This is not the way Parliament should run. Democracy is defined by the people, for the people and by elected representatives of our country. Elected representatives are in Parliament to voice every citizen's need. Justice should be delivered by the Speaker in that seat. Sad this is not happening.

Dont these opposition leaders have some innovative ideas. If leaders are muted inside Parliament, they should complete their speech outside Parliament.

@santhoshbm8

3 күн бұрын

Outside the parliament the debates doesn't go in records. The parliament is meant for debate and discussions. If opposition couldn't raise their voice in parliament, then why there should be a parliament and the opposition. Every one can sit on street and complete the speech.

@asha9988

3 күн бұрын

May be Get their own Mike!

@rajeshmoza6504

3 күн бұрын

@@santhoshbm8 Yes. Utlimately power lies with the people on street and so leaders should come to street to force government to mend its ways.

Paper leak, Airport leak, Ayodhya leak.

@rajkumarmuthiapillai448

3 күн бұрын

அதை செய்தது எல்லாம் திராவிட மாடலு காரண் பங்காளிக் கட்சி தாண்டா எல்லாம் மத வெறி பிடித்த ஔரங்கசீப் டோப்பா தலயன் திப்பு சுல்தான் ஜார்ஜ் பொன்னையா தான்...‌ எல்லாம் சரிதான் ஆனால் பப்பு லால் நெஹ்ரு இத்தாலி ஓடி விடுவான்

@ash5533

3 күн бұрын

😂 leaky bjp govt

Mr Nigam should replay the oath taking in previous parliament. He would know who began this "hooliganism "

Barkha and Akash just like Rajdeep are classic devil’s advocates, I think trying to remain at the center when center is pulled to the extreme is not neutrality it’s escapism and lack of courage. A man who walked by foot from the southern tip of India to Kashmir is called lazy, and a person who does not hold a single press conference, can not show up in the parliament to give one proper answer to a question by the opposition is portrayed as the man of 18 hours of work, btw the Indian voters have moved way ahead, otherwise Rahul Gandhi would not have won both seats by more than 3 lakhs and the “Vishwaguru” by 1.5 after trailing 3 rounds

Absolutely there is no need to talk about emergency excess after half a century. This is a kind of diverting from the burning issue unproductive paving the way to waste excequer.

@VinodBandari-ps5yd

3 күн бұрын

stop remembering 1947 freedom to 😂

@SuperRAJORSHI

3 күн бұрын

lets agree to disagree!

@nv9991

3 күн бұрын

How long should Gujrath riots be referred to?

@VinodBandari-ps5yd

3 күн бұрын

@@nv9991 why nobody talks for kashmiri hindu genocide?

Speaker only made it clear that this oath is on constitution only…what is the fuss about..

@loyalhandler

3 күн бұрын

The eyes are useless when the mind is blind..praying for your recovery

@kakroonimi

3 күн бұрын

@@loyalhandler you too..get well soon

@PriyaRajan-xn6nt

3 күн бұрын

@@loyalhandler💯💯💯🔥👍👍👍👌

@vidyadharnprabhu

3 күн бұрын

😀👍👍​@@loyalhandler

@sujatagarud3162

3 күн бұрын

He said the right thing 😊

Opposition is overdoing this protest. This is all politics nothing concerning welfare of people.

@melissasaldanha1197

3 күн бұрын

What.. really.. they are overdoing it? PM hasn’t even spoken one word about it. The ruling party is avoiding the entire scam. You should have said that ruling party is not doing anything about it..

@diyar8161

3 күн бұрын

Huh. Opposition is literally acting as a voice of pple

@PriyaRajan-xn6nt

3 күн бұрын

@@diyar8161🔥👍👍💯💯💯💯

@user-rz9yh8dw4s

3 күн бұрын

​@@diyar8161I would consider the Opposition to be constructive if they had collaborated with the government to solve this problem forever. This subject concerns the future of lakhs of people. It should not be used for political gain.

