Ok; I really like this theory, it makes a lot of sense It fixes one of the two problems I had with Game Theory's video on the subject, that is the question of sustainability and size of the black holes created, but not my major question. How would Gardevoir protect their trainer with one? This dilemma was still present in Game Theory's video with the black holes being minuscule and unsustainable. The answer is quite simple, yet never approached. Quick example; say someone threatens a Gardevoir's trainer with a gun and is quite intent on killing them, In this scenario, Gardevoir can create a small black hole near the gunman's hand causing the assailant to lose their hand; and possibly the gun; thus disabling them. Or even inside their head decapitating them. either way Gardevoir has saved their trainers life, using a black hole no less, proving the Pokedex correct. Even with an unsustainable black hole, this should still be possible; however, Game Theory doesn't mention this possibility and proceeds to say that because the black hole is too small, thus it can't be useful, thus the Pokedex is wrong. Conversely, I say the Pokedex is right, Gardevoirjust killed; in the given scenario; to keep their trainer safe. sorry for the long comment, I have a tendency to make long comments. Either way great video, keep up the good work.

My guess for the whole "It doesn't feel the pull of gravity" would be simply that its hovering happens automatically, like the beating of your heart. It doesn't have to focus its psychic powers to float, it just does.

"what are your thoughts on the matter", I see what you did there. Don't we see Gardevoir create a small black hole at the start of her Burst Attack in Pokken Tournament? All it affects is the enemy Pokemon. Evidently she can also control what the black hole affects as well. Also Gardevoir for Smash. Please.

@KingKayro87

Жыл бұрын

Gardevoir for Smash? Sure, who wouldn't want a Smash Gardevoir?

@toothbrush-guy

Жыл бұрын

@@KingKayro87shhh

0:45 what kind of destruction does it have? Expectations: Destroy everything Reality: just does nothing Unlike Kirby, if you ever know him. I bet Kirby swallows more things than a small black hole.

Gardevoir are very intelligent, soooooo there might be a Gardevoir that can speak like a human Yeah, it's possible, but hey, that's just a theory, a Pokemon theory!!!!!

@firepuppies4086

4 жыл бұрын

I think a ralts used Telepathy once. So...

@osmacar5331

4 жыл бұрын

That unsettles me to think about it, you bastard

@kristyosborne3416

4 жыл бұрын

You missed the chance to call it pokétheory

@rezendeiiz.knight1084

3 жыл бұрын

well ralts>gardevoir line have a hidden ability TELEPATHY I mean look at mewtwo and some other legendary pkmns that can speak to trainers

Wow Lockstin another debunked game theory video? It been forever since the last one

@Chaos89P

5 жыл бұрын

I honestly wish he'd do more of these, where he debunks what Game Theory has said. That "Morph Ball Is Not Lame" video is why I subbed in the first place.

@The_GhostWind

5 жыл бұрын

It’s been 84 years since the last one

@jayseanlewis6981

5 жыл бұрын

Now hang on guys let's keep it Gnoggin 👐

@aidenbar511

5 жыл бұрын

That video was how I found his channel.

@mysteriousmortal2303

5 жыл бұрын

I hate my life

Gravity also afects things without mass because it curves the space-time itself. If you exist, gravity afects you. On the other hand, if an object feels equal forces in oposite directions, it won't move at all. Suposing that telequinesis is like a magnetic field, gardevoir wudn't feel any force when floting. You can levitate iron if you have a magnet of the exact force at the exact distance over it, and the magnet would now feel an extra force pulling it down. Good video! P.D.: Excuse me if something isn't correctly writen, I'm Spanish.

Smallest element is helium. Hydrogen: Am I a joke to you?

@PkHunt13

4 жыл бұрын

Hydrogen is the lightest. But helium is the smallest. The extra protons pull the electron cloud closer. This it is smaller than helium

@saltsmath1712

4 жыл бұрын

@@PkHunt13 yeah i know, that was a dumb comment haha

@tedtective

4 жыл бұрын

Haha 😂 when I was reading this I thought I read hydragon

@BUTTERCUPANDCHICKADEE

4 жыл бұрын

@@tedtective yeah

If Gardevoir can make black holes, she surely can erase them without issues as well. I imagine her just creating a black hole big enough to absorb the threat and then destroying the black hole completely and utterly. Or maybe her "black holes" aren't actual black holes as we know them but just warp gates of darkness that teleport the threat away, making it look like it was eaten by the hole.

