The plaintiff was dead wrong for having her boyfriend there so much. She seems spoiled and entitled.

@cassandramae85

3 ай бұрын

💯

@msfranklin2650

3 ай бұрын

SO THE DEFENDANT SAID. SHE'S JUST JEALOUS & ENVIOUS OF THE PLAINTIFF BECAUSE HER FATHER PAYS HER EXPENSES & SHE HAS TO WK ALLL THOSE HRS

@mahalasincere

3 ай бұрын

Especially in a one bedroom house with a dog …

@PeopleRTheProblem

3 ай бұрын

@@msfranklin2650why are you screaming?

@izealliaeldridge1441

3 ай бұрын

⁠@@msfranklin2650 I’d be uncomfortable AND uneasy with my roommates man in my intimate space where I sleep. The daughter should have asked her dad to pay for a hotel a couple of nights so she could enjoy privacy with her bf. It’s about decency and comfortability.

Almost 1,000$ to share a room with someone is insane

@layal3018

4 ай бұрын

with 2

@alyssakaye9329

4 ай бұрын

@@layal3018 I misunderstood your comment at first lol, and yeah especially paying 1,000$ to have to sleep in a bedroom with a couple is extra insane.

@martinboyle9163

4 ай бұрын

Yeah, either the boyfriend needs to pony up or they need to have an OnlyFans page or something. Sharing a room? The room is too crowded already with a dog to have to deal with a boyfriend on any night! That's crazy! 😮

@alyssakaye9329

4 ай бұрын

@@martinboyle9163 oh yeah we can’t forget the dog as well! And it’s a puppy at that!! Yeah there’s just no way. You can get a 2 bedroom apartment here for 900$ a month.

@lenc3970

4 ай бұрын

@@martinboyle9163only a perv like you would mention OnlyFans 😂

Am I just old fashioned. As a parent, if I’m paying for school, I’m not paying rent so that you can live with your boyfriend at age 19.

@wileecoyote5749

3 ай бұрын

She getting pounded

@MrCharlesEldredge

3 ай бұрын

So right!

@projectionv.accountability1010

3 ай бұрын

Exactly!

@jennross6466

3 ай бұрын

I'm with you. Plus daddy was paying all her expenses which is gross because she will never learn responsibility when she has dad to fall back on.

@madi4481

2 ай бұрын

@@jennross6466 Somebody's dad doing their job by paying their student daughter's expenses is "gross"!? Bitter much because your daddy was a deadbeat...

If I'm sharing a room with someone, I would NOT be okay with their significant other spending the night all the time! That's so awkward and creepy!

@trwent

2 ай бұрын

Well if there were separate bedrooms, that would be one thing, perhaps. But all three of them sleeping in the same bedroom?

I don't understand why the boyfriend stayed with her, if he had his own place, why didn't she stay with him? I don't think I would want to be in a bed, in the same room, right next to two people doing things...

@Shellygrrl2573

4 ай бұрын

Sorry but that plaintiff is a liar. She knows that guy was there ALL the time, eating the food and showering. And for her to be in there doing stuff with the defendant having to listen to it in a one-bedroom, instead of just going to his place that he had is just gross. How is that not constructively evicting the defendant? It's no coincidence he now moved in because he was already living there.

@aprilpinketon2567

4 ай бұрын

Agree with you both! She complained in February agreed to stay until May and gave plenty of notice about her issue with the bf being there. If you want to shack up with your man have him pay half.

@ChasRiaStJohn

4 ай бұрын

She seems very bossy or controlling. The way she signaled to her dad when they were first walking in….like she was either telling him hurry up, go first, or open the door for me. But she’s young. I think she’ll look back and regret her actions. She’s a neat freak now, just wait till she has kids.

@ima4366

3 ай бұрын

The boyfriend is a typical bum, he couldn't even support her in Court.

@JamieM470

3 ай бұрын

@@Shellygrrl2573 I agree. Also, it's crazy to me that the plaintiff's father is proud of his daughter and supportive in every way--including paying her rent so she could play house with her current boyfriend. I know I'm a dinosaur, but back in my day a woman's virtue meant something, and a daughter whose virtue was so worthless that she gave it away for free would be a source of great shame and parenting failure.