@diyar8161

3 күн бұрын

@@user-rz9yh8dw4s collaboration will happen if the govt is ready to listen. When the opposition raised the concern of students regarding neet, speaker ne mic off kardiya. Leader of opposition was barely able to speak one word and then speaker ne mic off kardiya. Ab opposition ko bolne ka chance nahi doge to constructive kaise hoga. U should know that only when opposition is able to put pressure on govt through parliamentary discussion will govt be forced to take appropriate actions . Jab opposition ka awaaz hi band kar diya jayega to students keliye kon bolega

Does this man in the chair have an original certificate? Is he pretending to be deaf to the cries of Jai Ram.? What a shameful display?

The only job some people think they have is to light fire works. Does that work in constructive democracy?

26:00 From which date leader of opposition is constitutional post Mr. Literate .. As expected Friend of Dhruv Rathee

Internal Emergency in Parliament!

This might be the only election results after which all political parties are in happy and enthusiastic mood and showing off their childlike euphoria during oath taking ceremony 😂

Reservation must not be caste based for there are innumerable upper caste people who are poor, rather it should be based strictly on level of wealth, and it should not carry on for generations or for that matter beyond education. It's plainly destroying the country.

Why so many people's representatives are acting like clowns like as if they are in circus. 😀😀

It’s good thing why call uneducated person Akashi

Unnecessary debate. Barkha, did not expect you to spend time on this topic.

The people of India has already spoken in the last election for protecting the Constitution, hence it is better to move on and talk on NEET, Jobs. Peace in Manipur, Overall development of both rural and urban area etc....

The Speaker treatment is disrespectful to the MP. He is not a child...should not say sit down by waving his left hand

I also think congress should over play on constitution. This will give chance to BJP to bring how many times Congress played with it

@kirovmedia6972

3 күн бұрын

How many times you pimp?

Literate Mr. Banerjee should have known that Leader of Opposition is not a constitutional post, rather its a statutory post .

Speaker was a bit arrogant in ordering opposition members to sit down forgetting that the opposition MPs are also elected representatives like him. Ideally Speaker should not take sides and be unbiased. Whether it's ruling party or opposition party members, neutrality should be the mantra. Opposition as Mr Akash mentioned should start raising issues of national interest instead of wasting time discussing about Constitution only.

The guy with the bharat on his t shirt was smart

In the parliament, the whole ruling party was chanting PM , PM, PM ......., is it right?? Is the speaker saying anything about that. Each student in a class says, "Good morning, teacher, required to say only once in academic year.

next time she is gonna bring Dhruv rathee on the program. Indias PM in 2050: Dhruv Rathee

Mojo story is this how you observe the parliamentary proceedings? 😂 RG took oath in presence of pro-tem speaker whilst Dr ST took oath when Birla was present ..

After pseudo secularism now we have pseudo constitutional supporters with selective support and now this is now being extended like chewing gum- Opposition has to focus on constructive aspect of opposing and not just resort to drama

The whole debate on Shashi Tharoor being remarked with a seemingly casual comment by the Speaker is really a waste of time. I heard some of the stupidest comments from the likes of Mr Hegde, who also in a way objected to Mr Shantanu’s mention of Emergency by ridiculing him by action of a ‘namaskaar’. Had anyone held a debate against Mr Owaisi pronouncing ‘Jai Palestine’ surely would have been branded ‘communal’ by giving some silliest, but sounding convincing to some, of arguments.

You should be talking about the objectionable oath taken by Assaduddin's Jai palestain

Hegde was not hinting at congress he was at hinting at bjp only

I would like see a similar heated debate on “Jai Palestine”

@kirovmedia6972

3 күн бұрын

What about hindu rashtra?

@drmonabansal

3 күн бұрын

Sure any debate that concerns India. Why allegiance to Palestine 🤷🏽‍♀️

राहुल का नाम गांधी नही होता तो ये आज कहा होता क्या करा राहा होता ये बताओ

khangress led opposition is s big curse on bharats essence ( sanatan dharma)😢

Great discussion Barkha as much as i disagree with Akash and Sanjay but the discussion was in a very good flow. Looking for more such discussion

Was the Speaker in chair when all others were taking oath or was it the Protem Speaker ?

