FIFA 16 vs. FIFA 17 Demo - Ignite vs Frostbite Engine Graphics Comparison on PS4
Ойындар
GameStar PCs | Gaming PCs & Notebooks: www.one.de
We compare the graphics of FIFA 17 Demo with FIFA 16 both on PS4. This is also a comparison of Ignite vs. Frostbite Engine, as FIFA 17 evolves from the Ignite Engine to Frostbite Engine. Since this is the demo of FIFA 17, some interesting features are not available, for example playing while it's raining. We will of course do another comparison as soon as we get hands on the retail version. We did some face comparisons, too, for example from Boateng, Hazard, Müller, Ronaldo, etc. We used two of the three stadiums, Centurylink Field, home of the Sounders FC as well as Seattle Seahawks and the Stamfort Bridge Stadium, home of FC Chelsea.
--------------------
Wir vergleichen die Grafik von FIFA 16 mit der FIFA 17 Demo auf der PS4. Das ist gleichzeitig ein Vergleich zwischen der alten Ignite- und neuen Frostbite Engine, die nun mit FIFA 17 ihre Premiere in der FIFA-Serie feiert. Einige Features fehlen in der Demo, so kann man etwa nicht bei Regen spielen. Einen Vergleich davon reichen wir mit Erscheinen der Retail-Versionen nach. Wir haben zudem einige Spieler miteinander verglichen, darunter Boateng, Hazard, Müller, Ronaldo und Martial. Von den drei Stadien der Demo zeigen wir zwei, das Centurylink Field, Heimat der Sounders FC und der Seattle Seahawks, sowie das Stamfort Bridge Stadion, Heimat des FC Chelsea.
Candyland on Facebook: / candylandgs
Candyland on Twitter: / candylandgs
Captured with Nvidia ShadowPlay (130 Mbit) / Elgato GameCapture HD 60 Pro www.elgato.com/en/gaming/game...
Music: Come and Play - Digital Juice
System used in this video:
GameStar-PC Ultra
------------------------------------
Hier kaufen: bit.ly/1O7piZC
Intel Core i7 6700K 4.00 GHz
16 GB DDR4 RAM
Palit GeForce GTX 980 Ti Super Jetstream 6GB
MSI Z170A PC Mate Mainboard
Windows 10 Pro 64bit
Our second system:
GameStar-PC Titan
-------------------------------
Hier kaufen: bit.ly/1ZiQdlE
Intel Core i7-5820K 6x 3.3 GHz
16GB DDR4 Crucial Dual Channel 2133MHz (2x 8GB)
ZOTAC GeForce GTX 980 Ti Amp! Extreme Edition 6GB
500GB SATA III Samsung 840 EVO SSD
2TB SATA III Western Digital Red WD20EFRX
Windows 10 64bit
Пікірлер: 298
0:46 very realistic as Ronaldo doesn't give a duck.
@carlospierre3779
3 жыл бұрын
Wdym
add blur = new game
@SKY-Net_
7 жыл бұрын
xD true story ok, they add a story modus and new animations, but the price is almost high for a little "upgrade"
@Demente_Ente
7 жыл бұрын
this game is haram and halal, too meddl
@xDTHx
7 жыл бұрын
they switched engines from the ignite engine to the frostbite engine. which frostbite has better lighting, and better physics. notice how the clothes move in a realistic way on frostbite, but not on ignite. notice how the grass in frostbite has this realistic look to it, and then notice how the grass has pop at night.
@strawfrog1995
5 жыл бұрын
Got 17 today for 4$ on blu ray haha
It's amazing to me how every new FIFA iteration seems to look so much better than the last at first glance but when you compare it to the successor one year later, you realize how average the graphics really are. They always seem to get better but at the same time somehow they don't.
@feritosman
7 жыл бұрын
yeah they have better cloth dynamics here and sweat on faces, but this video is not a true representation of fifa 16. I just played it at 1080p on 3D, and the grass looks better than either of the examples here.
