There's one guy at the writer's room who's job is just asking "but what if the players killed them?"

@ProxyGateTactician

9 ай бұрын

I love the idea of that lol I want to be in that room

@chillinginthenameof

3 ай бұрын

If there's that one person, then they know their D&D players very, very well. 😂

@SaHaRaSquad

2 ай бұрын

The reverse bus factor - how many NPCs do you have to get rid of till the game gives up?

@GregerMoek

2 ай бұрын

Wasn't this what they called their own internal "n+1" system? Or maybe I understood that poorly. In DOS they had this as well, you could always continue the story no matter how murderous you were. There was always an animal or some sign or a book or something laying around to lead you to the right path even if you killed the whole town that gives out quests.

@Logovanni

13 күн бұрын

But what if the players killed HIM?

I'm pretty sure the replacement tieflings for the Saved the Grove party are also the ones that show up as corpses during the Raided the Grove party.

@ProxyGateTactician

9 ай бұрын

that's a fun little detail

@T3hIluvatar

9 ай бұрын

Larian getting their bang for their buck with these background characters

@S3Cs4uN8

9 ай бұрын

@@ProxyGateTactician Back having just made it to the goblin party. I can now confirm that the substitute tieflings do appear as corpses should you side with the goblins.

@ProxyGateTactician

9 ай бұрын

@@S3Cs4uN8 really cool to know thanks for sharing.

@faerie_willow

9 ай бұрын

You are correct, they are!

I don't know if you still read comments on older videos, but I may have found an NPC not too many people have seen. If you go on a date with Karlach you interact with the Orc waiter Henk from the The Singing Lute tavern. So I wondered what would happen if you killed him before Karlach invites you to the date. No date? Henk resurrected? Your dinner plates being carried by empty air? Turns out Henk has a brother (?), Honk, who takes his place. He looks similar but has different hair. Karlach even calls him Honk, so they had the VA record an extra line just in case some annoying player killed Henk. Henk isn't involved in any quest (afaik) and never leaves his tiny tavern, so the chances of people killing him are small. Honk doesn't even exist in the world (probably to make sure he doesn't get killed) and is only mentioned in letters with Henk. The only way to meet Honk is to be in a romance with Karlach and to kill Henk before karlach invites you to the date. So I'm guessing most people never saw Honk or even know he exists.

@ProxyGateTactician

7 ай бұрын

That’s so awesome thanks for sharing! I’ll add it to my list of chars I might make a follow up with a bunch of these chars. Sounds like very few people would have seen this char for sure

@IsilionNELE

7 ай бұрын

@@ProxyGateTactician I found another rarely encountered NPC (I think). Did you know Dror Ragzlin is in act 2? Well, "Zombie Dror Ragzlin" is. This wasn't even on the wiki (which I've now updated as much as I could)

@natedogg5671

5 ай бұрын

that's funny because I'm doing my first playthrough and I stole his body. It's currently in my camp@@IsilionNELE

@Roccondil

4 ай бұрын

@@IsilionNELE Zombie Minthara as well can appear in Act 2, If you leave Balthazar alive during the Nightsong quest.

@IsilionNELE

4 ай бұрын

@@Roccondil Yes and zombie Dror Ragzlin too, but this fight only happens when you pray at the altar of the absolute. It was mentioned in another comment on another video. Proxy Gate Tactician made a video about it: "Baldur's Gate 3 - 10 of the Most Secret Encounters You Probably MISSED" You can even find zombie versions of yourself and companions

Ya know I think the original two Baldur's gate games had the first of these fail safes I've seen, and by far my favorite way of handling these situations, with Biff the Understudy. If a character who was suppose to be there and for some reason couldn't be, Biff would show up and deliver their lines.

@Sorain1

8 ай бұрын

Which, if you managed to be particularly prolific in your killing, could mean Biff talking to himself.

@daviddaugherty2816

6 ай бұрын

Biff even shows up in-story in BG2. He's in the playhouse in the bridge district, mangling Haer'dalis's lines in the play he's too kidnapped to be in.

@teaz3139

6 ай бұрын

Biff was only in BG1. BG2 didn't have him except as a cameo.

@weebjeez

4 ай бұрын

​@@teaz3139so... Biff WAS in BG2, then?

@lilyivey5933

4 ай бұрын

that's actually hilarious

Things can get really buggy in Act III. I think that some of this makes sense though. Act I and Act II give you a ton of freedom to mess around and do things in very nonconventional ways. This is amazing. The problem is that Act III was meant to be a huge story act in its own right while also tying up all the loose ends. It would be virtually impossible for the devs to think of every possible scenario that players could come up with and I think this is why we see so many of these broken quests/dialogues once we enter Act III. It's sort of like trying to take your kids' fingerpaintings and create a masterpiece from them. It's pretty clumsy and outright falls flat on its face at times. The good news is that Larian seems to be committed to continuing to work on the game.

@jg113

9 ай бұрын

the same goes for corpses, in act 1 you can nearly talk to any corpse around in act 2 its like 3-4 orf them

@tylr3669

9 ай бұрын

Yeah that tracks. I did a lolth sworn evil run drow and act 1 was pretty solid. act 2 there's significant portions of the area that just die off or are massive fights with no interaction available. act 3 has references to the people we fought in act 2 who never spoke to us, and my companions have opinions that shouldn't be possible as we've never met these npcs before. This run is seriously borked....

@xixixi8483

9 ай бұрын

@@tylr3669 just give it some time, larian will patch it out eventually, my the time definitive edition comes out it will be fixed

@GiveMeTheRice

9 ай бұрын

There’s this one Tiefling girl named Karissa that I saw the corpse of 3 different times while going through act 1 and 2, then when I finally made it to act 3, she was having a grand old time at a bar drinking and shit. I like to just imagine she’s a secret main character of a different story who had to keep save scumming

@mel-burnes

9 ай бұрын

​@@GiveMeTheRicecould also pretend they're triplets whose parents were assholes when naming the kids

The only time I met Cerys was when I freed Zevlor in the Mindflayer colony and she joined the battle...... all the way from Last Light Inn. Like she rolled for initiative and but she took her turns in Last Light Inn

@Idziemel1

9 ай бұрын

Same thing happened to me, except I met her before in Last Light.

