Galaxy S5 vs LG G3: Clash of the Flagships | Pocketnow
Ғылым және технология
Learn more about the LG G3 and the Galaxy S5! See Pocketnow's full review of each: /2014/06/14/lg-g3-review | /2014/04/23/samsung-galaxy-s5-review-good-not-glam
Follow Michael:
/ captain2phones
Subscribe: bit.ly/pocketnowsub
pocketnow.com
Follow us:
flipboard.com/@Pocketnow
/ pocketnow
/ pocketnow
google.com/+pocketnow
/ pocketnow
About us:
Pocketnow has been a key source of mobile technology news and reviews since its establishment in 2000. With offices on three continents, Pocketnow offers round-the-clock coverage of the mobile technology landscape, from smartphones to tablets to wearables. We aim to be your number-one source for mobile tech news, reviews, comparisons, and commentary. If you love mobile as much as we do, be sure to subscribe!
Galaxy S5 vs LG G3: Clash of the Flagships | Pocketnow
• Galaxy S5 vs LG G3: Cl...
PocketNow
/ pocketnow
Пікірлер: 728
You know when you hear *The Voice* it's going to be a good review.
@Pocketnow
10 жыл бұрын
::hat tip:: Much obliged! ^M
@KristjanKahur
10 жыл бұрын
Agreed.
@kevinalcantar6228
10 жыл бұрын
I totally agree!!
@andysuryantorovanruzzette8085
10 жыл бұрын
Agreed
@ethan_219
10 жыл бұрын
Agreed
"Also, using a tap to wake up the screen, or to put it to sleep, feels much more modern than mashing a physical button." That's exactly why every major Android OEM uses on-screen buttons instead of hardware or capacitive buttons. Android introduced on-screen buttons back in 2011 with Ice Cream Sandwich. Samsung is still living in the past by refusing to follow suit.
@art6163
10 жыл бұрын
True indeed my friend
@FalcoGFX
10 жыл бұрын
I've actually always liked the capacitive buttons over the on screen buttons
@grayisagirl
10 жыл бұрын
tap to unlock screen has been introduced in 2012 by Nokia
@BenjaminOng5
10 жыл бұрын
Tapping the screen to wake/sleep the phone has nothing to do with capacitive buttons. It is to serve as an alternative to pressing the unlock button which is typically located on the top or side of the phone. This is a feature that will likely become more prevalent, as the screen size of phones continues to increase. Rather than having to stretch and reach for the unlock button, you can simply tap the screen to unlock it.
@PimpinPenguin96
10 жыл бұрын
Some of us actually like the physical buttons, you know. Although I would prefer a touch sensitive button (like the multitask and back button) as opposed to a physical button, I still would rather have those than the on screen buttons.
How come you didnt mention the screen on the G3 is 0.4mm bigger whilst being almost the same size as the S5
@s3atothemoon
10 жыл бұрын
mm or inch ?
@Masterincommander
10 жыл бұрын
dani sea mm i didnt say inch
@s3atothemoon
10 жыл бұрын
but isnt it 0.4 inch bigger ???
@marfg12345
10 жыл бұрын
It's 10mm bigger, not 4mm. It is 0.4'' bigger, though.
Recently upgraded to the LG G3, my thoughts: Battery Life: Was a concern, but that was before I got little over 6 hours on-screen time at normal use without power saver on. Screen: What happened to the pixels, I can't even make out any? 538PPI is incredible on this display, font is slightly sharper. Color correction seems pretty decent. Camera: Low light isn't top notch but is pretty damned good. Shooting video at 4K is pretty impressive as well. Use: Optimus UI seems to be rather snappy and really clean/minimal interface, but I haven't gotten the chance to install too much yet for the possibility for lag yet. The back buttons take a little bit to get used to but work extremely well. Cons: Screen isn't the best in daylight(like most phones) and the back of the phone around the camera and top part of the screen heats up a little with extended use. Nothing terrible, but it should be noted. My deciding point to get this phone over the M8 was the removable battery and higher PPI screen. The back-facing speaker was originally a down side over the M8's front facing speakers, but I normally use my headphones anyways or flip the phone around if I want to listen to Pandora. The camera is also solid as hell on the G3. After seeing some of the pictures which take advantage of the HTC's "ultra-pixel" cameras, it wasn't that impressive IMO. Overall, I'm very happy with the G3 as my new daily driver.