@DollarEuro_
Жыл бұрын
What about now
How does 16 look better? 17 has: • More detailed ground textures • Character models look far more realistic, the skin tones don't have that weird bland tone and the facial hair is improved. Not to mention you can actually see peoples eye colors •Grass doesn't have as many jaggies so I guess we can chock that up to better anti-aliasing • Colors pop far more • Better Draw Distance ( more NPC's view-able in the bleachers)
@Andreas163
7 жыл бұрын
I think hair in general looks a lot smoother now
@kelemangiar0
7 жыл бұрын
the grass is like fifa 08`s
@sibastianoff239
7 жыл бұрын
+Pluto the grass in the night doesnt look that good but in the day it looks fantastic better than fifa 16 thaught
@kelemangiar0
7 жыл бұрын
in the night... I CAN PLAY ONLY ON DAY IN THE DEMO STUPID
@suspectedcrab
7 жыл бұрын
Now all they need to do is put in player ID and drop the cartoon-style graphics and go for something more realistic. Don't think they'll ever do that. It's too much work. It's much easier to add one small thing, promote it, and sell it as a new game, and suckers will still buy it. EA are the worst game developers ever to walk the earth as much as they are publishers. Greedy cunts who should be frowned upon in the game industry.
Huge improvement :) Cloth physics, grass, animation, faces, ligtning. Great :)
@kelemangiar0
7 жыл бұрын
the cloth had physics since fifa 11, the grass is worse than fifa 15 and 16, the faces are over-saturated
@baronsengir187
7 жыл бұрын
goat boat afloat Yes. What about it?
@baronsengir187
7 жыл бұрын
goat boat afloat No. I mean cloth physics. Used also for clothes, yes.
Lmao the differences are like comparing last gen vs next gen despite both being from the same generation.
@andresuriza7159
7 жыл бұрын
Berenth Right? FIFA 16 looked so realistic but after watching FIFA 17 FIFA 16 looks horrible omg
@andresuriza7159
7 жыл бұрын
What do you mean they move bad?
better grapchics but dumb robotic animations wtf we are in 2016.
@DrewMcIntyre.
3 жыл бұрын
2020*
@FaffyWaffel
3 жыл бұрын
@@DrewMcIntyre. 2021*
@BoxterToaderu
2 жыл бұрын
@@FaffyWaffel 2022*
@robertoechenique9599
7 ай бұрын
2024*
@GiveMeSomeFreshCriticismBecaus
4 ай бұрын
@@robertoechenique9599 2025
The clothe physics are impressive on their own.
@AtaurRaziq
7 жыл бұрын
A bit overdone though, if you look at 3:11
1:53 HaHa, Hazard looks like a Lego-Man.
Its crazy how we got so impressed by this 3 yrs ago...2019 anyone?
@dxnotello3494
4 жыл бұрын
Gaming Adventurer 2020
the grass look so dead in fifa 17
@AM-qv2ed
7 жыл бұрын
yeah I agree with you
@Andreas163
7 жыл бұрын
i just played the demo on pc, the grass looks way better than that. To be honest, I think Fifa really took a step forward considering graphics. I also like the AI, the computer will now try to beat you with deep, direct passes instead of circling the ball around. This always annoyed me when playing against
@rubeng9649
7 жыл бұрын
It's blurred out smart one
@benbong4577
6 жыл бұрын
It looks more like a football field.
I Saw Fifa 16 better than Fifa 17
@NeoSlyde
7 жыл бұрын
You are blind then
@user-qc5jo3jg4l
7 жыл бұрын
you need glasses
@Awaks
7 жыл бұрын
+zLoRd CrUeL 47 No, I think he needs a new head. His current one is totally dead and messed up as a whole........
@TrueTacticia
7 жыл бұрын
These people are so full of shit, you can show them Doom 3 and Doom 2016 and they will swear up and down that Doom 3 looks better.
@AM-qv2ed
7 жыл бұрын
+TrueTacticia im talking about graphics but about gameplay and new things such as the journey and additional things in ultimate Team and career mode of course Fifa 17 better than Fifa 16
I bet they made the grass look shit this year so they could improve it next year and call it a new game
I was waiting for the day frostbite will be used..and here we are. Really nice upgrade!
The #FIFA17Demo is out and we compare Frostbite to Ignite Engine with #FIFA16 vs. #FIFA17 on PS4. If you like our videos, please support us! Like the video or subscribe us or visit us here: Candyland on Facebook: facebook.com/candylandGS Candyland on Twitter: twitter.com/CandylandGS
@SKY-Net_
7 жыл бұрын
make a comparison with sony's new HDR update for ps4. play different games with HDR "on" and "off"
@bluesonic3935
7 жыл бұрын
Why ps4 why always ps4 do compare on xbox make all videos on xbox
@AM-qv2ed
7 жыл бұрын
+blue sonic xfox fans 😂😂😂😂😂
@AM-qv2ed
7 жыл бұрын
+blue sonic im so sad that the xfox fans reached to this situation 😥😥😪
@bluesonic3935
7 жыл бұрын
Dude do you know how to shut up ok then you know how now shut up ok ps4 or pc fan
Fifa 17 Demo PC graphics comparison (Low - Medium - High - Ultra)?