@Sharkamfss

3 ай бұрын

You might not remember it since it's been 5 months, but did your screen turn black and loaded in Last Light to show you her turn? How did it play out?

@watan_5913

3 ай бұрын

This happened to me only a couple days ago, she just sprinted until she got to the rooftop and then kept skipping her turn. Still annoying since it had yo load her in each time ​@Sharkamfss

@itslydiabxtch

2 ай бұрын

I noticed this happened to me when I was freeing the Dwarfs & Tieflings from the prison

If you enjoyed this video be sure to check out The top 10 Weirdest Spells in Baldur' Gate 3 kzread.info/dash/bejne/qnikucxumJXOido.htmlsi=O_jwCYJutNpZO4Qb Patch 3 Update: Cerys will not talk about Zevlor if he died in Act I.

@dylan9186

9 ай бұрын

larian really is on top of their patch-game

@Songfugel

9 ай бұрын

This was not that uncommon, since he could easily get killed during the goblin attack or by siding with tieflings, then almost always Zevlor will he butchered by the druids before you can run to his help (since they fight outside of turn based)

@nickrizzo7901

9 ай бұрын

so for me it was the young tiefling you save in the grove who told me, even though zevlor was dead, that he had been leading the tieflings through the shadowlands. didnt have to do anything crazy just played a solo save and most of the tiefling didnt live the battle vs the goblin, including zevlor, whom everyone mourned

@mirabletest

9 ай бұрын

@@dylan9186 3 years after the game got its first release tho

@Baalsham

9 ай бұрын

@@Songfugel yeah, I kicked major butt in that fight but he still died. The goblins focused him hard for some reason, there was no saving him. Kinda figured he was an expected death, but i guess not.

In case anyone was wondering for science purposes I did kill all the characters to check if they had any unique loot, but there was nothing special.

@Fracture.Gaming

9 ай бұрын

Well, if it was for science...

@chriseash6497

9 ай бұрын

So Gale doesn’t count?

@Rabijeel

9 ай бұрын

I found a lot of uncommon Things in Act1. Mostly Potions and some Equip.

@Avendros

9 ай бұрын

It's easier to check for unique items by just pickpocketing them. If they drop any unique items, they are in there too!

@DovahVokuna

9 ай бұрын

It’s not really original. This game is a big wink to BioWare games. They did this in Mass effect 3 for instance if characters died in ME2. Nice video though

The fact you can have unique interactions with very specific failsafe characters is just amazing.

Considering that apparently only a few people were to see it, I honestly found it strange considering Zev died in my playthrough because he got killed during the goblin assault in act 1. It def feels like an oversight on their part because when he's brought up I'm constantly questioning, "Why are you talking about a guy who got eaten by spiders like he was still around?"

@thurmanstevenson5692

9 ай бұрын

😂 same

@swancrunch

9 ай бұрын

And also other way around - when you knock someone down instead of killing them - everyone thinks you're murderer. but you're not, you're batman, they all alive and well, look.

@yellowbirdie7182

9 ай бұрын

@@swancrunchthey die of untreated internal bleeding later on in the game

@Lunamana

8 ай бұрын

​@@swancrunchI tried to knock people out for roleplay reasons but quickly came to realize it's no different from killing them, it's a shame but it is what it is, toggling non lethal is pretty much worthless except for a few very specific instances

@HunterX57

7 ай бұрын

I recently started Lei'zel redemption playthrough, and found that you had to have the Orpheus Discs in Tav's inventory and then talk to her to get her to acknowledge them, but I found this out after wiping out the creche, and agreeing to help Voss, but her lines are all still "blasphemy against Vlaakith", as if she was reading them pre-mountain pass events.

There were a fair few broken dialogue flags in act 3 if you do things out of order. Also sometimes if you lie to a character all other companions will behave like you were bound to follow through on that lie.

@mattc9598

9 ай бұрын

(SPOILERS FOR ACT 3) I specifically denied a certain devil's contract to free a certain Githyanki, and then got yelled at by Gale for... accepting the contract? I'm going to start writing down these bugs and reporting them, seems only fair given how much work was put into this game

@Albatorwow

9 ай бұрын

** SPOILERS ** Yeah many broken flags can be found in act 3 still, I did the Iron Throne part of Gortash's Quest before doing the Hellfire Watcher Foundry, and when back in camp to talk to Duke Ravengard, Wyll was crying to me that we absolutly needed to save his father and the gnomes down there before they drowned... But your dad is right there my dude! ( just dont talk to wyll in that instance, talking to ravengard brings the flags back to normal )

@michasokoowski6651

9 ай бұрын

@@mattc9598 This bug was already fixed

@nyarparablepsis872

9 ай бұрын

​@@mattc9598Got the same issue. I've started making a list of these things.

@jorgeporras9262

9 ай бұрын

I can't remember too many specific instances but I remember quite a few broken dialogues in Act 2 as well. I think I had a few with Ketheric when I got key info about him from other people but then dialogues still popped up asking things I had been told twice or thrice about him as if it was the first time I had heard about them. And some Halsin and Jaheira dialogue options that never went away. A friend also got Astarion's bite scene and vampire reveal out of order twice in two different playthroughs. And there's also a lot of bugged romance dialogues, especially with characters noting that you're gonna sleep with other characters you just rejected during the camp party. Characters pretending they have something with you or even slept with you even after you rejected them harshly. And characters in Act 3 still pushing for romance after you've set things in stone with another monogamous partner, and the pushy character then feeling insta-betrayed because you're dating another person.

I had Cerys the whole time since Zevlor died in the grove battle (and Asharak too I guess?) but she still talked about Zevlor as if he survived into Act 2 before abandoning the Tieflings, same with Arabella and her parents, they also talked about Zevlor like that. The quest to find Zevlor did update when I traveled back to the Grove to his body, so despite the continuity break my game was otherwise unaffected

@ProxyGateTactician

9 ай бұрын

ohh I didn't think about going back for his body. I wonder what would happen if I just threw it on the floor of the tavern when I walk in there lol

@TrollANIMU

9 ай бұрын

@@ProxyGateTactician I was honestly so confused and was like " surely he didn't get resurrected somehow" because I distinctly remember trying to revive him after the battle because that's how I learned you can only resurrect party members. Another strange thing that had happened was that Gale died in that battle too, his projection gave me his revival instructions, but initiating the celebration just revived him and Gale spoke to me as if I followed his instructions afterwards. Curious if initiating the celebration just revives dead party members or I just had a strange bug.

