Which do you prefer? Let me know down below! Backingtracks in this video are available here: bit.ly/3fqyJEe

@maximilianosottile

2 жыл бұрын

GIBSON

@jimmyhalvardsson1489

2 жыл бұрын

Suhr HSS Stratocaster! 😀

@JayDoge

2 жыл бұрын

Why not both with a PRS with split-coil pickups

@bryantherocker

2 жыл бұрын

Strats are better 1 - the necks don't brake and are tougher 2 - Strats are lighter 3 - Strats can come with humbuckers or P90's or mini Humbs or... 4 - Strats have more tonal options between their pups 5 - A longer scale is good for downtunings [I have my strat on B] 6 - Whammy Bar 7 - Easier to Modify and Customized 8 - More comfortable to Play 9 - Easier to Replace a part 10 - Strats are far easier to get in tune and stay in tune 11 - Best cleans ever with single coils 12 - Less compression, more dynamics with single coils 13 - Individual Adjustment of String height

@lolzlarkin3059

2 жыл бұрын

An elite strat has a good imitation of that humbucker tone. Dont know why is disappeared for the ultra.

its refreshing to see you have taken the minimalist route, of owning only two guitars ! two guitars which rules the two extremes and covers most genre. Its cool especially in this era where every one is just flexing gears.

@jochem420

2 жыл бұрын

I feel like a tele would be a perfect bridge between the two, being suitable for nearly every genre

@T3L3cast3r

2 жыл бұрын

@@jochem420 Especially one with a four-way switch.

@sparkyguitar0058

5 ай бұрын

How acoustical can either sound? Well there is a need of another guitar then.

I wouldn’t say one of the two is better. It is like asking: “which tool do you prefer, a hammer or a saw?” Depending on the job at hand, you’d pick one of the two. Both guitars shine in their own niche. I love my Les Paul, I love my strat and, as you might have guessed from my screen name, I love my telecaster. Each guitar has a place in history and a place in my toolbox.

@clintfoard7332

2 жыл бұрын

Well put 👍

@simondavis942

2 жыл бұрын

Couldn’t agree more, I’ve got all 3, depends on type of song really, some I wouldn’t dream of using LP, others the LP is streets ahead. I’d have to say though the Fenders are probably more versatile, in my experience at least. But I love em all equally.

@christophergallagher531

2 жыл бұрын

Can't have enough Teles! I have started to wonder how humbuckers would do on one. I would not even think about one guitar being better than another, even if it makes for an interesting topic. Chris

@treeherder2201

2 жыл бұрын

That STUPID volume knob placement on a Strat tho. WHY? What possessed Fender to put it there?! That was the whole deal breaker for me with a Strat.

@christophergallagher531

2 жыл бұрын

I end up taking off the V knob. The idea must have been to wrap a pinky around it as an anchor. I have trouble with Tele switches too. I knock the V knob. There I use a Strat 'football'. Danny Gatton bent his over. Still , I like being on a venerable platform. Chris

I think Mark Knopfler showcases both Fender & Gibson pretty well. For example, hard to imagine Sultans of Swing on a Gibson but also hard to imagine Brothers in Arms on a Fender.

Thom I would like to tell you that I'm from Boston , Massachusetts .. Im 62 years old and music has been my life from the minute I saw the Beatles on the Ed Sullivan show .. I've been playing with the same childhood friends for over 40 years .. We have a music foundation that donates instruments to the local schools , we have sent children to Berkley School of music all in the name of a great friend and band member It called the Dave Moraes music foundation.. We have many great local guitar players , musicians and bands in this area ... So I don't just say this to anyone , you are not only one of my favorite guitar players , your choice of music , your style of teaching it and the enthusiasm in your approach is second to none ... Keep it going !

Your content is always authentic, effortlessly putting the music at the focal point rather than selling the idea of buying more gear to advance your playing.

The olde "the only guitar you'll ever need is a Telecaster" meme is quite frankly... True. I love my Gibsons especially my archtops and hollow bodies but as far as solid bodies goes the Fender Telecaster is the most dependable and versatile, its rock solid, stays in tune no matter what, it works with every pickups imaginable, replacement parts and customisation options are cheap and plentyful, it looks incredible timeless and understated at the same time. If you only have to have one solid body guitar the Fender Telecaster really is the one, thankfully you don't have to just have one !