Good phone (g3) vs bad phone (s5) :P
@aldofauzan4119
10 жыл бұрын
bad phone (g3) vs good phone (s5) :p
@alexschmidt1131
10 жыл бұрын
both are good, i still cant decide which one to take
@ErnestMarvinEsteban
10 жыл бұрын
Alex Schmidt take the S5. Feels like a more refined product. And that display is really gorgeous.
@1300l
10 жыл бұрын
Ernest Marvin Esteban I disagree strong on that. But if you think so, then im sure you will be happy with the S5
@ErnestMarvinEsteban
10 жыл бұрын
1300l already have one. The S5 just feels like a more all-around product than the G3. And though having a bit smaller display, it is still the better and probably even the best display right now. And the S5 just looks good in person too.
Great review Michael, absolutely love the sound bite at the very end😸
A really brilliant comparison video. Really well put together and the end part was very funny
G3 all the way! Even though i have a nexus 5 :P
Hello, I would so appreciate if you could tell me what dslr did you use to record this video? And what lens? Thank you
just got a g3 for my wife today, she has the note 2 and got 3 replacements from the warranty in less than 2 years, but because she broke the first one then lost the second one and then broke the third one again!lols im just hoping she will gonna love this phone and if she does, i hope she will appreciate it even more than her note 2s. good review by the way!
off the topic. i have a lumia 1520, before leaving for work around 7:20 am. i put everything on ON, the wifi, screen brightness on high, gps is on. on work sometimes i surf the net using my office's wifi connection. watch youtube videos and play games, especially asphalt 8, and other high intense games. picking up calls and msgs. what i really like about this phone is that, by the time i arrived home i still have 40% battery! and im a heavy user kind of guy. NOW my QUESTION is, is LG G3' battery performance and the S5's any good? like having everything turned on?
I go with the s5 I love the samsung eco system the boat load of features LG just doesn't do it for me but the tap the screen feature is sweet LG just isn't there yet
I enjoyed this review. Thank you for the comparison of using it as a tool or having an eye for detail. That was appreciated, and really did help put both devices in perspective. Now I know if I could ever buy one I would buy the lg l3.
Michael's voice in the sample video Is hilarious, but also a great review :)
Superb comparison, Michael! Keep the good work!
Is it just me, or am I the only one who thinks iOS and Android are both good?
@abdullahimran9057
9 жыл бұрын
Ios and android both are great, ios being more snappy and more secured. Android at the same time has more to offer in terms of features and customizability. :) but both are great in their own way its just a matter of preference mainly of security vs features.
@EpicNEd
9 жыл бұрын
***** But then iOS fan boys say that about Android fan boys as well? Whose right? No one, just the OS developers getting people to fight over their operating systems.
@abdullahimran9057
9 жыл бұрын
***** Bro I see you have let your emotion get the better of you... there is no denying the fact that i like android more than apple but when i said security i meant the option in android when you can go in a phones recovery by pressing the volume and home button and you can factory reset all the data and the phone will be new as before i'll see you find your android then :D plus ios not only doesn't have the recovery option but its hence more secured.... top that!
@bigstabby
9 жыл бұрын
I'm with you. I never understood why people get all Crips vs. Bloods about iOS and Android. It depends on personal taste, but both are generally efficient. Idiots who get worked up over that sort of thing mean that they have actually invested a part of their fucking being and character in association with a phone.lol Pathetic. Who cares?
@EpicNEd
9 жыл бұрын
Just so you guys know, I am using a galaxy tab pro 8.4. Not a bad tablet. My phone is an iPhone 4. Not a bad phone.
ok, I want to buy a smartphone(upgrading from a lg l5, so i guess everything will be a huge step forward) and i don't know which one, between :LG g3, SONY Z2, the S5 or the NOTE 3?
I'm going to be getting a new phone soon (current phone: iPhone 4) and mi wondering what phone i should get any suggestions?
Why didn't they (Samsung and LG) do a combination of both phones ;'( LG G3 looks so good and its design is amazing. Just if it would be waterproof... And S5's display is better because of higher contrast and better looking colors. (Not so natural colors compared to G3, but looks better)
Love the review! It actually gave a clear mind to go for the right phone. Thumbs up!
