Robin has the voice of an angel. His vocals is this song are my favorite of any singing I've heard in my lifetime. I cant get enough of Robin.

Robin's voice is to die for!!!!❤❤❤

I totally feel Robin takes this song with his gorgeous voice!! Allen has been their guitar player for many years!!❤❤❤

Definitely...one of the best!!! 3 of the sexiest, most talented men on earth, ever!!!

The full force of Robin on this one. I love this live version. They were so amazing. Sad that Mo & Robin are not here to see how another generation loves & appreciates them more than their contemporaries did for years. Barry seems to have come to terms with his grief & is able to bask in the love of so many fans

@sharonmerrow496

3 жыл бұрын

I've never heard this and have no idea who the 4th guy is.

@pearlegates7079

3 жыл бұрын

Alan Kendall , was their guitarist for many years.

@woodlark391

3 жыл бұрын

@@sharonmerrow496 I can't be certain, because their arms are covered -- it l👀ks like the fourth man is Barry's son, Steve. Please find "Barry Gibb's 2014 MYTHOLOGY Tour." There are some good ones on YT. Try this one...Steve shows up around 3+ mins in...Enjoy: kzread.info/dash/bejne/aYJqm6hmhtHQaKQ.html

@leniprof

3 жыл бұрын

@@woodlark391 It's Alan Kendall

@woodlark391

3 жыл бұрын

@@leniprof Thanks, Lenny...couldn't find my glasses!

The BeeGee are the best song they make sing along with them like the video and their voice

Need to hear robin voice listen to I started a joke or Massachusetts. Angelic voice

One of the best groups of all time and they wrote many songs for other artists. Robin has an amazing voice. I would love you to react to "i started a joke" brings tears to my eyes every time i hear it, please give it a go.

This is the best version of the song. Robin has a haunting voice, sooo beautiful and powerful, miss you very much. Thank you for sharing! Maybe you want to do -Rings around the moon- by Robin Gibb. ❤

@rwilson7197

2 ай бұрын

One of my faves... yes!❤

1967 version of To Love Somebody. I Started A Joke. You Win Again. Man In The Middle. Just to start with. 🥰🤣

Alone. Is one of my favourite BeeGees songs.

@Babsza

Жыл бұрын

Mine too and , you win again . There are so many though !

@LadyDoe17

Жыл бұрын

@@Babsza agreed. Love win again too.

One of my favorites....I love Robin's voice in this song. He just doesn't get enough credit, and Robin was one of the lead writers of their songs. just love your reactions, they are so honest and real. keep going down this rabbit hole young man, treasures to pass on to your children..keep the music alive.

@robertaclark3286

3 жыл бұрын

You're so right Karen, Robin didn't get enough credit. Robin owned this song.

The other guy is Alan Kendall. He joined the band in 1971 and played with them for over 30 years. You should watch the HBO documentary How Can You Mend a Broken Heart that came out in December of last year. He is featured, along with Barry, and a few engineers who worked with the Bee Gees as well. It’s a must see for anyone who loves their music.

@sarahlbeeney1920

Жыл бұрын

He also is an Australian..👌

For sure one of my favorites from them::. Love that it’s way later on their career. Like the song 🎵 “ALONE” it really just shows how they needed to change their music to keep up with the times and did so seamlessly and still managed to put out huge hits!

Great song. Alan Kendall, he was with them for a long time. Mo joked once he was with them longer than they were.

@maxmirni2768

Жыл бұрын

pure Mo - how funny is that !

After Fanny be Tender, I started a joke would be a good plan.

Number 1 in the UK 1993

@MystifiedSaint

3 жыл бұрын

The UK has far better taste in music than the US as far as the Bee Gees are concerned.

Reaching into the post disco period with this song. You have become a TRUE BeeGee fan. That's New York City, downtown (Manhattan). You can see the twin towers that were destroyed in the Sept 11 attack almost ten years after this video was shot.

ILOVE all the songs that they sing

Thanks Adogg! I just love Robin’s voice. You should do “I Started a Joke” from 1968 - features Robin singing lead. My friends and I sang that constantly as kids.

@brendamanley1785

11 ай бұрын

Two more great ones that Robin shines in are I Just Gotta Get A Message to you and Wedding Day...awesome

I agree with you Robins voice is greatness. The Background is the twin towers!!!! They can't disappoint me I love them all but for sure Barry owned a piece of my heart. I just love your reactions. When the sang How do you Mend a broken heart the were all in their 50s.

Never heard this one before. They still never disappoint. 💕💕

@trb2021

3 жыл бұрын

One of my favorites

@monaguedon7656

3 жыл бұрын

One of my absolute favorites !

Barry, Robin and Maurice 3 absolute geniuses 😆 wrote all their music 🎶 composed it and sang them all perfectly 🎶 I love ❤️ Robin’s voice his voice is unique, no one will ever come close to Robins voice all 3 are incredible on their own and extraordinary together, extremely talented!!

Love love love this one..gets me in my feelings for sure.