@AustinPierce7526

Жыл бұрын

I have 12 guitars and rarely play any but my Telecaster. It can do it all 🤙🏻

Great video and solid comparison of both of the classics! The way you have it EQ'd you can really hear the difference between the two, which makes it a joy to watch. Great playing too!

i had a strat and gibson studio, sold them, still regret the strat, but replaced them with gretsch electromatic 5120 and ibanez prestige rg1570, at first you miss out that fender sound, off course it is a personal thing ,the guitars are the best of both worlds. the real deal is the guitar brand is not the most important factor, the person who plays it, his style in short focus more on playing than buying guitars, collecting is nice, but with another approach keep on rocking, great video as always thnx rudi

You make both of them sound great! Thanx for sharing your talent with everyone!

You take the prize for self discipline....only having ONE guitar for so long. Hats off.....

Have had an SG and LP and sold them both. Still have two strats. One is an HSS Suhr which is the best of both worlds. Fenders much more comfortable for me. Having said that - it doesn't matter. As long as you're jamming out and having fun! 🎸🤘

I have both for this same reason - two extremes. But if I have to choose between the two, it's the Les Paul. Great videos!

Not having either (I have a Parker PM-60 and a Brian Moore 8.13), what I guess I notice is that with the amount of processing and digital modeling available out there, you can virtually make any guitar sound like any other. Knowing that the necks on different guitars can vary widely in terms of feel, I’d go with what plays the best to the individual, and leverage electronics to shape the sound so it’s appropriate to the tune. And I LOVE your videos, Guitar Pilgrim!!!

Love your redition of Tin Pin Alley & Little Wing . Love your playing and you come across a realy nice guy too 👍🎸

Your posts are so good. You are indeed the Johann Cruyff of guitar players and you make everything so interesting.

It’s double v single coil to the ear. My wife always preferred the sound of my old 63 Hofner Galaxie to my late 80’s Fender strat. Several guitars later, she definitely prefers humbuckers. No matter what I play. Or how badly. 🤣

@drmidnight2419

Жыл бұрын

Some people actually prefer farting sounds, excuse me.

5:57 I would’ve just looked at the camera after playing “Funk” on each brand and without a word .... 🛎 DING !! for Fender 🎸 But overall I love both as well as other Gibson and Fender models such as ... - Flying V - Jaguar - Mustang - SG - Telecaster - ES-335 - Explorer - Jazzmaster - Firebird

Very nice, you said it all at 3:55. Different. Both guitars are amazing.

Guitar Pilgrim As for the single at the grasshopper, most people play it with a pick, but I think it's primarily intended for playing with your fingers (meat, without nails). The Stratocaster was created at a time when it was not common to have a pedlboard, and most guitarists used a volume potentiometer to retreat when accompanied and to amplify during solo. In this way, with a properly set amplifier, everything fits together. Color and dynamic.

Always tuning in to your videos. Love your playing and teaching! Thank you I have both guitars and love them. 1 of each fits all styles. I also found that the strat sounds better playing Hendrix, SRV and funk. Anything clearer for the single coils. The Les Paul loves dirty, angry, mean playing music :)

@drmidnight2419

Жыл бұрын

Yes, the less pole stank. I can duplicate Gibson by Farting, the fart has the same tone and sustain, I can make it sound really aggressive too, depends how much gas I have. I can play some Zeppelin by farting sounds perfect, if you don't mind the stank.

I have a Stratocaster and a Les Paul and love them both. I've never been a big fan of humbuckers so my Les Paul is a '56 Gold Top with P90 pickups. I also have a Tele for chicken pickin' and a Danelectro 56-U2 for slide playing. Very much a case of horses for courses 😉

I agree, there is room for both, it depends on what kind of sound you want. I have a Strato and a Telecaster Masterclass which has a total Gibson configuration, same neck lenght, stop tail and two SD humbuckers. I use more the Strato because of my blues band, but sometimes I like the muddy sound of my Tele/LP!

Played professional for many years and it boils down to what sound you want for different songs. Deep mellow or clear and crisp.

I have a Strat and a Les Paul copy for this exact reason, they both can do stuff the other can't do and it's all about what you're feeling like playing at the moment. I tend to play my Strat more often though, I just like how it feels in my hands better.

