Feedback pedals: What's the difference?

Музыка

There are currently 4 feedback pedals which synthetically create feedback from your instrument. They all work differently and have other features. This is a quick overview of those features, for a more in-depth comparison check out this video: • Which FEEDBACKER is th...
0:00 Intro
0:36 Line6 Dr. Distorto
1:58 Boss DF-2 Super Feedbacker & Distortion
3:16 Boss FB-2 Feedbacker/Booster
4:50 Digitech Freqout
Signal Path: Fender Stratocaster (bridge humbucker) - Feedbacker pedal - Line6 HX Stomp (Das Benzin Mega (crunch tone) - 4x12 cab sim - Plate Reverb) - Focusrite 6i6 - DAW.
The Line6 Dr. Distorto sustains your note synthetically or adds an octave above it with a switch. When the feedback side of the pedal is activated, it automatically generates a note when the natural noise of your guitar fades out. You have control over the rise and fall time of the feedback, as well as a control to blend between dry and feedback. Besides feedback, there's an optional versatile distortion which goes from overdrive to fuzz with tone and volume controls. To top it off, there's also an optional noise gate with two settings.
The Boss DF-2 is the oldest pedal of the 4 and has a DS-2 style distortion which is always present when you activate the pedal, the feedback is only activated when you hold the footswtich down. When the feedback is activated, it sustains the last note that you played, boosts it and adds a wild vibrato. It plays that noise as long as you hold the footswitch down and you can even play notes over the feedback. You have control over the overtones of the feedback: with the knob turned down, it sustains the last played note you played and with the knob turned up, it adds an octave to it. The distortion side of the pedal has controls over level, tone and distortion.
The Boss FB-2 has a completely different approach to add feedback. Instead of synthetically sustaining the sound from your guitar, it tracks your playing. When you hold down the pedal to engage the feedback, it boosts that certain frequency to make your amp reach that feedback screech. The only knob to control this is the Feedback knob, which basically is a gain control for this circuit. The other part of the pedal is a booster and you have more control over that. It has knobs for boost level, tone and character, which morphs between a flat EQ-curve and a mid boost.
The Digitech Freqout is the only one of these 4 pedals that doesn't have other features and solely focusses on feedback. Digitech once made a program that analyses sounds to eliminate feedback in a live room, but for this pedal they reversed that so it actually boosts those feedback noises. You can choose between seven different sounds, control the input gain and the onset (which is the time for the feedback to kick in). There are also switches to choose between momentary or latching footswitch functionality and a switch to kill your dry sound so there's only feedback.
Instagram: / diyguitarguy
Facebook: / diyguitarguy

Пікірлер: 73

  • @mykhedelic6471
    @mykhedelic6471 Жыл бұрын

    The only one that works naturally and flexibly is the Freqout, and that guy does exactly what it says on the tin. And that's my feedback on it.

  • @taronb1992
    @taronb1992 Жыл бұрын

    The Digitech pedal does have a volume control. You mentioned in your video that it does not. The swell knob also doubles as a volume knob and has a top and bottom pot. One is for volumed and the other is for the time it takes for the feedback to come in. Thanks for the demo. If you play the pedal in auto mode, you get some really cool melodies that pop in out of our playing based on your playing style.

  • @trashjazz
    @trashjazz Жыл бұрын

    Freq out still 1st

  • @flaviomartignoni9524

    @flaviomartignoni9524

    2 ай бұрын

    Freeqout would be a good pedal, but the feedbacks don't last more than 10 seconds. I need a pedal with a feedback decay of over 30 seconds.

  • @michaelsnydermusic
    @michaelsnydermusic Жыл бұрын

    Great video. I hope you get more views. It deserves it! Subscribed!

  • @mikedwiles
    @mikedwiles4 ай бұрын

    Nice job! I recently picked up a Digitech Freqout. It's a lot of fun and does a decent job once you get the hang of it. I like that it works opposite of a feedback destroyer. Very cool idea. I never realized that a Dr. Distorto did feedback. I bet that is modeled on the HX Effects that I recently got. I still have an Echo Park from that series. It has held up much better than I ever thought it would.

