Gnosticism - Thunder Perfect Mind - Divine Feminine - Gender, Paradox and Violence

One of the most enigmatic and alluring text in the Nag Hammadi Library of Gnostic texts is the famed hymn-poem Thunder: Perfect Mind. This episode explores the origins, structure, parallels with an eye to Thunder's treatment of gender, language and colonialism. We also explore to what degree we can call Thunder 'gnostic' at all - why did this document survive in the Nag Hammadi library at all?
Recommended Readings:
Thunder: Perfect Mind - www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontl...
Taussig, etc. - The Thunder: Perfect Mind: A New Translation and Introduction - 978-0230105638
Prada Ad - www.prada.com/us/en/pradasphe...
#gnosticism #gnostic #hermeticism

Пікірлер: 251

  • @tomg5516
    @tomg5516 Жыл бұрын

    The title immediately made me think of the Buddhist text Vajracchedikā Prajñāpāramitā Sūtra, "The Perfection of Wisdom Text that Cuts Like a Thunderbolt".

  • @sinisterminister4201
    @sinisterminister42013 жыл бұрын

    The pendulum of the mind oscillates between sense and nonsense, not between right and wrong. -C. G. Jung

  • @disruptivemusings8363

    @disruptivemusings8363

    3 жыл бұрын

    I read somewhere: ordered chaos. Am still working all this out 📜

  • @sinisterminister4201

    @sinisterminister4201

    3 жыл бұрын

    The Disruptive Muse. “In all chaos there is a cosmos, in all disorder a secret order.” ― Carl Gustav Jung

  • @Themidnightegardener
    @Themidnightegardener3 жыл бұрын

    Yahoo! I'm a big Gnerd when it comes to Gnosticism!! Thanks bro!

  • @iankrom510

    @iankrom510

    3 жыл бұрын

    That pun is horrible! I love it!

  • @Riplee

    @Riplee

    3 жыл бұрын

    I’m a Gnome & you’ve just been gnomed

  • @Raulduke419

    @Raulduke419

    2 жыл бұрын

    gnice joke

  • @badluckrabbit
    @badluckrabbit3 жыл бұрын

    Are any other Mahayana or Vajrayana Buddhist viewers feeling a resonance between Thunder Perfect Mind and the Diamond Sutra, Heart Sutra, and the teachings on Prajnaparamita? Even the title itself "Thunder Perfect Mind" sounds like it should be the title of a Buddhist sutra rather than a "gnostic/hermetic" hymn.

  • @cloudsteps

    @cloudsteps

    Жыл бұрын

    100%nondual

  • @dvklaveren

    @dvklaveren

    Жыл бұрын

    I have been fascinated with parallels between platonism/gnosticism and Buddhism. The parallel between Demiurge entities and Great Brahma as depicted in the Pali Canon I thought were striking.

  • @Gaia369

    @Gaia369

    Жыл бұрын

    Oh yes, heart sutra is very much ALIGNMENT with the All, as this text reveals.

  • @ANiMALFRiENDS_GOLDMAN

    @ANiMALFRiENDS_GOLDMAN

    Жыл бұрын

    I AM the Nameless The Unamable 1 I AM the Thathomless The Unthathomable 1 I AM the Silence The Unsilencable 1 I AM the Numbers The Numberless 1 I AM the Moment The Momentless 1 I AM the Changing The Unchangeable 1 I AM the Speaking The Speechless 1 I AM the Beholder The Unbeholdable 1 I AM the Knowledge The Unknowable 1 I AM the Crowner The Uncrownable 1

  • @ANiMALFRiENDS_GOLDMAN

    @ANiMALFRiENDS_GOLDMAN

    Жыл бұрын

    TRUTH iS TRUTH MY FRiENDS BELOVED JESUS WAS ALSO GAUTAMA BUDDHA ST ESA HE IS KNOW AS AND WAS ZARATHUSTRA MOSES AND MANY OTHER BELOVED ONES

  • @comfylain
    @comfylain10 ай бұрын

    "And the mines are void of diamonds That we carry in our rags (Thunder Perfect Mind) Then all the world seems A sadness song" :)

  • @a.m.e.
    @a.m.e.3 жыл бұрын

    To me, since the feminine energy is water that comes up, and then fire that comes down, then thunder would be symbolic of integrated energy coming down from sky father to mother earth. The poem paints a picture of what integration looks like, and how the seemingly opposite qualities that contradict each other can actually dance.

  • @AlejandroMS67

    @AlejandroMS67

    7 ай бұрын

    Interesting point about the thunder, also perhaps worth noting is that thunder is the sound that comes from lightning, and lightning is a 2 way phenomenon where invisible electric current moves first from sky to ground, and then we see the 2nd half of that process which is the lit part from ground to sky, and it is this visible movement of light from ground to sky that causes the thunder.boom arising from the rapidly heated air channel around the lightning reaching temperatures equal to the surface of the sun.