Wow, such a huge improvements
Es wäre toll wenn ihr die Videos in 4K hochladen könntet. :)
frostbite engine where you at ... the whole world is looking for you ??
Frostbite is no doubt up there in the top 3 best Engines
@freddysaka230
4 жыл бұрын
Varga Dániel no
give fifa their props, this fifa is the most significantly different since fifa 11. the jump from 10 to 11 was massive, and while this change isnt as big , there are still significant changes. Good job ea, the game looks great
@crazygamingyt7245
9 ай бұрын
Because fifa 13 was the last to use the impact engine
Top view on Fifa17 looks alot better. The grass actually has different shades of color as material it looks better in 16
sheeeesh huge improvements
The nintendo switch must need at least the ignite engine, so the difference between ps3 and switch can get larger, that is how you make fifa (18/19)on the switch, last gen upgrade is for Wii U graphics
Madden 18 will be having Frostbite. can't wait
hyped af :O sept 29 come to me right nowww
As someone who plays PC and only has an xbone just for fifa and pes. I'm disappointed by the graphics update. Yes it looks better but 16 looked better than 15 and so on. This is running on the same engine as Battlefront, one of the most graphically beautiful games I've ever played and BF1 which looks fantastic and this is the best they can do? I'm sure they held back just so they can do a "graphics overhaul" on FIFA 18. Even on my PC at Ultra settings it just looks average. Also the LT ball guarding mechanic is overpowerd as fuck. I can just hold that button and no one can get through that.
Frostbite is the better engine, but in sport games the "map" is static and clean
why do you always take Boateng?
Why every time I play with the pro camera (ps4) the frame rate drops significantly? (sorry for my bad english)
@ThugHans89
7 жыл бұрын
It is 30 fps on consoles if you switch to the pro cam. On Pc the fps is 60 or more when using the pro cam.
Die frostbite Engine zeigt schon in battlefield seine geilheit kann jetzt nicht anders ausdrückenXD
NHL needs to make the switch, we’re into NHL 18 and it still runs on ignite
They still don't get the weight within the cloth physics correct - those shirts are not made out of tulle
Changes are significant enough.
why did you end it at the gameplay????? Its the gameplay that counts not all those stupid cutscenes,
@Candyland
7 жыл бұрын
Those aren't cutscenes. Those are scenes from Instant Replay mostly and every scene we show is rendered in real-time. We are a graphics comparison channel, so we focus on graphics, not on gameplay.
@BriefcaseJoe
7 жыл бұрын
Rekt by candyland pahahaha
@FC13900
7 жыл бұрын
OHHHHHHH lmao
@bobtheunicorn4113
7 жыл бұрын
True you could good player looks but terrible gameplay
the fifa 16 style of grass was better for me, more long and straight, in fifa 17 they tried to make it more realist and nobody apreciates it, the textures are better but they made it too curved and short (more like real life, but i still prefering fifa 16 grass) anyway is the best graphic upgrade ever in 1 year for fifa or pes
The crowd in movement looks insanely good in these games 0:53
nice, they added DOF to try and hide the graphics actually being the same
@roberto8442
7 жыл бұрын
ture
According to the cpu_benchmark site, the i7 6700 processor is only 3% better than my i3 8100 (4 cores and 4 threads), but it costs almost 3 times more. Blessed 8th generation of Intel processors!
Probs gehen an euch die vergleiche sind ja schneller da als die spiele :D
@futbolfutbol5209
6 жыл бұрын
Gboss Cen sa
try in you own console in your home to see the diference
I've never been playing a football since I was a kid to now. But I think Fifa 17's graphics looks better.
Thats the battlefield engine
name of the song at the beginning?
@potombo8613
3 жыл бұрын
Three years later no one knows
@GiveMeSomeFreshCriticismBecaus
4 ай бұрын
@@potombo8613what is the music name?
what the fuck is with the handshakes in fifa 16 4:01
se nota la diferencia de graficos
no need to waste your money if you already have fifa16.
Wie schafft ihr es so schnell das up zu loaden? ?
@Candyland
7 жыл бұрын
Vorbereitung und schnelle Leitung ;)
Football games always improve (Or have for the last 5 years) from the previous entry, unlike Madden
goal post and net missing shadows......
Ich spiele kein FIFA oder PES, aber sehe sofort die synthtetischen Animationen, FIFA 17 sieht besser aus, aber die Frostbite-Engine könnte noch einen Tick mehr
where is the grass in fifa17?