@demetroid6378

9 ай бұрын

@@TrollANIMU After having been the only survivor out of my coop party after the goblin attack, I can confirm that the celebration just straight up brings people back from the dead.

@brick7560

9 ай бұрын

​@@demetroid6378Damn, musta been one banger of a party

@phatymcdaddy

9 ай бұрын

​@@TrollANIMUhe also responds as if you did his little backup trick if you revive him with and already existing revivify scroll

It's probably not that rare, but if you play as Lae'zel, they have a replacement githyanki to help you through the nautiloid. He then becomes one of the very few playable characters to die from falling out of the nautiloid. Also, if you fail to save Shadowheart on the nautiloid (with a wisdom check of 2), she can be found trying to break through the locked door on the beach and is thankful that you at least tried. Edit: if you ask Volo for help after accepting Auntie Ethel's help, the game won't let you go through with the procedure as you only have one normal eye already. Edit: this is the first time one of my comments has had more than about 10 likes and its at 400 and still going.

@aouyiu

6 ай бұрын

Shadowheart even has unique dialogue when you save her from the pod, but either leave her alone or tell you to part ways on the nautiloid, when she's by the gate on the ground. They really thought of everything..... in Act One that is. Unfortunately the same cannot be said for Act Two and especially Act Three. It makes sense, they had years of Act One in early access. This could change in the future though knowing Larian, but it was upsetting to see. They've fixed a lot of this now, they've changed the game a lot since August 4th. Lol, there's even unique dialogue when you save her and party with her on the nautiloid, but never wake her up on the beach.

@barkasz6066

6 ай бұрын

Yeah Shadowheart has like 4 insertion points in act 1. One is the beach, the second at the door, third at the Grove and fourth just before the mountain pass.

@muffinconsumer4431

6 ай бұрын

If you kill shadowheart after freeing her, then revive her, she runs to the next room and her mind collapses, locking her out of being a companion. Weird as hell

@Goremize

6 ай бұрын

@@aouyiu It really feels that way, hopefully after some time the cut content can be added (Like the upper city and Avernus and there actually being consequences for the Tadpole such as daisy which was all removed).

@jeremyjoe7494

5 ай бұрын

This was how I got to meet Shadowheart. I was heartbroken when I rolled a nat1 on her and thought I lost a character, but I didn't want to reload the game during my only playthrough so I kept on going and there she was, waiting for me on the beach.

the effort and every small detail in this game truly makes this game a masterpiece

In Rimworld, when all of your colonists die due to "reasons"... a man in black with random stats and equipment appears on the map as your failsafe and final straw.

@ProxyGateTactician

9 ай бұрын

Oh yeah the man in black! He's a chance encounter but pretty high chance. I love that game. over 800 hours in it too lol

@rubiolo1019

9 ай бұрын

damn, i never full wiped without save scumming or just quitting so i never noticed but I saw it was an option to summon him with the mod Vanilla Expanded : Achievements and thought it was like the man in black in fallout even tho i never once saw him appear lol

@SpicyFiur

9 ай бұрын

@@ProxyGateTactician Don't expect to play more. Rimworld is made with Unity after all.

@Relseg

9 ай бұрын

@@SpicyFiur That unity debacle is just stupid as shit, whoever came up with that idea, and whoever approved it and thought it was fine, they all need to get their brain checked for malformations. Moreover they are stupid enough to say that in the case of something like Microsoft which is subscription based, they will charge Microsoft, as if Microsoft won't just delete all unity games and prohibit them.

@ProxyGateTactician

9 ай бұрын

@@SpicyFiur that’s sad

It's amazing how much detail is put into act 1 I don't even complain about the bugs i've seen in act 3, this game is so complex, they're doing the best anyone could

@ninjificus

9 ай бұрын

Hopefully they do flesh out the other 2 though because they feel so much emptier after the experience that is Act 1

@homeboi9794

9 ай бұрын

@@ninjificus Gotta wait for BG3: Definitive Edition then 😉

@tylr3669

9 ай бұрын

That's bc act1 had all the early access players. I had over 100 hours just running it with diff characters and roles. act1 is polished well. 2 is kinda ok. 3 is all borked up.

@mattc9598

9 ай бұрын

@@tylr3669 act 2 and 3 didn't have early access? I had never heard of the game until 2 weeks ago, just assumed it was all open. It really shows if that is that case; Act 1 had zero bugs, Act 3 I've had multiple times where somebody talks to me about a choice I made, but I never made that choice

@tylr3669

9 ай бұрын

@@mattc9598 yep. Early access has had act1 more or less unchanged for a year. 2 and 3 were hard locked.

It was so weird losing a lot of tieflings when fighting minthara and the goblins and making it to act 2 only to meet a bunch of tieflings I'd never seen before XD. Also another bug is that if you play as the dark urge and cut off gale's hand astarian still talks about how they'll have to tell him about the magic shop in act 3

@TheFeelTrain

9 ай бұрын

I wasn't even playing Durge, I'm just a dumbass who missed Gale in my first playthrough and Astarion said the same thing. I am doing multiple playthroughs so I knew of Gale from that, but technically if someone did what I did completely blind they would have no idea who this Gale person is lol.

@santosic

9 ай бұрын

@@TheFeelTrain I killed Shadowheart on my Githyanki playthrough at the beach, after not rescuing her in the nautiloid in the first place (so not even Lae'zel interacted with her since I didn't even touch her pod at all), and for most of the game it was fine, she was never mentioned at all. Act 3, though, lots of minor NPCs important to her storyline mention her by name as if she's still around, and my companions mentioned her too when I ultimately ended up not killing Mother Superior. Strangely, I got bugged out here the most because immediately the game seemed to think I betrayed Shadowheart, with all my companions calling me for it (including Lae'zel), but they never met her and she was never there to interact with Mother Superior to even be betrayed by me, whatever the betrayal is supposed to be, lol. Strangest bug I've seen yet regarding a missing companion. I've seen a similar one to yours with Gale on this same run (who's also missing since I didn't save him from the portal), where Tav mentions showing the Crown of Karsus book to Gale... whom she herself never rescued and never got properly introduced to lol 😅

@kirisuma2186

9 ай бұрын

@@santosic ... now I'm worried... I didn't like Lae'Zel so, even though I'm in my first play through, I killed her off the first chance I got... partly because of Roleplay reasons...