I feel for the defendant. A college student working 70 hours a week is insane. The claimant didn’t have to work, got to relax and couldn’t have her boyfriend over when the defendant was at work they wanted to invade her space when she was tired.

I think the defendant just felt bad about saying anything about the bf. When plaintiff started bitching about the cleaning, that's when defendant said enough. Everyone knows the bf moved in, immediately.

@Nevaeh1

3 ай бұрын

It sounds like the defendant had a lot of resentment towards the plaintiff. She was working 13 hours a day and receiving texts about dishes in the sink from someone who didn't work as much as her because they had a father to pay their bills. She wanted her friend to be more considerate that after a 13-hour shift and school, she only wanted to rest and not see her boyfriend.

@Bastion70

3 ай бұрын

@@Nevaeh1 the boyfriend also seems to be the defendants ex boyfriend.

@jennross6466

3 ай бұрын

@@Nevaeh1 I bet part of those dirty dishes belonged to the boyfriend.

Why would you have a boyfriend over on a one bedroom smh that’s silly

@AriesHeat-xq5pp

4 ай бұрын

At the end why the dad tried to touch his daughter's behind? I seen that 😮

@demarioda1

3 ай бұрын

When I was in college kids did this all the time. I never understood how you get your freak on with someone 2 feet away.

@AriesHeat-xq5pp

3 ай бұрын

@@demarioda1 I couldn't do that & I'm 33 yrs old. I'd like to be in a private special place with my lover

@HiddenAgendas

3 ай бұрын

3 somes

If I may... those drama queens, paying $910 each to share a one bedroom... should NEVER hae gotten a dog.

@elainevankat5353

4 ай бұрын

Exactly…. Such a ridiculous idea (poor dog!)

@davidperez5089

4 ай бұрын

Real rational thinking! Women are known for that!!😂

@16MedicRN

3 ай бұрын

​@@davidperez5089lol, as a woman I concur 😂

@thesingingdiamond_

3 ай бұрын

​@davidperez5089 I believe the defendant said the plaintiff's uncle paid for the dog and accompanied them while getting it. I guess you meant to say both men and women aren't very rational. 😂 Don't be ignorant. These poor choices have nothing to do with gender. 🤦🏾‍♀️

@matthewestrada5217

3 ай бұрын

​@@thesingingdiamond_ Exactly it's genetics not genitals

If the boyfriend was there most of the time, she shouldn't have had to pay all of it. Maybe a third.

@manuelsoares9698

3 ай бұрын

Not mandatory since his name isn't on the lease. The plaintiff most likely blind sided the defendant with the good ole "surprise boyfriend"... As good friends, they could've all gotten together and come up with a new payment plan but they are not legally obliged to do so.

@LOADING...o.o.o

9 күн бұрын

@@manuelsoares9698 Ya. In the future, if the roommate brings a bf more than 2 night a week, the second week there should be a conversation about it. I would have a talk or text to the roommate saying you aren't okay paying for additional person living there.

"only 2 times a week " well thats almost 1/3 of the month if she was honest the plaintiff is disgusting

@Amy-ej2px

3 ай бұрын

Two times a wk is still too much. One time a wk is too much. I don't want to hear that. Go to his room or a hotel or someplace else.

I'm sorry, but even in this day and age, having your father sit there and listen to you talk about your sex life had to be awkward.

@lukerinderknecht2982

4 ай бұрын

Dad goes to touch her butt at 12:48, so...

@16MedicRN

3 ай бұрын

​@@lukerinderknecht2982Gross

@scooneil

3 ай бұрын

Had to laugh at the Judge, too. The dad sitting right there-- "You KNOW what I'm asking you, right?" *Insert "how often did you and the BF bump uglies in the apartment" face.*

@MrCharlesEldredge

3 ай бұрын

Except these young people are taught that shame is wrong. Not that sin is wrong. So no shame.

@jennross6466

3 ай бұрын

@@lukerinderknecht2982 I doubt it was in a lascivious way.

2:04 $910 EACH?! To share one bedroom?! Holy..

@xExplosionsofAwesome

4 ай бұрын

That is dirt cheap for the area. Like dirt dirt cheap.

@Tuturu708

3 ай бұрын

@@xExplosionsofAwesomethe show was filmed many years ago. Today it would probably be closer to $1600 each to share a bedroom.