Hey NEED YOUR HELP.... I have a lg g3 and i was using my and it suddenly went to a thing clled hidden settings... then the screen when all black and grey and it said AT-MINI Os 3.1.... After that the screen went blue and it said Auto Detecting Item
This was tough for me, I was torn between the S5, One M8, and G3 when I bought a phone. I didn't like the M8's camera and that was relatively important to me, and I decided not to go with the S5 because it seems every Android user and their dog has one. So I got the G3, and I adore it... for the most part. The features that make it unique (knock code, button placement, etc) are amazing to me, but it does have its flaws, one of which being the horrid lag I experience every once in a while. A simple reboot usually fixes it but it can get to the point where it's almost unbearable to use. I only experience this lag during multitasking; it runs games like a breeze. I recently encountered a software issue with my mic where it doesn't work on any app on my phone except the camera. If you came here to see which one you want and decide on the G3, bear in mind that you should probably get a tempered glass screen protector. The digitizer is attached to the screen so that means if you so much crack your glass it could render the device useless. I'll occasionally use the S5 of a friend and it seems like a nice phone. The bright screen is nice. I know that it's a great phone, and I can't say it would be a 'bad' phone to choose. Aaaaand that's my input for anyone who is torn between the two like I was :D
@Odspeed001
7 жыл бұрын
Sparkishay Do you had any problem witb your g3 restarting itself over and over again? Mine is rebooting over and over again don't know what to do
@sparkishay1499
7 жыл бұрын
Do you mean it acts like it's going to start up but then doesn't and repeats that? If so, that, my friend, is called a bootloop. Happened to mine back in October. Your phone is bricked. But, if you have important pictures and other files on it, there is a way to get it to boot all the way into the actual phone. You'll probably think I'm lying but I kid you not, it works. You'll have to dissemble your phone and remove your motherboard. Bake the motherboard at 365 for 10 minutes and then let it cool. Put it back together and it should power on for you long enough to back everything up. However, I have heard cases where the phone continues to work for months but will eventually do it again. It's not reliable at this point
@Odspeed001
7 жыл бұрын
Sparkishay what motherboard are you talking about? Someone said i should change the battery
@sparkishay1499
7 жыл бұрын
The motherboard. The inside of the device. Look up disassembly videos of the G3 and you'll know what I'm talking about. You can try changing the battery but most likely it's a bootloop. It's a VERY frequent problem on LG devices
@Odspeed001
7 жыл бұрын
Sparkishay i just bought another battery now but the problem still persists.Don't know what to do now...i love this lg g3 so much😓😓😓
Could you give me your verdict of which one is better.
The best thing about LG phones is the center button is on screen and the display is IPS, hope they could have created one with a 4.7 inch display. Good review from Michael as always. Thanks
Might sound like a dumb question but does the water resistant s5 mean you could take pictures underwater? I'm not saying take the thing scuba diving but just stick it under water take a pic and bring it back up.
Great Comparison. Enjoying Michael's videos lately as they are unbiased & fun to watch.
I had no idea the brightness in screen is that different in the sun light on the LG G3. I come across this problem with my HTC One M7, hmm that kind of sucks.
Thank's for this great review/comparison! I own the G3 S since some days and go totally with your Arguments. The G3 is a good and fast Smartphone, but it's more an accessory than a everyday life Tool. I don't want to miss it at all anymore =)
Could you share what Air Fighter game that is you play? Its posted in many of your videos, and I want to try it out. It looks like a lot of fun. Thanks!
Great video bro. Keep up the good work. And thanks for making me like my GS5 even more lol :)
Is it the battery that heats up in the g3 ? ( or like the whole phone )
I find thin border around screen on later phones extremely annoying, because sometimes when holding phone my skin is touching the edge of the screen and making "accidental touches". I wondered for some time what's wrong with my S4 because it suddenly started acting weird but then noticed that when I held phone certain way my skin was in contact with the edge of the screen. Feels like user must have creepy long fingers in order to use these things properly lol
Where did you guys get that blue samsung galaxy s5 wallpaper?
Michael, love your reviews
Wht game was tht??I hve been lukn fr a good Air Plane stimulation game fr some time now
Is it wrong that I'm looking at the LG G3 hoping it has a run out as a Nexus as well?
You are the best Michael! The main reason why I watch Pocketnow videos :)
Michael Fisher you do the best reviews!.
Please Help, does the LG G3 Uk version has a qi wireless charger ability, thanks people.
I have a nexus 5 and if I wanted to buy one of this 2 phones.. It would be the G3 for sure.
Good review Mike!
i hv lg g3. but font style is cannot find so cannot use Myanmar letter...can you help me...