  • @bobfrancis123
    @bobfrancis1232 жыл бұрын

    I IMMEDIATELY looked up the text and read the MacRae translation. Wow. Yes, it is absolutely paradoxical but these words have immense power. “I am the utterance of my name.” What a statement of being! I’ll have to read and reread this poem over and over to grasp at the straws of intent present here. I wish I could read/speak pre-Medieval Coptic, because I’d love to hear this in its original language.

  • @kennethbeal

    @kennethbeal

    10 ай бұрын

    It really makes a lot of sense to me, "strangely enough" I hear a younger version of me saying. :) It is the author, speaking to us in this book we are in. Mind-bending. Especially the ending; we will meet the author. The "until they become sober" made me laugh; have been for more than 3 years. And, dual meanings exist of course. The "and go up to their resting place" reminded me of the ascension in The Stranger's Book: "What bound me has been killed, and I've been released. I'll go up to my Father, the One above all the great realms."

  • @justkiddin84

    @justkiddin84

    2 ай бұрын

    Yes. I heard, ‘I AM’.

  • @TormodiR
    @TormodiR3 жыл бұрын

    Once again you triggered my obsession with thunder/lighting and emphasized an enlightening text. I believe this is well done, thank you Dr. Sledge.

  • @LandELiberation
    @LandELiberation Жыл бұрын

    Your mention of Janus and liminality got me thinking about Hekate, and how she evolved from a similar figure to Janus but evolved through association; through the underworld and contacting spirits, to witchcraft by the Roman period, perhaps an interesting topic you could explore in a future video

  • @violetchristophe
    @violetchristophe Жыл бұрын

    While listening to this, my mind couldn't shake the feeling that the work had what might called called anti-patriarchical ideas. That it means to cast aside such rigid structures that would bind folks to roles according to their bodies. The mention of gender nonconformity further reinforced this idea. In the briefest sense from the description given, though I have yet to read the text, it speaks to liberation.

  • @mohammadrahal5394
    @mohammadrahal53943 жыл бұрын

    That coincidence of opposites sounds pretty much like Taoism to me Thank you for the great work, so many delights on your channel it's amazing ! Wish you the heights 🖖

  • @TheEsotericaChannel

    @TheEsotericaChannel

    3 жыл бұрын

    Thanks so much!

  • @danielpaulson8838

    @danielpaulson8838

    3 жыл бұрын

    Good observation. I see the connection too

  • @nothanks9040
    @nothanks90403 жыл бұрын

    Probably my favorite poem; ive always found theme of androgyny in the nag hammadi super interesting and impactful

  • @Gnarlodious
    @Gnarlodious3 жыл бұрын

    "Everything you know is wrong". It has always impressed my that the writer seems devoted to refuting every assumption about ancient knowledge, every historical and philosophical graven image smashed to pieces by an outsider. Admonishing us that the canonical gods, myths and legends are either made up or embellished/corrupted beyond recognition. And the author being a woman, delicately stating that the male ego has been the corrupting influence that obfuscated the original god (goddess). The only way then to regain the lost knowledge is to free ourselves from gender norms and dualistic paradigm of the masculinized version of history. This would really bring Hellenistic/Egyptian prehistory into agreement with Germanic/Celtic goddess mythologies.

  • @TheEsotericaChannel

    @TheEsotericaChannel

    3 жыл бұрын

    It is a wonderful text in that it really gets us out of those binaries!

  • @QuasarEE

    @QuasarEE

    10 ай бұрын

    The goddess does not see herself as female, or Shariputra as male, because she has transcended limiting thinking, has transcended socio-cultural conditioning, and has even gone beyond any biological conditioning.... "All women appear in the form of women in just the same way as the elder appears in the form of a woman. While they are not women in reality, they appear in the form of women. With this in mind, the Buddha said, ‘In all things, there is neither male nor female.'" Here there is no man, there is no woman, No self, no person, and no consciousness. The labels ‘male’ or ‘female’ have no essence, But deceive the evil-minded world.

  • @stridedeck
    @stridedeck2 жыл бұрын

    Thunder Perfect Mind (intellect) is the Gnostic essence, spark, and existence! The poem is going outside the thought-making process that we use in our daily existence. This source is the source of all that breathes into all.

  • @IndelibleNihilist
    @IndelibleNihilist3 ай бұрын

    Thank you for making this!

  • @changer1285
    @changer12853 жыл бұрын

    Uggghhhh this is giving me a braingasm! Mentioning the Appcryphal acts of John, The Mandaeans, and Indic literature in one sentence! Since I started reading the Bible again and learning what I could about ancient cultures before the NT came about, and praying the Holy Rosary of the Most Blessed Virgin daily, this is the exact connection that has been made for me.

  • @TheEsotericaChannel

    @TheEsotericaChannel

    3 жыл бұрын

    Thanks for all your thoughtful comments!