@valerielove8388

2 ай бұрын

IKR!!! 😮That's rent for a 3 bedroom home here in Sacramento California!😂

@trwent

2 ай бұрын

It ain’t North Dakota, that is for sure.

The plaintiff is totally passive/ aggress🤨

Judge Judy would’ve made the boyfriend pay 1/3 of the rent. The defendant had texts messages proving he was there several days a week.

Sharing a 1 bedroom for over 1k a month is ridiculous and on top of that if her BF had his own place, why was he there at all??

@theonlyairconditioner

3 ай бұрын

Because that's what ppl do when they are dating. I'm surprised at how many ppl in these comments don't seem to realize or know this.

@thatONE____

3 ай бұрын

​@@theonlyairconditioner there is another roommate that you have to consider in this case...in a 1 BEDROOM. I'm pretty sure the bf was there more than twice a week, so he needs to be paying 1/3 of the rent. But to cut all that out, since he has a place of his own, she should have been going to his place. Better yet they should've been roommates...but seems like he was the ex bf of the defendant at one point also. Not understanding how you don't realize and know that but common sense ain't so common, so there's that 🤷🏽‍♀️

The plaintiff made the place uninhabitable once she moved the boyfriend into the one room they shared. Which was stupid AF. She should be stuck with the rent. The defendant shouldn't have to tell her she uncomfortable. Common sense judge. I wouldn't give her a dime even after the ruling.

I just don't understand why anyone would accept having someone's boyfriend stay in a place where their name is on the lease. Thank God I have always opted not having roommates. After living in a dorm I understood quickly that I am not the type of person that's quickly to tolerate nonsense from anyone. The plaintiff is your typical entitled daddy's girl who thinks it's ok to burden other people with their living style. What a piece of work. JM should have only ordered the defendant to pay for a 3rd of the rent.

@salkur3654

2 ай бұрын

That boyfriend lived there and the defendant didn't like it but she didn't want to confront the plaintiff. The judge didn't take into consideration the age of the defendant. And we all know the boyfriend moved in the day after the defendant moved out. The plaintiff and her boyfriend took advantage of that student. Not a good judgement.

$1820 for a one bedroom apartment?! Heck nah.

@anaa03899

4 ай бұрын

Welcome to Boston 😅

@TheKingAuthor

4 ай бұрын

INSANE!

@utamorgan

3 ай бұрын

​@anaa03899 especially if it's Allston/Brighton!

@anaa03899

3 ай бұрын

@@utamorgan it's insane 😳

The moral to the story is, U never know someone until u move in with them.💐

@DEAN_23

18 күн бұрын

Or work with them....

We all know the boyfriend was there more than 2 a week. Who do these children think they're fooling?

@pizzelle2

3 ай бұрын

Why would the defendant lie and minimize how often he was there if she was trying to use that as a criticism…? The defendant wants to make the plaintiff look bad…

@t_onaysiaaa

Ай бұрын

Right then talking about he has a full time job! Well he was there right after he clocked out 😂😂

I kind of disagree with the judge on this one I think the text messages of the defendant complaining about the boyfriend being there all the time in advance should have been enough either for her to get out of the lease or the boyfriend to be obligated to pay a third of the rent the defendant admitted in the hallway that her boyfriend stayed there two times a week we all know if she's willing to admit to two days a week it's probably double or triple that

This judge is no Judge Judy. That plaintiff broke the lease when her boyfriend was there everyday.

@686JM

Ай бұрын

??? They didn't go to Judge Judy, they went to The People's Court. There was no proof of Constructive Eviction, the girls had drama and instead of working it out or getting something written releasing one of them from the lease they decided to not communicate.

Boyfriend stays Boyfriend pays

i can’t explain it but the plantiff gives me the ick

@michelleMYHELL5244

4 ай бұрын

with a lisp

@KiwiGirl1

4 ай бұрын

I wish she'd learn how to tie a scarf nicely 😕

@Neenaross214

4 ай бұрын

Yes ! A young Karen with a lisp lol You can’t be snotty AND have a lisp. Pick a struggle 😂😂

@socialmediamanagement1859

20 күн бұрын

​@@Neenaross214😂😂😂

If I’m sharing a room with her… no bf sleeping there with US!