You're so skillful. Love your playing!

I am the happy owner of tele, strat and PRS. They all sound bright and are more comfortable to play. I love the Gibson sound, but for me they have a neck that is clunky like a baseball bat. You are an amazing guitarist, thanks for your videos✌️

@keef7224

2 жыл бұрын

That’s why I’ve always preferred SG’s over LP’s. Obviously different models and eras have different neck profiles, but in general SG necks are much more comfortable for my hands.

The short answer is.. neither is better! They're both iconic instruments in their own right and are both phenomenal at what they do best. And yes.. having one of each is absolutely the way to go!

Both have their place. I prefer a guitar that sits in between the two. So, I've modified my Strat in a number of ways. One of the most important was to be able to "deck" the floating bridge from the top of the guitar using a wedge I can slide under the back of bridge in a few seconds, and remove it as easily. I usually leave it in place. I also replaced the pickups with stacked, noiseless humbuckers, removed the middle pickup, and switched a volume pot to tone pot for the bridge pickup.

Best guitar channel on the Internet. I prefer both. Also love the sound of the Telecaster and SG.

@ppvk2610

2 жыл бұрын

Well, I prefer both as well Just as I like both Guitar Pilgrim and Paul Davids channel ... Just as the question of above I do appreciate both

Firm member of the Fender camp here, but great appreciation for the Gibson LP. Just don't see one in my future.

Damn Pilgrim, those SRV licks were something else! I'm a strat guy so... Thanks for the great vid, still love your videos. :)

Great video. I have a Big Apple Strat, American with two Seymour Duncan humbuckers that do coil splitting on positions 2 and 4. I always install a treble bleed circuit.... I also have a strat with single coils and other guitars with humbuckers. I think you do you need both kinds, but if I had to choose one it would be the Big Apple Strat.

Thank you for your insights. I always learn something and your videos cheer me up. I don't own a Gibson so can't give a preference, but who knows? Sometime in the future maybe...🤪

Lekker Sengeruh, mooie vergelijking. Keep rockin’ it mate, happy 2022 😎

i have had two SGs and a Les Paul Studio over the years but always kept coming back to my strat. one reason is the amazing strat neck pickup, since as you mentions it gets a little muddy in the gibsons in the neck sometimes. but the biggest reason is the necks. cant wrap my thumb around most gibsons. however i found a double solution for both problems: i got a 70s ibanez les paul which has a pretty straty neck and put a seymour duncan sh6 in the neck position. now i have a bright sounding "les paul" where i can still do all playing like on a strat.

I use to play Coldplay and U2 on a Gibson (I still don't have a Fender) and it sounds brilliant! These 2 humbuckers are the best pickups ever.

I have an almost identical LP Studio (mine is a lefty). I've put Seymour Duncan Vintage Blues Zebra pickups on it - the difference in clarity and tone is night and day: no more muddiness! I've got a USA Deluxe Strat, too. The Strat is great, but I find the Gibson to be more versatile. It's nice to have both but, if I could only keep one, it'd have to be the Gibson :)

You make everything sound great! ✌️😎🎸🎶🎵🎶

As a non-playing fan of long duration, I'd have to say I like the one with 6 strings. But I liked the four-limbed attachment to both guitars.

Strats are better 1 - the necks don't brake and are tougher 2 - Strats are lighter 3 - Strats can come with humbuckers or P90's or mini Humbs or... 4 - Strats have more tonal options between their pups 5 - A longer scale is good for downtunings [I have my strat on B] 6 - Whammy Bar 7 - Easier to Modify and Customized 8 - More comfortable to Play 9 - Easier to Replace a part 10 - Strats are far easier to get in tune and stay in tune 11 - Best cleans ever with single coils 12 - Less compression, more dynamics with single coils 13 - Individual Adjustment of String height

Thanks for great vids! I agree with you. Some music craves single coil neck position and some humbucker bridge. No right no wrongs. I will stress though that it’s a matter of pickups not necessarily the brand. Would be nice if you put something out with the P-90, a somewhat magic sort of “in between” pickup. Again, thanks for a great channel. 👍🏻😊

I loved this comparison!

Gibson. One of the best days of my life, walking into guitar shop, slapping down bit of money for a heritage cherry sunburst les Paul standard.