  • @beroberoberoberobero852
    @beroberoberoberobero852 Жыл бұрын

    Oh that Prada Ad.... i thought it was some sort of short movie by Riddley Scott when it came out. Man, was i wrong, what a paradoxical experience was clicking that play button, never my expectations were so wrong in my life. But great video, your channel is amazing, thanks for sharing so much knowledge

  • @christopherlatini2520
    @christopherlatini25205 ай бұрын

    "But whenever you hide yourselves, I myself will appear. For whenever you appear, I myself will hide from you."

  • @notfancy2000
    @notfancy20002 жыл бұрын

    Glad I'm not the only one profoundly unsettled by the parallels between Thunder and Daughter of Fortitude and what these parallels might imply. Antinomialism as a form of mystical praxis is somewhat common (in what Kripal calls “tantras” in plural), but we can be fairly certain that neither Dee nor Kelley had access to sources, Gnostic or Hindu Tantric, from which they might have drawn inspiration. For me, more evidence that the Angelic Workings contain “true revelation” (whatever that might be) and are not, say, a literary hoax.

  • @elliotyu6573
    @elliotyu65732 жыл бұрын

    You mentioned the comparison to Indic literature already, but the paradoxical aspect of the text, especially how it affirms and denies having a trait, also reminds me of Nagarjuna's employment of the catuṣkoṭi (tetralemma) to illustrate śūnyatā (emptiness) and direct one towards the Middle Way. Funnily enough, even the title has a Buddhist feel to it, like it's translated from Sanskrit "śakrabodhicitta" or something.

  • @ohamatchhams

    @ohamatchhams

    Жыл бұрын

    The Esoteric Buddhist path is often called as "Diamond/Indestructible Lightning Bolt Vehicle"/Vajrayana, it has parallels to Flash/Fastest yet most brutal routes to Enlightenment, the first Japanese Buddhist schools and Sects developed in Japan were developing from Chinese Esoteric side of Mahayana Schools that it's either became borderline to full-fledged Vajrayana Tantric by Beliefs to practices

  • @jessicacottrell2426
    @jessicacottrell24263 жыл бұрын

    I was familiar with Thunder: Perfect Mind before but now I realize I was merely acquainted because I learned so much from this video. Thank you Dr. Sledge.

  • @TheEsotericaChannel

    @TheEsotericaChannel

    3 жыл бұрын

    Absolutely - it great for us all to learn together!

  • @bluesteel1389
    @bluesteel1389 Жыл бұрын

    This is one of the most interesting pieces of gnostic literature I've heard of. Thank you for bringing this to us!

  • @jimliedeka3978
    @jimliedeka39783 жыл бұрын

    I first heard Thunder in the Fox TV show Millennium in the 1990s. That is what originally kindled my interest in the Nag Hammadi library.

  • @TheEsotericaChannel

    @TheEsotericaChannel

    3 жыл бұрын

    Man....that was an awesome, awesome show.

  • @lh384
    @lh3842 жыл бұрын

    Not sure if you are aware, but Sue Monk Kidd's novel, The Book of Longings, uses Thunder Perfect Mind. The novel is about Jesus's wife, who after Jesus's death, joins a sort of proto-gnostic group and writes the hymn.

  • @jasonmitchell5219
    @jasonmitchell521910 ай бұрын

    What a fantastic piece of literature. I don't think I can even imagine Blake coming up with something like that and we all know he loved contraries. This poem is utterly strange, enchanting and yet deeply meaningful at the same time. I'll be re-reading it for a while even though I might require some therapy afterwards. I'd heard of it but never bothered to seek it out until watching this video. Thankyou.

  • @user-rt7wl2yg3u
    @user-rt7wl2yg3u10 ай бұрын

    man, I enjoyed this video so much. what a double horns badass theme and poem, cheers for the recommendation

  • @lucfierslight
    @lucfierslight3 жыл бұрын

    Thank you so much for bringing this poem to light. I’ve never heard of it before and to think this poet could’ve been a woman or GNC person makes me so happy. The poem seems so powerful and non-conforming - I love it.

  • @TheEsotericaChannel

    @TheEsotericaChannel

    3 жыл бұрын

    Glad you found it interesting and I'm happy that folks are discovering the text through the episode - it's such a wonderful text!

  • @lucfierslight

    @lucfierslight

    3 жыл бұрын

    @@TheEsotericaChannel - Thank you for the reply! The text really resonated with me as a queer witch. Is there anything one should be wary about when looking at the poem online or is the given translation pretty accurate?

  • @TheEsotericaChannel

    @TheEsotericaChannel

    3 жыл бұрын

    @@lucfierslight I think the typical translations online are pretty good. I prefer the Taussig, etc., translation, especially because of their attention to gender issues in the text.

  • @lucfierslight

    @lucfierslight

    3 жыл бұрын

    @@TheEsotericaChannel - Thank you for your insight! ✨

  • @lmvath211
    @lmvath211 Жыл бұрын

    Love your work. The subtle, dry, hints of humor a total plus! I’m always looking for more art historical images on each subject, and more image time to ponder.

  • @cbaci
    @cbaci2 жыл бұрын

    Couldn't the dichotomies inherent in Thunder Perfect Mind represent the dynamic tension between pairs of opposites which constitute the structure of pleroma?