@Hadeshy

9 ай бұрын

I destroyed last light inn in act 2, so the devilish ox didn't make it to act 3. But when I entered the (empty) barn where he was supposed to be in act 3, Astarion commented about how there was that ox again. I really stared a long time at him with worry

@sosukelele

9 ай бұрын

​@@kirisuma2186did the same, can't say that I noticed anyone bringing her up in my playthrough

I remember seeing Zae in my first playthrough because of the dancing dialouge but I'm sure I saw a few of the other backups as well. I didn't know you could expose Kagha so I just straight up started fighting the druids and they unfortunately killed a few of the tieflings in the scuffle 😢

@ProxyGateTactician

9 ай бұрын

lol she was the only interesting one.

@yagho290

9 ай бұрын

In my first playthrough I didn't even know Zevlor would ask me to kill Kagha, I just did it out of principle 😂

@DandeSaft

9 ай бұрын

I had zae as well, but i didnt start any combat with the druids. The telescope tiefling and the harpie child died for me tho since i didnt know they existed

@Jason-pb3zk

9 ай бұрын

That's why you should take your time and explore and not just be a murder hobo. Unless you actually *want* to be a murder hobo, in which case, i guess it's okay, lol.

@GrayRain0

9 ай бұрын

So I somehow one shotted Kahga. They all just attacked when I wouldn’t play nice at the entrance. So I kept my squishies with the tieflings and when they were running up. I stuck Kahga with a crit inflict wounds at 2nd level and I watched her fall! My whole party died but my main but we only lost 3 non important tieflings. It was hard asf but now I’ll try my hand at a no Druid playthrough. Can’t wait to go save Halsin ;)

These dives into niche parts of the game are amazing, well done

I think this is the only thumbnail with the "only 1% of players see this" that was actually true. Well done.

Im really disappointed that of all the replacement characters jve found, not a single one is Biff the Understudy (the original baldurs gate replacement character)

@highcaliber350

9 ай бұрын

Maybe ya just haven't looked hard enough yet! Or maybe Biff unfortunately passed away who knows

@axiosespada7651

9 ай бұрын

Well this did take place 120 years after. So he is probably dead

@chrisd1364

9 ай бұрын

@axiosespada7651 this is baldurs gate, death is a minor inconvenience at worst.

@axiosespada7651

9 ай бұрын

@@chrisd1364 Tell that to Jergal the retired god of death thats retired in the camp (aka Withers) XD. I don't think Myrkul the new god of death would bring back a jester that stayed in the five flagons inn basement back to life. nor would he be friendly about helping you after what you did to his avatar lol

@ubermaster1

9 ай бұрын

@@axiosespada7651well, there goes the surprise on Withers ruined for me..

Had me intrigued as usual. Awesome vid Proxy

One thing i ran into is the ranger hunting after asterion. Before i met him (or even knew he was a thing) i ended up staking asterion when he tried to bite me, and the dialogue ended up playing out as if he was still at my camp, even ending with my companions wondering if we should have given him up and the hunter saying theyd head to my camp, but they just never showed up.

@DragoVolcar

9 ай бұрын

Got that too. Was confused. I think maybe Astarion doesn't actually fully die? I stopped that playthrough, so there no way to check.

@Rurike

9 ай бұрын

@DragoVolcar i had no way of reviving him after that check, no scroll or withers option, and i was able to use "speak with dead" on his corpse, so probably just an oversight. With a million ways to play some things are bound to slip through the cracks

@stevebuckley7788

9 ай бұрын

I tried this in beta and there was an option to tell the hunter Astarion was dead and he asked where my camp was so he could go and see for himself stating that vampire spawn are harder to permanently kill than you'd think. I got the feeling that Astarion may get resurrected in a later act.

@Rurike

9 ай бұрын

@@stevebuckley7788 huh, guess ill see

@mibsu9178

9 ай бұрын

In my playthrough I told the hunter where Astarion was (at our camp), then told Astarion about it and he told he'd handle him. Later asked Astarion about this and he told that the hunter "won't be bothering us any longer".

A similar issue occurs if you disarm Voss for the silver sword. Lae'zel has dialogue about Orpheus after equipping the sword when it is not known of him at all until act 3. Edit: the dialogue I'm talking about references whether the sword is strong enough to break Orpheus' chains. From what I recall, all of the Gith are meant to believe Orpheus is dead. You only find out he is imprisoned in the artifact later. Only Vlaakith knows he's not dead. I'll try to find the plaques to see if they mention him still being alive and imprisoned.

@mauigonz

9 ай бұрын

Yea (Spoiler) After that she speaks of orpheus's betrayal So I was pretty hesitant of freeing him or not

@chiakiwi2991

9 ай бұрын

if you find tir text plates in the underdark (so this is still act 1), it mentions orpheus and laezel gets to talk about him and what she thinks of him

@maximilianoalcaraz7351

9 ай бұрын

you may not know about him as a player...but I'm pretty sure his people does...regardless what's the story of the campaign he is an important part of their history. Plus you find some text plates that gives context to stuff like this in act 1

@mikestein7771

9 ай бұрын

@chiakiwi2991 the dialogue I'm talking about references whether the sword is strong enough to break Orpheus' chains. From what I recall all of the Gith are meant to believe Orpheus is dead. You only find out he is imprisoned in the artifact later. Only Vlaakith knows he's not dead. I'll try to find the plaques to see if they mention him still being alive and imprisoned.

@chiakiwi2991

9 ай бұрын

@@mikestein7771 ohh understood, i was wondering if is was something like that! good to know :)

MAN IS A GENIUS i totaly forgot that bridge in a goblin camp is breakable and thats a safe way to kill minthara wothout triggering entire camp's hostile what a legend. ima doing my third playthroug as a drow now, gonna remember that

@ProxyGateTactician

9 ай бұрын

lol I always love when someone comments about something I didn't directly talk about like this.

