So, What’s Better Studio Version On Metallica Or Live?

@logancreed5041

Жыл бұрын

Live is awesome, but the studio was Cliff and Is F****** Flawless

@darrinsteele9841

Жыл бұрын

Studio imo, could y’all check out My Friend of misery by Metallica or maybe The outlaw torn by Metallica?

@luigidabber4573

Жыл бұрын

Studio, fasho.

@ctguitarguy8510

Жыл бұрын

For this song, and songs like it, that are really instrumental, long, intricate, you should generally stick to the studio first.

@ericeric8373

Жыл бұрын

Definitely you should check out the studio version!

To actually take this song in to its fullest is to listen to the studio version so you could hear how Cliff played it. Rob is good but the reason this song is so great is Cliff on the bass, it is truly a masterpiece.

@MiKeMiDNiTe-77

Жыл бұрын

My thoughts exactly I was hoping they were gonna jam the album version

@BBaker916

Жыл бұрын

Yes, you cannot have the same experience on the first decade of Metallica without Cliff. There's a reason they don't play some older songs live. Some out of respect, others because no other bassist can do what Cliff could.

@Mike_H76

Жыл бұрын

Couldn't agree more! Rob is excellent, I just don't see him in Metallica, personal opinion, anyone with a different one... good for you! Dang Lars gained a whole person in weight since the 90's!!!

@JohnnyDollar720

Жыл бұрын

You're not wrong about cliff, but I dig how they play it tuned down

@bigchris757

Жыл бұрын

We need them to react to Anesthesia(pulling teeth) to understand Cliff's greatness.

This sounds great for a live version, and Trujillo is a beast, but y'all need to check out the album version, with Cliff Burton on bass. No one compares to him.

@RojoCube

Жыл бұрын

Not comparing him but Johnny Christ is amazing live. I got to see A7X with The Rev. (Last tour before he passed away) but Johnny Christ did some solo stuff waiting for the others to get ready.

@nehuge

Жыл бұрын

Agreed, album version

@red-stapler574

Жыл бұрын

You should check out Trujillo's original band Suicidal Tendencies.

@emilhindo4784

Жыл бұрын

Really need to be the studio version for this.. 100% Having that said its a nice live version, but nothing will ever beat the studio version for this particular song. With headphones, even better, but that goes without saying for Metallica :)

@JawsVader1970

Жыл бұрын

You should check out s&m 1 and 2 from them no leaf clover and All within my hands

Cliff Burton enjoyed and studied classical music, and it influenced his writing. Orion is proof. RIP Cliff.

Orion is the best instrumental of the 1980s. You guys have to do Dyers Eve next!

@BJJUSAF

Жыл бұрын

I have been saying that for the last 3+ Metallica songs they have reacted to. I’m glad I’m not the only one who wants to see that reaction. Such a poignant and powerful song when you know the story behind it. Really heavy stuff and imagine James as a child screaming in pain in those lyrics. With their instrumental kick, I want so bad for them to do Pulling Teeth. That song you see the true beauty that made Cliff Burton something special. It’s also why I personally feel that if there was no Cliff Burton, we wouldn’t have Metallica.

@panamajack9T

Жыл бұрын

To live is to die and Dyers Eve because they kind of go together that's my favorite Metallica instrumental to live is to die

@PJBonoVox

Жыл бұрын

@@BJJUSAF Same. It the best thrash era Metallica song in my personal opinion.

@BensSoZen

Жыл бұрын

I really do like Call of Ktulu better.. it's more like an orchestral epic

@justinmccarty3886

Жыл бұрын

For me, its inseperable from To Live is to Die.

This song will be played at my funeral.

@TheTruthContestt

Жыл бұрын

No it won’t you trippin

@dennisplesz5129

Жыл бұрын

You definitely gave me a few ideas for my funeral hopefully it's a long ways away but yes I would pick a Metallica song a Bone Thugs-N-Harmony song Marshall Mathers the goat song a little Wayne song A guns n' roses song and a AC/DC song

@hankhill2103

Жыл бұрын

@@TheTruthContestt how can you decide his own life choice ?