One bedroom with two twin beds is crammed as it is. This is crazy!

@mahalasincere

3 ай бұрын

And a dog 🤦🏽‍♀️

@trwent

2 ай бұрын

And a boyfriend.

Judge Millian seems to correct her litigants a lot when they are being respectful. When someone says, "Yes ma'am", she says, "Don't call me that," when someone asks, "If I may" she says, "Don't ask me that." I was raised to always be respectful and "yes ma'am" and "If I may" shows respect. Anyhoo, she's my favorite judge and I can't get enough of her episodes. She is the reason cash never leaves one hand without a receipt in the other hand ❤

Her boyfriend shouldn't have been there. Not 2 days and not 1 day. No days. Its a 1 bedroom apartment with a dog. This is a sad case of a spoiled little girl whom gets what she wants. Her Daddy even came to court and Daddy paid the rent. This poor other girl just got set back $2300.00 when at the end her roomate moved in the boyfriend.

The plaintiff should have just stayed in her boyfriend’s parent’s basement where he’ll be living until he’s 40. Playing video games. MEATLOAF!!!

I feel bad for the defendant it looks like she wanted to cry

Wait a minute. The new boyfriend she moved in and was boning IN THE ROOM SHE SHARED WITH THE ROOMMATE, was the roommate's EX?!?!?

@lifewithangelina92

4 ай бұрын

That’s where the rift started

@ohcaptainmycaptain4829

4 ай бұрын

That's what happens when you are a female, and have female friends.

@trishadenegal718

4 ай бұрын

I catch that, too

@Bebedollie

4 ай бұрын

Eww nasty lol no respect or boundaries

@user-ri7jb6xi5l

4 ай бұрын

Yesssssss!!!!! She listened and learned to do what he likes

2 times a week is a lot to be in someone else space

Two people sharing a one bedroom. What could go wrong?

@rebeccalynn5334

Ай бұрын

Three* people lol sharing 1 room

2 times a week? Sure, just like a drunk driver had only 2 beers.

Not sure judge is right, what about right to privacy and enjoyment of place of residency? Feel she was pushed out by lack of same, similar experience here.

"Where did you learn 'If I may'?" "I learned from when she had her boyfriend..." Flew right over her head ✈️ Plaintiff didn't know what "getting testy" meant. These two aren't the brightest bulbs....

@lukerinderknecht2982

4 ай бұрын

LoL yup

@madi4481

2 ай бұрын

I was confused...I thought she was explaining how she learned "I may" from her doing the nasty 😅 That makes sense now

@madi4481

2 ай бұрын

But I think the defendant knew what testy means and gave a quick smart answer by saying that's when their issues started

The plaintiff was wrong for having her bf there so often. Why would you do your friend like that knowing y’all are sharing a room.

Poor dog. I bet the dog wasn't looked after properly either

@elainevankat5353

4 ай бұрын

Exactly, obviously it was neglected… It was the stupidity of the Plaintiff’s uncle who get them a dog!🤦‍♀️

You and the boy should get your own place

the fact that she didn’t initially charge her bf for being there. why have him staying over in a shared room. bad friend

Dad looks like the poisoned dead girl’s dad from The Sixth Sense

@taylakurner

4 ай бұрын

🤣🤣 He does!

@lillady1770

4 ай бұрын

Creepy 😂😂

@curiousnarwhal

4 ай бұрын

I thought he looked like that head demon from the Good Place.

Having her boyfriend over 3 times a week is unreasonable. Twice a month, maybe.

Subletting a 1bedroom is crazy

She found a roommate. Her boyfriend. She said out of her mouth that he started paying

Plaintiff walked in. Immediatly I can tell she is spoiled and thinks she looks oh so fabulous. NO

She should have stayed till September and made a rule the boyfriend couldn't be there

A boyfriend staying over in a living situation like that is a nonstarter for any reasonable person, ...they should have opted for a hotel a few nights instead.

The dog is the real victim

That’s bs the defendant shouldn’t have to pay when the plaintiff moved her bf in as another tenant. This judge doesn’t always get it right

First, this is exactly why I would never move in with a friend/cousin or do anything with them that involves money and agreements. I know I’m a clean freak to and don’t like dealing with lazy people who don’t clean up right after themselves. Second, I would be so uncomfortable if my friend has her boyfriend sleeping in the same room as us almost every night! I would never put my friend in that awkward position to. Disrespectful and very uncomfortable. I think what the defendant was really trying to explain to the judge is that the mess was also the boyfriend since he sleeps, eats, and showers there whenever he’s over.