  • @cam-inf-4w5
    @cam-inf-4w56 ай бұрын

    The overdrive on the boss sounds amazing

  • @martinvannostrand8488

    @martinvannostrand8488

    3 ай бұрын

    It’s disappointing in person, you wouldn’t believe how thin it can be. Makes your guitar feel lighter lol

  • @cam-inf-4w5

    @cam-inf-4w5

    3 ай бұрын

    @@martinvannostrand8488 yea cameras and mics never capture the intensity or depth of something.

  • @kidkique

    @kidkique

    3 ай бұрын

    ??? uhhh what?

  • @martinvannostrand8488

    @martinvannostrand8488

    3 ай бұрын

    @@cam-inf-4w5 my ears didn’t capture any depth from that pedal out of my amp either

  • @jannieVobis

    @jannieVobis

    Ай бұрын

    ​@@martinvannostrand8488Boss ds1 have a few basic rules tò apply of you want a nice and fat sound; 1) you may have already a break up sounding amp! 2) have the gain set at 10 or 11 o clock, depends from the gain set on your amp. 3) the tone control set a bit back from noon, also at 10 or 11 o clock.

  • @maartenstevens9848
    @maartenstevens984810 ай бұрын

    I liked that vibrato on the Boss. It could be an extra option for a new Freqout if Digitech ever makes new pedals again.

  • @gob5974
    @gob5974 Жыл бұрын

    Fender made a pedal dedicated to creating feedback but i haven't heard of or ever even seen an example of one in the flesh

  • @accrimony

    @accrimony

    24 күн бұрын

    the band hum uses that pedal

  • @maxtexman
    @maxtexman4 ай бұрын

    As far as I know, the Digitech FreqOut is the only one that you can bend the string during the feedback and manipulate the signal. I have one and really like it. I also have the Boss super distortion and feedbacker.

  • @Skullcrusha

    @Skullcrusha

    3 күн бұрын

    Can you tell me if FreqOut can be used with headphones or if it only works with amplifiers?

  • @RichInternationalAir
    @RichInternationalAir Жыл бұрын

    Excellent vid and overview, liked and subscribed! 🎸 Another option is the Behringer FD300 Ultra Feedback / Distortion (clone of the Boss DF-2), very affordable when they first appeared (I think) in '04 ish. It's well reviewed, but stigmatized by the love/hate some people have with their pedals. Also, I think the Boss FB-2 is a digital circuit. But I like it's sound too!

  • @DIYguitarGuy

    @DIYguitarGuy

    Жыл бұрын

    Thanks! I didn't know there was a Behringer clone. Looking at the videos. it sounds exactly the same as the Boss DF2! Apparently it also has a cult following. There's also one from Fender called the Runaway that's even rarer these days. I think the boost in the FB2 is analog but the feedback circuit is digital, but I must say I haven't checked the circuit board.

  • @RichInternationalAir

    @RichInternationalAir

    Жыл бұрын

    @@DIYguitarGuy, thanks for the kind reply, I didn't know about the Fender Runaway, cool! 🎸😎

  • @aprilschauer4864

    @aprilschauer4864

    Жыл бұрын

    ​@@RichInternationalAirthe behringer is no more in produktion.

  • @-jank-willson

    @-jank-willson

    10 ай бұрын

    nowadays they cost just as much as the Boss originals...

  • @dedballoons
    @dedballoons2 ай бұрын

    Way more fun just running the amp hot but I can see the practicality of this. I know my amp and pedals well and can make it feed or be silent on a whim, I enjoy interacting with the speakers in that way. I do think in certain environments a pedal could work well for people who just want a controlled feedback here and there without the risk of running their amp hot enough to do it naturally. Great for not blowing up FOH accidentally when live, great for bedroom guitar with volume restrictions. I suppose great if you haven't spent much time with high gain amps and always being diligent about how much noise you're creating.

  • @johnshelton8441
    @johnshelton84413 ай бұрын

    Thanks.

  • @kentl7228
    @kentl7228 Жыл бұрын

    It would be cool to have an expression pedal input to engage the effect and be able to move the feedback up an octave, though the Boss pedals kind of get there.

  • @DIYguitarGuy

    @DIYguitarGuy

    Жыл бұрын

    Yeah that would be a cool feature. The Fender Runaway has it but I was unaware of that pedal when I made this video. It's still a cool pedal but I prefer pedals that have an expression input (or midi) instead of one that's build in.