@TheTruthContestt

Жыл бұрын

@@hankhill2103 what are you talking about

"For Whom The Bell Tolls" live, Day at the Green, Cliff Burton at his finest

@dustyquarles4178

Жыл бұрын

Yes, this☝🏼

@liamyoung7938

Жыл бұрын

i watch that vid once a week

@kieranhunston8284

Жыл бұрын

Epic, best performance ever, only watched cliff em all the other day

Cliff wrote most of this song. This was his swan song, released roughly 6 months before he passed. He never got to perform it live. I’m glad you guys noticed the “Cliff Burton Day” sign and bothered to look him up. He’s my favorite Metallica member. 🤘🔥🔥🤘

@ordinarypete

Ай бұрын

Sac’d

Studio version is a must for this song. One of the most beautiful and rugged pieces of music imo 🔥

Definitely listen to the original studio version, thru some good headphones, in a room by yourself with your eyes closed. Y'all might not find anything about the meaning of this song online, due to the lack of lyrics, but listen to it as I described above and you'll find meaning in it. Remember, Orion is The Hunter. FWIW, this is my favorite Metallica song.

You should listen to the studio version to really appreciate the song. Cliff Burton on bass makes a huge difference. Plus check out Cliff Burton playing the bass solo Pulling Teeth live. Cliff will blow your mind on the bass

@Sum_Jigh

Жыл бұрын

You nailed it!

This songs always gives me chills. Hell of a masterpiece

Always a moving tribute to Cliff when they play Orion live in concert, Robert Trujillo does the bass parts justice but the studio version is a masterpiece and Cliff Burton's swan song; he was killed in a tour bus accident in Sweden in 1986, their tour bus swerved then rolled over, Cliff was thrown out a window and the bus landed on top of him...hell of a way to go

I like the one who always looks up the lyrics and meanings. He’s good at steering the ship.

@marcusMakoT

Жыл бұрын

Same

@ily0482

5 ай бұрын

Right? I looove him

Still my favorite instrumental of theirs. Such a dynamic song.

@panamajack9T

Жыл бұрын

Do you like TO LIVE IS TO DIE AND DYERS EVE?

@rahbeat9785

Жыл бұрын

Butchered by live version hahaha

@redrick8900

Жыл бұрын

Not a song.

@thiccboi4228

Жыл бұрын

@@rahbeat9785 no they did great

@rahbeat9785

Жыл бұрын

@@thiccboi4228 no, it sounds like dogshit. Check your ears, not my problem

RIP cliff he had such a huge influence on the sound they had when he was with them

Guys you aren’t supposed to watch this live you miss out on the whole musical composition of the recording from the studio version on the album.. it’s a musical masterpiece and you’re missing out on so much watching this live

@TopGun_-

Жыл бұрын

Completely agree. I’ve expressed this to them before.

I seen them live in 81' when Cliff was still alive. He was awesome.

Cliff Burton is arguably the greatest metal bassist of all time. I know he’s my favorite. RIP Cliff Burton

@Jokke472

Жыл бұрын

And easily top 10 Of all time.

You can tell Tae is really into the music. It's so awesome to see! Cliff was unreal, he plays on the Kill em all, Ride the Lightning, and Master of Puppets albums. Brandon's fav "for Whom the Bell Tolls" is Cliff on bass. Such a legend. Gone too soon.

Cliff wrote most of this song but never got to play it live :(

I love how much you guys love and appreciate Metallica.

Goosebumps everytime i hear this... People bash Lars for his outdated drums technique but miss the point that he is like the maestro of the band.

We gotta get these boys to a Metallica show

Metallica has so many bangers especially early on

Crazy to think, a crowd can sing with a song with no lyrics. That's how you know it's an amazing song.

I've heard this song a million times but Kirk's guitar at 8:43 in that section gave me the most huge goosebumps in this version.

Really wish y’all would’ve listened to the studio version

@birddogz545

Жыл бұрын

This, the audio isn't very good on this video

@tallycahamuhlhetru26

Жыл бұрын

@@birddogz545 No it is not.

