bro listened to every album ever made

@meciocio

Жыл бұрын

all of those are well known albums, not such a big deal

@Oliver-tp2sd

Жыл бұрын

These are pretty popular late 70’s mid 80 records

@IFP.249

Жыл бұрын

@@meciocio is just a joke dude cmon

@missingno6216

Жыл бұрын

He’s called the internets busiest music nerd for a reason

@anmts5565

Жыл бұрын

he is the busiest music nerd after all

This the first one I’ve seen where he isn’t laughing at their taste 😳

@alphalax7747

Жыл бұрын

Or saying L at everything

@Falxifer95

Жыл бұрын

And yet he couldn't help himself from doing a cringy Ian Curtis impression.

@jenconvertibles

Жыл бұрын

I mean she basically just picked the most accepted post punk artists, it’s kind of a bland list ngl

@BarryH90dz

Жыл бұрын

She picked albums that are in every “greatest post-punk albums of all time” list ever made lol

@sfglim5341

10 ай бұрын

@@jenconvertiblesessentials not favorites. Would be surprised to see an underground band in an essentials list

"Lets see those pics" woah Anthony slow down there

@noaj1234

4 ай бұрын

amazing pfp

@malwre_android1617

4 ай бұрын

@@noaj1234 thx bb urs too

he says “that’s a heavy one” but tyler is clearly not struggling

i felt so warm watching this, fantano brought the chill vibes.

@mfhiroshima

9 ай бұрын

Fr

the fact she chose love will tear us apart and not unknown pleasures or closer is hurtful

@forzaguy1252

Жыл бұрын

hell, even substance would be better

@igotdarkaether4813

11 ай бұрын

I know! It’s not even an album makes no sense.

@AudibleVisibIe

11 ай бұрын

She's edgy dood

Melon can we get a Doors album tier list soon?

@kikoroko1502

Жыл бұрын

Fr there’s barely any Doors content in youtube

@atulyabharadwaj2279

Жыл бұрын

@@kikoroko1502 confession: I got my tution teacher into the doors and he's a schizo nut job now who thinks drugs are profound.

@kikoroko1502

Жыл бұрын

@@atulyabharadwaj2279 Nice

@Blazing234

Жыл бұрын

From best: LA woman -> Self titled -> Strange Days -> Morrison hotel -> waiting for the sun -> soft parade

@Inari_Cloud

Жыл бұрын

Man tho I love their shit

psychocandy deserves more love tbh... inspired a generation of shoegaze bands

@KendrickMegaFan

Жыл бұрын

It literally invented shoegaze

@heckicusdoomicuswizardus1382

Жыл бұрын

​@@KendrickMegaFan bruh

@curly_wyn

Жыл бұрын

Yeah! “Songwriting’s one-dimensional” It’s supposed to be!

@panasonic_youth

Жыл бұрын

Yeah. Protogaze basically haha

All those albums are amazing

“Songwriting’s a bit one-dimensional, but..” Psychocandy is 60s bubblegum pop. It’s supposed to be one-dimensional; that’s what makes it awesome.

@sentortv7816

10 ай бұрын

And break core is supposed to sound like a dying washing machine, doesn’t make it good.

@samuelcamarillo1349

6 ай бұрын

​@@sentortv7816bad analogy

@sentortv7816

6 ай бұрын

@@samuelcamarillo1349

Hit me with some Magazine here. Real Life is an absolute cornerstone post-punk album. Post-punk with direct punk lineage in Howard Devoto. Luxuria too. Pornography by The Cure is an all-timer for me.

imo going w Seventeen Seconds for The Cure, underrated, my favorite record of theirs

all of em 10/10 smiths an 11 tho

I personally love Turn on the Bright Lights, but talking heads is a great pick as well!

@jdg1251

Жыл бұрын

Love that record so much

The Figurehead from Pornography is such a great song and I swear nobody talks about that one even when talking about the album

@klaedoe9042

Жыл бұрын

it is, but strange day is my personal favorite

looking at the comment sections and the reel, Interpol's Turn on the Bright Lights deserves more love here

@jack-uv6mt

11 ай бұрын

its not post punk

@agonzalez7095

10 ай бұрын

@@jack-uv6mt wdym its not post punk?? What would you call it then?