Definetly the best video about this issue

Great review, coming from a Dutchman living in Seattle (from Leiden). You almost have to play a LP and Strat through different amps because you need such a different EQ to make each guitar play to it's strengths. (I've also cheated by using an EQ pedal before I could afford two amps and an AB/Y box, or if the gig was too small for two amps.) I am also not a fan of Gibson stock pickups - especially in the neck. But irrespective of the pickup, you can do a lot to un-muddy the neck by lowering it quite a bit, and then I like to tilt it so the treble side is a little higher than the bass. My last trick is to make sure the magnets are set to follow the neck profile (raised in the middle) on both pickups. This will do wonders for your LP's tone and really help the midrange sing.

I’m Fender all the way but I really liked the sound of the Gibsons. It’s the scale length as well as the pickups that gives each their sound. Good vid! It’s the compression of the humbuckers maybe?

@GuitarPilgrim

2 жыл бұрын

I'd say Gibson is a little bit harder to play with but it can be very rewarding indeed!

Brilliant video cause both guitars are fantastic so well done 😎 cool 😎 I love this gezzer great guitarist and teacher 👍🏻

If I could afford both, yes, but my first choice Gibson LP ( Looks, versatilaty and playability)

I have just arrived at your channel. Love your style and personality. Great playing also.I have always been a Fender player. I went with the Strat and to cover the dual humbucker territory I went with the new Tele Deluxe. Gibson have always been the yang to the Fender Yin and the world is a better place with both. Gibson also makes some of the best acoustic guitars on the planet.So that's a plus

@kjneese

Жыл бұрын

Great comment and YES I love my Fenders (currently only own one Gibson electric) and feel they cover the most ground sonically, but Gibson may make the best acoustics in the world IMO.

I say life is too short to choose, get both. Stay Calm and Play On. Thanks GP.

Hey dude... First video of yours I have ever viewed. I appreciate your perspective on either brand. I do prefer Gibsons, but I am a rock/metal player but in the blues influence. BUT, when I do jams, it'd be total Strat time. Anyway, just want to add, I like your playing as well.

@GuitarPilgrim

2 жыл бұрын

thanks brother, I am glad you enjoyed the video, Rock on!

Will say I love all your videos and enjoyed this one. Didn’t you have the tone dialled in on the strat and completely rolled off on the Les Paul which exaggerated the difference?

Well, you just need a Telecaster and you got self covered for everything 🙌 Love Gibson and Strat ❤️

Hmm.. Clapton started on a Gibson. Eddie Van Halen started on Strat. Somehow Jimmy Page sold more Gibsons after he recorded with a Tele! Go figure! I love the tone & feel of my 83 hardtail Strat & my SRV Strat. And now my lovely wife gave me a Tele - Nashville Player Plus for Christmas. I would say I'm a Fender guy. But my son wanted a Gibson LP when he was a teenager so I've played one. Let's just say I wouldn't just throw it out the window if some gave me one, but I ain't rushin out the door to get myself one. BTW lower your bridge pickup on the treble side to reduce some of that overly bright tone on the Strat. It's done wonders for my SRV. Cheers to you and this superb channel. 00

Love both !! But for me the Strat is number one , so much tonal variety ..

Damn, that Strat sounds absolutely glorious ! (your playing helps too, of course). But yeah, a Strat and LP definitely cover a lot of ground. Next up, Tele ? ;) Greetings from a fellow Dutchman. Just found your channel. -> subscribed Have a good one !

Les Paul for rock. Strat for blues. That encompasses all the music I need to worry about.

And now, a tele. I like the tele tones but love the les Paul shape, so I made a les Paul shaped guitar, with 100% true tele specs (scale, woods, bridge, pickups). Same with a strat. Just les pauls over anything else for me.

That's why I think an HSS Fender is the best of both worlds

I know nothing about guitars but from what I heard to love the Fender. There's a clear "crispness" (if that is any way to describe a sound 🤷🏻) that the Gibson doesn't seem to have.

I’m in two bands. I play a Fender Tele in one band and play a Gibson or PRS in the other band. I’m just glad I have that opportunity. Each group requires something different from me so I pick the appropriate instrument.

This is absolutely the best comparison of these two styles of electric guitar.

This is why I love the telecaster so much

Very Usefull

When I downsized I bought at PRS 24-08. Tonal possibilities best of both worlds for a minimalist guitarist.