@Candyland
7 жыл бұрын
The grass is there, don't get confused by depth of field :)
@anoosh-22
7 жыл бұрын
i like long grass to be real
where the hell is the grass in fifa 17
завезли бы nvidea hairworks
Honestly, the more colorful graphics of FIFA 16 are much more stimulating than 17, even when considering the technical differences.
Guys did anybody noticed that on PS4 when playing on night, the ball is so white that it almost glows and the same for the white shirts, I also noticed some lag with long passes, also the colours are very bright and they tend to hurt my eyes. I am the only one experiencing this issues or it is general problem ? I mention I play on Tele Broadcast
@davidzlindra892
7 жыл бұрын
go to the setting menu click video calibration and calibrate the brightness... should help a lot :)
@encianhoratiu5301
7 жыл бұрын
I did that it seems the lighing has problems the far players look good but the closed they are to the bottom of the screen they are brigher after 2 games it hurt my eyes
@davidzlindra892
7 жыл бұрын
how close do you sit?
@encianhoratiu5301
7 жыл бұрын
Well my tv is a Samsung 32" and I don't sit very close i noticed this problem only in Fifa 17, in 16 I had not problems playing or GTA or other games, I just sold my 16 Copy and I kind of regret it because if the original game will be like that it is a dissapointment for me, frostbite does not impress at all
@encianhoratiu5301
7 жыл бұрын
I also tried on standard mode and on Game mode on standard it is unplayable and on gmae mode looks good but this is the only problem that it has every color seems to bee too bright
It makes me angry that FIFA did not want to put the frostbite engine on the play station 3 and that in battlefield they put it on that engine and it works very well
Miss the ignite engine
Some games get more changes in a free updates than Fifa give you for 60$ every year.
2:31 Ramsay Bolton?
Es Casi lo mismo! alto curro eso de vender todos los años "un nuevo juego de fútbol"
@seiyakun7564
7 жыл бұрын
mientras tengan a los mismos tontos pagando por el mismo juego seguiran haciendo lo mismo
The player indicator is huge wtf
look up a pro lookalike tuturial of both games and see how laughably big the difference is.
im talking about graphics
I like 16's grass.
FIFA got frostbite in FIFA 17 Madden and NBA gets frostbite in Madden 18 and NBA Live 18 Will NHL get frostbite in NHL 19? Please EA, I'm a hockey fan!
I like both
How do you download demo ?
@indranilroychowdhury3379
7 жыл бұрын
If you are playing on ps4, then go to demos, you will find it.
@mumbohd5957
7 жыл бұрын
+Indranil Roy Chowdhury (Akash) thxx
Another People: A new fifa! Oh, it's so original this fifa better grafics and the soccer players looks awesome Me: A new fifa! Oh, is the same bullshit :D
Pepole. the grass in fifa 17 its not like that, its the DOF
You shouldn't compare Bayern's players because their faces were scanned by EA in FIFA 17,thats unfair,the same with Hazard
grafisch sieht das richtig geil aus, von den island clap oder der pyrotechnik hab ich aber noch nichts gesehen, die elfmeteranimationen find ich jedoch einfach zum kotzen (sieht einfach hölzern und unrealistisch aus)
@Candyland
7 жыл бұрын
Ich hätte auch gern was davon in den Szenen gesehen, wenigstens Pyro. Aber dazu muss man wohl länger spielen...
@rouvi58
7 жыл бұрын
oder erst in der vollversion🤔
@Uchidaful
7 жыл бұрын
Die bewegen sich immer noch wie Roboters!Und
@rouvi58
7 жыл бұрын
wie und was laberst du
@bigsmoke1787
7 жыл бұрын
auf dem thumbnail sieht boateng immer noch schlecht aus
fifa 17 wants to be pes2017 soon bad
@TheConor43
7 жыл бұрын
Nope
@rivalvo
7 жыл бұрын
Nope
@theEchannel_official
7 жыл бұрын
Nope
FIFA 16.5?????
FIFA 16 is last beautiful FIFA game !!!
I want a better more unique crowd
it feels like pes engine just a little
Fifa 16 is like ps2 version of Fifa 17 PS4 xDD
PLEASE MADDEN...MAKE THE SWITCH!!!!!!!! IT'LL SAVE THE FRANCHISE
@alanbacon186
7 жыл бұрын
EA say that Madden 18 will had Frostbite
@tgnash_
7 жыл бұрын
DON'T MAKE ME CRY...YOU'RE GONNA MAKE ME CRY
@Raiders-wm5kb
7 жыл бұрын
Cost them alot more money aswell. EA already pays $50million ayear just for the exclusive NFL license.