@jack-uv6mt

10 ай бұрын

i guess im just being a stickler but its considered the post punk revival, tbh it is post punk just musically but some of genre is the era and scene that it revolved around@@agonzalez7095

@jack-uv6mt

10 ай бұрын

at the end of the day genre classification may help for discovering music but its not that inportant.@@agonzalez7095

@RiverOfBlacklights

9 ай бұрын

It's a great album but, I think they were going for classics from the 80's. A few bands and albums that paved the way for everything that came afterwards, including Interpol.

She 🛌 on Metal Box/Second Edition by Public Image Ltd.

Talking heads ❤

Anthony was so chill in this one

Bro dressed like a halloween pumpkin

She showed all the post-punk essentials lol

@Falxifer95

Жыл бұрын

Missing essentials: Juju by Siouxsie & the Banshees Marquee Moon by Television Prayers on Fire by The Birthday Party Pink Flag by Wire Bela Lugosi is Dead by Bauhaus Real Life by Magazine

@dogmanbitehurt8243

Жыл бұрын

@zgctliterally just described post-punk

@curly_wyn

Жыл бұрын

@Radon Post-punk before the peak of regular punk. Mostly one of the best guitar records!

@growskull

10 ай бұрын

​@zgctits literally short for post modern punk what do u expect

@jackreeder215

10 ай бұрын

@@Falxifer95 nah Marquee Moon isn't Post-Punk. Closer to Punk/Garage Rock. The first Post-Punk album belongs to Iggy Pop's The Idiot imo

Psychocandy was the best of the bunch ‘My little underground’ and ‘Never Understand’ are some of my favourite shoe gaze songs.

When is there gonna be a goddamn New Order Classic review?? Technique, Brotherhood or Low-Life will do. Nerd tf out Anthony, please!!!

the calmest melon

new order is awesome

Can't believe I didn't know the difference between synthpop and post punk until yesterday even though I grew up on both.

Psycho candy masterpiece

Lifted in the background is a good look! Amazing album

I don't really agree, but post-punk is a tricky label. I love The Smiths but I don't think of that as post-punk in the slightest. It's only 'post-punk' in the sense that it was released after punk hit the mainstream. To me, something like early Nick Cave is post-punk. Lots of edge and grit, but not following the punk music formula.

@horrorvacui3606

7 ай бұрын

Post punk is not a genre, that’s why.

My personal top post punk albums Kino- a star called the sun Molchat doma - monument Human Tetris - things I don’t need Peremotka - noch epohi

@manwithnoname2355

Жыл бұрын

In my opinion Molchat Doma is not even that good; Etzhi is better than Monument and Kino has better albums such as Gruppa Krovi where almost every song is incredibly good.

@jlummington

Жыл бұрын

​@@manwithnoname2355 Eh I do think Etazhi is better than Monument as a whole but the opener to monument is the best opener they made

@Potato-yd3hv

Жыл бұрын

I can't pick a favorite Kino album. As much as I love A Star Called The Sun and The Last Heroes, I have to pick The Black Album because of Leto and Kukushka... they're absolutely amazing.

@nopeoppeln

11 ай бұрын

@@Potato-yd3hv Posledniy Geroy, a re-collection album, is their absolute magnum opus. It's mostly songs from their previous album and EVERYTHING is better. the ambience, the production, the instrumentals which are way more upbeat, Tsoi's voice which is much more passionate but still very moody, less "boring" or "uninspiring" you can say, emotional and the lyrics usually are incredible, but that feature comes from their last album, because nearly all of the songs here are from there and ALL songs (except i'd say for Vojna maybe but both versions are great) are so much better than on Gruppa Krovi. also, you might say that the vocals here can sometimes be a bit annoying compared to very moody and deep sound of Tsoi there, but it feels so much more inspiring and passionate. it's unbelievably enjoyable, especially during a rainy night. it's a strong 9 to a 10 if I were Melon and Gruppa Krovi is a decent to strong 9

@Potato-yd3hv

11 ай бұрын

@@nopeoppeln Oh, I agree with you that Posledniy Geroy is 100x better than the Gruppa Krovi album. I remember not understanding the hype around songs like Gruppa Krovi and Spokoynaya Noch until I heard the Posledniy Geroy versions and it clicked for me. Tsoi's voice is so much more cold and Kasparyan's guitar is so much prominent, it hits you like a truck. I remember having an argument with some weirdo on a Kino Discord server who insisted that Gruppa Krovi's production was better because... there was a slightly newer synth, apparently. To each their own, but Posledniy Geroy's guitar just hits so hard and it feels so much cold in terms of ambience.