The best band I grew up with. They had hits in the 60’s 70’s 80’’ and 90’s and still sounded GREAT 🥰🥰

Just goosebumps galore from start to finish!!!!!

"For whom the bell tolls" is a fantastic song, a Masterpiece when Robin voice cames in his solo, it was amazing and give more powerful and emotion to this song In my personal opinion it's in my Top 10 of all Bee Gees songs could you included "Mr Natural" in your reactions? is an underrated song but for me a Masterpiece too

.... sigh.... You can see in the distance in the video, the World Trade Center..... There's nothing for it but to choke back a few tears. "There's a hole in my soul...." no kidding. Beautiful song. God Bless us, everyone.

Awesome! Two in one day!! Yep, Statue of Liberty is a dead give away. Lol. This song shows how long they were cranking out hits. Many, many years. Another great reaction!!😊

@Jonathan-iq3sg

6 ай бұрын

There is no way the Bee Gees could have known that capturing the Twin Towers in this video would make this song soo much more emotional.

Love Robin's voice.❤️❤️❤️

This is one of my favorites from them.

Oh my!, this is one of my favorite of the amazing Bee Gees. This is a great song, and especially when Robin comes in. His voice, oh my!

This is where the country is as a whole given all we have been through! God gives us hope and the love we all are hurting for..

Very lovely reaction. 🥰 They are special

My favorite Bee Gees song.

All that beegees Songs are great and sad too but I still love all the songs

The Bee Gees song catalog has over 2000 songs in it....have fun and enjoy AMAZING music....BEST group to EVER GRACE the music world. If you want to go back to their early years from the 60's listen to "Close Another Door" and "Jumbo" Jumbo has a riff in it that you will want to breath for Barry....I don't know how he did it without taking a breath but he did it.

Listen to Robin sing this song. His voice is so distinguishable. I love Robins voice and I love this song. Thank you.

Robin is singing "there's a hole in my soul". To me, it sounds like a tribute. American writer, Ernest Hemingway, wrote "For Whom The Bell Tolls'-- the book. The answer is "it tolls for thee." It's a superb book about the Spanish Civil War and the people who lived and died fighting. It was banned by many countries. Luv ya, Adogg. : O )

This is a beauty great reaction '' Fanny be tender '' really showcases their vocal range and harmonies .

Though the Bee Gees became known as the three brothers (their younger brother, Andy, who was a big solo star in his own right was due to join them just before he died in 1988, five days after his 30th birthday), they were originally the three elder brothers plus unrelated musicians playing drums and additional guitars, including this guitarist, Alan Kendall. A few of the lyrics of this song were purposely rewritten for marketing to sound like they're to an ex but they were actually initially inspired by losing their little brother and what he went through. This beautiful live performance was recorded in New York where the brothers were all at the time especially for broadcast on the BBC's Top of the Pops when the song went in at #4 in the UK charts.

I love you Robin. I miss you and Maurice. ❤️❤️❤️❤️

I can honestly say I love The Bee Gees but, I have never heard this song.🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

This is beautiful! My first time hearing too.

@le2800

2 жыл бұрын

Me too! And I thought I knew most of their recent songs, meaning anything after the 60s.

I love this dude so much. God bless you brother!

"Fanny be tender" Massachusetts. To love somebody. Omg I could go on and on.

Since you love this song so much, there’s two songs that I think you should listen to that are so good wind of change spirit tour and Fanny be tender with my heart you got to see that video awesome

My favorite For Whom the Bell Tolls and Massachusetts!❤

É de arrepiar

Check out:their early hits, including tear jerker “I started a joke”; “I’ve got to get a message to you”:“to love somebody” (covered by so many, most recently by K. Urban); & i think their 1st #1 “Massachusetts”

I love you man! Enough said. God bless you.

My favorite Bee Gee song ❤

This is one of my favorite Bee Gee song. Check out sticks and specks. And Robin sings lead is Massachusetts

Another great song by Bee Gees us Fanny be tender with my love. The vocals are incredible, no surprise there eh.

Please react to Bee Gees "Secret Love", "Words" and "You Win Again" Love your reactions, so real.

The Best! 🇮🇹♥️

Please listen to Bee Gees 1989 song named "One" . :)

The "4th guy" - Alan Kendall, long-time Bee Gees guitarist. He was in "Nights on Broadway" Midnight Special clip you'd viewed. Alan was previously with Eric Clapton's "Derek and the Dominoes" prior to his career with the Bee Gees. Robin Gibb always, always delivers a fantastic chorus/solo - If you want more hits from Bee Gees later years, "One" (1989) or "Alone" (1997)... Whatever the song, it touches your emotions, it's memorable... What an amazing legacy the Brothers Gibb have left the music industry!

Robin is my favorite because of his naturally higher singing voice. Whereas Barry would have to sing those high notes in his breathy falsetto, Robin could sing them in full voice. Having said that, though, those 3 brothers made some absolutely beautiful music together.

If you want to hear Robin you need to listen to I started a joke, Massachusetts, and my favorite from him run to me.

