the highest court in the land rules then we effectively have no rights and no rule of law. This is quite literally the worst thing the Australian government could do and you will find the Liberal party would not defy the court either. Government gets it legitimacy through two sources, the Constitution of Australia and the King of Australia. By defying the High Court of Australia you are both defying the Constitution AND the King, and thus your government is illegitimate and prone to being dissolved by the King. You might ask, why is that? This is because the Constitution outlines that Justices of the High Court are appointed by the Governor General who is the Kings official representative in Australia, i.e the King. if we were to do such a thing it would have massive consequences. tldr; const says high court is right and king appoints, you would be defying both if you violated the order and thus be illegitimate
@sandrajohn9837
Ай бұрын
@@xovain4574If they had deported them the Court would have had nothing to say on the matter.
Hi Australia from the UK. Tony Abbott's policy was right with immigration. Here in the UK we've had many deaths including two MPs committed by Muslim extremists and MPs have had to have a hotline to local Police if they feel intimidated by these left wing extremists. 🇦🇷🇬🇧🇱🇷🇦🇨🇨🇦🇭🇲
PM must be sacked
Why are violent criminals allowed to be imported in the first place? Please clarify.
If Morrison or Dutton were Immigration Ministers we wouldn't be hearing the end of it!! Giles and O'Neill strangely silent to date. Is peter Dutton to blame?
They should be made to look at this poor ladys face and see what pain she is going through.
Labor need to resign, this government is failing and failing over and over with their policies.
these two need to go now!!
Australia and Australians must always come first otherwise it’s time to boot the government out of office. Long live Australia!!
Giles will say 'nothing to see here '.Not unusual for a crime like this to occur in Australia.
wtf !!! how these labor pollies can sleep at night with all the damage they are doing is beyond me !!!
The white replacement in Australia.
@Jenifer_G
Ай бұрын
Hardly any whites in Australia left.
Labor is trying to use the tactics of the American Democrats on the illegal immigrants issue.
@xovain4574
Ай бұрын
That's simply not true. You also cannot compare Australian parties to American parties for so many reasons that should be obvious.
Never vote labour greens or teals again!😖😖
@eagle1579
Ай бұрын
Greens and Teals are the only thing that's keeping Labor from losing the next election. But got a feeling the Teals will lose a few seats, likewise the Greens.
Albo and labour wont take responsibility for this stuffup . Its always someone elses fault .
Labor never again as anything else is better for Australia!
@xovain4574
Ай бұрын
You're delusional, the Liberal party will get in power; fuck things up and you'll switch up. You need to lose the bipolar attitude and understand parties make mistakes, one just happens to make more ( liberals that is if you didnt realise already )
This is why Australians should be allowed to be armed as this will continue
@xovain4574
Ай бұрын
This is a stupid comment, please look at the culture of the country and then use others as references. You will come to the conclusion that arming the Australian population is a stupid idea.
@LeeGordon-fp9zf
Ай бұрын
We are allowed to own guns. Go get yr permit, and get a gun.
@LeeGordon-fp9zf
Ай бұрын
@@xovain4574 No. We should be arming ourselves. The Australia of today is more criminally driven than ever before. Letting in ppl from poor and fighting countries does not keep us safe. Our lax laws against criminals of any colour put us all in dangerous situations more now than before.
@helenowen5408
Ай бұрын
@@LeeGordon-fp9zf yeah but try using that firearm for the purpose of self-defence. And its not quite go get a permit and get a gun.🍺🇦🇺
@helenowen5408
Ай бұрын
@@xovain4574you really are a fckwit troll arent ya mate. Go get a life🤣🤣🤣
This is on the governments watch !!😡
Labor is so week on this matter, why do they get it wrong so many times!
@xovain4574
Ай бұрын
You can't even spell weak, I don't see why you should get a say on the matter..
For as long as judges and magistrates have jobs for life with no responsibility, justice will not be served as required by the public.
Why haven't these criminals been deported?
@eagle1579
Ай бұрын
That's the $65m dollar question DA, there has to be some sort of backhanded deal that's going on with the so called anti Australian high court.
@eagle1579
Ай бұрын
That's the $65m dollar question DA, there has to be some sort of backhanded deal that's going on with the so called anti Australian high court.
Vote Pauline Hanson for prime Minister. Never rely on two clowns running the two major parties in Australia
@eagle1579
Ай бұрын
Will be interesting to see what sort of vote One Nation gets in the upcoming Qld State election. Got a feeling it will be a high vote for them.
One could only be left thinking that Giles & ONeill are toxic to Albo's position now. If he doesn't, at the very least, sideline 'em then he's fast becoming his own worst enemy. The optics of this are NOT helping him....at ALL.