Gardevoir mega evolving and creating a black hole would be a really nice final smash if leaks are true

This might be one of your best videos: great editingand humor, and excellent science.

@adrienconverset6571

4 жыл бұрын

But wrong conclusion, as the pokedex clearly states "to protect its trainer, it will expend all its psychic power to create a small black hole". As much as I'd like my banker to think otherwise, you can't pull more money out of an empty account.

This is random but the Gardevior in the thumbnail gives me a stupid idea: What if she had Cloud's Buster Sword?

@deelim5092

4 жыл бұрын

What if gallades hands are the size of clouds buster sword

@kanadetachibana9737

4 жыл бұрын

What if gallade had cloud hair?

@Tyranitar.

3 жыл бұрын

youtube:this comment only has 2 replies! me: ok! opens up the replies youtube: wait no, it has over 10! QUALITY then realises that i opened the wrong comment

@Tyranitar.

3 жыл бұрын

@@deelim5092 elbows

@kitsunesden8085

3 жыл бұрын

*Sephiroth's Masamune

Wouldn't it be more accurate to describe it as a sphere of annihilation like the Dungeons and Dragons spell of the same name Instead of calling it a black hole

"It's zo zmall! Lige a liddle uniberzal zpaze bagguum!" #1 best baby imitation ever

Being that Machoke can lift an entire mountain with one arm and Larvitar eats an entire mountain to evolve, I imagine Gardevoir should be able to make a black hole with the Earth's gravity. I just think there are lots of other Gardevoir's prepared to stop it if it gets out of hand.

I always figured that Gallade was the knight, while Gardevoir was the mage/spell-caster. Still one of my favorite tag teams in a double battle.

"Gardevoir is a valiant..... Hugger?" How can you be good at hugging when you're so bony?

@osmacar5331

4 жыл бұрын

Cause apparently people like hugging skeletons? People like me hugging them but am bonier than a skeleton

@redmadness265

3 жыл бұрын

Also the giant horn/spike on their chest doesn't seem very embracing

OMG!! You the first youtuber (that is not a physicist) to get the details of black holes, right! Awesome vid! And I love Ralts, Kiralia, and Gardevoir too~

"Someone should make a series of [Tropes in media]" You mean Trope Talk from Overly Sarcastic Production ?

Some men just wanna see the comment section burn...

I always thought Gallade was a knight and Gardevoir was a Princess 😂😂

Super massive Black holes: “Am I a joke to you?”

Thank you for explaining this quite complex feild of physics correctly. I've never seen someone on KZread, who isn't explicitly a science channel do this this accuratly. I especially love, that you explained the relative gravity and that it is not directly linked to mass. Even a lot of physicists forget that sometimes.

Ah, I remember when I first found this channel from an anti theory on Samus's Morph Ball. Good times. I like how Lockstin goes the positive route, while Game Theory always goes negative.

Been a while since you last did one of these Game Theory Debunked videos! And here I thought that the "black hole" was just a fancy description for the move Shadow Ball, which Gardevoir can learn and looks very similar to a small black hole. One thing I don't like about Game Theory is how they constantly ignore the way things work in the games universes they theorize about while trying to replace it with how things work in real life. Who's to say physics in the Pokémon world (or the world of any game they theorize on) work anything like they do in our world to begin with? Or anything for that matter? Both the games and anime have provided plenty of proof that things that are normally fatal to us, like fire or high amounts of electricity, can be brushed off like it's nothing after drinking some lemonade. Proof being that Ash has been *REPEATEDLY* set on fire by Charizard, whose fire is stated to be able to melt *BOULDERS* and Team Rocket has been electrocuted _literally_ hundreds of times and sent flying for possibly miles at a time at the end of most episodes. Maybe black holes are far less dangerous in the Pokémon world than they are in our world, this is seriously something that GT never seems to consider!