@cassandra6710

3 ай бұрын

Agree. I've had ex in laws stay for a short period of time. I don't mind someone having to do laundry or shower of course but it starts to get overwhelming and some take advantage. Having a roommate can be tough, I couldn't ever do it because of myself. Just how I am. Also, I agree about the boyfriend. Even if it was a friend it's just rude.

The boyfriend was trying to get over on her😂😢

Sounds as if this insane judge is siding with this plaintiff. Scolding the defendant who works 70 hours a week and goes to school.

This judge is insane. The defendant tried everything to deal with moving out. What is wrong with her.

Rent $ among friends seems to be a common problem in today's society. Be careful who you cohabitate with and split rent.

he didnt stay often 3 nights a week, i call that often princess!

Honestly, the plaintiff FORCED OUT the defendant.

First person i’ve seen lowkey eat doug up and have the last word lmaoooo

I wouldn't be sharing nothing with nobody especially a 1 bed room apartment. Smh both of them are disgusting.😷🤦

Reallllly stupid of the uncle to buy them a dog.

boyfriend staying over twice a week is way too much.

I learned something new on this one!

I own rental properties in a college town. The reason students share bedrooms is because in college towns housing is very expensive, very hard to find, students have little money, and most landlords don't like renting to college students due to no rental history, low credit scores, the fear of too much partying, and damages to the apartment. I've heard stories of two bunkbeds per room including two bunkbeds in the living room. That's 4 people per room. So, a two-bedroom apartment would have 12 people. Nowadays, most leases restrict the number of people who can live in the apartment to only those on the lease. Leases also limit the number of overnight guest(s) stays to about 24 days a year specifically to avoid students moving in other students (to further split the rent) and then "claiming" they are only visitors.

Why don’t ppl watch previous cases to know if they can win or not before coming to the show?

The judge not taking the boyfriend being over all the time seriously wasn’t fair. They share a room and the boyfriend is there too? That sounds like a constructive eviction to me.

What complex is this $1800 should be 3 rooms not 1!

Why is the plaintiff wearing that tacky winter scarf with a summer dress?

@ananabi9910

4 ай бұрын

She wants to come off as nerdy😂

ohhhh this is exhausting

Have a good week people court family . ❤❤👍🏽 Sunday clocks go forward. Dont forget. ⏰ ☀️

that’s BS, she should be obligated to pay to shack up with this girl and her boyfriend.

Get the boyfriend to pay half the rent 🤷‍♀️

Try not to roommate if possible

It must have been embarrassing for that father to be dragged to court only to find out how many times a week his daughter was getting laid lol

I guarantee when I was in college I would not have put up with a roommate having her boyfriend sleep over in our shared bedroom... or even in a 2BR for that matter.

7:16 is she saying she is boning the same boyfriend? Meaning her friend ex?😅

@eisbeinGermany

4 ай бұрын

good question,

@bluedoor4682

4 ай бұрын

That is what it sounded like to me. Hence the gasps from the audience.

Nope. The problem is one girl has money and the other does not. She can be entitled but she should not pay for it.

To exaggerate and say she worked 70 hours but then say she worked 12-13 hours Thursday to Sunday. Okay so typical salary week? 😂

@rebeccalynn5334

Ай бұрын

Pretty sure she wasn't speaking on her entire schedule. She just brought up the dog scenario because no one would be home to let the dog out when she worked the doubles on those specific days. I don't think she was exaggerating.

‘He wasn’t there that much.’ No, he was there exactly that much. That much being enough for someone NOT on the lease to cause distress to the other person ACTUALLY ON the lease. But nobody died. And the defendant is still infinitely sexier than the other one.