  • @duantorruellas716
    @duantorruellas7163 жыл бұрын

    The divine feminine in all its glory. 👌

  • @mikewallis2987

    @mikewallis2987

    2 жыл бұрын

    More like gory

  • @milascave2
    @milascave2 Жыл бұрын

    THUNDER PERFECT PIG For I am the ham and the frozen one. The boiled one. And many are my chitlens. (Sorry. I know that putting that poem of mine here is not exactly kosher.)

  • @TheEsotericaChannel

    @TheEsotericaChannel

    Жыл бұрын

    Hilarious!

  • @williamchristensen7354
    @williamchristensen73543 жыл бұрын

    Thank you for the presentation and for the link! I appreciate it!

  • @kentschroer8208
    @kentschroer82083 жыл бұрын

    Thank for your videos! They have been of particular interest to me as write my Greek epic, adding flavors from various esoteric/occult influences.

  • @BlyssBliss
    @BlyssBliss3 жыл бұрын

    Loved this video - thank you! I recently came across your channel via Angela Puca. The seeming contradictions in Thunder made me think of a paper I came across last year by Gregory Shaw called 'Taking the Shape of the Gods: A Theurgic Reading of Hermetic Rebirth'. He talks about the dualist vs monist points of view in the Hermetica and speculates that it relates to the path of initiation. It made me wonder if the play of opposites in Thunder was a different expression of that same dynamic in the larger body of work that it was found with. I'm not an academic so I may be way off base - just wonderin'.

  • @rrrosecarbinela
    @rrrosecarbinela3 жыл бұрын

    Thank you, Doctor. May you find blessing.

  • @jbaquinones
    @jbaquinones3 жыл бұрын

    Very interesting. Happy New Year Dr Sledge.

  • @Rakkoma6
    @Rakkoma6 Жыл бұрын

    Deeply appreciate your videos on Gnosticism; it’s hard to find genuinely good and educational content on the subject. Thank you ♥️

  • @IndelibleNihilist
    @IndelibleNihilist3 ай бұрын

    wow you did a video on this! i love this writing more than anything. joined your Patreon - thank you 🙏

  • @paulshaddix5290
    @paulshaddix52903 жыл бұрын

    never ending excellence...thank you oh wise one..... thank you for a mind expanding lecture without strangeness or deviance...

  • @TheEsotericaChannel

    @TheEsotericaChannel

    3 жыл бұрын

    Thanks so much Paul!

  • @williammartinactor
    @williammartinactor4 ай бұрын

    Fascinating exegesis. Thankyou Dr. Sledge!

  • @esmeodoherty8209
    @esmeodoherty82092 ай бұрын

    Looking for part 2 of this. I just found your channel and have watched so many videos, I am assuming that as its a month old there is no part 2 yet. I am intrigued. Anyways thanks for being here very interesting and educational

  • @lauriel8735
    @lauriel8735 Жыл бұрын

    I searched for the The Pistis Sophia and found this that I really enjoyed, and I have heard you mention The Pistis Sophia but was wondering if you have done a whole segment on this writing? Thank you for bringing light to these lost scrolls.

  • @artkoenig9434
    @artkoenig9434 Жыл бұрын

    A very astute use of the Fayum mummy portraits. Thank you, sir!

  • @marquisstarks9471
    @marquisstarks9471 Жыл бұрын

    Great video Dr. Sledge. I especially appreciated the singing theory.

  • @FrJWF
    @FrJWF Жыл бұрын

    In Ephesians 4:6, Paul makes and off-hand comment about God as "above and through and in all things." Thunder Perfect Mind strikes me as an early Christian riff on this idea. It was widespread in pre-orthodox Christianity, with copies circulating in Egypt, Syria, and (at least via Irenaeus) Gaul.

  • @kevanhubbard9673
    @kevanhubbard96733 жыл бұрын

    A fine series and much to think about.

  • @wowhamba
    @wowhamba3 жыл бұрын

    I love your videos! I've gained so much knowledge from your efforts. Keep up the amazing work.

  • @TheEsotericaChannel

    @TheEsotericaChannel

    3 жыл бұрын

    Thanks for saying so - I'm happy you find the content worthwhile!

  • @madmaxrockatansky
    @madmaxrockatansky3 жыл бұрын

    Your channel is a real gem!

  • @TheEsotericaChannel

    @TheEsotericaChannel

    3 жыл бұрын

    Thanks for saying so - hope you find the content rewarding!

  • @K_F_fox
    @K_F_fox6 ай бұрын

    Also an uncanny parallel: Walt Whitman's "I Sing the Body Electric"

  • @veenorbury1429
    @veenorbury14293 жыл бұрын

    Thank you for the video, it definitely makes me want to go and learn more about this text!

  • @TheEsotericaChannel

    @TheEsotericaChannel

    3 жыл бұрын

    Awesome! Thanks for watching!

  • @lailajamilasmith
    @lailajamilasmith3 жыл бұрын

    I love your channel. You're amazing. Thank you so much.