@ralcogaming7674

5 жыл бұрын

OmegaX5000 let's not forget that odds are the gravity there is wayyy lower with them being able to carry 500lb pokemon on their heads, and the pokemon weights were altered to suit our gravity. I've grown disillusioned with game theory sadly there are always glaring holes in Austin's theories and Matpat has a bad habit of just saying pretty words.

@beegyoshi800

5 жыл бұрын

well, to be fair, it obviously works in the game world, he talk about if it was in real life. he wouldn't say that mario doesn't die when he gets hit by a bullet bill, because he clearly does it's pretty much a "what if it was in our world?" sort of thing

That picture of Gardevoir and her trainer was adorable. X3

Hey locktin, you’ve got a mountain on your head. *ITS GROOMING ME*

Gardevoir is like Scarlet Witch, their reality warping powers as almost as good as the reality stone it self, with Scarlet Witch being able to somewhat erase the mutant gene (House of M) and bring the dead back to life (Reviving Quicksilver)

@AwesomeMooseSmile

5 жыл бұрын

Don't think that Gardevoir is up to that level yet.

2:08 to skip ad

@milkyjuice646

5 жыл бұрын

Bless you.

Proud of you not giving up too guys, love the videos and the style you are doing! Feels more down to earth while also talking about fictional characters but ey its what I love

Heck ya I love Gardivoir, thanks dude

Funny thing is Gardevoir don't have no moves that relate to black hole. Maybe the z-move black hole eclipse. That acute black hole what type of breed is it.

@MrAuthor3DS

5 жыл бұрын

Well, Pokkén did make up for that with its Burst Attack (Fairy Tempest), which starts with a "black hole"...though given it transports the two to another realm, it's probably more of a portal.

@andresmarrero8666

5 жыл бұрын

It's weird that Gardevoir can't learn gravity either.

Dusclops can eat any of those black holes any day. Dusclops is OP.

12:00 Thanks!! That’s what I was screaming at the screen while watching MatPats video.

Love your videos, a good amount of your argument is sort of right (not saying the other persons is, I haven't watched it) but when physics is brought up I giggled watching you try to use it.

I want a Gardevoir for... Wholesome scientific research. I swear, STOP LOOKING AT ME LIKE THAT!!!!

@djinsanity3575

5 жыл бұрын

J Choogie I won't judge

@Chaos89P

5 жыл бұрын

A Psychic/Fairy type is bound to be a bit of a monster. I mean, why do you think Wally ends up with one in the Gen. 3 games/remakes?

@ljx2684

5 жыл бұрын

Yeah and i want a lopunny......also for research No seriously...you see those ears and * cough * those legs

@angeplaysroblox2430

5 жыл бұрын

You trynna smash

@ghilliedude434

5 жыл бұрын

@@angeplaysroblox2430 yes

Pokedexes are always insane and nonsensical. I actually believe that Pokémon wasn’t really intended for adults with scientific understanding. It is also a clever marketing strategy, as people will discuss about it and inadvertently advertise the games.

@giannityler8626

5 жыл бұрын

If gardevior can create black holes than mega gardevior gets a tier above mega Rayquaza Or would dragon accents mighty sky crush still be stronger?

@giin97

5 жыл бұрын

...carries children away..." There's also the one that used to be a human child...

@chezze8190

5 жыл бұрын

Redstone dragon Gaming "insane and nonsensical..." This is anime and videogames were talking about? What did you expect?

@randalica92

5 жыл бұрын

Especially the gen 1 dex went a bit overkill with the descriptions

@redstonedragongaming8795

5 жыл бұрын

Since I am still quite young, I haven’t played gen 1. Thanks for the information, cool memelord. And to the other comment, I think *logically, like a little too logical for my own good.* I have lost the sense of fantasy because I do not have time to do so.

Just thinking about the feats Gardevoir could potentially pull off with gravity powers like that is really friggen cool

VRV is actually awesome. Also instant like for the intro.

My theory is, since the PokéDex was mostly filled by kids in their pre-teens, maybe something's are exaggerated. For Gardevoire I think some kid was in danger and his Pokémon created a heavy vacuum, which the trainer thought of as a black hole.