@rahbeat9785

Жыл бұрын

too late. first impression matters. been spoiled by this shitty live version

When you get a chance listen to anesthesia pulling teeth on kill em all. Then check out the video on S&M2 where the guy from the symphony gets to play it. You know that dude waited his whole life for that moment.

Please do the studio version of this for the fullest experience lol

This is the one of the best if not the best songs on MoP and the best instrumental in the 80s Also it’s called Oh Ri Yin Orion

Always a classic. But damn its tough to control the emotions when the bass solo kicks in. RIP Cliff

Ya'll should check out some Pantera. This is all preference of course, but I prefer Dimebag Darrell's guitar playing over Kirk and James. The mainstream intro to the band would be "Walk" but there are so many great songs to choose from by them. Personally, I would highly recommend "Domination" but you guys already did it 3 months ago. That breakdown at the end fueled my love for breakdowns early on in my metal journey. Maybe check out something like Cemetery Gates. It has some soul in it and some heaviness R.I.P Dimebag

@randywatson8347

Жыл бұрын

Yeah Pantera is dope.

Yall Mettalica and eminem reactions always got me geeked bro, congrats 👏 on all the 🎓 graduates in the car fam

You guys should definitely start a band. If you don’t give up you’re bound to succeed! With consistent, intense practice over a lifetime, talent is revealed.

Rob did a killer job playing this song

Lars is a beast. Always gets a lot of hate but he is the conductor to the Metallica train

@ericberkey6709

Жыл бұрын

Lars does take a lot of *&^ . People think they should replace him but there is no Metallica without him. Lars and James put together all the songs and then add in Kirk and Robert.

@wallaceh.9423

Жыл бұрын

@@ericberkey6709 💯

'Orion' was the instrumental on the 1986 album 'Master of Puppets'... (Metallica was from the 80's) It was largely the work of bassist Cliff Burton, who was killed in a tour bus accident in 1986 at age 24 and he was a schooled musician. If u listen to the studio version, there's the quiet section w/ bass that sounds like a cosmic soundtrack and a very sad, mournful solo from Kirk Hammett... It was almost like Cliff Burton had an inkling that he was not going to make it and this piece of music was him saying 'goodbye'. Cliff's sister Connie Burton said in an interview that her brother was not religious (as far as she knew... he loved smoking pot 😁) but often, she would see Cliff up every morning in their parents' house watching Bill Graham Ministries on TV and repeating a line about "the kingdom of salvation"... The members of Metallica also recalled Cliff would be talking about 'the kingdom of salvation' from Bill Graham ministries and wrote a short poem while he was alive. After he died, Metallica recorded 'To live is to die' in 1988 and added Cliff Burton's poem as a spoken word in the instrumental track.

I check your channel everyday to see if you guys did any more metallica........you made my day by doing this one

i was born and raised on these guys. i appreciate the reaction! be keeping an eye out for more reactions

You should check out, “Spit Out The Bone”. It’s off their 2016 album and FULL of energy throughout the entire song. Also a GREAT song to work out to with insane instrumentals

@Dasxol

Жыл бұрын

I couldn't agreed more with you than i already do

@0rionknight636

Жыл бұрын

Do the Bass Channel's bass cover of this song, sounds so fire

@mdott93

Жыл бұрын

I've been requesting this!!! One day hahaha

It's 100 times better the studio version, the song that never star and never ends, and orion gives you only 8 minutes of the song but enough to a human. The studio version has the cliff burton's ingenuity, a masterpiece that culminates the máster of puppets álbum. The Best disk of metal ever written

You guys should definitely check out the studio version of this. It's one of Metallica's best ever songs and the live versions, while great sometimes, just don't compare to the original studio version's sound quality imo

Ive never seen this love performance. This was incredible. I absolutely love this song

Gotta do the studio version first, in order to appreciate the live version

love that you guys have such a wide variety of reactions. it’s not just rap, but y’all really stretch out. great video!

You Rock guys!🤘🔥 Love u , more tallica reactions!

The live version is fire but y’all have to check out the studio version

I've been listening to Metallica for over 30 years. There are a lot of great songs to choose from in their catalog. I would say check out the videos for "One" and "The Unforgiven." Both songs have powerful videos that go along with the thought-provoking lyrics. Thank you Cartier Crew💕

@kylegonzales1402

Жыл бұрын

They already did both.