  • @treaceeames4697

    @treaceeames4697

    Жыл бұрын

    Use a wah as well

  • @hydorah
    @hydorah Жыл бұрын

    The boss DF-2 and the Digitech had the best sounds. The Behringer had a dream set of features but sounded awful as did the silver Boss. Funny that you didn't use a big distorted tone in any of the demo but I guess you were constrained there by many of the pedals also being distortions. Sounded really odd to hear feedback swelling out of Chillipepper-esqe clean riff! Finally congrats on wearing shoes. I'm lowkey annoyed by the amount of pedal reviews wear you see a socked foot sneak into the picture and hit the switches

  • @DIYguitarGuy

    @DIYguitarGuy

    Жыл бұрын

    Haha thanks! Besides not wanting to bother viewers with my socks or bare feet, I don't like the feeling of stomping on footswitches without soles underneath my feet. What did you mean with the Behringer one? I know they did a clone of the DF-2 but apparently it sounds identical.

  • @hydorah

    @hydorah

    Жыл бұрын

    @@DIYguitarGuy It sounds horrendously digital and doesn't sound like feedback. Agreed on the feeling of stomp switches and also yes. I've noticed those guys usually wear socks that are intended so show how witty / edgy the wearer is. Very tiresome

  • @-jank-willson

    @-jank-willson

    10 ай бұрын

    which of these pedals could replicate the feedback on the green day 'brain stew' and Queen 'we will rock you' guitar parts?

  • @gooseabuse
    @gooseabuse Жыл бұрын

    Now compare e-bows and sustainiac pick ups with these feedback pedals.

  • @libo999
    @libo9992 ай бұрын

    Which place in the pedalboard is better for these effects?

  • @takiix
    @takiix Жыл бұрын

    👍👍👍

  • @kimhwang3610
    @kimhwang3610 Жыл бұрын

    I wonder if the freq out can be used like fernandes sustainer/sustainiac/ebow for legato sustain play...have you tried it?

  • @DIYguitarGuy

    @DIYguitarGuy

    Жыл бұрын

    It can provide those tones but it doesn't add sustain, it's dependant on the guitars sustain. It also does those ebow kind of sounds with the slow attack. You have no control over the release and it can be really abrupt. Maybe if you place a volume pedal after it, it can be smoothed.

  • @danieltv123

    @danieltv123

    10 ай бұрын

    What I disliked when I had one was that the feedback would just disappear after a few seconds.. unlike real amp feedback

  • @aydenlukacs

    @aydenlukacs

    9 ай бұрын

    @@danieltv123 I tried a freqout the other day at a music store and that was the one thing that disappointed me was the note disappeared after like 3-5 seconds. Do you know if there is any way to stop it from cutting out

  • @nathanweekley5857

    @nathanweekley5857

    5 ай бұрын

    If you put an EHX Freeze pedal before the Freqout, you can have infinite sustain from the Freeze and harmonic feedback from the Freqout.

  • @michaelholmes9153
    @michaelholmes91535 ай бұрын

    I was aware of the earliest orange Boss one from the 80s. Is it possible the distortion in it is the DS1 as the settings and pedal color are the same? I have the Digitech and it is the most versatile, its a shame it never really caught on like the Whammy. I set mine with the auto off so you can engage with the footswitch, level is about the same as original signal, gain two thirds and the feedback setting at oct above.

  • @DIYguitarGuy

    @DIYguitarGuy

    5 ай бұрын

    I think the DF2's distortion is the one from the DS2 Turbo Distortion on mode 2 (mode 1 is the same as the DS1)

  • @michaelholmes9153

    @michaelholmes9153

    5 ай бұрын

    But when did the DS2 come out? I thought late 80s well after the DS1 and the Feedback one. I should check that one out too as the Turbo is orange so it must relate with any orange BOSS distortion pedal@@DIYguitarGuy

  • @rc3754
    @rc37543 ай бұрын

    SoftTube's Acoustic Feedback blows them all away. Too bad it's only available as a plugin.

  • @user-qi6qw4kk4x
    @user-qi6qw4kk4x2 ай бұрын

    Can you play anything other than that one lick? And how about chords, you do know that chords feedback too?

  • @chrisdee5032

    @chrisdee5032

    2 ай бұрын

    Several of these pedals don't feedback properly with chords, the df2 even says so in the manual. Maybe stop being a fucking knob?