Forget about slogan this same congress use to dissolve the entire government and put the people behind the bar. And opposition having only 2 MPs of BJP use to fight.

Talk, talk, talk and just more talk. Is anybody going to initiate action against anybody for saying anything disrespectful?😮

If ragas mic is muted, what will be about mic of others, just think even in case of students. Cant imagine if this much victory was not there for opposition.are they getting upset on hearing samvidhan why?

Commenting about T Shirts on and Krta's shows the arrogance of current regime. If this continues people will teach lesson one after another

The fundamental take away from all this perhaps is that more and more people of India should actually purchase the red book and read the Constitution. Perhaps after reading the Sanvidhan people will stop raising a hell about Sanvidhan.

Mr nigaam & other stooges of Congress should address jai samvidhan at their drawing room, bedroom, kitchens to 😮the people who are available & not knowing about the details &:spirit of samvidhan instead of wasting public money at the parliament.

Professional Politics is the need of the times. REST IS WASTE OF TIME

Parliament is not a circus. Respect and honour should be restored. Opposition is acting like a den of hooligans.

@rekhakumar1441

Күн бұрын

Voice of the opposition is the voice of the people.

I find it hard to believe that speaker of loksabha behaving like BJP spoke person, what a shame n what's wrong in saying jai sambidhaan n barkha please don't become BJP dalaal.

Welcome Barkha. M yr fan from meghalaya. This is MODI KI GUARANTEE. jokes apart...

Ridiculous ending!! If facts doesn’t matter then why this panel discussion?? Pick up any falsehoods, gather few people who are happy to propagate it and be happy in that bubble. How would this debate be any different than WhatsApp university??

Mr Hegde you reslly think that they want Manusmriti to be the constitution? most ridiculous comment i have heard

Jai Palestine was nonsense in India

Rahul should be muted..he doesn’t know when to speak

I too feel that The speaker, should have responded by saying "Jai Samvidhan" and not make such an issue by blah blah blah to aggravate the whole issue. He seems to be a trouble naker,by making such statements, asking them BAIT JAO..made him look very cheap.😡

@paulhigginssuting4618

3 күн бұрын

Very TRUE. the word BAIT JAO means the Indian speaker is a very cheap cheap person. It shows that the speaker doesn't respect the constitution written by someone who is not a bramin

Why 2 BJP spokespersons Barkha?

This video is like a work of art, carefully crafted with love and passion.

Shame against who ever has done it

Given a chance Barkha Dutt will turn the narrative against BJP

Extremely unbalanced pannel

Constitution is a sacred agreement between, people of india and government for which vote is given.

Jai Samvidhan

Shantanu, one wrong does not justify another.

संसद के बाहर जनता को बताएं कैसे राष्ट्र विरोधी सरकार लोकतंत्र का गला घोंटती है माइक-वीडयो बंद कर जब विपक्ष ज्वलंत राष्ट्रीय मुद्दे उठाता है काले कानूनों पर निरंतर श्रंखला बनाइए जो आम लोग समझ सकें कि कहां ह्रास-हनन हो रहा है मानव-नागरिक मूल अधिकारों का

Barka make shows which will BENEFIT POORER PEOPLE UNEMPLOYED YOUTHS OF INDIA PRICE RISE ETC ETC!!!!! NOT ON SILLY THING'S SOMEONE SAID THIS N SPEAKER SAID THAT WHAT A SHAME FOR MEDIA OF INDIA

Even if I don’t like what is being said sometimes, I like Barkha’s debates

These debates are hopeless and off track

Why should anybody listen to counter against constitution, Barkha ? What is your intent?

this Guy Banerjee is the biggest godi you tuber 😄and they have the gumpshum to call others as godi

Where is your constant fixture, Tavleen Singh

5 congress vs 2 bjp. Barkha as always the panel not balanced

Christ, who is this guy, Akash.... Barkha introduced him as an ex-journalist.... seriously...thank God he is no longer in the profession....he has no logic...sounding so incoherent...