  • @TheEsotericaChannel

    @TheEsotericaChannel

    3 жыл бұрын

    Thank you so much!

  • @ArachneAnathema
    @ArachneAnathema7 ай бұрын

    Ah, this thunder perfect mind. Sorry, still finding your earlier videos. So much to catch up on.

  • @AethyrPrime
    @AethyrPrime Жыл бұрын

    Wow this series on Gnosticism is fantastic! I have been looking for a good source for this topic on KZread for ages.

  • @HMMM13670

    @HMMM13670

    6 ай бұрын

    This is a wonderful series, no doubt! If you’re looking for something even more in depth and specific, Professor David Brakke has a course available on The Great Courses that’ll blow your mind. It’s called something like Gnosticism: From Nag Hammadi to the Gospel of Judas. It’s the best education in Gnosticism available, imo. Check it out!!

  • @sagesherbalapothecary
    @sagesherbalapothecary Жыл бұрын

    Wow! This was super helpful.

  • @Velvet_Intrigue
    @Velvet_Intrigue3 жыл бұрын

    I love this channel! Would you consider doing an exploration of the beliefs of classical gnostics and the Manicheans?

  • @TheEsotericaChannel

    @TheEsotericaChannel

    3 жыл бұрын

    Yep, done a few episodes on the gnostics and mani will get his day as well!

  • @ConanDuke
    @ConanDuke2 жыл бұрын

    The experience of gnosis is a transcendence of paradox.

  • @CamiloGaetePuga
    @CamiloGaetePuga2 жыл бұрын

    Awesome video as usual Dr. Sledge. I wonder if you have read Lamb Lash's NOT IN HIS IMAGE, and if you can share any thoughts on his rendition of Gnosticism. Thank you so much!

  • @joekennedy5110
    @joekennedy51103 жыл бұрын

    Great Nag Hammadi business

  • @TheEsotericaChannel

    @TheEsotericaChannel

    3 жыл бұрын

    Thanks!

  • @joekennedy5110

    @joekennedy5110

    3 жыл бұрын

    @@TheEsotericaChannel Thanks for the awesome content :)

  • @asteroxfoundation
    @asteroxfoundation3 жыл бұрын

    Again, another well done scholarly presentation by Dr. Sledge.

  • @FraktalPriest

    @FraktalPriest

    3 жыл бұрын

    Like ur logo, made me go to ur website. Well done.

  • @asteroxfoundation

    @asteroxfoundation

    3 жыл бұрын

    @@FraktalPriest Thank you Elios. It is a symbol that kept appearing in my mind after some mystical experiences that I encountered from over three decades ago.

  • @livinginparallel
    @livinginparallel11 ай бұрын

    Thanks so much for putting together this playlist, you have no idea how helpful this is (er, you probably do, actually..)

  • @pauliedibbs9028
    @pauliedibbs90282 жыл бұрын

    This is the first I have ever heard of - or about - this amazingly enigmatic piece of artistic literature. Thank you 🙂 P.S. you just can't seem to escape the shenanigans of those dastardly hellions, Dr. Dee and Mr. Kelly...

  • @BlaineToole
    @BlaineToole11 ай бұрын

    I think the fairest way to frame it is as a poem about the nature of The Divine Femine in Patriarchal Society, and in one's own life. It's a challenging piece because you're meant to find your own interpretation of it. Because while the answers to most things are simple, they usually aren't easy.

  • @Infinitesimal-ho7it
    @Infinitesimal-ho7it7 ай бұрын

    I've got to get my hands on Thunder. I think it could inform a novel I'm working on . Just, wow!

  • @jasonyalove13
    @jasonyalove13 Жыл бұрын

    Thank you! The Prada commercial was fun =^..^=

  • @jessiross84
    @jessiross843 жыл бұрын

    You're the BEST!!!

  • @michaeldantepoet9863
    @michaeldantepoet98633 жыл бұрын

    The Sons of Thunder were Jesus' inner disciples, James the Great and John - Disciple of Love. The first man was said to martyred in 44 AD. Nevertheless, maybe this poem was written as an elegy for one of those men. James was the 'first' disciple of the twelve. It seems that these two men were called Sons of Thunder by Christ because of their impetuous natures. However, later literature says that James was 'level-headed' and John was 'loving' - we see, therefore, a spiritual transformation in the two men from angry, uncouth individuals into harmonious human beings. The poem sounds to me like the Shekinah or the Holy Spirit addressing the audience - she is the very spirit of Consciousness itself; henceforth, she contains, reconciles and transcends all opposites in the mind because she is the 'perfect mind.' Just in the same way as a Protestant Priest may feel uncomfortable throwing away a book about Catholic mystics, perhaps, this document was stored away respectfully. If it refers to the Sons of Thunder then this poem would have already been three hundred years old by the fourth century. Perhaps, this text was somewhat out of date by the time it was catalogued and hidden. On another level, thunder seems to represent enlightenment. Thunder may signify the sound of the Holy Spirit talking to the individual after their ego has been struck by the thunderbolt of Gnosis. Flowing light and flowing sound may connote the visible and invisible counterparts of the Logos. Just as there is a baptism of water and fire, perhaps, these baptisms are alluded to in the image of the sky (watery firmament) and the fire which lights up that sky through the implication of thunder. The sound of thunder shakes the heavenly mind with its sudden realisation as expressed through its feminine (loving and accepting voice), whilst at other times, the voice appears masculine or gender non-specific. This relates either to the life-force with created the body i.e. you maybe male but the intelligence which created it is not. In any case, this thunderous and perfected mind is the awareness which identifies or does not identify with the contents of its mind.... Just a few thoughts on the subject. Thunder is not mentioned in the text itself this is why I thought it may refer to a person who carried that title... What do you think? Is this idea just a longshot? As always, WONDERFUL, WONDERFUL CHANNEL....! Well done on such a magnificent set of lectures, you deliver them with such eloquence. Brilliant!!!!!!! :)