@NT-wf4kt
7 жыл бұрын
Today it was confirmed by EA
@freddysaka230
4 жыл бұрын
Nolan Cruz did adding frostbite make the gameplay good ?
I have to say, on PC on ultra, FIFA 17 looks fantastic. Pes aint got shit on FIFA. FIFA>PES
@suspectedcrab
7 жыл бұрын
PES has player ID. Players dribble and shoot like they do in real life. Players have accurately proportioned bodies as opposed to muscular and big. Konami puts more realistic details into their game aside from graphics. Not sure if you noticed, but FIFA tends to have more cartoon-y graphics. Before you jump down my throat like the mindless fanboy you probably are, I like FIFA better.
@killerofprimes
7 жыл бұрын
The Wolf Within meh, not a fanboy of anything. I do enjoy FIFA's authenticity and game modes better.
@suspectedcrab
7 жыл бұрын
Byron Cai Authenticity in what? There has to be more to it than that to make you like FIFA more. Sound? Presentation? Have you played PES? The game has authentic player movement which alone competes with FIFA where the animations for every player look the same. And it plays a more realistic and technical pace whereas FIFA is arcade-y and fast-paced. So, FIFA is just about equal with PES if only because the sound and presentation is more appealing.
@killerofprimes
7 жыл бұрын
The Wolf Within authenticity as in real teams. jerseys and players. just a personal preference :) sorry that i triggered you
@suspectedcrab
7 жыл бұрын
Byron Cai You didn't and there's nothing to apologize for. It's just strange that you find real jerseys and players more important than actual player likeness -- how they dribble, move and shoot like they do in real life. But anyway, have fun with the game.
best graphics!!
Biggest changest since fifa 06 and fifa 07
Certainly FIFA 17 has some improvements but... Why did Candyland put images of FIFA 16 without anti alias filter?... It's more than evident. If you are going to do an engine comparison be sure of being fair.
@oscarvela4584
7 жыл бұрын
Yes, you are right!... my mistake, sorry.
The green shaded, striped rectangle still looks the damn same. Not to mention everybody plays this on console from far away, so it still looks shit. No one wants to pay 60 dollars a year for literally just an update. This might be the only one worth buying since however long ago the ignite engine was integrated, but still not worth 60 bucks. at all.
fifa 17 pero los dos son buenos juegos
i don't like what they did with the grass should have left it alone
OMG better FIFA 16 LOL :D
Kind of like 16 graphics better your thoughts
Frostbitr in fifa? - HAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAH, no, it's only for destruction in Battlefield's :)
Where is the face scan? Look at Pereyra and alex Sandro... Come on.. 60 euros of game,and it still has not real faces of the strongest team of Serie A.Sick of this shit.
@coldmort
7 жыл бұрын
Maybe they didt want there face scanned.
Well it looks like this year Fifa didn't show its love for ps3, pes 2017 for ps3 looks better than Fifa 17 and it includes all modes like ps4, I'll go for pes 2017 for ps3 and fifa 17 for ps4. That's all.
@victordiazvazquez934
7 жыл бұрын
exactly my opinion , PES is giving old gen user a full experience while lacking some stuff compared to next gen FIFA, FIFA is pushing next gen consoles to its limits but forgot old gen in 2014
@AM-qv2ed
7 жыл бұрын
cause Konami didn't have anything new to do it in ps4 of course all modes will be in both generations but in ea every year theres a new thing in Fifa and it's hard to do it in ps3
Lool fuck frostbite, new engine please
Why does 16 look better
Not much of an improvement!
LOS GRAFICOS DE FIFA 17 SON MUCHISIMO MEJORES Q LOS DEL 16,Solo q el chabon q hizo el video puso las imagenes de fifa 16 de mejor calidad y las de fifa 17 no
fifa 16 looks brighter
@LouPatt
7 жыл бұрын
though it looks brighter it looks more cartoonie when brighter the Depth Of Field and textures is amazing I do no know why EA Is just now realizing that Frostbite engine is better then there shitty Ignite engine
Is the horrid bloom filter supposed to be an improvement??... 2017 looks like $#!t compared to 2016
💪 fifa 16 > fifa17>fifa 20 > PES
@positivelycurvedpikachu
3 жыл бұрын
@Alejandro Hernandez Valdez yes hahaahaha. pes is shit. I know. they paid me for saying that
リアルです
fifa 16 have better colours,better grass,no blur..........fifa 17 got very much blur,bad grass,weak lighting....the only plus for fifa 17 are the textures