@pistonfists

9 ай бұрын

If you sneak around and knock all the rando mobs in the room into the chasm (including the eye) you can have a normal fight with Minthara in that room without alerting the rest of the camp as well

@mooncalf_4534

9 ай бұрын

Why would you ever hurt the queen

@mrjoegangles

9 ай бұрын

But. But, my loot.

@lemmingrad

9 ай бұрын

The Silent Assassin solution.

And fun fact you can save the bard from dark urge by knocking her out and then immediately long resting. Dark Urge will merc her backup double instead of her, and she will be alive for the remaining content with her in it. (not much anyways)

@yoursonisold8743

9 ай бұрын

How do you knock out Alfira without killing her though? This game's non-lethal system is broken. Knocked out characters are treated as dead by the game.

@ProxyGateTactician

9 ай бұрын

She is one of the few characters it works on because she isn’t in a quest when she is knocked out. It’s mainly quest flags that are treated as dead causing the issue

@anthonyheman4621

9 ай бұрын

You can also avoid killing the backup bard by killing your durge and then picking up the corpse... seems to work to skip a few long rest events but not all.

@yoursonisold8743

9 ай бұрын

@@anthonyheman4621 Would that not break the Durge questline though?

@wildfireamv

9 ай бұрын

@@yoursonisold8743 I had the same issue, tried knocking her out and when I came back the next day she was dead anyway

Love all your videos on this game! I'll watch as many of them as you choose to make!

I love little details like this. Thank you for sharing!

The quality control on that game is phenomenal, especially in the first act

Oh, and another thing to note: If you randomly start picking up dead bodies and taket them to camp, and literally 'meat locker' them in a box, it also seems to mess some of the game's weird interactions up, like it doesn't quite seem to know that certain characters are 'dead'. Also, how you kill them seems to affect the game. I have 2 games going, my main legit, no mods, and am in the lower city. I started another one, the one I mentioned in the other comment, with the Level 20 Easy Xp thing to test out multiclass builds. I also used a Trainer to have 'no weight' so I could carry a crapton of bodies around, till I made camp. But yeah, I played as The Dark Urge, and randomly stealth killed (as a fighter druid, I know weird) everyon in the grove, methodically, with my Deep Gnome, every which way I could without alerting other people. I managed to kill like everyone but Aunti Ethel, because she's like Withers, and wont' actually die. But if you go around and quickly snatch up all the bodies to your inventory, ti's Metal Gear Solid level stealth, they don't see a 'dead body' and don't react. So like I said, I killed EVERYONE, except the druids guarding the idol, Kagha, Kurt, and the wolf, I went in, pissed off Kagha, they then went to war. There was then a WHOLE new set of bodies/npc's by the prison area, so I got 2x bodies for the price of one, due to the way the story must progress. I guess they didn't think anyone would be absolute batshit to Theif level murdergank the whole damn grove. So, when Minthara got there, there were no bodies, and she literally has a murdergasm, it's hilarious.

@jinXeD546933

9 ай бұрын

Why do you collect bodies?

@GoldAnthroWolf

9 ай бұрын

@@jinXeD546933 Well for a Dark Urge playthrough it seems only fitting that I collect the bodies of all those I murder! Or rather get killed. Also just seeing how long it takes to break the game's inventory managment.

@jinXeD546933

9 ай бұрын

​@@GoldAnthroWolf I agree, it’s a perfectly sensible reason.

Amazing thoughtfulness and diligence.

Best resume I've seen, I hope they offer you smth!

Never stop what you are doing. I love this. I love all of this. More than technical bug breaks, I am really interested in plot breaks as well. Like what happens if you avoid all the fail-safes for discovering Astarion is a vampire? How far does that train choo?

@roax206

6 ай бұрын

For one, I think my first death in the game was to Astarion during the blood sucking scene. I was waiting for the right skill check.

@elmatilda

3 ай бұрын

I didn’t take many long rests in my first playthrough so never got the blood drinking scene. Instead he randomly told me one time while we were out adventuring…just told me hey, I’m a vamp. And tav was just like cool I figured

The attention to detail to have extra stuff for failsafe characters

You're not lying with that QA remark, talk about edge case. As a developer I would love to work with someone this committed to testing

Man I love this game it's soo good the amount of effort and time put into this game is crazy the modding community is bound to go crazy aswell

You make some of the best BG3 videos man. Keep it up!

@ProxyGateTactician

9 ай бұрын

Thanks a ton!

This is crazy to know... Me and my friend saved the tieflings but Zevlor died during the goblin raid, somehow fail safe 1 must have also died, because later on we accidentially caused war with the tieflings when they were in our camp. A female tiefling, I'm now assuming to be Cerys was on our side despite all the other tieflings hating us. And then... Halsin killed her for some reason... So we unintentionally broke all their failsafes.

@swancrunch

9 ай бұрын

truly a dnd experience

@ggoddkkiller1342

9 ай бұрын

Accidentally threw a runepowder bomb on them? lol

@thewolfehunts6804

9 ай бұрын

@@ggoddkkiller1342 no. Took a dead goblin child out of my backpack in camp to show my friend

@ggoddkkiller1342

9 ай бұрын

@@thewolfehunts6804 Lmao, they act so pissed when you threw a corpse.

Lae'zel getting absolutely bodied at the very beginning was hysterical to me

Crazy to have a proper game, where choices matter and has impact.

Don’t forget the poor gith sod who is just a stand in for Lae’zel on the nautiloid if you are playing lae’zel as the mc. I was surprised he showed up since no one stands in for shadowheart, but I guess it’s bc lae’zel usually plays the part as your “tutorial” and I’d ur playing her then there is no one else to do it.

@ProxyGateTactician

9 ай бұрын

I'd imagine new players might lose that imp fight alone yeah. I was pretty surprised to see that guy.

another backup character is the dragonborn chick that replaces the tiefling bard the dark urge is supposed to kill if said tiefling bard is unable to come to your camp. this is a way to save her as the dark urge by knocking her out (non-lethal damage to her.. just make sure you do it in one strike to not get the negative reaction) before long resting when you kill her.

@DembaiVT

9 ай бұрын

Omg thank you for finding a way to save her. Even though I was doing a 'resist the urge' playthrough I killed her and was so sad. I love her singing!

