Hope everybody is having a good Monday, we got that extra 1 hour of sleep to help get us through our day! Let me know down below if you like this live track or the studio version of this song more! Don't forget to like, comment, subscribe! And most importantly, don't forget to have a great rest of your day and hopefully week, see you guys tomorrow! :)

This song has always been "from chaos to order" in my opinion. It starts off chaotic and without much order, and then settles into a beauty you just didn't see coming. I picture the birth of the universe.

@etiennetrasbo9022

Жыл бұрын

I've always pictured a battle. With the first chaotic part being the tragedy, the middle drum part being the actual battle, and the beautiful end as after the battle.

The last part called "Celestial Voice", from this version, turned me into a sucker for organ sound.

This album has the coolest album cover I've ever seen. Matches the trippy ass music

7:52 Best part! Richard Wright at his best!

@dougmphilly

4 жыл бұрын

Grimme1984 this was I think lots of us were so pissed at how roger treated rick towards the end.

This is my favorite off of Ummagumma live. I knew this version before the original... I was rather disappointed when I got to hear the original, since the epicness of the last section was missing. Not that it was bad in the original, but here they managed to provide a whole different feel. The middle drum section is also a lot more appealing to me in this version. Ready for some weird shit on wednesday?

@andyandalex

5 жыл бұрын

Polux Saurus My man, I am more than ready! I’m pretty open minded as an individual so I may dig it, we’ll see! Haha! 🔥

@BeeBumper

5 жыл бұрын

A lot of their early works sound way better live, more crisp and more depth.

I like the studio tracks, as well. Remember a Day, written, I believe, by Richard Wright, is especially, close to my heart.

Your reactions are the best!

@andyandalex

5 жыл бұрын

philip townley Thanks man I appreciate that! I just sit back and try to enjoy the music as if I’m not even recording, trying to give you guys the most genuine response I possibly can, loving the music so far, can’t wait to continue! Cheers! 🔥😁

I just love it

Epic track

Pls check the Live at Pompeii version of this song as well as Set the Controls played in a Church. Would be a treat!

Yeah, that's quite something, that track. Wait till you see it live at Pompeii, you will love that, I guarantee!

@andyandalex

5 жыл бұрын

Trevor Ayton Can’t wait for us to start doing live shows! 🔥😁

@TheBlackQueen

5 жыл бұрын

@@andyandalex Yeah, the Pompeii version is the best version!

It looks like a saucerful of secrets is blowing your mind as mine was blown when i heard it for the first time. I consider Ummagumma to be the greatest Pink Floyd album of them all.

Wait until you see them do it on the Pompeii video! LOL

saw them play this in 1971 in the pouring rain. beautiful

After seeing your reaction to celestial sound with David Gilmour’s ahhhhhhhhhhahhhh i felt that goosebump

I might be in the minority here, but neither the studio, "Ummagumma", or Pompeii versions are my favorite. I've heard some live bootlegs where Rick has crazy echo sound effects going on with his keyboard, and David gets even more intense with the guitar playing. "Rolf's Pepperland Bomb" is one bootleg I recall where it really stood out to me. 20 minutes long, and much better sound quality than here, too. I'm guessing Rick's new keyboard was introduced in 1970, which is when the performance is from. And I always felt this track was weak on the guitar during that middle section, but man, David really kicked it up in one of the versions I heard. Nick Mason also locks into a groove and gets progressively faster during the performance. The reason people love the Pompeii version so much is due it being a video, but during the middle section, Rick plays random piano chords just like the studio version, and David does some minimal guitar noise that can barely be heard in the mixing, so it's not what I'd call definitive without the visual element. I do love all of them for different reasons, though. By the way, you'll be interested to know that the studio side of the album is full of solo pieces by each band member, and the first one "Sysyphus" is completely a solo piece by Rick Wright!

@andyandalex

5 жыл бұрын

psychedelicpiper Hey man, well said! And I love it when you get to really get a taste of Richard Wright’s creativity and abilities, so I’m excited! 😁🔥

@donlebo6824

5 жыл бұрын

I concur, I've heard bootleg versions, that could get downright eerie and you can hear the quadraphonic effects swirling. The Floyd when they were on and tight, could really cook up the atmosphere.

@mikehawkertz9237

5 жыл бұрын

I’m gonna have to check that version out!

@donlebo6824

5 жыл бұрын

@@andyandalex Hey, have you checked out CAN or other german bands like Neu! or Amon Duul 2 or Faust? If you haven't I recommend you do so. Can are my faves of the bunch, but all have great stuff.

@fatfox57

5 жыл бұрын

@@donlebo6824 Can is a good suggestion. Granted how Andy has taken like a fish to water to the way Floyd's longer pieces are structured into phases or movements, and that he appreciates Nick Mason's contribution in regulating the transitions, maybe it's time for him to compare and contrast Jaki Liebezeit's role in Can's complex compositions. Though it's a long piece (at nearly 20 minutes) to choose as your first taste of a band, I'd suggest that he might find Bel Air from the Future Days album an immersive ride.