  • @promiscuous5761
    @promiscuous5761 Жыл бұрын

    Thank you.

  • @danielpaulson8838
    @danielpaulson88383 жыл бұрын

    Amazon has the hardcover currently available for 104.38. Out of stock, but price holds and won’t charge till shipped. Paperback is 99.99. Ouch

  • @mickswann357
    @mickswann3573 жыл бұрын

    Do you think the curious preformance/audience aspects of TPM might suggest that it was either adapted from, (or alternatively adapted to resemble) a text from one of the mystery traditions?

  • @TheEsotericaChannel

    @TheEsotericaChannel

    3 жыл бұрын

    It's possible but given the difference in cultural context I would look for more indigenous Egyptian influences.

  • @ktkatte6791
    @ktkatte67912 жыл бұрын

    I have thoughts about the inversion stuff seen here and in other texts... it's attempts to convey things that we have the precise language for, to describe now, but didn't exist back then...

  • @PapaYo4XXX
    @PapaYo4XXX3 жыл бұрын

    Sorry I've been so absent, life and all, Amazing job as always bro!

  • @TheEsotericaChannel

    @TheEsotericaChannel

    3 жыл бұрын

    I feel you friend, hope you are doing well and good to hear from you!

  • @eb6510
    @eb65108 ай бұрын

    As a trans person, "I am the utterance of my name" is one of the most powerful things I've ever read, thanks for introducing this wonderful work to me.

  • @ariasarcana3142

    @ariasarcana3142

    8 ай бұрын

    Same here! Aria signing in!

  • @artemismoonbow2475

    @artemismoonbow2475

    7 ай бұрын

    Me three makes a trinity. I envisage the author being a Gallae Priestess.

  • @6Haunted-Days

    @6Haunted-Days

    6 ай бұрын

    As the spiritual self isn't any sex or gender or any of that....I just don't get those who not only base almost their ENTIRE personality on being trans but also the life of their soul & spirit....🫤 I can already see that in 5yrs we'll probably see all over bad tictok video that now this was FOR A FACT written by someone who's "trans" 🤣😖

  • @annikajohansson9171

    @annikajohansson9171

    6 ай бұрын

    ​@@6Haunted-DaysI'm not against homosexuality and agree that trans is a representation of the divine of both sexes. However, I have theorized that it's an unbalance of divine feminine and masculine over many lifetimes which would explain the 'genetic' factor. However, unless one undergoes deep hypnosis over a long time to make up for the unfinished business on that past life wherein they were the opposite sex...they are at a loss. So they embrace the duality of the Devine as a trans.

  • @jacquiecotillard9699

    @jacquiecotillard9699

    4 ай бұрын

    Likewise here- peace be with us each, and flowers on the air.

  • @t9h3m
    @t9h3m3 жыл бұрын

    Thank you for the video, what a great way to start the year! One thing I'm not entirely clear about - at one point, you seem to discuss the identity of the author as if Thunder really was really meant to be read "literally" (i.e. the author talking about themselves) - I understand there may be little reason *not* to do so, but were contemporary texts generally written like that? Or is that simply one of the possible interpretations (given the surrounding mystery)? Oh and, at 4:39 you say a word that I hear as "eratology" (?), and even the KZread transcript seems to agree, but I cannot find this word anywhere, my search queries instead return "erotologies" and "teratology" - what is that? :)

  • @TheEsotericaChannel

    @TheEsotericaChannel

    3 жыл бұрын

    Aretology - sorry! Should have put that word on the screen!

  • @lucfierslight

    @lucfierslight

    3 жыл бұрын

    Thank you for asking because I also use CC and I know KZread isn’t the best at that.

  • @FraktalPriest

    @FraktalPriest

    3 жыл бұрын

    @@TheEsotericaChannel Yes that is a word I didn't know and that would be helpful for a description or an explanation first/after. I too couldn't hear what it was or truly meant... The fact is that you are so good at explaining things I really notice when I don't understand something - Keep up the *a m a z i n g* work!