The cure, the talking heads, joy division and new order are 4 of my favorite 5 bands 😮

Big shoutout on the Psycho Candy choice, created shoegaze and is possibly one of the more influential albums of the 80’s.

THE FALL? WIRE? MAGAZINE?

@unknown6390

Жыл бұрын

Lol right?? It's so funny how these kinds of videos stick to mostly popular stuff

@jimmyslowfade4442

Жыл бұрын

@@unknown6390 It's also amusing that some of these are pretty tenuous - I wouldn't really consider Talking Heads or The Smiths to be post-punk -- although I admit there's an argument to be made for the albums she mentions -- picking Pornography over Three Imaginary Boys by The Cure when the latter fits so neatly into the post-punk niche and then missing out giants of the genre like The Fall, Wire, Magazine, Gang of Four etc... It begs the question; what is this person smoking (and where can I get some?)

@ricochetsixtyten

Жыл бұрын

Chameleons - Script of the Bridge hugely underrated

@safebans1369

Жыл бұрын

ECHO AND THE BUNNYMEN BRUV

@jd1800

Жыл бұрын

This Heat - Deceit and Public Image Ltd - Metal Box/Second Edition

Heyyy that’s 3Hive Records from here in Provo, UT! Great store

Wow he was so nice to them in this one

The Most Calm Fantano review😂

I'm pretty sure I've been to that record store, and its where I bought TPAB on vinyl

Entertainment! by Gang of Four

Shoutout 3 hive record store in Provo, UT, glad to see them making it big with the fantano co-sign

But Love Will Tear Us Apart isn’t an album

It's post-punk, if you showed him 10 album It's most likely he's gonna like atleast 9

This is the beat Fantano could come up with for shorts LMAO

@something3867

Жыл бұрын

I mean at the end of the day people come for new music to listen to. This could be someone's first time hearing of joy division and shit like that has always been his goal

@sakinaalia1067

Жыл бұрын

I love this actually. It’s great to see his new music recs but I love his classic week and I find I agree with his choices for essentials much more than a list made by rolling stone with so many people that it’s diluted.

The human need to compartmentalise everything makes the term 'post punk' massively vague. I think of it more as the likes of Joy Division (correct), The Fall and PIL but suppose its all down to interpretation

No Marquee Moon? That’s number one on my essentials list. And if the only song by Joy Division you like is Love Will Tear Us Apart then you’re not really a Joy Division fan. The entirety of Unknown Pleasures is far more essential than the one off single of their biggest hit.

I would personally add Cut by The Slits. Album is criminally overlooked.

I love 3hive, didn't expect them to crossover into the Fantanoverse lol

Siouxsie Sioux? Minimal Compact? Bauhaus?

I'm trying to listen to what she is saying but this guy won't shut up...

Yo this is my favorite record store!

Old post punk is sweet but we gotta see some of the newer stuff

Fear of Music is honestly better, in my opinion.

Pornography is the best album by far it's so brooding and emotionally power!!

Steve Rizzou fit slaps

Never realised Talking Heads was post-ponk. For me it was always experimental and art rock.

@siouxsiexymox6594

Жыл бұрын

Post-punk is literally experimental Punk rock 🤣😂

@CG-mt7uq

Жыл бұрын

Just experimental rock :p

@jdg5209

Жыл бұрын

@@CG-mt7uq Dude TH are the poster boys of post-punk

@CG-mt7uq

Жыл бұрын

@@jdg5209 yeah I know it was very stupid from me 😅

@ricochetsixtyten

Жыл бұрын

post-ponk

What do you think of negative xp anthony

Yall check out desmond doom - surf goth album .

We needed joy Division

10/10 picks tbf

How is Psychocandy post punk? It’s noise pop/noise rock.

@curly_wyn

Жыл бұрын

It has a lot of post-punk in it.

Woah Fantano I know you hate the monarchy but you didn't have to say the Queen is dead better.

Yknow, I never see Anthony talk about The Cure, like at all.

She chose a single?

Apparently I don't know what post-punk is. I like a lot of first wave gothic music, and new wave though.