I like how you didn't interrupt it by pausing it and you genuinely like it.

Pretty good song for understanding why drugs and Floyd go together.

Saw them do this in Carnegie Hall, May 2nd 1972, tickets were three dollars. There were six of us, we got our own booth, first tier, stage center left.

I always liked how they replaced the organ with a voice at the end.

The definitive version.

I remember as a kid looking at the Ummagumma album at the record store, thinking about buying it when I was about 10 or 11 years old. I didn't know any of the songs at the time. Instead I bought Surrealistic Pillow by Jefferson Airplane and the first Buffalo Springfield album. Ummagumma would have been a little weird for me at that time. A few years later and I was jamming to Yessongs.

I'm probably one of the few who actually like the studio version a bit more. That said, I still think this version is fantastic and a great way to complete the live part of "Ummagumma". I feel the studio version is more ethereal, maybe artistic and takes you on a further journey (and those angelic voices are truly awesome). I suspect the fact that live version is so much more energetic gives it broader appeal which is quite understandable. My Pink Floyd collection would be incomplete without both versions.

@andyandalex

5 жыл бұрын

thegalaxybeing Very well said my friend! The angelic vibes from the voices do hit me harder on the studio version!

Viagem ao insólito...caramba!!!!!

you loved the last Deep Purple try this one live ( Deep Purple - Highway Star 1972 Video HQ ). thanks.🎸

@andyandalex

5 жыл бұрын

albertzappa I’m down! I think I’m going to try and do some more studio songs by them but I’ll for sure get around to doing live shows! I just think I’ll appreciate them live more if I hear some more of their stuff, thanks for the suggestion I added it to the list! 🔥😁

@psychedelicpiper999

5 жыл бұрын

@@andyandalex Is it just me, or does the studio production for "Machine Head" make the songs sound weaker than the live versions? Just my observation. Sounds too commercial. The "Made in Japan" live versions absolutely blew them away. I recall "Fireball" being my favorite studio album. It's been a long time since I've visited Deep Purple.

@ANationalAcrobat

5 жыл бұрын

@psychedelicpiper Their live sound on albums like ”Made in Japan” and ”Scandinavian Nights” is superior to studio albums for sure. To me ”Machine Head” sounds almost poppy after raw ”In Rock” album.

You're right about Nick Mason, and you can only really tell that from their live recordings, which in the 1968-1971 period were particularly impressive

@andyandalex

5 жыл бұрын

Simeon Teitelbaum For sure! He’s going on tour this coming year and I’m super excited! He’ll be playing a lot of older Floyd, my girlfriend and I can’t wait! 🔥😁

@simeonteitelbaum3673

5 жыл бұрын

@@andyandalex I've seen his band play and they're tremendous. They're managed to breathe new life into those songs and play them with energy and verve

@simeonteitelbaum3673

5 жыл бұрын

Well I've seen them on youtube lol

@andyandalex

5 жыл бұрын

Simeon Teitelbaum That’s amazing! I’m not going to check anything out, I’m gonna just see them live and let them blow me away, they’re coming to Florida next year, I may do a vlog with my girl as we’re going to the show, we’ll see! 😁

Lol, back in the day, these earlier Floyd albums were usually listened to when tripping on acid ... I find it interesting that people even listen to these now...this early stuff wasn't so much music as they were "acid aids " . I find them hard to listen to now, 55 years later, and in my right mind. Love all their stuff, but these earlier are better on acid. 😆

Did yoy try PINK FLOYD - LIVE AT POMPEII ???

@andyandalex

5 жыл бұрын

Pim Sluiter I have not! Many have said that was an amazing show though, we’ll have to get around to it!

@pimsluiter4554

5 жыл бұрын

@@andyandalex Thanks for you're respons,...it is a concert without any audience,..in an old roman amphitheatre wich was dig out after a vulcano eruption 2000 years ago,..the whole town of pompeii was buried under vulcano ashes, ,..pink floyd play some of their old songs like,..medle part 1 and 2 set the controls,..becarfull with that axe,..sausefull of secrets one of these days,...etc 50 minutes film I think,...let me know when you saw the movie,..thanks

@andyandalex

5 жыл бұрын

Pim Sluiter For sure! Thanks for the back story! 😁

@BeeBumper

5 жыл бұрын

@@andyandalex Yes do yourselves a solid and watch it all, some of their early works done live in the amphitheater in Pompeii without an audience (just imagine the logistics to get electricity to the site). They did all their greatest older songs live and shot it. It was as if they were marking a line in the sand while they were putting together the Dark Side of the Moon at the time.

Have you heard Pink Floyd's "Echoes" yet?