@darcraven01

9 ай бұрын

@@DembaiVT you're welcome though i didnt find it. i read it online somewhere. im just helping to spread the info. o7 lol

@ofanichan

4 ай бұрын

​@@DembaiVT i completely missed her my first play through because for some reason, I never even noticed the road in the grove that lead to the beach. And in act 2 she got killed by the demon guys who worked for the big guy and I got so sad 😔

I have found one more thing in Act2 quests: If we run with last Shar Justiciar (Rat guy), up to Yurgir The Orthon In Shar's Gauntlet, Yurgir will not react on his last contract target presence until we finish the fight (by killing justiciar). Sad, I was up to some unique dialog to this one.

I was surprised to find a video where the dwarf (or is she a halfling?) lady you normally meet at the brothel in act 3 shows up in act 1 to save you from Gut if you allow her to imprison you and can't get out.

@vince4503

9 ай бұрын

ahh Hope's sister? She appear everywhere in your journey from Act 1. Found her in tiefling celebration too, gone soon after, and the earliest you can meet her actually failing all the checks against Gut, and she will kill her and free you

@fealubryne

9 ай бұрын

You can also catch her spying on you in the Shadowlands if you pass a... I think it was a Perception check. I found her on my first run, somehow missed her on my second. She's behind a broken cart a little ways inside the ruined town near Moonrise Tower.

@santosic

9 ай бұрын

I experienced this in my Tiefling Bard playthrough!! On every subsequent playthrough, I've happened to be playing an Elf character and so when taking the sleeping potion, nothing happens and Priestess Gut attacks me. This time I thought I'd still take the potion and see what happens when it does make me fall asleep, and I got a whole new scene of Tav imprisoned and I chose not to escape when given the option, and then I see *her* show up and rescue me. Definitely an unexpected surprise that is only made better having already played the game once and thus knowing who she is and who she works for. Like, if this had happened on my first playthrough, it wouldn't have been such an impactful or surprising moment

@malkav0488

9 ай бұрын

​@@santosicI had Wyll imprisoned instead of Tav and turns out he does know who she is and comments on it

@shadowsdawn1

9 ай бұрын

She's also at the circus in Rivington near the necromancer.

The tieflings that are backups you cited at the party are ones I believe you see at the goblin version party as dead bodies if you did an evil run and raided the grove.

This is so fun to watch.😃

@ProxyGateTactician

9 ай бұрын

Glad to hear! I didn’t have as much time this week so did what I could

When I got imprisoned in the Goblin camp I failed all rolls to unshackle yourself and was doomed to die. The failsafe there was that the girl working for Raphael teleports in and unlocks you (while she killed all mobs nearby)

I kind of appreciate Larian even more now. The hell of a job they did.

In my playthrough, I convinced Minthara to take a war party to the grove and double crossed them and wiped out the goblins and Minthara with the help of the Tieflings. Unfortunately, Zevlor was a bit TOO zealous with his desire to personally slay the entire goblin army and he got himself killed during the battle. The same glitch happens in Act 2 where they act like Zevlor is still alive. Interestingly, I actually got Cerys to show up in Act 1 post battle as well, so maybe one of the 3 tieflings who died was the first failsafe as well. I thought it was quite odd for this character I already met to re-introduce herself and then tell me to go hunt down a dead character that she already saw die.

@roax206

6 ай бұрын

Same here. I think Ashrak is one of the like 3 main fighters at the gate, so if things go badly, chances are he will die anyway.

I actually saw Gerson like 2 days ago, I was in combat with the goblin leaders at the time, but sent someone back to the grove to get the stealing idol reward (ring of protection), because I realised partway through my fight I would block myself out of that quest when I finished that battle. The camera autopanned back to my Grove character and played that cutscene the second i finished that leader lmao.

@ProxyGateTactician

9 ай бұрын

3rd person now to mention it now! Out of around 300,000 lol My statistic is holding up. It’s such a weird NPC I wondered how they even remembered to give it a voice actor credit

@ggoddkkiller1342

9 ай бұрын

Is it possible to get the ring without stealing idol?

@acharori7332

8 ай бұрын

@@ggoddkkiller1342 as far as im aware no, just make sure you steal it after you save kagha (find the note in the swap area), confront her and have her stop the ritual. Stealing it before that will trigger a cival war event which you dont want.

Dude! I love your videos. the more odd the more fun. Keep having fun!

@ProxyGateTactician

9 ай бұрын

Thanks! That's the stuff I enjoy doing in the game. Lucky for me

Another Gerson! I might have to try this on my next play through!

I was watching your mythbusting video a couple hours ago and forgot I had your channel pulled up on my phone when I unlocked it.. Surprised I'm so early lol

@ProxyGateTactician

9 ай бұрын

ur first!

I was super surprised to get random help from a character that appeared in act 3 when letting priestess gut keep me in her dungeon without fighting back. Usually you just die when doing dumb things.

This is what makes BG3 game of the year. Not a big budget, not revolutionary graphics, but passion. Love for the game, and insane attention to detail.

@ProxyGateTactician

Ай бұрын

Agreed. Passionate game devs really make the difference and it was awesome seeing them tell everyone with every award they won

I love that not only did Larian studies put this much effort into having fail-safes ready, but they even anticipated outcomes for the players that either bumbled around or deliberately bypassed fail-safes such as the pre-shadowfell illithid ending

Its funny that there is a character called 'Bent' whose job is to make sure you get bend right out of the grove so they can replace the NPCs.

Zhentarim trader from act 2 seems also has fail-safe mechanics, as it becomes one of the Zhent leaders in act 3 by plotting with Absolute cult. You can knock-her out, take her goods and she'll be alive later, while most characters knocked-out accounted as dead. Probably, also has double or replacement in act 3.

Love this! Keep going and keep going strong!

One of the biggest failsafes in this game is that most of the time you don't have to talk to anyone or begin a quest in order to do it. If you know how to progress the quest you can just go straight to the destination, find/kill whatever you need, then talk to the quest giver, and they'll be additional dialogue options to say you've already done it. BG3 isn't the first game to have this system but this system is much more fleshed out. Most games won't even spawn the thing you need to do until activating the qust, but not BG3. Everything's loaded, just go do it. you can always rp it as your character accidentally stumbling upon this "thing" and resolving it, then later finding someone who'd want it done. I'm sure it's happened plenty of times organically in people's first playthrough. Like that time I found the necromancy book down the well without reading the quest book first. I just sorta got lost, got attacked by spiders then found a magic mirror

Anyone who does a Kill everyone Run knows about the Tiefling backups, but even I did not know of... whatever his name was.