  • @mellodika
    @mellodika5 ай бұрын

    1.digitech (so clean signal) 2.boss fb-2, okay digitech that i wanted for my music

  • @mrbaiser4133
    @mrbaiser4133 Жыл бұрын

    How does the TC Electronic Infinite compare to these pedals?

  • @DIYguitarGuy

    @DIYguitarGuy

    Жыл бұрын

    It doesn't. The only pedal of these four that's capable of holding a note for as long as you want is the Boss DF-2, but keep in mind that it's monophonic, so that's only one note and no chords. Besides that, it'll always add a wild vibrato effect and it's pre-gain, so it will always sound distorted.

  • @simonkormendy849
    @simonkormendy84929 күн бұрын

    What happened to all the sound in this video?

  • @eyesintheskies
    @eyesintheskies Жыл бұрын

    I’’ll take the digitech 👍

  • @tatomoize9602
    @tatomoize960211 ай бұрын

    Thanks for the test, to use before a digital pedalboard without speakers, would you only recommend the Digitech? , greetings

  • @DIYguitarGuy

    @DIYguitarGuy

    11 ай бұрын

    You're welcome. For that setup I would recommend all of them except the FB-2, that one really relies on speaker feedback. I think the Freqout is the best sounding one so I use that on my digital pedalboard without speakers as well, there's a demo on my channel, if you're interested.

  • @GuitarG123

    @GuitarG123

    2 ай бұрын

    The FB2 not working without speakers doesn't make sense. Isn't the whole idea for these pedals to eliminate amps for silent headphone practice or direct ampless recording. Why does FB1 need to see a speaker.I can't see how it can interact with a guitar speaker?

  • @Brutuscomedy
    @Brutuscomedy Жыл бұрын

    One can always run a distortion pedal into one of those analog amp sims, such as a cheap Joyo or more expensive Tech 21, to generate massive feedback.

  • @annedeoedipus7849

    @annedeoedipus7849

    10 ай бұрын

    Wow, cool, I did not think of that. Thanks that will be super useful.

  • @Brutuscomedy

    @Brutuscomedy

    10 ай бұрын

    @@annedeoedipus7849 The RAT Solo pedal worked well in this regard but I had to sell it. Just recording with the Tech 21 Tri-AC at the moment which sounds pretty darn good to my ears

  • @-jank-willson

    @-jank-willson

    10 ай бұрын

    I am not sure what you are talking about? does the joyo amp simulator pedal have a separate FX loop like some amps do? Could you link me to a video?

  • @Brutuscomedy

    @Brutuscomedy

    10 ай бұрын

    @@-jank-willson I, for example, plugged a RAT Solo pedal into the Joyo and was able to get a lot of great feedback. I imagine almost any distortion pedal would suffice, however. Just gotta crank some knobs Also, I think I used the Extreme Metal for that and even its "boost" switch so ya might have to really hit the circuit hard.

  • @-jank-willson

    @-jank-willson

    10 ай бұрын

    @@Brutuscomedy how do you plug a pedal into another pedal (other than in-series like a regular pedalboard, but that won't create any feedback)? Or does it have an FX loop just like how some fancy amps have an fx loop? Or is it one of those passive feedback looper pedals? i have no idea what you are talking about im sorry 😭🤣 The sound I am trying to go for, is the queen 'we will rock you' and green day 'brain stew' guitar solo feedback sound.

  • @joeking433
    @joeking4337 ай бұрын

    You would think someone would come out with a DF-2 clone. Are you out there, Josh?

  • @DIYguitarGuy

    @DIYguitarGuy

    7 ай бұрын

    There is one: the Behringer FD300 Ultra Feedback/Distortion.

  • @hotrod8915
    @hotrod89157 ай бұрын

    Yeah, I'd like a pedal that does the opposite. Next, review a static and a white noise pedal

  • @esmeulonsouzadeoliveira3636
    @esmeulonsouzadeoliveira3636 Жыл бұрын

    Like 325 .

  • @eddie81540
    @eddie81540 Жыл бұрын

    Freqout por lejos

  • @haganvonburger7930
    @haganvonburger793011 ай бұрын

    The Dr distorto one is obviously the worst

  • @averageaustralian7488
    @averageaustralian74887 ай бұрын

    Mate, I only got 50 bucks

  • @CatFish107
    @CatFish107 Жыл бұрын

    Holy crap, whatever you do, do not demonstraye how these sound with playing going through. ONLY show sustained last notes. What a waste of time.

Келесі