  • @user-pv6lm1ik6t
    @user-pv6lm1ik6t2 жыл бұрын

    I think I read it wean I did my paper on Gnosticism cool very interesting video

  • @SKP-op4vd
    @SKP-op4vd2 жыл бұрын

    "Thunder perfect mind" sounds almost like the title of some Vajrayana Buddhist terma text.

  • @danielpaulson8838
    @danielpaulson88383 жыл бұрын

    IMHO. Metaphoric representations. Try seeing the female as your soul. (Or subconscious mind) It retains our memories of experiences and the current emotion attached to the experiences. The good and the bad. We are the paradox. I mean each of us contains the paradox to various degrees. It’s a poem about normal human life. A very unpopular lesson that few like, encapsulated in a complex poem enjoyed and shared by the masses. The nested teaching gains the widest possible dissemination in a carrier shell. I believe it has deep personal significance.

  • @Gaia369
    @Gaia369 Жыл бұрын

    I am the utterance of my Name.

  • @TheEsotericaChannel

    @TheEsotericaChannel

    Жыл бұрын

    I am the comment and the reply

  • @Gaia369

    @Gaia369

    Жыл бұрын

    @@TheEsotericaChannel I am Sofia. Now Sacred times have Come. 👁️

  • @elusuariosecreto2458
    @elusuariosecreto24583 жыл бұрын

    I know that pic you chose for the Channel. It's from the Necromancers manual about a ring that can make the dead seem alive and the living seem dead. As a fun fact I did the ritual with some changes lol.

  • @inma5665

    @inma5665

    3 жыл бұрын

    wow, which necromancer manual?

  • @Tarnbar

    @Tarnbar

    2 жыл бұрын

    How did the ritual turn out?

  • @elainedaprano9130
    @elainedaprano91302 жыл бұрын

    Is the Gnostic Adam&Eve story the same one as in "The Forgotten Books of Eden"/ Pseudopigrapha?

  • @claires4869
    @claires48692 жыл бұрын

    do you see any connection between the narrator of thunder and the daughter or fortitude monologue delivered by babalon in dee and kelley’s work? the tone and themes seem very similar to me

  • @TheEsotericaChannel

    @TheEsotericaChannel

    2 жыл бұрын

    She's not called Babylon there but "the daughter of fortitude" but yep, I mention as much in the episode

  • @claires4869

    @claires4869

    2 жыл бұрын

    @@TheEsotericaChannel oh yep, commented before i got to that part. thanks for another awesome video!

  • @mediocrates3416
    @mediocrates34163 жыл бұрын

    There is the meditative flash and following visions; lightening and thunder.

  • @elementalliving916
    @elementalliving9166 ай бұрын

    I feel seen, thank you.

  • @rhrh9128
    @rhrh91286 ай бұрын

    Question please?! You mentioned the word thunder within the poem and that it was a big reveal you would not spoil. I did not remember this reveal so I went back and again found no thunder word within the poem as Translated by George W. MacRae . . . . . can you redirect me to a different translation/interpretation? Thanks for the sharing ans depth you cover on your channel.

  • @FriendlyEsotericDude
    @FriendlyEsotericDude3 жыл бұрын

    Where can I find that Dee excerpt about the "Daughter of Fortitude"?

  • @TheEsotericaChannel

    @TheEsotericaChannel

    3 жыл бұрын

    "I am the daughter of Fortitude, and ravished every hour from my youth. For behold I am Understanding and science dwelleth in me; and the heavens oppress me. They cover and desire me with infinite appetite; for none that are earthly have embraced me, for I am shadowed with the Circle of the Stars and covered with the morning clouds. My feet are swifter than the winds, and my hands are sweeter than the morning dew. My garments are from the beginning, and my dwelling place is in myself. The Lion knoweth not where I walk, neither do the beast of the fields understand me. I am deflowered, yet a virgin; I sanctify and am not sanctified. Happy is he that embraceth me: for in the night season I am sweet, and in the day full of pleasure. My company is a harmony of many symbols and my lips sweeter than health itself. I am a harlot for such as ravish me, and a virgin with such as know me not. For lo, I am loved of many, and I am a lover to many; and as many as come unto me as they should do, have entertainment. Purge your streets, O ye sons of men, and wash your houses clean; make yourselves holy, and put on righteousness. Cast out your old strumpets, and burn their clothes; abstain from the company of other women that are defiled, that are sluttish, and not so handsome and beautiful as I, and then will I come and dwell amongst you: and behold, I will bring forth children unto you, and they shall be the Sons of Comfort. I will open my garments, and stand naked before you, that your love may be more enflamed toward me"

  • @FriendlyEsotericDude

    @FriendlyEsotericDude

    3 жыл бұрын

    @@TheEsotericaChannel Thank you!