@maskofthedragon

5 жыл бұрын

The PokeDex being written by anything but professionals is pure headcanon bullshit not supported by anything

@ArceusDX

5 жыл бұрын

The Pokedex isn't written by kids though, all the data's already on the dex, the kids just catch the Pokémon to unlock that data, heck, in the anime, which is more canon than fan theories, the Dex already has all the data installed.

@mattiaberti9160

5 жыл бұрын

I think that the pokèdex shows us the true nature of the pokèmon world... But the actual gameplay can't for obvious reasons.

@gottesurteil3201

5 жыл бұрын

We don't know the specifics of the contract between Oak and Red/Blue in regards to the pokedex. Are we really to believe that the POKEMON PROFESSOR is having CHILDREN write entries for the pokedex and classifying the pokemon as well? Or is it rather the professor had the kids catch the pokemon, research them himself, and then come up with the descriptions/classifications? I find the latter more likely. The games at the time probably did not have the time to accurately portray this process, and so had the entries appear right away upon capture so that you could learn more about the pokemon quickly without dealing with busy work.

9:40 I need some more Infromation

Gardevoir is the only Psychic and Fairy type to create black holes Now with the dark type z move _' _*_BLACK HOLE_*_ eclipse'_ every dark type can now do that

No problem. Blushes also work just fine. Also, I really like your intonations and clear, beautiful editing. Never pointed that out.

Everyone knows that Gardevoir is Sans.

@grant9637

5 жыл бұрын

Wat

@gumbowallace

5 жыл бұрын

PowahSlap Entertainmint gallade is ness

@giannityler8626

5 жыл бұрын

Heyy Gardevior is Sans and ness

@firepuppies4086

5 жыл бұрын

Well the amount of porn is comparable

@firepuppies4086

5 жыл бұрын

@@GustafMedF can't really say

6:38 Where can I find that picture?

I've seen game theory do this kind of thing so many times now, and this was the first video I ever saw talking about it, I heard they even did a similar thing with mega man. By "thing" I mean them conveniently missing or not paying attention to something that could possibly shatter their theory or change it in such a way that it wouldn't be as interesting.

i love every video maxill is in good work lockstin

4:41 Sooo gardevuor doesn’t suck??

10:58 The star implodes. The force of nuclear fusion pushing energy outward against gravity is what causes the star not to implode YET. When a dying star reaches the point of not producing enough energy, it is not able to withstand the downward force of gravity, and implodes into a back hole, or explodes creating a super nova. I am not positive if supernovas explode and can create black holes or not.

@BrendonCap

5 жыл бұрын

What happens is when a star implodes it blows off it's less dense outer layer, leaving the more dense elements in the core, silicon, iron, ect. to turn into a black hole

@AJ-js4xi

5 жыл бұрын

Seths Dad Well, yes, if the force of gravity is strong enough :)

That was a surprisingly tame thumbnail. I'm impressed and proud.

I haven't understood how gravity is a radiation until you explained. Thank you, it really helped!

Gardovir is a princess and galalde is a knight ....

@wingedbluj1674

5 жыл бұрын

Well, as Gardevoir can be both male and female, I believe they were based on the concept of a Guardian Angel.

@Cakecrasher

5 жыл бұрын

Winged BluJ I was thinking sword and shield which I think makes sense

@Tree_-wp5zn

5 жыл бұрын

OK both of you make sense...

@ohwow7688

5 жыл бұрын

Gardevoir is a mage

@huricane887

5 жыл бұрын

They were suppose to make Gardevoir a female only pokemon but scrapped the idea for some reason.

Smart? ✔ Funny? ✔ Awesome personality? ✔ Awesome interests? ✔ Insanely attractive? ✔ ✔ ✔ If I was a single woman, Lockstin....if I was a single woman ❤

The hair just makes these videos so much better

Way to make my favorite pokemon even cooler ;)

I love how this videos use science to explain the unsciensable

@Bob-aaaaa

5 жыл бұрын

Ha

imagine if gardevoir try to make black hole to protect you but you get sucked by the black hole and never get out gardevoir:😳😳😳😭😭 me:😐😐😐😐🤨 ? like if you had a same thinking.