Go way back and watch when they were really young the song they are singing is To Love Somebody

The fourth guy is their lead guitarist who has been with them for years. I never understood why he was standing in the spot where Mo usually stands though. Because usually Mo is next to Robin. Do the Bee Gees songs "One", "Words", "Paying the price of love", or maybe "Warm ride " . They have so many great songs that you could play 3 songs a week for well over a year and still not play them all.

Great find! I've never seen this before! Thank you for sharing 😍 ... the best use of the internet to date

The song Immortality. With Celine Dion is another great one 💯👩🏼‍🦳

Great reaction again!! Love this song and the use of NYC with the Twin Towers in view-- For whom the bell tolls indeed!! In my top 11 to 20 or 21 to 30 (and so on)?? Bee Gees created masterpieces. Not a bad or "meh" song going to top 50. I haven't worked out my top 51 to 100 yet, so I may make additions. I figured the odds are they have lots more great songs.

Listen to You win again! One of my favorites!

And…i repeat, “Lonely Days”, their Beatles homage (which for years, i thought WAS the fab4)

My favorite

The other guy is their long-time lead guitarist Alan Kendall...sometimes referred to as the fifth Gibb brother.

Ñ canso de ouvir essa banda incrível! Que voz de Robin Gibb gente! Linda demais! Amo! Amo! Muito Lindo vídeo!❤❤❤❤👍👍👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷😍😍😍

I believe this song was written for their brother Andy. He sounded like Barry. But when he got famous he ended going down the path in life.

The 4th one is allan kendall. Hes played guitar with them since they started out.

Love Robin’s voice in this too! Even 20 years later than many of the hits you’ve listened to- they’re amazing! So upsetting that Robin and Maurice aren’t with us.

Barry and his lovely wife Linda are together now for 50 some odd years, five children, and can you all just imagine what Linda went through during their early years?? All those females throwing themselves all over Barry?? OMygoodness 😳🙂💓... Well, she stayed and endured it, and I'm the end there she was still loving her man. Linda you are truly amazing girl, I have the upmost respect for you sweetie...🎶🎶🎶

My favorite!

You win again is another great one from the bee gees

"Run to Me". Great song.

They said in an interview that this song was about Andy and Victoria.

That is their lead guitarist who has been with them pretty much forever.

This song was dedicated to their youngest brother, Andy Gibb who died at the age of 30.

Just do'em all 🤣👍

Robin and Barry are both lead singers in the group. Maurice also lead songs too.

We're one week away from the 20th anniversary of 9/11. I'm from New York and I miss my Manhattan Skyline. That's Rockefeller Plaza and my mom worked in the building on the left. 20yrs and it still feels like yesterday 😪 "Where were you when the world stopped turning?? 🇺🇸🙏

O guitarrista deles fica tão emocionado que tenho a impressão de que ele vai fazer piruetas no palco...

Please react to THIS IS WHERE I CAME IN live by the BEEGEES thanks

That is NYC, Brooklyn Bridge Park, I am there every week doing photography, never knew back then they videotaped this track there. Just beautiful!!

They change their music to go with the times but still go with their talent In Florida

That is their lead guitarist's. He had been with their band for years.

Robin from Bee Gees now deceased from cancer their youngest brother Andy was with Bee Gees went out on his own had few hits like I JUST WANT TO BE YOUR EVERYTHING died from cocaine O.D. maybe 79 but Barry had a great career writing producing singing back up oldest brother I no he Barry did work with M.J. they were hot in 70's n 80's!!!

@MystifiedSaint

3 жыл бұрын

Andy was not with the Bee Gees. Barry guided him out on his own as a teenager. He also didn't die of a drug O.D. He died of myocarditis, an inflammation of the heart muscle which was caused by a recent viral infection.

PERFECTLY sung in NEW YORK ! After 9ll😢

❤️❤️❤️❤️ keep playing The Bee Gees!! Can’t help but smile! If you want to hear Maurice sing lead watch Closer than close! Great song!!!

The fourth man playing lead guitar is the only other official Bee Gee. That is, he is an official member of the band and not simply an employee.

Fannie be tender with my love. My all time favorite! Like most of their music there’s a climatic part to it when their voices just go up to heaven and back.🥰😊🥰

@kathystammen8774

3 жыл бұрын

I have seen a lot of people react to the Bee Gees and you my friend are my most favorite because your face lights up like a Christmas tree when you hear them

Alan Kendall... He was with them a lot of years.... Robin hit the song out of the park... He is my only love....

Bee Gees"Bodyguard,and Barbra Streisand and the BeeGees bacjup "Promises.Barbra and Varry duets"Guilty" ,and "What kind of Fool".

Fallen Angel from the same album, Size Isn't Everything, is another good Robin lead.

NYC.

Takes my thoughts straight to Andy and I always cry. ( Reminds of The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald by Gordon Lightfoot when the bell chimed for each man that died) Ironic too seeing the twin towers in the background.

This video is definitely THE BEST‼️❤️

Robin RIP!!