@ProxyGateTactician

9 ай бұрын

Yeah his name is weird as hell lmao. When he showed up I was like ??? who the hell is this guy. Immediatley go to google and youtube searching his name for 0 results

@rhinopatomus

9 ай бұрын

Who is everyone? Does this include recruitable companions?

@Blockinstaller12

9 ай бұрын

@@rhinopatomus Depends on how you set your rules. When I did my run, I did kill everyone I had a chance to, companions and all.

@Syaniiti

9 ай бұрын

@@Blockinstaller12 I mean, at least 50% of the companions deserve to be killed instantly, 16% at most deserve to live.

Edge cases are funny things, the narrower a path the more consistent of an experience, but sometimes you don't want that, you want each run through to be unique, and so naturally the path starts winding with offshoots, little things like this that may seems small really add up when you consider how many of them exist along the games progression, leading to ultimately a much more living and breathing world.

It’s pretty easy to meet Karis, ashrak can commonly die fighting if you bring minthara to the grove

In my first playthrough of the game both Zevlor and Asharak were killed when I tried to take out that one evil druid lady. I didn't even know meeting Cerys early wasn't standard lol

@ProxyGateTactician

9 ай бұрын

I always love the stories people had in this game. They're so different

Minor Act 1 Dark Urge storyline spoiler: There is another Tiefling thing that not a lot of people know. If you knock out Alfira she is not the one who comes to your camp during the Dark Urge playthrough. Another will come there and have the same results that she had after you wake up. So, assuming you do everything to save the tieflings, you can find her again in Act 2 and even get the quest reward for saving her (in reality, you saved her twice in this scenario).

@stephenpuisis632

7 ай бұрын

Tried, patched. Alfira shows up in camp with 1 hp before you rest

@jeremypurdy1833

5 ай бұрын

​@@stephenpuisis632 i just did this the other day, it's not patched. Knock Alfira out and her replacement is killed in her place that night. Step 1: go to the Grove, find Alfira. Talk to her or don't, it doesn't impact her going to your camp. Step 2: Initiate combat, turn on Non-Lethal, take Alfira down. Step 3: go to camp/ Long Rest. You should get a dragonborn in camp instead of Alfira. They will be murdered that night. If you didn't get the dragonborn, Alfira is not knocked out. If you want to be even safer, steal an item near her so she is temporarily hostile (Minthara 'trick' the devs added to recruit Minthara in A2 for 'Good' playthroughs that kill the Goblin leaders) and then knock her unconscious.

Cerys actually also appears during the Minthara gate fight at the Grove, although she doesn't appear in the grove itself.

I got the Cerys failsafe in my first playthrough and when she spoke to me in act 2 and said she hadn't met me before I was just sat there like 'You invited yourself to a party at my camp like three days ago?'

Act 1 is so polished and then you cut to the act 2 carys meeting and i think to myself 'ah this is where the bugs begin'

@ProxyGateTactician

8 ай бұрын

At least they patched that specific bug like 2 weeks after this video came out

@FidgetyPigeon

8 ай бұрын

Yeah they're slowly fixing all the bugs, you love to see it! But dang it felt so jank playing through sometimes 😂

I had the same thing happen with Cerys. But what I did was I killed the 2 generals and let Minthara attack the grove. Zevlor and his backup died in that fight and Cerys was there waiting for me after I won. In act 2 everyone speaks as if Zevlor is still alive and I even had the quest to find him in moonrise towers.

If you hit Auntie Ethel in the grove first time you see her, her entire line gets bugged - still is. Either way, the game is massive and a shining beacon of storytelling and having decisions impact the story

@kasane1337

5 ай бұрын

I love how she just starts running, suddenly disappears and nobody in the camp bats an eye even though you just tried to murder someone.

I love the dark urge one if you knock out the bard

For some reason when hope died in the fight with Raphael the party still talked like she was alive.

There is a bug if you attaack jaheria at the inn and runaway, the harpers will forget you if you save nighsong. Problem is if you ally with the harpers at the base of moon and fight with jaheria, the after party of ketheric will have isobel and the fist aggro you. So Aylin then aggros you and you have to kill the fist and isobel if she is a live an Jaheria is coool with slaughtering them.And then the cutscene plays like isobel is alive evn thou she is a corpse and or fighting u

I am very curious what would happen if you managed to, in unison, aggro the Goblin leaders and the Grove at once, and wipe them both out. Just going full scorched earth, whether they have a fail safe for if you kill/piss off *everyone*.

@ANCIENTWARRI0R

9 ай бұрын

If you want to see what happens when everyone is killed you can always watch..Being a PSYCHOPATH in Baldur's Gate 3 - Act: 1

@panzrok8701

9 ай бұрын

Well everyone will be just dead. You dont have to save the Grove or kill the Goblins and you can just continue to act 2 without them.

@TheWaffleRadio

7 ай бұрын

@@panzrok8701 .....Mission accomplished lol

Its amazing how detailed this game is like i feel like i should stop savescumming and allow myself to do what i truly want to do and know the game most likely has a plan for it

The depth of this game doesn't stop to surprise me

Interestingly, in ACTII, many of the Tieflings died by decisions of Zevlor and their backups, maybe this is possible to avoid by eliminating them.

@ggoddkkiller1342

9 ай бұрын

His mind was manipulated by absolute so same can happen to next leader as well. At least he claimed so it could be just a lie lol

@dig8634

7 ай бұрын

@@ggoddkkiller1342 He definitely was affected by the Absolute, but I don't think you can really claim the result had anything to do with him being influenced. Even with him fighting, they wouldn't have stood a chance. It only meant he got captured instead of escaping or dying trying to fight. I don't think dsheep's point works either, because none of Zevlor's decisions affect the outcome. They can't get over the broken bridge to Baldur's Gate, so they either die at the creche or go through the shadowcurse, which means they will still end up in that combat encounter where Zevlor got captured. There is no other choice they could make

@daviddaugherty2816

6 ай бұрын

He died in my first playthrough. Those tieflings are still dead/missing, but it's just mentioned that they were ambushed. No one but Cerys even mentioned him.