Wow I need a fan.

17, 2014, flower boy, mmlp, tcd, and I am I was are the only good ones

Love Will Tear Us Apart over Unknown Pleasures is objectively incorrect

Hey Anthony what do you think of deathconciousness

3hive representin. I bought my first record there

No PiL 😢

Out of all the things she could’ve chosen for Joy Division, she doesn’t choose Unknown Pleasures or Closer. Bruh.

Smith's and psychocandy post punk? Yall reaching

Pornography is so underrated. It is super heavy though.

The melon is now a pumpkin

link your other channels to this one

Gang of Four???

No Interpol? Damn

Where tf is siouxsie and the banshees??

No Joy Division, no Public Image Ltd., not even Souixsie... Good albums, but if you want to listen to "the essential post-punk", start with those guys, they were really formative in the genre.

@danwillreview

Жыл бұрын

Correction: Love Will Tear Us Apart is Joy Division

@agonzalez7095

Жыл бұрын

joy division was literally there

@jlummington

Жыл бұрын

​@@danwillreview he maybe meant that there wasnt a full length album by joy division but idk

Okay but who's the chick tho

@Blaza303

Жыл бұрын

Tyler.

you know what else is a 10/10 mbdtf

This doesn’t really quite seem like post punk to me entirely. Gang of Four and television come to mind for me but it was never my favorite genre

Jeebus. Post punk (and goth) top 10s are always so boring.

I know post punk can mean alot of things but no 7 Seconds or Dag Nasty. Please don't correct me of you think they're "emotional hardcore" that's not a genre that applies to anything but Fugazi.

Anth-noying Orange

What was the second to last album I couldn’t hear what was said

@riverlake4642

Жыл бұрын

Chicken butt

@nabilmoufid6404

Жыл бұрын

psychocandy by jesus and the mary chain

@cockandballtortureconnoiss2643

Жыл бұрын

@@nabilmoufid6404 👍

@ryankm4056

Жыл бұрын

Based name

Melons out here since he’s divorced lol .

Brotherhood is post punk??? Also Self titled is better than the Queen is dead

Disintegration is their best

@curly_wyn

Жыл бұрын

The safe choice, but no. Pornography is their best album. It’s much more tight and consistent and has fully leans into the despair and darkness and hatred and pessimism, which is what I want.

@RiverOfBlacklights

9 ай бұрын

_'Disintegration'_ is basically when normies discovered The Cure on MTV and thought _'Lovesong'_ and _'Pictures Of You'_ were written for them. Had those songs *NOT* been in there? That album wouldn't have been so big and all the normies that were suddenly "Cure fans" [lol] would simply look at them as a "freak band" with guys who dress in black, wear makeup and have crazy big hair, just like they did prior to that album. Vanilla... Nothing beats the true dark trilogy of _'Seventeen Seconds', 'Faith'_ and _'Pornography'._

@mrmxyzptlk8906

9 ай бұрын

@@curly_wyn definitely not. Disintegration isn’t only more consistent. But it fuses their previous gloomy depressing sounds and introduces a cold but transcendent fresh sound that’s unrivaled. And the songwriting is an entire step up as well. Pornography is great but Disintegration is their masterpiece.

@mrmxyzptlk8906

9 ай бұрын

@@RiverOfBlacklights no, Disintegration is their best. Being a contrarian is worse than being a normies. And a normie isn’t an issue. An contrarian is.

@RiverOfBlacklights

9 ай бұрын

@@mrmxyzptlk8906 Right, so why are you contradicting me? See how easy it is to flip your weak script? Just cause you saw some episode of South Park saying it's "the best", doesn't make it so... lol

🥛

No PIL?

All W’s except talking heads

Wait, I thought Tyler was black

Proof that post punk is a meaningless term

Where the fuck is Gang of Four?

Anthony stop talking over women 😡

The absolute woat fit and face

The smiths arent post punk. Well maybe a little. They are inspired by post punk and new wave. But they are more alternative pop.

@horrorvacui3606

7 ай бұрын

Post punk is not a genre, stfu

chairs missing - wire. nuff said

Listen to women, fantano

Am I retarded or something but I swear Love will tear us apart isn’t on any album? Or does any recording count as an album? Cus if so then wouldn’t most lists consist of purely singles?