I tend to use the bridge pickup while playing my SG and the neck pickup on my strat, like you do. The other pickups requires a lot of eq to sound good.

That fender sounds awesome.

If you're going to play country, I believe nothing tops a telecaster. Overall my personal favorite is/was my '52 American vintage reissue tele. It had the original vintage wiring making the forward p/u dark (like a bass guitar) in the neck position. The middle position gave the neck p/u tone. It was perfect if you was going to play something like "Bring it on home" by the mighty Zeppelin. I know most people changed the wiring or neck pickup but I liked it. I believe those guitars had the most sound options. I also like the vintage radius, l don't bend much and I like the way it fits the hand. It was also nitro lacquered. They don't have the tuning problems associated with Gibson's and Stratocaster's. Personally I think the telecaster is the overall winner.

They’re both great and totally different. I have 4 of each and love them all.

I agree with you 100%. I have a Strat with I prefer for my style of music being Blues, aka: Stevie Ray Vaughan and Eric Clapton.

Tone wise, I agree with everything you said. I own and play both, but my Gibson is an ES-335 not a Les Paul. I prefer the Gibson, and it's my #1, or go to guitar. I only switch to Fender when I need to. But for me it's not so much about tone as feel. To me, the Gibson just feels right in my hands. Whenever I pick up any guitar, in my mind, I'm comparing it to my ES-335. It's the standard by which I measure guitars. Especially the neck. Thin, wide and flat, in other words; Perfect. My Fender feels very chunky and takes a bit of "getting used to" every time I pick it up. This is all 100% personal preference of course.

The best: one guitar with HSS pickup configuration! 😜

Damn the comparison in the beginning had my Gibson fanboyness going. I actually prefer the les Paul’s sound in the Hendrix snd srv clips. It’s really my sound!

I'm a lefty so stuff is always more expensive. 0My first electric was a used 70's lawsuit Antoria Les Paul custom I bought in the mid 90's (Ibanez I believe) which I still have and plays and sounds great. I bought a cheapo strat just for the single coil sounds and had it set up properly. Each gets used depending on the music. I'd like proper versions but as I'm more drums and keyboard these days they are good enough for me. If I wanted to treat myself I think I'd go for a tele.

Don't forget a HSS strat. You lose some single coil bridge sounds even with coil split but you get a more agressive bridge sound with the humbucker. When you're in a cover band which plays lots of different genres it may be the guitar thay you need....

Well, a Strat is the most versatile sounding guitar out of the box.It covers everything from glassy to wood. It’s become the workhorse for most styles of music, but the longer scale lenght with higher string tension always tempts me to play with a bear grip and make me sweat from the hard work. It’s like taming a beast. Tuning down to e flat changes this feeling a lot. Then, tension equals a Gibson . Gibson, for this reason seems easier to play out of the box. Lighter grip, more melodic style, but the dynamics of the humbuckers is somewhat muddy in low gain. I use some original PAFs I bought cheaply some 20 years ago. But...crank the tube amp to the point of breakup, give it a boost and suddenly you are into another dimension of sustain, overtones and saturation that makes you want to ride on forever. If I was to travel and could only take one guitar, it would definitely be a 62 Strat with an oval c neck. Just because it is more challenging to play and has a greater spectrum of sounds. But in a setup, I just can’t say. Because playing electric guitar is so deeply interwoven with the amp you play, you are in fact playing two instruments. The guitar and the amp.

Telecasters work best for me. This is an under statement. To keep with up with reality, in that a tool can only do what it does, there are two Strats and an Epiphone Dot ready for action. One Strat has 'Lipstick' pick ups. It looks and plays great, but gets limited action, over the pick ups. Finger picking! The second Strat has 'Texas Specials'. This is a leap of faith! The thing is you may like one in your bridge position. In the Dot there is a Duncan 'Phat Cat' in the neck. You may find one, use full. Keep the faith. Chris

Jeez bro nice harmonics on that strat

Nice video my friend !

Terrific video Thom! Agreed, both are great guitars. IF I could play at all, I would invest in both of them! BTW, how is the little one doing? Hope that all is well....... 👍😉

@GuitarPilgrim

2 жыл бұрын

She's is fantastic Steve! Just a slight lack of sleep for daddy, that's all haha

i love them both....Strat and Tele and a prs single cut SE....:-)....each for their own.....but i still like your basic idea of owning just the ONE guitar.....