I saw one of these backup characters in grymforge, where in short I betrayed both Duergar sides (in the battle one side were allies but I killed them too) a Duergar archer survived and an "absolute novice Duergar" appeared and got to act as the new leader (I killed him too after he refused to free the Gnomes)

My first run Zevlor and Asharak both died fending off Minthara's offensive, so Cerys took over immediately... and promptly died to the Winged Horrors in Last Light...

Hilarious that I found all these already, I thought for sure I missed one but nay. My bad decision making is on point.

It's probably not that rare but if you play as Lae-zel you meet a completely different gith who helps you out and does the intro flip on the ship. He doesn't survive the crash though and you find is corpse and gear slightly past where shadowheart lays if you saved her. I don't even remember the guys name but I think of that VA sometimes.

@ProxyGateTactician

9 ай бұрын

I do too. I wonder who will end up being the rarest voiceacted NPC in the game. That dude is pretty rare for sure almost no one plays laezel

Cerys is in the grove when you completely exterminate all goblin life.

@ProxyGateTactician

9 ай бұрын

Where? I checked all around the camp and only noticed her if Zevlor dies.

Good job on this. Great idea for a video.

@ProxyGateTactician

2 ай бұрын

Thanks!

The amount of dialogue Larian recorded for incredibly niche scenarios is insane, but shows the level of detail they put into the game. I was able to sequence break the Auntie Ethel questline in two ways in my evil playthrough: Avoiding talking to Auntie Ethel at the grove or where she's confronted by Mayrina's brothers by going through the underdark and using the mushroom ring to go straight to her house, and again by managing to kill Auntie Ethel before she retreats while in her house. Ethel had new dialogue asking who the party is, and Mayrina had new dialogue where she's incredibly upset at the party for ruining what she, at this point, still thought was a deal which would work in her favor.

Fun stuff. I have definitely seen things that I'm quite certain very few people have. And that goes for just about anyone playing the game. We've all had some unique experiences. It's the reason I don't mind "spoilers" because in all likely hood I won't actually experience a lot of them no matter how many times I play. One thing I've started doing a lot is just knocking people out (passive toggle). Quite often they end up appearing later. Some you can even knock out, loot their corpse, heal them up, then give them money and they are your best bud again.

@mauigonz

9 ай бұрын

They don't drop all the loot If you knock them up So I knock them up, save, load and kill them Two times the exp and all the loot

@AbstractTraitorHero

9 ай бұрын

@@mauigonzYou should probably marry them first BEFORE you knock them

Hmm wonder if there are similar contingencies if you side with the goblins and destroy the grove, but also kill a bunch of the important goblin camp characters. What happens if you agree to join Minthara's assault on the Grove, let her leave, and then murder the other two leaders, but still choose to join her in the assault?

@ProxyGateTactician

9 ай бұрын

hmm now I wonder too lol I didn't try that side

@anniedarkheart5224

9 ай бұрын

That's what I did in my playthrough. After Minthara left with her goblin squad, I killed the other two leaders.

Larian should hire you, amazing work.

This is so cool considering as a DM i also have failsafes for if my players kill important characters

Cerys one happened natural to my friends and me in one run. We told Minthara where the groove was, and then betrayed her, but during the battle Zevlor died, and I suppose the other guy did too, cause then came Cerys to tell us all that stuff Then in Act 2, the same. "Zevlor was alive", but it wasnt

I didn't expected this. Like for "key" people such as Zevlor - sure. But to this extent? This is insane. I really hope this becomes if not industry standard (just because the industry is so shit right now, it would be a miracle for everything to improve like instantly), then at least something to aim for if you have enough development time.

@ProxyGateTactician

9 ай бұрын

Right? It’s basically something I’ve never seen in any other game. The love that went into it that almost all players won’t even see

This just tells me how many possibilities the devs need to consider...

I was saved by one of Raphael's minions in the goblin camp. I think. The only visual link was that sparkly gold teleport magic

Kariss is actually in the Grove, but a bit hard to get into without enough strength to jump (or a crate or two), and you can make a bet with her! You can access her by going to Zevlor and going to the ladder i think, the other exit in other words

@lucirose7552

5 ай бұрын

Thats lakrissa

Heya, @ProxyGateTactician, did they hotfix the knock-out-then-reload-then-kill-for-more-xp "Strategy" ?

@ProxyGateTactician

9 ай бұрын

It still worked last I tried it on the goblins and a few other mobs, but I noticed it doesn't work in the tutorial and I don't know why.

@jeromedarnell6270

9 ай бұрын

@@ProxyGateTactician when did you last try it? I have it a shot last night on the goblins in front of the village with zevlor and no dice from a reload.

That’s actually crazy asf It’s been a hot minute since I’ve seen a company put this much effort into a game

This is an insane level of development. It’s insane that u even found all this out.

Dark Urge spoilers I found it interesting that the tiefling bard girl who you meet in the grove and then subsequently horrifically murder has a backup if she was killed already, being some random Dragonborn bard. Even weirder is that you WANT to keep the Tiefling bard alive if you're a caster because you can get some OP robes from her in act 2, so if you're Dark Urge you can both trigger this failsafe and keep her alive by knocking her out right before the event occurs.

Thank you for pronouncing Cerys correctly. It’s a beautiful Welsh name that’s often used in fantasy games but nearly always pronounced “serris”

@ProxyGateTactician

9 ай бұрын

I googled a pronunciation guide beforehand for the word and followed it lol most people complained about the pronunciation that I did here thanks!

There really needs to be a failsafe for Dammon, at least someone in The forge of Nine, since I got locked out of karlachs quest line

@Syaniiti

9 ай бұрын

Lucky for you the entirety of Karlachs questline is completely pointless and doesn't matter because parts of her quest got cut.

@Pheeon

9 ай бұрын

@@Syaniiti but how will I sex?

That's awesome. So cool to see this level of attention to detail and meaningful responses to the players actions, letting the player do "dumb" things without breaking the game. Can't think of many other games except New Vegas that have this level of freedom + fail-safes.