I'm glad you're still getting sponsors

2:43 When You Can’t Describe Something LOL

"If a tree falls in the woods, and no one is around to hear it, does it make a sound?" Yes. Yes it does. So you're kinda wrong. Why? Just because there is no ear to receive the sound waves does not mean the sound waves don't exist. The moment the vibrations are caused, those vibrations are literally the sound waves traveling through the medium of air. This is why if we left a tape recorder in the vicinity, the sound could be captured for replay at a later time. The sound waves exist because the tree falling, whether someone is present or not, still creates the vibrations carried by the medium.You can't say something doesn't exists based on your lack of perceiving it. Now all the other black hole stuff, yeah, I agree with you. But sir, that tree made a sound, whether you perceived it or not.

Seriously. The hype for pokémon lets go is smaller than a Planck length?

nice video! love these

thanks,now i'm imagining gardevoir launching a mini blackhole as a hadouken

Um I have a question, so sense Spirtomb is made from alot of evil spirits so hear is my question, what would happen if it was replaced with good spirits or if all it's spirits left ?

@cassandrafiscus9192

5 жыл бұрын

For some reason, I read your comment and thought "I wonder if Spiritomb has Multiple Personality Disorder? XD

@grunkleg.3110

5 жыл бұрын

If the spirits left, it would just be an Odd Keystone. If it had good spirits, I dunno, maybe it would become a Fairy-type

@zoroearc2582

5 жыл бұрын

The spirits can’t leave, they’ve been bound to the keystone

@chillileo6803

5 жыл бұрын

Well what would happen if it DID

@chillileo6803

5 жыл бұрын

That is the question

Hey dude

gardevoir type : i don't care gardevoir feeling: i realy don't want to know gardevoir : i hate you

It's a missed opportunity that, to my knowledge, Gardevior doesn't have any moves that play off the black hole creation.

Taking on matpat, bold. Not very popularity smart, but bold Love the vid though, good work

Now its time to talk about your hair. How tf did you made it? Review it! EXPLAIN!

Tbh, I think the relationship between Gardevoir and Galade might be a reference to King Arthur and (in some depictions) his sister, Morgan/Morgana. One a valiant magic knight and king wielding the king of all blades, the other, a sorceress bearing one of the strongest known affinities for magic power.

The type of black hole the pokemon world uses is slightly different, The "protect it's trainer" bit could likely mean a way to use blackholes to teleport the trainer out, and teleport itself, or everything around it, as it was shown in the anime when Gardevoir used Teleport. Blackholes have many theories, Pokemon is using all of them and then some, in "right" and "wrong" ways.

Lockstin and Maxill collab to take on Game Theory?! SHUT UP AND TAKE MY MONEY!

@echowolf3602

5 жыл бұрын

And again I say theory war

Just admit it. You're now officially a Pokétuber.

@massawassa115

5 жыл бұрын

I think he already admitted to that a while back matey

Gardevoir is my favorite pokemon so I love it when people make videos on it

I'd actually really like to see a series of you picking apart movie physics and tropes

Oh my gosh did he say that the hype for the let’s go games is smaller than a plonk I really like that game

@gabrielle6071

4 жыл бұрын

There was no hype for it however because it wasnt really what any of the community was hoping for in the first pokemon switch game. Similarly the hype for sword and shield was cut in half.

I feel like Maxill is the biggest Matt Pat hater.

@AwesomeMooseSmile

5 жыл бұрын

I mean..... It's maxill

@RealFolkFashionandHealth

5 жыл бұрын

Galaxy-Eyes Garchomp Maxill just seems to hate everyone. As the person above me said it's Maxill.

Who’s that Pokémon? It’s disappointment! Disappointment: I’m disappointed in my self.

17:25 Overly Sarcastic Productions actually has a series called Trope Talks where they discuss literary tropes. It's really good.

Gallade = Duck?? Gardevoir = chicken???

@Bob-aaaaa

5 жыл бұрын

What

@ShufTheXD

5 жыл бұрын

@@Bob-aaaaa Exactly.