@Angela_Fleming

Жыл бұрын

@@kylegonzales1402 I'll have to check them out, thanks!

You guys rock. Thank you for this channel.

you guys should totally do slayer soon, south of heaven, raining blood, dead skin mask are some of my favorites

Cliff Burton was a musical genius, you HAVE to check out some Cliff solos. RIP Cliff.😢😢

RIP CLIFF BURTON!! The master bassist and composer of this song and to be honest it’s something Metallica hardly plays, it’s just a beautiful memory of the genius of Cliff Burton. He actually studied musical theory, and he’s a major part of the Metallica growth in how they wrote their music, REST IN POWER CLIFF 🌹❤️ When Metallica was inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, Metallica brought up RAY BURTON who is Cliffs father, and he was so gracious to Metallica and the fans, truly shows how the band takes care of “family”

You know you're doing well when a stadium sings along with your instrumental song

Love watching you guys discover these legendary songs. Metallica has been with me all my life. I’m happy to see them join yours

Haven’t seen this video but I hope you can appreciate the artistry of this song.

Y’all gotta react to anesthesia, another Metallica instrumental, specifically the 1983 live at the metro version

Shout to you guys from London Ontario Canada...keep up the good vids!

Cliff is one of the best bass players in history. Look, if you take the same song - Orion performed by him, it's just a masterpiece. Also check out the song - For whom the bell tolls (live) Cliff'Em All.💪

This is a GREAT studio song!! Our son's middle name is Lars (the drummer)!!

@BillKrayer12thMan

10 ай бұрын

That's awesome!! My cousin named her son Cliff in memory of Cliff Burton.

@reneeheknowsmyname6771

10 ай бұрын

@@BillKrayer12thMan ...... Nice!!

Metallicas instrumentals are next level. You dont see many other metal bands doing it and all of theirs are bangers. Rush is more rock than metal but they are next level, incredible musicians. YYZ by Rush is one of the greatest rock instrumentals ever, you should check it out!

@v.j.3029

Жыл бұрын

Rush’s La Villa Strangiato is also an epic instrumental piece.

@ComicHorder410

Жыл бұрын

@@v.j.3029 💯! I dont know if there are 3 more technically sound musicians in one rock band than the guys in Rush.

@redrick8900

Жыл бұрын

Rush is a snooze. It all sounds like rejected 80's sitcom theme songs.

@ComicHorder410

Жыл бұрын

@@redrick8900 Lol 40 million plus albums sold and pretty much every rock musician that has come since say you are wrong.

@redrick8900

Жыл бұрын

@@ComicHorder410 Nope. Plenty of Rock musicians say that exact same thing. That's where I got that. I didn't come up with it but it rang so true that I say it to other people. Most musicians think Rush is crap. That's why other bands don't copy their sound. The people that actually like them tend to be frat boys that don't play instruments.

Love love love!! Orion. It's mystically beautiful.

If y’all want insight to who cliff was watch their live For Whom the Bell Tolls from day on the green. Truly one of a kind

No live cover is going to replace the original studio version……ever 😂

You guys are avid listeners to Metallica, and really enjoy them. For that reason my pick for you guys is Avenged Sevenfold. They are definitely a spirited successor to the sound that Metallica created. S there library is extensive and I’m sure you guys will enjoy❤

@gabrielc3303

Жыл бұрын

YES!! They can start with Nightmare

@doxnreality7057

Жыл бұрын

Trivium would be a more direct comparison

You guys should watch For Whom The Bell Tolls Live at The Day on the Green 1985. RIP Cliff

I love you guys so much. For real. This gives me faith in humanity. Y'ALL Brothers actually get the brilliance and majesty of basically the greatest heavy metal band of all time - MetallicA I am a 48 yr old white dude from Seattle, and I have seen a lot....A LOT of rock music in my days and you guys attention to the mighty, the legendary Metallica....it just makes me happy my friends. I love you guys, and I only wish good things for you all. Much love, from Dave, in Seatlle. Go Sea Hawks......