Three words for company of incompetents spells Australian Labour Party. Create havoc for 3 years and get taxpayer funded support for life ! The rest of us will continue to pay dearly for a long time.
@xovain4574
Ай бұрын
Okay but look at the Liberal party, consistently fuck up, consistently abuse our rights and move our country more towards a police state / dictatorship then fuck up our nature before having to be kicked out. You honestly cannot make this up, how delusional / short sighted are you?
Speaking about male on female violence!
8its wonder Albo hasn’t demanded this to be censored too
@xovain4574
Ай бұрын
Wanting to remove footage of horrific attacks from the internet is not "Censoring", you are delusional if you think it's okay for the government to stand there and be like " ok lets allow videos of these murdered victims to be spread! " and if you haven't seen said videos, I suggest you go watch them. It's quite horrific.
This poor woman and her husband should get compensation, Britteny did.
Not a word on ABC News Adelaide tonight (29 Apr) ????
What is so hard about charging this grub and if convicted locking him up and at the expiration and sentence deport him. No residency of any type in this country as he has failed the character test and deny him entry for life. Labour clearly stuffed up but do not have the guts to admit it. The High Court decision applied to one person only not 150.
They would blame Peter Dutton cause they have no idea
@xovain4574
Ай бұрын
Peter dutton was the former minister, under the liberal party the immigration system was fucked because you're too stupid to realise that Liberal is PRO immigration and PRO illegal immigration, but yeah didn't think that one through did you? You're probably wondering.. HOW ARE THEY PRO IMMIGRATION? Easy! Cheap workers, do the math yourself, look at better sources than sky news.
@eagle1579
Ай бұрын
it's the only thing they have...Labor are so pathetic.
I wonder how many times can these people commit crimes .is it 1 of 10 times or more
That poor lady. She has been badly abused. Government are definitely responsible and should give her a big payout for her pain and suffering. Which was so unnecessary if that criminal had been kept in detention.
Yep, as usual nothing to see here! The government will not publicise something they do not want the public to see, it has to be alternative platforms.
@xovain4574
Ай бұрын
You're crazy, you're watching sky news which is liberal propaganda, which will only show you anti Labor sentiment and hide liberal issues.. then say there's nothing to see here? I think you need to get a better news source first of all.. then contemplate why x company might want to push liberal propaganda.. might have something to do with the massive payouts and tax breaks the liberals give them :) but you're so simple minded you never once thought that maybe your news source was extremely biased. stop falling for DIP.
Change the goverment
They are quite happy to let us have a vote on gay marriage and the aboriginal voice , how about letting us have a vote on immigration!!!!
The word sack comes to mind
Sue the Labor party for $$$$$$$ on this attack
When has labor ever cared for Australians and Australia...Labor r more for other countries citizens, Never ever ever vote labor they will never be for us
@xovain4574
Ай бұрын
This isn't true, Labor is by far the best party out of the two major ones. The liberals will abuse your rights, turn us into a police state, waste tax payer money and fuck our nature like they continuously do in the past, Labor by far has done good. The reason you've came to the opinion you have right now is because you're literally watching SKY NEWS which is Liberal propaganda. They get tax breaks and pay-outs from the Liberal government and in turn post propaganda and make absurd donations to the party. You need to think more critically and find better news sources because you're horribly misinformed.
Allegedly Nothing. If you saw what was done to her. 😏
Labor needs to show they have balls but with them it will never happen. We have a pancy unfortunately running our country sad for us..
It’s not just detainees, it’s the youth and adults across the country committing offences and continuously getting bail multiple times. There are cases where some of these imbeciles have had bail 10+ times. At what point would a judge think to themselves, ok perhaps now that this offender has repeatedly committed offences on numerous seperate bails that now might be the time to reject bail. What a joke. Law enforcement do a great job but bail is the constant issue. Look at Queensland, look everywhere.
Not fit for purposes- they must be accountable for not opposing bail - there’s no way this horrific bashing would have happened - now a family will NEVER FEEL SAFE! 💔😥
Si vis pacem .... para bellum
The Labour government has it's number one priority to let in increasing numbers of illegal migrants from the ME to appease its Muslim citizens & bolster its vote. Australia is a country that continues to bend over to toxic religious ideology ( that i emigrated from) and getting screwed every time.
Labor is responsible for this assault, they care more for foreigners than they do Australians.