@RealFolkFashionandHealth

5 жыл бұрын

Shuffled And Truffled Ah I see you speak pokémonese allow me to say. Pikachu Charizard Onix Diglett Psyduck Giratina Empoleon Onix Darkrai Diglett.

@ShufTheXD

5 жыл бұрын

@@RealFolkFashionandHealth Raikou.

@Bob-aaaaa

3 жыл бұрын

what

“Hooker” hOW DARE.

"So you can keep pretending they were better!" I'm dying, Squirtle.

It's good day to die hard when a lockstin debunks game theory video pops up.

Gardevoir could be a Boy or a girl Seriously!

@justarandomsovietofficerwi2023

5 жыл бұрын

I don't wanna f*** a trap!

@justarandomsovietofficerwi2023

5 жыл бұрын

Popmaster 5971 oh wait yaoi

Gnoggin Debunked?: They ACTUALLY hate MatPat!

@merpo2806

5 жыл бұрын

Who doesn't at this point.

@hunterbiden7250

5 жыл бұрын

Gnoggin Is irrelevant compared to that sellout.

@corenlavolpe6143

5 жыл бұрын

I do think he has a chip on his shoulder, but honestly I like both Lockstin and MatPat. But I'm curious. Why do people say MatPat is a sellout? Someone please explain why you think that, if you do.

@zeroattentiongaming820

5 жыл бұрын

@@merpo2806 Literally every channel I watch that does even tangentially theory related content is constantly taking shots at the guy.

@selinnazsur2328

5 жыл бұрын

Coren la Volpe I really don't understand that either. I like both of these guys, can't a creator do his job without being called a sellout? I don't think he is tbh, KZread is pretty much his only income. He has many mouths to feed, INCLUDING a baby now (even though the baby still doesn't eat solid food but you get my point)

If Gardevoirs can ignore gravity that suddenly explains their egg group being only amorphous.

Many people have dedicated large amounts of their lives exploring and experimenting with Gardevoir's black holes.

The video above this one was about how sex is like a sandwhich Good timing 👏

@hunterbiden7250

5 жыл бұрын

Sub box or recommendations?

@afroartist7805

5 жыл бұрын

Home page It was an ad 😂

@fancyhat_

5 жыл бұрын

Phew, I wasn’t the only one with that ad. Why is KZread having ads about... condoms...?

@afroartist7805

5 жыл бұрын

@@fancyhat_ idek lmao

@BackDisease

5 жыл бұрын

@@fancyhat_ because FaMiLy FrIeNdLy CoNtEnT

You refer to gardevoir as "her", but gardevoir is a 50/50 gender split, and has a name in Japanese that roughly translates to "sir knight". It's a bit of a weird thing to think about, especially considering the fact that mega gardevoir is clearly wearing a dress.

@FrostyTheCookie

5 жыл бұрын

Guys can wear dresses too lol, it's just more common in certain societies (probably the one you're in) for girls to wear a dress. In my traditional culture from where I'm from, men usually wear dresses as it symbolizes strength and pride.

@GamingGardevoir

5 жыл бұрын

NPC thank you

Lockstin is the theorist we need, Maxill is the one we deserve

You could make a black hole of light (a Kugelblitz), so should Gardevoir not be able to create one of pure psychic energy?

Dirt

@runningoncylinders3829

5 жыл бұрын

Dirt

7:23 her? DID YOU JUST ASSUME HER GENDER? GARVERVOIR CAN BE MALE TOO

@humiddanny1212

5 жыл бұрын

You reffered to it as "her" too

@gunjfur8633

5 жыл бұрын

Dank Danny Ooooooooooo! :O

@medianxx4687

5 жыл бұрын

I refer them as "it"

@slothful2039

5 жыл бұрын

@@medianxx4687 But pokemon are sentient :'(

@ZenoDovahkiin

5 жыл бұрын

It's standard practice to refer to Pokémon like Animals. It's "it" unless you talk about a specific Guardevoir.

The Large Hadron Collider does something similar (or at least to simulate it). What's interesting is that there's also a Z move that create a black hole. The pokédex entry even say that Dusclops is walking black hole x)

I like both you and Game Theory, so yeah!

:) Yay, someone who sees through that Game Liar's "theories".