BJP guy also honest, the congress is just trying it on

Sanjay Hegde making some arguments - not high on intellect

Correct pronunciation of Adityanath is as in Aaaditya

Title of the video is different then the debate discussion...😮

The freak control is palpable ..this is what happens with weak opp and complacency!!

Jai Shantanu.....he was the only one who was talking sense!

@pp47-04

3 күн бұрын

Only an Andhbhakt will say that. Do continue with it. Good luck!

Modi's "infrastructure" revolution

Barkha very biased today and showed your inclination is on which side.................

He dint say anything to Rahul

Baba talks nonsense all the time. Speaker did well to shut up the guy by muting him.

Barkha Dhut take separate debate to NDA and Oposition.

Too clever these congress guys

The pakistani woman returns with indi

This particular airport roof was constructed in 2009, Shut up banerjee

💯💯💯agree with Deshbakht(Akash Bannerjee), Adv Khadial & Adv Hegde ….there is a need to say Jai Samidhan now more than ever ……Given everything that has happened over the last 10 yrs 🔥🔥🔥

@samarendranathmaiti1091

3 күн бұрын

Try at your home & at your work place. Say jai samvidhan one lkh times to your family members. No body bothers. But it bothers me when you make fun of sambidhaan for simply vote bank politics. I am sure one day it will back fire because you can not fool our gullible voters all the times. Get ready for that. Till then keep doing funs about samvidhan.

@deec2564

3 күн бұрын

What the F is samvidhan . Its a man made documents and after 70 years surley needs to change with time . IG changed it to include secular and socialist . Then others can also change when needed . Ambedkar was not god that he got it correct . he was a failed politician . Just being glirified when he is not there . Its modi for next 5 years , so save your breath

@nissinlilbabybeandoc1285

2 күн бұрын

what has happened in last 10 yrs

Barkha has clear Congress leaning

Pm mute mode on manipur.

People's pointing,During those days,skeptics are contains by maintaining RAJA DHARMA on ruling by emperor.., now! it contains cinematic dharma, in name of rhetoric lies nd hypocrisy.., people's resounding voices, that implanting skeptical on Parliament is irrelevance on democracy, in name of skeptical..,likely, we're running nation under people's democracy, here! Where those sengol is necessary.., whomever retaining power, he was controlled under chair, enjoying power by constitutionally.., therefore, it's a myth of butchering the democracy..,

Should also juxatapose on jais said in last parliament

We all saw how Rahul Gandhi was not allowing parliament to move ahead..

@pp47-04

3 күн бұрын

Exactly the opposite!

@gulistanden580

3 күн бұрын

He was not allowed to speak.😢

@noneoftheabove666

3 күн бұрын

That's the exact reason why he is in the Parliament, that's why they get their funding

@kakroonimi

3 күн бұрын

@@gulistanden580 parliament has a protocol…I think everyone knows that..???when to speak..

What about the emergency

Akash is a snake Always trying to be neutral but this man is always bringing Rahul down Get A Life and besides Rahul is not PM and just voted for he can't control and takecare and mention every single thing that happens daily in the Country (All which Modi is responsible for) Cut Rahul some slack

What does "samvidhan" mean? Please translate

But will loose in the long run

people's talk, Across on nation, it's difficult to see congee media's, instead of predicting sangi media's..,where's, they are engaged on social media's, because of main stream intranspetancy..,

Why did these people not have a problem with Jai Palestine

Barkha is correct

Mojo 2 detox self of Presumed principalship of elitism built in Varnashrm; Negated by The Samvidhan 4 V The CITIZEN of INDIA*

Aakash Bannergy and Sanjay Hegde should be introduced as anti BJP spokes person

mojo is my dog's name . he's very cute and naughty

There will be no peace until unless BJP,s alive in India.

@VinodBandari-ps5yd

3 күн бұрын

where there is no peace in Pakistan vis a vis middle east?

@nissinlilbabybeandoc1285

2 күн бұрын

I think these people are the biggest dictator want BJP to die so much hate for a hindu party

Barkha, Same perception about akash & you. All narratives initiated by you modi haters will always be taken with bit of salt.

Rahul muted the Mike n he muted his voice deliberately n blame the speaker of the house😊