Jimi Page did a cool thing on the Les Paul with the selector in the middle position and roll off the neck pickup volume to 7. Try it!

A Strat and Les Paul covers most of the bases for sure. I’m lucky enough to own a Strat and a Les Paul and it’s the Gibson that’s my go to choice for most rock and blues. Lovely playing as always 🎸

Fender strat is the only guitar that I own two of in the same pickup configuration although one has gold foils and the other is a mix of seymour duncans and fender pups.

What ever guitar makes you play is the best guitar. If I had to move abroad and choose only one I would take my strat cause I think it is more like a swiss army knife. It can do almost anything. But then again maybe you only need the mighty Gibson which is like a sword instead of a army knife Fender. Your content is very good and inpiring! Keep up with the good videos!

Deffinitely wouldn't want to miss either one of the two altough i'm more a Gibson guy i have to admitt i'm playing my Fender more often lately.

The biggest difference between those two guitars is the neck length. The Gibson is shorter scale - frets closer together. This suits people with shorter fingers. The second biggest difference is the radius of the neck. Gibson uses 12 inch which is much more flat than fender that likes 9.5 inch and even down to 7.25 on some. The third biggest difference in those guitars is single coil vs double coil. Double coils remove the hum at the cost of some articulation. Another thing with the les paul is that it outputs more than a strat. You need to turn the volume down on the guitar itself to get it more into the strat dynamics when using both in the same amp. Those neck pickups go muddy quick with too much input. Another big difference is the sustain. The Les Paul will hold a note for a week with a little bit of gain. Finally, I would say gibson and fender both offer many pickups and tones. This was more of a Strat vs Les Paul than Fender vs Gibson thing. My #1 guitar is a 1997 les paul special with p90s. Try THAT kind of guitar and you see what time it is :D I have a couple of SGs and one Strat. I love the strat sound, but my fingers much prefer the shorter scale and flat boards of the gibson family. Rock on!

@Magnum_Opus_Music

2 жыл бұрын

Totally correct! When i want the "Fender Clean Sound" on my LP i can't go higher than 4 on the volume knob of the LP. After the 4 it wants to distort just a fraction when playing slightly harder. And it sound very close to my strat sound. Gain staging is very important in the audio world. The right levels ar key here! Cheers mate play on 🎸✌️

Haha - I thought the SRV sounded great on the Gibson. A little warmer - smoother. Very nice.

You know that your Gibson studio has the humbuck and single coil built into it. You just have to pull the knobs up (away from the body). The ones that control volume. This gives the Gibson even more sounds to play with. Maybe you can show it a video to let us what you think about that?

I like both but I ❤️ my Fenders🎶. Oh, my Gibson is a Yamaha AES620L.

I prefer listening to you play anything than me playing either. Though I still do enjoy playing both...and even others. When finances allow--having both is king. But being you...that tops them both. Stay Well.

Great video ! thanks ! What is the model of your fender stratocaster ? where can Buy the same please ?

I own a bunch of guitars.. and i totaly agree with u… but in my opinion, there is a third guitar that every guitarist must have or at least must have tried: A rickenbacker… really underated guitars… anyway, i’ve the chance to find a Gibson les paul Classic from 1992… believe it or not, it sounds like a fender … really classy sound and a lot of treble even in the neck pickup :)

Well, my experience with both is that Gibson goes out of tune more often that the Strato. Also Fender is much softer to play than the Les Paul.

I really like that riff you based on Warwick Avenue!

Great video but is a LP Studio a good comparison to the Fender? I wonder how a Standard would compare with it.

Bravo!

Personally, I have Epiphone Dot (335) which I put USB interface and make music in Studio One. Often I get little bit muddy sounds even when with clean presets from Guitar Rig. I think the reason are heavy humbuckers that don't allow for cleaner sound. Question is: Would I get little bit cleaner sound if I used guitar with single coil pickups such as Telecaster or Stratocaster? Thanks for answer. :)

Fender is more indyvidual Instrument. You can sound unique through Single Coil. Its harder to have own sound playing humbuckers. Srv, rory Gallagher, Hendrix, gilmour