5:30 Sorry, but if you want to point out flaws for others, try not to mess up too. Nuclear Explosion = Fission OR Fusion. Biggest known is the Zar Bomba... 50 MEGAtons of TNT. Fission Bomb = Only Fission without a Hydrogen Fusion stage... neither (see Ivy King of the US for 500kt). Please check your terminology next time. 10:00 You can turn that supposed mindblow on its head. Hearing is the change of pressure inside our ear based on our sensory organ. So obviously the tree makes a sound if it falls in any enviroment it can cause a change in airpressure by direct intervention or resonance. In short, YES, it does create a pressure wave if force is involved and a moving medium comes into contact (sorry space you are silent and mostly empty). Do you register it? No... not if you are too far away. Doesn't mean it is not there. I know you wanted an allegory, but I wouldn't pick this one.

@dragonheart5312

5 жыл бұрын

I don't get what your trying to disprove? The first one he is just giving a comparison of energy levels. It doesn't have to correlate. For the second part, it is true that it doesn't make a sound. If nothing is around to sense the vibration, it stays a vibration and doesn't progress to become a sound.

@viviengemai9796

5 жыл бұрын

He said 107 tons - I could berate him further for not saying KILOtons mind you - is the biggest man made nuclear explosion. That is plain wrong! Not only is it 107 kilotons, but I even looked it up now. The biggest PURE fission bomb also reaches at least 500kt. This time the US build it, it is the Ivy King. So however you slice it, nuclear explosion (60 MEGATONS or 251040 Terajoule) or the biggest fission bomb, he is wrong on ALL accounts. And no, for anything there - animals etc - it would still be registered as a sound. And your way to avoid it becoming sound is purely based on sensory interpretation, not the basic physical property. The physical property doesn't vanish when unobserved, only your interpretation does. Sound per definition is a physical property. He is wrong in both cases here. Just accept it.

@dragonheart5312

5 жыл бұрын

@@viviengemai9796 separating for convince. 1. He said tons of tnt. What you could be saying is kilotons of force. There is a difference. When a bomb goes of, it reacts with the air getting "heavier" increasing the amount of force the weight ratio. 2. Sound is not a physical property, it is a sensation. Vibrations are that physical property. So something doesn't make sound if nothing is close enough to perceive the vibration. Ergo, if you are too far away, you can't hear it, but it still happens.

@viviengemai9796

5 жыл бұрын

I know he said tons himself - and he didn't write it in the video either it only states tons. And no he gave his supposed measurement of Terajoules to tons (ktons in fact). It is 107.xxx for the values given. So he 100% certainly used the basic measurement of force here. And the air wouldn't get heavier by pressure force, it gets more DENSE by accelerating the molecules close to the explosion and making them crash into those further away from the epicenter. When it gets compressed, the speed goes down but the mass increases. F = m*a. Thus the total force doesn't change. Whenever the air becomes more dense, the speed reduces even more, ultimately stopping the explosions expansion and bringing it to a near halt - if done in a friction free enviroment. It stops earlier with friction and other factors that make it dissipate. Common death by explosion, internal force trauma. For your sound, aside of basic physical definition of sound, here is Oxford for you: Vibrations that travel through the air or another medium and can be heard when they reach a person's or animal's ear. Note that they need to fulfill the potential, not actually do reach you to be classified as a sound. Any air vibration in a certain audible range is considered sound.

@tra12048

5 жыл бұрын

Yea, I've never understood the "tree falls in forest, no one to hear it, does it sound make?" saying... Of course it still makes a sound, just nobody is around to observe it... I understood this when I was 5 years old, and you have this saying quoted over and over by big names incessantly. sigh... If we went by that logic, then frequencies that we cannot perceive would not be "sound" either, and yet they are. The universe does not revolve around human beings lmao

Great video with good points

Thank you! I have been explaining the tree falling thing to people since high school and everyone called me crazy! But yet again, I have found someone else smarter than me who agrees with me on something idiots tell me is wrong.

I love your videos but you exclusively called gardevoir a 'she' and it kinda pissed me off because gardevoir can be both male and female. You should just gardevoir a 'it'.