  • @pragmatic

    @pragmatic

    3 жыл бұрын

    @@TheEsotericaChannel this is simply beautiful. I would be pleased if you were to add more feminist content to you channel, International Women's Day is, as always March 8th. This fragment interests me because men as then and now had many avenues of pursuing love and sex (courtesan, slave girl or common prostitute--take your pick). The text elevates the woman of Temperance/dignity as proper wife and sensual object of desire

  • @ruthanneseven

    @ruthanneseven

    2 жыл бұрын

    @@TheEsotericaChannel Invocation to Aphrodite comes to mind. Thanks for sharing. The Thunder has been my favorite for decades. Kudos for bringing it into the YTverse. I have always felt that it was meant to be read aloud. It has a Bardic/Norse riddle connection to me for some reason. Also connects with something I read in Graves 'White Goddess'. After so many books and decades of delving, it's a chore to recall where I saw what and why a certain impression arises! First time viewer. ✌

  • @spilledinfinity8652
    @spilledinfinity8652 Жыл бұрын

    i think thats the one Maria Sabina used to recite. quite the nod. and a good anthem for anyone living in post reset earth. It all is and isnt now.

  • @flowerpt
    @flowerpt10 ай бұрын

    This poem rocks! Thank you, Justin. Don't get hung up on the genders, folks - this is a treatise against binary thinking, among many other things. I am not a face side, I am not an obverse side - I am a coin.

  • @darren.mcauliffe
    @darren.mcauliffe Жыл бұрын

    That ad makes as much sense as any other ad for perfume.

  • @buciorjakub
    @buciorjakub3 жыл бұрын

    I wish this was longer

  • @TormodiR
    @TormodiR3 жыл бұрын

    Would you happen to know where the original can be found.

  • @TheEsotericaChannel

    @TheEsotericaChannel

    3 жыл бұрын

    You can find the facsimiles at a large university library - individual volumes are very expensive. The Coptic original can be found in the volume I recommended.

  • @1snakebob
    @1snakebob6 ай бұрын

    ❤❤❤❤ ty

  • @laurenelizabeth2592
    @laurenelizabeth25923 жыл бұрын

    What do you make of the translation of the Dead Sea Scrolls by John M. Allegro and his ideas about the use of mushrooms as items of worship and in the creation of cults (asexual reproduction, vision inducing properties, etc.) And his claims that the ancient texts were not translated correctly?? He was cast aside as a heretic much the same way Graham Hancock is ridiculed by historians for his claims that ancient cultures we highly developed, existed in both continent's, etc...?

  • @TheEsotericaChannel

    @TheEsotericaChannel

    3 жыл бұрын

    I think Allegro makes interesting points and there is an anti-psychedelic bias in academia. Though I find the argument for much of that circumstantial.

  • @segundoteran6687
    @segundoteran6687 Жыл бұрын

    Dr. Is it me or does it seem that there are some writing symbols in the necklace of the portraits of the women!? Please let me know!

  • @thinknewideas4131
    @thinknewideas4131 Жыл бұрын

    Hey dude, have you read "From Paul to Mark"?

  • @mediocrates3416
    @mediocrates34163 жыл бұрын

    I"ve been thinking Nag Hammadi came from India, cuz Gospel of Thomas, the Acts of Thomas (from Nag Hammadi?), and the Mar Thoma Church. Cool there's Indian phraseology in Thunder; any chance all of Nag Hammadi has Indian influence of one sort or another?

  • @sariahmarier42
    @sariahmarier42 Жыл бұрын

    I think the parallels between Thunder and other texts are uncanny because there's a common thread of "truth" behind them. In fact, the parallels which exist behind most every religious text strikes me as uncanny for this reason. I think it's quite likely that multiple individuals from different cultures over various time periods from all over the Earth have stumbled upon a reality which for most is simply too spiritual to believe and that's why we interpret it incorrectly placing emphasis on a divine being rather than the divinity which is Being itself.

  • @IrrippiOntor
    @IrrippiOntor3 ай бұрын

    Has very similar themes to Shaivism, hasn't it? Essentially also encompasses the themes of the Great Goddess and the Age Set Goddesses merged into a depersonalized totality. If you are familiar with Glorantha, very reminiscent of the Goddess Sedenya, and the phases of that Moon Goddess, in particular Gerra, grief and fall, Natha, waxing and Lesilla the full moon.

  • @serget4693
    @serget4693 Жыл бұрын

    I feel like when someone's done shrooms, thunders mind and mindless concepts make a lot of sense

  • @demianalva6803
    @demianalva68033 жыл бұрын

    Dearest Dr. Justin: Is your ESOTERICA logo, a Mayan gliph?

  • @arxsyn

    @arxsyn

    3 жыл бұрын

    Yes I was wondering the same. It's very striking and unique. Love it~!

  • @laurenelizabeth2592
    @laurenelizabeth25923 жыл бұрын

    The space between being and non being. Beginning and ending, something and nothing. Is this like a koan to focus the mind for revelation, enlightenment?

  • @TheEsotericaChannel

    @TheEsotericaChannel

    3 жыл бұрын

    I've thought about that as well thinking about the text as a kind of koan but who knows? Regadless, if the text works that way for you then koan it is!

Келесі