What r heck is Australia hiding and doing. Law is law... dont be politically correct..enforce Australian law..please Australia...!!!
will the government and the opposition call for mandatory detention of all people with mental illness stemming from the fatal stabbings at Bondi resulting in 6 dead and the church stabbing resulting in a number of casualties in hospital
Wheres the esafty commissar
@lornatodd4750
Ай бұрын
Sipping $500 bottles of wine waiting for Albosleezy to give her more power.
All the refugee advocates suddenly go quiet .
I wonder what would happen if this was one of theirs or albos mum
Cease funding immigrants access to the high court of Australia. No Australia citizens are able to have representation to th HC of A paid by the taxpayers.
@Ozzie3356
Ай бұрын
It's a lawyers picnic the immigration high court cases, and a rort Labor knows been going on for years.
This elderly couple could've died. One incidence is too many. It is just incapability and the two ministers should be sacked immediately, PM should hold a conference and apologise in public for putting the Australians in danger, and the released detainees should be detained and no further release should be made. There's no other way to prove the government cares for average Australians.
WEF policies coming home to roost.
Why is he still here?
She shud to sue the government
What the he'll is going on
Dumb and dumber good to see the sequel was made in Australia. Staring two of Albos finest Ministers.
It’s always too little too late for most of these situations.
Putrid.
And Albo can only say...it's really a State matter now...wow !!
@sandrajohn9837
Ай бұрын
It's never his fault and never his responsibility.
@eagle1579
26 күн бұрын
@@sandrajohn9837 Yep, he knows he's lost all credibility on this now, and is now referring all questions on this to the useless fall guy Andrew Gilles.
@sandrajohn9837
25 күн бұрын
@@eagle1579 Hardly the response one might have hoped for (had one not known better 🫤)
Onya but what you just showed is just as bad as the priest stabbing is it gonna get removed
Telephone call for Peter Dutton, hello Sky News please ask that question where is he
Stop saying “alleged” … 😵
Individual Moslems may show splendid qualities. Thousands become the brave and loyal soldiers of the Islam: all know how to die: but the influence of the religion paralyses the social development of those who follow it. No stronger retrograde force exists in the world. Far from being moribund, Mohammedanism is a militant and proselytizing faith. It has already spread throughout Central Africa, raising fearless warriors at every step; and were it not that Christianity is sheltered in the strong arms of science, the science against which it had vainly struggled, the civilisation of modern Europe might fall, as fell the civilisation of ancient Rome.
I call this the albanese, is so much like joe biden its not funny know this women should directly sue albert biden albanese
Lol... The only place I'm afraid to visit is Bondi Westfield.....🥵
@HyperVaccinated
Ай бұрын
Same... lots of violent antivaxxers in that area....
@WitchDoctor.933
Ай бұрын
@@HyperVaccinated Reported for Misinformation. 😆
@Father-Grandfather
Ай бұрын
And the cemetery to say hi to father and grandfather 😂
@tomjones5338
Ай бұрын
@@HyperVaccinated you dribble some brown stuff from your mouth still shaming anti-vaxxers people like you wanted them banned from society couldn't careless if they lose everything your a heartless soulless no empathy you need to grow up get over ask God for forgiveness and repent for your cruelty towards others
Maybe you shouldn’t throw immigrants in jail without just cause.
@sandrajohn9837
Ай бұрын
We don't. What part of, 'law,', don't you understand? According to international law refugees are required to seek asylum at the first safe place they come to. It's a fair step from Africa or the Middle East to Australia. Illegal, economic immigrants are lawbreakers and have no claim.
Meaningless news, Why to not talk about the hostages ??
@LuciferBlack-zp8lr
Ай бұрын
Checkbook journalism.
@WitchDoctor.933
Ай бұрын
See a Therapist.
@tomerhuss
Ай бұрын
@@WitchDoctor.933 hello antisemite
@tomerhuss
Ай бұрын
@@LuciferBlack-zp8lr There are 130 hostages in Gaza, praying for them costs nothing, be human
@tomerhuss
Ай бұрын
@@WitchDoctor.933 antisemitism is a disease
Released by the court of Australia. Andrew Bolt has lost the little credibility he once had with subscribers for this very reason.. Misinterpretation of the truth to suit his own agenda.
These incompetent idiots don’t care about their own citizens!!! How shameful!!!!
If this was my mother Bimbo and Ferret would be resting in hospital on life support
Sky News sensoring comments as usual..... Freedom of speech & expression is still a civil right regardless or wether you clowns object to the manner in people respond to your supposed journalistic talents
@xovain4574
Ай бұрын
Haha deleting and censoring loads of my comments too. It's what you expect from a news source which promotes a... certain party which objects to both the values of Freedom of Speech and Freedom of Expression ( no matter how much they might want to claim otherwise! )