I dont like soft keys. I have the M8 and i dont know how many times while playing games, like Fruit Ninja or Pac Man, and i accidentally bring up the soft keys. Its annoying. I prefer the buttons on my S5.
@krusher08
10 жыл бұрын
You can hide the softkeys on all the apps if you wanted to with some apps on the play store, one being called all in one gestures try that out I'm sure you won't have a problem with the soft keys after that. However that said you can not use the keyboard with immersive mode turned on, but you can toggle between showing and hiding with a gesture so you can access the keyboard again!
@CarlosDiaz-dd6yi
9 жыл бұрын
***** The app all in one gestures did not work
Pls make a video about the G3 vs S5LTE-A, thankyou
so what do you think is the best phone between samsung and LG?
Cool video glad you did it in my city Boston and I'm an LG G2, G3 guy I had samsung galaxy s4 and it was okay but I'm not a fan anymore they have gestures most people in the world don't even use in which is one reason why the S4 cost so much. On My LG G2 I use everything from the screen tap to wake it up when I get on that orange and red line you seen. I use the one hand keyboard that they have to text and dial numbers, the Quick memo, the Quick remote and most of all the Quick Translator so I'm going to the the LG G3 soon though
You forgot to say "I´m Michael Fisher, this is Pocketnow and this is..." I am so used to your reviews that I missed it.
Can you guys please do a comparison between the g3 and the xperia z2 please???
I wish back then I would have done my homework and got the LG G3 instead of the S5. I have a Note 4 and an LG G3 right now, and I'm so loving the LG G3! I have the Octos MOD on the LG and it just smokes everything! I have around 10 to 12 applications installed and it feels so good to have an Apple like experience, with the convenience of multitasking and customization! If you could strip the Note 4 down, that would be so freaking awesome! Who invented Knox? What the hell were they thinking!
which one should i take? i love lg's design so much and the ui and some functions are nice too, but samsung has these MANY interestig features, like ipxx, fingersprint sensor, heartrate sensor (maybe not that usefzl), many gestures like smart stay ..., nice ui, better display, more camera functions, ...
what is the name of the jet game you are playing on the g3
Great review.
Your review is spot on! I know now what type of user I am. :) That's why I'm leaning more towards the G3 because of its design and I'm gentle with my phones.
It's amazing how influential a video review can be on your choice of devices.
Picking up my G3 Thursday. Been pro iPhone since the 3 but now feel it's time for a change. Tried the Z1 a few months back. Took it back after 24 hours. The OS was horrible by comparison. Fingers crossed the G3 is way better.
Great review thx
U shot that video in Boston? Seen the red line.
glad someone could make an honest comparison without getting emotions or excitement involved.
My G3 was second hand this year. Paid 100 bucks for it. Came with its charger and box. Screen is minty fresh. Although when it heats up its got alot to do with pushing the pixels on a 2K screen.
Call me crazy but I still prefer my Nexus 5 over most phones out now. (M8 seems like a good phone, might be too large though)
Excellent as usual Mike
can anybody please tell me the name of that jets game appeared in the video?
*That intro is quite epic* lol
Omg.. Awesomest review ever!!!!! Great job Michael.
excellent vedio...... to conclusion what is more good?
Perfectly summed up the g3's multi tasking: "you have the choice between overcrowded and space wasting"
when are all the apps going to be optimized for 1440p? its kind of pointless to have a 1440p display and you can only view 720p/1080p content
Hey mike can I get a galaxy s5 for AT&T
best reviewer out there,way to go!!
which ones slower? i have an S3 and i understand its full of bloatware, so it slows down after a while and gains lag and also much longer delay when home button is pushed. Is the G3 and S5 like this? Do they gain any lag or delay after being used for a while?
@MY1S1
9 жыл бұрын
Android is Android and Android will lag. But Samsung has touchwiz and will probably make it lag a bit more than the G3.
@Snipit1990
9 жыл бұрын
Mohamad Sadeddin I have never had lag with stock android but only stock, the g3 lags a bit for me now and then.
z3 compact or the lg g3?
what game is that on 5:48???
I have a lg g2 and i get an upgrade in 2 months. But neither phones have showed me i really need them. The difference between my last optimus g into a LG G2 was massive! Only thing that would pull me is a water proof phone.