The version on Master puppets is way better

Studio version is much more powerful

Good job guys, keep killing it!

Harvester of Sorrow is my personal favorite Pretty much sums up my life

ugh ... you guys ... make me experience ... RE-experience my first time hearing these songs ... so many nuances ... thank you for sharing and being open minded to old music hehe. Sometimes i feel like there is hope yet for people in this world. Thank YOU JESUS CHRIST!!!

I’m a music instructor, I teach bass, piano, and guitar. Two of my students actually performed this song on bass and guitar two months ago during a recital. Both teenagers. It’s cool to see u guys expanding your musical horizons, mad props. Also what u said was exactly on point. Everybody in the band has a job to do. The drummers job is to make sure the rhythm is solid, the guitar has to provide melody and harmony, the bass locks in with the rhythm of the drums and the harmony of the guitar to make them fit together, and the singer has to look good on stage lol.

I’m a year behind, but these videos are being pushed into my feed. I looked at what you guys are doing now and it’s nada like This. Hope you guys are all kicking butt still. Smashed that 👍🏽

"Leper messiah"......is another fan favorite.....studio version with lyrics......will blow your mind!

Hey guys, love that you guys have been going thru the Metallica catalog. I’m a drummer and it was this band that inspired me to drum. You guys need to do some “Tool” songs review or watches. Keep doing what y’all be doing. It’s cool to see people listen to these songs for the first time. Respect ✊🏽🤘🏽

Love all your reactions 😂

I've seen them 12 times starting 1986 all shows were mind blowing...

This is such a masterpiece ❤❤

The album version of this with Cliff Burton, listen to it at night on a long drive…. The absolute best!

This my favorite song I was at yankee stafium the 2nd time they ever played it in America...crzy and it was my first concert

Nice playing by Rob especially during that middle section like hearing the fingers on that part

Cliff Burton was the most talented member when they first got together back in the early 80s he wrote most of the stuff back then Cliff Burton was super talented. He was amazing.

Im 52 now but i ❤Metallica as a kid, still do, love Orion man!! 🤟

Love watching you guys. Videos for Halo on Fire and The Day That Never Comes are some more recent epics. Also, To Live Is To Die is an instrumental on their next album after Puppets, and it’s a tribute to Cliff. They’ve got a lot to check out!

It was tragic, Cliff Burton burns alive in a bus crash in the Netherlands. It's very emotional to listen to the guys retell the story, you can find it on KZread. He was the best, I was just graduating high school. I'll never forget the day I heard the news.

I could tell Tae and Solomon were having an experience! Love these videos.

Love it when the crowd is louder than the speakers

Cliff Burton Was, Is, and Always will be the Thunder of Orion. That song is the peak and culmination of Everything Cliff brought to Metallica to that point.

you guys have the most entertaining convos ever😭 “beethoven, michael jackson, youngboy..” 😭😭

If y'all like Metallica, check out any of Cliff Burtons live stuff. He was the Bassist who gave heart not only to Metallica while he was alive, but inspired generations of different players and sounds. RIP.

if you guys enjoyed that synchronized guitar lead, you should try to listen to Keeper of the Seven Keys, by Helloween, or maybe even Halloween by them too. they really go crazy with those solos. Great video guys, love your content!

Next video would love to see you react to ride the lightning or the thing that should not be. Great video as always guys.

I love playing this on both bass and regular guitar!

lots of Love and drive!!!!

I love to see these guys feelin it for metal! Way to rep the headbanger bands and rip Cliff! ML&R to you 🤘

I love yalls channel. When I subscribe to you guys you were only at like 13,000 subs. You always come with a good vibes. Love your metal reactions and your Tom McDonald reactions.. nothin but love.

Love you guys ! 🙏🏻🤘🏻

Luv these young cats.

This song saved my life I cry every time I hear it, Master Piece! Put on the head phones and turn that sh#t to eleven. After the ashes of drug addiction Metallica's 'Orion' and Ozzy's 'Changes' refilled my soul altering my life's course. RIP Cliff P.S. your new metal club assignment each one is to dawn the headphones and experience Orion's magic grab a chair buckle up.