OK I felt no type of way about the judgment because it was correct. However, I am getting from the plaintiff that she decided to have a living situation with a friend. But then decided that her and her boyfriend wanted to basically share the apartment too. If he had his own place, why not alternate the weeks. I wouldn’t want anybody staying at my house every week. I live in one bedroom, in even a friend coming over every week sometimes I would like a little bit of peace and quiet and if it’s me and the roommate OK. But you’re inviting another person not considering the fact that this is my apartment too. The plaintiff is basically just letting her boyfriend live there for free on and off every week And making her roommate pay while she made her feel uncomfortable. Plus disgusting I would never wanted to sleep in a room where myself and my friend is having relations. With our partners.

Crazy to share a room for $1000 and have the roommate letting boyfriend sleep over. Daddy let your girl grow up. Your paying your 19 year old rent for her boyfriend to sleep over. Way entitled.

I asked my roommate, why do you never tidy up the place and he said, because you always do it.

6:08 3 days per week then anything extra is deemed as living there for tax purposes so you might as well charge rent

Lord if I have to watch that Hertz commercial with Brady every time I watch these videos I’m gonna stick a pen in my eye.

The plantiffs voice is like nails on a chalk board.

If the school session ended in May, wouldn't they both be moving out any way? Isn't that how student apartments work? I sincerely do not know.

@krystalericalewis

4 ай бұрын

No - leases are still 12 months from Aug 1st to July 31st. Then when non renewals move out on the 31st, the complex does one big turn in about 3 weeks and new move ins come like the 3rd week of August. The complex needs to do this in order to be making money year round or there would be no money coming in for the summer months. Former Student Housing PM here😊

@Criminal.Lawyer.2024

4 ай бұрын

I have rentals in a college town. The two girls were sophomores, meaning they both had two years of college remaining. In most college towns housing is so hard to find that students will often stay in the apartment until they graduate. But consider this. Let's say one is a senior and the other is a junior. The senior may move out after graduation, but the junior still has another year so she may want/need to stay until she graduates.

@juliecranford534

4 ай бұрын

I always went to summer school, too. Great way to knock out a few hours.

@zenobiachapman1636

3 ай бұрын

I don't think this was college housing but more so just a regular apt they leased for the school year. So normally a lease would be for 6 or 12 months. And they also probably didn't plan on going home for the summer.

1 bedroom for that much?! That’s a rip off.

@LOADING...o.o.o

9 күн бұрын

Come to LA. It's from 1800 to 2500.

I know how the defendant feels. My Spring semester of my freshman year of college, my constantly had her boyfriend over. He'd be there when i I woke up, and when I went to bed. I was so glad when the semester was over.

The entitlement of the defendant... "just have your dad pay my bills"

@mahalasincere

3 ай бұрын

No The entitlement of the plaintiff. To have her 2 legged dog over everyday & night in a 1 bedroom with 2 twin beds…. are you kidding me that should be embarrassing. And to top it off her uncle implied they get a puppy …. Smh

I'm side with the defendant. I ain't living with 2 people. I signed up for a room with one person. Defendant should have done was find someone to live there and then counterclaim the amount for the boyfriend living there.

Simple..if you share a room, no boyfriend/girlfriend sleepovers. If you have your own romm, then see if the other roommate is alright with occasional sleepovers. Otherwise...court you go.

If the boyfriend was there most of the time I think you should pay for it and I don't think the judge is paying attention to that

I did same thing, left when a roommate had her bf there but he was abusive and crazy and she hasn’t listen and kick him out so I was out of there 🤷🏻‍♀️

She should’ve just roomed with her man from the beginning! SMH

6:18 *Harvey:* "Can they stay over 7 nights a week?" *Woman:* "I think in some scenarios it could happen." 😳🤦‍♂️😭 *LITERALLY* *NOBODY* *CAUGHT* *THAT*

Plaintiff definitely a future Karen

A dog is the last thing they needed.

I disagree...I think the roommate voided their contract by letting her boyfriend take over the other girl's space

It looks like the father grabs his daughters butt after the interview with Doug

@namnack

4 ай бұрын

Old habits die hard.

@LoveChild71

4 ай бұрын

Or he was about to do it and then realized that they were in public......nasty!

@Bebedollie

4 ай бұрын

Ew

@arayaklove

4 ай бұрын

Yall are so traumatized and disturbed

@angelatayler7304

3 ай бұрын

Omg . I thought the same thing

"when she had the SAME boyfriend" ooooh so that's what broke them apart.

Defendant was envious of plaintiff. That was the true problem.