What widget is that at the top
thank you for the info =)
Im not getting the note 4 this year since getting the sony xperia tab2 now i just want reg phone again g3 s5 m8 or moto x+1 (if it is good) all for of these should be a good upgrade of note 2
What phone does MF use personally? I think that would be a good video.
u did not mention the g3 remote and s5 touch id
He's using the Korean version of this LG G3. The international/EU/American version has been reported to have a BRIGHTER screen though not quite as bright as the S5 its just fine and actually has better outdoor visibility than the HTC M8.
I got the G3 and it's soooooo cool :D
@pvxxyfairy
9 жыл бұрын
I know I love my G3!
@tuananhnguyen6372
9 жыл бұрын
Me 2 XD
@craftygirlization
9 жыл бұрын
Wow im so happy mine will arrive today
Every flagship phone is going to be top notch, it comes down to what YOU prefer or what company you simply like the best, I recently bought a G3 and I have no complaints, I can honestly say I would probably be just as happy if I bought a S5 or HTC One M8 or whatever else, all these phones are beasts, mine is rooted with custom ROMS, I prefer customization and I could do all that on any of the top smart phones so for me, it doesn't really matter what phone I get because Im gona customize the shit out of it anyway, cheers mates :-)
@superpiff420
9 жыл бұрын
What kind of rom you running on your g3 do they ha 've aosp for it was thinking about getting one but wasn't sure about development support
I just got the G3 and I have been very happy with my decision. The phone is just full of smart ideas. It's super fast, a giant screen but on a somewhat compact device, and the buttons on the back are a cool feature. For $50 less than the S5, I got a higher clocked CPU, 1GB of extra ram, and 16GB of extra storage. The S5 is a great device, but the G3 is a little more refreshing coming from a galaxy s3.
Love the comparison
on of the best reviews ive seen
Hey Fish, can you train all the other reviewers in the world how to do spot on, unbiased and well orated reviews like yours? Thanks!
What about the price Michael? :)
would it be smart to tade my s4 for the g3? I'm reading a lot of KZread comments under g3 videos, and the battery seems to be a real problem. I had the same experience with the htc one where everyone was saying how awesome it was, then actually traded for one, and delete like I got ripped the hell off bwcause of yh3 atrocuous battery.
@rg0
8 жыл бұрын
+TIKI K Don't. I've had several G3s in the past, and the Adreno 330 GPU in the S801 can't handle the 1440p display. And the battery life does suck.
@kingtutt880
8 жыл бұрын
***** true. Didn't trade.
I just fixed my G3 using the LG Flash Tool, and I'm loving it. 5.0.1 is gr8.
Are you kidding us ? On lgs notification bar you choose Auto (screen light) and say negative to G3 ...
6:40 isn't that video about launching a r/c plane off a r/c aircraft carrier? I literally just watched that video...
Good video!
Best review I've seen yet
MF, you just made my Happy Hour Happier! TGIF & Cheers.
@jamesm568
10 жыл бұрын
So basically both phones are just the same thing with a different case.
@Itaintyouitsme
10 жыл бұрын
James Meagher pretty much, except for the display, & design.
@jamesm568
10 жыл бұрын
otis ellis One thing I found annoying with edge to edge screen is when u hold the phone your fingertips is always accidentally touching something.
@Itaintyouitsme
10 жыл бұрын
James Meagher not so with the G3 because the buttons are on the back so you will hold it differently from what I've heard from reviewers.
@jamesm568
10 жыл бұрын
otis ellis Maybe.
Man i love these phones but I have a nexus 5 so it would be stupid to upgrade right now, hopefully I can last till the end of the year or next year
i watched this on my g3 its great . camera is clean , screen is beatiful , perfornmance is a beast and i love the double tap to awaken and unlock .
I'm debating what phone I would like, I'm between note 4 g3 or s5 which one do you recommend?
@YoungstaD713
9 жыл бұрын
g3
@lane6136
9 жыл бұрын
LG g3
@YoungstaD713
9 жыл бұрын
S6....so much nicer though just got rid of my G3 but I'm good with phones as of right now.
@kramhy252
9 жыл бұрын
cris ranjel no way the g3 beats the other! the note 4 rules both of them as well! G3 battery life is not close to the note 4 and it heats up way more! the note 4 also packs the better display along with the s5, resolution isn't always the deciding form factor! amoled is way better than i think the IPS ? on the g3.
@pauletteborders2649
9 жыл бұрын
Note 4 beats all except g flex 2
Michael Fisher makes the best reviews i think.
Got the s5, s5 active, and g3 and I prefer to use the s5 active just because I love the camouflage green lol
I thought you would change your intro with your picture
looks like u like the Samsung more is that true?