@andyandalex

5 жыл бұрын

Donna Ransom Perhaps a snip at some point but I’ve never actually heard the song, excited to listen to it once we get to Meddle! 🔥😁

@donnaransom3770

5 жыл бұрын

@@andyandalex I think "Fearless" is on Meddle too. Enjoying your reactions to my favorite band😊

@andyandalex

5 жыл бұрын

Donna Ransom I believe my girlfriend showed me Fearless a while back, but I can’t recall much about it, can’t wait to continue on! Glad you enjoy the reactions! 🔥😁

@euronymous2487

5 жыл бұрын

@@donnaransom3770 See at anneliese Michel 6 demons in rock

HEY ANDY,CHECK "Into the void" BY BLACK SABBATH'S ALBUM (Master of reality) Sorry for my bad english,im Brazilian 👍

@andyandalex

5 жыл бұрын

fRedd You’re good! And I’m doing all the albums for Black Sabbath in order! 😁🔥

@drfre4400

5 жыл бұрын

@@andyandalex Thanks man!😆

Can you imagine hearing this as a teen in the 60s, your mind must have been blown away. I'm not one of those "music was better back then, I was born in the wrong generation" fags but it's hard to find magic like this in todays music. Hopefully in the future we can get to other Prog bands like Rush or Genesis, the stuff I heard yet is amazing.

@andyandalex

5 жыл бұрын

J. Well said, I agree completely, I can’t find much modern artists that produce music with this type of creativity, it’s crazy. Thanks for watching man! 😁🔥

@ANationalAcrobat

5 жыл бұрын

Back in time the thing was to be somehow unique. I’m not saying that all the bands sounds the same today, because they don’t. But still I think the golden days of creativity and experience were in the 60’s and 70’s.

@andyandalex

5 жыл бұрын

NationalAcrobat Back when psychedelic substances were being introduced to those who cared to partake. 😉

Seeing that we are educating you here is 2 bands we need to talk to you about. One RORY Gallagher, an Irish guitarist who was possibly the best guitarist in the world, try any of these 3 albums for starters , Live in Europe, Irish tour and stage struck, all 3 are live, Gallagher was phenomenal live, out of these 3 albums 'Moonchild ' on stage struck would be my favourite by a country mile, his solo is just mind blowing. His live performances are legionary and was more a live artist than a studio one, the studio sound does not live up to his live work.. Although now deceased and buried in Cork Eire His music is still alive with numerous tribute bands playing his music live all over europe. Try this u-yube link to a Rory performance of moonchild kzread.info/dash/bejne/ma182896qLi8osY.html 2nd 'Santana'; Where do we start with Santana? Look up their break through performance at Woodstock ( 1969) volume 3 (Their 3rd album was known as Volume 3) track 3 remains possibly one of their best tracks in my humble opinion, they have to be up there with Floyd without any doubts but a total different sound, lets see what the opinion is amongst your followers here is regards ian derby UK

@andyandalex

5 жыл бұрын

Ian Loasby Thanks for the pro tips man, sounds dope, will have to look into them! Cheers! 🔥😁

Pink Floyd's particular unholy trinity - Interstellar Overdrive, Saucerful Of Secrets...and the third one is coming up next! It's impossible to choose between the studio and U-g versions, but I tend to remember the “outline” of the live version, and some details from some "other" (meaning ROIO) live versions. It reminds me - this very trippy non-lp cut you may not have heard yet kzread.info/dash/bejne/mXltyLOEgMvSl9o.html

@andyandalex

5 жыл бұрын

Grithron2 Thanks! And yeah I loved them both for different reasons!

Hey its me. I had previously offered if you wanted a copy of the Live at Pompeii show to react to, and you asked to DM you for your email address so I could send it to you. The problem is that I don't know how to get in contact with you privately to exchange emails. Do you have a Twitter or Amino I could contact you on? (If not, I'd suggest getting an Amino account because we have a Pink Floyd community you could join. Just a side note). But I'm not able to Private Message on KZread or anywhere else. If not, I could simply just comment my Email address and you could email me. I'll delete the comment after that. Only if necessary and/or the only option.

@andyandalex

5 жыл бұрын

The Black Queen Hey I just made an Amino, I’d love to join the community, it’s called AndyReacts! 😁🔥

@TheBlackQueen

5 жыл бұрын

@@andyandalex aminoapps.com/c/pink-floyd I'm the leader there

Pompeii is even better!

Pompeii version is best.

Am I the only person to appreciate this album. Such a great album it’s much better than more and the albums after the final cut, those albums just sucked. First, they just have that horrible production to them second, this is also invoked with the production but I feel the reverb was unnecessary, third it was just weak albums no song on there except high hopes grabbed my attention. The more albums great too but I feel that the instrumental songs destroyed the album from being a really great album. In conclusion I fell this albums a masterpiece that should be appreciated more than it should be underrated as fuck.